Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, I think the point about the particular flu strain that may have leaked from a Russian lab is that we know what it was. It is less of a surprise to have a virus that we know was likely to be in a lab rather than a completely new one that we have no evidence was in the lab.

I feel a deja vu from May 2021.

We discussed all this back then. Even this very lab (though at a satellite location in Yunnan), and this very researcher had spillover of a new virus IN the lab without knowing about the new virus.
2 rodent species kept in 'too close' proximity made a recombinant virus and infected students with Hanta.

We know this happened. They wrote a paper about it.

Remember?

An outbreak of hemorrhagic fever with renal syndrome occurred among students in a college (College A) in Kunming, Yunnan province, China in 2003. Subsequent investigations revealed the presence of hantavirus antibodies and antigens in laboratory rats at College A and two other institutions. Hantavirus antibodies were detected in 15 additional individuals other than the index case in these three locations. Epidemiologic data indicated that the human infections were a result of zoonotic transmission of the virus from laboratory rats.

A virus was isolated from rats in College A and the full-length genome sequence revealed that this was a new Hantaan virus isolate, designated strain KY. Sequence analysis of the three genome segments indicated that this new isolate is a reassortant derived from human and rat Hantaan viruses.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13470685#post13470685
 
Last edited:
Some basics for anyone who can't or doesn't want to Google how it is done:

Might SARS‐CoV‐2 Have Arisen via Serial Passage through an Animal Host or Cell Culture? - A potential explanation for much of the novel coronavirus’ distinctive genome

This is all discussed in the thread, especially earlier on.
IOW one need not see obvious genetic engineering to have a lab adapted pathogen.

Re the furin cleavage site which has been discussed at length in the thread:



People like to claim a lab leak never resulted in a pandemic but that isn't true. In 1977 a lab modified flu virus leaked and caused a pandemic.

From your source

if the novel coronavirus had arisen from serial passage of a “precursor” progenitor virus in a lab, or from bats infecting a commercial mink farm somewhere in China, which would also provide the conditions for serial passage

Effectively this is what the natural cross over theory would be. From bat to an intermediate animal an outbreak within that animal group (giving rise to lineage A and B). Whilst one would not normally term transmission in an outbreak passage this is what they mean here. So whilst there are some errors in the paper it really comes out as equivical.
 
I feel a deja vu from May 2021.

We discussed all this back then. Even this very lab (though at a satellite location in Yunnan), and this very researcher had spillover of a new virus IN the lab without knowing about the new virus.
2 rodent species kept in 'too close' proximity made a recombinant virus and infected students with Hanta.

We know this happened. They wrote a paper about it.

Remember?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13470685#post13470685

To be correct the virus was a reassortment of two rat viruses, not from different species.

Further sequence analysis of the medium (M) genome segment revealed that it originated from a recombination event between two rat Hantaan virus lineages.

The virus infected the rats at the animal breeders, most likely due to transmission from a wild rodent. The infected rats were then used in experiments and the students became infected. This is in effect the opposite of a laboratory leak (or a leak in the opposite direction - into the laboratory from outside). Effectively this is the same as the postulated wet market cross over, infected animals were imported / people at work were exposed and became infected. There was no person to person transmission.

This is actually qa well recognised phenomenon.
https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/15/2/08-0291_article
 
From your source

Effectively this is what the natural cross over theory would be. From bat to an intermediate animal an outbreak within that animal group (giving rise to lineage A and B). Whilst one would not normally term transmission in an outbreak passage this is what they mean here. So whilst there are some errors in the paper it really comes out as equivical.
Did you forget what you posted? :confused:

Planigale said:
I don't think you understand, you can't adapt a virus to human to human spread in a laboratory.

Your reply to my post is a non-sequitur.

Errors in what paper? The one describing how serial passage in a lab could have resulted in COVID becoming adapted to human to human spread? It's an essay describing a potential origin for COVID, not a study.

From my link:
Unless the intermediate host necessary for completing a natural zoonotic jump is identified,
And it hasn't been despite how many people are jumping on the raccoon dog bandwagon.

the dual‐use gain‐of‐function research practice of viral serial passage should be considered a viable route by which the novel coronavirus arose.
Do you need more documentation to understand how serial passage works? :boggled:

Care to enlighten us with what error you noticed in the paper? :rolleyes:
 
Did you forget what you posted? :confused:



Your reply to my post is a non-sequitur.

Errors in what paper? The one describing how serial passage in a lab could have resulted in COVID becoming adapted to human to human spread? It's an essay describing a potential origin for COVID, not a study.

From my link:And it hasn't been despite how many people are jumping on the raccoon dog bandwagon.

Do you need more documentation to understand how serial passage works? :boggled:

Care to enlighten us with what error you noticed in the paper? :rolleyes:

The errors are obvious.
 
If it were true that "the evidential value of the presence of the laboratory [were] zero," then the plausibility that a lab leak caused the pandemic would be the same whether there was a lab in Wuhan or not. Since that is obviously not the case, then the presence of the lab must have "evidential value."

Becoming a pandemic requires a city and there are labs in every city where such a pandemic could plausibly start. Since the chances of there being a lab nearby approaches 100% regardless of whether it was a lab leak or zoonotic crossover, so the presence of a lab gives us zero information about how the pandemic started.
 
I don't think the question is if the coronavirus was created or modifed in a lab. The question is if the lab helped in any way in the spread, even if it meant just collecting samples, which then leaked.
The question IMHO is if the labs and their activities are safe enough, and if they shouldn't be a lot safer. That does include modification and creation of new viruses, of course. But also just collection and observation.

Coronavirus samples are usually genetic materiel from bat fecal samples, not from live viable viruses. You can't contract the disease from these types of samples.
 
Maybe .. but when collecting them in bat caves ?

I forget the exact number of viable viruses isolated over many years of hunting bat viruses but it was of the order of eight. Most new viruses are detected on the basis of non-viable RNA (or DNA). the articles that suggest WIV had hundreds of viruses fail to understand the difference. very few viable viruses that could be cultured i the lab were identified. The huge majority were identified on PCR testing of guano etc.

Many more viruses have been collected in Wuhan over the years, and one research expedition captured as many as 400 wild viruses,[ 31 ] which were added to a private repository that has since grown to over 1500 strains of virus,[ 32 ] meaning that the Wuhan Center for Disease Control and Prevention has a massive catalogue of largely undisclosed viruses to draw from for experiments
.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7435492/
one error.
 
Becoming a pandemic requires a city and there are labs in every city where such a pandemic could plausibly start. Since the chances of there being a lab nearby approaches 100% regardless of whether it was a lab leak or zoonotic crossover, so the presence of a lab gives us zero information about how the pandemic started.

That's blatantly false, since if there were no lab, then we could rule out that a lab leak caused the pandemic. The believe that the presence of other labs in the vicinity of where the pandemic did not has any bearing on what caused the pandemic is such a bizarre fallacy that I cannot fathom why people think it matters.

I suspect that there are wet markets in every major Chinese city, too. Applying your logic to that fact leads to the equally bizarre conclusion that the presence of a wet market in Wuhan has no effect on the hypothesis that a wet market was the origin of the pandemic.
 
Last edited:
That's blatantly false, since if there were no lab, then we could rule out that a lab leak caused the pandemic. The believe that the presence of other labs in the vicinity of where the pandemic did not has any bearing on what caused the pandemic is such a bizarre fallacy that I cannot fathom why people think it matters.

There was essentialy zero chance of there not being a lab nearby.

I suspect that there are wet markets in every major Chinese city, too. Applying your logic to that fact leads to the equally bizarre conclusion that the presence of a wet market in Wuhan has no effect on the hypothesis that a wet market was the origin of the pandemic.

The mere presence of a live animal market isn't being used as evidence. Rather, the evidence points to the market.
 
The mere presence of a live animal market isn't being used as evidence.

Of course it is. Indeed, it is the single most important piece of evidence supporting the animal market theory. No market; no market theory.

Rather, the evidence points to the market.

Any evidence pointing to the market depends on the existence of a market. Without a market, there is no market theory.

Incidentally, even if it is true that there is a virology lab in every Chinese city, as you claim, I doubt that all those labs are working on coronaviruses. But it's irrelevant anyway, since labs not in the vicinity of where the outbreak began are irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
Maybe .. but when collecting them in bat caves ?

Isolating live coronaviruses from bat samples is notoriously tricky—mostly because only a small fraction of samples contain even a whiff of the viruses (whereas specimens from people with SARS or covid-19 are often teeming with coronaviruses). The process of culturing viruses involves providing them with cells they can infect. Several labs around the world have tried to get live bat coronaviruses and failed. Until January 2021, the Wuhan lab was the only one that had managed the feat, according to Stephen Goldstein, a coronavirus expert at the University of Utah in Salt Lake City. And the person with the green thumb was Yang Xinglou, a senior research scientist on Shi’s team.
....
In all his years of work, Yang has managed to isolate only three bat coronaviruses—all of them close relatives of SARS-CoV-1. More recently, the team managed to synthesize three bat coronaviruses from their genomic sequences. All six are close relatives of SARS-CoV-1. None of them, said virologists MIT Technology Review spoke to, could have been the source of SARS-CoV-2: they’re just too different.
https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-covid-lab-leak-wuhan/

We have isolated three closely-related bat coronaviruses over the last 15 years (here an isolated virus is a live virus which can grow in cultured cells in the laboratory) and all of them are SARS-related coronaviruses. These bat viruses share 79.8% sequence identity and are distantly related to SARS-CoV-2. On February 3, we published a paper in Nature and reported that SARS-CoV-2 is 96.2% identical at the whole-genome level to a bat coronavirus named RaTG13 (I would like to emphasize that we have only the genome sequence and didn’t isolate this virus).
https://www.science.org/pb-assets/PDF/News PDFs/Shi Zhengli Q&A-1630433861.pdf
 
Of course it is. Indeed, it is the single most important piece of evidence supporting the animal market theory. No market; no market theory.



Any evidence pointing to the market depends on the existence of a market. Without a market, there is no market theory.

Incidentally, even if it is true that there is a virology lab in every Chinese city, as you claim, I doubt that all those labs are working on coronaviruses. But it's irrelevant anyway, since labs not in the vicinity of where the outbreak began are irrelevant.

If a virology laboratory said it wasn't working on coronaviruses then it would be accused of concealing it. That is what we see at WIV. WIV says they had no precursor to SARS-CoV-2 and people do not believe them.

There are four wet markets in the city, epidemiology associates the early outbreak only with one and not with WIV. Environmental swabbing was done widely including in farms in the area, the early virus was located in environmental swabs around the wet market. Other sites of origin were suspected and looked at but the evidence favours the wet market as an early centre of the outbreak. Certainly how the virus entered the wet market is unclear. It could have been brought in by a person, but more likely by animals.

In contrast, there is no clustering of cases associated with WIV, staff were tested early and serology showed no evidence they had been infected by SARS-CoV-2.

Q: Is it possible that someone associated with the institute became infected in some other way, for instance while collecting, sampling, or handling bats?
A: Such a possibility did not exist. Recently we tested the sera from all staff and students in the lab and nobody is infected by either bat SARSr-CoV or SARS-CoV-2. To date, there is "zero infection" of all staff and students in our institute.
https://www.science.org/pb-assets/PDF/News PDFs/Shi Zhengli Q&A-1630433861.pdf
 
Of course it is. Indeed, it is the single most important piece of evidence supporting the animal market theory. No market; no market theory.

Ridiculous. The evidence is what happened in the market and near the market, the existence of the market itself hasn't been used as evidence by anyone.

Any evidence pointing to the market depends on the existence of a market. Without a market, there is no market theory.

Irrelevant. Since evidence for what happened in and around the market exists, the market itself exists.

Incidentally, even if it is true that there is a virology lab in every Chinese city, as you claim, I doubt that all those labs are working on coronaviruses.
If? Most major hospitals and universities in the world have at least a BSL2 lab. There could be dozens of them in a large city like Wuhan and yes labs all over China study Coronaviruses and have since the SARS outbreak. They are a major disease risk in China and are treated as such.

But it's irrelevant anyway, since labs not in the vicinity of where the outbreak began are irrelevant.

Again, the existence of a lab tells us nothing to help us distinguish between a lab leak and zoonotic crossover. It's a useless factoid, nothing more.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom