Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
One very interesting point was that a laboratory cover up would have required a time machine. Until the outbreak of pneumonia of unknown cause in Wuhan was identified as being due to a novel coronavirus there would have been no need to conceal any research. So conference proceedings, email exchanges, papers submitted would have reflected activity up to that point. Papers comparing features of isolated bat coronaviruses would have no reason not to include a virus that would leak in future. Yet papers in progress now published show no evidence of any virus or any research that could have led to SARS-CoV-2.
There are a number of published papers by Shi and others before Dec 2019 that reveal all sorts of things including how COVID could have happened. You seem very late to the party here.
 
This appears to be an essentially data free publication.
:boggled:

From the abstract:
... According to municipal reports and the testimonies of 31 residents and 28 visitors, the bat was never a food source in the city, and no bat was traded in the market. There was possible natural recombination or intermediate host of the coronavirus, yet little proof has been reported. Was there any other possible pathway? We screened the area around the seafood market and identified two laboratories conducting research on bat coronavirus. Within ~280 meters from the market, there was the Wuhan Center for Disease Control & Prevention (WHCDC) (Figure 1, from Baidu and Google maps). WHCDC hosted animals in laboratories for research purpose, one of which was specialized in pathogens collection and identification 4-6. In one of their studies, 155 bats including Rhinolophus affinis were captured in Hubei province, and other 450 bats were captured in Zhejiang province 4. The expert in collection was noted in the Author Contributions (JHT). ...
What kind of 'data' were you expecting to find?
 
:boggled:

From the abstract:

What kind of 'data' were you expecting to find?

More than gossip and a google map! How did they select the informants? How representative were they of the local population? What is the gender, age social class, break down of their informants? How did they elicit the information, did they carry out a semi-structured interview or was it a standardised questionnaire? Did they attempt to report on research being carried out in 2019, or just research published in 2013?

If an undergraduate student presented this to me as 'research' I would fail them.
 
More than gossip and a google map! How did they select the informants? How representative were they of the local population? What is the gender, age social class, break down of their informants? How did they elicit the information, did they carry out a semi-structured interview or was it a standardised questionnaire? Did they attempt to report on research being carried out in 2019, or just research published in 2013?

If an undergraduate student presented this to me as 'research' I would fail them.
Well it wasn't a student presenting "research" now was it. :rolleyes:

As for the demographics of those earliest patients, China won't release that information. This paper was written in Feb 2020 shortly after the pandemic started. There was then ongoing data collection on patients presenting to hospitals in Wuhan.

Huang C, Wang Y, Li X, et al. Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novel coronavirus in Wuhan, China. The Lancet 2019. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30183-5.

Methods
All patients with suspected 2019-nCoV were admitted to a designated hospital in Wuhan. We prospectively collected and analysed data on patients with laboratory-confirmed 2019-nCoV infection by real-time RT-PCR and next-generation sequencing. Data were obtained with standardised data collection forms shared by WHO and the International Severe Acute Respiratory and Emerging Infection Consortium from electronic medical records. Researchers also directly communicated with patients or their families to ascertain epidemiological and symptom data. Outcomes were also compared between patients who had been admitted to the intensive care unit (ICU) and those who had not.

Most of the infected patients were men (30 [73%] of 41); less than half had underlying diseases (13 [32%]), including diabetes (eight [20%]), hypertension (six [15%]), and cardiovascular disease (six [15%]). Median age was 49·0 years (IQR 41·0–58·0). 27 (66%) of 41 patients had been exposed to Huanan seafood market. One family cluster was found. Common symptoms at onset of illness were fever (40 [98%] of 41 patients), cough (31 [76%]), and myalgia or fatigue (18 [44%]); less common symptoms were sputum production (11 [28%] of 39), headache (three [8%] of 38), haemoptysis (two [5%] of 39), and diarrhoea (one [3%] of 38). Dyspnoea developed in 22 (55%) of 40 patients (median time from illness onset to dyspnoea 8·0 days [IQR 5·0–13·0]). 26 (63%) of 41 patients had lymphopenia. All 41 patients had pneumonia with abnormal findings on chest CT. Complications included acute respiratory distress syndrome (12 [29%]), RNAaemia (six [15%]), acute cardiac injury (five [12%]) and secondary infection (four [10%]). 13 (32%) patients were admitted to an ICU and six (15%) died. Compared with non-ICU patients, ICU patients had higher plasma levels of IL2, IL7, IL10, GSCF, IP10, MCP1, MIP1A, and TNFα.

If that's the kind of data you are looking for, you need to check the supporting citations.
 
Plaingale was clearly asking about "testimonies of 31 residents and 28 visitors" etc (sources of data in the paper being discussed) and not about patient data that has not been released.
 
Well it wasn't a student presenting "research" now was it. :rolleyes:

As for the demographics of those earliest patients, China won't release that information. This paper was written in Feb 2020 shortly after the pandemic started. There was then ongoing data collection on patients presenting to hospitals in Wuhan.

Huang C, Wang Y, Li X, et al. Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novel coronavirus in Wuhan, China. The Lancet 2019. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30183-5.


If that's the kind of data you are looking for, you need to check the supporting citations.

That seems like a lot of demographic data on the earliest know cases. I fail to see how linking to this information supports your insistence that China won't release this information.
 
From patient zero to 1,000 infections in three weeks with 13 variants would be very difficult math.

Nobody knows who patient zero is. The papers by Worobey et. al only talk of the first 174 known cases. It is unreasonable to expect them to look at unknown cases as well.

Early cases lived near to and centered on the Huanan market
The 2021 WHO mission report identified 174 COVID-19 cases in Hubei Province in December 2019 after careful examination of reported case histories (7). Although geographical coordinates of the residential locations of the 164 cases who lived within Wuhan were unavailable, we were able to reliably extract the latitude and longitude coordinates of 155 cases from maps in the report (figs. S1 to S8).
Although early COVID-19 cases occurred across Wuhan, most clustered in central Wuhan near the west bank of the Yangtze River, with a high density of cases near to, and surrounding, the Huanan market (Fig. 1A). We used a kernel density estimate (KDE) to reconstruct an underlying probability density function from which the home locations for each case were drawn (25). Using all 155 of the December 2019 cases, the location of the Huanan market lies within the highest density contour that contains 1% of the probability mass (Fig. 1B). For a KDE estimated using the 120 cases with no known linkage to the market, the market remains within the highest density 1% contour (Fig. 1C). The clustering of COVID-19 cases in December around the Huanan market (Fig. 1, B and C, insets) contrasts with the pattern of widely dispersed cases across Wuhan by early January through mid-February 2020 (Fig. 1, D and E), which we mapped using location data from individuals who had used a COVID-19 assistance channel on Sina Weibo, a Chinese social media platform (26). Weibo-based data analyses showed that, unlike early COVID-19 cases, by January and February, many of the sick individuals who sought help resided in highly populated areas of the city, particularly in areas with a high density of older people (Fig. 1E and figs. S9 and S10).
 

This appears to be an essentially data free publication.

:boggled:

From the abstract:

What kind of 'data' were you expecting to find?

More than gossip and a google map! How did they select the informants? How representative were they of the local population? What is the gender, age social class, break down of their informants? How did they elicit the information, did they carry out a semi-structured interview or was it a standardised questionnaire? Did they attempt to report on research being carried out in 2019, or just research published in 2013?

If an undergraduate student presented this to me as 'research' I would fail them.

Well it wasn't a student presenting "research" now was it. :rolleyes:

As for the demographics of those earliest patients, China won't release that information. This paper was written in Feb 2020 shortly after the pandemic started. There was then ongoing data collection on patients presenting to hospitals in Wuhan.

Huang C, Wang Y, Li X, et al. Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novel coronavirus in Wuhan, China. The Lancet 2019. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30183-5.





If that's the kind of data you are looking for, you need to check the supporting citations.

No, that is NOT how research works. You cannot just cite a bunch of studies and say that your research now has data. Anyone can cite studies.

By the way, I notice that the paper Sherkeu links to has literally ZERO citations of its own.

BUT.... one of the papers you linked to says this...

By Jan 2, 2020, 41 admitted hospital patients had been identified as having laboratory-confirmed 2019-nCoV infection. Most of the infected patients were men (30 [73%] of 41); less than half had underlying diseases (13 [32%]), including diabetes (eight [20%]), hypertension (six [15%]), and cardiovascular disease (six [15%]). Median age was 49·0 years (IQR 41·0–58·0). 27 (66%) of 41 patients had been exposed to Huanan seafood market.

Worobey et. al say....

Of the initial 41 people hospitalized with unknown pneumonia by 2 January 2020, 27 (66%) had direct exposure to the Huanan Wholesale Seafood Market (hereafter, “Huanan market”) (2, 5, 6). These first cases were confirmed to be infected with a novel coronavirus, subsequently named severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2), and were suffering from a disease later named coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). The initial diagnoses of COVID-19 were made in several hospitals independently between 18 and 29 December 2019 (5). These early reports were free from ascertainment bias because they were based on signs and symptoms before the Huanan market was identified as a shared risk factor (5).
 

I don't know why you would hang your hat on a "paper" like this....


The expert in collectionwas noted in the Author Contributions (JHT). Moreover, he was broadcasted for collectingviruses on nation-wide newspapers and websites in 2017 and 2019 7,8. He described thathe was once by attacked by bats and the blood of a bat shot on his skin. He knew theextreme danger of the infection so he quarantined himself for 14 days 7. In another accident,he quarantined himself again because bats peed on him. He was once thrilled for capturinga bat carrying a live tick 8

(10) (PDF) The possible origins of 2019-nCoV coronavirus. Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/360910691_The_possible_origins_of_2019-nCoV_coronavirus [accessed Mar 17 2023].

TheWHCDC was also adjacent to the Union Hospital (Figure 1, bottom) where the first groupof doctors were infected during this epidemic. It is plausible that the virus leaked around and some of them contaminated the initial patients in this epidemic, though solid proofs are needed in future study
(10) (PDF) The possible origins of 2019-nCoV coronavirus. Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/360910691_The_possible_origins_of_2019-nCoV_coronavirus [accessed Mar 17 2023].

I look forward to "solid proofs" about the plausibility of the virus that "leaked around".

The article itself, only a few hundred words at most, only says there is speculation about the virus having leaked from a lab. But it is indeed completely free of any other data. The papers it cites only underlines the likelihood that it emerged from the seafood market.
 
That seems like a lot of demographic data on the earliest know cases. I fail to see how linking to this information supports your insistence that China won't release this information.
Those are not the earliest recognized cases which BTW we know about because it was before China stopped sharing data.

We know about the cases. We don't know their demographics and where they were likely exposed. We do know it is unlikely they were exposed at the wet market.

Of course there are conflicting reports about patient zero (who may not have been patient zero after all).

https://www.livescience.com/first-case-coronavirus-found.html
A 55-year-old individual from Hubei province in China may have been the first person to have contracted COVID-19, the disease caused by the new coronavirus spreading across the globe. That case dates back to Nov. 17, 2019, according to the South China Morning Post. ...

That's more than a month earlier than doctors noted cases in Wuhan, China, which is in Hubei province, at the end of December 2019. At the time, authorities suspected the virus stemmed from something sold at a wet market in the city. However, it's now clear that early in what is now a pandemic..., some infected people had no connection to the market. That included one of the earliest cases from Dec. 1, 2019 in an individual who had no link to that seafood market, researchers reported Jan. 20 in the journal The Lancet. ...

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2...ent-in-wuhan-was-at-animal-market-study-finds
The first known Covid-19 case was a vendor at the live-animal market in Wuhan, according to a scientist who has scrutinised public accounts of the earliest cases in China.

The chronology is at odds with a timeline laid out in an influential World Health Organization (WHO) report, which suggested an accountant with no apparent link to the Hunan market was the first known case.
That's from Worobey who ignored data that didn't fit his outcome.


Frontline: A Timeline of China’s Response in the First Days of COVID-19
DECEMBER 1, 2019 A man in his 70s starts experiencing symptoms. He is later admitted to a hospital in Wuhan, China.

MID-DECEMBER, 2019 People begin turning up at hospitals in Wuhan with strange white spots on their lung scans. Many of the cases are traced back to the city’s Huanan Seafood Market, where a variety of live animals are sold. Whether the market is where the virus first leapt from animals to humans is unknown.

DECEMBER 24, 2019 A sample is taken from a Wuhan Central Hospital patient’s lungs and sent to Vision Medicals, a private company 500 miles from Wuhan that produces a partial genetic sequence of the virus within 48 hours. ...

DECEMBER 30, 2019 Around this time, hospitals in Wuhan start seeing dozens of patients with severe pneumonia.

More virus samples are sent to other labs for sequencing. One lab tells Wuhan Central Hospital, mistakenly, that the virus is SARS itself. The lab’s results circulate quickly among the doctors and reach Li Wenliang, an ophthalmologist.

Li forwards a message to a group of doctors with a warning: “Don’t circulate this information outside the group, tell your family and loved ones to take precautions.”

His message goes viral.

The local health commission orders Wuhan hospitals to report new cases directly to them and bars the release of information to the public. The orders leak and spread online.

This is when Promed publishes its first account of what is going on.
The World Health Organization learns about the outbreak from social media and from Promed, not from the Chinese government.

At this point China is insisting everything is under control. Dr Li is warned and told to sign a statement he was wrong to be causing trouble.

A woman travels to Thailand with an active infection.
Publicly, the Chinese government has been saying the outbreak is linked to the Huanan Seafood Market. When Thai health officials talk to the woman, they find that she has had no contact with the market.

“That is really the critical information for us, that the spreading may be generalized in Wuhan,” says Rome Buathong of Thailand’s ministry of public health.

And as is typical for a face-saving culture:
JANUARY 11, 2020 A representative of the WHO says on Chinese state TV: “It appears that … new cases have stopped after the market was temporarily closed. So the public health intervention has controlled this part of the outbreak. And we can see that there is no clear evidence of sustained human-to-human transmission, which gives us a lot of reassurance.”

The representative praises the “sheer speed of the response in China” and “the extremely rapid investigation.”

Then the severe cases in Wuhan explode:
MID-JANUARY, 2020 Wuhan hospitals are treating hundreds of patients with respiratory symptoms. The health care worker at Wuhan Central Hospital says: “Every day there were several hundred people with fever arriving at our emergency department. Hundreds every day. I was definitely afraid. I realized that this illness was everywhere.”

Patients begin to die.

Local and provincial authorities only count cases linked directly to the Huanan market, according to leaked documents. And only they are authorized to confirm cases, not doctors.
Now why is that? And why has Worobey backed this disinformation up?

And not until mid-Jan did cases start spreading outside of Wuhan to other parts of China.
JANUARY 19, 2020 Outbreaks appear in other parts of China. Despite the Chinese government’s internal warnings to health officials about a potential pandemic, there is no public lockdown as millions of Chinese prepare to travel for Lunar New Year.
IOW, Wuhan was the center of the pandemic and it is not a clearly supportable conclusion that patient zero was a vendor at the market.
 
IOW, Wuhan was the center of the pandemic and it is not a clearly supportable conclusion that patient zero was a vendor at the market.
Therefore there is only one possible conclusion - lab leak!

I don't know why you would hang your hat on a "paper" like this....
Nobody should be 'hanging their hat' on anything - yet here we are...
 
Are you suggesting analysts at intelligence agencies sideline as full time researches in virology? That seems like a rather extraordinary claim.

As usual, when someone starts a reply, "Are you suggesting...," you know that what's coming next is straw man. What I said is that you do not know that the intelligence services do not have people who are qualified to assess the published science. Even if they do not have such scientists among their employees, they have access to every scientist in the world, including the scientists who published the work on the origin of the pandemic, with whom they can formally or informally consult.

Differing opinions in the published science is why you need all the implicit knowledge and experience actual researchers in the field possess. It takes that experience to see where papers have gone wrong, where they can be improved and what they have right.

Well, different scientists with your "implicit knowledge and experience" have evaluated the research and arrived at different conclusions. So much for "implicit knowledge and experience." Furthermore, whatever conclusions they have come to, they have come to without the information that the intelligence services have. So they do not have the full picture.
 
That's from Worobey who ignored data that didn't fit his outcome.

No, he doesn't ignore data that doesn't fit his outcome. I think we have been through this many times with you making casual assertions of researcher malpractice, but Worobey clearly identifies areas where things are unclear. For example...

the earliest known cases should not necessarily be expected to be the first infected or linked to Huanan Market: They probably postdated the outbreak’s index case by a considerable period (10). Moreover, only ∼7% of SARS-CoV-2 infections lead to hospitalization (11); most fly under the radar. Similarly, it is entirely expected that early, ascertained cases from a seafood market would be workers who were not necessarily directly associated with wildlife sales once the outbreak began spreading from human to human. The index case was most likely one of the ∼93% who never required hospitalization and indeed could have been any of hundreds of workers who had even brief contact with infected live mammals.
Crucially, however, the now famous “earliest” COVID-19 case (1), a 41-year-old male accountant, who lived 30 km south of Huanan Market and had no connection to it—illness onset reported as 8 December—may have become ill with COVID-19 considerably later (12). When interviewed, he reported that his COVID-19 symptoms started with a fever on 16 December. This is corroborated by hospital records and a scientific paper that reports his COVID-19 onset date as 16 December and date of hospitalization as 22 December (see fig. S1). This suggests that he may have been infected through community transmission after the virus had begun spreading from Huanan Market.

Link

That December 1st case which was claimed to initially be the first known case seems not to have had Covid until later.

As for those November cases that you mention, it is hard to come to strong conclusions about them if we know so little.
 
One very interesting point was that a laboratory cover up would have required a time machine. Until the outbreak of pneumonia of unknown cause in Wuhan was identified as being due to a novel coronavirus there would have been no need to conceal any research. So conference proceedings, email exchanges, papers submitted would have reflected activity up to that point. Papers comparing features of isolated bat coronaviruses would have no reason not to include a virus that would leak in future. Yet papers in progress now published show no evidence of any virus or any research that could have led to SARS-CoV-2.

A similar point that Eddie Holmes brought up was that if the Huanan Seafood Market was merely the site of the biggest superspreader event, then you could also say "What a coincidence!" that of all the places that the lab leak could have been magnified it just so happened to look like it did so at the exact place you would expect a SARS-like virus to emerge.
 
This week, an international team of virologists, genomicists, and evolutionary biologists may have finally found crucial data to help fill that knowledge gap. A new analysis of genetic sequences collected from the market shows that raccoon dogs being illegally sold at the venue could have been carrying and possibly shedding the virus at the end of 2019...

The genetic sequences were pulled out of swabs taken in and near market stalls around the pandemic’s start. They represent the first bits of raw data that researchers outside of China’s academic institutions and their direct collaborators have had access to. Late last week, the data were quietly posted by researchers affiliated with the country’s Center for Disease Control and Prevention, on an open-access genomic database called GISAID. By almost pure happenstance, scientists in Europe, North America, and Australia spotted the sequences, downloaded them, and began an analysis.

The samples were already known to be positive for the coronavirus, and had been scrutinized before by the same group of Chinese researchers who uploaded the data to GISAID. But that prior analysis, released as a preprint publication in February 2022, asserted that “no animal host of SARS-CoV-2 can be deduced.” Any motes of coronavirus at the market, the study suggested, had most likely been chauffeured in by infected humans, rather than wild creatures for sale.

The new analysis, led by Kristian Andersen, Edward Holmes, and Michael Worobey—three prominent researchers who have been looking into the virus’s roots—shows that that may not be the case. Within about half a day of downloading the data from GISAID, the trio and their collaborators discovered that several market samples that tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 were also coming back chock-full of animal genetic material—much of which was a match for the common raccoon dog. Because of how the samples were gathered, and because viruses can’t persist by themselves in the environment, the scientists think that their findings could indicate the presence of a coronavirus-infected raccoon dog in the spots where the swabs were taken.

Link


The researchers caution that it is not conclusive evidence, but it is suggestive, that animals passed on the virus. However, it is not clear that the raccoon dogs are the intermediary species. Anyway, it could be an important finding. Could be...
 
Link


The researchers caution that it is not conclusive evidence, but it is suggestive, that animals passed on the virus. However, it is not clear that the raccoon dogs are the intermediary species. Anyway, it could be an important finding. Could be...

I just found the report. It will be dismissed out of hand by some here, but this looks promising.
 
I think a lot of people reason like Nate Silver does here:

Nate Silver said:
Yeah, I see it as a question of statistical inference or probabilistic reasoning for which the evidence comes in a variety of forms. For instance, China's lack of transparency probably ought to affect your estimate of P(LabLeak) even if it isn't an issue of the science per se.

Link

Does China's behaviour lead to a greater chance that the lab leak is likelier than spillover?

YES: Lab leak is the ONE thing that China would not accept/admit.

OR...

NO: Lab leak or a wet market spillover are the TWO things that China would not accept/admit.

We know this because China have tried to cover up natural viruses before:

Peter Jacobs said:
China didn't just try to cover up SARS classic in 2003, it covered up TWO other zoonotic outbreaks in 2019! not including SARS-CoV-2! A pneumonic plague outbreak and an influenza (non-SC2 related), which actually was in Hubei before and during the pandemic.

Link

Also...

everythingism said:
Did you see this story about SARS-1 outbreak? It alleges that Chinese officials drove some of the SARS patients around in ambulances for the duration of the WHO visit in order to hide them.

Link

BEIJING, China -- Beijing authorities have gone to staggering lengths to hide SARS patients from visiting World Health Organization (WHO) inspectors, according to TIME magazine.

At one of the most reputable of the city's hospitals, 31 patients suffering the potentially lethal disease were driven around in ambulances for the duration of the WHO visit, said TIME.

And at a military hospital, 40 SARS patients were said to have been moved to a hotel for the duration of the WHO tour, in an apparent attempt to deceive inspectors about the true extent of the outbreak.

The timing of the revelations could prove a major embarrassment to the Chinese government.

CNN Link from 2003

After SARS, you can imagine how much of an embarrassment/shame it would be if yet another deadly virus "SARS 2" no less, erupted from a wet market where officially no animals were being kept.

Covering up a wet market spillover would be, as Skeptic Ginger likes to say, what you might expect from a "face-saving culture".
 
I just found the report. It will be dismissed out of hand by some here, but this looks promising.

It already is being dismissed on Twitter by the DRASTIC members and people like Richard Ebright who says "No serious person will take it seriously." He is on record calling essentially every scientist that favours a natural spillover as a "bought and paid for" "stooge".

He also says the same of the editor of Science and one of their writers Jon Cohen, who wrote this piece:

A scientific sleuth in France has identified previously undisclosed genetic data from a food market in Wuhan, China, that she and colleagues say support the theory that coronavirus-infected animals there triggered the COVID-19 pandemic. Several of the researchers presented their findings on Tuesday to the Scientific Advisory Group for the Origins of Novel Pathogens (SAGO), an expert group convened last year by the World Health Organization.

“The data does point even further to a market origin,” says Kristian Andersen, an evolutionary biologist at Scripps Research who attended the meeting and is one of the scientists analyzing the new data. If so, the findings weaken the view of a vocal minority that a virology lab in Wuhan was the likely origin of SARS-CoV-2, perhaps when the coronavirus infected a lab worker, who spread it further.

Florence Débarre, a theoretician who specializes in evolutionary biology and works at the French National Centre for Scientific Research, unearthed the data, which consists of genetic sequences posted in GISAID, a virology database, by Chinese researchers. The Chinese team had collected environmental samples from the Huanan Seafood Market, which was connected to a cluster of early COVID-19 cases and despite its name also sold a variety of mammals for food. Since Débarre spotted the sequences, GISAID has removed them, noting that this was at the request of the submitter.

Link

I think we will have to wait and see when the researchers write up their results and to see how it does in peer review.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom