I have not followed this debate very closely, but until yesterday I thought that there were three distinct hypotheses. One, this virus has a natural origin and jumped from other species into humans. Two, this virus was found in animals, studied in the lab, and accidentally released. Three, this virus was deliberately engineered as a weapon. After reading the article by Nicholas Wade, it seems to me that there is a fourth hypothesis: the virus was engineered but it then escaped from the lab. The fourth hypothesis blends portions of hypotheses two and three. Is this summary of the hypotheses correct and complete?
Well, the WHO speculate four hypotheses, although they don't seem to really be distinct:
1.) The virus that causes Covid came directly from bats to humans (there have been similar viruses such as RatG13 which is maybe the closest known virus to SARS-CoV2 and which did manage to kill some people in a cave although this is probably because of the close proximity to it).
2.) Covid came to humans from bats via another animal. Various other animals have been suggested such as pangolins (I believe there is a coronavirus found in pangolins that has similar spike protein which made it one of the top suspects for a while, and this would be similar to how SARS came to humans, via markets which sold wild animals, specifically a civet cat. Many other viruses seem to have made a journey from bats to humans via an amplifying animal - Hendra, Ebola, Nipah...)
The thing about (1) and (2) is that the closest viruses known to SARS-Cov2 seem to have come from Yunnan Province which is a long distance from Wuhan. So this has led to some speculation...
3) WHO/China also suggested that the virus somehow hitched a ride to Wuhan on frozen food (I think almost nobody seems to take this one seriously, and really doesn't it still depend on 1 or 2? so it isn't a parsimounious explanation.)
or
4) Given that Zhengli Shi is one of the foremost researchers of SARS-like coronaviruses and her work was mostly in Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV), wouldn't that solve the mystery of how it got to Wuhan?
So then, yes, there are subdivisions of 4 that present themselves.
4a) It was made entirely there as a bioweapon. - No evidence for that and almost nobody takes it seriously although there is a Chinese dissident scientist who claims she worked there and saw it all and says that is exactly what happened.
4b) Shi's team collected some type of SARS-like virus and put it through Gain of function treatment to make it more virulent and easier to transmit to humans for the purpose of being able to more easily find counter-strategies against it (the claim then is that the WIV scientists were working on something they believed would benefit humanity, rather than 4a, which suggests that they were acting out of malevolence). And then...oops, it got out...maybe someone got infected, maybe protocols weren't followed, maybe it was thrown out in a biohazard bin, etc...
4c) Similar to 4b: It is a virus that was collected from bats,
but it was not experimented on, or not altered, but it got out anyway.
In addition to the 4a,b,c hypotheses, it is claimed that the virus got out around September, or at least that is when the Chinese authorities discovered it, and they took down a database of SARS-like coronaviruses.
I think that about covers the hypotheses.
Please add to this list if I left something out.