That's another fit the evidence to the conclusion situation. COVID was extremely well adapted to spread person to person. It took SARS1 more than a month circulating among people to reach that optimum adaptation. I just posted a link about that very difference between the 2 pandemics.
Since COVID came on the scene it has continued to mutate. That's why there are so many variants including many that are more infectious than the original version. Think about it,
does anyone leaning toward the spillover camp think COVID wasn't really adapted to humans until the Delta or Omicron variants appeared?
COVID 19 was well adapted to humans specifically in the spike protein gene segment.
Getting back to one citation from your link. There were 2 cases, TWO, of a novel coronavirus (CoV-HKU1) pneumonia that the source was not found. Well d'uh! Why would they search for a source of 2 cases?
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC538593/
Back to your link: No cluster around the WIV? Why would there be unless the initial lab leak was widespread among students and staff? One person (or 3) are initially exposed. Then it depends on a number of factors.
Consider our experience here in WA State. Patient zero arrives on a plane from Wuhan to Everett WA (just north of Seattle). There was no detected outbreak clustered around Everett. Another patient turned up in south Seattle. There was no cluster detected around that case. Then it reached a nursing home in Kirkland, east of Seattle. Suddenly patients and staff started becoming sick and dying. If you were to map these cases out geographically it would look like patient zero must have been in the Life Care Center (nursing home) in Kirkland.
It was a super spreader event location.
The fact there was not a cluster of cases connected to the WIV doesn't rule out the lab and rule in the market.
Back to your link:
How does that not apply to a lab leak?
Patient zero is infected in the lab. It's not recognized until the super spreader event at the market results in a cluster of severe cases.
Re that small fraction of spillovers resulting in an outbreak, we discussed that, it was based on sampling communities that live near the bats in Yunnan for CoV antibodies.
That supports speculating about an hypothesis, it isn't evidence confirming that hypothesis occurred in Wuhan.
This is exactly what I've been saying, the evidence as it stands doesn't support the hypothesized scenario. It could have happened this way, that could be a reason we don't see X, it's possible .... yadda yadda.
The paper goes on to cite all the lab accidents that didn't result in a pandemic. You can't say because it never happened that this is the same. China has not been transparent. They covered up the first cases (which BTW they also did with SARS1).
And this is crap:Yes there is data to suggest this is exactly what Shi was working on, and it was in a BSL2 lab, not the newer BSL4 lab. And there is evidence it was covered up. It's all been posted in this thread.
But they were culturing coronaviruses in human adapted cells and human adapted mice and Shi lied about it.
The WHO inspection team complained they were not allowed to see the actual data, only the summarized results. (Citations in thread) No cases of illness at the WIV during flu season? Seriously?
BBC: Covid-19 pandemic: China 'refused to give data' to WHO team
Looking for the WHO inspection team wanting to see the raw data on WIV staff and students (which is posted upthread) I just searched for it again. I found this:
https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/Declassified-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins.pdf
That is not consistent with
the claim a super spreader event at the wet market was the initial outbreak.
Oh dear, the post is too long.

More will have to follow.