Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here's some interesting stuff that appears in Spillover about SARS-1.

The amplifier host (masked palm civets) were found fairly quickly, but mostly by chance (as well as raccoon dogs). And it led to a mass cull and then a law making the same of wild civets illegal. However, this was also followed by another study in which civets were found not to have the virus, and some reversal of the law. It was then that they started looking into bats as the most likely origin of the virus, and it took a long time, more than a decade?, to trace the progenitor virus.

I don't know where Quay and Muller are getting that 80% figure from. Do you have a link? I suppose it is unlikely to appear in a Wall Street Journal article.

Please have a look at the attached photographs of the pages from Spillover. Note that the market vendor willingly allowed his animals to be swabbed in a market in Shenzhen (which is not the market that SARS originated from, by the way).
 

Attachments

  • Spillover 1.jpg
    Spillover 1.jpg
    122 KB · Views: 4
  • Spillover 2.jpg
    Spillover 2.jpg
    116.5 KB · Views: 3
You keep on commenting on a super spreader event at the market, but there is no evidence for this I am aware of, could you reference the evidence for a super spreader event?
Oh for crying out loud! You came late to this discussion but surely you could just look this up. There are dozens of citations in this thread about the market being the location of a super spreader event. No one here needs to spoon feed that to you.

Note how an appropriate response is not to accuse you of making up a superspreader event, but to ask you to evidence this.
:dl:
 
Last edited:
That's another fit the evidence to the conclusion situation. COVID was extremely well adapted to spread person to person. It took SARS1 more than a month circulating among people to reach that optimum adaptation. I just posted a link about that very difference between the 2 pandemics.

Since COVID came on the scene it has continued to mutate. That's why there are so many variants including many that are more infectious than the original version. Think about it, does anyone leaning toward the spillover camp think COVID wasn't really adapted to humans until the Delta or Omicron variants appeared?

COVID 19 was well adapted to humans specifically in the spike protein gene segment.

Getting back to one citation from your link. There were 2 cases, TWO, of a novel coronavirus (CoV-HKU1) pneumonia that the source was not found. Well d'uh! Why would they search for a source of 2 cases?

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC538593/


Back to your link: No cluster around the WIV? Why would there be unless the initial lab leak was widespread among students and staff? One person (or 3) are initially exposed. Then it depends on a number of factors.

Consider our experience here in WA State. Patient zero arrives on a plane from Wuhan to Everett WA (just north of Seattle). There was no detected outbreak clustered around Everett. Another patient turned up in south Seattle. There was no cluster detected around that case. Then it reached a nursing home in Kirkland, east of Seattle. Suddenly patients and staff started becoming sick and dying. If you were to map these cases out geographically it would look like patient zero must have been in the Life Care Center (nursing home) in Kirkland.

It was a super spreader event location. The fact there was not a cluster of cases connected to the WIV doesn't rule out the lab and rule in the market.
Back to your link:How does that not apply to a lab leak?
Patient zero is infected in the lab. It's not recognized until the super spreader event at the market results in a cluster of severe cases.

Re that small fraction of spillovers resulting in an outbreak, we discussed that, it was based on sampling communities that live near the bats in Yunnan for CoV antibodies. That supports speculating about an hypothesis, it isn't evidence confirming that hypothesis occurred in Wuhan.
This is exactly what I've been saying, the evidence as it stands doesn't support the hypothesized scenario. It could have happened this way, that could be a reason we don't see X, it's possible .... yadda yadda.

The paper goes on to cite all the lab accidents that didn't result in a pandemic. You can't say because it never happened that this is the same. China has not been transparent. They covered up the first cases (which BTW they also did with SARS1).

And this is crap:Yes there is data to suggest this is exactly what Shi was working on, and it was in a BSL2 lab, not the newer BSL4 lab. And there is evidence it was covered up. It's all been posted in this thread.

But they were culturing coronaviruses in human adapted cells and human adapted mice and Shi lied about it.

The WHO inspection team complained they were not allowed to see the actual data, only the summarized results. (Citations in thread) No cases of illness at the WIV during flu season? Seriously?

BBC: Covid-19 pandemic: China 'refused to give data' to WHO team

Looking for the WHO inspection team wanting to see the raw data on WIV staff and students (which is posted upthread) I just searched for it again. I found this:
https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/Declassified-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins.pdf
That is not consistent with the claim a super spreader event at the wet market was the initial outbreak.


Oh dear, the post is too long.:rolleyes: More will have to follow.

Note how an appropriate response is not to accuse you of making up a superspreader event, but to ask you to evidence this.[/QUOTE]

Given that we think the SARS-CoV-2 outbreak started late November / early December and was detected at end of December this matches the one month for SARS.

You also seem to ignore the references above that viruses (specifically SARS) can pre adapt to humans during circulation in other mammal species. You also ignore that lineage A was not well adapted and dies out.

Yes we believe that SARS-CoV-2 was a generalist virus (multiple references given), that could infect many mammals (there is little variability in mammalian ACE receptors), it was sufficiently adapted to spread in humans, and in minks, and in white tailed deer etc. It then became better adapted.

The issue isn't that there is no clustering around WIV, but that if there was a zoonotic transmission then the likeliest site was at a market that sold species likely to transmit a coronavirus to humans. In science one makes a prediction and tests it. If there was a zoonotic transmission event this should be associated with a wild life market. The evidence supports this.

Several novel corona viruses have been described in China one succeeded, SARS-CoV-2
 
That's another fit the evidence to the conclusion situation. COVID was extremely well adapted to spread person to person. It took SARS1 more than a month circulating among people to reach that optimum adaptation. I just posted a link about that very difference between the 2 pandemics.

It is your argument that Covid was circulating from around September 2019. Yet there are no official cases until December, and the unofficial cases date back to around November 17th.

So, it would seem that the adaptation timeline could have been more or less the same.

Now, you can say, "Ah! But I posit that during the Wuhan Military Games there was a massive outbreak and the city was locked down!" (you have said things along those lines.

But then you are faced with another problem. According to your source Quay and Muller say that thousands of samples of blood from flu/seasonal illness patients do NOT show up any SARS-CoV. Well, surely that is a bigger problem for those who claim that the virus was already raging "out of the box" from September onwards. Where are these victims?

On the other hand, if we assume spillover, there could have been asymptomatic infections over a month or more until it adapted well enough to pass from one person to another. People working within the vicinity of an amplifier host like a raccoon dog might make sense.

Of course we don't know this, but it seems to me to be a more coherent and parsimonious explanation than the elaborate, ever-changing, contradictory, and incoherent range of arguments for the lab leak.
 
Here's some interesting stuff that appears in Spillover about SARS-1.

The amplifier host (masked palm civets) were found fairly quickly, but mostly by chance (as well as raccoon dogs). And it led to a mass cull and then a law making the same of wild civets illegal. However, this was also followed by another study in which civets were found not to have the virus, and some reversal of the law. It was then that they started looking into bats as the most likely origin of the virus, and it took a long time, more than a decade?, to trace the progenitor virus.

I don't know where Quay and Muller are getting that 80% figure from. Do you have a link? I suppose it is unlikely to appear in a Wall Street Journal article.

Please have a look at the attached photographs of the pages from Spillover. Note that the market vendor willingly allowed his animals to be swabbed in a market in Shenzhen (which is not the market that SARS originated from, by the way).
It's a pain in the butt to enlarge those stupid thumbnails in order to read them. At least type a couple of key points. Read it again, it says there wasn't any SARS CoV found in farmed civets and there was one infected raccoon dog found infected.

I am quite familiar with the intermediate host for SARS1. You are confusing the intermediate species where SARS circulated becoming better adapted to humans and the bat reservoir which is where the intermediate animals acquired the infection.

I have mentioned this at least half a dozen times.

Whether it was civet cats or raccoon dogs or another intermediate species, it didn't pass directly from bats to people. And your Spillover book says the same thing. Bats are the reservoir. Market animals were the intermediate species.

I'll go look for the source of Quay and Muller's numbers.
 
So, let me explicitly say that this is not necessarily a conspiracy theory, but the arguments for lab leak often involve similar methodology such as anomaly hunting and relying on very dubious sources and non-experts and making contradictory claims and often involving elaborate arguments (Mojiang mine serial passage claims), or the Wuhan Military Games superspreader story, coupled with claims that the virus got out in September 2019 completely adapted to the human ACE and, oh yeah, there is no seroprevalence among anyone with seasonal illnesses in Wuhan at all. How do all these things fit together to a coherent story?

The assumption would have to rely on the same seroprevalance results being fabricated and also that the virus somehow almost disappeared again only to flare up in, of all places, a wet market.

Again a more parsimonious explanation is that it simply started there first of all.
 
It's a pain in the butt to enlarge those stupid thumbnails in order to read them. At least type a couple of key points. Read it again, it says there wasn't any SARS CoV found in farmed civets and there was one infected raccoon dog found infected.

I am quite familiar with the intermediate host for SARS1. You are confusing the intermediate species where SARS circulated becoming better adapted to humans and the bat reservoir which is where the intermediate animals acquired the infection.

I have mentioned this at least half a dozen times.

Whether it was civet cats or raccoon dogs or another intermediate species, it didn't pass directly from bats to people. And your Spillover book says the same thing. Bats are the reservoir. Market animals were the intermediate species.

I'll go look for the source of Quay and Muller's numbers.

I am not confusing anything at all.

I know the difference between a reservoir host and an intermidate.

At least read what I say before misrepresenting me:

The amplifier host (masked palm civets) were found fairly quickly, but mostly by chance (as well as raccoon dogs). And it led to a mass cull and then a law making the same of wild civets illegal. However, this was also followed by another study in which civets were found not to have the virus, and some reversal of the law. It was then that they started looking into bats as the most likely origin of the virus, and it took a long time, more than a decade?, to trace the progenitor virus.

The "amplifier host" IS the intermediate host.
 
Re the 80%, the link is embedded in the paragraph.:rolleyes:

https://zenodo.org/record/5104853#.YVxk2JrMLIW

For SARS-CoV-1 and MERS, when human cases were found to be associated with markets, animal testing in those markets found a high level of infection (about 80%) in the respective intermediate hosts and a detectable level (about 10%) in farms in the supply chain.20 Market workers were seropositive at high levels (10-40%) and the virus could be recovered from multiple markets for many months. 21
20 Tu C, Crameri G, Kong X, et al. Antibodies to SARS coronavirus in civets. Emerg Infect Dis. 2004 Dec;10(12):2244-8. doi: 10.3201/eid1012.040520. SARS Antibodies in Civet
21: Hu S, Shi Z-L. Investigation of Animal Reservoir(s) in SARS-CoV. Y. Lu et al. (eds.), Emerging Infections in Asia. Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2008, pp 57-73.
Look at that, one of Shi's claims to fame: finding the bat reservoir for SARS1. :thumbsup:

NOTICE THE HUGE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN FINDING EVIDENCE OF A SPILLOVER SOURCE FOR COVID-19. If only China would look in the right place.


This gets so tedious. It's why this wears me out. I go to great lengths to support my claims as opposed to some people who can't even review the thread or do a basic Google search.
 
Last edited:
I am not confusing anything at all.

I know the difference between a reservoir host and an intermidate.

At least read what I say before misrepresenting me:


The "amplifier host" IS the intermediate host.
I did read it. But I don't see your point then for taking pictures of those book pages unless you are claiming it took years to find the reservoir for SARS1 as an excuse for why they haven't found the intermediate host for COVID.
 
Re the 80%, the link is embedded in the paragraph.:rolleyes:

https://zenodo.org/record/5104853#.YVxk2JrMLIW


Look at that, one of Shi's claims to fame: finding the bat reservoir for SARS1. :thumbsup:

NOTICE THE HUGE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN FINDING EVIDENCE OF A SPILLOVER SOURCE FOR COVID-19. If only China would look in the right place.


This gets so tedious. It's why this wears me out. I go to great lengths to support my claims as opposed to some people who can't even review the thread or do a basic Google search.

Right, so 80% of civets in a particular market. The number of actual animals is quite low:

Of 103 civet serum samples tested, 18 were positive on at least one of the three assays used, for ≈17% overall seroprevalence. However, when seroprevalence among civets from farms and the market was compared, differences were observed. For samples taken in January 2004, 14 of 18 obtained from the Xinyuan Live Animal Market in Guangzhou tested positive by all three assays (Table), for a seroprevalence of 78%. In contrast, the prevalence on each farm was <40% (4 of 10 animals from the farm in Shanwei tested positive, and no positive animals were found on the other farms); the overall prevalence on farms was 4 (≈10%) of 38. SARS-CoV antibody levels in the four animals at the farm in Shanwei, which is located ≈240 km east of Guangzhou (Figure), were lower than those from the market, and two samples positive by VNT failed to react on IFA or Western blot

So if the likelihood of finding positive samples is much higher in a market and yet no susceptible animals were tested in that market, it might give a false impression that the market was clean of infected animals.

I posted the tables before showing which animals were tested in the market, and civets and raccoon dogs were not among those tested. So, Quay and Muller can conclude, "See, no animal!"

That would be well and good except that we now have conclusive DNA evidence that raccoon dogs and civets were in the market recently enough to have left genetic remains. So why were these not tested? We don't know! But we should know!
 
I did read it. But I don't see your point then for taking pictures of those book pages unless you are claiming it took years to find the reservoir for SARS1 as an excuse for why they haven't found the intermediate host for COVID.

No, there are two points:

1.) the researcher got lucky! The market vendors were happy to hand over their animals for testing. I think we cannot assume that vendors would do the same now. They may kill or remove animals that they assume could get them into trouble.

2.) only testing in specific places will show up positive results. The 80,000 animals figure is meaningless if you only test animals that have a low likelihood of carrying a pathogen. Maybe the testing was done in good faith, but that still doesn't mean it could find the intermediate species.
 
Question for you. Have you ever been to China?
You don't have to go there to understand there are not virology labs doing coronavirus research all over the country. Nor do you need to go there to understand just how different things are from Western countries, or that the government has tight control over what someone like Dr Shi is allowed to say publicly.

As I've noted before as an occupational infectious disease consultant when SARS1 broke out (and actually before that with the HPAI-H5N1) I read everything from research articles to Promed tracking the spread of SARS around the world. There were some frightening things at the time from the government locking the doors to a hospital with the staff inside to an ED doc who hid his exposure to a SARS patient so he could go on a pre-planned visit to Disneyland Tokyo.

And it wasn't just China. India reported they were screening everyone at the airports while a person at one airport reported they were not screened at all.

I have a friend in Hong Kong who has given me a lot of insights until she stopped talking when China took over Hong Kong. I also asked Wolfman a bit about the face saving. Haven't seen him around here for quite a while. I also know a lot about SE Asian culture and the face saving from years of having an obsessive curiosity about other cultures.


History is repeating itself: NPR: Jiang Yanyong, the doctor who exposed the size of the 2003 SARS outbreak, dies at 91
In April 2003, as the ruling Communist Party was suppressing news about the outbreak of the highly contagious Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome, Jiang wrote an 800-word letter stating there were many more SARS cases than were being officially reported by the country's health minister.

Jiang emailed the letter to state broadcaster CCTV and Hong Kong's Beijing-friendly Phoenix Channel, both of which ignored it. The letter was then leaked to Western media outlets that published it in its entirety, along with reports on the true extent of the outbreak and official Chinese efforts to hide it.

The letter, along with the death of a Finnish United Nations employee and statements by renowned physician Zhong Nanshan, forced the lifting of government suppression, leading to the resignations of both the health minister and Beijing's mayor. Strict containment measures were imposed virtually overnight, helping to restrain the spread of the virus that had already begun appearing overseas.
 
Right, so 80% of civets in a particular market. The number of actual animals is quite low:
No, that's not what it says. Why are you distorting the evidence?

Care to try again?
For SARS-CoV-1 and MERS, when human cases were found to be associated with markets, animal testing in those markets found a high level of infection (about 80%) in the respective intermediate hosts and a detectable level (about 10%) in farms in the supply chain.20 Market workers were seropositive at high levels (10-40%) and the virus could be recovered from multiple markets for many months
None of that is true with COVID.


... That would be well and good except that we now have conclusive DNA evidence that raccoon dogs and civets were in the market recently enough to have left genetic remains. So why were these not tested? We don't know! But we should know!
All you have is what we already knew, live raccoon dogs had been for sale at the market.

What's seriously problematic is the fact all the COVID positive specimens from the market were similar and they matched the virus circulating among humans.

So did the raccoon dog(s) have a human adapted strain they passed on to people? And after exploding onto the Wuhan scene only then did it become well adapted to humans?

These claims are not even internally consistent. Did it need to adapt or was it already adapted? Did it come from the silent cases circulating in Wuhan or the raccoon dog(s) at the market? If it was spread from multiple markets wouldn't we see Worobey's target epidemiology maps around those markets? Did those raccoon dogs have a less pathogenic strain?

Makes my head spin.
 
You don't have to go there to understand there are not virology labs doing coronavirus research all over the country. Nor do you need to go there to understand just how different things are from Western countries, or that the government has tight control over what someone like Dr Shi is allowed to say publicly.

No, you haven't. Okay, well then, I think it would be better for you not to write stuff like this....

Skeptic Ginger said:
You have not cited any sources and it's clear you are generalizing from limited knowledge about China.

As opposed to your, what, limitless knowledge about China?

I think this is rather Dunning-Kruger-esque in that someone who has never been to the country, but used to talk to someone in Hong Kong until China took over (that happened in 1997!) and because you chatted with Wolfman, means that your own generalizations are likely to be accurate.

If you went to China you may be surprised by how difficult it is to try and summarize what you are seeing there and assume it all comes down to 1.4 billion robots running the same software. It is a really complex country with various levels of decision-making going on and probably a lot of corruption too.

It might be that you can accurately predict what, say, the CCP is going to do, but even then people are often caught off-guard as Hu Jintao found out recently. The most we can agree on is that China is not being open about the emergence of the virus, and this is true whether or not it is a lab leak or a spillover.
 
No, there are two points:

1.) the researcher got lucky! The market vendors were happy to hand over their animals for testing. I think we cannot assume that vendors would do the same now. They may kill or remove animals that they assume could get them into trouble.

2.) only testing in specific places will show up positive results. The 80,000 animals figure is meaningless if you only test animals that have a low likelihood of carrying a pathogen. Maybe the testing was done in good faith, but that still doesn't mean it could find the intermediate species.
So does China pressure people to cover COVID cases or sources up?

Must have been a pretty surgical operation to only test the animals you didn't expect to find COVID in.

You and the spillover proponents can go on and on making excuses for the missing data. Or you can look at the data that isn't missing and follow it to the conclusion it supports.
 
No, that's not what it says. Why are you distorting the evidence?

Care to try again?

I'm not "distorting the evidence". I am citing the actual paper that Quay is using to distort the evidence and which you are parroting.

The paper is actually from the same people who are mentioned in the Spillover section that disputed Guan Li's findings.

Their argument was that the farms were largely clear of SARS-CoV.

Look again!!

Of 103 civet serum samples tested, 18 were positive on at least one of the three assays used, for ≈17% overall seroprevalence. However, when seroprevalence among civets from farms and the market was compared, differences were observed. For samples taken in January 2004, 14 of 18 obtained from the Xinyuan Live Animal Market in Guangzhou tested positive by all three assays (Table), for a seroprevalence of 78%. In contrast, the prevalence on each farm was <40% (4 of 10 animals from the farm in Shanwei tested positive, and no positive animals were found on the other farms); the overall prevalence on farms was 4 (≈10%) of 38. SARS-CoV antibody levels in the four animals at the farm in Shanwei, which is located ≈240 km east of Guangzhou (Figure), were lower than those from the market, and two samples positive by VNT failed to react on IFA or Western blot

FOUR animals! And from a single farm.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3323399/

This was the type of study that China used to relax laws on farmed wildlife.

The 80% figure is from a single market.

In Guan Li's case that is in Spillover, it was 100% (6 out of 6 civets).

So I am not "distorting the evidence".
 
So does China pressure people to cover COVID cases or sources up?

Must have been a pretty surgical operation to only test the animals you didn't expect to find COVID in.
You and the spillover proponents can go on and on making excuses for the missing data. Or you can look at the data that isn't missing and follow it to the conclusion it supports.

I posted tables of this.

They went to farms of cows and sheep and pigs. Tens of thousands of them showed up no SARS-CoV. Would you be surprised?

They also went to the Wuhan zoo and tested all the animals there, by the looks of things.

All negative. Would you be surprised?
 
No, you haven't. Okay, well then, I think it would be better for you not to write stuff like this....

As opposed to your, what, limitless knowledge about China?
Not limitless. When a person makes statements like there are virology labs all over China and I know there are not, then that is generalizing from not enough information.

You don't have to go to China to know a lot about the country. A lot of reading helps.

The person making the unsubstantiated claims with not a single citation among a slew of paragraphs, claiming falsely I'm only citing newspaper stories, that is the person who needs to support their claims.
 
Also, if I post tables screenshot from papers, you complain because you don't like opening them up as it is a "pain in the ass". BUT you also claim that only you are citing sources for your arguments.

Can't have it both ways. I am citing sources and you complain. I am quoting papers and you claim that the papers "distort the evidence" and yet these are the papers that Quay and Muller base their own claims on.

Sheeeesh!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom