Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is anyone paying any attention to this?

The House Oversight Committee held a hearing on Wednesday on the origins of COVID-19 following a new report from the Energy Department that it had determined, with low confidence, that the novel coronavirus had escaped from a lab in China.

Watch the full event in the player above.

Former CDC Director Dr. Robert Redfield was among those who testified.

COVID-19’s origins remain hazy. Three years after the start of the pandemic, it’s still unclear whether the coronavirus that causes the disease leaked from a lab or spread to humans from an animal.

This much is known: When it comes to COVID-19 misinformation, any new report on the virus’ origin quickly triggers a relapse and a return of misleading claims about the virus, vaccines and masks that have reverberated since the pandemic began.

Link

I haven't watched any yet, and not sure if I will bother.

Marjorie Taylor Greene is apparently on this committee. :rolleyes:
 
By the way, I have been listening to an excellent discussion of the lab leak and the evidence against it that will be released on a skeptically-minded podcast that I am a patron of. I think it will be coming out next week, but it is partly in response to Alina Chan and Matt Ridley's claims, but also to the various other theories of lab leak.

An important thing to realize is that there isn't just one lab leak theory but rather a whole ecosystem of them, which draw on mutually incompatible evidence.
 
Last edited:
Are there independent sources for this other than China's governmental CDC director George Gao (born Gao Fu, 1961) making a new claims 2 years into the pandemic? I would think that for skeptics, this is a case of garbage in/garbage out data.

Why would you believe such a claim?
eta: perhaps you do not believe it and are simply reporting propaganda of the Chinese gov't.

I think you misunderstand. Michael Worobey and Jonathon Pekar each wrote papers with other scientists claiming that the spread of Covid-19 looks to have been centred on the Hunan Seafood Market, and furthermore that two lineages existed rather than one (suggesting, according to Pekar et.al that there had been multiple spillovers rather than one).

George Gao wasn't endorsing the Hunan Seafood market spillover hypothesis and changing his mind that it is now the suspected area of spillover. He and the Chinese CDC were releasing a paper on environmental findings. The fact that the two lineages of the virus were both found in the market was incidental to their report.

For what it is worth, the Chinese authorities not only dispute lab leak, they also dispute the market origins.

The Chinese official argument is that Covid came out of a US lab, and was probably introduced to China either on frozen lobsters from America, or by the US military during the Wuhan Military Games.
 
Are there independent sources for this other than China's governmental CDC director George Gao (born Gao Fu, 1961) making a new claims 2 years into the pandemic?
I would think that for skeptics, this is a case of garbage in/garbage out data.

Why would you believe such a claim?

eta: perhaps you do not believe it and are simply reporting propaganda of the Chinese gov't.

The evidence does not come from the Chinese government who officially disagree with this. The evidence is from research by independent scientists.

Summaries here.

https://www.sydney.edu.au/news-opin...-the-origins-of-covid-came-from-a-market.html

https://www.science.org/doi/full/10.1126/science.abm4454

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9704731/

Some original papers

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abp8715

https://www.science.org/doi/full/10...l_ver=Z39.88-2003&rfr_id=ori:rid:crossref.org

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9937728/
 
Are there independent sources for this other than China's governmental CDC director George Gao (born Gao Fu, 1961) making a new claims 2 years into the pandemic?
I would think that for skeptics, this is a case of garbage in/garbage out data.

Why would you believe such a claim?

eta: perhaps you do not believe it and are simply reporting propaganda of the Chinese gov't.

After SARS arose from zoonotic transmission from a wet market in China, China committed to ending these and improving hygiene regulations. China had clearly failed to do this in Wuhan. It is actually worse for China if there was an origin for SARS-CoV-2 from a wet market. A laboratory origin is excusable if China enforced international regulations and could have happened anywhere, indeed the Chinese believe that the origin may have been from a US laboratory leak. Having had a near miss pandemic with SARS in identical circumstances and having publicly committed to deal with the risk from wet markets China is clearly negligent if the origin of SARS-CoV-2 was the wet market.
 
Yeah. Like they believe the balloon we shot down was a weather balloon.

The point is that many of the lab leak proponents think that all the WIV has to do is open up the lab, show everyone the databases, allow international inspectors and virologists to come in and comb the markets and wildlife farms and all will be well and the lab could be removed from suspicion.

BUT that assumes two things that are almost certainly not true:

1. The Wuhan Insititute of Virology can act independently of the Chinese government. To the extent that they could before, I would assume that is a far lower possibility now.

2. The Chinese government has some interest in revealing a market origin in order to exonnerate the lab. I would assume they do not want this at all given their official position of blaming the US.
 
Are there independent sources for this other than China's governmental CDC director George Gao (born Gao Fu, 1961) making a new claims 2 years into the pandemic?
I would think that for skeptics, this is a case of garbage in/garbage out data.

Why would you believe such a claim?

eta: perhaps you do not believe it and are simply reporting propaganda of the Chinese gov't.

Chinese science is this and that. I've seen Chinese chemistry papers that clearly were made up with no labwork. But in this case, I am going to go with the scientist, Not MTG or Lauren Boebert or Elon Musk.

And there was a link in the Yahoo item.
https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abm4454
 
Last edited:
Riight.. all that evidence which ignores the evidence about the earliest cases China refuses to release the data on. :rolleyes:
 
After SARS arose from zoonotic transmission from a wet market in China, China committed to ending these and improving hygiene regulations. China had clearly failed to do this in Wuhan. It is actually worse for China if there was an origin for SARS-CoV-2 from a wet market. A laboratory origin is excusable if China enforced international regulations and could have happened anywhere, indeed the Chinese believe that the origin may have been from a US laboratory leak. Having had a near miss pandemic with SARS in identical circumstances and having publicly committed to deal with the risk from wet markets China is clearly negligent if the origin of SARS-CoV-2 was the wet market.
Oh puullease! That's absolute crap claiming China would seem less culpable were the source to be a wet market.

You seem to have little knowledge about Chinese culture.
 
The point is that many of the lab leak proponents think that all the WIV has to do is open up the lab, show everyone the databases, allow international inspectors and virologists to come in and comb the markets and wildlife farms and all will be well and the lab could be removed from suspicion.

BUT that assumes two things that are almost certainly not true:

1. The Wuhan Insititute of Virology can act independently of the Chinese government. To the extent that they could before, I would assume that is a far lower possibility now.

2. The Chinese government has some interest in revealing a market origin in order to exonnerate the lab. I would assume they do not want this at all given their official position of blaming the US.
Yeah...no.

What China needs to do is open up access to the demographics of the first cases and data re illnesses among WIV staff, not just proclaiming none of them were ill in the winter of 2019.

Re #1, no the WIV is not independent of the government.

Re #2, China wants to blame an origin outside of China. This has been discussed upthread.

We'll see what happens if the request Biden order the release the data supporting the DoE and the FBI reports is acted on.
 
Yeah...no.

What China needs to do is open up access to the demographics of the first cases and data re illnesses among WIV staff, not just proclaiming none of them were ill in the winter of 2019.

Re #1, no the WIV is not independent of the government.

Re #2, China wants to blame an origin outside of China. This has been discussed upthread.

We'll see what happens if the request Biden order the release the data supporting the DoE and the FBI reports is acted on.

Now that you are back, could you respond to this, please…



“With pneumonia”!!!

Citation needed please. All I heard was “symptoms consistent with Covid-19”. There are a lot of symptoms consistent with Covid-19 and these are also consistent with flu as well.

Please show the evidence that they had pneumonia..

Also, please double check that date. You say “September 2019” but I don’t think I have seen that date before.

Look here at the White House “fact sheet” that merely said some of them may have been sick with symptoms consistent with BOTH Covid-19 and seasonal illnesses. I think they would have been more specific if they had evidence of pneumonia in September 2019:



https://2017-2021.state.gov/fact-sheet-activity-at-the-wuhan-institute-of-virology/
 
But as you agreed, the WIV is not independent of the Chinese government and so lack of cooperation does not mean lab leak. What it means is that the Chinese government does not want to accept that the virus began in China either through a lab accident or the wildlife trade. They want to blame the US essentially.

The scientists such as Worobey et. al acknowledge that they are working with incomplete data but say this does not mean they cannot draw conclusions. In fact science always proceeds from incomplete data.
 
Now that you are back, could you respond to this, please…
I'm working on that. I'm exhausted and having serious medical problems so don't think for a minute I'm simply walking away from any challenges here.

It's hard to actually look for valid citations when so many unqualified news sources repeat the ******** that "most scientists believe ... blah blah blah." That's crap reporting by unqualified sources.

This Forbes link is paywalled: Report: May, 2021; Wuhan Lab Staff Went To Hospital With Covid-Like Symptoms Before Confirmed Outbreak, New Intelligence Finds
Three researchers working at a Wuhan virology lab went to the hospital with Covid-like symptoms weeks before the first Covid-19 case was confirmed in China on December 8, according to newly disclosed U.S. intelligence obtained and reported by the Wall Street Journal on Sunday—corroborating previous State Department findings and casting further doubts on the longstanding assertion that Covid-19 did not escape from a lab.

That was back in 2019, not a time when one would go to the hospital for a mild URI. Much earlier in the thread there were sources that said in China going to the hospital might not mean what it means here. So I've been looking for something to resolve the discrepancy.

In 2019 what were recognized as COVID symptoms? Certainly not everyone with flu-like symptoms.

So what's your issue? No source claimed these staff members had pneumonia? Why did they come to anyone's attention then?


Biden is being pressured to order the DoE material released. That would be helpful. In the mean time I'll continue my pursuit of reliable sources, not every Tom, Dick and Harry's news reports.

It's obvious to me it's going to eventually turn out this came from the lab. What's unclear in my latest review of the available sources is how involved were our intelligence sources in the GoF research being done at the WIV in 2018 and earlier. And when those funds were cut off in ~2018 how much was Fauci involved in maintaining funding for GoF research at the WIV (through EHA)?

I don't want to go all CT here, but I also don't want to dismiss valid leads. I still have Dr Huff's book on hold at my local library. It's conceivable he's being falsely portrayed as a nut job if one considers his credentials. And it's possible his testimony isn't credible. That's why I pointed out the issues with his claims before you tried to imply I didn't know about them. I'm keeping an open mind.


Remember you accuse me of data dumping and/or gish-galloping when my posts are too long so the next thing I have to say will follow.
 
Oh puullease! That's absolute crap claiming China would seem less culpable were the source to be a wet market.

You seem to have little knowledge about Chinese culture.

I said the opposite, China is more culpable if the origin is from a wetamarket, because the same thing had happened with SARS.
 
I said the opposite, China is more culpable if the origin is from a wetamarket, because the same thing had happened with SARS.

Not convinced that follows. The labs would be under far closer control by the CCP than the ordinary citizens in the wet markets. Saying sorry for not managing to improve after SARS would be a lot easier than saying sorry that a government controlled organisation screwed up the biosecurity at their prestigious lab.

As pointed out above, China want to point the finger elsewhere completely - surely eliminating the lab would be in their interest?
 
I'm working on that. I'm exhausted and having serious medical problems so don't think for a minute I'm simply walking away from any challenges here.

It's hard to actually look for valid citations when so many unqualified news sources repeat the ******** that "most scientists believe ... blah blah blah." That's crap reporting by unqualified sources.

This Forbes link is paywalled: Report: May, 2021; Wuhan Lab Staff Went To Hospital With Covid-Like Symptoms Before Confirmed Outbreak, New Intelligence Finds


That was back in 2019, not a time when one would go to the hospital for a mild URI. Much earlier in the thread there were sources that said in China going to the hospital might not mean what it means here. So I've been looking for something to resolve the discrepancy.

In 2019 what were recognized as COVID symptoms? Certainly not everyone with flu-like symptoms.

So what's your issue? No source claimed these staff members had pneumonia? Why did they come to anyone's attention then?


Biden is being pressured to order the DoE material released. That would be helpful. In the mean time I'll continue my pursuit of reliable sources, not every Tom, Dick and Harry's news reports.

It's obvious to me it's going to eventually turn out this came from the lab. What's unclear in my latest review of the available sources is how involved were our intelligence sources in the GoF research being done at the WIV in 2018 and earlier. And when those funds were cut off in ~2018 how much was Fauci involved in maintaining funding for GoF research at the WIV (through EHA)?

I don't want to go all CT here, but I also don't want to dismiss valid leads. I still have Dr Huff's book on hold at my local library. It's conceivable he's being falsely portrayed as a nut job if one considers his credentials. And it's possible his testimony isn't credible. That's why I pointed out the issues with his claims before you tried to imply I didn't know about them. I'm keeping an open mind.


Remember you accuse me of data dumping and/or gish-galloping when my posts are too long so the next thing I have to say will follow.

I asked for a citation for two things. That the WIV workers:

a) had pneumonia (as you claimed had been claimed)
b) were sick in September 2019.

You have not backed this up.

Instead you give some vague innuendo about how it must have been bad if it was noted. Really? Not convincing.

Also, do you not see how you are going further and further down a conspiratorial rabbit hole by clutching tight to vague anomalies while also suggesting the plot is getting bigger and bigger.

Also "[Huff"s] being falsely portrayed as a nut job". Dude, the guy is putting himself on InfoWars etc... No one has to work hard to portray him as a nutjob. Just read his insane Twitter feed where he is calling for summary executions of Daszak and Fauci etc....

Sorry to hear about your medical issues, by the way. I hope you can recover or get some good treatment for them.
 
Not convinced that follows. The labs would be under far closer control by the CCP than the ordinary citizens in the wet markets. Saying sorry for not managing to improve after SARS would be a lot easier than saying sorry that a government controlled organisation screwed up the biosecurity at their prestigious lab.

As pointed out above, China want to point the finger elsewhere completely - surely eliminating the lab would be in their interest?

How could the Chinese eliminate the lab? (Or do ou mean it should be demolished?). Even if they allowed a full inspection and no evidence was found people would just say the evidence was removed or covered up. There is no way an inspection of the laboratory can prove to those who believe in the laboratory leak theory that SARS-CoV-2 did not leak from the laboratory. Even if a clear ancestor was found in an animal, people would claim that it had been collected and studied in 2019 and leaked and the subsequent rediscovery was just it being rediscovered or a deliberate misdirection.

After SARS China committed to introducing sanitary measures in wet markets. The danger of wet markets as a source of a zoonotic infection has been warned about for years. there is evidence that China had tried to suppress that the regulations had not been enforced at Wuhan wet market. If Wuhan city authorities had enforced Chinese regulations on wet markets the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic would almost certainly never have happened. SARS demonstrated the possible pandemic risk of a novel coronavirus arising from a wet market. A novel flu virus would also be a possible pandemic virus arising in a wet market.

The concern a lot of people have is the focus on the laboratory then becomes an excuse not to do anything about the continued risk of wet markets. Every previous pandemic has been of zoonotic origin. The major future risk is from zoonotic spread. If the governmental response is to tighten up security in virology labs, and reduce scientific co-operation with China, nor only will this not reduce future risks, but actually increase risks by reducing the ability to respond to novel viruses.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom