Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Would you get that chip off your shoulder, please! Your knee-jerk hostility and constant leaping to the most uncharitable assumptions about others is tiresome.

I was asked to supply a link to one of a number of hypotheses. I was saying exactly the same thing as you and others that this is one of a number of hypotheses and one that nobody takes seriously.
It's not a chip. I have tried to keep this thread on the topic of evidence and science. Posting the latest CT belongs in the thread in the CT forum.

This has all the elements of pure CT crap:
... accusing scientists from around the world of creating and uploading fake coronavirus sequences from bats and other animals into a genetic data bank. The goal of this effort, according to the paper, is to obscure the "true origin" of the new coronavirus, SARS-CoV-2.
It doesn't belong in this thread.
 
I've acknowledged it over and over again.
Comments like these suggest you are not taking Daszak's conflict of interest at the level the evidence supports:
Daszak is the one most often mentioned, but he was part of a WHO team with scientists from all over the world.

They are apparently keeping silent and/or complicit in the lab leak cover-up according to most theories on this.
Who are they? And where has it been posted there is a coordinated effort to cover up the origin of COVID?

There are the Chinese authorities.

There is Daszak.

And there is the 'bat woman' top researcher at the WIV who stated nothing in her studies came close to matching COVID genetics.

It has also been noted the WHO does not wish to piss the Chinese government off.

No one has posted they believe there is any kind of cabal here.
 
Comments like these suggest you are not taking Daszak's conflict of interest at the level the evidence supports:

This is a meaningless statement. What comment am I supposed to make? What is the level the evidence supports?

Who are they?

WHO are they!

Members of the international team:

Prof. Dr. Thea Fisher, MD, DMSc(PhD) (Nordsjællands Hospital, Denmark)
Prof. John Watson (Public Health England, United Kingdom)
Prof. Dr. Marion Koopmans, DVM PhD (Erasmus MC, Netherlands)
Prof. Dr. Dominic Dwyer, MD (Westmead Hospital, Australia)
Vladimir Dedkov, Ph.D (Institute Pasteur, Russia)
Dr. Hung Nguyen-Viet, PhD (International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI), Vietnam)
PD. Dr. med vet. Fabian Leendertz (Robert Koch-Institute, Germany)
Dr. Peter Daszak, Ph.D (EcoHealth Alliance, USA)
Dr. Farag El Moubasher, Ph.D (Ministry of Public Health, Qatar)
Prof. Dr. Ken Maeda, PhD, DVM (National Institute of Infectious Diseases, Japan)

Link

And where has it been posted there is a coordinated effort to cover up the origin of COVID?

There are the Chinese authorities.

There is Daszak.

And there is the 'bat woman' top researcher at the WIV who stated nothing in her studies came close to matching COVID genetics.

It has also been noted the WHO does not wish to piss the Chinese government off.

No one has posted they believe there is any kind of cabal here.

Well, there you go. You have said that the Chinese (including Zhengli Shi - the batwoman) have covered it up to save face , Daszak is also involved because of his conflict of interest. The WHO is playing to China's tune. That's the cabal right there, implied right in this very post.
 
I realize it isn't easy.

That said, my other points stand.

As far as access to a Chinese BSL-4 lab is concerned, I would expect from the outset that it is difficult to get full access.

As a thought experiment, would a US BSL-4 be open to a WHO inspection where the team gets to look at anything and everything they want?

My guess is, no.

It may depend on the lab, but certainly a WHO team with Chinese and Russian team member wold NEVER get access to labs like the one in Fort Detrick Maryland.
 
1 - It could have been a work in progress

2 - There's more to bioweapons than direct military action. Consider the economic damage that the world has suffered by exposure to a virus which kills mainly retired people.

That said, I don't take the idea seriously either.

Most military research would actually be involved in developing counter measures to biological attacks. If anything this research is even more sensitive because if someone knows your countermeasures they can potentially find a way around them
 
Comments like these suggest you are not taking Daszak's conflict of interest at the level the evidence supports:Who are they? And where has it been posted there is a coordinated effort to cover up the origin of COVID?

There are the Chinese authorities.

There is Daszak.

And there is the 'bat woman' top researcher at the WIV who stated nothing in her studies came close to matching COVID genetics.

It has also been noted the WHO does not wish to piss the Chinese government off.

No one has posted they believe there is any kind of cabal here.

Has anyone ever asked Daszak what he did for the money he received from the Pentagon? According to a recent FOIA filed last July, he got over $40m from them (and Homeland Security) starting in 2013, the year before GOF was banned in the US (with some exceptions for certain projects to finish).

Dasak's own website says he got DoD funding so it isn't as if it is a secret.
EcoHealth Alliance (‘EHA”) is the recipient of various grant awards from federal agencies including the National Institute of Health, the National Science Foundation, US Fish and Wildlife Service, and the US Agency for International Development and the Department of Defense.

The foia request is real and can be seen logged here:
https://www.dtra.mil/Portals/61/FY2020 FOIA Log.pdf

DTRA stands for Defense Threat Reduction Agency- the part that deals with nuclear threats and disarmament, dirty bombs and other WMD's- including chemical and biological.
The bulk of the money is from this agency. (if those who got the FOIA are relating the contents truthfully!)

The summary of funding can be seen here:https://www.independentsciencenews....ng-as-of-01_10_2020-Fed.-Grants-Contracts.pdf

So, while USAID and the NIH make perfect sense for research and aid as to work in global health and disease threats, what exactly was Peter providing to the Pentagon for all that money?

I'm not suggesting what relationship was there or the work done. I honestly do not know. If anyone can find descriptions of these grants in detail, please do tell!!
 
Last edited:
Has anyone ever asked Daszak what he did for the money he received from the Pentagon? According to a recent FOIA filed last July, he got over $40m from them (and Homeland Security) starting in 2013, the year before GOF was banned in the US (with some exceptions for certain projects to finish).

Dasak's own website says he got DoD funding so it isn't as if it is a secret.


The foia request is real and can be seen logged here:
https://www.dtra.mil/Portals/61/FY2020 FOIA Log.pdf

DTRA stands for Defense Threat Reduction Agency- the part that deals with nuclear threats and disarmament, dirty bombs and other WMD's- including chemical and biological.
The bulk of the money is from this agency. (if those who got the FOIA are relating the contents truthfully!)

The summary of funding can be seen here:https://www.independentsciencenews....ng-as-of-01_10_2020-Fed.-Grants-Contracts.pdf

So, while USAID and the NIH make perfect sense for research and aid as to work in global health and disease threats, what exactly was Peter providing to the Pentagon for all that money?

I'm not suggesting what relationship was there or the work done. I honestly do not know. If anyone can find descriptions of these grants in detail, please do tell!!

What he did for the money?

As in "who did you have to blow to get that kind of funding"?

Or do you mean what did he do with the money?

There is a page which shows the Annual Reports, here.

There is also a link on that page to Charity Navigator that gives EcoHealth Alliance an excellent score for transparency and use of funding. It turns out that it spends about over 90% on its programme, and around 6% on administration, so it sounds very much above board. If EcoHealth Alliance are also upfront about the fact that they get funding from the Pentagon then I am not sure what the issue is.

(Is Charity Navigator a good source? I don't know).

So what is its programme that they put money into? Well, that is on their website too:

Biosurveillance
Deforestation
One Health
Pandemic Prevention Wildlife Conservation

I wouldn't be surprised if the Pentagon was interested in working on Pandemic preparedness and biosurveillance. Indeed, some of the GoF work is designed to identify potential threats.

I also found this published by EcoHealth Alliance: "Opportunities for Enhanced
DEFENSE, MILITARY,
AND SECURITY SECTOR
ENGAGEMENT IN
GLOBAL HEALTH SECURITY"
 
Looking more into the links you posted and the questions of what does EcoHealth Alliance do with the DoD and why, the independent science news link itemizes how much and to which programs.

Biosurveillance for spillover of filoviruses etc...
Rift Valley fever research in South Africa
Reducing threat of pathogens of febrile illnesses in Liberia
Hemorraghic fever in Tanzania
It looks like they also work with AfriCom...

I don't understand what is nefarious about this?
 
Looking more into the links you posted and the questions of what does EcoHealth Alliance do with the DoD and why, the independent science news link itemizes how much and to which programs.

Biosurveillance for spillover of filoviruses etc...
Rift Valley fever research in South Africa
Reducing threat of pathogens of febrile illnesses in Liberia
Hemorraghic fever in Tanzania
It looks like they also work with AfriCom...

I don't understand what is nefarious about this?
It's not 'nefarious'. All the world powers spend money on bio-threats, natural and potentially weaponized.

I was surprised at all of the direct overlap with other 'pandemic threat' programs that are most talked about, like the USAID backed PREDICT program which was reinvented last Sept as STOP Spillover ($100M):
With the consortium's cross-disciplinary experience and deep relationships in partner countries, STOP Spillover will contribute directly to the reduction of future outbreaks from known zoonotic viruses.

Then there are research grants by 5 or 6 other depts (like NIH and NSF)- which also have many international partners, including gov't, NGO, scientific institutes, and private firms.

NIH and also USAID fund "One Health" ($85M) which establishes the EpiCenter for Emerging Infectious Disease Intelligence (they also get funds for the Global Virome Project):
Our team will facilitate collaborative responsiveness to emerging infectious disease risk at the local, regional, and international levels. Our work will focus on arboviruses, filoviruses, and coronaviruses, as well as newly emerging threats that pose epidemic and pandemic risk.

The main US agency in charge or pandemic response is the Dept of HHS which has the CDC and ASPR (Assistant Secretary for Preparedness and Response) which "advises on matters related to bioterrorism and other public health emergencies."

There are the main international bodies like the WHO and the GHSA (Global Security Health Agenda) for which the US gov't contributes heavily to coordinate efforts in preventing emerging health threats.

NATO and the UN also have their own task forces dedicated to bio-threats.

DoD's dept grant to study bat viruses in W. China says
"DEFENSE THREAT REDUCTION AGENCY (DTRA), DEPT OF DEFENSE: SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH - COMBATING WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION.
Objectives
To support and stimulate basic, applied and advanced research at educational or research institutions, non-profit organizations, and commercial firms, which support the advancement of fundamental knowledge and understanding of the sciences with an emphasis on exploring new and innovative research for combating or countering Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMD)."

Many of these grants are shared with the same programs, with the same people and partners, and the same research activities as others - all with essentially the same goal of reducing global disease threats.

The difference in the DoD is that, in addition to an interest in general 'health security' from natural sources, they have the added responsibility of looking out for for weaponized bio-terrorism threats and ways to combat it. I don't think it's too outlandish to wonder how scientific or intelligence reports to the military may differ from the others.

It may also be as simple as a way for all the agencies to collaborate and share the expenses- with the DoD having the largest purse. Which is why I asked about it....because I don't know.
 
My taxes are done so I can spend more time on this tomorrow.

As far as Daszak is concerned, his company is nonprofit and the causes the company invests the grants on are worthy causes. I said that earlier. That doesn't mean he doesn't collect a hefty salary and he has a significant interest in the work his company does.

That translates to him having serious motivation to hide the potential that the pandemic resulted from his company's work or from the WIV. All the funding from multiple sources could dry right up if it turns out one of the dangerous viruses they were working with escaped the lab.

Given COVID should have been the very thing they were working to prevent, it says that at a minimum the research Daszak's company was doing did not prevent or even ready the world for this pandemic.

And that is especially troublesome given COVID is within the range of horseshoe bat coronaviruses.

So we still have the very thing the WIV and Daszak were working on just happened to start in Wuhan and nowhere else in China.

Back to Andersen's work finding 2 distinct strains of COVID in Wuhan, the biggest question becomes, isn't this finding even more of an improbable coincidence?

So what is the hypothesis here, that 2 different wet markets in China just happened to infect 2 different people in Wuhan? Where did the 2 strains diverge?

Andersen believed she found links to both strains outside of Wuhan. That's fine but I've not seen the timeline of these other infections. Were they before or after Sept 2019 which is when Andersen found both lineages in Wuhan.

If the evidence of divergent lineages really does rule out the WIV and/or Daszak's work as the likely source, how did those 2 lineages end up in 2 patients in Wuhan in Sept 2019?

IIRC, Andersen didn't identify these 2 patients, but rather walked the genetic clock back and that's where she believed 2 patients in Wuhan were infected. I'll have to review the evidence tomorrow or in the next couple days if it takes me longer.

If there is evidence the pandemic didn't start in Wuhan, let's see it. I don't mean evidence it could have happened outside of Wuhan. I mean evidence it did.

Given there have been undetected cases there still should be some evidence explaining how or why the known cases turned up in the very place researchers were investigating related coronaviruses.
 
Last edited:
Given COVID should have been the very thing they were working to prevent, it says that at a minimum the research Daszak's company was doing did not prevent or even ready the world for this pandemic.
And that is especially troublesome given COVID is within the range of horseshoe bat coronaviruses.

That's hardly fair. There are charities and institutions that work to stop famine, and war and various other problems. If those things happen we don't say, "well those charities and institutions are a failure!"

EcoHealth Alliance are involved in all kinds of projects all over the world with all kinds of viruses, formulating policies for how to live around bats, trying to identify hotspots and new viruses etc... They can't nessarily be everywhere at once.

Besides, do we know that the work they and their colleagues have done not helped the world's virologists when it comes to vaccines etc...?



Back to Andersen's work finding 2 distinct strains of COVID in Wuhan, the biggest question becomes, isn't this finding even more of an improbable coincidence?

So what is the hypothesis here, that 2 different wet markets in China just happened to infect 2 different people in Wuhan? Where did the 2 strains diverge?

Andersen believed she found links to both strains outside of Wuhan. That's fine but I've not seen the timeline of these other infections. Were they before or after Sept 2019 which is when Andersen found both lineages in Wuhan.
If the evidence of divergent lineages really does rule out the WIV and/or Daszak's work as the likely source, how did those 2 lineages end up in 2 patients in Wuhan in Sept 2019?

IIRC, Andersen didn't identify these 2 patients, but rather walked the genetic clock back and that's where she believed 2 patients in Wuhan were infected. I'll have to review the evidence tomorrow or in the next couple days if it takes me longer.

If there is evidence the pandemic didn't start in Wuhan, let's see it. I don't mean evidence it could have happened outside of Wuhan. I mean evidence it did.

Given there have been undetected cases there still should be some evidence explaining how or why the known cases turned up in the very place researchers were investigating related coronaviruses.

If you are talking about the same Andersen as I think you are, Andersen is a he.

And if you are talking about the more recent paper, I believe it is by Robert Garry, although Andersen and Garry seem to have been doing a lot of research together with other researchers such as Ian Lipkin, Andrew Rambaut and Eddie Holmes such as this earlier paper.

Sept 2019 which is when Andersen found both lineages in Wuhan.

Andersen found both lineages in Wuhan in Sept 2019? Where is this stated?
 
I somehow read "she" or maybe I misread "Kristain". Anyway, correction noted.

I still have to review the links I posted last year to discuss the rest.
 
That's hardly fair. There are charities and institutions that work to stop famine, and war and various other problems. If those things happen we don't say, "well those charities and institutions are a failure!"

EcoHealth Alliance are involved in all kinds of projects all over the world with all kinds of viruses, formulating policies for how to live around bats, trying to identify hotspots and new viruses etc... They can't nessarily be everywhere at once.

Besides, do we know that the work they and their colleagues have done not helped the world's virologists when it comes to vaccines etc...?


I do question the risk vs reward of the virus hunting. Seems to me that it is better to look for human or animal sickness in areas of concern, then take measures, as they did with the people in Africa who were getting infected from contaminated sap from bats sipping on it. Put a small cover on it, provide local education...and the problem was mitigated.

Going out purposefully to find one of the 800k- 1M or so (estimated) dangerous unknown viruses at risk for spillover and bringing them back to labs to see how easily they could infect humans....and then using humans to do the tests on other mammals with human traits seems to be pretty risky!

Recall that SARS infected 3 different labs even after it was under control, and 3 separate times just at one high level BS-4 lab in Beijing.
That is just one virus.
Another virus being studied (Hanta) infected students (and then other locals) in Yunnan with an unknown recombinant strain- a NEW spillover between lab animals.


Let's say that the scientists are given enough money to look for thousands more dangerous viruses. 10k or 20k even. What are the odds of a natural spillover vs a lab spillover getting to a major city? What are the odds that both would happen anyway given that the natural one probably goes undetected or mutates outside of the collection time period in some area that was unknown to be ripe for it?
Essentially, they are testing mostly 'losers' without knowing the Russian roulette they play that could result in a pandemic. That's why most of the coronavirus work was done in BS-2 and BS-3 labs and not the BS-4 one. The vast majority of wild non-human samples are relatively harmless- always have been and always will be.

But it just takes ONE.
The virus we have as our pandemic de jure is not like the leaks before. Exposure through aerosols may go unnoticed. There may be no sickness in a day, or a week, or ever! There would be no reason to even test for it.
All the while transmission is possible and can quickly grow exponentially.

Monitor the people and the animals. Then assess risk. If a pattern emerges that populations of a certain size living in proximity with animal vector habitats or bird migration areas are ill or positive for virus antibodies, then investigate thoroughly and take measures.

The evidence for spillover was encountered a few times in Yunnan- and 4 people exposed at the same time actually DIED. What was done? Isnt this what they are there to prevent??? To catch it at the first infections?
They took samples back to the lab to study. And kept coming back for more, for years.
What else needed to happen to get their attention of a problem?

And now, knowing they were right there where this thing originated (no matter what hoops the virus traveled through afterwards), and they called the area concerning for spillover of dangerous viruses.... how did that 10+ yrs of research help us? That we 'know' things about some of the related viruses is just extra knowledge, but it hasn't helped any humans survive, or get vaccinated, or develop treatments. It could help with the next one....or it could be the cause of it.
 
Last edited:
I do question the risk vs reward of the virus hunting. Seems to me that it is better to look for human or animal sickness in areas of concern, then take measures, as they did with the people in Africa who were getting infected from contaminated sap from bats sipping on it. Put a small cover on it, provide local education...and the problem was mitigated.

Going out purposefully to find one of the 800k- 1M or so (estimated) dangerous unknown viruses at risk for spillover and bringing them back to labs to see how easily they could infect humans....and then using humans to do the tests on other mammals with human traits seems to be pretty risky!

Recall that SARS infected 3 different labs even after it was under control, and 3 separate times just at one high level BS-4 lab in Beijing.
That is just one virus.
Another virus being studied (Hanta) infected students (and then other locals) in Yunnan with an unknown recombinant strain- a NEW spillover between lab animals.


Let's say that the scientists are given enough money to look for thousands more dangerous viruses. 10k or 20k even. What are the odds of a natural spillover vs a lab spillover getting to a major city? What are the odds that both would happen anyway given that the natural one probably goes undetected or mutates outside of the collection time period in some area that was unknown to be ripe for it?
Essentially, they are testing mostly 'losers' without knowing the Russian roulette they play that could result in a pandemic. That's why most of the coronavirus work was done in BS-2 and BS-3 labs and not the BS-4 one. The vast majority of wild non-human samples are relatively harmless- always have been and always will be.

But it just takes ONE.
The virus we have as our pandemic de jure is not like the leaks before. Exposure through aerosols may go unnoticed. There may be no sickness in a day, or a week, or ever! There would be no reason to even test for it.
All the while transmission is possible and can quickly grow exponentially.

Monitor the people and the animals. Then assess risk. If a pattern emerges that populations of a certain size living in proximity with animal vector habitats or bird migration areas are ill or positive for virus antibodies, then investigate thoroughly and take measures.

The evidence for spillover was encountered a few times in Yunnan- and 4 people exposed at the same time actually DIED. What was done? Isnt this what they are there to prevent??? To catch it at the first infections?
They took samples back to the lab to study. And kept coming back for more, for years.
What else needed to happen to get their attention of a problem?

And now, knowing they were right there where this thing originated (no matter what hoops the virus traveled through afterwards), and they called the area concerning for spillover of dangerous viruses.... how did that 10+ yrs of research help us? That we 'know' things about some of the related viruses is just extra knowledge, but it hasn't helped any humans survive, or get vaccinated, or develop treatments. It could help with the next one....or it could be the cause of it.

Well, that is why I am looking forward to hearing what Daszak and others say on TWiV when they come on the podcast in a week or two.

In the meantime, from what I understand they have done some important work in mitigating or understanding viruses (Nipah, Hendra (which is related to Nipah), and Ebola for example).

Some of the work is of course controversial and it will be worth examining.

At the moment, I don't think any of us know enough to make those judgments yet.
 
I somehow read "she" or maybe I misread "Kristain". Anyway, correction noted.

I still have to review the links I posted last year to discuss the rest.

No problem. I think some people on Twitter (of the lab leak persuasion) have taken to calling him Hans (Hans Kristian Andersen, presumably because they consider him to be telling fairy tales).
 
although there is a Chinese dissident scientist who claims she worked there and saw it all and says that is exactly what happened.
Who? Nameless Chinese dissident scientist has the strong smell of woo conspiracy about it. Much like the old "Russian scientist" woo decades ago.

Any chances to actually track that one down?

Most military research would actually be involved in developing counter measures to biological attacks. If anything this research is even more sensitive because if someone knows your countermeasures they can potentially find a way around them
Far more plausible, and there is even evidence for that. No evidence I know of for an accidental leak, but certainly evidence that China was afraid the US would have the ability, and were working on countermeasures in Wuhan.
 
Last edited:
Andersen tweets:

And here they are - the 'mysterious' (hint, not mysterious) eight SARS-like CoVs from the Wuhan Institute of Virology, just put online at CNCB.

I expect paper to follow? These are distantly related to SARS-CoV-2 as previously mentioned.

Zhengli Shi and co-authors seem to have a pre-print up about these.

Are these coronaviruses that people had been wondering about being scrubbed from the database, or somehow not available when they should be?
 
Dr. Fauci reconsiders

"I am not convinced about that, I think we should continue to investigate what went on in China until we continue to find out to the best of our ability what happened," Fauci told PolitiFact's managing editor Katie Sanders.
"Certainly, the people who investigated it say it likely was the emergence from an animal reservoir that then infected individuals, but it could have been something else, and we need to find that out. So, you know, that's the reason why I said I'm perfectly in favor of any investigation that looks into the origin of the virus," he continued.
A quote from a story at CNN
It is difficult to know what to make of his cautious statement. Perhaps he is hedging his bets.
 
Last edited:
Huh? What is Fauci reconsidering and what "bets" would he be hedging?


ETA: He doesn't appear to be reconsidering. He hasn't contradicted anything he's said earlier and he never expressed any final conclusion that would even make reconsidering possible. This appears to be blown up for sensationalism purposes.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom