Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
The main bit of evidence however is that all the COVID specimens collected from the wet market were closely related human COVID viruses. not one of them suggested it was well adapted to raccoon dogs.

Again, the distribution of the COVID positive cultures in the market is here under "What does the genetic evidence in the report say?"
Science: A new pandemic origin report is stirring controversy. Here are key takeaways

From the beginning of the article:


Commenting on the cultures:



Repeating what I posted upthread:
Surveillance of SARS-CoV-2 in the environment and animal samples of the Huanan Seafood Market


There has never been genetic evidence of any COVID cultures that weren't connected to humans in the market.

I repeat (apparently it is necessary to do so), unless the suspect raccoon dog carried a human adapted virus there is no evidence of a spillover here.

FWIW, I also don't think that the new paper is strong evidence of spillover. I think I have already said that, but want to repeat it here anyway.

That said, what it does show, as I also said before, is that the testing of animals that was reported before, and sometimes used as evidence that there was no spillover, was inadequate.

The WHO-SAGO are clearly very interested in these findings. Why do you think that is?
 
Maybe this was already brought up, but it seems that the intelligence on whether there was a lab leak will be released. So we can look forward to a lot of new theories! ;)

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden signed a bipartisan bill Monday that directs the federal government to declassify as much intelligence as possible about the origins of COVID-19 more than three years after the start of the pandemic.

The legislation, which passed both the House and Senate without dissent, directs the Office of the Director of National Intelligence to declassify intelligence related to China’s Wuhan Institute of Virology. It cites “potential links” between the research that was done there and the outbreak of COVID-19, which the World Health Organization declared a pandemic on March 11, 2020. The law allows for redactions to protect sensitive sources and methods.

U.S. intelligence agencies are divided over whether a lab leak or a spillover from animals is the likely source of the deadly virus. Experts say the true origin of the coronavirus pandemic, which has killed more than 1.1 million in the U.S. and millions more around the globe, may not be known for many years — if ever.

Biden, in a statement, said he was pleased to sign the legislation.

Link
 
Vincent and Amy give a short answer to a question about the paper and Florence Débarre's sample analysis here:

https://youtu.be/_o64pTxU_rE?t=4436

Hey, the fun thing is that Vincent said he is going to do an episode on the paper on "Friday", which I suppose is tomorrow in America (as this was recorded about 24 hours ago.

Vincent of course thinks that assumptions it came from a lab is BS.
 
FWIW, I also don't think that the new paper is strong evidence of spillover. I think I have already said that, but want to repeat it here anyway.

That said, what it does show, as I also said before, is that the testing of animals that was reported before, and sometimes used as evidence that there was no spillover, was inadequate.

The WHO-SAGO are clearly very interested in these findings. Why do you think that is?
OK, I get it. You are still dismissing the fact no trail of infection in an intermediate species has been found because there are plenty more places they need to look.

But then why post stuff about how long it took to find the reservoir for SARS1 and not consider how fast intermediate animals were found at several wet markets in Guangdong?

Seriously, there was no difficulty tracing SARS1 to multiple spillover events in Guangdong. And it was clear it took a month or so for SARS1 to adapt to efficient person to person spread.

Camels were suspected early on with MERS. There was little mystery there as to how the spillover occurred.

Now we have SARS2, the genetics reveal it was easily spread person to person right when the pandemic began. It might have gotten even more efficient with later variants. But not being absolutely perfectly fine-tuned in Dec 2019 does not suggest it hadn't been adapted to humans in a lab.


Then there is the nonsense the WIV was further away than the market. :rolleyes: That's absurd. There were 2 WIV labs and the CCDC lab was only a couple miles from the wet market.

I showed how COVID was introduced into WA State. There was no cluster of cases around patient zero, and that included some investigation of passengers on the flight from Wuhan he flew in on. Where the first recognized cluster occurred was more than 20 miles away in Kirkland and wasn't recognized until some time later.

There are 20.87 miles from Everett to Kirkland in south direction and 24 miles (38.62 kilometers) by car, following the I-405 S route.
 
Last edited:
Because if you argue that the lab leak case is supported by the huge co-incidence (it can't be a coincidence!) that there is a virology lab working on coronaviruses in Wuhan. The co-incidence disappears if over half of big cities have a virology lab working on coronaviruses. So that plank of the argument for a lab leak disappears.


That's not a valid argument. If it is accepted that the outbreak originated in Wuhan, then all that matters for there to be a lab-leak hypothesis is that there is a lab in Wuhan. Labs anywhere else in the country are irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
That's not a valid argument. If it is accepted that the outbreak originated in Wuhan, then all that matters for there to be a lab-leak hypothesis is that there is a lab in Wuhan. Labs anywhere else in the country are irrelevant.

Yes, it is permissive but no more than that. I agree that if there was no laboratory then there could not be a laboratory leak. However, I disagree that because there is a laboratory, that is evidence that there was a laboratory leak. The evidential value of the presence of the laboratory is zero. The case for the laboratory leak then has to be made.

The problem with the laboratory leak theory is there is no evidence linking the laboratory with SARS-CoV-2. Just a lot of mud slinging and innuendo.
 
OK, get it. You are still dismissing the fact no trail of infection in an intermediate species has been found because there are plenty more places they need to look.

But then why post stuff about how long it took to find the reservoir for SARS1 and not consider how fast intermediate animals were found at several wet markets in Guangdong?

Seriously, there was no difficulty tracing SARS1 to multiple spillover events in Guangdong. And it was clear it took a month or so for SARS1 to adapt to efficient person to person spread.

Camels were suspected early on with MERS. There was little mystery there as to how the spillover occurred.

Now we have SARS2, the genetics reveal it was easily spread person to person right when the pandemic began. It might have gotten even more efficient with later variants. But not being absolutely perfectly fine-tuned in Dec 2019 does not suggest it hadn't been adapted to humans in a lab.


Then there is the nonsense the WIV was further away than the market. :rolleyes: That's absurd. There were 2 WIV labs and the CCDC lab was only a couple miles from the wet market.

I showed how COVID was introduced into WA State. There was no cluster of cases around patient zero, and that included some investigation of passengers on the flight from Wuhan he flew in on. Where the first recognized cluster occurred was more than 20 miles away in Kirkland and wasn't recognized until some time later.

There are 20.87 miles from Everett to Kirkland in south direction and 24 miles (38.62 kilometers) by car, following the I-405 S route.

I don't think you understand, you can't adapt a virus to human to human spread in a laboratory. We do not yet understand enough about viral transmission. Laboratory passage makes viruses less fit.

If the virus wasn't capable of person to person transmission we would not have had a pandemic. No other virus required to be adapted in a laboratory to cause a pandemic. Why should this virus uniquely require intelligent design instead on natural selection like every other pandemic?
 
Last edited:
Yes, it is permissive but no more than that. I agree that if there was no laboratory then there could not be a laboratory leak. However, I disagree that because there is a laboratory, that is evidence that there was a laboratory leak. The evidential value of the presence of the laboratory is zero. The case for the laboratory leak then has to be made.

The problem with the laboratory leak theory is there is no evidence linking the laboratory with SARS-CoV-2. Just a lot of mud slinging and innuendo.

That particular lab was studying gain of function on coronaviruses. That doesn't count as suspicious in your eyes?

At all?
 
... that because there is a laboratory, that is evidence that there was a laboratory leak.
That's a straw man. There is way more to it than that.

...The evidential value of the presence of the laboratory is zero. The case for the laboratory leak then has to be made.
It's not zero, but the case has been made.

...The problem with the laboratory leak theory is there is no evidence linking the laboratory with SARS-CoV-2. Just a lot of mud slinging and innuendo.
IOW you still have not reviewed the thread for all the stuff you aren't acknowledging.
 
I don't think you understand, you can't adapt a virus to human to human spread in a laboratory.
OMG!!!! You can't be that naive.


We do not yet understand enough about viral transmission. Laboratory passage makes viruses less fit.
:dig: You really should stop digging that hole you are in.


If the virus wasn't capable of person to person transmission we would not have had a pandemic. No other virus required to be adapted in a laboratory to cause a pandemic. Why should this virus uniquely require intelligent design instead on natural selection like every other pandemic?
And more straw arguments.
 
Some basics for anyone who can't or doesn't want to Google how it is done:

Might SARS‐CoV‐2 Have Arisen via Serial Passage through an Animal Host or Cell Culture? - A potential explanation for much of the novel coronavirus’ distinctive genome
Unless the intermediate host necessary for completing a natural zoonotic jump is identified, the dual‐use gain‐of‐function research practice of viral serial passage should be considered a viable route by which the novel coronavirus arose. The practice of serial passage mimics a natural zoonotic jump, and offers explanations for SARS‐CoV‐2's distinctive spike‐protein region and its unexpectedly high affinity for angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE2), as well as the notable polybasic furin cleavage site within it.

This is all discussed in the thread, especially earlier on.
The long‐standing practice of serial passage is a form of gain‐of‐function research that forces zoonosis between species, and requires the same molecular adaptations necessary for a natural zoonotic jump to occur within a laboratory, leaving the same genetic signatures behind as a natural jump but occurring in a much shorter period of time.
IOW one need not see obvious genetic engineering to have a lab adapted pathogen.

Re the furin cleavage site which has been discussed at length in the thread:
Although they only emerge under artificial conditions in influenza viruses, these furin cleavage sites are found within several branches of the coronavirus family tree. However SARS‐CoV‐2 is the only lineage B coronavirus found with one, and the only other coronaviruses known to have them are only at most 60% identical to this novel coronavirus.[ 5 ] ...

It is possible that this novel coronavirus gained its furin cleavage site through recombination in an intermediate host species, however there are also two laboratory processes that may have imbued SARS‐CoV‐2 with its furin cleavage site which will be discussed below. ...

serial passage through a live animal host simply forces the same molecular processes that occur in nature to happen during a zoonotic jump, and in vitro passage through cell culture mimics many elements of this process—and neither necessarily leaves any distinguishing genetic traces.


People like to claim a lab leak never resulted in a pandemic but that isn't true. In 1977 a lab modified flu virus leaked and caused a pandemic.
... Although no one has ever taken responsibility for the introduction of this virus, it would become the first known example of a virus created by serial passage leaving a lab, which was later determined due to its inexplicable genetic distance from any known sister strain.[ 8 ]
 
People like to claim a lab leak never resulted in a pandemic but that isn't true. In 1977 a lab modified flu virus leaked and caused a pandemic.

I read about that "Russian Flu" of '77. Had not known there were genetic modifications.
From old papers I saw, the virus only affected those under 25, and the last time an H1N1 was effectively circulating was 25 years prior. (so thanks Russia for bringing it back!)

Upon study of that virus, it appeared to be a near exact copy to a 1950 sample frozen from the flu at that time. Seems the Russians had a frozen sample as well and... ??? No one really knows. The Soviets denied everything.
Denial works- and eventually people don't care as much and there is little price to pay.
 
Yes, it is permissive but no more than that. I agree that if there was no laboratory then there could not be a laboratory leak. However, I disagree that because there is a laboratory, that is evidence that there was a laboratory leak. The evidential value of the presence of the laboratory is zero.


If it were true that "the evidential value of the presence of the laboratory [were] zero," then the plausibility that a lab leak caused the pandemic would be the same whether there was a lab in Wuhan or not. Since that is obviously not the case, then the presence of the lab must have "evidential value."
 
Not listened yet, but thought I would stick this BBC interview with Florence Debarre.

May be of interest to some...

Link

Richard Ebright has already made up his mind...

Trigger Warnings: "thumbnails"
 

Attachments

  • Richard Ebright reaction.jpg
    Richard Ebright reaction.jpg
    27 KB · Views: 9
I read about that "Russian Flu" of '77. Had not known there were genetic modifications.
From old papers I saw, the virus only affected those under 25, and the last time an H1N1 was effectively circulating was 25 years prior. (so thanks Russia for bringing it back!)

Upon study of that virus, it appeared to be a near exact copy to a 1950 sample frozen from the flu at that time. Seems the Russians had a frozen sample as well and... ??? No one really knows. The Soviets denied everything.
Denial works- and eventually people don't care as much and there is little price to pay.

It's not clear whether the leak was of a virus sample that had merely been frozen for 25 years or whether there was work being done with the virus to modify it for use in a vaccine program.

There are some interesting parallels to today.

Lab leak is the biggest suspect in 1977 flu pandemic. But it took 3 decades to gain currency
The reason why the Russian flu is believed to be have started with a lab leak is that the H1N1 virus that caused the pandemic was found to be closely related to human influenza viruses that circulated in 1949-1950. Since viruses are known to evolve continuously, this discovery, made in 1978, convinced many scientists that a preserved sample of the virus from mid-20th century found its way out of a lab. ...

Here's where it gets interesting:
US researchers suggest that the Western scientists didn’t pursue the lab leak theory at the time for several reasons. These include tensions between the US and the USSR amid the Cold War.

The WHO’s Global Influenza Surveillance and Response System (GISRS) — a network of laboratories to monitor the spread of influenza — was established in 1952 to conduct global influenza surveillance.

Russia joined this network only in 1971.

In a 2014 report titled “Laboratory Escapes and ‘Self-fulfilling prophecy’ Epidemics”, Martin Furmanski, affiliated with the Scientists’ Working Group on Chemical and Biologic Weapons Center for Arms Control and Nonproliferation, wrote that Western scientists at the time did not want to offend their Russian and Chinese counterparts, as their cooperation was important for such a global networks to track influenza to be successful.
Sound familiar?

A 2015 paper by Michelle Rozo and Gigi Kwik Gronvall at UPMC Center for Health Security noted how the 1977 outbreak had become a “cautionary tale” in the arguments against gain-of-function research — which involves enhancing the properties of a virus in a way that makes it more infectious or dangerous, so as to preempt potential pandemics and prepare vaccines or treatments.

Such research had come under the scanner in the US after a 2012 study modified an avian flu virus to show how it may have transmitted into humans.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1977_Russian_flu
It has been suggested by many researchers that the virus leaked to the public from a laboratory accident.[4][11][24][25] The virus may have escaped from a lab attempting to prepare an attenuated H1N1 vaccine in response to the US swine flu pandemic alert of 1976.[26] The World Health Organization, however, ruled out a laboratory origin in 1978 after discussions with researchers in the Soviet Union and China: their report stated that "the laboratories concerned either had never kept H1N1 virus or had not worked with it for a long time".[3][5]
Others have suggested that it resulted from a vaccine trial or challenge.[5][23] The multiple source locations of outbreak made a single-laboratory origin less likely than a vaccine accident.[5] Virologist Peter Palese claims the outbreak was the "result of vaccine trials in the Far East involving the challenge of several thousand military recruits with live H1N1," according to personal communication with virologist Chi-Ming Chu.[14]
The idea that the virus may have been a deliberately-deployed bioweapon appears unlikely and inconsistent with Soviet biological weapon research at the time.[5]

It hasn't been shown clearly that the virus was being altered but that is one hypothesis.
 
It's not clear whether the leak was of a virus sample that had merely been frozen for 25 years or whether there was work being done with the virus to modify it for use in a vaccine program.

There are some interesting parallels to today.

Here's where it gets interesting:
Sound familiar?

Eerily. It sounds like our own words years earlier in this very thread.
They were much poo poo'd at the time- and poo is an appropriate description of the sentiments directed at us. CONSPIRACY! But I am patient.
 
That particular lab was studying gain of function on coronaviruses. That doesn't count as suspicious in your eyes?

At all?

No.

1) There is no evidence that SARS-CoV-2 was the product of gain of function research or artificial adaption.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-020-0820-9
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8570237/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9546612/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7836551/

2) There is no evidence that WIV had access to an ancestral virus that could have been subject to gain of function research or otherwise manipulated to create SARS-CoV-2

So it is irrelevant to the origin of SARS-CoV-2.
 
It's not clear whether the leak was of a virus sample that had merely been frozen for 25 years or whether there was work being done with the virus to modify it for use in a vaccine program.

There are some interesting parallels to today.

Lab leak is the biggest suspect in 1977 flu pandemic. But it took 3 decades to gain currency


Here's where it gets interesting:
Sound familiar?




https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1977_Russian_flu


It hasn't been shown clearly that the virus was being altered but that is one hypothesis.

But AH1N1 was a known pandemic virus that arose naturally in the US probably because of a jump from birds to pigs as an intermediate species. This was widely worked on in laboratories both for diagnostic, research and vaccine production.

The discussion isn't whether laboratory leaks occur. There is no doubt they do. The question is whether a novel coronavirus was in someway created at WIV and then leaked.
 
Yeah, I think the point about the particular flu strain that may have leaked from a Russian lab is that we know what it was. It is less of a surprise to have a virus that we know was likely to be in a lab rather than a completely new one that we have no evidence was in the lab.
 
But AH1N1 was a known pandemic virus that arose naturally in the US probably because of a jump from birds to pigs as an intermediate species. This was widely worked on in laboratories both for diagnostic, research and vaccine production.

The discussion isn't whether laboratory leaks occur. There is no doubt they do. The question is whether a novel coronavirus was in someway created at WIV and then leaked.

I don't think the question is if the coronavirus was created or modifed in a lab. The question is if the lab helped in any way in the spread, even if it meant just collecting samples, which then leaked.
The question IMHO is if the labs and their activities are safe enough, and if they shouldn't be a lot safer. That does include modification and creation of new viruses, of course. But also just collection and observation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom