Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nonsense.

What's nonsense is thinking that the intelligence community is qualified to offer original criticism of peer reviewed science. The only way the intelligence community could reach a conclusion counter to what's in the published science is if they are discarding the science and is therefor working with only a tiny fraction of the available information.

As soon as the intelligence community deviates from the published science they are working from a much smaller base of information and this makes their conclusion highly error prone.
 
A laboratory leak would be an error by an individual, or a technical failure of equipment. It does not reflect on the CCP. Whereas regulation of the wet market and enforcing hygeine regulations is the responsibility of the local party. It is directly a failure of part of the CCP.

Though I agree that China would prefer neither option was true.

Yes, China will obfuscate and deny and deny and deny...and any new data will be meant to just confuse the issue.

But lab leak (aka 'community viral escape directly related to scientific research') is NOT preferable to blaming an unlawful wet market.

The Lab, the Science, the Elite International Collaboration, the State-of the-Art Equipment... it is a very sought after and calculated status symbol of China as a premier global player- even if some of it is a lie.
Top Tier, the most, the best, the first, etc...

"Lab leak" would be a very BIG deal. Still, most of the propaganda we hear over in western countries is really meant for China's own people internally.
 
Last edited:
What's nonsense is thinking that the intelligence community is qualified to offer original criticism of peer reviewed science.

You don't know that they are not.

The only way the intelligence community could reach a conclusion counter to what's in the published science is if they are discarding the science and is therefor working with only a tiny fraction of the available information.

The published science is itself full of contradictory information.
 
The paper you linked doesn't show that human exposure happened that early. It says that is the time the MRCA existed. Multiple papers since this one was published have shown that there were more than one crossover event. This means the MRCA must have existed before these jumps to the human population occurred.

The MRCA in this cases is going to be the ancestor of all the separate jumps into the human population and would have never have circulated in humans. Circulation in the human population would have only occurred after the first lineages diverged. The first human infections would therefor have likely been early Nov not Mid Sep - Oct when the MRCA was circulating in it's animal host.

1000 cases would represent about 7 generations of a virus with an R of 2.5. That would seem to point to crossover dates being in early Nov rather then Sep or Oct.
The MRCA referred to in the TopHap study is strictly from human coronaviruses they mapped.

You need to cite something from one of my links instead of doing your own math on the "7 generations" and the "R of 2.5" because those numbers are unsupported.


There was a hypothetical assertion that these crossovers are common and most burn out. The basis for the hypothesis was some blood studies in the areas where bats live that harbor coronaviruses. That's a very long way from Wuhan and it wasn't directly connected to the COVID pandemic.

If you are going to imagine a spillover not coming from the seafood market you need a source and some evidence. Just saying it could have happened is where you start but that goes nowhere without some evidence.

The 13 variants were from human cases. No precursor cases have been found circulating among nonhumans. And were said hypothesis you are suggesting true, why would all the cases cluster around Wuhan?
 
Last edited:
What we see is that early on senior scientists were considering all (reasonable) origin theories. The natural spill over theory required that early cases were (mostly) associated with an area of animal contact. That closely related viruses are found in nature. Both of which have been found to be the case. This is good science.

The laboratory leak theory should have been able to show early cases associated with the laboratory and a closely related virus to be present in the laboratory - neither of which have been demonstrated.

The laboratory leak theory constantly shifts; was it due to mine workers, was it virus hunters, was it gain of function research, was it a result of serial passage, was it genetically engineered. (We will leave aside theories about NWO, Gates, etc. that unfortunately poison the discourse.) These have failed to gain evidence with time, indeed the closer any particular detailed is studied the weaker the evidence becomes.
 
Because TopHap uses a much larger genomic database.

Okay, that seems reasonable. It seems that they used "outgroups", including that of RaTG13, to determine the expected speed of mutation of the virus, as well as genomes from SARS-CoV2 including that of RaTG13.

Three outgroup coronavirus genomes were added to the alignment: Rhinolophus affinis (RaTG13) and Rhinolophus malayanus (RmYN02) bats and the Manis javanica pangolin (MT040335) (Liu et al., 2020; Zhou et al., 2020). Following the above procedure, we also assembled a bigger dataset containing 1,106,862 genomes (hereafter 1MG) from the GISAID database covering the period from December 24, 2019 to September 11, 2021.

What do you make of Pekar et.al.'s reasons for rejecting that analysis?
 
Last edited:
:confused:

Are you not reading my posts?

The earliest cases we know of are from December 2019. There are potential posited earlier cases that everyone acknowledges, but there are no known diagnoses of Covid prior to the December 2019 cases.

Are you taking an assumption for a fact?

Oh, while we are at it, I asked you earlier to substantiate your claim that three workers from the WIV:

a) got sick in September 2019
b) had pneumonia.

This was news to me, because although there was discussion about WIV workers being ill, there had been few specifics, and I certainly don't remember September 2019 or pneumonia.

I know you said you were not feeling well, but I am assuming your most recent activity here suggests you might be feeling better and now able to remember where you read this last time. However, to put my cards on the table, I think you misremembered it and that not even the well-known lab leakers have claimed this.
 
Just wondered if anyone was interested in these podcasts in which, first, a lab leak theory is sketched out by Alina Chan and Matt Ridley to Sam Harris, and then Kristian Andersen, Eddie Holmes and Michael Worobey explain why they see spillover as a much more likely origin of Covid, on the Decoding the Gurus podcast. I think for those who are on the fence would do well to listen to both arguments.

For what it is worth, Alina Chan and Matt Ridley essentially make the claim, on Sam Harris's podcast, that yes, the whole of the science establishment or biotechnology in particular seems to have some kind of institutional rot at its core.



So this is them putting forward their theory, and some people may find it persuasive. But if you do listen to it, then I think you should also listen to this podcast episode which is more or less a response to the Sam Harris podcast episode with Chan and Ridley, where Andersen, Worobey and Holmes come on to argue their case.

If you would prefer to get the preambles and the intros by the hosts out of the way, skip to here.


I think it would be a good idea to listen to both.
 
I listened to both, a bit slow in parts could of done with editing down. It left me more convinced that there was low probability of a lab leak, and high probability of a zoonotic spill over at the Wuhan wet market.
 
I listened to both, a bit slow in parts could of done with editing down. It left me more convinced that there was low probability of a lab leak, and high probability of a zoonotic spill over at the Wuhan wet market.

Glad that you gave them a listen. I think I arrived at a similar conclusion.
 
You don't know that they are not.

Are you suggesting analysts at intelligence agencies sideline as full time researches in virology? That seems like a rather extraordinary claim.

The published science is itself full of contradictory information.

In general that's true in most scientific research, though in this case the weight of the published science is overwhelmingly on the side of zoonotic crossover.

Differing opinions in the published science is why you need all the implicit knowledge and experience actual researchers in the field possess. It takes that experience to see where papers have gone wrong, where they can be improved and what they have right.

For the rest of us we pretty much need to follow the responses to the papers to figure this out which is why citations are so important. If other researches build on it, it's likely solid science, if other researches ignore it or refute it, it probably is not.
 
The MRCA referred to in the TopHap study is strictly from human coronaviruses they mapped.

So? When there are multiple crossover events the MRCA isn't going to be a human virus. The ancestor of the viruses involved in the 2+ different crossover events would never have circulated in the human population.


You need to cite something from one of my links instead of doing your own math on the "7 generations" and the "R of 2.5" because those numbers are unsupported.

The estimated R of 2.5 the original virus was heavily used, I'm not going to chase around links for such basic information for you. 7 generations is some basic math based on the definition of R. It's a rough estimate to be sure, but it lines up with the most common published estimates for the first human cases.
 
(Sorry AS, my reply to the WIV staff having pneumonia in Sept is in the queue) First things first. I posted this before about earlier cases of COVID in Wuhan before Dec 2019. Here it is again:

https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/14/health/who-mission-china-intl/index.html
The WHO food safety specialist added the team had been presented by Chinese scientists with 174 cases of coronavirus in and around Wuhan in December 2019. Of these 100 had been confirmed by laboratory tests, he said, and another 74 through the clinical diagnosis of the patient’s symptoms.
You don't get 174 severe cases in Dec 2019 unless the cases started accumulating before Dec. China was not testing everyone at that time.

This would have been cases presenting to hospitals that were "noticed" by doctors.

Ben Embarek said it was possible this larger number – of likely severe cases that had been noticed by Chinese doctors early on – meant the disease could have hit an estimated 1,000-plus people in Wuhan that December.
From a single introduction and a super-spreader event at the market?

Initially there was a claim by the Chinese and pro-spillover proponents that a second market was involved. That was because 2 lineages were found. The market was never named. There might have been a claim of some sewage testing positive, I have a vague recollection of that.

But it looks like there were 13 documented variants already in Wuhan in Dec 2019. So where did all these variants come from? From that same single patient zero on Dec 8th? Or from that patient plus one more vaguely identified patient 0.1? In 3 weeks?

You all want to claim without a shred of intermediate-species evidence that all these human strains really represented multiple spillover events, or as was suggested well up-thread, COVID doesn't need to adapt as it is a "generalist" as Planigale revisited even though that hypothesis was dismissed months ago.

Genetic evidence is not subject to bias though interpretation of that evidence is. And when researchers really really really don't want to find out the lab was the source of a deadly pandemic ... there is a lot of bias there.

Next post is about that bias so don't anyone go claiming it's about a CT. What I'm going to post is well documented. Feel free of course to counter the evidence, but this is about bias not some CT.
 
Glad that you gave them a listen. I think I arrived at a similar conclusion.

One very interesting point was that a laboratory cover up would have required a time machine. Until the outbreak of pneumonia of unknown cause in Wuhan was identified as being due to a novel coronavirus there would have been no need to conceal any research. So conference proceedings, email exchanges, papers submitted would have reflected activity up to that point. Papers comparing features of isolated bat coronaviruses would have no reason not to include a virus that would leak in future. Yet papers in progress now published show no evidence of any virus or any research that could have led to SARS-CoV-2.
 
One very interesting point was that a laboratory cover up would have required a time machine. Until the outbreak of pneumonia of unknown cause in Wuhan was identified as being due to a novel coronavirus there would have been no need to conceal any research. So conference proceedings, email exchanges, papers submitted would have reflected activity up to that point. Papers comparing features of isolated bat coronaviruses would have no reason not to include a virus that would leak in future. Yet papers in progress now published show no evidence of any virus or any research that could have led to SARS-CoV-2.

Do you really believe there is no evidence of people in China and elsewhere talking about a unique pneumonia in late 2019?

Among them there was a married couple of scientists, early on, in Wuhan that did write a paper, looking at the likely origins, and were promptly quashed- along with many others. Xiao and Xiao.
 
One very interesting point was that a laboratory cover up would have required a time machine. Until the outbreak of pneumonia of unknown cause in Wuhan was identified as being due to a novel coronavirus there would have been no need to conceal any research. So conference proceedings, email exchanges, papers submitted would have reflected activity up to that point. Papers comparing features of isolated bat coronaviruses would have no reason not to include a virus that would leak in future. Yet papers in progress now published show no evidence of any virus or any research that could have led to SARS-CoV-2.

Yea, that included the genomes whose appearance on GenBank had been embargoed while the paper was in progress four years ago that appeared recently including RaTG13 but nothing closer to SARS-CoV2.

It’s a little bit like the Zapruder film being released and now certain people asking where the missing frames are.

A similar thing happened when Worobey wanted to see some the supplemental data for one of Zhengli Shi’a papers on RaTG13 worrying that one of eight sequences referred to might have been the progenitor virus and then, once released and shown that it wasn’t there he changed his mind from being lab-leak friendly to thinking zoonosis was now most likely.

Indeed, the apparent tell-tale signs were not there.

Of course, the lab leakers argue it could be in an online database but that went offline before there was any sign of Covid (although this is why some of the lab leakers favour the idea of sick WIV workers and phylogenetic estimates that put the emergence in September).
 
Do you really believe there is no evidence of people in China and elsewhere talking about a unique pneumonia in late 2019?

Among them there was a married couple of scientists, early on, in Wuhan that did write a paper, looking at the likely origins, and were promptly quashed- along with many others. Xiao and Xiao.

Could you link to the paper please?
 
(Sorry AS, my reply to the WIV staff having pneumonia in Sept is in the queue) First things first. I posted this before about earlier cases of COVID in Wuhan before Dec 2019. Here it is again:

https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/14/health/who-mission-china-intl/index.html
You don't get 174 severe cases in Dec 2019 unless the cases started accumulating before Dec. China was not testing everyone at that time.

This would have been cases presenting to hospitals that were "noticed" by doctors.

From a single introduction and a super-spreader event at the market?

This is how exponential growth works. There is no evidence of a super spread event. It was normal exponential growth of an infection in a densely populated urban area. This is how epidemics work. Assume 1 case infects three people on average every four days - which is roughly what early figures suggest. day 1 - 1 person, day 4 - 3 people, day 8 - 9 people, day 12 - 27 people, day 16 - 81 people, day 20 - 243 people, day 24 - 729 people, day 28 - 2187 people, day 32 - 6361. One person at the beginning of December and six thousand at the end of December with no super spreader event.

Initially there was a claim by the Chinese and pro-spillover proponents that a second market was involved. That was because 2 lineages were found. The market was never named. There might have been a claim of some sewage testing positive, I have a vague recollection of that.

But it looks like there were 13 documented variants already in Wuhan in Dec 2019. So where did all these variants come from? From that same single patient zero on Dec 8th? Or from that patient plus one more vaguely identified patient 0.1? In 3 weeks?


It is now thought bothe lineage A and lineage B originated from the same wet market. Two entrants one failed to progress. Lineage A and B were probably variants in the source animal species.

This is how viral evolution works, especially with an emerging infection in a novel host. Every time every virus replicates novel mutants will be produced. Evolution occurs within the host. The most efficient mutants will then be spread. These will be new variants. We have good evidence from WGS that especially in those who are immunocompromised with chronic infections a whole series of new variants evolve. One original virus will produce multiple variants. I suspect that if more of the original viruses were available for WGS more variants would be found.

https://academic.oup.com/emph/article/10/1/142/6555377


You all want to claim without a shred of intermediate-species evidence that all these human strains really represented multiple spillover events, or as was suggested well up-thread, COVID doesn't need to adapt as it is a "generalist" as Planigale revisited even though that hypothesis was dismissed months ago.

Genetic evidence is not subject to bias though interpretation of that evidence is. And when researchers really really really don't want to find out the lab was the source of a deadly pandemic ... there is a lot of bias there.

Next post is about that bias so don't anyone go claiming it's about a CT. What I'm going to post is well documented. Feel free of course to counter the evidence, but this is about bias not some CT.

You may have dismissed SARS-CoV-2 as a generalist virus, I don't think virologists have. The paper below says "our results support the progenitor of SARS-CoV-2 being capable of efficient human–human transmission as a consequence of its adaptive evolutionary history in bats, not humans". You need to look at original papers not out dated commentaries.

While an undiscovered “facilitating” intermediate species cannot be discounted, collectively, our results support the progenitor of SARS-CoV-2 being capable of efficient human–human transmission as a consequence of its adaptive evolutionary history in bats, not humans, which created a relatively generalist virus.

https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.3001115

Our findings suggest that minimal adaptation was required for onward transmission in mink and deer following human-to-animal spillover, highlighting the ‘generalist’ nature of SARS-CoV-2 as a mammalian pathogen.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-30698-6
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom