
Snark is not helping you.
Of course I understand the significance. People favoring the spillover hypothesis are acting like it's the smoking gun/source animal found when it is not.
Let's get a few things straight. One of reports says the positive cultures were from
a surface used to remove hair and feathers. That is not the same as "suggests raccoon dogs were present at the time when Covid-19 samples were taken".
NPR Mar 17, 2023: WHO calls on China to share data on raccoon dog link to pandemic. Here's what we knowHair/feather remover, a cart does not say raccoon dog DNA.
He didn't say which stall specifically in the article.
Now here's where the
article's information conflicts with itself:
But the caption under the images of the raccon dogs says this:
So which is it, the raccoon dogs in the images were in that specific stall or the general area of the stall?
If you've ever done geocaching you'd know the best GPS can do is the general area, close but you still have to look around for the cache.
Not that it's all that relevant.
In 2014 there were live raccoon dogs sold in or near the stall where 5 positive COVID cultures were detected.
That still leaves 2 possible scenarios, one, the source was a raccoon dog in that stall, or, two, the vendor in that stall was the super spreader who contaminated all the surfaces. Yet people are running with this as if it is a smoking gun when it isn't.
Tests in ICUs where COVID patients were cared for found positive cultures all over the place.
My point was that the raccoon dogs could not have been infected by bats also for sale at the market. It wasn't a comment about the bats infecting people.
However, the rest is all well and good but how does that provide evidence as opposed to just speculating it could explain the lack of other infected raccoon dogs?
How much of a coincidence would it be if the virus was only in one animal and that animal ended up in a Wuhan market within miles of the WIV and the other nearby labs? That's waay more of a stretch than the virus coincidentally turned up near the labs where they were studying similar viruses.
If a SARS-like coronavirus was circulating in a population of raccoon dogs why wouldn't one or more have ended up at other markets? Or ended up infecting one or more of the animal trappers? Or the transporters?
And now the data is getting misstated like a game of telephone. One source says the positive COVID cultures were combined with raccoon dog DNA. So I hunted down information closer to the source:
Science, Mar 2023: Unearthed genetic sequences from China market may point to animal origin of COVID-19But Gao is promoting the hypothesis that the virus originated outside of China. So there is this:
Which samples, which stalls, which animals specifically, what do they mean by "suggests? The graph is in the Science link with this statement:
And keep in mind these were environmental samples, not direct human or animal samples.