I have no idea what to make of the competing claims about the phylogentic analyses. The only thing I can really go by is looking at what other scientists seem to make of it.
When I look at the TopHap analysis (that puts an emergence of SARS-CoV-2 at mid-September to early-October 2019), I see that it has been
cited 6 times according to Google Scholar.
The citations are
Pekar et.al (2022) in which they respond to the TopHap analysis in a way that means nothing at all to me:
The A.1 and A+C29095T proposed ancestral haplotypes were strongly rejected by all the phylodynamic analyses, even when rooting with recCA or bat sarbecovirus outgroups, which include both C18060T and C29095T (Table 1 and data S3). Hence, WA1-like and 20SF012-like haplotypes cannot plausibly represent the MRCA of SARS-CoV-2 as previously suggested (19–21); the similarity of these genomes to the recCA is due to C-to-T reversions. Haplotypes not reported in Table 1 were similarly rejected (data S3).
We inferred the time of MRCA (tMRCA) for SARS-CoV-2 to be 11 December 2019 [95% highest posterior density (HPD) interval, 25 November to 12 December] by using unconstrained rooting. It has been suggested that a phylogenetic root in lineage A would produce an older tMRCA than would a lineage B rooting (21). Therefore, we developed an approach to assign a haplotype as the SARS-CoV-2 MRCA (A, B, C/C, A.1, or A+C29095T) and inferred the tMRCA (fig. S18D). The tMRCA was consistent with the recCA-rooted and fixed ancestral haplotype analyses (table S2 and supplementary text).
We infer only three plausible ancestral haplotypes: lineage A, lineage B, and C/C. However, the inability to reconcile the molecular clock at the outset of the COVID-19 pandemic with a lineage A ancestor without information from related sarbecoviruses (such as the recCA) requires us to question the assumption that both lineages A and B resulted from a single introduction.
One of the citations is by one of the co-authors,
Kumar along with several other authors, in article in the BMJ which lists a number of possible early detections of SARS-CoV2 such as PCR, skin biospy, wastewater etc... mostly in Italy from September, October or November 2019:
"the combination of all knowledge acquired so far
from retrospective studies strongly suggests that SARSCoV-2 was circulating outside of China considerably
earlier than the currently postulated time frame of late
December 2019/early January 2020, at least in some parts
of the world....
...An analysis of the information transmission chain
regarding the hypothesis of early circulation outside
China reveals not only a dismissive attitude towards this
hypothesis,50 but also that this hypothesis is linked to
other hypotheses regarding SARS-CoV-2. In other words,
accepting the idea that SARS-CoV-2 or its progenitor(s)
might have circulated in many regions of the world for
months before it was discovered in Wuhan challenges
several widely accepted assumptions about this virus.
However, it is important to note that the early origin of
SARS-CoV-2 has no bearing on the debate about the laboratory leak versus natural origin, and it does not exclude
the possibility of its origin in Hubei or somewhere else in
China. The acceptance of the early origin is inconvenient
in that we may no longer be able to use the circumstantial evidence of time and location of the first detection of
SARS-CoV-2 as our final answer.
That is interesting in that the authors broaden the question of when and where the virus originated much more widely.
Then the other citations are from Dr Quay (lab leak proponent), Latham and Wilson (two more lab leak proponents who concocted the elaborate Monjiang Mine serial passage theory that was extremely popular on this thread for a while until BANAL-52 rendered it redundant) and something called Blacklisted news.
Hmmm... well, if we look at Pekar et. al (2022) we see that it has
53 citations. Admittedly, one of those is by
Worobey et.al (2022), which was published alongside it, so we shouldn't count. In addition, some of the citations are critical, such as a pre-print by
Bruttel, Washburne and VanDongen which claims that Pekar et. al (2022) and Worobey et. al (2022) fall foul of ascertainment bias. (For his part, Worobey claims that the supplementary data that went with his paper on the Huanan Market Origins refutes the ascertainment bias).
In addition, Worobey et. al (2022) has itself now been
cited 98 times.
I get that some people don't accept citation counts as a reliable metric, but I think there is a bit of dog-that-didn't-bark evidence here. The TopHap gets only 6 citations, so why are other people in the field not impressed by it? Is it because other people in the field don't know about it? Is it because the TopHap paper somehow has low status and so scientists want to steer clear of it? Is it because of a conspiracy of silence, or worse???
Why also, has Worobey et. al received 98 citations and Pekar et. al received 53? Or should we consider this number to be lower than it otherwise would be?
Worobey is well-respected in his field of the origins of viruses. Not only for his work on HIV/AIDS, but his top cited paper is called "Origins and evolutionary genomics of the 2009 swine-origin H1N1 influenza A epidemic" with 2592 cites. He has an
h-index of 52, which is not bad at all.
So why are so many top scientists in this field apparently trying to cover up a leak from a lab? Worobey, Pekar, Holmes, Andersen, Garry, Rasmussen, Rachaniello, Wurtheim, Rambaut, etc...? Oh, and then of course, Francis Collins and Fauci also seem to be in on it. And Farrar, etc...?
I don't see why they would be doing this. We have to either assume they are extremely incompetent or extremely corrupt.