angrysoba
Philosophile
You vacillate between implied confidence it was a spillover and this, "I have not ruled a lab leak out."
I may see spillover as more likely, but I don't triumphantly "take it to the bank" when there is no reason to. I don't know if I actually stated what you said in the quotes or if you made that up, but you have claimed a lab leak is "obvious". This is why jt512 has said you are "overconfident".
It's OK, I do the same. I do think the evidence is leaning more and more toward the lab but that's because I find fault with Worobey's paper. IMO he's trying to relive his glory days when he mapped out HIV cases to find the source. But so much differed there, in particular he had more cases to analyze and he had a wider geographical area to narrow the source down to.
Why assign bad motives to people?
He excuses the missing data on early cases and leaves the CCDC labs off his map. The cases he does include have some connection to the market. Did he ascertain if any of them had any connections to the WIV or the CCDC labs? Did any of the positive cases ride the subway, especially line 2 that goes to the WIV? Did he take into account there are no residential areas near the WIV which would bias where the infected persons lived. Did he take into account the suspicious claim made by Shi that no one in the lab was sick all winter long?
It's a pretty biased study and I don't see a lot of critical analysis of it.
For the bold, there are large files of supplementary materials which attempt to show how ascertainment bias was ruled out.
But here is one part from it...
Reported cases not directly linked to Huanan market lived significantly closer to the market than linked
cases. If cases with no identified link to Huanan market were primarily ascertained through contact
tracing of personal contacts of Huanan-linked cases (a path dependent ascertainment bias), they would be
expected to have a similar geographic distribution as cases linked to the market. On the contrary, we note
that on average they lived closer to the market (4.00 vs 5.74km, p=0.029). This pattern is thus better
explained if the primary risk factor for linked cases was their place of work, while the primary risk factor
for unlinked cases was proximity to the market and community spread starting at the market.