This has already been discussed at length in the thread. No, there is nothing impossible that would rule out natural evolution of COVID. The problem is all that leaves a trail, and with COVID after 3 years there is still no trail it happened naturally except a flawed (missing data) epidemiological study. Yes it took a number of years to find the reservoir for SARS, but it didn't take any time at all to find the intermediate species from which the virus jumped to people.
Neither hypothesis has been proved, lab leak nor spillover. What are we left with?
COVID appeared out of the blue only a short distance from the WIV where coincidentally they were studying coronaviruses related to SARS and they were doing so in a level 2 biosafety lab. In addition there was another lab only a couple miles from the seafood market, the Chinese CDC that was also studying coronaviruses. And they moved into a nearby new building about the time of the initial outbreak. Moving risks breaches of infection control.
There was a super-spreader event at the seafood market. There was a potential link specifically to raccoon dogs sold at the market in a particular stall. One researcher, Worobey, documented early spread from the market outward.
The problem is China clamped down on the information of the actual earliest cases and the researcher, Worobey, ignored that missing data. What we did know before the actual earliest patient data was hidden was that several of the patients had absolutely no connection to the seafood market.
Science; Jan 2020: Wuhan seafood market may not be source of novel virus spreading globally - Description of earliest cases suggests outbreak began elsewhere
The WHO requested that information on those 41 cases but China blocked further release of the data and the Chinese researchers were told to shut up. A memo went out to the area labs telling them to purge any related genomes in their data bases, to destroy any coronavirus positive specimens they had and to not test any future specimens. (citations are in this thread)
Back to the raccoon dogs, no raccoon dogs anywhere have been found that had any coronavirus circulating that was close to COVID. That leaves 4 options.
1) Despite an extensive search we've still not found the source of a COVID variant circulating in any raccoon dogs in other markets and coincidentally no circulating virus jumped to humans outside of Wuhan.
2) The first case of human adapted coronavirus appeared as a spontaneous variant in only a couple animals at the market that coincidentally became the source of a super spreader event. One has to ignore the 14 earliest cases China won't share data on that have no connection to the market.
3) Someone traveling from Yunnan, Laos or elsewhere was directly infected by a bat and brought it to Wuhan without infecting anyone along the way.
4) Or, the virus was adapted to humans in the lab and that's why it appeared abruptly on the scene ~Nov 2019 and needed no further circulating in humans to adapt to rapid person to person spread.
Number 4 is the most plausible and the only one that there isn't data one would expect if it were one of the other 3.
From your post
The paper, written by a large group of Chinese researchers from several institutions, offers details about the first 41 hospitalized patients who had confirmed infections with what has been dubbed 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV). In the earliest case, the patient became ill on 1 December 2019 and had no reported link to the seafood market, the authors report. "No epidemiological link was found between the first patient and later cases," they state. Their data also show that, in total, 13 of the 41 cases had no link to the marketplace. "That's a big number, 13, with no link," says Daniel Lucey, an infectious disease specialist at Georgetown University.
Earlier reports from Chinese health authorities and the World Health Organization had said the first patient had onset of symptoms on 8 December 2019—and those reports simply said "most" cases had links to the seafood market, which was closed on 1 January.
This means that 28/41 did have a link to the market. this is actually quite a significant number, you rarely identify 100% linkage in outbreak investigations. Noticeably theyt do not give how many of these 41 cases had links to a virology laboratory. That number was zero. So 13/41 not linked to the market is evidence against the market whilst 41/41 not linked to a virology laboratory isn't evidence against a laboratory leak?
There were two seperate SARS-CoV-2 lineages that caused early cases, one of which died out, this would have to mean two seprate leak events, but would be typical for a zoonotic origin. SARS-CoV had multiple entrances into the human population.
SARS-CoV-2 did not occur out of the blue. There was SARS-CoV, MERS, HKU1, 3 previous novel coronavirus events in the last twenty years. The high risk for a novel coronavirus event was a known risk. The first outbreak will alweays be the first.
We do not know the zoonotic origin of Ebola, nor thye origin of the recent global outbreak of mpox, from past experience it may take years or never to identify the source.
There is no evidence the virus was 'adapted' to humans, there is evidence that it is a generalist able to infect many mammal species. Subsequent evolution has shown its adaption to humans.
