Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
It already is being dismissed on Twitter by the DRASTIC members and people like Richard Ebright who says "No serious person will take it seriously." He is on record calling essentially every scientist that favours a natural spillover as a "bought and paid for" "stooge".

He also says the same of the editor of Science and one of their writers Jon Cohen, who wrote this piece:



Link

I think we will have to wait and see when the researchers write up their results and to see how it does in peer review.

This is also a nice review - makes quite clear that the Chinese are trying to cover up the association with the market as the source of the animal to human jump.

https://www.science.org/content/art...d-proof-covid-19-s-origin-wuhan-animal-market
 
Last edited:
"New data links pandemic’s origins to raccoon dogs at Wuhan market
Genetic samples from the market were recently uploaded to an international database and then removed after scientists asked China about them."
NYT
(paywall)
 
It will be difficult to come to any conclusions until there is some kind of paper, such as pre-print, with the relevant data being available to those who want to evaluate this independently.

I've seen that it is not just those who argue for lab leak who are being a bit critical of the way this story has been handled.

But.... it seems it might be an attempt by some Chinese scientists to get data out that conflicts with the CCP official line of a virus that came from abroad, as well as demonstrating that wildlife was indeed in the market even if it wasn't the cause of the spillover despite Chinese authorities claims to the contrary.

So, we definitely do have evidence that China are covering up a possible wet market origin.

Link
 
Last edited:
Just as an example the Chinese do not necessarily cover up laboratory leaks.

An inadequacy in sanitizing processes in a biopharmaceutical plant in Lanzhou, China, during July and August 2019, led to the aerosolization of Brucella that was subsequently spread through wind to nearby settlements and academic institutes, resulting in >10 000 human brucellosis cases, as of November 2020. The leak, possibly the largest laboratory accident in the history of infectious diseases, underlines the particular characteristics of Brucella that have made the pathogen a historical entity in biodefense research and a major cause of laboratory-associated infections. It further underlines the need for enhanced vigilance and strict regulatory interventions in similar facilities.

https://academic.oup.com/cid/article/75/10/1845/6604450
 
"New data links pandemic’s origins to raccoon dogs at Wuhan market
Genetic samples from the market were recently uploaded to an international database and then removed after scientists asked China about them."
NYT
(paywall)

I think this is probably the same story: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/bc-as-virus-outbreak-new-data_n_6414858ee4b00c3e6073850f

Of course, scientists from the Wuhan Lab probably ate racoon dogs from the wet market and introduced it to them. (You'll hear that shortly)
 
I think this is probably the same story: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/bc-as-virus-outbreak-new-data_n_6414858ee4b00c3e6073850f

Of course, scientists from the Wuhan Lab probably ate racoon dogs from the wet market and introduced it to them. (You'll hear that shortly)

Leaked email:
“Hooray everyone! We have successfully created a pandemic-potential virus by inserting a furin cleavage site into top secret acquisition BANAL-52 and we’re going to nip down the Huanan Market for raccoon dog to celebrate! We heard there is only one left so we’ve not got time to remove our Hazmat suits. It’ll be fine!”
 
Leaked email:
“Hooray everyone! We have successfully created a pandemic-potential virus by inserting a furin cleavage site into top secret acquisition BANAL-52 and we’re going to nip down the Huanan Market for raccoon dog to celebrate! We heard there is only one left so we’ve not got time to remove our Hazmat suits. It’ll be fine!”

Thank God! We finally have the explanation for the last two years.
 
As usual, when someone starts a reply, "Are you suggesting...," you know that what's coming next is straw man. What I said is that you do not know that the intelligence services do not have people who are qualified to assess the published science.

You don't seem to understand what a strawman is. For it to be a strawman, you'd have to have a stronger version of the argument that what I presented. "you don't know that they don't" is NOT a stronger version of any argument.

Even if they do not have such scientists among their employees, they have access to every scientist in the world, including the scientists who published the work on the origin of the pandemic, with whom they can formally or informally consult.


Fat lot of good it does them if they ignore the conclusions these researchers have reached.

Well, different scientists with your "implicit knowledge and experience" have evaluated the research and arrived at different conclusions. So much for "implicit knowledge and experience." Furthermore, whatever conclusions they have come to, they have come to without the information that the intelligence services have. So they do not have the full picture.

Without the background to fully understand the science the intelligence services are missing out on far more information that the research scientists are. Unless the intelligence services accept their limitations and take the published research at face value they are missing out on far more information than the actual scientists. In such a case they can't possibly have "the full picture".
 
Last edited:
I don’t think anyone doubts this.

Lots of people have doubted it. In the thread it is sometimes assumed that the Chinese authorities would prefer it to be from a wet market than a lab, because….”face” apparently and if you disagree then “you just don’t know Chinese culture” apparently.

But beyond this thread, when papers had been written showing photographs from Holmes’s trip to the Huanan wet market and other findings about wildlife trade being in operation there, it was laughed off by the lab leak theorists who questioned the believability of the pictures or tried to suggest the pictures were from other markets or that there may have been animals there once but no evidence they were still on sale during the beginning stages of the pandemic.

In addition, we repeatedly hear about how many animals were tested and yet no trace showed up of SARS-CoV2, BUT none of the animals from the wet markets appear to have been tested. We’re raccoon dogs from Huanan tested? If not and we now might have evidence that the raccoon dogs were there, why weren’t they tested? We know, for example, that elephants at the Wuhan zoo were tested, but if you don’t look in the likely places you can’t be surprised if the evidence is missed.
 
Without the background to fully understand the science the intelligence services are missing out on far more information that the research scientists are. Unless the intelligence services accept their limitations and take the published research at face value they are missing out on far more information than the actual scientists. In such a case they can't possibly have "the full picture".


While you were preoccupied with straw-man denial, you failed to understand my point that you are just assuming they don't have the expertise to evaluate the scientific data. You don't know what expertise they have.

You're entitled to your opinion of their incompetence, even you have no competence yourself to judge it.
 
Oops. This is from a year or two ago when evidence from the wet market about live animals, particularly raccoon dogs, were being sold.

A prominent lab leaker was very busy pooh-poohing the idea that such animals could be a possible cause of a spillover event....
 

Attachments

  • Alina 1 jpeg.jpg
    Alina 1 jpeg.jpg
    76.3 KB · Views: 5
  • Alina 2 jpeg.jpg
    Alina 2 jpeg.jpg
    65.7 KB · Views: 5
  • Alina 3 jpeg.jpg
    Alina 3 jpeg.jpg
    61 KB · Views: 5
While you were preoccupied with straw-man denial, you failed to understand my point that you are just assuming they don't have the expertise to evaluate the scientific data. You don't know what expertise they have.

You're entitled to your opinion of their incompetence, even you have no competence yourself to judge it.

Now there is an example of a strawman.

What they lack is the ability to generate meaningful original counterarguments to published research. If they stick to counterarguments makes by other researchers in the peer reviewed literature they may be fine.

The problem in this case is that there is no meaningful support for a lab leak in the published literature and there is broad support for zoonotic crossover in the published literature. There is simply no justification for the intelligence community, or anyone else, rejecting the published science.
 
It was not wrong to consider the option of a laboratory leak, but to persist when all the evidence favours the more likely option of a zoonotic source and to substitute an ever more complex conspiracy involving scientists from many countries seems foolish.
 
Now there is an example of a strawman.

What they lack is the ability to generate meaningful original counterarguments to published research.

No. That's not a strawman, and you are repeating the exact same mistake that apparently you are blind to. You have no ******* idea what their capabilities are, yet you repeatedly proclaim their limitations.
 
Amanpour and Company interview with Jaimie Metzl, it's time to listen to him again.

Why the COVID-19 Lab-Leak Theory Has New Credibility and Why It Matters | Amanpour and Company -- 18 minutes




Interesting that Jamie Metzl went on CNN and Newsmax etc... to promote the lab leak theory in response to the Department of Energy announcing that they had low confidence in the theory using data not publicly available.

Of course, the same Jamie Metzl, responds to the news about the raccoon dog DNA like this....

[QUOTE_"Jamie Metzl"]Although I believe #COVID19 most likely stems from an accidental research-related incident in Wuhan, I have an open mind on the pandemic origins issue. The recent media manipulation campaign focused around inaccessible new data has not moved the needle for me.[/QUOTE]

Link
 
Link


The researchers caution that it is not conclusive evidence, but it is suggestive, that animals passed on the virus. However, it is not clear that the raccoon dogs are the intermediary species. Anyway, it could be an important finding. Could be...
I'm surprised you aren't running to the bank with this latest news headline.

For the record those pics of the raccoon dogs being for sale at the market (in the past but likely also in late 2019) is not a new revelation. Also it's not new that the Chinese claimed to have 5 or so positive cultures from that one vendor stall at the market. I'm not sure how long ago I read that but it was more than a week ago.

The problem still remains, where was that COVID or COVID-similar virus circulating in raccoon dogs before they reached the market? All of the positive findings are explained by one super-spreader vendor in that stall getting infected by a customer.

It has already been determined live bats were not for sale at the market and those particular coronavirus carrying bats are not commonly eaten by the residents of Wuhan.
 
I just found the report. It will be dismissed out of hand by some here, but this looks promising.
No one is dismissing it out of hand. The question is no different, where is the evidence said animal got infected before arriving at the market? Why is there no trail or source of that animal infection except the vendor themself being the source of the positive cultures in the stall?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom