Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not so simple though. Even if they don't work directly for China, they are hardly immune to political pressure from China. Plus half the members of the team are Chinese citizens and they had veto power over anything that might make it into the report.

WHO inquiry into COVID-19 origins 'compromised by politics', say scientists awaiting overdue report



The open letter is in a format that cannot easily be copy-pasted, but should be read.

I realize it isn't easy.

That said, my other points stand.

As far as access to a Chinese BSL-4 lab is concerned, I would expect from the outset that it is difficult to get full access.

As a thought experiment, would a US BSL-4 be open to a WHO inspection where the team gets to look at anything and everything they want?

My guess is, no.
 
Garry has published this

https://virological.org/t/early-app...-suggests-sars-cov-2-has-a-natural-origin/691

He was an author on the original Andersen paper. He argues that the early appearance of two distinct lineages argues against a lab or engineered origin.

Can't trust Garry! He let the Ebola out! [Of course, I am joking, but this is apparently an accusation he had levelled at him when some Ebola turned up outside of the normal area it was thought to be located].

Thanks for the link!
 
Garry has published this

https://virological.org/t/early-app...-suggests-sars-cov-2-has-a-natural-origin/691

He was an author on the original Andersen paper. He argues that the early appearance of two distinct lineages argues against a lab or engineered origin.

From your link:
The majority of early cases were linked to different markets that sold wildlife or wildlife products in Wuhan.
And yet they could not find any source of initial exposure at any of the markets. The virus was found in cases earlier than the market cases and while there was a potential exposure from another market, it was a relative that had been to that market but the case had not.

There is a paper upthread addressing the 2 lineages.

I'll go back and look again. That researcher believed the cases started much earlier than the Wuhan cases but he could not explain two things, why Wuhan and why were earlier cases not detected?
 
Last edited:
I realize it isn't easy.

That said, my other points stand.

As far as access to a Chinese BSL-4 lab is concerned, I would expect from the outset that it is difficult to get full access.

As a thought experiment, would a US BSL-4 be open to a WHO inspection where the team gets to look at anything and everything they want?
My guess is, no.

Which just means any investigation of a leak near a US lab would be similarly incomplete and thus suspect.
 
NYTimes:

A group of 18 scientists stated Thursday in a letter published in the journal Science that there is not enough evidence to decide whether a natural origin or an accidental laboratory leak caused the Covid-19 pandemic.

They argued, as the U.S. government and other countries have, for a new investigation to explore where the virus came from.

The organizers of the letter, Jesse Bloom, who studies the evolution of viruses at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in Seattle, and David Relman, a microbiologist at Stanford University, said they strove to articulate a wait-and-see viewpoint that they believe is shared by many scientists. Many of the signers have not spoken out before.

“Most of the discussion you hear about SARS-CoV-2 origins at this point is coming from, I think, the relatively small number of people who feel very certain about their views,” Dr. Bloom said.

He added: “Anybody who’s making statements with a high level of certainty about this is just outstripping what’s possible to do with the available evidence.”

The new letter stated: “Theories of accidental release from a lab and zoonotic spillover both remain viable.”

The letter in Science:

As scientists with relevant expertise, we agree with the WHO director-general (5), the United States and 13 other countries (6), and the European Union (7) that greater clarity about the origins of this pandemic is necessary and feasible to achieve. We must take hypotheses about both natural and laboratory spillovers seriously until we have sufficient data. A proper investigation should be transparent, objective, data-driven, inclusive of broad expertise, subject to independent oversight, and responsibly managed to minimize the impact of conflicts of interest. Public health agencies and research laboratories alike need to open their records to the public. Investigators should document the veracity and provenance of data from which analyses are conducted and conclusions drawn, so that analyses are reproducible by independent experts.

In the NYTimes articel, Kristian Andersen is quoted as opposing the both-sidedness of the letter:

Kristian Andersen, a virologist at the Scripps Research Institute in La Jolla, Calif., has been a strong proponent of the overwhelming likelihood of a natural origin. He was one of the authors of an often cited paper in March 2020 that dismissed the likelihood of a laboratory origin based largely on the genome of the SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes Covid-19. “We do not believe any type of laboratory-based scenario is plausible,” that paper stated.

Speaking for himself only, Dr. Relman said in an interview that “the piece that Kristian Anderson and four others wrote last March in my view simply fails to provide evidence to support their conclusions.”

Dr. Andersen, who reviewed the letter in Science, said that both explanations were theoretically possible. But, “the letter suggests a false equivalence between the lab escape and natural origin scenarios,” he said. “To this day, no credible evidence has been presented to support the lab leak hypothesis, which remains grounded in speculation.”

He also tweeted this
 
... As a thought experiment, would a US BSL-4 be open to a WHO inspection where the team gets to look at anything and everything they want? ....
If there was a reason, then yes.

CDC level 4 biosafety labs are inspected on a regular basis as a requirement in order to have certain biohazards like smallpox virus.

I can't get the following files to open, maybe someone else can:

Startpage search:
https://www.who.int/csr/disease/smallpox/Report_2009_CDC_WHO_Inspection.pdf?ua=1
Report of WHO Biosafety Inspection Team of the Variola Virus ...
conducted in the laboratories meet the highest requirements for biosafety and biosecurity. ... laboratory level, with Principal Investigators holding responsibility in ...

https://www.who.int/csr/disease/smallpox/Smallpox-CDC-inspections-2012.pdf?ua=1
(WHO) Biosafety Inspection Team of the Variola Virus Maximum ...
May 11, 2012 ... At the time of the inspection the laboratory was decommissioned for ... be considered to have an acceptable level of biosafety and laboratory ... and procedures for disinfecting suits and boots before leaving the animal holding ...
 
Garry has published this

https://virological.org/t/early-app...-suggests-sars-cov-2-has-a-natural-origin/691

He was an author on the original Andersen paper. He argues that the early appearance of two distinct lineages argues against a lab or engineered origin.

That is an excellent piece, thanks!

And yet they could not find any source of initial exposure at any of the markets.

Garry's piece covers that:

Certain species of animals may have been removed after the appearance of the first COVID-19 cases and the linkage of COVID-19 cases to the market, but prior to the closure of the Market on January 1, 2020.

And the real meat is the next two sentences:

It should also be noted that environmental samples that did test positive were associated with the portion of the market where wildlife or wildlife products were sold. A temporal analysis of the early human cases at the Huanan market confirms the pattern of spread from the areas of the market where wildlife products were sold to other parts of the market.

That would appear to be extremely unlikely in the case of a lab leak, but fully in keeping with natural origin.

Looks like the case for natural infection is growing stronger.
 
Garry's piece covers that:
And the real meat is the next two sentences:

That would appear to be extremely unlikely in the case of a lab leak, but fully in keeping with natural origin.
That is hardly conclusive of anything, and none of it is new except claiming there were different strains found in different animal markets. Maybe one of those was the patient who had a relative that had gone to a different animal market but the patient had never gone there.

Remember Daszak was off on the farmed wild animals as the nebulous source that he was going to show in his final report. Only oddly, there was no identified source there either.

WHO Points To Wildlife Farms In Southern China As Likely Source Of Pandemic

I haven't had time yet to go back to the one article that mentions the two strains. When I get my taxes done I will.

Looks like the case for natural infection is growing stronger.
No it isn't. There are multiple pieces of evidence in this thread, and look at you, latching on to one that supports your confirmation bias. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Yes doesn't it. :rolleyes:

The irony of you rolling eyes at me is not lost at all. Nowhere have I stated any degree of certainty as to the origin and have taken pains to say that we still do not know.

Compare that to this post:

I was contemplating the universe for a bit today and it struck me what devastation has occurred (and is occurring) worldwide because of a careless act in a single lab.

Then you might like to roll the eyes the other way a bit.
 
Remember Daszak was off on the farmed wild animals as the nebulous source that he was going to show in his final report. Only oddly, there was no identified source there either.

I am pretty sure Daszak never said the final report was going to show that.

My understanding was that given what they had found so far, this was going to be the theory they were going to pursue. Obviously the hunt for the source is continuing.
 
I realize it isn't easy.

That said, my other points stand.

As far as access to a Chinese BSL-4 lab is concerned, I would expect from the outset that it is difficult to get full access.

As a thought experiment, would a US BSL-4 be open to a WHO inspection where the team gets to look at anything and everything they want?

My guess is, no.

I think the latest thinking among proponents of the lab-leak hypothesis is that it more likely escaped from a BSL-2 or BSL-3 lab.

The real problem, however, was not the unsafe state of the Wuhan BSL4 lab but the fact that virologists worldwide don’t like working in BSL4 conditions. You have to wear a space suit, do operations in closed cabinets and accept that everything will take twice as long. So the rules assigning each kind of virus to a given safety level were laxer than some might think was prudent.

Before 2020, the rules followed by virologists in China and elsewhere required that experiments with the SARS1 and MERS viruses be conducted in BSL3 conditions. But all other bat coronaviruses could be studied in BSL2, the next level down. BSL2 requires taking fairly minimal safety precautions, such as wearing lab coats and gloves, not sucking up liquids in a pipette, and putting up biohazard warning signs. Yet a gain-of-function experiment conducted in BSL2 might produce an agent more infectious than either SARS1 or MERS. And if it did, then lab workers would stand a high chance of infection, especially if unvaccinated.

Much of Dr. Shi’s work on gain-of-function in coronaviruses was performed at the BSL2 safety level, as is stated in her publications and other documents. She has said in an interview with Science magazine that “The coronavirus research in our laboratory is conducted in BSL-2 or BSL-3 laboratories.”

The lower the BSL level, the greater the potential for escape, as the safety measures are more relaxed.

Anyway, if it escaped, it seems likely that it escaped not from the new BSL-4 facility but from the BSL-2 or BSL-3 laboratories, as that is where Dr. Shi says they did their coronavirus research.
 
proline and O-glycosylation

Preprint. "Here, we show that O-glycosylation near the furin cleavage site is mediated by specific members of the GALNT enzyme family and is dependent on the novel proline at position 681 (P681)."

This is from the abstract to the preprint, which has not yet been peer-reviewed. I am still attempting to understand this paper, but I thought it might be germane to the discussion of the proline in the PRRA sequence. O-glycosylation can occur at serine or threonine residues, and IIUC T678 is a possible location for this post-translational modification. Glycosylation decreases furin cleavage.
 
Last edited:
Preprint. "Here, we show that O-glycosylation near the furin cleavage site is mediated by specific members of the GALNT enzyme family and is dependent on the novel proline at position 681 (P681)."

This is from the abstract to the preprint, which has not yet been peer-reviewed. I am still attempting to understand this paper, but I thought it might be germane to the discussion of the proline in the PRRA sequence. O-glycosylation can occur at serine or threonine residues, and IIUC T678 is a possible location for this post-translational modification. Glycosylation decreases furin cleavage.


Thanks! The final remark in the discussion says that loss of the proline may cause increased infectivity, therefore arguing against including it in an engineered virus.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
I am pretty sure Daszak never said the final report was going to show that.

My understanding was that given what they had found so far, this was going to be the theory they were going to pursue. Obviously the hunt for the source is continuing.
NPR: WHO Points To Wildlife Farms In Southern China As Likely Source Of Pandemic
China shut down those wildlife farms in February 2020, says Peter Daszak, a disease ecologist with EcoHealth Alliance and a member of the WHO delegation that traveled to China this year. During that trip, Daszak says, the WHO team found new evidence that these wildlife farms were supplying vendors at the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in Wuhan with animals....

Those wildlife farms, including ones in the Yunnan region, are part of a unique project that the Chinese government has been promoting for 20 years now.

"They take exotic animals, like civets, porcupines, pangolins, raccoon dogs and bamboo rats, and they breed them in captivity," says Daszak.

The agency is expected to release the team's investigative findings in the next two weeks. In the meantime, Daszak gave NPR a highlight of what the team figured out.
"China promoted the farming of wildlife as a way to alleviate rural populations out of poverty," Daszak says. The farms helped the government meet ambitious goals of closing the rural-urban divide, as NPR reported last year.

"It was very successful," Daszak says. "In 2016, they had 14 million people employed in wildlife farms, and it was a $70 billion industry."
 
Thanks! The final remark in the discussion says that loss of the proline may cause increased infectivity, therefore arguing against including it in an engineered virus.

Here is what was posted upthread: Published in Mar, published in June 2020: On the origin and continuing evolution of SARS-CoV-2

Nature Mar 2020: The proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2

From your link above:
Introduction
Our previous commentary on the Proximal Origins of SARS-CoV-2 (Andersen et al., 2020) concluded that, “SARS-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct or a purposefully manipulated virus." The possibility of a laboratory release or Lab Leak was also considered, but it was determined that a natural origin of SARS-CoV-2 is much more likely.
So it acknowledges the source posted upthread.

No one here anyway is arguing for a purposefully constructed virus. That's the same thing Daszak throws out hoping to distract from the other two options.


I'm still doing taxes, this is a short break. I'll have to look at the claims in Andersen et al's paper from last year. Because there are still some holes in the hypothesis.
 

Yes, but read again...

During that trip, Daszak says, the WHO team found new evidence that these wildlife farms were supplying vendors at the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in Wuhan with animals....

It only says that wildlife farms were supplying vendors.

It says literally nothing about whether they had been shown to be the trail for Covid.

I remember what was said at the time, only that they know who the vendors are and that should be the next stage of the research.

There was literally never any suggestion that they had found the Covid trail and that it would appear in the report. That was never promised.
 
No one here anyway is arguing for a purposefully constructed virus. That's the same thing Daszak throws out hoping to distract from the other two options.

You are always attributing motive and machinations to Daszak.

The point is that yes indeed the claim is often made that this is the result of GoF.

I am sure you have said the same thing.

What is all the talk of the furin cleavage site about? - To some extent the claim is of a manipulated virus.

What is all the talk of the way the virus seems so suitable to human transmission? The claim is of a manipulated virus.

The point is that proponents of the lab leak are using multiple hyotheses so you cannot pretend that this is a strawman.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom