Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not limitless. When a person makes statements like there are virology labs all over China and I know there are not, then that is generalizing from not enough information.
You don't have to go to China to know a lot about the country. A lot of reading helps.

The person making the unsubstantiated claims with not a single citation among a slew of paragraphs, claiming falsely I'm only citing newspaper stories, that is the person who needs to support their claims.

Apparently there are 42 BSL-3 labs and over 1,000 BSL-2 labs in China

In 2004, China’s central government launched a national BSL program that aimed at building a national BSL network comprising high-level BSLs as the nodes. High-level BSLs were then constructed and successfully operated.2 As of December 31st 2013, 53 BSLs, including 42 BSL-3s, had been fully accredited in China1 and more laboratories have completed the accreditation in recent years. In addition, more than 1000 BSL-2 labs are currently being operated in universities, research institutions, hospitals and R&D entrepreneurship centers.[2], [9], [12] In addition, four mobile BSL-3 laboratories were imported from Labover (Montpellier, France) and distributed to institutes in Beijing, Shanghai, and Guangdong for the nation-wide surveillance of pathogens and the emergency response of post-disaster and global public health events.

Link
 
Enough of this AS. I'm not going to play dueling rabbit holes with you.

I quoted from the source of Quay's paper. What are you quoting from? A whole different paper?

If you want to say you found X that contradicts Y then say so. Don't claim I didn't cite the paper and quote directly from it.

I'll look at your NEW source and get back to you.


Spillover is years out of date BTW. I told you that pages back. I got a copy from the library. I was not impressed.
 
Enough of this AS. I'm not going to play dueling rabbit holes with you.

I quoted from the source of Quay's paper. What are you quoting from? A whole different paper?

If you want to say you found X that contradicts Y then say so. Don't claim I didn't cite the paper and quote directly from it.

I'll look at your NEW source and get back to you.


Spillover is years out of date BTW. I told you that pages back. I got a copy from the library. I was not impressed.

LOL! Sure.
 
Pulling facts out of your rear is not an ad hominem. It has a specific meaning: You have not cited any sources and it's clear you are generalizing from limited knowledge about China.

Your whole post. You claim there are virology labs all over China studying coronaviruses for starters.

Looking at the English language literature from 2015 - 2019, specifying the largest twenty Chinese cities (Wuhan sits in the middle in this list) as institution every city has universities carrying out virology research. 13/20 were active in coronavirus research. This is probably an under estimate as there may well be Chinese language research published. What was unique about Wuhan was not that it had virology research, nor that it carried out coronavirus research, but that it had a BSL4 labiratory. People made the jump that if they had a BSL4 laboratory that meant they had nasty viruses and that those nasty viruses must be the cause of the outbreak. People jump to the report that the BSL4 laboratory was under funded / staffed. This is irrelevant, coronavirus research does not require level 4 containment. That is why more than half of large cities have coronavirus research despite not having BSL4 facilities.

Now you claimed that there was a super spreader event and that Wuhan was in some (relevant) way unique. Please evidence these assertions.
 
The latest situation as I see it:

Scientists:
We proved things CCDC hid from science using new data the CCDC released to us, then we analyzed it for some evidence.
We wrote a paper about it.
What a coincidence, a team of China's CCDC scientists just confirmed what we confirmed about the 'new' data they themselves gave us, after years of not giving it to us.

The evidence is overwhelming.

Therefore, raccoon dogs.
 
Thanks so at the time of that report there were one thousand labs suitable for coronavirus research and 42 suitable for research on SARS / MERS.

What does it matter how many labs there were throughout China? All that matters for there to be a lab-leak hypothesis, is that there was a lab working on coronaviruses in the vicinity of Wuhan.
 
What does it matter how many labs there were throughout China? All that matters for there to be a lab-leak hypothesis, is that there was a lab working on coronaviruses in the vicinity of Wuhan.

Because if you argue that the lab leak case is supported by the huge co-incidence (it can't be a coincidence!) that there is a virology lab working on coronaviruses in Wuhan. The co-incidence disappears if over half of big cities have a virology lab working on coronaviruses. So that plank of the argument for a lab leak disappears.

Even if the city had a virology laboratory that did not work on coronaviruses I guess people would claim that the Chinese were hiding the coronavirus work.

There is also the argument that it must be more than a co-incidence that Wuhan has one of China's three BSL4 facillities. This is irrelevant since BSL4 laboratories are not required for work on corona viruses.
 
Also, if I post tables screenshot from papers, you complain because you don't like opening them up as it is a "pain in the ass". BUT you also claim that only you are citing sources for your arguments.

Can't have it both ways. I am citing sources and you complain. I am quoting papers and you claim that the papers "distort the evidence" and yet these are the papers that Quay and Muller base their own claims on.

Sheeeesh!
It's not opening thumbnails that is the problem. It's enlarging them. If you try to enlarge an open thumbnail the main screen opens back up. So I have to enlarge it a dozen times then shrink it back down to proceed reading the thread.

It's a pain in the ass.
 
Apparently there are 42 BSL-3 labs and over 1,000 BSL-2 labs in China

Link
Well that's absurdly misleading.

There are ~1,000 BSL3 labs in the US and we have a fraction of China's population. ~70% of those labs aren't research labs.

https://www.niaid.nih.gov/sites/default/files/bsl3_survey.pdf

See page 20, less than 30% of those are involved in research and that includes drug companies doing product research.

https://www.niaid.nih.gov/sites/default/files/bsl3_survey.pdf

All the labs that handle specifically identified pathogens like brucellosis, anthrax and TB have biosaftey regulations that include BSL2 and above capabilities. They aren't all doing coronavirus research which is what was claimed in this quote:
Every large city will have clinical and research / university virology laboratories at BSL2. Academic virus research is very much about manipulating viruses. If you claim that Wuhan is unique in having coronavirus research then it is your responsibility to provide the evidence. If you looked at research carried out in say the largest twenty Chinese cities and showed that coronavirus research was only done in Wuhan that would be of note, but if say five cities carry out coronavirus research then it was a 1;4 chance the outbreak would occur in a city where there was corona virus research, not such a coincidence.
Bolded sentence #1 is the claim that needs to be supported.

Bolded sentence #2 is false. I never said the only one was in Wuhan. And there are at least 3 in Wuhan, BTW—2 at the WIV and one at the CCDC.

The idea of trying to dilute the coincidence of COVID pandemic beginning near the WIV and the CCDC by claiming there was coronavirus research elsewhere is a fail. How many wet markets are there in Wuhan alone? How many are there across China? How many are there near a research facility doing the kind of work they were doing at the WIV. There are ~1.5 Billion people in China. How many of those people live near a research lab, let alone one doing coronavirus research and of those let alone one doing gain of function research on coronaviruses?

Then there was the uninformed assertion that there was no suoer spreader event at the seafood market when that was established at the very beginning of the pandemic and it is documented multiple times in this thread.

I don't mind having a reasonable debate. I shouldn't have to counter unsupportable assertions that it wasn't such a coincidence the pandemic started near the WIV and the CCDC. And I especially shouldn't have to revisit nonsense like there was no super spreader event at the seafood wet market when that was well established and documented in this thread.
 
Last edited:
LOL! Sure.
Lol it is. It was written in 2012, a decade ago. That is out of date by medical research standards because medicine is advancing so fast.

It's like saying spillovers can happen therefore they did happen in this case.

I agree if one is going by odds, the odds of COVID coming from a spillover are greater than the odds it came from a lab leak.

But there is just as great of odds that the location of the beginning of the pandemic so close to the WIV doing research on that very pandemic pathogen makes the spillover odds a wash.
 
Looking at the English language literature from 2015 - 2019, specifying the largest twenty Chinese cities (Wuhan sits in the middle in this list) as institution every city has universities carrying out virology research. 13/20 were active in coronavirus research. This is probably an under estimate as there may well be Chinese language research published. What was unique about Wuhan was not that it had virology research, nor that it carried out coronavirus research, but that it had a BSL4 labiratory. People made the jump that if they had a BSL4 laboratory that meant they had nasty viruses and that those nasty viruses must be the cause of the outbreak. People jump to the report that the BSL4 laboratory was under funded / staffed. This is irrelevant, coronavirus research does not require level 4 containment. That is why more than half of large cities have coronavirus research despite not having BSL4 facilities.

Now you claimed that there was a super spreader event and that Wuhan was in some (relevant) way unique. Please evidence these assertions.
Where is your citation? :confused:

Even if there were 13 labs doing coronavirus research, that is in a country with ~1.5 billion people. How many of them were doing gain of function research? How many had collected specimens from bats in Yunnan for over a decade?
As for the super spreader event at the wet market you need to read more of the thread before asking people to go over that material again. There is no dispute that a super spreader event happened at the wet market.
 
Lol it is. It was written in 2012, a decade ago. That is out of date by medical research standards because medicine is advancing so fast.

It's like saying spillovers can happen therefore they did happen in this case.

I agree if one is going by odds, the odds of COVID coming from a spillover are greater than the odds it came from a lab leak.

But there is just as great of odds that the location of the beginning of the pandemic so close to the WIV doing research on that very pandemic pathogen makes the spillover odds a wash.

Calling the book outdated is silly unless new evidence contradicts the information I am presenting from it. The pages I showed were about the SARS outbreak. It’s not “outdated”. It’s information about how the virus was tracked down. Similarly I have used it as a source referring to Worobey’s detection of HIV/AIDS origins. If you call it “outdated” merely because of the date then your own citations on origins of SARS are also “outdated” as they are frequently papers from 2003 and 2004. But they should only be considered “outdated” if they are inaccurate because more recent research refutes them.
 
...

Of course, scientists from the Wuhan Lab probably ate racoon dogs from the wet market and introduced it to them. (You'll hear that shortly)
:rolleyes:

There's no need for this. The evidence it came from the market in the first place is weaker than weak tea.
 
The latest situation as I see it:

Scientists:
We proved things CCDC hid from science using new data the CCDC released to us, then we analyzed it for some evidence.
We wrote a paper about it.
What a coincidence, a team of China's CCDC scientists just confirmed what we confirmed about the 'new' data they themselves gave us, after years of not giving it to us.

The evidence is overwhelming.

Therefore, raccoon dogs.
Not to mention pics of raccoon dogs at that market in 2014 were posted.
 
Last edited:
The main bit of evidence however is that all the COVID specimens collected from the wet market were closely related human COVID viruses. not one of them suggested it was well adapted to raccoon dogs.

Again, the distribution of the COVID positive cultures in the market is here under "What does the genetic evidence in the report say?"
Science: A new pandemic origin report is stirring controversy. Here are key takeaways

From the beginning of the article:
But critics, many of whom suspect SARS-CoV-2 may have escaped from the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV), say the new sequences offer no great insight beyond the confirmation that the seafood market also sold mammals. It is “just preposterous” to suggest this is evidence that animals were actually infected with SARS-CoV-2 and transmitted it to humans, computational biologist Erik van Nimwegen says. In a 2021 letter in Science, he and 17 other scientists—including two who issued the new report—called for a “balanced consideration” of the lab-leak hypothesis.

Commenting on the cultures:
The report describes finding raccoon dog mtDNA in six samples from two different stalls in the Wuhan market. A sample from a cart that tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 also had “abundant” raccoon dog genetic material. Far less human genetic material was found in the same sample.


Repeating what I posted upthread:
Surveillance of SARS-CoV-2 in the environment and animal samples of the Huanan Seafood Market
It has reported that a certain number of the early case clusters had a contact history with Huanan Seafood Market. Therefore, surveillance of SARS-CoV-2 within the market is of vital importance. Herein, we presented the SARS-CoV-2 detection results of 1380 samples collected from the environment and the animals within the market in early 2020. By SARS-CoV-2-specific RT-qPCR, 73 environmental samples tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 and three live viruses were successfully isolated. The viruses from the market shared nucleotide identity of 99.980% to 99.993% with the human isolate HCoV/Wuhan/IVDC-HB-01. In contrast, no virus was detected in the animal swabs covering 18 species of animals in the market. The SARS-COV-2 nucleic acids in the positive environmental samples showed significant correlation of abundance of Homo sapiens with SARS-CoV-2.

There has never been genetic evidence of any COVID cultures that weren't connected to humans in the market.

I repeat (apparently it is necessary to do so), unless the suspect raccoon dog carried a human adapted virus there is no evidence of a spillover here.
 
Well that's absurdly misleading.

There are ~1,000 BSL3 labs in the US and we have a fraction of China's population. ~70% of those labs aren't research labs.

https://www.niaid.nih.gov/sites/default/files/bsl3_survey.pdf

See page 20, less than 30% of those are involved in research and that includes drug companies doing product research.

https://www.niaid.nih.gov/sites/default/files/bsl3_survey.pdf

All the labs that handle specifically identified pathogens like brucellosis, anthrax and TB have biosaftey regulations that include BSL2 and above capabilities. They aren't all doing coronavirus research which is what was claimed in this quote:Bolded sentence #1 is the claim that needs to be supported.

Bolded sentence #2 is false. I never said the only one was in Wuhan. And there are at least 3 in Wuhan, BTW—2 at the WIV and one at the CCDC.

The idea of trying to dilute the coincidence of COVID pandemic beginning near the WIV and the CCDC by claiming there was coronavirus research elsewhere is a fail. How many wet markets are there in Wuhan alone? How many are there across China? How many are there near a research facility doing the kind of work they were doing at the WIV. There are ~1.5 Billion people in China. How many of those people live near a research lab, let alone one doing coronavirus research and of those let alone one doing gain of function research on coronaviruses?

Then there was the uninformed assertion that there was no suoer spreader event at the seafood market when that was established at the very beginning of the pandemic and it is documented multiple times in this thread.

I don't mind having a reasonable debate. I shouldn't have to counter unsupportable assertions that it wasn't such a coincidence the pandemic started near the WIV and the CCDC. And I especially shouldn't have to revisit nonsense like there was no super spreader event at the seafood wet market when that was well established and documented in this thread.

WIV was not near the wet market concerned it is miles away. It is not near where the early cases clustered, which was around the wet market.

Where do you think the BSL2 labs are? In small villages? They'll be in cities. I have checked and all twenty of China's largest cities have universities carrying out virology research requiring BSL 2 at least. Several of those cities have more than one institution carrying out research so will have more than one BSL2 facility. Some were doing research requiring BSL3. That is not saying those are the only thirteen places doing research, but thirteen out of twenty cities checked.

I think you need to decide which laboratory you are going to say the leak is from. CDC is near the wet market but hasn't done gain of function research. WIV isn't near but did.
 
There are a huge number of different virus species (trillions) so identifying the ancestor for SARS-CoV-2 may take some time this study surveyed just under two thousand animals and discovered 65 new mammalian viruses 21 with potential for causing human illness. They were also able to obtain evidence for movement of viruses between species.

https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/...m/retrieve/pii/S0092867422001945?showall=true

A further pandemic remains a real risk and not from a laboratory leak.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom