Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Don't her actions and her concerns and the fact that she voiced them not sound completely reasonable to you?

Totally reasonable. Being so certain after only looking at limited data is not. This should have had a very detailed in-depth investigation.


I don't understand how they are at odds. Presumably the virus in the second case can be isolated from the lab rats themselves.

I think we have already seen an argument for why the virus did not come from the lab in this case which is that the viruses they had sequenced were not similar enough.

They don't sequence every sample, and not every virus arising in every lab animal could be sampled- as was the case with the rats. They did not even know that 50% of one set of rats had Hanta antibodies before testing.

Further, animals are regularly disposed. They may be long dead before you have a chance to test them. Especially for SARS CoV-2 which can fly under the radar for a period of time.

I think lab escapes have sometimes been noticed in other ways such as sending the wrong vials to people, or when a researcher accidentally stabs themselves with a syringe.

It should be pointed out as well that some viruses just appear in unexpected places. This has happened, for example, with Ebola.

Fair enough. I was focusing more on infections but mishandling of these bio-hazards is also an area of concern.
 
Yes it was Sept 2019, about the time of the first case as calculated by the genetic history clock.

This is an interesting date as it is the same month that predict PREDICT program was shutting down after 10 years of USAID funding. Could changes in the lab at that time have led to a mistake? (yeah...I'm in speculation mode!)

Areas of research and education in PREDICT were rolled into other programs- including a new one called Spillover. But no new funding would be given to seeking out dangerous viruses and manipulating them in the lab to see how dangerous they could be to humans.
They had til March 2020 to wrap things up. Some disbanded before that.

2019 News:

SCNL-USAID PREDICT-2 Ebola Host Project Ends in Liberia
(Oct 14, 2019)
PREDICT-2 Liberia research project has been focused on the sampling of animals’ specimen for scientific purposes, mainly with the aim to understand the spillover of viruses from animal to animal and from animal to human.

Over 5,000 bats and 300 rodents in total were sampled during the research process with one of the bats showing positive for the Zaire strain of the Ebola Virus.

According to PREDICT-2 Liberia Project Country Coordinator Jim Desmond, he was pleased with the level of research and data generated during the research process and encouraged all those that worked with the project to make maximum use of the knowledge and skills acquired from the various experts.
-------

Cameroon Charge d’Affaires’ Speech- Closeout Ceremony of the USAID PREDICT Project Sept 24, 2019
The PREDICT project has benefitted from some of the most advanced and prestigious institutions in the American scientific and medical communities. It was implemented by a consortium led by the University of California at Davis that included EcoHealth Alliance, Metabiota Inc., the Smithsonian Institution, and Wildlife Conservation Society, with support from Columbia and Harvard universities. Working with partners in 30 countries, PREDICT has built virus surveillance platforms that identify and monitor zoonotic pathogens or those that can be shared between animals and people.
-------

Pandemic prevention program ending after 10 years -USAID Predict led virus discovery, health training, risk education Jan 2, 2020

The Predict project is winding down after 10 years of work that identified 1,100 unique viruses, provided aid to 60 disease detection laboratories, and trained 6,200 people in 30 countries. The project, led by the UC-Davis One Health Institute, is part of the USAID Emerging Pandemic Threats program.

David Wolking (senior manager for the One Health Institute at UC-Davis and global operations manager for Predict) said Predict’s second five-year term ended Sept. 30, 2019, although USAID provided a six-month extension for studies that use the project’s accumulated evidence to learn about virus spillover, spread, and countermeasures. He knows USAID officials want to continue the type of work conducted by Predict: reducing pandemic threats, increasing laboratory capacity, and learning what dangerous viruses threaten people, especially those circulating in wildlife.

Dr. William Karesh is executive vice president for health and policy at EcoHealth Alliance, one of the founding organizations in Predict. He said Predict’s 10-year run was a success, and it makes sense to move on.

The local partners from Predict are staying in their home countries, where they can teach others and build defenses against emerging disease, Dr. Karesh said.

“At some point, when we do foreign aid and when we do development projects, they’re supposed to become self-sustaining or sustainable,” he said. “That’ll never happen if you continue projects for hundreds of years.”
-------

Scientists Were Hunting for the Next Ebola. Now the U.S. Has Cut Off Their Funding. NYT, Oct 25, 2019

Dennis Carroll, the former director of USAID’s emerging threats division who helped design Predict, oversaw it for a decade and retired when it was shut down. The surveillance project is closing because of “the ascension of risk-averse bureaucrats,” he said. Because USAID’s chief mission is economic aid, he added, some federal officials felt uncomfortable funding cutting-edge science like tracking exotic pathogens.
The end of the program “is definitely a loss,” said Peter Daszak, president of the EcoHealth Alliance, a nonprofit global health organization that received funding from the program. “Predict was an approach to heading off pandemics, instead of sitting there waiting for them to emerge and then mobilizing. That’s expensive."

“The United States spent $5 billion fighting Ebola in West Africa,” he added. “This costs far less.”

Of course September 30 was just the official end date- they would have known for some time prior that the program was about to end. I'm not sure how the WIV would have been affected though. They continued to receive funding from the NIH, which is referenced in their scientific papers.

I am left wondering if the end of PREDICT may have affected the research or staffing decisions of Shi's team at the WIV.
 
Last edited:
I was recently alerted to this very good piece, which I found well worth the time it took to read:

Origin of Covid — Following the Clues

I'll refrain from quoting excerpts, unless requested, because I think it is best read from beginning to end. It is somewhat lengthy as it discusses many details, but it is definitely readable.
 
I was recently alerted to this very good piece, which I found well worth the time it took to read:

Origin of Covid — Following the Clues

I'll refrain from quoting excerpts, unless requested, because I think it is best read from beginning to end. It is somewhat lengthy as it discusses many details, but it is definitely readable.

Thanks, an excellent piece and food for thought.

I don't know enough genetic science to know, but I'm sending Capsid a PM to ask for his opinion. The furin cleavage seems particularly damning.
 
Yes, interesting read. My understanding from TWIV was that the proline in the furin cleavage site would have been removed if the virus was engineered. It’s not intuitive to keep it there. Not a strong argument IMO.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Yes, interesting read. My understanding from TWIV was that the proline in the furin cleavage site would have been removed if the virus was engineered. It’s not intuitive to keep it there. Not a strong argument IMO.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Would removing it have been a further stage in development? Could the virus have still been a work in progress?
 
Would removing it have been a further stage in development? Could the virus have still been a work in progress?


Maybe. But if the focus is on that site to improve binding to the receptor, I would expect some thought into what amino acid residues would be used and including a proline that introduces a kink would normally be avoided.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Yes, interesting read. My understanding from TWIV was that the proline in the furin cleavage site would have been removed if the virus was engineered. It’s not intuitive to keep it there. Not a strong argument IMO.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Interesting that you say that. My own view here is based partly on the fact that TWiV has been absolutely adamant that there is no way that this came from a lab.

I know that Vincent Raccanielo is a big proponent of GoF research (judging by his comments on the podcast and elsewhere), but I have no real understanding of the complexities of this.

May I ask you as someone who I gather knows a lot about viruses what your ideas are about where this comes from?

Specifically,

1.) Do you think this is more likely to be a naturally created or lab-created virus?
2.) If it is simply a natural virus, then do you think it more or less likely that it emerged in the wild, or that somehow it is a natural virus that leaked from the WiV?
3.) How much do you find the actions of Zhengli Shi, Peter Daszak, and their associates (Linfa Wang, Angela Rasmussen, Eddie Holmes, Kristian Andersen, etc...) to be reasonable/suspicious?
 
Interesting that you say that. My own view here is based partly on the fact that TWiV has been absolutely adamant that there is no way that this came from a lab.

I know that Vincent Raccanielo is a big proponent of GoF research (judging by his comments on the podcast and elsewhere), but I have no real understanding of the complexities of this.

May I ask you as someone who I gather knows a lot about viruses what your ideas are about where this comes from?

Specifically,

1.) Do you think this is more likely to be a naturally created or lab-created virus?
2.) If it is simply a natural virus, then do you think it more or less likely that it emerged in the wild, or that somehow it is a natural virus that leaked from the WiV?
3.) How much do you find the actions of Zhengli Shi, Peter Daszak, and their associates (Linfa Wang, Angela Rasmussen, Eddie Holmes, Kristian Andersen, etc...) to be reasonable/suspicious?


As a scientist, I don’t think anything. I need more evidence to answer your questions.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I was recently alerted to this very good piece, which I found well worth the time it took to read:

Origin of Covid — Following the Clues

I'll refrain from quoting excerpts, unless requested, because I think it is best read from beginning to end. It is somewhat lengthy as it discusses many details, but it is definitely readable.
Some worthwhile points:
From early on, public and media perceptions were shaped in favor of the natural emergence scenario by strong statements from two scientific groups. These statements were not at first examined as critically as they should have been. ...

By this criterion, the signatories of the Lancet letter were behaving as poor scientists: they were assuring the public of facts they could not know for sure were true.
They note Daszak's undisclosed (at the time of the letter) conflict of interest.


And there's been a lot of denial this was going on:
Virologists like Dr. Daszak had much at stake in the assigning of blame for the pandemic. For 20 years, mostly beneath the public’s attention, they had been playing a dangerous game. In their laboratories they routinely created viruses more dangerous than those that exist in nature.


More unfounded assertions followed that a lab accident was so unlikely as to be a certain: didn't happen. Many people in this discussion have adopted that underlying premise, Some of whom I think left the discussion believing the lab leak hypothesis belonged in the CT forum.


Again it was proposed it would be possible to see lab markers had the virus been genetically manipulated in the lab.
The Andersen paper’s speculation about designing a viral spike protein through calculation has no bearing on whether or not the virus was manipulated by one of the other two methods.


They note another piece of evidence it couldn't have been manmade ...
And this conclusion, grounded in nothing but two inconclusive speculations, convinced the world’s press that SARS2 could not have escaped from a lab.


Serious thought on the matter interrupted by a bit of humor:
In 2000 Dutch researchers, for instance, earned the gratitude of rodents everywhere by genetically engineering the spike protein of a mouse coronavirus so that it would attack only cats.
:D


Human hubris:
That statement was made in 2015. From the hindsight of 2021, one can say that the value of gain-of-function studies in preventing the SARS2 epidemic was zero. The risk was catastrophic, if indeed the SARS2 virus was generated in a gain-of-function experiment.


The denials this kind of thing went on at the WIV are disgusting:
Dr. Shi returned to her lab at the Wuhan Institute of Virology and resumed the work she had started on genetically engineering coronaviruses to attack human cells.


Further:
The approach could have generated SARS2-like viruses, and indeed may have created the SARS2 virus itself with the right combination of virus backbone and spike protein.

It cannot yet be stated that Dr. Shi did or did not generate SARS2 in her lab because her records have been sealed, but it seems she was certainly on the right track to have done so. “It is clear that the Wuhan Institute of Virology was systematically constructing novel chimeric coronaviruses and was assessing their ability to infect human cells and human-ACE2-expressing mice,” says Richard H. Ebright, a molecular biologist at Rutgers University and leading expert on biosafety.


Re Daszak, we posted a link to this upthread:
On 9 December 2019, before the outbreak of the pandemic became generally known, Dr. Daszak gave an interview in which he talked in glowing terms of how researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology had been reprogramming the spike protein and generating chimeric coronaviruses capable of infecting humanized mice.


And we posted about this as well re the new WIV level 4 biosafety lab:
“The new lab has a serious shortage of appropriately trained technicians and investigators needed to safely operate this high-containment laboratory,” the inspectors wrote in a cable of 19 January 2018.


But all this talk of the WIV's level 4 lab implies they were being super careful with their experiments. Turns out no one likes all those level 4 conditions.
Before 2020, the rules followed by virologists in China and elsewhere required that experiments with the SARS1 and MERS viruses be conducted in BSL3 conditions. But all other bat coronaviruses could be studied in BSL2, the next level down. BSL2 requires taking fairly minimal safety precautions, such as wearing lab coats and gloves, not sucking up liquids in a pipette, and putting up biohazard warning signs. Yet a gain-of-function experiment conducted in BSL2 might produce an agent more infectious than either SARS1 or MERS. And if it did, then lab workers would stand a high chance of infection, especially if unvaccinated.


This is the thing mentioned up thread but which was dismissed by some posters here because it couldn't be verified:
According to a fact sheet issued by the State Department on January 15,2021, “ The U.S. government has reason to believe that several researchers inside the WIV became sick in autumn 2019, before the first identified case of the outbreak, with symptoms consistent with both COVID-19 and common seasonal illnesses.”


I think this strengthened the finding:
Three people working at a BSL3 lab at the institute fell sick within a week of each other with severe symptoms that required hospitalization. This was “the first known cluster that we’re aware of, of victims of what we believe to be COVID-19.” Influenza could not completely be ruled out but seemed unlikely in the circumstances, he said.


Circumstantial evidence is how close to the WIV the pandemic started. The article suggests the first cases occurred in Sept. That's important because that's when the Chinese authorities restricted access to a ton of genetic information being studied in Wuhan.

I mentioned this argument:
The infected person (or animal) carrying this highly transmissible virus must have traveled to Wuhan without infecting anyone else. No one in his or her family got sick. If the person jumped on a train to Wuhan, no fellow passengers fell ill.


There's a discussion about the lack of a natural trail such as was documented in SARS 1.
... Even those who think lab origin unlikely agree that SARS2 genomes are remarkably uniform. Dr. Baric writes that “early strains identified in Wuhan, China, showed limited genetic diversity, which suggests that the virus may have been introduced from a single source.”

A single source would of course be compatible with lab escape, less so with the massive variation and selection which is evolution’s hallmark way of doing business....

The uniform structure of SARS2 genomes gives no hint of any passage through an intermediate animal host, and no such host has been identified in nature.


TBC...
 
Yes, interesting read. My understanding from TWIV was that the proline in the furin cleavage site would have been removed if the virus was engineered. It’s not intuitive to keep it there. Not a strong argument IMO.

Thanks!

As a scientist, I don’t think anything. I need more evidence to answer your questions.

And double thanks for that.

That's why I asked you - you deal in evidence of the kind necessary to make sense of the claims and counter-claims.

Some worthwhile points:They note Daszak's undisclosed (at the time of the letter) conflict of interest...

He's pretty heavy on that point, yet I notice that Nicholas Wade himself is not above making scientific claims without evidence that have been refuted by actual scientists.

I do however, trust Capsid implicitly and his points leave things at the same situation we had before it - more evidence needed, so it's still all speculation.
 
Continued:

So it’s hard to explain how the SARS2 virus picked up its furin cleavage site naturally, whether by mutation or recombination.

That leaves a gain-of-function experiment.


And we have Dr Quay also cited above and IIRC dismissed by some:
“Since 1992 the virology community has known that the one sure way to make a virus deadlier is to give it a furin cleavage site at the S1/S2 junction in the laboratory,” writes Dr. Steven Quay, a biotech entrepreneur interested in the origins of SARS2. “At least eleven gain-of-function experiments, adding a furin site to make a virus more infective, are published in the open literature, including [by] Dr. Zhengli Shi, head of coronavirus research at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.”


We're running out of smoking guns:
So how did SARS2 acquire a pair of arginine codons that are favored by human cells but not by coronaviruses?


But a natural event is still on the table:
“Yes, but your wording makes this sound unlikely — viruses are specialists at unusual events,” is the riposte of David L. Robertson, a virologist at the University of Glasgow who regards lab escape as a conspiracy theory. “Recombination is naturally very, very frequent in these viruses, there are recombination breakpoints in the spike protein and these codons appear unusual exactly because we’ve not sampled enough.”

Egads Batman is that possible?
A long chain with several improbable steps is unlikely to ever be completed.


We've posted upthread about the generalist hypothesis.
One problem with this idea, though, is that if SARS2 jumped from bats to people in a single leap and hasn’t changed much since, it should still be good at infecting bats. And it seems it isn’t.


Why is this?
... Dr. Shi reports she collected at the same time but has not yet published despite their great relevance to the ancestry of SARS2.


This certainly doesn't let the WIV off the hook:
Researchers could have gotten infected during their collecting trips, or while working with the new viruses at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. The virus that escaped from the lab would have been a natural virus, not one cooked up by gain of function.
There were images of these guys collecting their specimens from the caves and it hardly looked like any precautions were taken. The article notes why this is still an unlikely scenario.


Of course we can't rule anything out yet until something (ie the genetic trail) is ruled in. But:
That said, the available evidence leans more strongly in one direction than the other. Readers will form their own opinion. But it seems to me that proponents of lab escape can explain all the available facts about SARS2 considerably more easily than can those who favor natural emergence.


A summary of all the evidence for lab leak includes the following smoking gun that has been rationalized in this thread in any number of ways as well has been by DasZak along with the Chinese authorities who came up with the farmed wild animal hypothesis.
In all of China, the pandemic broke out on the doorstep of the Wuhan institute.


I thought the arguments for a natural spillover would contain just that. Instead the article rebuts every argument for spillover.


Blame is assigned to multiple entities by the article. I'm glad they included this about Daszak:
Anyone who rocks the boat by raising awkward political issues runs the risk that their grant will not be renewed and their research career will be ended. Maybe good behavior is rewarded with the many perks that slosh around the distribution system. And if you thought that Dr. Andersen and Dr. Daszak might have blotted their reputation for scientific objectivity after their partisan attacks on the lab escape scenario, look at the 2nd and 3rd names on this list of recipients of an $82 million grant announced by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases in August 2020.
Just because Eco is a non-profit organization doesn't mean there was no profit motive to assert the narrative we should all rule out a lab leak as a CT.


As I noted upthread, here's one more harm done by Dump:
Because President Trump said the virus had escaped from a Wuhan lab, editors gave the idea little credence.


I'm going to go back over the discounting of Dr Quay was in this thread.
Steven Quay, a physician-researcher, has applied statistical and bioinformatic tools to ingenious explorations of the virus’s origin, showing for instance how the hospitals receiving the early patients are clustered along the Wuhan №2 subway line which connects the Institute of Virology at one end with the international airport at the other, the perfect conveyor belt for distributing the virus from lab to globe.


Told ya so. ;)
 
He's pretty heavy on that point, yet I notice that Nicholas Wade himself is not above making scientific claims without evidence that have been refuted by actual scientists.
Which claim(s) is that?


I do however, trust Capsid implicitly and his points leave things at the same situation we had before it - more evidence needed, so it's still all speculation.
I'm pretty sure we all respect Capsid's POV.

I'm pretty sure I've not said anything close to "there is proof". If you think I have, please quote me so I can clear that up.

That said, I have said and continue to believe that the evidence by far favors a lab leak. This thorough presentation of the evidence, much of which we have posted corroborating sources for up thread, makes an excellent case why 'prove it was a natural event' falls upon the people making that claim.

We have very good evidence COVID came from a lab, almost certainly from the WIV. That evidence has grown stronger not weaker with time.

And the implications are stunning!
 
Last edited:
That's about a different paper by Wade. :confused:
To the Editor:

As scientists dedicated to studying genetic variation, we thank David Dobbs for his review of Nicholas Wade’s “A Troublesome Inheritance: Genes, Race and Human History” (July 13), and for his description of Wade’s misappropriation of research from our field to support arguments about differences among human societies.

As discussed by Dobbs and many others, Wade juxtaposes an incomplete and inaccurate account of our research on human genetic differences with speculation that recent natural selection has led to worldwide differences in I.Q. test results, political institutions and economic development. We reject Wade’s implication that our findings substantiate his guesswork. They do not.

We are in full agreement that there is no support from the field of population genetics for Wade’s conjectures.



The lady doth protest too much, methinks. What does that have to do with my post?
You were arguing the lab leak was "still all speculation". I was merely stating my position that the evidence supported the lab leak to a much greater degree than the natural spillover, but I'm fine with the fact there is no absolute proof yet.
 
Vincent Racaniello says there will be three members of the WHO Origins Committee on TWiV in three weeks.

Maybe one to look out for.
 
Vincent Racaniello says there will be three members of the WHO Origins Committee on TWiV in three weeks.

Maybe one to look out for.

I feel like they are under too much political pressure from the Chinese government to dare to say anything that might allow for the possibility that it escaped from the lab.
 
I feel like they are under too much political pressure from the Chinese government to dare to say anything that might allow for the possibility that it escaped from the lab.

Possibly, but they don’t work for China. If they felt differently they could resign, and virologists who interview them can also make up their own minds about whether they believe what these particular scientists are saying.
 
Possibly, but they don’t work for China. If they felt differently they could resign, and virologists who interview them can also make up their own minds about whether they believe what these particular scientists are saying.

It's not so simple though. Even if they don't work directly for China, they are hardly immune to political pressure from China. Plus half the members of the team are Chinese citizens and they had veto power over anything that might make it into the report.

WHO inquiry into COVID-19 origins 'compromised by politics', say scientists awaiting overdue report

A team of experts from the World Health Organisation (WHO) on a mission to trace the origins of the COVID-19 epidemic, intend to scrap an eagerly-awaited interim report of their mission to China. This comes amid mounting tensions between Beijing and Washington over the investigation, along with an open letter from an international group of scientists who are demanding for a new probe, according to a Wall Street Journal report. The open letter, signed by 26 distinguished academics from around the world, outlines that the WHO-led investigative report was compromised by the inherent limitations of operating under the control of Chinese authorities.

The scientists elaborate on why the investigation report might be perceived as unreliable by the scientific community, saying, "the joint team did not have the mandate, the independence, or the necessary accesses" to perform a full and unrestricted investigation into the many SARS-CoV-2 origin hypotheses proposed. These theories including a natural spillover from an animal source, as well as a laboratory/research-related incident in which the pathogen escaped a controlled setting.

The letter goes on to point out nine fundamental problems that undermine the investigation. The joint investigation "falls short of the mark", the scientists said, adding that it was essential for the international community that a full and unrestricted investigation be organized. The letter describes a detailed layout of what the investigation ought to address – from the multidisciplinary nature of the investigating team to the range of reports they should have unrestricted access to. The WHO being an international agency that relies on the collaboration of its member states, the scientists said, is limited in what it can achieve in an investigation of this kind.

The open letter is in a format that cannot easily be copy-pasted, but should be read.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom