Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
What are the hypotheses?

I have not followed this debate very closely, but until yesterday I thought that there were three distinct hypotheses. One, this virus has a natural origin and jumped from other species into humans. Two, this virus was found in animals, studied in the lab, and accidentally released. Three, this virus was deliberately engineered as a weapon. After reading the article by Nicholas Wade, it seems to me that there is a fourth hypothesis: the virus was engineered but it then escaped from the lab. The fourth hypothesis blends portions of hypotheses two and three. Is this summary of the hypotheses correct and complete?
 
I have not followed this debate very closely, but until yesterday I thought that there were three distinct hypotheses. One, this virus has a natural origin and jumped from other species into humans. Two, this virus was found in animals, studied in the lab, and accidentally released. Three, this virus was deliberately engineered as a weapon. After reading the article by Nicholas Wade, it seems to me that there is a fourth hypothesis: the virus was engineered but it then escaped from the lab. The fourth hypothesis blends portions of hypotheses two and three. Is this summary of the hypotheses correct and complete?

I think we can throw out the "deliberately engineered as a weapon" hypothesis, and I am not aware of anyone serious promoting that idea.

The idea that Nicholas Wade is talking about is actually that the research was being done with the best of intentions, the objective being to predict what the next zoonotic outbreak like SARS or MERS might look like. So yes, you manipulate the naturally-occurring virus to see what sort of mutations might make it more likely to jump from animals to humans. Then you test it in vitro to see if the virus can infect human cells. But you are not supposed to let it escape of course. I guess the idea is that you could make vaccines and such ahead of time and have them ready when it actually happens?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gain_of_function_research
Gain of function research (GoFR) is a field of medical research focused on the serial passaging of microorganisms in vitro and in vivo. This places positive selective pressure on the microorganisms to effect mutations that would increase their pathogenicity, transmissibility, and antigenicity. These studies can also expand the host tropism of a pathogen to new host species or organ tissue. This research is intended to reveal targets to better predict emerging infectious diseases and to develop vaccines and therapeutics.

In virology, gain-of-function research is employed with the intention of better understanding current and future pandemics.[1] In vaccine development, gain-of-function research is conducted in the hope of gaining a head start on a virus and being able to develop a vaccine or therapeutic before it emerges.[1]

So, as you can see, this is not intended to create a weapon. It's intended to understand the viruses better, to develop vaccines and therapeutics, and to predict emerging infectious diseases.
 
I have not followed this debate very closely, but until yesterday I thought that there were three distinct hypotheses. One, this virus has a natural origin and jumped from other species into humans. Two, this virus was found in animals, studied in the lab, and accidentally released. Three, this virus was deliberately engineered as a weapon. After reading the article by Nicholas Wade, it seems to me that there is a fourth hypothesis: the virus was engineered but it then escaped from the lab. The fourth hypothesis blends portions of hypotheses two and three. Is this summary of the hypotheses correct and complete?

Well, the WHO speculate four hypotheses, although they don't seem to really be distinct:

1.) The virus that causes Covid came directly from bats to humans (there have been similar viruses such as RatG13 which is maybe the closest known virus to SARS-CoV2 and which did manage to kill some people in a cave although this is probably because of the close proximity to it).

2.) Covid came to humans from bats via another animal. Various other animals have been suggested such as pangolins (I believe there is a coronavirus found in pangolins that has similar spike protein which made it one of the top suspects for a while, and this would be similar to how SARS came to humans, via markets which sold wild animals, specifically a civet cat. Many other viruses seem to have made a journey from bats to humans via an amplifying animal - Hendra, Ebola, Nipah...)

The thing about (1) and (2) is that the closest viruses known to SARS-Cov2 seem to have come from Yunnan Province which is a long distance from Wuhan. So this has led to some speculation...

3) WHO/China also suggested that the virus somehow hitched a ride to Wuhan on frozen food (I think almost nobody seems to take this one seriously, and really doesn't it still depend on 1 or 2? so it isn't a parsimounious explanation.)

or

4) Given that Zhengli Shi is one of the foremost researchers of SARS-like coronaviruses and her work was mostly in Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV), wouldn't that solve the mystery of how it got to Wuhan?

So then, yes, there are subdivisions of 4 that present themselves.

4a) It was made entirely there as a bioweapon. - No evidence for that and almost nobody takes it seriously although there is a Chinese dissident scientist who claims she worked there and saw it all and says that is exactly what happened.

4b) Shi's team collected some type of SARS-like virus and put it through Gain of function treatment to make it more virulent and easier to transmit to humans for the purpose of being able to more easily find counter-strategies against it (the claim then is that the WIV scientists were working on something they believed would benefit humanity, rather than 4a, which suggests that they were acting out of malevolence). And then...oops, it got out...maybe someone got infected, maybe protocols weren't followed, maybe it was thrown out in a biohazard bin, etc...

4c) Similar to 4b: It is a virus that was collected from bats, but it was not experimented on, or not altered, but it got out anyway.

In addition to the 4a,b,c hypotheses, it is claimed that the virus got out around September, or at least that is when the Chinese authorities discovered it, and they took down a database of SARS-like coronaviruses.

I think that about covers the hypotheses.

Please add to this list if I left something out.
 
Last edited:
4a) It was made entirely there as a bioweapon. - No evidence for that and almost nobody takes it seriously although there is a Chinese dissident scientist who claims she worked there and saw it all and says that is exactly what happened.

Who is this person? Somehow I must have missed this news. It sounds rather far-fetched to me. For starters, its military utility seems to be close to zero. It mainly only kills old people or those with pre-existing conditions. Soldiers are young and healthy, and get discharged from the military if they aren't. It makes no sense as a bioweapon.
 
Who is this person? Somehow I must have missed this news. It sounds rather far-fetched to me. For starters, its military utility seems to be close to zero. It mainly only kills old people or those with pre-existing conditions. Soldiers are young and healthy, and get discharged from the military if they aren't. It makes no sense as a bioweapon.

Here is a link. As I say, I don't think it is being taken seriously by many people.
 
Who is this person? Somehow I must have missed this news. It sounds rather far-fetched to me. For starters, its military utility seems to be close to zero. It mainly only kills old people or those with pre-existing conditions. Soldiers are young and healthy, and get discharged from the military if they aren't. It makes no sense as a bioweapon.

1 - It could have been a work in progress

2 - There's more to bioweapons than direct military action. Consider the economic damage that the world has suffered by exposure to a virus which kills mainly retired people.

That said, I don't take the idea seriously either.
 
Yes, but read again...



It only says that wildlife farms were supplying vendors.

It says literally nothing about whether they had been shown to be the trail for Covid.

I remember what was said at the time, only that they know who the vendors are and that should be the next stage of the research.

There was literally never any suggestion that they had found the Covid trail and that it would appear in the report. That was never promised.
You seem to be in denial about Daszak promoting this version of 'it wasn't the lab'. Why?
 
I have not followed this debate very closely, but until yesterday I thought that there were three distinct hypotheses. One, this virus has a natural origin and jumped from other species into humans. Two, this virus was found in animals, studied in the lab, and accidentally released. Three, this virus was deliberately engineered as a weapon. After reading the article by Nicholas Wade, it seems to me that there is a fourth hypothesis: the virus was engineered but it then escaped from the lab. The fourth hypothesis blends portions of hypotheses two and three. Is this summary of the hypotheses correct and complete?

I guess this depends on one's definition of "engineered".

Just before the first cases came to the attention of the medical community Daszak was interviewed (the link to the interview is here) about the gain of function research with coronavirus he was involved in. The interview was in early Dec IIRC.

Gain of function research could produce a virus that looked natural. I was under the impression that an engineered virus was one that genetic segments were purposefully inserted and that would be easily detected with genetic analysis. That was not detected.

The CT this was the Chinese military developing a bioweapon was for all intents and purposes, ruled out.

'Chimeras' show a genetic shift rather than genetic drift and they occur in the wild. This occurs with the flu virus and it also occurs with coronavirus. IOW it is a natural occurrence but one can encourage such a recombinant strain to occur in the lab.

It's my understanding the potential means this virus emerged as a pandemic are:
1) Directly constructed (no evidence of this).
2) The 'chimera' occurred in the wild.
2a) Could have occurred in the horseshoe bats and directly infected humans. There is evidence this is possible.
2b) Could have occurred with an intermediary species in between — bat -> unidentified spacies -> human. The problem with this hypothesis is no unidentified species like the Civet Cat with SARS 1 has been found.​
3) And it could have been developed experimentally in the lab using similar processes that occur in the wild. It would look the same genetically as if it had occurred in the wild.​

The research paper developed by Andersen et al back in early 2020 and linked to much earlier in the thread showed the 2 different strains she found. It took the earliest cases back to Sept in Wuhan, but she hypothesized it went back even further. If the first cases were in Sept it explains the Chinese government removing a large amount of coronavirus genetic data from general scientific access.

Andersen also thought the 2 strains diverged earlier than Sept and found evidence in strains circulating in different populations.

Two questions arise, I don't see a timeline of when those specimens were collected. And why then did this pathogen emerge very near the lab where gain of function research was going on?

I left those questions unanswered when I posted Andersen's work.

Dr Quay's two papers directly connected the initial cases to the WIV including showing temporal and physical evidence. That included a pattern of hospitalized cases in the path of the mass transit line #2 that goes from the WIV into other parts of Wuhan.


I still haven't looked closely at the new citation Capsid posted. (Tax day is Monday. I can't ever seem to get my taxes done until the last minute.)
 
Who is this person? Somehow I must have missed this news. It sounds rather far-fetched to me. For starters, its military utility seems to be close to zero. It mainly only kills old people or those with pre-existing conditions. Soldiers are young and healthy, and get discharged from the military if they aren't. It makes no sense as a bioweapon.

Covid-19 seems an unlikely bioweapon, for reasons you stated and others. Generally, for a bio-weapon, you want something that is rapidly lethal or incapacitating, but not excessively contagious, so that you can target it carefully, and not have it spread back to you. Antrhax is one example. I think the hypothesis that it was something the Wuhan lab was experimenting with, that escaped accidentally is quite plausible, but I haven't seen any huge reason to favor that hypothesis over it being an entirely natural event of an animal virus jumping to humans.
 
Here is a link. As I say, I don't think it is being taken seriously by many people.

OK, that's even beyond the level of crazy that I had imagined:
Yan's second report doubles down on the theory, accusing scientists from around the world of creating and uploading fake coronavirus sequences from bats and other animals into a genetic data bank. The goal of this effort, according to the paper, is to obscure the "true origin" of the new coronavirus, SARS-CoV-2.

The authors have little evidence to back-up these accusations, according to Emma Hodcroft, a geneticist who studies the coronavirus with the Nextstrain group in Switzerland.

"To me, the most outlandish claim is that there is a global conspiracy of scientists planting 'fake' SARS-like-CoV genomes into public databases in order to lay the groundwork for manufacturing and releasing a deadly variant," she told Business Insider.

This would mean that it's not just the Chinese military, but somehow scientists from all over the world who have sequenced the virus are also in on it.
 
This would mean that it's not just the Chinese military, but somehow scientists from all over the world who have sequenced the virus are also in on it.

Well most lab leak theories tend to assume some complicity of virologists all over the world.

Daszak is the one most often mentioned, but he was part of a WHO team with scientists from all over the world.

They are apparently keeping silent and/or complicit in the lab leak cover-up according to most theories on this.

Similarly, all the virologists on TWiV routinely cover-up for China, the WHO, EcoHealth Alliance, etc...

It doesn't mean it isn't true, but if the argument works against the bioweapon theory, then it also works to some extent with the idea that the leaked virus was on the database, the database was taken down, and the virologists of the world are claiming ignorance (or just simply not mentioning anything at all about an apparently suspicious pattern of behaviour).
 
Well most lab leak theories tend to assume some complicity of virologists all over the world.
Not in that way though. I.e., "creating and uploading fake coronavirus sequences". More like, they want to make sure that their profession isn't blamed for creating a pandemic, and also they don't want their research funding to be cut, so they are very keen to dismiss the (accidental) lab-leak hypothesis.




Similarly, all the virologists on TWiV routinely cover-up for China, the WHO, EcoHealth Alliance, etc...

I am not a regular listener to that podcast, but is there a particular episode of that which delves into the origin question?
 
Well most lab leak theories tend to assume some complicity of virologists all over the world.

Daszak is the one most often mentioned, but he was part of a WHO team with scientists from all over the world.

They are apparently keeping silent and/or complicit in the lab leak cover-up according to most theories on this.

Similarly, all the virologists on TWiV routinely cover-up for China, the WHO, EcoHealth Alliance, etc...

It doesn't mean it isn't true, but if the argument works against the bioweapon theory, then it also works to some extent with the idea that the leaked virus was on the database, the database was taken down, and the virologists of the world are claiming ignorance (or just simply not mentioning anything at all about an apparently suspicious pattern of behaviour).
Did you just completely ignore all the links in this thread discussing Daszak's conflict of interest? And how that played a role in the WHO making some initial claim that the lab leak hypothesis was ruled out which caused the head of the WHO to speak out the lab leak was not ruled out?

You don't seem to be keeping up when it comes to the evidence of Daszak's conflict of interest.
 
So maybe post it in the CT thread instead of trying to discredit this one.

Would you get that chip off your shoulder, please! Your knee-jerk hostility and constant leaping to the most uncharitable assumptions about others is tiresome.

I was asked to supply a link to one of a number of hypotheses. I was saying exactly the same thing as you and others that this is one of a number of hypotheses and one that nobody takes seriously.
 
I am not a regular listener to that podcast, but is there a particular episode of that which delves into the origin question?

There have been a few, but not in a comprehensive systematic way.

I suppose there is one where they talk about it here:

https://youtu.be/LqGPuFoYiNY?t=3935

I think each week when Vincent Racaniello and Amy Rosenfeld take Q&A they get people asking about lab leak etc... It might be worth tuning in for those (I think they would be about 9 am our time in Japan every Thursday. I tend to have it on in the background when I am doing other work, or I listen to it later).

That said, they have said that three members of the WHO team will be coming onto the podcast (I think that includes Daszak) so that should be interesting.
 
One thing I do notice however, is that there do appear to be factions within the microbiology world with virologists, epidemiologist and molecular biologists apparently warring with each other.

One thing that had caused friction before was the dispute over the use of gain of function research. Most people who appear on TWiV tend to be all for it.

Other scientists, some of whom they clearly have some professional animus with, are dead against it and ultimately in the US, at least, the latter prevailed and got the research effectively banned.

As you noted, Puppycow, much of this is done at a very low biosecurity level as well.

So I can see how the biases on each side may lead to certain conclusions that are in opposition.
 
I am not a regular listener to that podcast, but is there a particular episode of that which delves into the origin question?

I was listening to the latest one and it just heard the host saying that Fox News played a clip of him talking to Peter Daszak from a TWiV episode that went out not long before the pandemic.

Apparently parts of the interview had been played on Tucker Carlson's show...

https://youtu.be/l7iRb4YjzzQ?t=1387

The response on the show is that the interview was misunderstood, although they seem to be so excited to talk about how it was misunderstood that I didn't really understand it.

The interview being referenced is here:

https://youtu.be/IdYDL_RK--w?t=1791

However, one interesting point here is that one person mentioned here (Ralph Baric), I think, signed the letter that was sent to Science saying that the lab leak theory cannot be ruled out.

LETTERS
Investigate the origins of COVID-19
Jesse D. Bloom1,2, Yujia Alina Chan3, Ralph S. Baric4, Pamela J. Bjorkman5, Sarah Cobey6, Benjamin E. Deverman3, David N. Fisman7, Ravindra Gupta8, Akiko Iwasaki9,2, Marc Lipsitch10, Ruslan Medzhitov9,2, Richard A. Neher11, Rasmus Nielsen12, Nick Patterson13, Tim Stearns14, Erik van Nimwegen11, Michael Worobey15, David A. Relman16,17,*
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom