Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay, presumably because that one will contain the smoking gun?

Yet if there is something they know that made them "moderately confident", would they not share this information with the rest of the intelligence community?
It was shared earlier in the pandemic that 3 people from the WIV were seen with pneumonia in Sept 2019. Then it was dropped from the news cycle as unconfirmed. They might have better evidence that initial assertion was true.

As for sharing information with other agencies, hah! You don't remember when 911 occurred the FBI did not share crucial information with the CIA. These agencies are disconnected, there is no mechanism they regularly share information. Congress might have the information but when the GOP cries: lab accident, China bad they have no credibility. Face it the Trump cult GOP made a mess of the science here.
 
It was shared earlier in the pandemic that 3 people from the WIV were seen with pneumonia in Sept 2019. Then it was dropped from the news cycle as unconfirmed. They might have better evidence that initial assertion was true.

As for sharing information with other agencies, hah! You don't remember when 911 occurred the FBI did not share crucial information with the CIA. These agencies are disconnected, there is no mechanism they regularly share information. Congress might have the information but when the GOP cries: lab accident, China bad they have no credibility. Face it the Trump cult GOP made a mess of the science here.

“With pneumonia”!!!

Citation needed please. All I heard was “symptoms consistent with Covid-19”. There are a lot of symptoms consistent with Covid-19 and these are also consistent with flu as well.

Please show the evidence that they had pneumonia..

Also, please double check that date. You say “September 2019” but I don’t think I have seen that date before.

Look here at the White House “fact sheet” that merely said some of them may have been sick with symptoms consistent with BOTH Covid-19 and seasonal illnesses. I think they would have been more specific if they had evidence of pneumonia in September 2019:

The U.S. government has reason to believe that several researchers inside the WIV became sick in autumn 2019, before the first identified case of the outbreak, with symptoms consistent with both COVID-19 and common seasonal illnesses. This raises questions about the credibility of WIV senior researcher Shi Zhengli’s public claim that there was “zero infection” among the WIV’s staff and students of SARS-CoV-2 or SARS-related viruses.

https://2017-2021.state.gov/fact-sheet-activity-at-the-wuhan-institute-of-virology/
 
Of the 41, which doesn't include the actual first case because earlier cases have been identified, 30% had no connection to the market.

Other that living within a few hundred meters of it...

And again, by the time you have 41 known hospitalizations the chain of infections is at least 5-7 people long. Why would any reasonable person expect that after the virus has already jumped through 7 different people that every one of them should still have a direct connection to the live animal market?

The earliest cases were found going back through hospital records. We don't know if they had a connection to the WIV because China is refusing to disclose that data.


What's you position of handing out patients private medical information to the media? Do you do it? Do you encourage people to do it? Do you think everyone should do it?

It might look like the bulk of cases connected to the market must include patient zero. But it only takes one person getting infected in the lab to start the spread.

If someone is infected with Covid it's unreasonable to think they would spread to random strangers in a market but not their co-workers. This is a moot point since the staff at the lab were tested and the results were negative.
 
Citation?

Apologies the earliest know case was Dec 10 not Dec 8. Dec 8 was was the supposed date for the "first case had no link to the market" but in fact he wasn't hospitalized with Covid until Dec 22.

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abm4454

Crucially, however, the now famous “earliest” COVID-19 case (1), a 41-year-old male accountant, who lived 30 km south of Huanan Market and had no connection to it—illness onset reported as 8 December—may have become ill with COVID-19 considerably later (12). When interviewed, he reported that his COVID-19 symptoms started with a fever on 16 December. This is corroborated by hospital records and a scientific paper that reports his COVID-19 onset date as 16 December and date of hospitalization as 22 December (see fig. S1). This suggests that he may have been infected through community transmission after the virus had begun spreading from Huanan Market. He believed that he may have been infected in a hospital or on the subway during his commute; he had also traveled north of Huanan Market shortly before his symptoms began (12). If his symptoms indeed began on 16 December, then it postdated multiple cases in workers at Huanan Market, making a female seafood vendor there the earliest known case, with illness onset 10 December.
 
What's you position of handing out patients private medical information to the media? Do you do it? Do you encourage people to do it? Do you think everyone should do it?

WHO wanted to see the records as part of the investigation into the pandemic...they didn't need the names, just the data. It is sort of important when you have 7 billion people hostage to a virus.
China refused to provide it.

China did, however, allow them to interview the 'first case' who said that although he didn't go to a market, maybe his parents did- and then they (the parents) visited him. His parents did not get Covid.
 
Last edited:
I just worry that all this is a bit like the Cubans being responsible for Havanna syndrome. Politically convenient. Lots of opinions by governmental organisations with little apparent expertise in the area. A growing consensus view by independant experts that the true nature of the problem is not due to wicked communists.
Yes, it is very convenient right now. And counterproductive - unless your goal is to start WWIII.

Studying infectious diseases carries risks. If there was a lab leak then any deficiencies in containment protocols need to be dealt to, which also applies if there wasn't a leak. We don't need a leak to identify deficiencies. But if we want to prevent future pandemics this research needs to done, despite the risk. Otherwise we are flying blind at the mercy of whatever breaks out.

The Wuhan Institute of Virology was trying to help,
In 2005, a group including researchers from the Wuhan Institute of Virology published research into the origin of the SARS coronavirus, finding that China's horseshoe bats are natural reservoirs of SARS-like coronaviruses...

In 2017, a team from the institute announced that coronaviruses found in horseshoe bats at a cave in Yunnan contain all the genetic pieces of the SARS virus, and hypothesized that the direct progenitor of the human virus originated in this cave. The team, who spent five years sampling the bats in the cave, noted the presence of a village only a kilometer away, and warned of "the risk of spillover into people and emergence of a disease similar to SARS".

In 2018, another paper by a team from the institute reported the results of a serological study of a sample of villagers residing near these bat caves (near Xiyang Township 夕阳乡 in Jinning District of Yunnan). According to this report, 6 out of the 218 local residents in the sample carried antibodies to the bat coronaviruses in their blood, indicating the possibility of transmission of the infections from bats to people.
Their research showed that bat viruses were already getting into humans. It was only a matter of time before one hit a major population center.

Whether there was an actual 'lab leak' or not is irrelevant - it was going to get us anyway. Rather than pinning blame on these researchers we should be praising them for potentially putting their lives at risk to save others. We could criticize the response by the authorities in China, but we should remember that our own performance in this area was less than stellar.

Destruction of the environment such as that which might increase human/animal interactions is a whole other can of worms and unless you are using it to support this being a spillover it drifts off-topic in this thread.
No, it's the can of worms. But let's continue sticking our heads on the sand and pretend that Covid was just a laboratory accident. Whether there was a lab leak or not, it is being used as a scapegoat so we don't have to face the real cause.

Playing the blame game is not doing anybody any good. You may think the 'truth' should be told whatever it might be, and this is simply a desire for scientific accuracy. But by concentrating on this irrelevant detail you are enabling the blamers - who don't care a whit about scientific accuracy and will continue pushing their narrative even if it turns out the 'lab leak' theory is 100% wrong. If they get their way then you were their useful idiot.

We need to defuse tensions with China, not exacerbate them. And the way we do that is to acknowledge they were just as much victims of Covid as we were - if not more. Nobody wanted this to happen, least of all China. Stop blaming the victim and concentrate on what to do about future outbreaks in a spirit of cooperation rather than antagonism.
 
Last edited:
Their research showed that bat viruses were already getting into humans. It was only a matter of time before one hit a major population center.

Agree. They were. Not very viral, and in rural areas.

Whether there was an actual 'lab leak' or not is irrelevant - it was going to get us anyway. Rather than pinning blame on these researchers we should be praising them for potentially putting their lives at risk to save others.

They took a small fraction of potential viruses and did research to see if they could be made to infect humans. That is putting the collectors and lab workers in danger. Historically, we know this to be true. That is also potentially making a blueprint for a bioweapon.
In doing so, it unnecessarily puts everyone on our planet also in danger, the same danger they have if the risk becomes actualized and human vectors then walk around in public unaware. Do it enough, and the results are more predictable than anything nature would do if left alone.
It is becoming less of a rarity with each year that the science is way cheaper and much more available- globally.

None of this research has resulted in preventing an outbreak. Not in 30 years of trying. What was done, without manipulating viruses, was to show areas that are more dangerous, specific animal vectors that are more dangerous.

Maybe we should not bring those dangers, year after year, altering them to be more dangerous to humans, to see the danger to humans, and into a highly populated city with the hutzpah to think everything is super safe. Leaks happen. Viruses have been altered to kill, even accidentally.


Stop blaming the victim and concentrate on what to do about future outbreaks in a spirit of cooperation rather than antagonism.

So what to do now? Do you think scientists should continue to go out into rural areas to collect small samples from the hundreds of thousands of potential threats out there for spillover and manipulate them to infect human cells, .... to protect humanity? Just to see? Just to be published? Should the US fund our adversaries to see how close a virus may be to being a danger to humans- by MAKING it so? ?

That makes ZERO sense to me. It is a recipe for a pandemic, not from animals, but human fallibility (or worse)- and we see it now.

Perhaps we should put efforts into EARLY and extensive monitoring and testing any anomolies in animal populations or in human symptoms that would give us rapid responses.
I'll guess won't cost so many trillions, arrest the development of children, and alter the mental health of the only planet we know.

disclaimer: I am not an infectious disease expert. Though I have found that those who said they were, were often very wrong. And those who trust the China data to be accurate when they delete data, or give it months later or not at all? C'mon.
 
Last edited:
WHO wanted to see the records as part of the investigation into the pandemic...they didn't need the names, just the data. It is sort of important when you have 7 billion people hostage to a virus.
China refused to provide it.

China did, however, allow them to interview the 'first case' who said that although he didn't go to a market, maybe his parents did- and then they (the parents) visited him. His parents did not get Covid.

The WHO rightly asked for anything and everything, but there are some things that couldn't be handed out under Chinese law but these would be denied under the laws of most western nations as well.

More to the point what specific critical information do you think China has held back? In terms of tracking the pandemic dates, places and where patients lived/worked was all available, so what specific info is missing?
 
The WHO rightly asked for anything and everything, but there are some things that couldn't be handed out under Chinese law but these would be denied under the laws of most western nations as well.

More to the point what specific critical information do you think China has held back? In terms of tracking the pandemic dates, places and where patients lived/worked was all available, so what specific info is missing?

Tedros (WHO) and many others in the international scientific community want the raw data, not personal information. Almost 3 years into this, China still doesn't provide it. There is no violation . Scientific studies share it all the time. Clinical studies are literally made from it without giving personal information.

The genetic database, which was online to a consortium of international researchers for 10 years til taken offline in Autumn of 2019 is also not available to this day.

Are you thinking China is being super honest, forthright, and ethical about the sharing what they can of the early days of Covid in their city? Do you maybe possibly think they had reason to hide things. Do you think the us govt might have reason to as well?

Do you believe China when they say they shut down the wildlife market in 2020? hint: they did not. Not that it matters. But maybe you'll argue that they sent strong letters out.
 
Tedros (WHO) and many others in the international scientific community want the raw data, not personal information.

So you don't have an example of any specific information that isn't available.

The genetic database, which was online to a consortium of international researchers for 10 years til taken offline in Autumn of 2019 is also not available to this day.

What makes you say it isn't available. It's not online, but that isn't the same thing at all.
 
Agree. They were. Not very viral, and in rural areas.



They took a small fraction of potential viruses and did research to see if they could be made to infect humans. That is putting the collectors and lab workers in danger. Historically, we know this to be true. That is also potentially making a blueprint for a bioweapon.
In doing so, it unnecessarily puts everyone on our planet also in danger, the same danger they have if the risk becomes actualized and human vectors then walk around in public unaware. Do it enough, and the results are more predictable than anything nature would do if left alone.
It is becoming less of a rarity with each year that the science is way cheaper and much more available- globally.

None of this research has resulted in preventing an outbreak. Not in 30 years of trying. What was done, without manipulating viruses, was to show areas that are more dangerous, specific animal vectors that are more dangerous.

Maybe we should not bring those dangers, year after year, altering them to be more dangerous to humans, to see the danger to humans, and into a highly populated city with the hutzpah to think everything is super safe. Leaks happen. Viruses have been altered to kill, even accidentally.




So what to do now? Do you think scientists should continue to go out into rural areas to collect small samples from the hundreds of thousands of potential threats out there for spillover and manipulate them to infect human cells, .... to protect humanity? Just to see? Just to be published? Should the US fund our adversaries to see how close a virus may be to being a danger to humans- by MAKING it so? ?

That makes ZERO sense to me. It is a recipe for a pandemic, not from animals, but human fallibility (or worse)- and we see it now.

Perhaps we should put efforts into EARLY and extensive monitoring and testing any anomolies in animal populations or in human symptoms that would give us rapid responses.
I'll guess won't cost so many trillions, arrest the development of children, and alter the mental health of the only planet we know.

disclaimer: I am not an infectious disease expert. Though I have found that those who said they were, were often very wrong. And those who trust the China data to be accurate when they delete data, or give it months later or not at all? C'mon.

I am not sure what you think 'gain of function' research does. It is not a blueprint for a bioweapon. There are lots of potentially much more effective agents already, the problem with bioweapons is delivery and control.

An area where gain of function is life saving is developing phage therapy.

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmicb.2021.653107/full
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41587-019-0133-z

So you are arguing against doing reseach because it is 'scary', preventing the development of therapies that can deal with the issue of developing antibiotic resistance and may be very effective for bacteril pandemics such as TB.

The danger as we have seen with SARS, SARS-CoV-2, MERS, Mpox, Nipah, etc. is not 'collectors', but human impact on the environment, human / animal contacts, combined with globalisation and urbanisation. Small nosocomial events are probably reasonably common, but in rural areas they probably die out, major transmission events only occur in urban areas.

Most large Chinese cities will have virology laboratories. Many will be doing research involving coronaviruses because that is a virus of major concern in China after SARS. So an outbreak in many Chinese cities would have been in a city with a virology laboratory doing coronavirus research.

If HPAI AH5N1 crosses into humans we will be doing the same thing all over again, closing schools, promoting masks and social distancing.
 
I am not sure what you think 'gain of function' research does. It is not a blueprint for a bioweapon. There are lots of potentially much more effective agents already, the problem with bioweapons is delivery and control.

An area where gain of function is life saving is developing phage therapy.

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmicb.2021.653107/full
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41587-019-0133-z

So you are arguing against doing reseach because it is 'scary', preventing the development of therapies that can deal with the issue of developing antibiotic resistance and may be very effective for bacteril pandemics such as TB.

The danger as we have seen with SARS, SARS-CoV-2, MERS, Mpox, Nipah, etc. is not 'collectors', but human impact on the environment, human / animal contacts, combined with globalisation and urbanisation. Small nosocomial events are probably reasonably common, but in rural areas they probably die out, major transmission events only occur in urban areas.

Most large Chinese cities will have virology laboratories. Many will be doing research involving coronaviruses because that is a virus of major concern in China after SARS. So an outbreak in many Chinese cities would have been in a city with a virology laboratory doing coronavirus research.

If HPAI AH5N1 crosses into humans we will be doing the same thing all over again, closing schools, promoting masks and social distancing.

I'm not sure you understood my point. ??

I am against doing gain-of-function to see if a virus can be made to infect humans and cause boduly harm, or death.

In the case of 'many' laboratories, there are 2 people in the world that were deemed 'batman' and 'bat woman'- experts that were looked to for research on bat-derived SARS-like coronaviruses - predating the current pandemic for many years. One is Baric in North Carolina (UNC) and the other is Shi (WIV) in Wuhan. Baric taught Shi a no-see-um method for manipulating the genes of these viruses.

This emerged in Wuhan, near Shi's lab at WIV, far from the closest known sources.

That this likelihood of a lab leak, given the proximity, was summarily dismissed as racist crackpot fringe fantasist CTer thinking within mere weeks of the outbreak is astonishing. It was not good science to conclude 'natural spillover' before much was even known at the time.

Even if many still think it is mere coincidence, I'm hopeful that the skeptical will be open-minded to reconsider when (and if) more evidence is disclosed. The tide seems to be moving slowly in that direction...and only in that direction.
 
Agree. They were. Not very viral, and in rural areas.
That's naive. Rural areas are not cut off from urban areas - they are where minerals are mined, crops are grown and animals raised. How do you think that stuff gets to the cities? And these days even rural people don't stay in one place for their whole lives.

As Covid-19 mutated it became more effective at spreading. Alpha was 50 times more transmissible than the original strain, Delta was 50% more transmissible than Alpha, and Omicron is 3 times more transmissible than Delta and has a higher rate of reinfection. To prevent pandemics we need to detect and squash these viruses while they are still 'not very viral'.

Bat origin of human coronaviruses
Abstract

Bats have been recognized as the natural reservoirs of a large variety of viruses. Special attention has been paid to bat coronaviruses as the two emerging coronaviruses which have caused unexpected human disease outbreaks in the 21st century... Various species of horseshoe bats in China have been found to harbor genetically diverse SARS-like coronaviruses... On the other hand, diverse coronaviruses phylogenetically related to MERS-CoV have been discovered worldwide in a wide range of bat species...

SARS first emerged in late 2002 in Guangdong Province, southern China... Being highly transmissible among humans, SARS rapidly spread to Hong Kong and other provinces across China and then to other 28 countries... early cases of SARS in 2002–2003 and all 4 cases in 2003–2004 had a history of animal contact through animal trade in wet markets or in restaurants where live animals were kept in Guangdong Province.

Several years before the outbreak of SARS, two other zoonotic viruses, Nipah virus and Hendra virus, emerged in Asia and Australia and they were both known to be originated from bats... SL-CoVs were also discovered in rhinolophids from Slovenia, Bulgaria and Italy...

HCoV-229E was found in the 1960s and causes comparatively mild common colds worldwide. A bat coronavirus detected in Hipposideros caffer ruber in Ghana termed Hipposideros/GhanaKwam/19/2008 was genetically related to HCoV-229E...

Conclusions

Although the study of bat-borne coronaviruses has only started just about 10 years ago, the scientific community has already learnt a great deal of useful lessons which will be instrumental in mitigating, predicting, and preventing future zoonotic coronavirus outbreaks. Some of these lessons are summarized below.

Bats harbor coronaviruses with great genetic diversity. It is believed that most, if not all, currently circulating alphacoronaviruses and betacoronaviruses in different mammals are evolutionally linked to ancestral coronaviruses originated from bats. Different species of rhinolophid bats in China carry genetically diverse SARS-like coronaviruses, some of which are direct ancestors of SARS-CoV and hence have the potential to cause direct interspecies transmission to humans.
Date of that article? 22 December 2015.

Most large Chinese cities will have virology laboratories. Many will be doing research involving coronaviruses because that is a virus of major concern in China after SARS. So an outbreak in many Chinese cities would have been in a city with a virology laboratory doing coronavirus research.
If there wasn't a virology laboratory in Wuhan, the haters would have found something else to blame. If there were no virology labs in the whole of China - it would be a secret lab that the Chinese were hiding from us.
 
That's naive. Rural areas are not cut off from urban areas - they are where minerals are mined, crops are grown and animals raised. How do you think that stuff gets to the cities? And these days even rural people don't stay in one place for their whole lives.

As Covid-19 mutated it became more effective at spreading. Alpha was 50 times more transmissible than the original strain, Delta was 50% more transmissible than Alpha, and Omicron is 3 times more transmissible than Delta and has a higher rate of reinfection. To prevent pandemics we need to detect and squash these viruses while they are still 'not very viral'.

Bat origin of human coronaviruses
Date of that article? 22 December 2015.

If there wasn't a virology laboratory in Wuhan, the haters would have found something else to blame. If there were no virology labs in the whole of China - it would be a secret lab that the Chinese were hiding from us.

Ok.

By not very viral, I mean they can affect the local population but they arent endemic in those areas, meaning the spread is contained...you know, until it isnt. But more times than we'd like to know about, it jumps to a human host. The it can adapt to spread faster, and usually less harmful- but not always, as seen with Delta- and can recombine, go back and forth between other mammals, etc.... I'll be more specific in posting next time so there are no misunderstandings.

SARS-CoV-2 was a bit different in that it was infectious quickly without any evidence (that we know about) that it spread for a period of time in another mammal population (as we find in other outbreaks), or one that of the few people to get direct infection- like those miners and villagers did- happened to travel within days to Wuhan.
It could have happened. Animals with it could have traveled 1000 miles, or bit by bit spread it along a supply chain trail. So far, none have been found.

What we DO know is that people from Wuhan went there specifically to collect specimens containing potentially dangerous viruses in a cave where humans had been deathly ill and bring them back. That travel of those bat viruses (and also live bats!) are the only ones we know for sure that made the 1,000mi journey.

You can say that is conjecture. I have a mind that visualizes and maps out all the ways things can happen. And this virus could have many other ways of getting there. There just seems to be one very obvious one to look at that was squashed, vehemently, at the start. I'm skeptical.
 
Last edited:
That's naive. Rural areas are not cut off from urban areas - they are where minerals are mined, crops are grown and animals raised. How do you think that stuff gets to the cities? And these days even rural people don't stay in one place for their whole lives.

As Covid-19 mutated it became more effective at spreading. Alpha was 50 times more transmissible than the original strain, Delta was 50% more transmissible than Alpha, and Omicron is 3 times more transmissible than Delta and has a higher rate of reinfection. To prevent pandemics we need to detect and squash these viruses while they are still 'not very viral'.

Bat origin of human coronaviruses
Date of that article? 22 December 2015.

If there wasn't a virology laboratory in Wuhan, the haters would have found something else to blame. If there were no virology labs in the whole of China - it would be a secret lab that the Chinese were hiding from us.

Good points.

Why are bats such an issue?
 
Good points.

Why are bats such an issue?

They have unique immune adaptations, likely because they are the only mammals that fly. High temp, high metabolism, low immune response.

They can keep a virus or 2 without getting sick from it. And there are a crap ton of them living in close quarters.
 
They have unique immune adaptations, likely because they are the only mammals that fly. High temp, high metabolism, low immune response.

They can keep a virus or 2 without getting sick from it. And there are a crap ton of them living in close quarters.

Yeah, I seem to remember reading that bats make up something like a quarter of all mammals.

You missed another “batman” who is Linfa Wong, at Duke University in Singapore. I think he is someone who argued that bats have most viruses that can spillover to humans.

They also do other things like crap and urinate on people or door handles, and drink sap that is collected in forests (something that was implicated in a Nipah outbreak if you read the “outdated” (Skeptic Ginger) book, Spillover. Also, as suggested in the film Contagion (that describes in remarkable similarity to Covid-19) an oubreak of a Nipah-like virus, bats sometimes live in close proximity to farmed animals which are then sent around the country from rural areas to big cities. A little-known fact is that animals found to have the SARS virus actually turned up in Hubei province a few years after the original outbreak of SARS. Hubei province is the same province in which Wuhan is located. This suggests that that whole “oh what a coinkydink!” might not have been as coincidental as is being argued.
 
OK, you all get gold stars. Lots of bat species. Different bat species live in close contact with each other. Bats fly. Result lots of bat viruses, lots of crossover between bat viruses, bat viruses become wide spread. Limited but some contact between bats and humans, but importantly some bats enter urban areas. Hence bats are very high risk for zoonotic pandemic infections.
 
It appears that some virus sequences appeared on GenBank in 2022 that were initially submitted in 2018 for a paper about the evolution of SARS-CoV. Apparently some students under Zhengi-Shi tried to get a paper featuring these sequences published, but the paper was rejected by a number of journals because they did not contain whole genome sequences.

One of the sequences is RaTG13. However, nothing closer to SARS-CoV2 than RaTG13 exists among the sequences. This suggests that the work the WIV was doing prior to the Covid outbreak was indeed as they have been claiming, rather than with the SARS-CoV2 progenitor that lab leak enthusiasts claim.

Link
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom