Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not really. Labs like the CCDC are ten-a-penny and yet now it seems some lab leak proponents are particularly interested in that one. The reason why they used to be interested in the WIV was because of the BSL-4 lab. Then they found out that that BSL is not relevant for a SARS-like virus and they heard that the WIV did pseudo-type virus research at BSL-2 and BSL-3.

Now think of the coincidence that if you assume it was the CCDC lab that it leaked from how big a coincidence it was that all the hospitals and doctors around assumed it had spilled out of a wet market given how many cases there were there? See how these coincidences work?

Oh and while we are at it, does it really make sense to say it was a coincidence that there was both the WIV and the CCDC there? This seems to be juggling with numbers without rationale. Are you saying that the lab leak is 2-1 against the wet market because you have two labs and only one wet market?

Hard to follow this, AS. Where do you get this from? "WIV did pseudo-type virus research at BSL-2" What pseudo virus? :confused: They were studying PPP, potentially pandemic pathogens, in particular SARS-like coronaviruses.

And what hospitals and doctors were assuming it was a spillover from the wet market and how is that relevant? :confused:

No one is saying two labs to one market, that's an odd statement. Labs were studying the very virus near where the pandemic started. Compare that coincidence to one animal carrying the virus just happens to infect patient zero near the labs where the virus was being studied.
 
Except for the claim raccoon dogs, civet cats and the like weren't tested I'm not sure what you think I disagree with here. I don't recall if you posted a link supporting that.


Let's take a step back here again:
No one can find the animal that gave people covid-19

This from the paper identifying closely related viruses in palm civets for SARS, which is accepted as evidence that SARS was a natural cross over event. Note they did not find the virus that infected humans.

A novel coronavirus (SCoV) is the etiological agent of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS). SCoV-like viruses were isolated from Himalayan palm civets found in a live-animal market in Guangdong, China. Evidence of virus infection was also detected in other animals (including a raccoon dog, Nyctereutes procyonoides) and in humans working at the same market. All the animal isolates retain a 29-nucleotide sequence that is not found in most human isolates. The detection of SCoV-like viruses in small, live wild mammals in a retail market indicates a route of interspecies transmission, although the natural reservoir is not known.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12958366/
(The actual paper referenced by your source)

These two papers document the natural evolution of a virus adapted to infect humans in palm civets. A variety of mutations occurred in SARS in palm civets, one of which was highly adapted to humans leading to a virus capable of causing human to human transmission.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15695582/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16140765/

But here is where the problem lies:

Which animals did they test? You have said before they left certain animals out of testing. Why would they do that when they would want to cover up a lab-leak?

Closing in on Covid-19 origins – With insights from The Wall Street JournalThe paper goes on to discuss other evidence for the lab-leak hypothesis which we have discussed in this thread.

And sadly this was all hand-waved away because Trump and the GOP were in charge of the hearing. And people in this thread dismissed Dr Quay because he had a product to sell.

Led by Science: The COVID-19 Origin Story
SELECT SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE CORONAVIRUS CRISIS
Opening Remarks of Dr. Steven C. Quay, MD, PhD


Six facts:

1. The Chinese first told the world that the COVID pandemic began in the Huanan Seafood Market ...

... However, after 18 months of investigation, we now know it did not
begin in a market in Wuhan for the following three reasons.
First, none of the 11 patients from the Huanan market or another market were infected with the
earliest virus, meaning they came into the market already infected. The four patients with the
earliest version of the virus all had one thing in common: none had any exposure to the Huanan
Market. ...

Second, none of the environmental specimens from the market had the earliest virus ,,,

Third, 457 animals from Huanan market were tested; all were negative for COVID. 616 animals
from suppliers to the market were tested; all were negative. 1864 wild animals from Southern
China of the type found in the market were tested for COVID and were all negative. ...

After testing 9952 stored human blood specimens from hospitals in Wuhan from before
December 2019, there was not a single case of COVID in any specimen ...



5. SARS-CoV-2 has a unique trigger on its surface called a furin cleavage site ...

6. Finally, SARS-CoV-2 was pre-adapted for human-to-human transmission from the first patient.
Specifically, the part of the virus that interacts with human cells was 99.5% optimized.

But we have that shiny new Worobey study, this evidence is so yesterday.

Steven Quay is not a virologists, nor an infectious disease specialist. His opinion is no better than mine, and I am not an expert either.

1) The comment that because the '11 cases' linked to Huanan market did not have the earliest virus means that they brought the virus into the markey is nonsense. Given that most cases were asymptomatic and only symptomatic cases were identified it would be expected that these would not be the earliest virus. If the market was the site of the cross over that does not mean every case linked to the market is infected by an animal, but that many people with the virus will be associated with the market, and onwardly transmitting it at the markey (and other places). Worobey has addressed the issue that unlinked cases are more likely to live close to the market than linked cases, reinforcing this was the epicentre. We do not have the WGS from all the environmental samples so we cannot know whether any of these are an early virus or not. We do know that the first response was to close the market and slaughter animals so we may not have samples from the animals present at the time, particularly as the authorities initially denied any live animal sales.

For SARS-CoV-2, 249 early cases of COVID-19 were examined genetically, and they were all human-to-human transmissions. For a community-acquired zoonosis, the probability of this occurring is the same as flipping a coin 249 times and getting heads every single time. ...
This is nonsense. What does he think happens that every other case is acquired from an animal and only 50% are human to human? Of course once the outbreak occurs nearly all if not all cases are going to be human to human.

It is now down the Furin cleavage site is not unique to SARS-coV-2.

I have quoted above a paper by actual virologists sti=udying actual viruses in actual bats showing pre adaption to humans occurs. laboratory passage in tissue culture actually adapts viruses to tissue culture and makes them less infectious. The binding site was 99.5% optimised. A very precise figure which we now know empirically is wrong as the virus has been able to further optimise itself.

So yes this is old, and not published in a scientific journal and not peer reviewed and some is clearly nonsense by someone who does not understand epidemiology or statistics.

Perhaps science actually advances? More data is better analysed. Why keep going back to old newspaper articles? I could find old articles and comments by famous people and testimony to house hearings saying the hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin are the cure for covid. Yet the hard science says they are not.
 
Surely you aren't equating the large amount of evidence SARS was a spillover event with the absolute paucity of evidence COVID was a spillover event? :rolleyes:
 
That who was there? Raccoon dogs? Yeah, they were documented there in 2014! And there is supposed to be some mitochondrial DNA of raccoon dogs on the same surfaces as COVID was found.

OK, but additional reports were that human DNA was also present with the COVID positive specimens.

Please provide the best evidence you know of that resolves the following problem:
I know you claim they didn't test the 'right' animals. Why would the Chinese avoid testing the most likely intermediate species?

But let's move on.
Same link:
​
OK so it started right out of the gate spreading person to person in Wuhan near the WIV, the CCDC labs, and the wet market.

Let me take a break here with a reminder about coincidences.

It would be quite a coincidence if the one raccoon dog carrying a human adapted COVID virus turned up in a wet market in Wuhan close to the WIV and close to the CCDC lab that was even closer to the market. And that's given there was no trail said raccoon dog left on its way to the market—not among related species, not among animal trappers or handlers, and not among raccoon dogs sent to other markets in China.

Do you not agree that's an unlikely coincidence? It would be quite a coincidence for a human adapted COVID virus to turn up near the labs that were studying human adapted pathogenic coronaviruses.

Is that not less likely to be a coincidence?

You have fallen for the prosecutors fallacy. What was the chance that a red for d would come down the road just as I was crossing it and hit me? So it must have been deliberate.

1) Coincidences happen.
2) Most large cities have virology laboratories.
3) A pandemic event is most likely to occur in a large city in China.
4) Many Chinese virology laboratories carry out corona virus research
5) WIV was placed there because Wuhan was thought to be at very high risk of a SARS like event. The laboratory was there because it was thought this might happen. It was doing the research because this was an expected event. It is a bit like saying because a guard was at the bank when it was robbed it must have been an inside job because why have a guard there if they did not know it was going to be robbed.
6) WIV was not near the market. The CDC laboratory is but there is no evidence it was carrying out the sort of research lab leak proponents would require for it to create SARS-CoV-2.
7) There is no evidence it was artificially adapted, there is evidence it was naturally occurring.
 
Well, here is the pre-print, everyone.

Link

I think it is worth noting that the title is:

"Genetic evidence of susceptible wildlife in SARS-CoV-2 positive samples at the Huanan Wholesale Seafood Market, Wuhan: Analysis and interpretation of data released by the Chinese Center for Disease Control"

Lots of familiar names: Pekar, Moshiri, Robertson, Wertheim, Garry, Rasmussen, Andersen, Holmes, Rambaut, Worobey and the final name on the paper is Florence Debarre, who I think discovered the sequences.
 
Well, here is the pre-print, everyone.

Link

I think it is worth noting that the title is:

"Genetic evidence of susceptible wildlife in SARS-CoV-2 positive samples at the Huanan Wholesale Seafood Market, Wuhan: Analysis and interpretation of data released by the Chinese Center for Disease Control"

Lots of familiar names: Pekar, Moshiri, Robertson, Wertheim, Garry, Rasmussen, Andersen, Holmes, Rambaut, Worobey and the final name on the paper is Florence Debarre, who I think discovered the sequences.

From the paper

Data accumulated since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic point clearly towards a zoonotic origin of SARS-CoV-2.

1. A preponderance of thee arliest hospitalized COVID-19 patients were linked to a single location, one of just four locations in a city of 11 million people where plausible intermediate hosts of SARS-CoV-2 were sold live. There are hundreds or thousands of other sites that would have been equally or more likely than this wild life market to have the first-detected and largest cluster of early cases hadt he outbreak there not been associated with wildlife sales.

2. The locations of early, severe COVID-19 cases without a clear epidemiological link to the Huanan market nevertheless were so centered on and close to the Huanan market that it is clear that community transmission of SARS-CoV-2 began in this local area and only later expanded across Wuhan, and the rest of the world. Importantly, this includes those infected with lineageA viruses (and not just lineage B), indicating that early community spread of both early lineages of the virus radiated out from the market.

3. The locations of SARS-CoV-2-positive environmental samples in the Huanan market were close to or exactly where susceptible live mammals were sold.

4. The early genetic diversity of SARS-CoV-2 suggests multiple spillovers, and both early lineages, “A” and “B”, were directly observed at the market and geographically associated with the market’s location in away not expected by chance.

5. Live susceptible animals such as raccoon dogs had been reported to be on sale in this market, including during the month (November 2019) when the first human SARS-CoV-2 infection is estimated to have occurred.

6. Evidence collected and generated by China CDC and analyzed here shows that genetic material of such potential intermediate hosts was detected in SARS-CoV-2 positive environmental samples.
 
You have fallen for the prosecutors fallacy.
Oh puhlese. :rolleyes:

Did you just make all this stuff up? :boggled:

PG said:
2) Most large cities have virology laboratories.
3) A pandemic event is most likely to occur in a large city in China.
4) Many Chinese virology laboratories carry out corona virus research
Most large cities in China don't have labs that are manipulating pathogenic SARS-like coronaviruses in BSL2 labs.

There is an important lab in Beijing, IIRC.

https://www.newsweek.com/controvers...may-have-started-coronavirus-pandemic-1500503
The Wuhan Institute has a record of shoddy practices that could conceivably lead to an accidental release, as officials at the U.S. Embassy in Beijing reportedly warned in a cable on January 19,*2018. "During interactions with scientists at the WIV laboratory, they noted the new lab has a serious shortage of appropriately trained technicians and investigators needed to safely operate this high-containment laboratory," states the cable, according to the Washington Post.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wuhan_Institute_of_Virology
Prior to and throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, coronavirus research at the WIV has been conducted in BSL-2 and BSL-3 laboratories.[24]



PG said:
4) Many Chinese virology laboratories carry out corona virus research
Evidence?


PG said:
5) WIV was placed there because Wuhan was thought to be at very high risk of a SARS like event.
WTF? Where did you get this from? The WIV was established in 1956. Research on SARS was begun there in 2005. It was the best place to build a BSL4 lab and had nothing to do with being a location at high risk for a SARS-like event.

The risk of a spillover would be near the caves and mines in southern China, in particular Yunnan Provence where SARS emerged from. It's ~1,300 kilometers to the south.


PG said:
6) WIV was not near the market.
The hell it wasn't.
Propublica Oct 2022: COVID-19 Origins: Investigating a “Complex and Grave Situation” Inside a Wuhan Lab
The WIV has two campuses and performed coronavirus research on both. Its older Xiaohongshan campus is just 8 miles from the crowded seafood market where COVID-19 first burst into public view. Its newer Zhengdian campus, about 18 miles to the south, ...


PG said:
... The CDC laboratory is but there is no evidence it was carrying out the sort of research lab leak proponents would require for it to create SARS-CoV-2.
Yes they were.

CNN; Feb 2023: Assessment Covid-19 leaked from Chinese lab is a minority view within US intel community, sources say
Three sources told CNN that the Department of Energy's shift was based in part on information about research being conducted at the Chinese Centers for Disease Control in Wuhan, China, which was studying a coronavirus variant around the time of the outbreak.

CNN has previously reported that the Chinese CDC lab in Wuhan was researching coronaviruses and bats,
but it is unclear how closely related the variants being studied there were to SARS-CoV-2, the strain of the virus which spread around the world in 2020.



PG said:
7) There is no evidence it was artificially adapted, there is evidence it was naturally occurring.
There is evidence it was manipulated by serial passages through human adapted mice and cells. No it was not a Frankenstein virus with parts patched together. This is all documented in the thread.
https://zenodo.org/record/4477081#
With CoV-2, every one of the more than 294,000 virus genomes sequenced can be traced back to the first genomic cluster and in the first patient in that cluster, a 39-year-old man who was seen at the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) Hospital about one mile from the Wuhan Institute of Virology. The CoV-2 pandemic has the phylogenetic signature of one pure virus sequence infecting one human, with human-to-human spread thereafter; there is just the one and only jump into the human population ever seen. This lack of posterior diversity has been alluded to by Dr. Shi, by the WHO, and by other prominent virologists; they just never take that critical piece of the evidence to the next the proper inference. ...

The virus in a true zoonosis also contains the signature record of the gradual changes and adaptions it made in the protein key, the Spike Protein, it uses to unlock human cells and cause infection.*With SARS-CoV-1 the Spike Protein had fewer than one-third of all the changes it would later develop by the time it became an epidemic. With CoV-2 the Spike Protein was almost perfectly adapted to the human lock, using 99.5% of the best amino acids possible

There is genetic mapping more recent than this work, see my most recent citations.

Here's an interview with Peter Daszak before he knew about the first cases of COVID. It was at a conference on the Nipah virus in Dec 2019. He discusses manipulating coronaviruses and testing coronaviruses collected in the wild starting at minute 28. He says coronaviruses are easy to manipulate and discusses work Shi did with Ralph Baric in NC. When that gain of function work was paused, Shi took the tools back to the WIV:

It's pretty creepy considering what happened just after the interview.
 
Well, here is the pre-print, everyone.

Link

I think it is worth noting that the title is:

"Genetic evidence of susceptible wildlife in SARS-CoV-2 positive samples at the Huanan Wholesale Seafood Market, Wuhan: Analysis and interpretation of data released by the Chinese Center for Disease Control"

Lots of familiar names: Pekar, Moshiri, Robertson, Wertheim, Garry, Rasmussen, Andersen, Holmes, Rambaut, Worobey and the final name on the paper is Florence Debarre, who I think discovered the sequences.


From the paper:
We downloaded the public data to search for genetic sequences from non-human animals, which the CCDC did not identify in their February 2022 preprint. The preprint also posited that all SARS-CoV-2-positive samples in the market were the result of human infections, claiming that the market was a site of amplification of an already widespread epidemic.
That fits the data.


In some cases, the amount of animal genetic material was greater than the amount of human genetic material, consistent with the presence of SARS-CoV-2 in these samples being due to animal infections.
That's just silly. It's a market selling animals, of course the environmental samples are going to have more animal DNA than human DNA.

If you look at environmental sampling of an ICU treating COVID patients you find COVID. You don't find an abundance of nurses' or patient's DNA.


The graph on page 8 shows raccoon dog DNA in one place, but human DNA everywhere COVID material was found except one place.

We found SARS-CoV-2-positive samples in which human mtDNA sequences were most abundant scattered throughout the rest of the market, indicating that in other samples the virus had been shed by infected persons.
Bingo!

The authors conclude that COVID susceptible animals were in one stall that COVID was also found on multiple surfaces. They claim it was plausible two spillover events occurred in this one stall. That supposedly accounts for the two lineages, A & B.

So the claim is 2 raccoon dogs in the same stall infected 2 humans, one of which just happened to be the human super spreader. Seriously? And I'm the biased person here?
 
From the paper:
That fits the data.


That's just silly. It's a market selling animals, of course the environmental samples are going to have more animal DNA than human DNA.

The specific animals matter. I already showed you a table (in fact several tables) showing animals that had been tested. Raccoon dogs were not among them. The suggestions that raccoon dogs were there due to photographic evidence was greeted by you with some squid ink deflections about "seasonality" and "chicken plucking" etc... earlier in the thread, you and Sherkeu spent a lot of time throwing cold water on the idea that the wildlife trade was a big thing in Hubei/Wuhan etc... and some dissembling comments about how there were no bats in the market. Something we already knew.

Now you say, animal market selling animals? Well, durrrr!

If you look at environmental sampling of an ICU treating COVID patients you find COVID. You don't find an abundance of nurses' or patient's DNA.

I don't understand your point.

What their point was, is made clear in the bit that they wrote just before the bit you quoted:
 

Attachments

  • Animal testing 1.jpg
    Animal testing 1.jpg
    94.8 KB · Views: 4
The specific animals matter. I already showed you a table (in fact several tables) showing animals that had been tested. Raccoon dogs were not among them. The suggestions that raccoon dogs were there due to photographic evidence was greeted by you with some squid ink deflections about "seasonality" and "chicken plucking" etc... earlier in the thread, you and Sherkeu spent a lot of time throwing cold water on the idea that the wildlife trade was a big thing in Hubei/Wuhan etc... and some dissembling comments about how there were no bats in the market. Something we already knew.

Now you say, animal market selling animals? Well, durrrr!
Your table was a pretty tiny number out of 80K animals tested. There were pics of raccoon dogs for sale at the market in 2014. I don't believe anyone said they weren't sold there.

Why on Earth would the Chinese test every animal except ones known to carry SARS like coronaviruses?

What you keep missing is the inability for anyone to find a population of any intermediate animal passing a related coronavirus among themselves. One animal, two, that's not what one needs to find if one is going to seriously entertain the spillover hypothesis.

There is a bit of confusion in this thread between a reservoir and an intermediate species. Horseshoe bats are the reservoir for SARS-like coronaviruses. That took a number of years to find.

But the SARS pandemic didn't start because a human was infected from a bat. Rather bats infected civet cats and the virus circulated in that population. At some point those civet cats from the infected population reached more than one wet market in Guangdong China. Tracing human infections back to the 2 wet markets was fairly quick.

CBC Canada 2006: SARS originated in civet cats, Chinese scientists say
An official from the Guangzhou Centre for Disease Control and Prevention, said genetic testing has shown that the virus that killed more than 800 people, including 44 in Canada, came from civets.

"Our research has shown that the SARS coronavirus found in human victims is the same as the SARS coronavirus found in civet cats," said Wang Ming, China Daily reported.

Severe acute respiratory syndrome, or SARS, emerged in Guangdong in southern China in 2002, spreading tomore than 8,000 people.
It wasn't settled that civets were the intermediate animal.
Science 2021: Trading of animals susceptible to bat coronaviruses is the likely cause of the COVID-19 pandemic [supposedly, but I've cited this for what it says about SARS]
The zoonotic origin of SARS-CoV was subsequently linked to live animals available at markets. Further sporadic spill-over events of SARS-CoV from animals took place in Guangzhou, Guangdong, and some researchers working with cultured virus were infected in laboratory accidents ...

Three years after the SARS epidemic began, investigations revealed that horseshoe bats (Rhinolophus) in China were harboring related coronaviruses (4). These collectively form the species SARS-related coronavirus (SARSr-CoV), which comprises the Sarbecovirus subgenus of the Betacoronavirus genus. It was inferred that a sarbecovirus circulating in horseshoe bats seeded the progenitor of SARS-CoV in an intermediate animal host, most probably civet cats (3). Although other possible intermediate hosts for SARS-CoV were identified, in particular raccoon dogs and badgers (for sale with civet cats in animal markets), it is a population of civet cats within markets that appear to have acted as the conduits of transmission to humans from the horseshoe bat reservoir of SARS-CoV, rather than civet cats being a long-term reservoir host species.
There was little difficulty tracing the initial SARS crossover to 2 wet markets. From there it circulated among humans for a month or so before picking up the genetic changes which made it so well adapted to person to person spread.

This is not what we've seen with COVID at all. And trying to fit the evidence to this hypothesis is not how one does good science. One should be seeing what the evidence supports.


I don't understand your point.
My point was the person or animal shedding the virus is not necessarily shedding their own respective genetic material. Say I cough and shed a lot of virus that lands on an environmental surface. You collect a sample from that surface. You will find the virus and probably some of my DNA from my saliva. But if that surface is in a wet market where raw meat is cut up and sold all day long, you'll find a large volume of DNA from all the animals and relatively little from me.


What their point was, is made clear in the bit that they wrote just before the bit you quoted:
As if all they needed to do was find a 'possible' intermediate animal and the spillover was proven. No, they need more than that.
 
Last edited:
You'll have to quote the bit where they say that.
I'm going by the chart in the article. There is raccoon dog DNA along with COVID. There are several other animals detected as well as human DNA. It seems pretty clear this is the stall of the super spreader vendor.

All the other positive specimens from around the market mostly show human DNA with the COVID virus recovered.

In addition the paper notes that there were 2 spillover events which accounts for the 2 lineages.

Since none of the other analyses at the market show COVID and raccoon dogs, one has to assume 2 persons were infected in 2 separate spillover events in this one stall. And that means 2 separate raccoon dogs because they had separate lineages.

Even if the other supposed spillover event happened at a different market, we are left with an even more pronounced dilemma. Why can't the population of raccoon dogs be found where a SARS like virus is circulating? Why haven't any other outbreaks occurred anywhere in China?

It makes no sense.
 
Your table was a pretty tiny number out of 80K animals tested. There were pics of raccoon dogs for sale at the market in 2014. I don't believe anyone said they weren't sold there.

Why on Earth would the Chinese test every animal except ones known to carry SARS like coronaviruses?
.

Table 1 (I think) showed animals tested at the Huanan seafood market. There were dogs and snakes and rabbits etc… but no raccoon dogs.

We know that raccoon dogs are susceptible to SARS-1 because when the first evidence of intermediary species were found, palm civets was one species and raccoon dogs were one of (I think) two others. This appears in Spillover by the way.

I showed tables of many other 80,000 and they tended to be cows and sheep and traditional livestock as well as a smaller number of more exotic animals like African elephant etc… my point was that they did not test 80,000 likely intermediaries.

So why did they not test raccoon dogs? I don’t know.

You think it would be obvious they should but I can think of many scenarios why they would not.

One of these is that vendors would not want to be found selling raccoon dogs given that they are known to potentially have pandemic potential viruses. They knew there was a virus in the city. What might a vendor do? Destroy the evidence probably. This is speculation of course but the point is that this new preprint shows evidence of raccoon dog that the CCDC is denying was there.

Honestly it would make a lot of sense to test all the markets for all livestock but that is complicated if it was illegal to have that livestock in the first place.
 
I'm going by the chart in the article. There is raccoon dog DNA along with COVID. There are several other animals detected as well as human DNA. It seems pretty clear this is the stall of the super spreader vendor.

All the other positive specimens from around the market mostly show human DNA with the COVID virus recovered.

In addition the paper notes that there were 2 spillover events which accounts for the 2 lineages.

Since none of the other analyses at the market show COVID and raccoon dogs, one has to assume 2 persons were infected in 2 separate spillover events in this one stall. And that means 2 separate raccoon dogs because they had separate lineages.

Even if the other supposed spillover event happened at a different market, we are left with an even more pronounced dilemma. Why can't the population of raccoon dogs be found where a SARS like virus is circulating? Why haven't any other outbreaks occurred anywhere in China?

It makes no sense.

So it’s a strawman. Thought so.
 
Oh puhlese. :rolleyes:

Did you just make all this stuff up? :boggled:

Most large cities in China don't have labs that are manipulating pathogenic SARS-like coronaviruses in BSL2 labs.

If they did, it would be in a BSL2 laboratory because that is where coronavirus research is done. It is not done in the BSL4 laboratory such as WIV has. Every large city will have clinical and research / university virology laboratories at BSL2. Academic virus research is very much about manipulating viruses. If you claim that Wuhan is unique in having coronavirus research then it is your responsibility to provide the evidence. If you looked at research carried out in say the largest twenty Chinese cities and showed that coronavirus research was only done in Wuhan that would be of note, but if say five cities carry out coronavirus research then it was a 1;4 chance the outbreak would occur in a city where there was corona virus research, not such a coincidence.

This is essentially anti-Chinese propaganda. The report did not say there were dangerous practices. What it said was that the laboratory could not be fully utilised because of lack of funding. In any case this is irrelevant 'look squirrel' evidence. Coronavirus research is not carried out in BSL4 laboratories so the staffing at the BSL4 laboratory is irrelevant.

Yes they were.

CNN; Feb 2023: Assessment Covid-19 leaked from Chinese lab is a minority view within US intel community, sources say



There is evidence it was manipulated by serial passages through human adapted mice and cells. No it was not a Frankenstein virus with parts patched together. This is all documented in the thread.

No there is no evidence it was manipulated by serial passage through human adapted mice and cells. Indeed if that happened it would be likely to make the virus less transmissible not more so. I provided a paper by virologists looking at viruses in animals showing pre-adaption happens in animals. Please reference an actual paper providing evidence that serial passage was necessary or done. Happy to agree it was not a Frankenstein virus.

https://zenodo.org/record/4477081#


There is genetic mapping more recent than this work, see my most recent citations.

Here's an interview with Peter Daszak before he knew about the first cases of COVID. It was at a conference on the Nipah virus in Dec 2019. He discusses manipulating coronaviruses and testing coronaviruses collected in the wild starting at minute 28. He says coronaviruses are easy to manipulate and discusses work Shi did with Ralph Baric in NC. When that gain of function work was paused, Shi took the tools back to the WIV:

It's pretty creepy considering what happened just after the interview.

The campus where She worked which is the suspect site for the leak is 18 miles away, so not close. Especially given the place of residence of the early cases, both linked and unlinked.

You keep on quoting gossip, from newspapers. Are you now arguing the leak was from the CDC, in which case what happened at WIV and what Shi did was irrelevant. This is the problem with the laboratory leak theories, they are a hydra. Which laboratory was the alleged leak from, was the virus genetically manipulated or a product of serial passage? Yet it remains true that whilst early SARS-CoV-2 lineages were found at the market, there is no evidence that a source virus was at any laboratory in Wuhan. Bats are scary, they did bat research, China is scary, Chinese bats are very scary, China did research on Chinese bats therefore they must have caused the pandemic. There is no evidence that bat research was done at the time, one would also have to show that the bats researched were from a species and area where the closely related wild type virus was found. The laboratory leak theory is full of 'what if' and devoid of hard data, which is why you have to keep quoting news papers.

Talks about coronavirus and collecting viruses and manipulating viruses have happened for years, I have attended some. Just taking the last one that happened before the pandemic is another example of creating a co-incidence. People were dong this because the highest perceived risk was a coronavirus cross over event. Since you don't believe in a Frankenstein virus the 'gain of function' research is irrelevant. The gain of function research is irrelevant, you can only do research on a virus you have, since the laboratories did not have the ancestral virus, they could not do gain of function research on it.

As time goes on evidence for a natural cross over event increases, no evidence for a laboratory leak accumulates.
 
What are you talking about? It's from the preprint and other cited sources. I never said you or anyone in the thread were making these arguments.

I think the straw man is your constant reference to a super spreader event. There is no evidence for this. The natural cross over theory does not require a super spreader event at the market. All it requires is the natural transmissibility of SARS-CoV-2. One or two or several animals were infected by a progenitor virus as animal infected animal the virus mutated, on at least two occasions at least one person was infected by coronavirus from sick animals. Two of those cross over events were by a virus able to spread from person to person, one was not well enough adapted to become widely spread so died out, one spread from person to person, simple exponential growth meant that hundreds were ill by the end of December 2019. It required only one initial event, probably around he beginning of December, and did not require a super spreader event.
 
So @Planigale, you made it up then.

You complain about my sources then post without any.

What is it you are accusing me of lying about? Do you understand the difference of an ad hominem attack by accusing someone of lying without evidence that they have done so and politety asking for a source?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom