Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
The scientists such as Worobey et. al acknowledge that they are working with incomplete data but say this does not mean they cannot draw conclusions.

There is asymmetry between the information the scientific community has and the information the intelligence services (FBI, DOE, etc.) have. The intelligence services have all the information that scientific community has because that information is public, but the scientific community doesn't have all the information that the intelligent services have because that information is secret. I think that the zoonosis hypothesis is the more likely one, but I take the the lab leak hypothesis seriously because of this information asymmetry.
 
Last edited:
I asked for a citation for two things. That the WIV workers:

a) had pneumonia (as you claimed had been claimed)
b) were sick in September 2019.

You have not backed this up.

Instead you give some vague innuendo about how it must have been bad if it was noted. Really? Not convincing.

Also, do you not see how you are going further and further down a conspiratorial rabbit hole by clutching tight to vague anomalies while also suggesting the plot is getting bigger and bigger.

Also "[Huff"s] being falsely portrayed as a nut job". Dude, the guy is putting himself on InfoWars etc... No one has to work hard to portray him as a nutjob. Just read his insane Twitter feed where he is calling for summary executions of Daszak and Fauci etc....

Sorry to hear about your medical issues, by the way. I hope you can recover or get some good treatment for them.

The other odd thing about this theory is that since the majority of cases are asymptomatic especially in younger people, it would be very unlikely that three early cases would all be symptomatic at the same time.

The earliest report of the three scientist is an anonymous source given in the Wall Street Journal. Essentially this seems to be gossip.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/intell...b-fuels-debate-on-covid-19-origin-11621796228

A good review of work at the WIV here.

https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-covid-lab-leak-wuhan/
 
There is asymmetry between the information the scientific community has and the information the intelligence services (FBI, DOE, etc.) have. The intelligence services have all the information that scientific community's has because that information is public, but the scientific community doesn't have all the information that the intelligent services have because their information is secret. I think that the zoonotic hypothesis is the more likely one, but I take the the lab leak hypothesis seriously because of this information asymmetry.

That worked well with Iraq's WMD didn't it?

The problem is that intelligence services aren't intended to be neutral they are looking for threats.
 
It's obvious to me it's going to eventually turn out this came from the lab.

It's obvious to you? It isn't even obvious to the intelligence agencies, who have more information that you do. They are split on the origin of the pandemic, and most have low confidence in their conclusions.
 
There is asymmetry between the information the scientific community has and the information the intelligence services (FBI, DOE, etc.) have. The intelligence services have all the information that scientific community has because that information is public, but the scientific community doesn't have all the information that the intelligent services have because that information is secret. I think that the zoonosis hypothesis is the more likely one, but I take the the lab leak hypothesis seriously because of this information asymmetry.

Yes, but why are only two intelligence services persuaded by it? And are these intelligence services knowledgeable about the scientific details? If two services find it persuasive but others, presumably in possession of the same intelligence unpersuaded then where does it leave us?

Also, look at this….

We'll see what happens if the request Biden order the release the data supporting the DoE and the FBI reports is acted on.

Why is SG only interested in seeing evidence that would confirm her bias? Why not be interested in information that would potentially falsify her beliefs? Why doesn’t she want to see evidence from the other services?

Well, I guess because she has made up her mind and therefore given undue levels of credibility and even attempted to “sex up” some of the info by claiming things that were not even in the fever dreams of Mike Pompeo.

It's obvious to me it's going to eventually turn out this came from the lab.

It’s obvious to Skeptic Ginger but it is not obvious to me. I think it is possible it came from a lab but I struggle to put together a plausible narrative that fits Ockham’s razor. The most plausible still requires layers and layers of official complicity from scientists and organizations that don’t even have any good reason to be part of a cover up.
 
Last edited:
That worked well with Iraq's WMD didn't it?

Nice fallacy. Most scientific hypotheses are eventually found to be wrong, so we could apply that fallacy to the scientific community, too.

The problem is that intelligence services aren't intended to be neutral they are looking for threats.


That's just your own prejudice talking. They were tasked to determine the source of the virus.
 
Last edited:
How could the Chinese eliminate the lab? (Or do ou mean it should be demolished?). Even if they allowed a full inspection and no evidence was found people would just say the evidence was removed or covered up. There is no way an inspection of the laboratory can prove to those who believe in the laboratory leak theory that SARS-CoV-2 did not leak from the laboratory. Even if a clear ancestor was found in an animal, people would claim that it had been collected and studied in 2019 and leaked and the subsequent rediscovery was just it being rediscovered or a deliberate misdirection.

After SARS China committed to introducing sanitary measures in wet markets. The danger of wet markets as a source of a zoonotic infection has been warned about for years. there is evidence that China had tried to suppress that the regulations had not been enforced at Wuhan wet market. If Wuhan city authorities had enforced Chinese regulations on wet markets the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic would almost certainly never have happened. SARS demonstrated the possible pandemic risk of a novel coronavirus arising from a wet market. A novel flu virus would also be a possible pandemic virus arising in a wet market.

The concern a lot of people have is the focus on the laboratory then becomes an excuse not to do anything about the continued risk of wet markets. Every previous pandemic has been of zoonotic origin. The major future risk is from zoonotic spread. If the governmental response is to tighten up security in virology labs, and reduce scientific co-operation with China, nor only will this not reduce future risks, but actually increase risks by reducing the ability to respond to novel viruses.

It's a lot easier to take a righteous stand when you have opened everything up and nothing has been found, including gaps in the data, rather than keeping all the data secret. I suppose there could have been other things happening in the lab that the Chinese are afraid might be evident, but it still seems contrary to me.

The problem with the wet markets is the lack of any findings as to how a crossover occurred. Do you think the Chinese are deliberately failing in their attempts to find the link to enable the blame to be laid on the US??
 
Yes, but why are only two intelligence services persuaded by it?

None of the intelligence agencies are convinced of either hypothesis. The DOE and the FBI think the evidence favors a lab leak slightly (DOE) or moderately (FBI), others believe the evidence slightly favors the zoonosis hypothesis, and others think the evidence favors neither hypothesis over the other.

And are these intelligence services knowledgeable about the scientific details?

That information is public, and I would hope and assume, but have no way of being sure, that the intelligence services would have taken it into account. After all, in order to draw a conclusion about two competing hypotheses, you have to consider the evidence for both of them. Whether they have the internal expertise to evaluate the epidemiological and molecular data is another question, but they can formally hire outside scientific consultants or informally query outside scientists. Every scientific paper published on the pandemic and beyond contains the email address of the corresponding author.

If two services find it persuasive but others, presumably in possession of the same intelligence unpersuaded then where does it leave us?

It leaves us with having to make a subjective judgment on the probabilities of the two hypotheses based on the information that we have, which includes the fact that the intelligence services of the US, based on information that we don't have, are split and largely unconvinced either way.
 
Last edited:
None of the intelligence agencies are convinced of either hypothesis. The DOE and the FBI think the evidence favors a lab leak slightly (DOE) or moderately (FBI), others believe the evidence slightly favors the zoonosis hypothesis, and others think the evidence favors neither hypothesis over the other.



That information is public, and I would hope and assume, but have no way of being sure, that the intelligence services would have taken it into account. After all, in order to draw a conclusion about two competing hypotheses, you have to consider the evidence for both of them. Whether they have the internal expertise to evaluate the epidemiological and molecular data is another question, but they can formally hire outside scientific consultants or informally query outside scientists. Every scientific paper published on the pandemic and beyond contains the email address of the corresponding author.



It leaves us with having to make a subjective judgment on the probabilities of the two hypotheses based on the information that we have, which includes the fact that the intelligence services of the US, based on information that we don't have, are split and largely unconvinced either way.

Indeed, which suggests to me that the intelligence agencies don't know but the relevant expert scientists (virologists) tend to think it was natural. That's why I tend to favour spillover.

Now, I could be wrong, of course, and I don't make statements as categorical as those by SG, but I think the heuristics that we learn as skeptics ought to be applied. If every hole in your theory is fixed by widening a conspiracy or relying on a more elaborate explanation, then you are probably making a mistake. If it also involves "hidden" evidence such as "those early cases" or "those secret reports" or "those emails in which the virologists admitted that it defo came from a lab" or even, and yes this was proposed with a straight face here "that funding for spillover research involved secretly hiding a genuine case of spillover back in 2012 and then using that virus to create a more deadly pathogen for unknown reasons". For some reason, SG and every other lab leak proponent no longer talks about RaTG13 anymore.
 
It's a lot easier to take a righteous stand when you have opened everything up and nothing has been found, including gaps in the data, rather than keeping all the data secret. I suppose there could have been other things happening in the lab that the Chinese are afraid might be evident, but it still seems contrary to me.

The problem with the wet markets is the lack of any findings as to how a crossover occurred. Do you think the Chinese are deliberately failing in their attempts to find the link to enable the blame to be laid on the US??

There is evidence that the Chinese did try and conceal the role of the wet market and that wild animals were being sold. It is only because someone happened to film in the wet market shortly before the outbreak started we know that contrary to early Chinese assertions that no live animals were in the wet market that the regulations on this were to enforced. There is evidence China has deliberately tried to conceal the role of the wet market.

Remember it took over ten years to identify the source of SARS. We do not know the source of the West African Ebola outbreak, nor the MPox outbreak.

The Chinese could help by identifying the animals sold in the wet market and the source of those animals allowing a more targeted search for the source virus. So far he closest is from Laos.

The lack of a local source may mean hat the virus was not local, perhaps as the Chinese suggest that bat species in the US should be checked out, if a recent ancestor was found in a bat in the US then this would strongly support the Chinese assertion that the source was imported from the US! It is noticeable how little published data there is on US bats.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41579-021-00652-2
 
Indeed, which suggests to me that the intelligence agencies don't know but the relevant expert scientists (virologists) tend to think it was natural. That's why I tend to favour spillover.

That logic doesn't make sense. The intelligence services have access to more information than the scientific community does, and they favor the zoonosis hypothesis less. That suggests that that additional information casts doubt on the zoonosis hypothesis or, to put it another way, that if the scientific community had access to that additional information, they would be more skeptical of the zoonosis hypothesis.

Your reasoning makes sense only if you assume that the intelligence services did not take the information available to the scientific community into account or that they did not evaluate it properly. That could be, but it would mean that the intelligence services are incompetent.
 
Nice fallacy. Most scientific hypotheses are eventually found to be wrong, so we could apply that fallacy to the scientific community, too.
And we are. The way science works is that hypotheses are tested against logic and evidence, and the ones that don't stack up are discarded. In the case of Iraq WMDs the evidence was bogus and no extant WMD program was found.

In the case of the 'lab leak' hypothesis there never was any evidence for it - just lies, innuendo, and bad logic. "There's a lab in Wuhan so it must be the origin!". "They were doing Gain of Function which created it!". "It's a military Lab that engineers bioweapons!". "The liberal news media are trying to bury the truth!".

All the available evidence points away from a lab leak and towards the wet market. Even the scientists who initially asked for investigating the possibility of a lab leak agree. But the lab leakers cling to what unevidenced supposition they can find to argue the opposite - against logic and the scientific method.

Unfortunately the lies and illogic are having an effect on public opinion.

Mehdi Hasan Show: The truth about the Covid 'Lab Leak' theory

https://youtu.be/EHACkULrga8
 
That logic doesn't make sense. The intelligence services have access to more information than the scientific community does, and they favor the zoonosis hypothesis less. That suggests that that additional information casts doubt on the zoonosis hypothesis or, to put it another way, that if the scientific community had access to that additional information, they would be more skeptical of the zoonosis hypothesis.

Your reasoning makes sense only if you assume that the intelligence services did not take the information available to the scientific community into account or that they did not evaluate it properly. That could be, but it would mean that the intelligence services are incompetent.

That's one possibility, yes. Maybe the FBI are not that good at weighing up the scientific evidence. Or maybe it has politicized and non-objective agents, such as Trump appointees, who are more loyal to their political fellow travellers. Or maybe the intelligence community is being deliberately ambiguous to see how it affects Chinese responses (I thought similar things about the Chinese balloon episode) as well as the possibility that there are some total whackos who work for the intelligence community who prefer elaborate and weird explanations to simple ones (same again goes for some of the weirdos who are fascinated by UFOs/UAPs etc...), not to mention "sexed up" dossiers etc...

But anyway, the report that the IC released on Covid origins is pretty bland and essentially argues that not much can be concluded from what they know. They also, interestingly, find the "sick workers" story to be "not diagnostic" of Covid 19.

Link
 
It should be pointed out that the report is actually pretty out of date now. In other words, it doesn't take into account more recent analyses from Worobey et. al or Pekar et. al. and it states RaTG13 from the Mojiang Mine in Yunnan as the closest relative to SARS-CoV2 when we now know that BANAL-52 from Laos is closer and that it contains the receptor binding domain (RBD) which was considered unique in SARS-CoV2 until then.

In other words, one of the theories heavily promoted by some lab leak theorists, including here, was that RaTG13 MUST be the key to the spillover, was essentially falsified by the discovery of BANAL-52, and the idea that the RBD must have been engineered or created through gain-of-function is also falsified.

Of course, lab leakers didn't miss a beat and immediately assumed that the WIV had acquired BANAL-52 earlier and inserted the furin cleavage site (FCS) because of unfunded grants suggesting similar ideas, etc...
 
Maybe the FBI are not that good at weighing up the scientific evidence. Or maybe it has politicized and non-objective agents, such as Trump appointees, who are more loyal to their political fellow travellers.

At last check, the FBI has been described as Trumptown, even before Trump and his Administration's rather overt government-wide efforts to focus on elevating loyalists and to punish impartial competence that didn't tell them what they wanted to hear. The chance of pre-existing politically-rooted bias playing a distinct role is unfortunately high, even if loyalty to their fellow political travellers might not be the direct mechanism. That RW propagandists know how to manipulate those like them a bit too well and have been doing so effectively is one of the unfortunate truths of our time.
 
Last edited:
I said the opposite, China is more culpable if the origin is from a wetamarket, because the same thing had happened with SARS.
I read what you said correctly and you are wrong, period. You don't understand Chinese culture.

COVID-19 Origins: Investigating a “Complex and Grave Situation” Inside a Wuhan Lab - The Wuhan lab at the center of suspicions about the pandemic’s onset was far more troubled than known, documents unearthed by a Senate team reveal. Tracing the evidence, Vanity Fair and ProPublica give the clearest view yet of a biocomplex in crisis.
Ever since the Chinese city of Wuhan was identified as ground zero for the COVID-19 pandemic, a contingent of scientists have suspected that the virus could have leaked from one of the WIV’s complex of laboratories. The WIV is, after all, the venue for some of China’s riskiest coronavirus research. Scientists there have mixed components of different coronaviruses and created new strains, in an effort to predict the risks of human infection and to develop vaccines and treatments. Critics argue that creating viruses that don’t exist in nature runs the risk of unleashing them.

The WIV has two campuses and performed coronavirus research on both. Its older Xiaohongshan campus is just 8 miles from the crowded seafood market where COVID-19 first burst into public view. Its newer Zhengdian campus, about 18 miles to the south, is home to the institute’s most prestigious laboratory, a biosafety level 4 (BSL-4) facility, designed to enable safe research on the world’s most lethal pathogens. The WIV triumphantly announced its completion in February 2015, and it was cleared to begin full research by early 2018.

Like many scientific institutes in China, the WIV is state-run and funded. The research carried out there must advance the goals of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). As one way to ensure compliance, the CCP operates 16 party branches inside of the WIV, where members including scientists meet regularly and demonstrate their loyalty.
Week after week, scientists from those branches chronicled their party-building exploits in reports uploaded to the WIV’s website. These dispatches, intended for watchful higher-ups, generally consist of upbeat recitations of recruitment efforts and meeting summaries that emphasize the fulfillment of Beijing’s political goals. “The headlines and initial paragraphs seem completely innocuous,” Reid says. “If you didn’t take a close look, you’d probably think there’s nothing in here.”

You think China would prefer a lab accident under those circumstances to a natual spillover at a wet market? Think the researchers at the WIV would readily admit a leak had occurred? :rolleyes:


China has pushed 2 stories, one that the virus arrived on imported frozen food, and, two, that the lab leak occurred in the US at Fort Detrick.
 
I asked for a citation for two things. That the WIV workers:

a) had pneumonia (as you claimed had been claimed)
b) were sick in September 2019.

You have not backed this up.

Instead you give some vague innuendo about how it must have been bad if it was noted. Really? Not convincing.

Also, do you not see how you are going further and further down a conspiratorial rabbit hole by clutching tight to vague anomalies while also suggesting the plot is getting bigger and bigger.

Also "[Huff"s] being falsely portrayed as a nut job". Dude, the guy is putting himself on InfoWars etc... No one has to work hard to portray him as a nutjob. Just read his insane Twitter feed where he is calling for summary executions of Daszak and Fauci etc....

Sorry to hear about your medical issues, by the way. I hope you can recover or get some good treatment for them.
I'm not well, nave some 'effing patience.
 
It's obvious to you? It isn't even obvious to the intelligence agencies, who have more information that you do. They are split on the origin of the pandemic, and most have low confidence in their conclusions.
I don't have the restriction of being politically sensitive in what I post.
 
Why is SG only interested in seeing evidence that would confirm her bias? ....
That's what I'm posting, not what I've read. There's an unsupportable bias in this thread that the virus came from the wet market. Talk about confirming your biases.
:id:

BTW, why do you feel the need to tell others what they should think about my posts? They can read. Can you find any posts of mine where I felt the need to say AS (or anyone else) this or AS that? No, because I address people's arguments directly. I have no need to recruit allies.
 
Last edited:
... For some reason, SG and every other lab leak proponent no longer talks about RaTG13 anymore.
:confused:

Why should it be brought up in the current discussion. It's not very close genetically to COVID 19.

NIH; April 2020: Full-genome evolutionary analysis of the novel corona virus (2019-nCoV) rejects the hypothesis of emergence as a result of a recent recombination event
The levels of genetic similarity between the 2019-nCoV and RaTG13 suggest that the latter does not provide the exact variant that caused the outbreak in humans, but the hypothesis that 2019-nCoV has originated from bats is very likely. We show evidence that the novel coronavirus (2019-nCov) is not-mosaic consisting in almost half of its genome of a distinct lineage within the betacoronavirus. These genomic features and their potential association with virus characteristics and virulence in humans need further attention.

I am reading some more recent studies that found multiple COVID variants were circulating in Dec 2019. I haven't had time to distill them yet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom