Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
You vacillate between implied confidence it was a spillover and this, "I have not ruled a lab leak out."

I may see spillover as more likely, but I don't triumphantly "take it to the bank" when there is no reason to. I don't know if I actually stated what you said in the quotes or if you made that up, but you have claimed a lab leak is "obvious". This is why jt512 has said you are "overconfident".

It's OK, I do the same. I do think the evidence is leaning more and more toward the lab but that's because I find fault with Worobey's paper. IMO he's trying to relive his glory days when he mapped out HIV cases to find the source. But so much differed there, in particular he had more cases to analyze and he had a wider geographical area to narrow the source down to.

Why assign bad motives to people?

He excuses the missing data on early cases and leaves the CCDC labs off his map. The cases he does include have some connection to the market. Did he ascertain if any of them had any connections to the WIV or the CCDC labs? Did any of the positive cases ride the subway, especially line 2 that goes to the WIV? Did he take into account there are no residential areas near the WIV which would bias where the infected persons lived. Did he take into account the suspicious claim made by Shi that no one in the lab was sick all winter long?

It's a pretty biased study and I don't see a lot of critical analysis of it.

For the bold, there are large files of supplementary materials which attempt to show how ascertainment bias was ruled out.

But here is one part from it...

Reported cases not directly linked to Huanan market lived significantly closer to the market than linked
cases.
If cases with no identified link to Huanan market were primarily ascertained through contact
tracing of personal contacts of Huanan-linked cases (a path dependent ascertainment bias), they would be
expected to have a similar geographic distribution as cases linked to the market. On the contrary, we note
that on average they lived closer to the market (4.00 vs 5.74km, p=0.029). This pattern is thus better
explained if the primary risk factor for linked cases was their place of work, while the primary risk factor
for unlinked cases was proximity to the market and community spread starting at the market.
 
All the national labs, which are under the DOE, do original scientific research.



You don't know that they don't have virologists on stall. And if they don't, the have access to every virologist in the free world, including the ones who did the very research you are talking about.


If the DoE has virologists on staff then present us with links to some of the papers they have published.

Strawman again. Strike three. You're out. Bye.

If you have a stronger version of that argument by all means present it, but so far all you do is keep repeating "you don't know that they don't" which isn't an argument anyone should take seriously.
 


We need to hold fire on that one. As far as I know, I think do not hav proof or infected raccoon dogs. As yet all we have is evidence that raccoon dogs were in the places being swabbed.

We still need to wait until we can see a paper that other virologists can look at and independently verify. Ultimately it would be helpful if it allows the WHO to put more pressure on China to release more data publicly.

At this point it seems to me that everyone, whether lab leak or spillover proponent is in some confirmation bias mode.

Even if it's not raccoon dogs specifically the fact that you have covid associated with animal pens suggests it's present in both animals and humans at the market which in turn strongly implies zoonotic crossover is occurring. Yes there is the possibility that the crossover is human to animal but this would debunk the idea that Covid must somehow be tuned for humans.
 
Yes, but look again...

Indeed, why were raccoon dogs not tested? This is the problem I pointed out before. You won't find it if you don't look in likely sources.

When we kept hearing from LL proponents the meme "80,000 animals tested and no virus" they were testing animals that were unlikely to carry the virus such as stray dogs and zoo animals.

And...

Yes, the CCP wants to imply that the virus was imported. They don't state it directly because they want the paper to get through peer review and claiming that it came from outside China would be an unsupportable conclusion given that it requires some extreme gap-filling or conspiracy (i.e the Italians or Americans brought it in during the Wuhan Military Games).

Apparently the Gao paper was the reason why people like Florence Debarre were looking at GSAID waiting for the sequences to appear. It seems to have something to do with how sequences and reads are stored and embargoed (so that nobody else gets to see them before the pre-prints get published in journals), but because it has been about one year since Gao's preprint came out, other researchers were expecting the reads and the sequences to appear suddenly online.

According to one Twitter thread, this is how it happened...

Link

I think some LLers are saying, "Well, how convenient that this important data only appeared for a nanosecond and isn't available any more..." But it makes sense if the data was being looked for, and then disappeared after SAGO notified the Chinese CDC who were upset about it being there.
Except for the claim raccoon dogs, civet cats and the like weren't tested I'm not sure what you think I disagree with here. I don't recall if you posted a link supporting that.


Let's take a step back here again:
No one can find the animal that gave people covid-19
A first step was to double-check that the outbreak really did start in Wuhan, not elsewhere. China undertook a fairly vast effort to see if covid-19 could have been spreading, unseen, any earlier than December 2019. Chinese researchers checked records of more than 200 hospitals around the country for suspicious pneumonias, tracked how much cough syrup pharmacies had sold, and tested 4,500 biospecimens stored before the outbreak, including blood samples that could be screened for antibodies. The WHO team says it even interviewed the office worker who, on December 8, 2019, became the first recognized covid-19 case in China.

So far, there is no evidence the outbreak went undetected elsewhere before the Wuhan cases. Genetic evidence also narrows the chance that the virus was spreading much earlier. Because of how the germ has accumulated mutations with time, it’s possible to estimate when it first started spreading between people. That data, too, points to a start date of late 2019.

About half the early cases, in December, had a link to the Huanan Wholesale Seafood Market, a maze of stalls selling frozen fish and some wild animals. That’s why animal markets are under suspicion. But the case is not airtight. The genetic evidence indicates that these cases are a branch of the early outbreak—that the market was a place where its spread was amplified, but not necessarily the starting point.


But here is where the problem lies:
One problem with the lab leak theory is that it presumes the Chinese are lying or hiding facts, a position incompatible with a joint scientific effort.

Which animals did they test? You have said before they left certain animals out of testing. Why would they do that when they would want to cover up a lab-leak?

Closing in on Covid-19 origins – With insights from The Wall Street Journal
Over 80,000 animals – from 209 species – were tested, including wild, domesticated and market animals. “As the WHO investigation reported, not a single animal infected with SARS-CoV-2 was found. ...

An extensive data set from late 2019—more than 9,000 hospital samples—is available of people exhibiting flulike (thus Covid-like) symptoms in China’s Hubei and Shaanxi provinces before the epidemic started. Based on SARS-1 and MERS, the natural zoonotic theory predicts 100 to 400 Covid infections would be found in those samples. The lab-leak hypothesis, of course, predicts zero. If the novel coronavirus were engineered by scientists pursuing gain-of-function research, there would be no instances of community infection until it escaped from the laboratory. The World Health Organization investigation analyzed those stored samples and found zero pre-pandemic infections. This is powerful evidence favoring the lab-leak theory
The paper goes on to discuss other evidence for the lab-leak hypothesis which we have discussed in this thread.

And sadly this was all hand-waved away because Trump and the GOP were in charge of the hearing. And people in this thread dismissed Dr Quay because he had a product to sell.

Led by Science: The COVID-19 Origin Story
SELECT SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE CORONAVIRUS CRISIS
Opening Remarks of Dr. Steven C. Quay, MD, PhD
In the last 18 months, we have learned an immense amount about the origin of the pandemic. But one of
my frustrations is that virologists and science writers around the world seem to want to ignore what we
have learned and the inevitable conclusion it reveals. As inconvenient as it is, I believe the evidence
conclusively establishes that the COVID pandemic was not a natural process but instead came from a
laboratory in Wuhan China, and that it has the fingerprints of genetic manipulation through a process
called ‘gain-of-function’ research. ...

Six facts:
1. The Chinese first told the world that the COVID pandemic began in the Huanan Seafood Market ...

... However, after 18 months of investigation, we now know it did not
begin in a market in Wuhan for the following three reasons.
First, none of the 11 patients from the Huanan market or another market were infected with the
earliest virus, meaning they came into the market already infected. The four patients with the
earliest version of the virus all had one thing in common: none had any exposure to the Huanan
Market. ...

Second, none of the environmental specimens from the market had the earliest virus ,,,

Third, 457 animals from Huanan market were tested; all were negative for COVID. 616 animals
from suppliers to the market were tested; all were negative. 1864 wild animals from Southern
China of the type found in the market were tested for COVID and were all negative. ...

After testing 9952 stored human blood specimens from hospitals in Wuhan from before
December 2019, there was not a single case of COVID in any specimen ...

For SARS-CoV-2, 249 early cases of COVID-19 were examined genetically, and they
were all human-to-human transmissions. For a community-acquired zoonosis, the probability of
this occurring is the same as flipping a coin 249 times and getting heads every single time. ...

5. SARS-CoV-2 has a unique trigger on its surface called a furin cleavage site ...

6. Finally, SARS-CoV-2 was pre-adapted for human-to-human transmission from the first patient.
Specifically, the part of the virus that interacts with human cells was 99.5% optimized.


But we have that shiny new Worobey study, this evidence is so yesterday.
 
Which animals did they test? You have said before they left certain animals out of testing. Why would they do that when they would want to cover up a lab-leak?

It’s very obvious. They want to cover up a market origin as well.

It’s a lucrative illegal and therefore officially non-existent industry that took up the slack from a mass culling of pigs that happened after a swine flu epidemic raged through China in 2019.

You have convinced yourself of a reductive assumption that China wants to “save face” because…. Chinese. But you have maybe come to that conclusion because you are an American and Americans assume that everything is about them. For Americans, when we talk about China they assume we are talking about America. But China may have domestic reasons why it would be extremely bad for them if a pandemic and extreme lock-downs were caused by having not stamped out the illegal trade in wildlife even after the first SARS.

In other words, it is merely your assumption that China wants to cover up a lab leak and not a market spillover and yet the recent evidence suggests China is indeed covering up the illegal wildlife trade.
 
It’s very obvious. They want to cover up a market origin as well.

It’s a lucrative illegal and therefore officially non-existent industry that took up the slack from a mass culling of pigs that happened after a swine flu epidemic raged through China in 2019.

You have convinced yourself of a reductive assumption that China wants to “save face” because…. Chinese. But you have maybe come to that conclusion because you are an American and Americans assume that everything is about them. For Americans, when we talk about China they assume we are talking about America. But China may have domestic reasons why it would be extremely bad for them if a pandemic and extreme lock-downs were caused by having not stamped out the illegal trade in wildlife even after the first SARS.

In other words, it is merely your assumption that China wants to cover up a lab leak and not a market spillover and yet the recent evidence suggests China is indeed covering up the illegal wildlife trade.


The view I take is that China would probably have few issues with scapegoating an individual in the case of a real lab leak. In this case it becomes that individual that is to blame, not China, not Chinese culture, not the government.

On the other hand the live animal trade can't be separated from China, it's culture or it's government. A problem that arises from live animal markets directly challenges everything China wants to defend and so would be a far more important thing to cover up.
 
.... This is why jt512 has said you are "overconfident".
To which I don't disagree and don't care.

....Why assign bad motives to people?
IMO it's the best explanation for his ignoring important data on the earliest cases.

....For the bold, there are large files of supplementary materials which attempt to show how ascertainment bias was ruled out.

But here is one part from it...
And yet he has this information when the Chinese government continues to block access to the demographics of the earliest cases.

Post editorial board: What is China hiding about early COVID cases?
Josephine Ma, the China news editor of the South China Morning Post, in Hong Kong, reported later that the first patient was a 55-year-old who fell ill on Nov. 17, 2019. Eight more people, from 39 to 79 years old, got sick later in November. Quoting leaked government documents, Ms. Ma found 27 infections by Dec. 15, and 60 by Dec. 20....

The research group DRASTIC, which has been probing the origins of the virus, has now found evidence that Ms. Ma’s report was right on target. The researchers have determined that by the end of February 2020, China had identified as many as 260 cases from the previous December. Yet China reported to the World Health Organization a year later — in early 2021 — that there were only 174 cases that December. This raises important and still unanswered questions: Who were these early cases? How did they get sick? Why were they not reported to the WHO?
So how does Worobey know where the earliest cases lived? How does he explain the genetic evidence I just posted that the supposed patient zero in his study did not have the genetics of a first case?
 
SELECT SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE CORONAVIRUS CRISIS
Opening Remarks of Dr. Steven C. Quay, MD, PhD[/url]

Six facts:

Third, 457 animals from Huanan market were tested; all were negative for COVID. 616 animals
from suppliers to the market were tested; all were negative. 1864 wild animals from Southern
China of the type found in the market were tested for COVID and were all negative. ...

But we have that shiny new Worobey study, this evidence is so yesterday.

Look at the table. They tested rabbits, and snakes and cats and fish. But no raccoon dogs.

So where are we now? The LLers usually flip flop on this alternately claiming that there is no evidence there were any, and if evidence turns up that they were saying we always knew that anyway.
 

Attachments

  • Huanan testing.jpg
    Huanan testing.jpg
    96.2 KB · Views: 3
There was a fair bit of retrospective testing of usual farm livestock from all across China. Some of it was collected in 2018.

It's fine that they did such testing, but these two tables come to almost 20,000 in all and none of them would be likely culprits of a spillover, so you can see how quickly you could arrive at that 80,000 figure and not find it, because it is like looking for a needle in a haystack...
 

Attachments

  • Huanan testing 2.jpg
    Huanan testing 2.jpg
    81.2 KB · Views: 3
  • Huanan testing 3.jpg
    Huanan testing 3.jpg
    75.8 KB · Views: 2
The view I take is that China would probably have few issues with scapegoating an individual in the case of a real lab leak. In this case it becomes that individual that is to blame, not China, not Chinese culture, not the government.

On the other hand the live animal trade can't be separated from China, it's culture or it's government. A problem that arises from live animal markets directly challenges everything China wants to defend and so would be a far more important thing to cover up.

I think it might have been more acceptable for China early on into accept a market spillover and that might explain why they were seriously investigating the possibility. In fact, China's early reaction seems consistent with it. Even Sam Harris on that podcast with Chan and Ridley interpreted their words about how there was ascertainment bias favouring a market spillover and the suggestion there was no human-to-human transmission at that point, that they really believed it. Chan herself seems to understand the implication and then says something like, "Oh, yes but they also sold the genome on an auction to a vaccine company".

But, as the pandemic spread, and suddenly there were calls for reparations against China regardless of whether the virus occurred through lab leak or market, then it became a semi-official, then perhaps official line that the virus came from outside. This is why more recent papers such as Gao's preprint alludes to outside causes.

It is odd to me, though, that Chan and Ridley take Gao's claim that the market was a superspreader event on face value, but of course won't do the same about a lab leak.
 
This one did include raccoon dogs among 68 other species that were tested in Hubei. It isn't at all clear how many of them, or where.

The point is that the 80,000 animals tested is nowhere near as comprehensive as people like Stephen Quay and other LLers claim. A large number of those tests seem to be padded figures.
 

Attachments

  • Huanan testing 4.jpg
    Huanan testing 4.jpg
    91.9 KB · Views: 5
Post editorial board: What is China hiding about early COVID cases?So how does Worobey know where the earliest cases lived? How does he explain the genetic evidence I just posted that the supposed patient zero in his study did not have the genetics of a first case?


Honestly, it is difficult to know what to make of this case and others. It may have been Covid, and may not have been.

I hope that the recent findings lead to more pressure on China to reveal more about what they know to SAGO.

But interesting is that the Guardian report on the same claim of the early case from November 17th shows this...

The origins of the virus have become part of US-China diplomatic conflict, fuelled by US officials calling the disease “Chinese coronavirus” or “Wuhan virus”.

It’s widely accepted, including by the head of China’s Center for Disease Control and Prevention that the virus originated in Hubei. However in recent ​weeks Chinese officials have started suggesting or outright claiming that the virus ​did not ​originate​ in China, but perhaps in the US​, a conspiracy theory that is gaining traction​. On Thursday, Zhao Lijian, a foreign ministry spokesman, suggested without evidence that the US army may have brought it into China.
“Epidemics always have become political,” said Mayer. “Governments seem opposed to admitting that things were handled imperfectly, yet it is only by identifying the imperfections and shortcomings that things can be addressed to do a better job next time. With emerging infections, there will always be a next time.”

In other words, back in March 2020, it seems that Gao was of the impression that the virus began in the market or at least in Wuhan (or Hubei in general) and yet the official narrative was turning towards blaming the US. The implication with the US military being blamed is that the Wuhan Military Games was the time when American soldiers brought it to China.

Anyway, this demonstrates that China was already forming the narrative that it was neither lab leak or market and why they absolutely will not accept a market origin now.
 
Look at the table. They tested rabbits, and snakes and cats and fish. But no raccoon dogs.

So where are we now? The LLers usually flip flop on this alternately claiming that there is no evidence there were any, and if evidence turns up that they were saying we always knew that anyway.
Dogs, rats, cats, weasels are all susceptible to COVID. And that certainly isn't 80K animals, maybe there were no raccoon dogs or civet cats because they were off season in the market.

You can't go by this list to claim the search for a source left out important animals.
 
... It is odd to me, though, that Chan and Ridley take Gao's claim that the market was a superspreader event on face value, but of course won't do the same about a lab leak.
It wasn't at face value. Go back over my last half dozen posts, the genetics were evidence the market vendor did not have one of the first cases.
 
This one did include raccoon dogs among 68 other species that were tested in Hubei. It isn't at all clear how many of them, or where.

The point is that the 80,000 animals tested is nowhere near as comprehensive as people like Stephen Quay and other LLers claim. A large number of those tests seem to be padded figures.
:rolleyes:
 
Dogs, rats, cats, weasels are all susceptible to COVID. And that certainly isn't 80K animals, maybe there were no raccoon dogs or civet cats because they were off season in the market.

You can't go by this list to claim the search for a source left out important animals.

And yet now we have genetic material suggesting that they were there.
 
And yet now we have genetic material suggesting that they were there.
That who was there? Raccoon dogs? Yeah, they were documented there in 2014! And there is supposed to be some mitochondrial DNA of raccoon dogs on the same surfaces as COVID was found.

OK, but additional reports were that human DNA was also present with the COVID positive specimens.

Please provide the best evidence you know of that resolves the following problem:
MIT Tech:
This time, though, the intermediate-host hypothesis has one big problem. More than a year after covid-19 began, no food animal has been identified as a reservoir for the pandemic virus. That’s despite efforts by China to test tens of thousands of animals, including pigs, goats, and geese, according to Liang Wannian, who leads the Chinese side of the research team. No one has found a “direct progenitor” of the virus,
I know you claim they didn't test the 'right' animals. Why would the Chinese avoid testing the most likely intermediate species?

But let's move on.
Same link:
A first step was to double-check that the outbreak really did start in Wuhan, not elsewhere. China undertook a fairly vast effort to see if covid-19 could have been spreading, unseen, any earlier than December 2019. Chinese researchers checked records of more than 200 hospitals around the country for suspicious pneumonias, tracked how much cough syrup pharmacies had sold, and tested 4,500 biospecimens stored before the outbreak, including blood samples that could be screened for antibodies. The WHO team says it even interviewed the office worker who, on December 8, 2019, became the first recognized covid-19 case in China.

So far, there is no evidence the outbreak went undetected elsewhere before the Wuhan cases. Genetic evidence also narrows the chance that the virus was spreading much earlier. Because of how the germ has accumulated mutations with time, it’s possible to estimate when it first started spreading between people. That data, too, points to a start date of late 2019.
OK so it started right out of the gate spreading person to person in Wuhan near the WIV, the CCDC labs, and the wet market.

Let me take a break here with a reminder about coincidences.

It would be quite a coincidence if the one raccoon dog carrying a human adapted COVID virus turned up in a wet market in Wuhan close to the WIV and close to the CCDC lab that was even closer to the market. And that's given there was no trail said raccoon dog left on its way to the market—not among related species, not among animal trappers or handlers, and not among raccoon dogs sent to other markets in China.

Do you not agree that's an unlikely coincidence? It would be quite a coincidence for a human adapted COVID virus to turn up near the labs that were studying human adapted pathogenic coronaviruses.

Is that not less likely to be a coincidence?
 
That who was there? Raccoon dogs? Yeah, they were documented there in 2014! And there is supposed to be some mitochondrial DNA of raccoon dogs on the same surfaces as COVID was found.

OK, but additional reports were that human DNA was also present with the COVID positive specimens.

Please provide the best evidence you know of that resolves the following problem:
I know you claim they didn't test the 'right' animals. Why would the Chinese avoid testing the most likely intermediate species?

But let's move on.
Same link:
​
OK so it started right out of the gate spreading person to person in Wuhan near the WIV, the CCDC labs, and the wet market.

Let me take a break here with a reminder about coincidences.

It would be quite a coincidence if the one raccoon dog carrying a human adapted COVID virus turned up in a wet market in Wuhan close to the WIV and close to the CCDC lab that was even closer to the market. And that's given there was no trail said raccoon dog left on its way to the market—not among related species, not among animal trappers or handlers, and not among raccoon dogs sent to other markets in China.

Do you not agree that's an unlikely coincidence? It would be quite a coincidence for a human adapted COVID virus to turn up near the labs that were studying human adapted pathogenic coronaviruses.

Is that not less likely to be a coincidence?

Not really. Labs like the CCDC are ten-a-penny and yet now it seems some lab leak proponents are particularly interested in that one. The reason why they used to be interested in the WIV was because of the BSL-4 lab. Then they found out that that BSL is not relevant for a SARS-like virus and they heard that the WIV did pseudo-type virus research at BSL-2 and BSL-3.

Now think of the coincidence that if you assume it was the CCDC lab that it leaked from how big a coincidence it was that all the hospitals and doctors around assumed it had spilled out of a wet market given how many cases there were there? See how these coincidences work?

Oh and while we are at it, does it really make sense to say it was a coincidence that there was both the WIV and the CCDC there? This seems to be juggling with numbers without rationale. Are you saying that the lab leak is 2-1 against the wet market because you have two labs and only one wet market?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom