Sherkeu
Illuminator
Don't her actions and her concerns and the fact that she voiced them not sound completely reasonable to you?
Totally reasonable. Being so certain after only looking at limited data is not. This should have had a very detailed in-depth investigation.
I don't understand how they are at odds. Presumably the virus in the second case can be isolated from the lab rats themselves.
I think we have already seen an argument for why the virus did not come from the lab in this case which is that the viruses they had sequenced were not similar enough.
They don't sequence every sample, and not every virus arising in every lab animal could be sampled- as was the case with the rats. They did not even know that 50% of one set of rats had Hanta antibodies before testing.
Further, animals are regularly disposed. They may be long dead before you have a chance to test them. Especially for SARS CoV-2 which can fly under the radar for a period of time.
I think lab escapes have sometimes been noticed in other ways such as sending the wrong vials to people, or when a researcher accidentally stabs themselves with a syringe.
It should be pointed out as well that some viruses just appear in unexpected places. This has happened, for example, with Ebola.
Fair enough. I was focusing more on infections but mishandling of these bio-hazards is also an area of concern.