Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
This has already been discussed at length in the thread. No, there is nothing impossible that would rule out natural evolution of COVID. The problem is all that leaves a trail, and with COVID after 3 years there is still no trail it happened naturally except a flawed (missing data) epidemiological study. Yes it took a number of years to find the reservoir for SARS, but it didn't take any time at all to find the intermediate species from which the virus jumped to people.

Neither hypothesis has been proved, lab leak nor spillover. What are we left with?

COVID appeared out of the blue only a short distance from the WIV where coincidentally they were studying coronaviruses related to SARS and they were doing so in a level 2 biosafety lab. In addition there was another lab only a couple miles from the seafood market, the Chinese CDC that was also studying coronaviruses. And they moved into a nearby new building about the time of the initial outbreak. Moving risks breaches of infection control.

There was a super-spreader event at the seafood market. There was a potential link specifically to raccoon dogs sold at the market in a particular stall. One researcher, Worobey, documented early spread from the market outward.

The problem is China clamped down on the information of the actual earliest cases and the researcher, Worobey, ignored that missing data. What we did know before the actual earliest patient data was hidden was that several of the patients had absolutely no connection to the seafood market.

Science; Jan 2020: Wuhan seafood market may not be source of novel virus spreading globally - Description of earliest cases suggests outbreak began elsewhere

The WHO requested that information on those 41 cases but China blocked further release of the data and the Chinese researchers were told to shut up. A memo went out to the area labs telling them to purge any related genomes in their data bases, to destroy any coronavirus positive specimens they had and to not test any future specimens. (citations are in this thread)

Back to the raccoon dogs, no raccoon dogs anywhere have been found that had any coronavirus circulating that was close to COVID. That leaves 4 options.

1) Despite an extensive search we've still not found the source of a COVID variant circulating in any raccoon dogs in other markets and coincidentally no circulating virus jumped to humans outside of Wuhan.

2) The first case of human adapted coronavirus appeared as a spontaneous variant in only a couple animals at the market that coincidentally became the source of a super spreader event. One has to ignore the 14 earliest cases China won't share data on that have no connection to the market.

3) Someone traveling from Yunnan, Laos or elsewhere was directly infected by a bat and brought it to Wuhan without infecting anyone along the way.

4) Or, the virus was adapted to humans in the lab and that's why it appeared abruptly on the scene ~Nov 2019 and needed no further circulating in humans to adapt to rapid person to person spread.​

Number 4 is the most plausible and the only one that there isn't data one would expect if it were one of the other 3.

From your post

The paper, written by a large group of Chinese researchers from several institutions, offers details about the first 41 hospitalized patients who had confirmed infections with what has been dubbed 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV). In the earliest case, the patient became ill on 1 December 2019 and had no reported link to the seafood market, the authors report. "No epidemiological link was found between the first patient and later cases," they state. Their data also show that, in total, 13 of the 41 cases had no link to the marketplace. "That's a big number, 13, with no link," says Daniel Lucey, an infectious disease specialist at Georgetown University.

Earlier reports from Chinese health authorities and the World Health Organization had said the first patient had onset of symptoms on 8 December 2019—and those reports simply said "most" cases had links to the seafood market, which was closed on 1 January.

This means that 28/41 did have a link to the market. this is actually quite a significant number, you rarely identify 100% linkage in outbreak investigations. Noticeably theyt do not give how many of these 41 cases had links to a virology laboratory. That number was zero. So 13/41 not linked to the market is evidence against the market whilst 41/41 not linked to a virology laboratory isn't evidence against a laboratory leak?

There were two seperate SARS-CoV-2 lineages that caused early cases, one of which died out, this would have to mean two seprate leak events, but would be typical for a zoonotic origin. SARS-CoV had multiple entrances into the human population.

SARS-CoV-2 did not occur out of the blue. There was SARS-CoV, MERS, HKU1, 3 previous novel coronavirus events in the last twenty years. The high risk for a novel coronavirus event was a known risk. The first outbreak will alweays be the first.

We do not know the zoonotic origin of Ebola, nor thye origin of the recent global outbreak of mpox, from past experience it may take years or never to identify the source.

There is no evidence the virus was 'adapted' to humans, there is evidence that it is a generalist able to infect many mammal species. Subsequent evolution has shown its adaption to humans.
 
I just worry that all this is a bit like the Cubans being responsible for Havanna syndrome. Politically convenient. Lots of opinions by governmental organisations with little apparent expertise in the area. A growing consensus view by independant experts that the true nature of the problem is not due to wicked communists.
Do you have some knowledge about what expertise the DoE used to analyze the lab leak hypothesis or are you imagining said expertise based on the name of the department? :rolleyes:

From what I see they mostly have done computational work. Actual virology seems to be done by collaborating institutions.
Same question. What exactly do you see in a confidential report not released to the public yet?


From your post

This means that 28/41 did have a link to the market. this is actually quite a significant number, you rarely identify 100% linkage in outbreak investigations. Noticeably theyt do not give how many of these 41 cases had links to a virology laboratory. That number was zero. So 13/41 not linked to the market is evidence against the market whilst 41/41 not linked to a virology laboratory isn't evidence against a laboratory leak?
Virology is one aspect of epidemiology but certainly patterns of spread is another. Worobey's whole study was based on mapping the early cases and showing they spread out from the market. I find it especially annoying however how much credence is applied to his study while they ignore the missing data. You claim that missing data on the earliest 13 of 41 cases isn't significant. What kind of math are you using? :boggled:

As for none of them being linked to the lab, well d'uh. That is an obvious reason the Chinese government would want to withhold the data on those specific cases. There is that early report of 3 WIV lab workers who had pneumonia. Shi denied anyone at the WIV had had pneumonia but then she denied access to the actual data when the WHO team investigating the origin of COVID asked for it.

There's easily a pseudo-appearance of the origin in the market if all you are analyzing are the cases that came from there. This is especially true given we know a super-spreader event took place there. We've seen many other super-spreader events with COVID.


... There were two seperate SARS-CoV-2 lineages that caused early cases, one of which died out, this would have to mean two seprate leak events, but would be typical for a zoonotic origin. SARS-CoV had multiple entrances into the human population.
SARS had multiple entrances into the population in Guangdong that were well documented from more than one wet market. Then it circulated in the human population for a month or more before it gained a better adaptation to human cells. Only then did the dangerous SARS outbreak occur. It was found that a closely related coronavirus was circulating in civet cats resulting in the jump to humans. And that is how it ended up in multiple wet markets.

As for the 2 lineages, one would expect to find a similar viral strain circulating in a source animal population. That has not been found.

Those 2 strains are not so far apart genetically that B couldn't be a variant of A. This was discussed already.


... SARS-CoV-2 did not occur out of the blue. There was SARS-CoV, MERS, HKU1, 3 previous novel coronavirus events in the last twenty years. The high risk for a novel coronavirus event was a known risk. The first outbreak will alweays be the first.

We do not know the zoonotic origin of Ebola, nor thye origin of the recent global outbreak of mpox, from past experience it may take years or never to identify the source.

There is no evidence the virus was 'adapted' to humans, there is evidence that it is a generalist able to infect many mammal species. Subsequent evolution has shown its adaption to humans.
This is not accurate. The source of ebola has a different history.

History of ebola
African fruit bats are likely involved in the spread of Ebola virus and may even be the source animal (reservoir host). Scientists continue to search for conclusive evidence of the bat’s role in transmission of Ebola. 1 The most recent Ebola virus to be detected, Bombali virus, was identified in samples from bats collected in Sierra Leone.2
Those bats infect intermediate animals that infect humans but at least one outbreak was traced to the bats directly.

Bat-filled tree may have been ground zero for the Ebola epidemic - Study suggests the first known victim, a toddler, could have been infected playing in the hollow trunk

And there was this (from the CDC link):
The use of contaminated needles and syringes during the earliest outbreaks enabled transmission and amplification of Ebola virus. During the first outbreak in Zaire (now Democratic Republic of Congo – DRC), nurses in the Yambuku mission hospital reportedly used five syringes for 300 to 600 patients a day. Close contact with infected blood, reuse of contaminated needles, and improper nursing techniques were the source for much of the human-to-human transmission during early Ebola outbreaks.3

So it's nothing like what has occurred in Wuhan where the source of a spillover hasn't been found after 3 years of searching. There was no lab studying ebola viruses in Africa before an outbreak began.


Regardless of the original source, monkeypox was first seen in a monkey colony kept in a lab.
CDC
Mpox was discovered in 1958 when two outbreaks of a pox-like disease occurred in colonies of monkeys kept for research. Despite being named “monkeypox,” the source of the disease remains unknown. However, African rodents and non-human primates (like monkeys) might harbor the virus and infect people.

The first human case of mpox was recorded in 1970. Prior to the 2022 outbreak, mpox had been reported in people in several central and western African countries. Previously, almost all mpox cases in people outside of Africa were linked to international travel to countries where the disease commonly occurs or through imported animals. These cases occurred on multiple continents.
There is no mystery there.


As for SARS, MERS and HKU1, you misunderstand what I mean by out of the blue. Only SARS resulted in a pandemic and it was short-lived because there were no mild cases. Contract tracing was effective. MERS did not result in a pandemic and neither has HKU1.

Coronavirus HKU1 Infection in the United States
Again no pandemic.

Out of the blue when it comes to COVID means it was well adapted to humans. Being a "generalist" virus was one hypothesis. It has not been supported as explaining how well COVID was adapted to humans when it first appeared.


You are rehashing old **** that has already been discussed. Got anything new?
 
Last edited:
Do you have some knowledge about what expertise the DoE used to analyze the lab leak hypothesis or are you imagining said expertise based on the name of the department? :rolleyes:

Same question. What exactly do you see in a confidential report not released to the public yet?



Virology is one aspect of epidemiology but certainly patterns of spread is another. Worobey's whole study was based on mapping the early cases and showing they spread out from the market. I find it especially annoying however how much credence is applied to his study while they ignore the missing data. You claim that missing data on the earliest 13 of 41 cases isn't significant. What kind of math are you using? :boggled:

As for none of them being linked to the lab, well d'uh. That is an obvious reason the Chinese government would want to withhold the data on those specific cases. There is that early report of 3 WIV lab workers who had pneumonia. Shi denied anyone at the WIV had had pneumonia but then she denied access to the actual data when the WHO team investigating the origin of COVID asked for it.

There's easily a pseudo-appearance of the origin in the market if all you are analyzing are the cases that came from there. This is especially true given we know a super-spreader event took place there. We've seen many other super-spreader events with COVID.


SARS had multiple entrances into the population in Guangdong that were well documented from more than one wet market. Then it circulated in the human population for a month or more before it gained a better adaptation to human cells. Only then did the dangerous SARS outbreak occur. It was found that a closely related coronavirus was circulating in civet cats resulting in the jump to humans. And that is how it ended up in multiple wet markets.

As for the 2 lineages, one would expect to find a similar viral strain circulating in a source animal population. That has not been found.

Those 2 strains are not so far apart genetically that B couldn't be a variant of A. This was discussed already.


This is not accurate. The source of ebola has a different history.

History of ebolaThose bats infect intermediate animals that infect humans but at least one outbreak was traced to the bats directly.

Bat-filled tree may have been ground zero for the Ebola epidemic - Study suggests the first known victim, a toddler, could have been infected playing in the hollow trunk

And there was this (from the CDC link):

So it's nothing like what has occurred in Wuhan where the source of a spillover hasn't been found after 3 years of searching. There was no lab studying ebola viruses in Africa before an outbreak began.


Regardless of the original source, monkeypox was first seen in a monkey colony kept in a lab.
CDCThere is no mystery there.


As for SARS, MERS and HKU1, you misunderstand what I mean by out of the blue. Only SARS resulted in a pandemic and it was short-lived because there were no mild cases. Contract tracing was effective. MERS did not result in a pandemic and neither has HKU1.

Coronavirus HKU1 Infection in the United States
Again no pandemic.

Out of the blue when it comes to COVID means it was well adapted to humans. Being a "generalist" virus was one hypothesis. It has not been supported as explaining how well COVID was adapted to humans when it first appeared.


You are rehashing old **** that has already been discussed. Got anything new?

It is not the earliest 13 out of 41, but 13 out of the earliest 41.
 
Do you have some knowledge about what expertise the DoE used to analyze the lab leak hypothesis or are you imagining said expertise based on the name of the department? :rolleyes:

Same question. What exactly do you see in a confidential report not released to the public yet?

I think this is the issue, isn't it.

There is nothing new as far as we know.
 
It is not the earliest 13 out of 41, but 13 out of the earliest 41.
There can only be 1 patient zero (or 2 if you buy the 2 lineages meant two spillovers). There were cases before those 41. This stuff was brushed under the rug by Jan 2020 though it keeps rearing its head.

I posted all this already but people insist on repeating old arguments yet again.

Reuters: First COVID-19 case could have emerged in China in Oct 2019 - study
The virus that causes COVID-19 could have started spreading in China as early as October 2019, two months before the first case was identified in the central city of Wuhan, a new study showed on Friday.

Researchers from Britain's University of Kent used methods from conservation science to estimate that SARS-CoV-2 first appeared from early October to mid-November 2019, according to a paper published in the PLOS Pathogens journal. ...

However, some early cases had no known connection with Huanan, implying that SARS-CoV-2 was already circulating before it reached the market.

A joint study published by China and the World Health Organization at the end of March acknowledged there could have been sporadic human infections before the Wuhan outbreak.


Jesse Bloom of the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in Seattle recovered deleted sequencing data from early COVID-19 cases in China.

The data showed that samples taken from the Huanan market were "not representative" of SARS-CoV-2 as a whole, and were a variant of a progenitor sequence circulating earlier, which spread to other parts of China.


This is where Bloom had an issue:
The U.S. National Institutes of Health confirmed to Reuters that the samples used in the study were submitted to the Sequence Read Archive (SRA) in March 2020 and later deleted at the request of Chinese investigators, who said they would be updated and submitted to another archive.
Dr Bloom walked back his assertion the deleted coronavirus genomes was done purposefully by Dr Shi to coverup cases connected to her research. That did not change the fact of his analysis though he has since been overly generous in his trust of Shi.


More research forgotten:
Another study by Australian scientists, published on Thursday in the Scientific Reports journal, used genomic data to show SARS-CoV-2 binds to human receptors far more easily than other species, suggesting it was already adapted to humans when it first emerged.

It said it was possible there was another unidentified animal with even stronger affinity that served as an intermediary species, but the hypothesis that it leaked from the lab could not be ruled out.


Anyone have anything new or any comments on the EcoHealth Alliance VP's whistleblowing? Or has Biden released any of the DoE analysis?

Here, I'll make it easy for everyone so we can move past all the ad nauseum arguments we've already discussed: Huff thinks the FBI was involved and has tried to shut him up. You might also want to look at EcoHealth Alliances' response to Huff.

Right off the bat in the latter are several falsehoods that are supportable like the claim the ECA isn't really connected to the WIV because they don't do direct research and 2 they deny any GoF research despite the fact Dazsak and Shi are authors on a paper before the pandemic describing their GoF research.

I can't address the assertions about the FBI until I see Huff's book.
 
Last edited:
Anyone have anything new or any comments on the EcoHealth Alliance VP's whistleblowing? Or has Biden released any of the DoE analysis?

Here, I'll make it easy for everyone so we can move past all the ad nauseum arguments we've already discussed: Huff thinks the FBI was involved and has tried to shut him up. You might also want to look at EcoHealth Alliances' response to Huff.

Right off the bat in the latter are several falsehoods that are supportable like the claim the ECA isn't really connected to the WIV because they don't do direct research and 2 they deny any GoF research despite the fact Dazsak and Shi are authors on a paper before the pandemic describing their GoF research.

I can't address the assertions about the FBI until I see Huff's book.

This Andrew Huff?
 
Last edited:
Is he really your guy?
 

Attachments

  • Andrew Huff 2.jpg
    Andrew Huff 2.jpg
    59.4 KB · Views: 4
  • Andrew Huff Infowars 2.jpg
    Andrew Huff Infowars 2.jpg
    22.8 KB · Views: 4
  • Andrew Huff 3.jpg
    Andrew Huff 3.jpg
    45.3 KB · Views: 4
  • Andrew Huff Infowars TV.jpg
    Andrew Huff Infowars TV.jpg
    65.9 KB · Views: 4
Huff thinks the FBI was involved and has tried to shut him up. You might also want to look at EcoHealth Alliances' response to Huff.

Huff thinks the FBI is involved and tried to shut him up?

LOL! The FBI is the agency that is most convinced of the lab leak. Why would they try to shut him up?

Two possiblities spring to mind:

1. Huff is a liar.
2. Huff is correct but the FBI are limited hangout shills who are trying to cover-up their part in the lizard Apocalypse and all the clues are there with the railroad, the power plants.... the eggs... yeah man, they are trying to destroy eggs because that's how conventional vaccines are made and they want to make mRNA ones which change your DNA and let Bill Gates control you with chips...dude, this weed is awesome although it is making me a bit paranoid.
 
That will be a circus. Is Rand Paul on that committee?

Yes, probably a circus. Or a witch trial. Wade, Redfield and Metzl will be there.

Some pretty typical comment in response to Daszak’s announcement. Some people made up their minds long ago.
 

Attachments

  • 3CAA1C16-5085-4329-B51C-D313D1A303D0.jpg
    3CAA1C16-5085-4329-B51C-D313D1A303D0.jpg
    55.2 KB · Views: 9
Yep, the very one I suggested you look at. :thumbsup:

And yes I've seen everything from his interview with Bannon to the rest. But none of that matters if we look at the verifiable claims he's made and nothing else.

For example he noted the US gov did a piss poor job monitoring where the money went when it came to GoF research. The OIG (Office of Inspector General) found the same thing.
The National Institutes of Health and EcoHealth Alliance Did Not Effectively Monitor Awards and Subawards, Resulting in Missed Opportunities to Oversee Research and Other Deficiencies
What OIG Found
Despite identifying potential risks associated with research being performed under the EcoHealth awards, we found that NIH did not effectively monitor or take timely action to address EcoHealth's compliance with some requirements. Although NIH and EcoHealth had established monitoring procedures, we found deficiencies in complying with those procedures limited NIH and EcoHealth's ability to effectively monitor Federal grant awards and subawards to understand the nature of the research conducted, identify potential problem areas, and take corrective action. Using its discretion, NIH did not refer the research to HHS for an outside review for enhanced potential pandemic pathogens (ePPPs) because it determined the research did not involve and was not reasonably anticipated to create, use, or transfer an ePPP. However, NIH added a special term and condition in EcoHealth's awards and provided limited guidance on how EcoHealth should comply with that requirement. We found that NIH was only able to conclude that research resulted in virus growth that met specified benchmarks based on a late progress report from EcoHealth that NIH failed to follow up on until nearly 2 years after its due date. Based on these findings, we conclude that NIH missed opportunities to more effectively monitor research. With improved oversight, NIH may have been able to take more timely corrective actions to mitigate the inherent risks associated with this type of research.

We identified several other deficiencies in the oversight of the awards. Some of these deficiencies include: NIH's improper termination of a grant; EcoHealth's inability to obtain scientific documentation from WIV; and EcoHealth's improper use of grant funds, resulting in $89,171 in unallowable costs.

... Although WIV cooperated with EcoHealth's monitoring for several years, WIV's lack of cooperation following the COVID 19 outbreak limited EcoHealth's ability to monitor its subrecipient. ...
I posted evidence of this very thing upthread and now the OIG corroborates the documents I cited.

There's more but I'll try to do this one subject at a time.
 
Senate votes to declassify origin intelligence:

https://news.bloomberglaw.com/healt...d-origins-declassification-by-biden-spy-chief

The Senate voted unanimously Wednesday night to require Director of National Intelligence Avril Haines to declassify information on the origin of Covid-19.

The bill (S. 619), which passed without objection or a roll-call vote, could put pressure on the Biden administration to voluntarily declassify.

The move comes after the Wall Street Journal reported that Haines’s office provided classified intelligence to the White House and key members of Congress showing the Energy Department had concluded Covid most likely came from a lab leak in China.

eta^ I checked on this to see what it really said (as I like to do!)...It isnt on their official senate list but there is a video of it.
I think the S619 bill sought to consider the unanimous consent for reconsideration of a bill as now read 3 times and, because of that, it is passed with unanimous consent- and that is what was what was passed. No vote. Just 30 seconds of procedure.

Anyone want to watch c-span and figure out why I barely understand what I just wrote??

https://www.c-span.org/video/?c5059774/user-clip-s19-unanimous-consent-request

eta#2:
ahhh. This bill passed in 2021, unanimously. It is now reintroduced - so it goes to the House for consideration now. Must have been dumped last time.
 
Last edited:
It is not the earliest 13 out of 41, but 13 out of the earliest 41.

41 diagnosed. Given how many covid infections have either no symptoms or only mild symptoms there were likely several hundred cases at the time so we are likely talking about 5-7 jumps from the original infection. It's no surprise that this far in some people who hadn't been to the market were infected.

It's worth noting, however, that all these people lived close to the market and not close to the lab. "The lab" keeps changing, the closest lab was was run by the Chinese NIH and is sometimes attributed instead even though the WIV didn't work there but it's still farther away from the reported cases than the market. Regardless, the early cases clearly cluster near the market, not a lab, regardless of which lab you are talking about.
 
In the earliest case, the patient became ill on 1 December 2019 and had no reported link to the seafood market, the authors report.

The earliest know case was infected around Dec 8. The patient referenced above was admitted to hospital on Dec 1 but not with Covid they contracted Covid weeks later and were not one of the earliest cases.
 
:popcorn1

There's an FBI report that needs to be released as well.

Okay, presumably because that one will contain the smoking gun?

Yet if there is something they know that made them "moderately confident", would they not share this information with the rest of the intelligence community?
 
“It is incorrect to frame this issue as scientifically undecided,” said Prof Angie Rasmussen of the University of Saskatchewan in Canada. “Two prior studies – one of which I co-authored – demonstrate clearly using multiple lines of evidence that the pandemic emerged into the human population at least twice over an approximately two-week period at or immediately upstream of Huanan market in association with the live animal trade,” she said.

“Any data suggesting a lab leak would have to be consistent with this evidence. So far, all competing hypotheses challenging our findings have failed to pass peer review. Since the DoE findings are described as ‘weak’ and ‘low confidence’, I’d be surprised if this new intelligence meets that bar.”
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2...uld-we-take-the-us-does-covid-lab-leak-theory

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abp8715
 
.... It's worth noting, however, that all these people lived close to the market and not close to the lab. ...
This needs some common sense addressing:

There's not evidence of ongoing transmission at the lab so of course you won't see clusters near the lab. In addition the cases were identified (IIRC) initially from the hospitals they were seen at. The earliest cases were found going back through hospital records. We don't know if they had a connection to the WIV because China is refusing to disclose that data.

Of the 41, which doesn't include the actual first case because earlier cases have been identified, 30% had no connection to the market. Worobey attributes that to unrecognized community spread. That makes perfect sense and it happened here in WA State. Three cases were identified as being genetically related but they were far apart and the cases in between were not found.

Back to Captain Obvious: If only 1 or maybe 3 persons were infected by a lab error they could have started a community spread. There are a lot of possible reasons they didn't infect a cluster of colleagues at the lab.
They might have stayed home when they were symptomatic.
There might have been cases among people at the WIV that didn't warrant going to the hospital.
People wear masks and gloves in BSL2.
​
Bottom line, cases did not necessarily cluster around patient zero.
Here in WA the first recognized outbreak was a super spreader event at a nursing home in Kirkland WA. The first case came in from China to Everett WA and showed up at a hospital. No cases were found among the people he traveled on the plane with, none in his household and none were infected in the hospital. The additional case was in Seattle and was found in a flu screening study.

If you were to look at the epidemiology you would find a significant cluster of cases were centered around the nursing home. Patients, staff and visitors were infected. The outbreak was recognized by an ED doc one of the nursing home patients was taken to.

Applying that same pattern you have patient zero leaving the lab with the virus. It spreads in the community somewhere and a few patients show up at area hospitals but no one is looking for COVID yet. Then the cluster shows up connected to the super spreader event at the market and that is where it is recognized as a new pathogen.

It might look like the bulk of cases connected to the market must include patient zero. But it only takes one person getting infected in the lab to start the spread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom