Their research showed that bat viruses were already getting into humans. It was only a matter of time before one hit a major population center.
Agree. They were. Not very viral, and in rural areas.
Whether there was an actual 'lab leak' or not is irrelevant - it was going to get us anyway. Rather than pinning blame on these researchers we should be praising them for potentially putting their lives at risk to save others.
They took a small fraction of potential viruses and did research to see if they could be made to infect humans. That is putting the collectors and lab workers in danger. Historically, we know this to be true. That is also potentially making a blueprint for a bioweapon.
In doing so, it unnecessarily puts everyone on our planet also in danger, the same danger they have if the risk becomes actualized and human vectors then walk around in public unaware. Do it enough, and the results are more predictable than anything nature would do if left alone.
It is becoming less of a rarity with each year that the science is way cheaper and much more available- globally.
None of this research has resulted in preventing an outbreak. Not in 30 years of trying. What was done, without
manipulating viruses, was to show areas that are more dangerous, specific animal vectors that are more dangerous.
Maybe we should not bring those dangers, year after year, altering them to be more dangerous to humans, to see the danger to humans, and into a highly populated city with the hutzpah to think everything is super safe. Leaks happen. Viruses have been altered to kill, even accidentally.
Stop blaming the victim and concentrate on what to do about future outbreaks in a spirit of cooperation rather than antagonism.
So what to do now? Do you think scientists should continue to go out into rural areas to collect small samples from the hundreds of thousands of potential threats out there for spillover and manipulate them to infect human cells, .... to protect humanity? Just to see? Just to be published? Should the US fund our adversaries to see how close a virus may be to being a danger to humans- by MAKING it so? ?
That makes ZERO sense to me. It is a recipe for a pandemic, not from animals, but human fallibility (or worse)- and we see it now.
Perhaps we should put efforts into EARLY and extensive monitoring and testing any anomolies in animal populations or in human symptoms that would give us rapid responses.
I'll guess won't cost so many trillions, arrest the development of children, and alter the mental health of the only planet we know.
disclaimer: I am not an infectious disease expert. Though I have found that those who said they were, were often very wrong. And those who trust the China data to be accurate when they delete data, or give it months later or not at all? C'mon.