Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's what I'm posting, not what I've read. There's an unsupportable bias in this thread that the virus came from the wet market. Talk about confirming your biases.
:id:

BTW, why do you feel the need to tell others what they should think about my posts? They can read. Can you find any posts of mine where I felt the need to say AS (or anyone else) this or AS that? No, because I address people's arguments directly. I have no need to recruit allies.

No, you only want to see the DoE file and the FBI one. Apparently not interested in other reports from agencies that think it came from nature. That is confirmation bias.

I’d be happy to look at all of them.
 
No, you only want to see the DoE file and the FBI one. Apparently not interested in other reports from agencies that think it came from nature. That is confirmation bias.

I’d be happy to look at all of them.
If you could really read my mind you could have won the MDC money. :rolleyes:
 
Amanpour and Company interview with Jaimie Metzl, it's time to listen to him again.

Why the COVID-19 Lab-Leak Theory Has New Credibility and Why It Matters | Amanpour and Company -- 18 minutes

With China-U.S. tensions on the increase, the origin of the coronavirus is one issue driving a wedge between the two nations. A hearing on Capitol Hill this week explored the potential causes of the COVID-19 outbreak. Jamie Metzl, who attended the hearing, warned U.S. lawmakers to not dismiss the hypothesis that the virus leaked from a Chinese lab. He speaks with Hari Sreenivasan about the importance of examining this theory.

Originally aired on March 10, 2023

 
Last edited:
I read what you said correctly and you are wrong, period. You don't understand Chinese culture.

COVID-19 Origins: Investigating a “Complex and Grave Situation” Inside a Wuhan Lab - The Wuhan lab at the center of suspicions about the pandemic’s onset was far more troubled than known, documents unearthed by a Senate team reveal. Tracing the evidence, Vanity Fair and ProPublica give the clearest view yet of a biocomplex in crisis.

You think China would prefer a lab accident under those circumstances to a natual spillover at a wet market? Think the researchers at the WIV would readily admit a leak had occurred? :rolleyes:


China has pushed 2 stories, one that the virus arrived on imported frozen food, and, two, that the lab leak occurred in the US at Fort Detrick.

A laboratory leak would be an error by an individual, or a technical failure of equipment. It does not reflect on the CCP. Whereas regulation of the wet market and enforcing hygeine regulations is the responsibility of the local party. It is directly a failure of part of the CCP.

Though I agree that China would prefer neither option was true.
 
A laboratory leak would be an error by an individual, or a technical failure of equipment. It does not reflect on the CCP. Whereas regulation of the wet market and enforcing hygeine regulations is the responsibility of the local party. It is directly a failure of part of the CCP.

Though I agree that China would prefer neither option was true.

So you glossed over the link?
Like many scientific institutes in China, the WIV is state-run and funded. The research carried out there must advance the goals of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). As one way to ensure compliance, the CCP operates 16 party branches inside of the WIV, where members including scientists meet regularly and demonstrate their loyalty.

Week after week, scientists from those branches chronicled their party-building exploits in reports uploaded to the WIV’s website. These dispatches, intended for watchful higher-ups, generally consist of upbeat recitations of recruitment efforts and meeting summaries that emphasize the fulfillment of Beijing’s political goals. “The headlines and initial paragraphs seem completely innocuous,” Reid says. “If you didn’t take a close look, you’d probably think there’s nothing in here.”

But much like imperfect propaganda, the dispatches hold glimmers of real life: tension among colleagues, abuse from bosses, reprimands from party superiors. The grievances are often couched in a narrative of heroism — a focus on problems overcome and challenges met, against daunting odds.. ...

In summary:
Senate researchers’ findings and analysis, Vanity Fair, in partnership with ProPublica, spent five months investigating their underlying evidence. We analyzed WIV documents, consulted with experts in CCP communications, asked biocontainment experts to help analyze documents and reviewed with independent scientists the possible evidence that certain vaccine research may have begun far earlier than acknowledged.

We also traced the hazards that arose as the WIV built a lab to research the world’s most dangerous pathogens. Taken together, our reporting provides critical context that is not included in the pared-down 35-page interim report. It offers the most detailed picture to date of the months leading up to the COVID-19 outbreak, including new details on the intense pressure the lab faced to produce breakthrough research, its struggles to grapple with mounting safety issues and a previously unreported series of references to what investigators on the Senate team believed to be a biocontainment incident shortly before the virus began infecting its first victims.
Doesn't mean that was the incident that resulted in a lab leak. They were studying the coronaviruses in a BSL2 lab, not the BSL4. But what it does say in the article is the government was pressuring the researchers to come up with new discoveries that make China look good in the eyes of the world.

Saving face, looking scientifically advanced, underlings keeping any negative information secret from the government personnel—that is what China does, it's embedded in their culture.

You can either look into it for yourself or not. Making up what you think the Chinese would prefer is unsupported.
 
So you glossed over the link?


In summary:Doesn't mean that was the incident that resulted in a lab leak. They were studying the coronaviruses in a BSL2 lab, not the BSL4. But what it does say in the article is the government was pressuring the researchers to come up with new discoveries that make China look good in the eyes of the world.

Saving face, looking scientifically advanced, underlings keeping any negative information secret from the government personnel—that is what China does, it's embedded in their culture.

You can either look into it for yourself or not. Making up what you think the Chinese would prefer is unsupported.

No, i did not gloss over the link. Yes the laboratory like most scientific institutes world wide is state funded, although apparently some of that funding was from the USA as well as China. But you seem to ignore my point that a leak would not be a failure of the CCP, whilst a transmission from a wet market is directly a failure of the CCP. Could you address that point?

You may not be familiar with BSL levels. You do not study coronaviruses in a BSL 4 laboratory, that would be for e.g. Ebola or Marburg. Research on animal viruses would be routinely in a level 2 facility. Animal research might be in level 3. Any occurrence in a BSL4 laboratory is irrelevant.

ETA
Forgive me if I do not take the option of Vanity Fair seriously on this issue. Did you read the MIT article I linked to?

https://www.technologyreview.com/202...ab-leak-wuhan/
 
Last edited:
No, i did not gloss over the link. Yes the laboratory like most scientific institutes world wide is state funded, although apparently some of that funding was from the USA as well as China. But you seem to ignore my point that a leak would not be a failure of the CCP, whilst a transmission from a wet market is directly a failure of the CCP. Could you address that point?

You may not be familiar with BSL levels. You do not study coronaviruses in a BSL 4 laboratory, that would be for e.g. Ebola or Marburg. Research on animal viruses would be routinely in a level 2 facility. Animal research might be in level 3. Any occurrence in a BSL4 laboratory is irrelevant.

ETA
Forgive me if I do not take the option of Vanity Fair seriously on this issue. Did you read the MIT article I linked to?

https://www.technologyreview.com/202...ab-leak-wuhan/

Bad link, can't read it.

First, yes I understand biosafety levels, don't insult me.

Yes, there are technical issues in the Propublica article which conflict with a lot of things. I didn't link to it for the technical issues. I linked to it to give you an idea about saving face and the Chinese culture. I posted about the face-saving cultural issues in this thread and in the SARS thread.

When SARS broke out in Beijing officials covered it up. Soon it was out of control.

Lancet 2003: Beijing doctor alleges SARS cases cover-up in China
Jiang made the claims in a signed statement provided to Time magazine. The statement said that two People's Liberation Army hospitals were now treating SARS patients—hospitals 309 and 302—and Hospital 309 is “already full to capacity”. The Ministry of Health, in a statement released on April 15, said that Beijing had just 37SARS patients.

Jiang said that he went public with his claims because he feared that “a failure to disclose accurate statistics about the illness will only lead to more deaths”.

He said he “could not believe” statements made by China's Health Minister Zhang Wenkang that Beijing had only 12 SARS cases and that three patients had died. “As a doctor who cares about people's lives and health, I have a responsibility to aid international and local efforts to prevent the spread of SARS”, he said.
Guardian 2003: China accused of Sars cover-up
A senior Chinese doctor today accused his government of covering up details about the spread of severe acute respiratory syndrome (Sars), while a Beijing hospital was shut down, reportedly because medical staff became infected.

Even as state media repeated the government's claim that the outbreak is under control, the health ministry said officials from throughout China had been summoned to Beijing to discuss efforts to counteract Sars.

The official word is they learned their lesson and reported the COVID outbreak right away. But they didn't. There was an ophthalmologist who worked in a hospital who tried to notify colleagues by email that there was an outbreak of an unknown pneumonia. He was confronted by officials and threatened with jail if he didn't shut up. Later he contracted COVID and died. The government apologized to him posthumously. It's all documented upthread.

Bottomline, none of those WIV scientists, staff or students would have reported potential lab leaks.
 
Last edited:
Neither do the intelligence agencies. Their jobs are to give the president the most accurate possible results. I think you're way overconfident.
That doesn't mean the public gets the same information as the POTUS.

A lot of people in this thread think I'm way overconfident. Doesn't bother me. I was involved in followup of the SARS outbreak that reached Canada and touched the US. My job as a consultant, educator and practitioner was to keep EMS and other healthcare workers safe.

CDC: SARS (10 Years After)
Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) is a respiratory illness that affected many people worldwide in 2003. It was caused by a coronavirus, called SARS-associated coronavirus (SARS-CoV). SARS was first reported in Asia in February 2003. The illness spread to 29 countries, where 8,096 people got SARS and 774 of them died. The SARS global outbreak was contained in July 2003. Since 2004, there have not been any known cases of SARS reported anywhere in the world.

I saw SARS coming because I was following the ISID news feed. Health care workers were dying in an outbreak in Guangdong. That was frightening. So I watched the whole thing unfold from those first cases to the end of the outbreak followed by a couple lab accidents that infected people but did not go further.

https://isid.org/about-the-international-society-for-infectious-diseases/


I've followed the HPAI-H5N1 SINCE 1997.
Emergence and Evolution of H5N1 Bird Flu | Avian Influenza (Flu)

We've been waiting for that to become a pandemic ever since. I think now it actually is getting close.


The point is, I've seen these emerging viruses more than a few times. It was my job to keep up to date on them until I retired last Oct. I know what I see here with COVID.

Worobey traced HIV back to a source location decades ago but he's left out data on the earliest cases of COVID in his current analysis. There are a number of lines of inquiry re tracing the genetic trail backward. I'm not impressed by those claiming this proves that. There's new information out now about just how many variants were actually circulating initially in Wuhan. I'll get back to that.


The source animal has not been found.
COVID 19 did not need time to adapt to human to human spread.
For cripe's sake they were studying potentially pandemic coronavirus pathogens right there where the bloody pandemic began, in a BSL2 lab no less.
China continues to withhold data.
There has been a concerted effort from the start to quash any thought the source was a lab leak. An awful lot of people don't want to know that for multiple reasons.

Yes, I am confident. No I am not overconfident. And sure enough the lab leak origin hypothesis keeps chugging right along no matter who would prefer it wasn't so.
 
Yes, I am confident. No I am not overconfident.

If "it's obvious to me it's going to eventually turn out this came from the lab" means what it sounds like it means, namely, that you are sure it came from the lab, then, you are indeed being overconfident.
 
Bad link, can't read it.

First, yes I understand biosafety levels, don't insult me.

Yes, there are technical issues in the Propublica article which conflict with a lot of things. I didn't link to it for the technical issues. I linked to it to give you an idea about saving face and the Chinese culture. I posted about the face-saving cultural issues in this thread and in the SARS thread.

When SARS broke out in Beijing officials covered it up. Soon it was out of control.

Lancet 2003: Beijing doctor alleges SARS cases cover-up in China
Guardian 2003: China accused of Sars cover-up

The official word is they learned their lesson and reported the COVID outbreak right away. But they didn't. There was an ophthalmologist who worked in a hospital who tried to notify colleagues by email that there was an outbreak of an unknown pneumonia. He was confronted by officials and threatened with jail if he didn't shut up. Later he contracted COVID and died. The government apologized to him posthumously. It's all documented upthread.

Bottomline, none of those WIV scientists, staff or students would have reported potential lab leaks.

Sorry about link try this

https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-covid-lab-leak-wuhan/

Also this

https://www.technologyreview.com/20...an-natural-spillover-wuhan-wet-market-huanan/
 
That doesn't mean the public gets the same information as the POTUS.

A lot of people in this thread think I'm way overconfident. Doesn't bother me. I was involved in followup of the SARS outbreak that reached Canada and touched the US. My job as a consultant, educator and practitioner was to keep EMS and other healthcare workers safe.

CDC: SARS (10 Years After)

I saw SARS coming because I was following the ISID news feed. Health care workers were dying in an outbreak in Guangdong. That was frightening. So I watched the whole thing unfold from those first cases to the end of the outbreak followed by a couple lab accidents that infected people but did not go further.

https://isid.org/about-the-international-society-for-infectious-diseases/


I've followed the HPAI-H5N1 SINCE 1997.
Emergence and Evolution of H5N1 Bird Flu | Avian Influenza (Flu)

We've been waiting for that to become a pandemic ever since. I think now it actually is getting close.


The point is, I've seen these emerging viruses more than a few times. It was my job to keep up to date on them until I retired last Oct. I know what I see here with COVID.

Worobey traced HIV back to a source location decades ago but he's left out data on the earliest cases of COVID in his current analysis. There are a number of lines of inquiry re tracing the genetic trail backward. I'm not impressed by those claiming this proves that. There's new information out now about just how many variants were actually circulating initially in Wuhan. I'll get back to that.


The source animal has not been found.
COVID 19 did not need time to adapt to human to human spread.
For cripe's sake they were studying potentially pandemic coronavirus pathogens right there where the bloody pandemic began, in a BSL2 lab no less.
China continues to withhold data.
There has been a concerted effort from the start to quash any thought the source was a lab leak. An awful lot of people don't want to know that for multiple reasons.

Yes, I am confident. No I am not overconfident. And sure enough the lab leak origin hypothesis keeps chugging right along no matter who would prefer it wasn't so.

1) The source animal has not been found; it took years to find the source for SARS and decades for HIV. The source of many other zoonotic outbreaks are unknown. If the source was from a laboratory then we should know as the source would be known by definition, otherwise it would not be in the laboratory.

2) Covid -19 (I think you mean SARS-CoV-2) did not need time to adapt; this is the prosecutors fallacy. You do not know how many times nr for how long the virus failed. You are only looking at the one of millions of evolutionary variants that was successful. There is good evidence there are multiple infection events that fail to become an outbreak. What we do know is that the virus was a generalist virus that was able to cause outbreaks in minks and deer, it was not specific to humans. `We do know it was not well adapted to humans as subsequent mutations resulted in far better adaptions.

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct.../10/2259/pdf&usg=AOvVaw17CM_1dtWN8FHYoPXaM3gk

3) The reason they were studying coronaviruses was because coronaviruses were known to be high risk for causing a pandemic. They were known to be high risk in that particular area. They were doing the studies because they knew that there a high risk of a pandemic event starting locally. Nearly all major Chinese cities will have a virology laboratory, many of which will study coronavirus. The likelihood is that if you chose any large Chinese city it would have a virology laboratory carrying out coronavirus research. It is not a co-incidence that in an area where coronavirus had been identified as a public health risk that research was being done.

4) There is no evidence that any of the viruses in WVI were precursors to SARS-CoV-2. BSL-2 was the appropriate level for the research carried out, there is nothing wrong in that and it doesn't mean that there was a laboratory leak of a virus that the laboratory did not possess.

5) There is evidence that China suppressed evidence of live animal sales at the wet market. China has suppressed evidence. But that does not mean you can select the evidence suppression. Why isn't the evidence suppression relating to the wet market equally evidence in favour of that source?
 
There is an important issue here that needs to be emphasised. Every pandemic to date has been zoonotic in origin. Arguments against this for SARS-CoV-2 are dangerous. They will switch preventative measures from hygiene precautions around animals e.g. at wet markets, and to preventing virology research. This is not just an academic or political argument it will have real consequences for resourcing pandemic preparedness and prevention.
 
There is an important issue here that needs to be emphasised. Every pandemic to date has been zoonotic in origin. Arguments against this for SARS-CoV-2 are dangerous. They will switch preventative measures from hygiene precautions around animals e.g. at wet markets, and to preventing virology research. This is not just an academic or political argument it will have real consequences for resourcing pandemic preparedness and prevention.

Not nearly as dangerous as arguments against free speech.
 

What am I supposed to get out of those links? Angrysoba already posted multiple citations to the scientists who now believe it was a spillover. Nothing's changed where it matters, in particular:

The earliest cases
The intermediary species

And the other one is a fluff piece. Dr Shi has great PR that she's just a dedicated researcher who was worried about her lab work then she rushed home from a conference to double check and the COVID genome was not among her samples. :rolleyes:

She responded to Dr Bloom's discovery of genetic segments that had been deleted from her 2019 work with a likely story and the 'original' data. Shi has yet to address the full coronavirus database the Chinese government took offline in Sept 2019.

And Daszak has done nothing to resolve the missing data. Just before the pandemic erupted Daszak was still claiming the GoF research was yielding great results. Remember that interview from the virology conference? Whoops!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom