(Sorry AS, my reply to the WIV staff having pneumonia in Sept is in the queue) First things first. I posted this before about earlier cases of COVID in Wuhan before Dec 2019. Here it is again:
https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/14/health/who-mission-china-intl/index.html
The WHO food safety specialist added the team had been presented by Chinese scientists with 174 cases of coronavirus in and around Wuhan in December 2019. Of these 100 had been confirmed by laboratory tests, he said, and another 74 through the clinical diagnosis of the patient’s symptoms.
You don't get 174 severe cases in Dec 2019 unless the cases started accumulating before Dec. China was not testing everyone at that time.
This would have been cases presenting to hospitals that were "noticed" by doctors.
Ben Embarek said it was possible this larger number – of likely severe cases that had been noticed by Chinese doctors early on – meant the disease could have hit an estimated 1,000-plus people in Wuhan that December.
From a single introduction and a super-spreader event at the market?
Initially there was a claim by the Chinese and pro-spillover proponents that a second market was involved. That was because 2 lineages were found. The market was never named. There might have been a claim of some sewage testing positive, I have a vague recollection of that.
But it looks like there were 13
documented variants already in Wuhan in Dec 2019.
So where did all these variants come from? From that same single patient zero on Dec 8th? Or from that patient plus one more vaguely identified patient 0.1? In 3 weeks?
You all want to claim without a shred of intermediate-species evidence that all these human strains really represented multiple spillover events, or as was suggested well up-thread, COVID doesn't need to adapt as it is a "generalist" as Planigale revisited even though that hypothesis was dismissed months ago.
Genetic evidence is not subject to bias though interpretation of that evidence is. And when researchers really really really don't want to find out the lab was the source of a deadly pandemic ... there is a lot of bias there.
Next post is about that bias so don't anyone go claiming it's about a CT. What I'm going to post is well documented. Feel free of course to counter the evidence, but this is about bias not some CT.