Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
The virus we have is very close to the bat virus. Not any particular virus, but all the parts look like known virus parts.

Tracking down various variants, the bat virus remains were collected and sequenced in China. No live virus from the bat feces could be grown in lab. It's all in the Quammen book. He called and zoomed a number of scientists around the world during the pandemic year.

https://www.amazon.com/Breathless-S...77503346&sprefix=david+quammen,aps,159&sr=8-2
It's kind of hard to evaluate something that is in a book but if the highlighted bit is a claim in that book, it's false.

I quote quite a bit here but that's because the article is exceptionally thorough and long. To review what has already been covered in this thread:

MIT Tech Review - PANDEMIC TECHNOLOGY PROJECT - Inside the risky bat-virus engineering that links America to Wuhan - China emulated US techniques to construct novel coronaviruses in unsafe conditions.
In 2013, the American virologist Ralph Baric approached Zhengli Shi at a meeting. Baric was a top expert in coronaviruses, with hundreds of papers to his credit, and Shi, along with her team at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, had been discovering them by the fistful in bat caves. In one sample of bat guano, Shi had detected the genome of a new virus, called SHC014, that was one of the two closest relatives to the original SARS virus, but her team had not been able to culture it in the lab. Baric had developed a way around that problem—a technique for “reverse genetics” in coronaviruses. Not only did it allow him to bring an actual virus to life from its genetic code, but he could mix and match parts of multiple viruses. He wanted to take the “spike” gene from SHC014 and move it into a genetic copy of the SARS virus he already had in his lab. The spike molecule is what lets a coronavirus open a cell and get inside it. The resulting chimera would demonstrate whether the spike of SHC014 would attach to human cells.
Those chimera viruses were not closely related to COVID. But Shi learned the technique from her work with Baric and used it. Shi also acquired the human adapted mice strain from Baric.

Baric asked Shi if he could have the genetic data for SHC014. “She was gracious enough to send us those sequences almost immediately,” he says. His team introduced the virus modified with that code into mice and into a petri dish of human airway cells. Sure enough, the chimera exhibited “robust replication” in the human cells—evidence that nature was full of coronaviruses ready to leap directly to people.


The NIH knew about Shi's work back in 2015.

A lot of attention has been paid to the new Level 4 Biosafety lab at the WIV. But it was only recently completed. The work on coronaviruses prior to the pandemic was carried out at BSL-2.
The NIH decided the risk was worth it. In a potentially fateful decision, it funded work similar to Baric’s at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, which soon used its own reverse-genetics technology to make numerous coronavirus chimeras.

Unnoticed by most, however, was a key difference that significantly shifted the risk calculation. The Chinese work was carried out at biosafety level 2 (BSL-2), a much lower tier than Baric’s BSL-3+.


Back when Daszak was basking in his million dollar glory days:
Shi managed to culture WIV1 in her lab from a fecal sample and show that it could directly infect human cells, proving that SARS-like viruses ready to leap straight from bats to humans already lurked in the natural world. This showed, Daszak and Shi argued, that bat coronaviruses were a “substantial global threat.” Scientists, they said, needed to find them, and study them, before they found us.

Many of the other viruses couldn’t be grown, but Baric’s system provided a way to rapidly test their spikes by engineering them into similar viruses. When the chimera he made using SHC014 proved able to infect human cells in a dish, Daszak told the press that these revelations should “move this virus from a candidate emerging pathogen to a clear and present danger.”


All one need do is look at papers Shi coauthored before the COVID pandemic when they weren't trying to hide anything.
Two years later, Daszak and Shi published a paper reporting how the Chinese lab had engineered different versions of WIV1 and tested their infectiousness in human cells. The paper announced that the WIV had developed its own reverse-genetics system, following the Americans’ lead. It also included a troubling detail: the work, which was funded in part by the NIH grant, had been done in a BSL-2 lab. That meant the same viruses that Daszak was holding up as a clear and present danger to the world were being studied under conditions that, according to Richard Ebright, matched “the biosafety level of a US dentist’s office.”


When Shi was denying the virus was even in the WIV lab, she also claimed they had no live bats. Evidence was provided in the thread supporting the opposite, that they did indeed have live bats in the lab. Here is one of a number of sources:

Yup, the Wuhan Institute of Virology Kept Live Bats within Its Walls
In 2015, Shi Zhengli — a.k.a. “Bat Woman” — and a group of other virologists announced that they had “generated and characterized a chimeric virus expressing the spike of bat coronavirus SHC014 in a mouse-adapted SARS-CoV backbone.” Other scientists in the field warned that this research, designed to help prevent another SARS pandemic, was setting up a higher risk of setting off another pandemic. Nature magazine, November 12, 2015:

But other virologists question whether the information gleaned from the experiment justifies the potential risk. Although the extent of any risk is difficult to assess, Simon Wain-Hobson, a virologist at the Pasteur Institute in Paris, points out that the researchers have created a novel virus that “grows remarkably well” in human cells. “If the virus escaped, nobody could predict the trajectory ,” he says.

“The only impact of this work is the creation, in a lab, of a new, non-natural risk,” agrees Richard Ebright, a molecular biologist and biodefence expert at Rutgers University in Piscataway, New Jersey. Both Ebright and Wain-Hobson are long-standing critics of gain-of-function research.​


Daszak, Shi and the Chinese government are proven liars when it comes to covering up the lab leak.
 
[snark snipped]

Read. The. Link.

4 agencies say natural, 2 say lab.

It really is that simple.

You're right that none of them have better than low confidence, so we're exactly where we were 12 and 24 months ago.
And my source said 4 lab leaks of low confidence and 1 of moderate confidence. I can cherry pick better than you can. ;) The WSJ is behind a paywall.

It's quite useless to debate who is for or against whichever hypothesis. That whole thing is muddied by Daszak steering the WHO committee and other researchers against the lab leak, the GOP and Trump accusing China without supporting evidence and Gym Jordan's personal vendetta against Fauci.


Can we move on without arguing everything we already addressed? I am specifically trying to avoid the stalemate we were at before I took a break from this thread. It's incredibly tedious when people bring up stuff that has been thoroughly discussed already. I don't mind reviewing a few things but I would appreciate if people moved this discussion forward.

What do you have to say about the EcoHealth Alliance whistleblower?
 
Last edited:
Prove it.

I'd like to see evidence that suggestions this was an accidental Wuhan lab leak, was a racist conspiracy theory.

Thanks.

Why Pandemics Give Birth To Hate: From Bubonic Plague To COVID-19
The pandemic has been responsible for an outbreak of violence and hate directed against Asians around the world, blaming them for the spread of COVID-19. During this surge in attacks, the perpetrators have made their motives clear, taunting their victims with declarations like, "You have the Chinese Virus, go back to China!" and assaulting them and spitting on them...

This narrative — that "others," often from far-flung places, are to blame for epidemics — is a dramatic example of a long tradition of hatred. In 14th-century Europe, Jewish communities were wrongfully accused of poisoning wells to spread the Black Death. In 1900, Chinese people were unfairly vilified for an outbreak of the plague in San Francisco's Chinatown. And in the '80s, Haitians were blamed for bringing HIV/AIDS to the U.S., a theory that's considered unsubstantiated by many global health experts...

Some politicians, including former President Donald Trump publicly blamed China for the pandemic, calling this novel coronavirus the "Chinese Virus" or the "Wuhan Virus." They consistently pushed that narrative even after the World Health Organization (WHO) warned as early as March 2020, when the pandemic was declared, that such language would encourage racial profiling and stigmatization against Asians. Trump has continued to use stigmatizing language in the wake of the Atlanta shooting, using the phrase "China virus" during a March 16 call to Fox News.
 
Prove it.

I'd like to see evidence that suggestions this was an accidental Wuhan lab leak, was a racist conspiracy theory.

Thanks.
In addition to what Roger posted there was an actual effort by Peter Daszak to inject the narrative that the lab leak hypothesis was a CT. He authored a letter to the Lancet then got almost 30 researchers to sign it without revealing he had written it. Some of the signatories withdrew their names after the disclosure they had been misled.

At some point Tedros from the WHO made a point of saying Daszak's intervention in the first WHO report dismissed the lab hypothesis before a single shred of evidence was collected. This is all documented near the beginning of this thread.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately this doesn't help. I have yet to see anything from the DoE themselves, all I have is a paraphrase of a paraphrase. And how the Department of Energy is in a position to draw meaningful conclusions on this matter is perplexing to me.

But perhaps the 'low confidence' qualifier explains it. They had to make a pronouncement one way or the other, from insufficient evidence. They might as well announce - with 'low confidence' - that a coin will turn up heads or tails.
 
In addition to what Roger posted there was an actual effort by Peter Daszak to inject the narrative that the lab leak hypothesis was a CT. He authored a letter to the Lancet then got almost 30 researchers to sign it without revealing he had written it.
This has absolutely nothing to with the known fact that epidemics stir up racism. We all saw it.

The 'lab leak' hypothesis is an enabler of racism, and many of its proponents are using it for this purpose. That's why they call it the 'Wuhan Lab leak' and the 'China virus'.

But it's not just the 'leak' itself which is in question. Once that is accepted as true, the next step is to accuse China of deliberately engineering it for some nefarious purpose. We all know where the virus came from originally, whether it 'escaped' from a lab or not. Making China into a scapegoat allows us to ignore the real cause of this pandemic - the ongoing destruction of the environment by all humans. When the next one hits we might not have that luxury...
 
The Department of Energy?????

had no idea they were experts in virology.

LOL!!!
Why do they need to be? There are multiple areas of inquiry and the genetic and epidemiological evidence are but two avenues.

I should point out that the claim was made by TA that
US agencies that report on the pandemic 4-2 in favour of natural origins.

This was based on a paywalled WSJ article. We can't see the actual report because it is classified.

Here's what the WSJ says as near as I can tell:
The Energy Department Now Blames a Chinese Lab Leak for COVID
In an article published by the Wall Street Journal, the newspaper says a new classified intelligence report shows that the DoE has changed its position on the virus’s origins from undecided to blaming a lab leak. The FBI is the most high-profile U.S. agency to land on the lab leak source, and though the bureau has “moderate confidence” in the idea, the new DoE stance is only being taken with “low confidence.”

Of course, “low confidence” is not reserved for believing that a lab leak was the source of the pandemic. The National Intelligence Council believes that the virus came through natural transmission, beginning with an animal, with [low confidence level. There are four U.S. agencies that fall in this camp, while two others—including the CIA—are still undecided on the origins of the pandemic.

So, 2 agencies undecided, 4 with low confidence it was a natural spillover, the DoE with low confidence it was a lab leak and one, the FBI, with moderate confidence it was a lab leak.

It's statistically misleading to claim that means 4-2 agencies conclude it is a spillover in a post emphasizing there was low confidence in the lab-leak position without pointing out there was equally low confidence in the spillover hypothesis.


Re racism, according to a CNN opinion piece:
For the better part of 2020, advocates of the lab leak theory had to fight against claims they were being xenophobic or racist — in part thanks to anti-Chinese rhetoric from then-President Donald Trump, who embraced the theory.
 
This has absolutely nothing to with the known fact that epidemics stir up racism. We all saw it.
Did you get the idea I was denying there is a racist element here just because I also added there was the initial effort to categorize the lab leak as CT?


The 'lab leak' hypothesis is an enabler of racism, and many of its proponents are using it for this purpose. That's why they call it the 'Wuhan Lab leak' and the 'China virus'.
Of course. Trump and the GOP made sure to use that narrative.

Early on Peter Daszak from the EcoHealth Alliance who is probably implicated in a lab leak made a concerted and long lasting effort to portray the lab leak hypothesis as a CT. There is more than enough room here for both racism and CT taint to go around.


But it's not just the 'leak' itself which is in question. Once that is accepted as true, the next step is to accuse China of deliberately engineering it for some nefarious purpose. We all know where the virus came from originally, whether it 'escaped' from a lab or not. Making China into a scapegoat allows us to ignore the real cause of this pandemic - the ongoing destruction of the environment by all humans. When the next one hits we might not have that luxury...
Most virology researchers early on that did see evidence of gain of function research but did not see and made a good case this was not 'engineered' as a bioweapon.


Destruction of the environment such as that which might increase human/animal interactions is a whole other can of worms and unless you are using it to support this being a spillover it drifts off-topic in this thread.
 
Last edited:
Of course. Trump and the GOP made sure to use that narrative.

Early on Peter Daszak from the EcoHealth Alliance who is probably implicated in a lab leak made a concerted and long lasting effort to portray the lab leak hypothesis as a CT. There is more than enough room here for both racism and CT taint to go around.

"Probably implicated in a lab leak" is question-begging.

The reason why it was early on dismissed as a CT is because the early claims were that it was a bioweapon or engineered.


Most virology researchers early on that did see evidence of gain of function research but did not see and made a good case this was not 'engineered' as a bioweapon.

These claims came much later. The letter that you put so much weight on came out in February 2020. Who was talking about gain of funciton then?

Many of the lab leak proponents have been using redacted emails to claim that the scientists such as Holmes, Farrar, Fauci and Andersen believed it was a lab leak. But clearly in those emails they are initially surprised at the structure of the virus and wonder if it had been engineered (like the conspiracy theorists had been claiming with no evidence). Only after they looked more closely at the virus did they decide it wasn't and then they decided to write the letter in response to the conspiracy theories (and they were conspiracy theories).

And of course, they were aware of the Wuhan Institute of Virology, so its existence also factored into their calculations about how likely it was to be engineered.

They also point out that it is a separate question of whether it could have been a captured virus that escaped the lab as well. But the letter was aimed at questions of an engineered virus.

Destruction of the environment such as that which might increase human/animal interactions is a whole other can of worms and unless you are using it to support this being a spillover it drifts off-topic in this thread.

It is not off-topic at all. Quanmen in his book Spillover argues that environmental degradation is more likely to cause spillover. Indeed, preventing environmental destruction's effects and how humans can live alongside potential dangerous pathogens is also the purpose of the Eco-Health Alliance.
 
That's not new, Tero. It's not evidence for a natural spillover unless you can show the steps the virus took actually emerging in the wild.
 
Natural origin means what? What animal? None have been found. No evidence for it.

There is, however, evidence that a Sars corona virus adapted to humans was being sequenced as part of research at the lab in Wuhan (and funded in part by the US). Wuhan WIV is THE top bats sars corona virus lab in the world. Wuhan is where the outbreak happened. The closest viruses are a thousand miles away, but are documented to have been collected and transported to the lab in Wuhan - for many years. The research was being done, not in the level 4 facilities with the most safety controls, but level 2 and 3.

So, while not definitive, what more do you need to say "likely"?
It's been the likely source this whole time.

This is completely objectively false. When SARS-COV-2 adapted to humans it became far more infectious the the original strains. Meanwhile SARS-COV-2 was highly infectious to most animals it came across right out of the gate, humans being no exception.

This isn't the behavior of a virus that was "adapted to humans" at the beginning of the pandemic. Furthermore there is no evidence it was ever isolated in a lab prior to it's identification in Dec 2020 and characteristic features of the virus are at odds with what you would get from modification in a lab.
 
The sequence of our virus is known.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SARS-CoV-2

I used Google Scholar to find a paper that only had a free abstract I read. It stated that all parts of the human virus were found as parts of different bat viruses.

The lab leakers are still split into groups.

1. There are some who think that the WIV had a natural virus they collected from the wild and it got out because of lax procedures. In a way it is spillover +. That said, this type of theory suffers in one way because it doesn’t explain another aspect of “evidence” which is how it was effective at spreading so quickly. All viruses have different rates at which they adapt to human receptors so most virologists don’t really have an issue with it but …

2. …some lab leakers have claimed that gain of function made a virus better adapted to humans so it is spillover double +. They had a virus from the wild and made it more infectious in the lab and then it got out. But some lab leakers find that doesn’t explain another aspect which is the futon cleavage site. So some have claimed….

3. It was a virus from the wild that was almost the same as the current one but with a furin cleavage site inserted. In other words, back to the engineering claim. This one actually seems to be the dominant lab leak theory.
 
Most virology researchers early on that did see evidence of gain of function research but did not see and made a good case this was not 'engineered' as a bioweapon.


Some felt the furin cleavage site looked suspicious. This fear was dismissed as soon as it was realized this structure was commonplace in related viruses and poorly optimized for infecting humans.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom