That's hardly fair. There are charities and institutions that work to stop famine, and war and various other problems. If those things happen we don't say, "well those charities and institutions are a failure!"
EcoHealth Alliance are involved in all kinds of projects all over the world with all kinds of viruses, formulating policies for how to live around bats, trying to identify hotspots and new viruses etc... They can't nessarily be everywhere at once.
Besides, do we know that the work they and their colleagues have done not helped the world's virologists when it comes to vaccines etc...?
I do question the risk vs reward of the virus hunting. Seems to me that it is better to look for human or animal sickness in areas of concern, then take measures, as they did with the people in Africa who were getting infected from contaminated sap from bats sipping on it. Put a small cover on it, provide local education...and the problem was mitigated.
Going out purposefully to find one of the 800k- 1M or so (estimated) dangerous unknown viruses at risk for spillover and bringing them back to labs to see how easily they could infect humans....and then using humans to do the tests on other mammals with human traits seems to be pretty risky!
Recall that SARS infected 3 different labs even after it was under control, and 3 separate times just at one high level BS-4 lab in Beijing.
That is just one virus.
Another virus being studied (Hanta) infected students (and then other locals) in Yunnan with an unknown recombinant strain- a NEW spillover between lab animals.
Let's say that the scientists are given enough money to look for thousands more dangerous viruses. 10k or 20k even. What are the odds of a natural spillover vs a lab spillover getting to a major city? What are the odds that both would happen anyway given that the natural one probably goes undetected or mutates outside of the collection time period in some area that was unknown to be ripe for it?
Essentially, they are testing mostly 'losers' without knowing the Russian roulette they play that could result in a pandemic. That's why most of the coronavirus work was done in BS-2 and BS-3 labs and not the BS-4 one. The vast majority of wild non-human samples are relatively harmless- always have been and always will be.
But it just takes ONE.
The virus we have as our
pandemic de jure is not like the leaks before. Exposure through aerosols may go unnoticed. There may be no sickness in a day, or a week, or ever! There would be no reason to even test for it.
All the while transmission is possible and can quickly grow exponentially.
Monitor the people and the animals. Then assess risk. If a pattern emerges that populations of a certain size living in proximity with animal vector habitats or bird migration areas are ill or positive for virus antibodies, then investigate thoroughly and take measures.
The evidence for spillover was encountered a few times in Yunnan- and 4 people exposed at the same time actually DIED. What was done? Isnt this what they are there to prevent??? To catch it at the first infections?
They took samples back to the lab to study. And kept coming back for more, for years.
What else needed to happen to get their attention of a problem?
And now, knowing they were right there where this thing originated (no matter what hoops the virus traveled through afterwards), and they called the area concerning for spillover of dangerous viruses.... how did that 10+ yrs of research help us? That we 'know' things about some of the
related viruses is just extra knowledge, but it hasn't helped any humans survive, or get vaccinated, or develop treatments. It could help with the next one....or it could be the cause of it.