Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Aussie expert weighs in:

“I think you will not get better evidence for a zoonotic origin than this, quite frankly,” says Professor Edward Holmes, a viral evolution expert based at the University of Sydney and author of a report on the new data.

I'm not sure how he thinks the pandemic would have been different had we known this at the time.
 
Aussie expert weighs in:

“I think you will not get better evidence for a zoonotic origin than this, quite frankly,” says Professor Edward Holmes, a viral evolution expert based at the University of Sydney and author of a report on the new data.

I'm not sure how he thinks the pandemic would have been different had we known this at the time.

I agree, what difference would it have made? Most of us dealing with the pandemic assumed it was of zoonotic origin because that was what everyone was expecting. Even if it was a laboratory leak the management would have been the same.
 
I think the straw man is your constant reference to a super spreader event. There is no evidence for this. The natural cross over theory does not require a super spreader event at the market. All it requires is the natural transmissibility of SARS-CoV-2. One or two or several animals were infected by a progenitor virus as animal infected animal the virus mutated, on at least two occasions at least one person was infected by coronavirus from sick animals. Two of those cross over events were by a virus able to spread from person to person, one was not well enough adapted to become widely spread so died out, one spread from person to person, simple exponential growth meant that hundreds were ill by the end of December 2019. It required only one initial event, probably around he beginning of December, and did not require a super spreader event.

Never mind, I think I was misreading part of your post
 
Last edited:
Aussie expert weighs in:

“I think you will not get better evidence for a zoonotic origin than this, quite frankly,” says Professor Edward Holmes, a viral evolution expert based at the University of Sydney and author of a report on the new data.

I'm not sure how he thinks the pandemic would have been different had we known this at the time.

Hmmm… the “Aussie” expert (actually British, in my opinion) was one of the co-authors of the paper, so not exactly impartial.

It’s also disappointing that he thinks this is the best evidence. I would assume there can be found evidence in the wildlife farms or even at other markets if someone did more testing targeting the right areas. There will also presumably be a close progenitor virus somewhere in the bay reservoir, presumably with an FCS.
 
Table 1 (I think) showed animals tested at the Huanan seafood market. There were dogs and snakes and rabbits etc… but no raccoon dogs.

We know that raccoon dogs are susceptible to SARS-1 because when the first evidence of intermediary species were found, palm civets was one species and raccoon dogs were one of (I think) two others. This appears in Spillover by the way.

I showed tables of many other 80,000 and they tended to be cows and sheep and traditional livestock as well as a smaller number of more exotic animals like African elephant etc… my point was that they did not test 80,000 likely intermediaries.

So why did they not test raccoon dogs? I don’t know.

You think it would be obvious they should but I can think of many scenarios why they would not.

One of these is that vendors would not want to be found selling raccoon dogs given that they are known to potentially have pandemic potential viruses. They knew there was a virus in the city. What might a vendor do? Destroy release the evidence probably. This is speculation of course but the point is that this new preprint shows evidence of raccoon dog that the CCDC is denying was there.

Honestly it would make a lot of sense to test all the markets for all livestock but that is complicated if it was illegal to have that livestock in the first place.

FTFY.

I would suggest that the vendor probably released all the racoon dogs locally at the first hint of trouble.

Much easier than killing them all and then disposing of the bodies.

The instinct for self preservation would likely have driven them to the easiest method of disposal (which I'd argue is release).

As evidence I'd point to people that 'flush' tropical fish, jellyfish and baby crocodiles.
 
It’s also disappointing that he thinks this is the best evidence. I would assume there can be found evidence in the wildlife farms or even at other markets if someone did more testing targeting the right areas. There will also presumably be a close progenitor virus somewhere in the bay reservoir, presumably with an FCS.

The problem now is that if the virus is found, it will be easy to shrug it off as coming from humans.

The Chinese tried very hard to hide what had been happening at the market.
 
What is it you are accusing me of lying about? Do you understand the difference of an ad hominem attack by accusing someone of lying without evidence that they have done so and politety asking for a source?

I said nothing about lying. Pulling 'facts' out of your rear is not lying.

You claim China this and China that when you appear to be applying some generalization and you have no actual knowledge about the Chinese culture or country.

Your generalizing is unsupportable.
 
FTFY.

I would suggest that the vendor probably released all the racoon dogs locally at the first hint of trouble.

Much easier than killing them all and then disposing of the bodies.

The instinct for self preservation would likely have driven them to the easiest method of disposal (which I'd argue is release).

As evidence I'd point to people that 'flush' tropical fish, jellyfish and baby crocodiles.
The market was closed by the government shortly after the first cases were detected. Vendors didn't need to get rid of any animals though there were some for sale that were prohibited. I'm not sure what happened in those cases.



The problem now is that if the virus is found, it will be easy to shrug it off as coming from humans.

The Chinese tried very hard to hide what had been happening at the market.
The genetics, especially with all the variants, would be difficult to lie about. If there is a strain similar to COVID (and I don't mean 96%) found circulating in any of the suspect animals it could be actual evidence of a spillover. Same with finding a much closer genetic match circulating among horseshoe bats (and I don't mean finding all the ingredients in different bats) with a trail showing how it got to Wuhan it could be actual evidence of a spillover.


But what we have instead is the genetics of an enhanced ACE2 binding spike proteins and a furin cleavage site in the COVID virus which for all intents and purposes there is no record of in the wild. The furin cleavage site genetics isn't even found in sarbecoviruses.

The wet market has all the hallmarks of a super spreader event. China is still withholding important information on the actual first cases.


NOTE: NOT NEWS SOURCES!!!!! :rolleyes:

Evolutionary origins of the SARS-CoV-2 sarbecovirus lineage responsible for the COVID-19 pandemic
Excerpt from the abstract:
We find that the sarbecoviruses-the viral subgenus containing SARS-CoV and SARS-CoV-2-undergo frequent recombination and exhibit spatially structured genetic diversity on a regional scale in China. SARS-CoV-2 itself is not a recombinant of any sarbecoviruses detected to date, and its receptor-binding motif, important for specificity to human ACE2 receptors, appears to be an ancestral trait shared with bat viruses and not one acquired recently via recombination. ... indicating that the lineage giving rise to SARS-CoV-2 has been circulating unnoticed in bats for decades.
Note "giving rise to" not 'already found in'. The precursor was there all along and would have been among the hundreds of specimens the WIV has been collecting since the SARS1 pandemic.

Dr Shi claimed there were no live cultures of these viruses going on but overwhelming evidence that is a lie has been posted in this thread.


Comparison of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 Spike Protein Binding to ACE2 Receptors from Human, Pets, Farm Animals, and Putative Intermediate Hosts
Excerpt from the abstract:
However, ACE2 of pangolin exhibits seven changes relative to human ACE2, and a similar number of substitutions is present in ACE2 of bats, raccoon dogs, and civets, suggesting that SARS-CoV-2 may not be especially adapted to ACE2 of any of its putative intermediate hosts. ... Effective binding to the host receptor ACE2 is the first prerequisite for infection of cells and determines the host range. Our analysis provides a framework for the prediction of potential hosts of SARS-CoV-2. We found that ACE2 from species known to support SARS-CoV-2 infection tolerate many amino acid changes, indicating that the species barrier might be low.
But:
Finally, our analysis also showed that SARS-CoV-2 may not be specifically adapted to any of its putative intermediate hosts.
So yes it can easily infect other species. But is it specifically adapted to humans?

Here's a news link because it led to 2 other study citations.
https://www.wionews.com/opinions-bl...-artificially-adapted-to-infect-humans-299220
The lead author of the study [cited below] stated, “there are some highly unusual features, including optimal human adaptation, that in the absence of identification of a close to identical virus in an animal population from which COVID-19 could have arisen, would point in the direction of human intervention at some point in the evolution of COVID-19.”

But gee, let's forget about those inconvenient facts, there's an hypothesis a raccoon dog for sale at the market could have been infected.

In silico comparison of spike protein-ACE2 binding affinities across species; significance for the possible origin of the SARS-CoV-2 virus
Human ACE2 has the strongest binding interaction, significantly greater than for any species proposed as source of the virus. ...

Our data indicates that the earliest isolates of SARS-CoV-2 were surprisingly well adapted to human ACE2, potentially explaining its rapid transmission.

And the second paper: SARS-CoV-2 is well adapted for humans. What does this mean for re-emergence?
In a side-by-side comparison of evolutionary dynamics between the 2019/2020 SARS-CoV-2 and the 2003 SARS-CoV, we were surprised to find that SARS-CoV-2 resembles SARS-CoV in the late phase of the 2003 epidemic after SARS-CoV had developed several advantageous adaptations for human transmission. Our observations suggest that by the time SARS-CoV-2 was first detected in late 2019, it was already pre-adapted to human transmission to an extent similar to late epidemic SARS-CoV. However, no precursors or branches of evolution stemming from a less human-adapted SARS-CoV-2-like virus have been detected.

So did Worobey address this, miss it or willfully ignore it?
Importantly, the market samples are genetically identical to human SARS-CoV-2 isolates and were therefore most likely from human sources.


Were the isolates from the stall with the raccoon dog DNA significantly different from the other isolates? If you wait long enough people forget all these inconvenient facts and you can present new data as if nothing contradicts it.
And I haven't even gotten to the furin site yet.
 
Last edited:
I think we can safely say anything official coming from China is a lie to some extent. You don't need evidence for that.

Absolutely. But some evidence is hard to fake, in particular genetic evidence. And more than a bit of evidence has been dug up from papers written before the pandemic started. Hard to go back and rewrite history. People can try but there are copies that exist.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm… the “Aussie” expert (actually British, in my opinion) was one of the co-authors of the paper, so not exactly impartial.

It’s also disappointing that he thinks this is the best evidence. I would assume there can be found evidence in the wildlife farms or even at other markets if someone did more testing targeting the right areas. There will also presumably be a close progenitor virus somewhere in the bay reservoir, presumably with an FCS.

Testing now may not tell you much because Covid is so widespread your samples would be contaminated with viruses that spread from humans back into the animal population. Imagine trying to sample humans today in a search for the first linages of SARS-CoV-2, all you'd find are the latest circulating strains not the original.

What you need are samples that were taken before the pandemic or in the early stages of it. AFAIK no such samples exist from wildlife farms.
 
The problem now is that if the virus is found, it will be easy to shrug it off as coming from humans.

The Chinese tried very hard to hide what had been happening at the market.

Testing now may not tell you much because Covid is so widespread your samples would be contaminated with viruses that spread from humans back into the animal population. Imagine trying to sample humans today in a search for the first linages of SARS-CoV-2, all you'd find are the latest circulating strains not the original.

What you need are samples that were taken before the pandemic or in the early stages of it. AFAIK no such samples exist from wildlife farms.

Maybe or maybe not. I would think that it is possible to establish whether or not raccoon dogs are an intermediate of SARS-CoV2 and that the progenitor virus exists in bats (if this is the case) by large-scale sampling and using some kind of established phylogenetic analysis.

I think that the same kind of research can be, has been and is done in the case of SARS and MERS.

Of course, this would require co-operation from China and there seems to be none.
 
Skeptic Ginger said:
So did Worobey address this, miss it or willfully ignore it?

Worobey and others addressed this in another, earlier paper, that you definitely read. ;)

Regarding claims that SARS-CoV2 was already adapted to humans (Piplani et. al and Zhan et. al):

Considerable attention has been devoted to claims that SARS-CoV-2 was genetically engineered or adapted in cell culture or “humanized” animal models to promote human transmission (Zhan et al., 2020). Yet, since its emergence, SARS-CoV-2 has experienced repeated sweeps of mutations that have increased viral fitness (Deng et al., 2021; Otto et al., 2021; Simmonds, 2020). The first clear adaptive mutation, the D614G substitution in the spike protein, occurred early in the pandemic (Korber et al., 2020; Volz et al., 2021). Recurring mutations in the receptor binding domain of the spike protein, including N501Y, K417N/T, L452R, and E484K/Q—constituent mutations of the variants of concern—similarly enhance viral infectivity (Cai et al., 2021; Khan et al., 2021; Kuzmina et al., 2021) and ACE2 binding (Liu et al., 2021; Starr et al., 2020; Zhu et al., 2021a), refuting claims that the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein was optimized for binding to human ACE2 upon its emergence (Piplani et al., 2021).

Link
 
I said nothing about lying. Pulling 'facts' out of your rear is not lying.

You claim China this and China that when you appear to be applying some generalization and you have no actual knowledge about the Chinese culture or country.

Your generalizing is unsupportable.

Stop the ad hominem attacks; address the argument.

Can you specify which particular statement you wish me to provide supporting evidence for?
 
Maybe or maybe not. I would think that it is possible to establish whether or not raccoon dogs are an intermediate of SARS-CoV2 and that the progenitor virus exists in bats (if this is the case) by large-scale sampling and using some kind of established phylogenetic analysis.

I think that the same kind of research can be, has been and is done in the case of SARS and MERS.

Of course, this would require co-operation from China and there seems to be none.

The difference between SARS and MERS is that SARS-CoV-2 is essentially everywhere. If you test an animal and find SARS or MERS it almost certainly related to the progenitor of the human virus. If you find SARS-CoV-2 it almost certainly the human virus spread back into the animal population.
 
The difference between SARS and MERS is that SARS-CoV-2 is essentially everywhere. If you test an animal and find SARS or MERS it almost certainly related to the progenitor of the human virus. If you find SARS-CoV-2 it almost certainly the human virus spread back into the animal population.

It is possible. I don’t know. But presumably certain viral lineages in raccoon dogs or other species could be detected and distinguished from spillback cases.
 
Worobey and others addressed this in another, earlier paper, that you definitely read. ;)

Regarding claims that SARS-CoV2 was already adapted to humans (Piplani et. al and Zhan et. al):

Link

That's another fit the evidence to the conclusion situation. COVID was extremely well adapted to spread person to person. It took SARS1 more than a month circulating among people to reach that optimum adaptation. I just posted a link about that very difference between the 2 pandemics.

Since COVID came on the scene it has continued to mutate. That's why there are so many variants including many that are more infectious than the original version. Think about it, does anyone leaning toward the spillover camp think COVID wasn't really adapted to humans until the Delta or Omicron variants appeared?

COVID 19 was well adapted to humans specifically in the spike protein gene segment.

Getting back to one citation from your link. There were 2 cases, TWO, of a novel coronavirus (CoV-HKU1) pneumonia that the source was not found. Well d'uh! Why would they search for a source of 2 cases?

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC538593/
In this study, we report the discovery of a novel group 2 coronavirus in the nasopharyngeal aspirates (NPAs) of patients with pneumonia. The complete genome of the coronavirus was sequenced and analyzed. Based on the findings of this study, we propose that this new virus be designated coronavirus HKU1 (CoV-HKU1).

Back to your link:
although case reporting may be subject to sampling biases reflecting the density and age structure of the population in central Wuhan, and the exact location of some early cases is uncertain.
No cluster around the WIV? Why would there be unless the initial lab leak was widespread among students and staff? One person (or 3) are initially exposed. Then it depends on a number of factors.

Consider our experience here in WA State. Patient zero arrives on a plane from Wuhan to Everett WA (just north of Seattle). There was no detected outbreak clustered around Everett. Another patient turned up in south Seattle. There was no cluster detected around that case. Then it reached a nursing home in Kirkland, east of Seattle. Suddenly patients and staff started becoming sick and dying. If you were to map these cases out geographically it would look like patient zero must have been in the Life Care Center (nursing home) in Kirkland.

It was a super spreader event location. The fact there was not a cluster of cases connected to the WIV doesn't rule out the lab and rule in the market.
Back to your link:
No bat reservoir or intermediate animal host for SARS-CoV-2 has been identified to date. This is presumably because the right animal species and/or populations have not yet been sampled and/or any progenitor virus may be at low prevalence. Initial cross-species transmission events are also very likely to go undetected. Most SARS-CoV-2 index case infections will not have resulted in sustained onward transmission (Pekar et al., 2021), and only a very small fraction of spillovers from animals to humans result in major outbreaks.
How does that not apply to a lab leak?
Patient zero is infected in the lab. It's not recognized until the super spreader event at the market results in a cluster of severe cases.

Re that small fraction of spillovers resulting in an outbreak, we discussed that, it was based on sampling communities that live near the bats in Yunnan for CoV antibodies. That supports speculating about an hypothesis, it isn't evidence confirming that hypothesis occurred in Wuhan.
This is exactly what I've been saying, the evidence as it stands doesn't support the hypothesized scenario. It could have happened this way, that could be a reason we don't see X, it's possible .... yadda yadda.

The paper goes on to cite all the lab accidents that didn't result in a pandemic. You can't say because it never happened that this is the same. China has not been transparent. They covered up the first cases (which BTW they also did with SARS1).

And this is crap:
there is no data to suggest that the WIV—or any other laboratory—was working on SARS-CoV-2,
Yes there is data to suggest this is exactly what Shi was working on, and it was in a BSL2 lab, not the newer BSL4 lab. And there is evidence it was covered up. It's all been posted in this thread.

Viral genomic sequencing without cell culture, which was routinely performed at the WIV, represents a negligible risk because viruses are inactivated during RNA extraction (Blow et al., 2004). No case of laboratory escape has been documented following the sequencing of viral samples.
But they were culturing coronaviruses in human adapted cells and human adapted mice and Shi lied about it.

Despite extensive contact tracing of early cases during the COVID-19 pandemic, there have been no reported cases related to any laboratory staff at the WIV, and all staff in the laboratory of Dr. Shi Zhengli were said to be seronegative for SARS-CoV-2 when tested in March 2020
The WHO inspection team complained they were not allowed to see the actual data, only the summarized results. (Citations in thread) No cases of illness at the WIV during flu season? Seriously?

BBC: Covid-19 pandemic: China 'refused to give data' to WHO team
Microbiologist Dominic Dwyer told Reuters, the Wall St Journal and the New York Times the team requested raw patient data from early cases, what he called "standard practice".

He said they only received a summary. ...

The investigators had asked for raw data on the 174 identified cases of Covid-19 from Wuhan in December 2019, Professor Dwyer told Reuters.

Only half of the early cases had been exposed to the seafood market where the virus was initially detected.

Looking for the WHO inspection team wanting to see the raw data on WIV staff and students (which is posted upthread) I just searched for it again. I found this:
https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/Declassified-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins.pdf
The IC assesses that SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, probably emerged and infected humans
through an initial small-scale exposure that occurred no later than November 2019 with the first known cluster of
COVID-19 cases arising in Wuhan, China in December 2019. In addition, the IC was able to reach broad
agreement on several other key issues. We judge the virus was not developed as a biological weapon. Most
agencies also assess with low confidence that SARS-CoV-2 probably was not genetically engineered; however, two
agencies believe there was not sufficient evidence to make an assessment either way. Finally, the IC assesses
China’s officials did not have foreknowledge of the virus before the initial outbreak of COVID-19 emerged.
Aft
That is not consistent with the claim a super spreader event at the wet market was the initial outbreak.


Oh dear, the post is too long.:rolleyes: More will have to follow.
 
That's another fit the evidence to the conclusion situation. COVID was extremely well adapted to spread person to person. It took SARS1 more than a month circulating among people to reach that optimum adaptation. I just posted a link about that very difference between the 2 pandemics.

Since COVID came on the scene it has continued to mutate. That's why there are so many variants including many that are more infectious than the original version. Think about it, does anyone leaning toward the spillover camp think COVID wasn't really adapted to humans until the Delta or Omicron variants appeared?

COVID 19 was well adapted to humans specifically in the spike protein gene segment.

Getting back to one citation from your link. There were 2 cases, TWO, of a novel coronavirus (CoV-HKU1) pneumonia that the source was not found. Well d'uh! Why would they search for a source of 2 cases?

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC538593/


Back to your link: No cluster around the WIV? Why would there be unless the initial lab leak was widespread among students and staff? One person (or 3) are initially exposed. Then it depends on a number of factors.

Consider our experience here in WA State. Patient zero arrives on a plane from Wuhan to Everett WA (just north of Seattle). There was no detected outbreak clustered around Everett. Another patient turned up in south Seattle. There was no cluster detected around that case. Then it reached a nursing home in Kirkland, east of Seattle. Suddenly patients and staff started becoming sick and dying. If you were to map these cases out geographically it would look like patient zero must have been in the Life Care Center (nursing home) in Kirkland.

It was a super spreader event location. The fact there was not a cluster of cases connected to the WIV doesn't rule out the lab and rule in the market.
Back to your link:How does that not apply to a lab leak?
Patient zero is infected in the lab. It's not recognized until the super spreader event at the market results in a cluster of severe cases.

Re that small fraction of spillovers resulting in an outbreak, we discussed that, it was based on sampling communities that live near the bats in Yunnan for CoV antibodies. That supports speculating about an hypothesis, it isn't evidence confirming that hypothesis occurred in Wuhan.
This is exactly what I've been saying, the evidence as it stands doesn't support the hypothesized scenario. It could have happened this way, that could be a reason we don't see X, it's possible .... yadda yadda.

The paper goes on to cite all the lab accidents that didn't result in a pandemic. You can't say because it never happened that this is the same. China has not been transparent. They covered up the first cases (which BTW they also did with SARS1).

And this is crap:Yes there is data to suggest this is exactly what Shi was working on, and it was in a BSL2 lab, not the newer BSL4 lab. And there is evidence it was covered up. It's all been posted in this thread.

But they were culturing coronaviruses in human adapted cells and human adapted mice and Shi lied about it.

The WHO inspection team complained they were not allowed to see the actual data, only the summarized results. (Citations in thread) No cases of illness at the WIV during flu season? Seriously?

BBC: Covid-19 pandemic: China 'refused to give data' to WHO team

Looking for the WHO inspection team wanting to see the raw data on WIV staff and students (which is posted upthread) I just searched for it again. I found this:
https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/Declassified-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins.pdf
That is not consistent with the claim a super spreader event at the wet market was the initial outbreak.


Oh dear, the post is too long.:rolleyes: More will have to follow.
You keep on commenting on a super spreader event at the market, but there is no evidence for this I am aware of, could you reference the evidence for a super spreader event?

Note how an appropriate response is not to accuse you of making up a superspreader event, but to ask you to evidence this.
 
Last edited:
From your quote, AS:
refuting claims that the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein was optimized for binding to human ACE2 upon its emergence (Piplani et al., 2021).
Define "optimized".

This is from the WSJ. As far as the non-pay-walled section goes, this is excerpted in the BizNews link:
https://www.biznews.com/thought-leaders/2021/10/07/covid-19-origins-science
Science Closes In on Covid’s Origins
Four studies—including two from WHO—provide powerful evidence favoring the lab-leak theory.

By Richard Muller and Steven Quay
Oct. 5, 2021 6:19 pm ET
Based on experience with SARS-1 in 2003 and MERS in 2012, we know that many people are infected by a host animal long before a coronavirus mutates to the point where it can jump from human to human. An extensive data set from late 2019—more than 9,000 hospital samples—is available of people exhibiting flulike (thus Covid-like) symptoms in China’s Hubei and Shaanxi provinces before the epidemic started. Based on SARS-1 and MERS, the natural zoonotic theory predicts 100 to 400 Covid infections would be found in those samples. The lab-leak hypothesis, of course, predicts zero. If the novel coronavirus were engineered by scientists pursuing gain-of-function research, there would be no instances of community infection until it escaped from the laboratory. The World Health Organization investigation analyzed those stored samples and found zero pre-pandemic infections. This is powerful evidence favoring the lab-leak theory.
It did not circulate widely before becoming well adapted to person to person spread.


Comparing SARS1 TO SARS 2:
Within months of the SARS-1 and MERS outbreaks, scientists found animals that had hosted the viruses before they made the jump to humans. More than 80% of the animals in affected markets were infected with a coronavirus. In an influential March 2020 paper in Nature Medicine, Kristian Andersen and co-authors implied that a host animal for SARS-CoV-2 would soon be found. If the virus had been cooked up in a lab, of course, there would be no host animal to find.

As for optimized:
In their Nature Medicine paper, Mr. Andersen and colleagues pointed to what they considered the poor design of SARS-CoV-2 as evidence of zoonotic origin. But a team of American scientists mutated the stem of the coronavirus genome in nearly 4,000 different ways and tested each variation. In the process they actually stumbled on the Delta variant. In the end, they determined that the original SARS-CoV-2 pathogen was 99.5% optimized for human infection—strong confirmation of the lab-leak hypothesis. ... The National Institutes of Health database shows no FCS in more than 1,200 viruses that can exchange with SARS-CoV-2.

And if you look at pre-pandemic papers (posted already but here it is again)
... a 2018 grant proposal—written by the EcoHealth Alliance, a U.S.-based nonprofit, and submitted to the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, or Darpa—contained a description of proposed experiments that would involve splicing the FCS sequences into bat viruses so a research team could look for changes in infectivity. Darpa opted not to fund the grant, but the absence of the FCS in related coronaviruses, together with the apparent desire and capability of scientists to make such an insertion, strongly argues in favor of the laboratory origin thesis.
Good ol', "it wasn't us" Daszak. :rolleyes:

But gee, Dr Quay has written COVID guidelines for sale, he must be dismissed out of hand.
 
Last edited:
Stop the ad hominem attacks; address the argument.
Pulling facts out of your rear is not an ad hominem. It has a specific meaning: You have not cited any sources and it's clear you are generalizing from limited knowledge about China.

Can you specify which particular statement you wish me to provide supporting evidence for?
Your whole post. You claim there are virology labs all over China studying coronaviruses for starters.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom