Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Some felt the furin cleavage site looked suspicious. This fear was dismissed as soon as it was realized this structure was commonplace in related viruses and poorly optimized for infecting humans.

Indeed, and that should be a sign that virologists DID take lab leak theory seriously, before changing their mind on the evidence.
 
"Probably implicated in a lab leak" is question-begging.

The reason why it was early on dismissed as a CT is because the early claims were that it was a bioweapon or engineered.
:rolleyes: If a lab leak is conclusively established then Daszak almost certainly knew about it and helped cover it up. It's not begging any question considering that up until the beginning of the pandemic in late 2019 Daszak was promoting research on the coronavirus supposedly to develop vaccines against them.

Have you forgotten all the evidence of Daszak pushing the CT taint on the lab origin hypothesis? Really?

An engineered bioweapon has never been seriously entertained in this thread. It had nothing to do with Daszak's letter to the Lancet or complaints to the WHO that Daszak was trying to push a false narrative.

Here's the Lancet letter:
Statement in support of the scientists, public health professionals, and medical professionals of China combatting COVID-19
We stand together to strongly condemn conspiracy theories suggesting that COVID-19 does not have a natural origin.

26 out of 27 signatories of the Lancet letter dismissing lab-leak theory of COVID-19 origin are linked to Wuhan researchers: Report
Being published in a respected medical journal, this letter had effectively shut down any serious probe into the lab leak theory for the origin of the virus at that time. While the authors of the letter had not revealed any link with the Wuhan lab, soon it was revealed that the letter was orchestrated by British zoologist Peter Daszak, president of the US-based EcoHealth Alliance, which funded research at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

In June last year, the journal was forced to issue a clarification regarding Peter Daszak’s link with the laboratory, admitting that vital information was not revealed earlier when the letter was published.
Like I said, Daszak pushed the 'lab leak was a CT' narrative and it did lasting damage ... for about a year until other researchers began to actually look at the lab leak hypothesis.


These claims came much later. The letter that you put so much weight on came out in February 2020. Who was talking about gain of funciton then?
Did I conflate gain of function research hazards with Daszak's initial efforts to call the lab leak hypothesis a CT? I did not.


Many of the lab leak proponents have been using redacted emails to claim that the scientists such as Holmes, Farrar, Fauci and Andersen believed it was a lab leak. But clearly in those emails they are initially surprised at the structure of the virus and wonder if it had been engineered (like the conspiracy theorists had been claiming with no evidence).
The emails were damning evidence but they hardly were being relied on as the most crucial evidence. Yet here we go again as has been the habit throughout this thread of spillover proponents claiming a small subsection of evidence is all or most of what evidence there is. Those emails are very damning, but they hardly represent the body of evidence supporting the lab leak hypothesis. And maybe you buy the excuses Fauci came up with but I've read the emails and Fauci's rationalization isn't credible.


Only after they looked more closely at the virus did they decide it wasn't and then they decided to write the letter in response to the conspiracy theories (and they were conspiracy theories).
CT CT CT ... yada yada. On the lab leak hypothesis side few if any in this thread are posting unsupported conclusions. Name calling it a CT does not support your position. There's no need to go over all this old ****. It has been debated ad nauseum. No one in this thread is seriously debating the bio-weapon hypothesis. The only conspiracy is that of China, Daszak and Shi hiding data and lying about not working with live bats or coronavirus cultures.


And of course, they were aware of the Wuhan Institute of Virology, so its existence also factored into their calculations about how likely it was to be engineered.
Which letter is this one? The Lancet letter? Fauci's rationalizing of the emails letter? :confused:


They also point out that it is a separate question of whether it could have been a captured virus that escaped the lab as well. But the letter was aimed at questions of an engineered virus.
Once again, no one in this thread is pushing the engineered bio-weapon hypothesis so who are you debating here?

It is not off-topic at all. Quanmen in his book Spillover argues that environmental degradation is more likely to cause spillover. Indeed, preventing environmental destruction's effects and how humans can live alongside potential dangerous pathogens is also the purpose of the Eco-Health Alliance.
You mean that old outdated, 'written before the pandemic' book? There's no doubt as we destroy animal habitats and increasingly raise domestic livestock in concentrated farms that the risk of exposure to new pathogens increases. That's why I pointed out it was on topic if Roger used it to support a spillover hypothesis. I could have missed that.
 
Last edited:
SG, you arguing for the sake of it and mixing things up. I pointed out that the letter was written before gain-of-function arguments were being made and they were addressing the bioweapon claims. This is what was discussed in the emails prior to this. I think you shouldn’t try to rewrite the history on this.
 
Indeed, and that should be a sign that virologists DID take lab leak theory seriously, before changing their mind on the evidence.
To review, I think this is where we left off in the furin discussion:

Nov 2021, Chan: How Does the SARS-CoV-2 Spike Compare with Those of Other SARSr-CoVs?
Several novel SARS-CoV-2-like genomes from horseshoe bats in Japan (Rc-o319), Cambodia (RshSTT182 and RshSTT200), Thailand (RacCS203, 224, 253, 263, and 271), Laos (BANAL-52, -103, -116, -236, and -247), and China (RpYN03-09) have been published (Murakami et al. 2020; Delaune et al. 2021; Temmam et al. 2021; Wacharapluesadee et al. 2021; Zhou et al. 2021). However, to this day, no known sarbecovirus except SARS-CoV-2 has an FCS insertion at the S1/S2 junction.

The authors concluded:
As more bat CoVs are sampled, it is possible that another SARSr-CoV will be discovered with an S1/S2 FCS insertion. FCSs have evolved naturally in other non-sarbecovirus families of betacoronaviruses (Wu and Zhao 2020). Therefore, an S1/S2 FCS emerging in a sarbecovirus is consistent with natural evolution. Even so, the knowledge that scientists had a workflow for identifying novel cleavage sites in diverse SARSr-CoVs and experimentally characterizing these cleavage sites in SARSr-CoVs—likely in a manner that makes the resulting recombinant SARSr-CoV practically indistinguishable from a rare SARSr-CoV with a naturally emerging FCS—makes it challenging to rule out an artificial origin of the SARS-CoV-2 S1/S2 FCS (Daszak 2018; Lerner and Hibbett 2021).
 
SG, you arguing for the sake of it and mixing things up. I pointed out that the letter was written before gain-of-function arguments were being made and they were addressing the bioweapon claims. This is what was discussed in the emails prior to this. I think you shouldn’t try to rewrite the history on this.

You may think your posts are clear but they are not. Perhaps you should be more precise about what you are replying and referring to. Even here you aren't clear.

Daszak's contrived letter to the Lancet talked about not persecuting researchers and about not creating CTs.

Gain of function and bioweapons had zero zilch nada to do with my posting evidence Daszak tainted the field. So why are you even referring to those?

At no point had I referred to Fauci's emails when referring to the Lancet letter and Daszak's influence on the WHO investigation.

Stop conflating the three issues and perhaps that will clear things up.
 
I’m not mixing anything up. I am clarifying things.

Your posts are full of insinuation and innuendo papering over the cracks in the argument.

If you think there was no engineering involved in your theory then where did the furin cleavage site come from?
 
Off to the races with the Fauci emails and his denial the US funded any gain of function research:

To review: I've already just re-posted evidence that the US did indeed fund gain of function research at the WIV and there is a new source noting how poorly the NIH was tracking that research. When the NIH temporarily cut off funding for GoF research in 2017, the WIV work wasn't affected.


NPR: 5 Things We Learned From Anthony Fauci's Emails
The emails are embedded in the article, all 3,234 pages of them.

This can be summed up by saying at first Fauci, Collins, Redfield and others leaned toward the lab leak hypothesis. But they changed their tune and one cannot help but think that was purely a political move. It would be silly to think it didn't dawn on these guys what the implications of a pandemic being China's fault would mean.

These emails are interesting and reveal some candid thoughts but they hardly constitute the bulk of the evidence of the lab leak hypothesis.


Now papers on the GoF research published before the pandemic is where the most significant evidence besides the genetic evidence resides.
 
I’m not mixing anything up. I am clarifying things.

Your posts are full of insinuation and innuendo papering over the cracks in the argument.
You're going to have to be more specific here.


If you think there was no engineering involved in your theory then where did the furin cleavage site come from?
Bioengineering in this thread referred to direct gene segment splicing here and there. It would have been obvious.

Gain of function research involved passing the virus through cultures of other coronaviruses and in cell lines that were close to human cell lines. Desirable outcomes were then isolated and passed through again ... rinse & repeat until you have the desired viral sequence with the gain of function you want.
 
CNN interviews one of the main WSJ reporters who wrote the article that is behind the paywall for some of us. The reason the DoE was involved is because they oversee the research labs in the US.

The first 6 min is the interview, the last 4 expands to talking about China supporting Russia.


The US Department of Energy has assessed that the Covid-19 pandemic most likely came from a laboratory leak in China, according to a newly updated classified intelligence report.

Two sources said that the Department of Energy assessed in the intelligence report that it had “low confidence” the Covid-19 virus accidentally escaped from a lab in Wuhan. ...

The latest assessment further adds to the divide in the US government over whether the Covid-19 pandemic began in China in 2019 as the result of a lab leak or whether it emerged naturally. The various intelligence agencies have been split on the matter for years. In 2021, the intelligence community declassified a report that showed four agencies in the intelligence community had assessed with low confidence that the virus likely jumped from animals to humans naturally in the wild, while one assessed with moderate confidence that the pandemic was the result of a laboratory accident.

Three other intelligence community elements were unable to coalesce around either explanation without additional information, the report said.

The Wall Street Journal first reported on the new assessment from the Department of Energy. A senior US intelligence official told the Journal that the update to the intelligence assessment was conducted in light of new intelligence, further study of academic literature and in consultation with experts outside government. ...
 
CNN interviews one of the main WSJ reporters who wrote the article that is behind the paywall for some of us. The reason the DoE was involved is because they oversee the research labs in the US.
The first 6 min is the interview, the last 4 expands to talking about China supporting Russia.


This is the problem. if they are the organisation funded to supervise research laboratories and I assume in this instance biological containment facilities, then their business is to look for leaks. It is in their interest to promote the laboratory leak theory. This will justify further funding for this area of the DoE.
 
So you are saying their area of expertise resulted in them misdiagnosing the problem. :rolleyes:

They actually went from undecided to the lab hypothesis. We don't know what new evidence changed their assessment. I doubt there is a connection to funding.
 
Last edited:
So you are saying their area of expertise resulted in them misdiagnosing the problem. :rolleyes:

They actually went from undecided to the lab hypothesis. We don't know what new evidence changed their assessment. I doubt there is a connection to funding.


Indeed. DoE runs virus labs + Virus labs leak ≠ Give DoE more money.
 
Nothing unusual about coronavirus evolution.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0092867421007091

Previous studies have revealed frequent host switching of coronaviruses among bats (Latinne et al., 2020). Indeed, we identified nearly 100% identical coronaviruses from multiple different bat species, indicative of the frequent cross-species virus transmission. As noted above, this in part likely reflects their roosting behavior and propensity to share the same or close habitats.

.... this broad geographic region in Asia is rich in many other bat families (Anthony et al., 2017) and other wildlife species that have been shown to be susceptible to SARS-CoV-2 in vitro . It is therefore essential that further surveillance efforts should cover a broader range of wild animals in this region to help track ongoing spillovers of relatives of SARS-CoV-2 and SARS-CoV, as well as other pathogenic viruses from animals to humans.

This study presents the identification of four SARS-CoV-2 related coronaviruses in bats, including one virus displaying high sequence identity to SARS-CoV-2 in most genomic regions. However, the direct evolutionary progenitor of SARS-CoV-2 remains unclear, and our sampling only considers a small number of bat species from a restricted geographic region. In addition, we did not consider other potential mammalian hosts for SARS-CoV-2 related coronaviruses that may also shed light on virus origins.

This sort of thing...where there clearly is a lot of data yet to be collected...prevents actual bilogists from saying "yes there clearly was a lab leak."
 
Indeed. DoE runs virus labs + Virus labs leak ≠ Give DoE more money.

Does the Department of Energy have any virology laboratories? Does it in fact inspect any virology laboratories? Has it fallen foul of the 'I am a physicist; I understand how the universe works, therefore I understand everything in the universe' fallacy?
 
Nothing unusual about coronavirus evolution.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0092867421007091

This sort of thing...where there clearly is a lot of data yet to be collected...prevents actual bilogists from saying "yes there clearly was a lab leak."
This has already been discussed at length in the thread. No, there is nothing impossible that would rule out natural evolution of COVID. The problem is all that leaves a trail, and with COVID after 3 years there is still no trail it happened naturally except a flawed (missing data) epidemiological study. Yes it took a number of years to find the reservoir for SARS, but it didn't take any time at all to find the intermediate species from which the virus jumped to people.

Neither hypothesis has been proved, lab leak nor spillover. What are we left with?

COVID appeared out of the blue only a short distance from the WIV where coincidentally they were studying coronaviruses related to SARS and they were doing so in a level 2 biosafety lab. In addition there was another lab only a couple miles from the seafood market, the Chinese CDC that was also studying coronaviruses. And they moved into a nearby new building about the time of the initial outbreak. Moving risks breaches of infection control.

There was a super-spreader event at the seafood market. There was a potential link specifically to raccoon dogs sold at the market in a particular stall. One researcher, Worobey, documented early spread from the market outward.

The problem is China clamped down on the information of the actual earliest cases and the researcher, Worobey, ignored that missing data. What we did know before the actual earliest patient data was hidden was that several of the patients had absolutely no connection to the seafood market.

Science; Jan 2020: Wuhan seafood market may not be source of novel virus spreading globally - Description of earliest cases suggests outbreak began elsewhere
The paper, written by a large group of Chinese researchers from several institutions, offers details about the first 41 hospitalized patients who had confirmed infections with what has been dubbed 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV). In the earliest case, the patient became ill on 1 December 2019 and had no reported link to the seafood market, the authors report. "No epidemiological link was found between the first patient and later cases," they state. Their data also show that, in total, 13 of the 41 cases had no link to the marketplace. "That's a big number, 13, with no link," says Daniel Lucey, an infectious disease specialist at Georgetown University.

Earlier reports from Chinese health authorities and the World Health Organization had said the first patient had onset of symptoms on 8 December 2019—and those reports simply said "most" cases had links to the seafood market, which was closed on 1 January.

The WHO requested that information on those 41 cases but China blocked further release of the data and the Chinese researchers were told to shut up. A memo went out to the area labs telling them to purge any related genomes in their data bases, to destroy any coronavirus positive specimens they had and to not test any future specimens. (citations are in this thread)

Back to the raccoon dogs, no raccoon dogs anywhere have been found that had any coronavirus circulating that was close to COVID. That leaves 4 options.

1) Despite an extensive search we've still not found the source of a COVID variant circulating in any raccoon dogs in other markets and coincidentally no circulating virus jumped to humans outside of Wuhan.

2) The first case of human adapted coronavirus appeared as a spontaneous variant in only a couple animals at the market that coincidentally became the source of a super spreader event. One has to ignore the 14 earliest cases China won't share data on that have no connection to the market.

3) Someone traveling from Yunnan, Laos or elsewhere was directly infected by a bat and brought it to Wuhan without infecting anyone along the way.

4) Or, the virus was adapted to humans in the lab and that's why it appeared abruptly on the scene ~Nov 2019 and needed no further circulating in humans to adapt to rapid person to person spread.​

Number 4 is the most plausible and the only one that there isn't data one would expect if it were one of the other 3.
 
Does the Department of Energy have any virology laboratories? Does it in fact inspect any virology laboratories? Has it fallen foul of the 'I am a physicist; I understand how the universe works, therefore I understand everything in the universe' fallacy?
I simplified the lab's function because other areas of research weren't relevant to the thread. The connection between the DoE and the labs under their purview was new to me.

Office of Science Laboratories
An outgrowth of immense investment in scientific research initiated by the U.S. Government during World War II, the National Laboratories have served as the leading institutions for scientific innovation in the United States for more than seventy years.

The Energy Department's 17 National Labs tackle the critical scientific challenges of our time -- from combating climate change to discovering the origins of our universe -- and possess unique instruments and facilities, many of which are found nowhere else in the world. They address large scale, complex research and development challenges with a multidisciplinary approach that places an emphasis on translating basic science to innovation.
I'm not sure which labs are doing research on COVID but it looks like the department has been deeply involved in COVID issues from the beginning.

I doubt they need any money because of a finding the virus came from a lab leak.
 
Last edited:
The Los Alamos National Laboratory has been deeply involved in many aspects of covid-19. Tracking variants, genomic work, analyzing replication advantage, spread characteristics in various settings and countries. They study a wide range of topics. Check out their site and covid work.

https://www.lanl.gov/
 
FBI thinks its a lab leak:

"Covid: FBI chief Christopher Wray says China lab leak 'most likely'"

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-64806903

I just worry that all this is a bit like the Cubans being responsible for Havanna syndrome. Politically convenient. Lots of opinions by governmental organisations with little apparent expertise in the area. A growing consensus view by independant experts that the true nature of the problem is not due to wicked communists.
 
The Los Alamos National Laboratory has been deeply involved in many aspects of covid-19. Tracking variants, genomic work, analyzing replication advantage, spread characteristics in various settings and countries. They study a wide range of topics. Check out their site and covid work.

https://www.lanl.gov/

From what I see they mostly have done computational work. Actual virology seems to be done by collaborating institutions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom