Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
You can't say "low confidence" of a lab origin means 2-4 likelihood without saying what the confidence is for a natural spillover event.

You're conflating two different things.

The DOE itself states it has low confidence.

Apparently, there are 5 other agencies (one of which is FBI) with opinions on where it started. Right now, DOE and FBI say the lab, the other 4 days natural origin.
 
Headline: Lab Leak Most Likely Origin of Covid-19 Pandemic, Energy Department Now Says

U.S. agency’s revised assessment is based on new intelligence

To poke a little at that -

4/ DOE doesn’t say how they arrived at their opinion or whether they included virologists and epidemiologists in the process.

So, in short, not much way to verify much of anything. In a way, that's rather convenient for anyone more interested in backing their bias, whatever it is. Given the timing, I also sorta have to wonder if politics is in play at all, too.

Either way, CT's are likely to jump on it.
 
You're conflating two different things.

The DOE itself states it has low confidence.

Apparently, there are 5 other agencies (one of which is FBI) with opinions on where it started. Right now, DOE and FBI say the lab, the other 4 days natural origin.

Citation please. I posted this, maybe you haven't read that post yet:
In 2021, the intelligence community declassified a report that showed four agencies in the intelligence community had assessed with low confidence that the virus likely jumped from animals to humans naturally in the wild,

Anyway, it's not much of a debate at this point who holds which opinions. I put Huff's book on hold, my library has it on order.
 
You're conflating two different things.

The DOE itself states it has low confidence.

Apparently, there are 5 other agencies (one of which is FBI) with opinions on where it started. Right now, DOE and FBI say the lab, the other 4 days natural origin.

Natural origin means what? What animal? None have been found. No evidence for it.

There is, however, evidence that a Sars corona virus adapted to humans was being sequenced as part of research at the lab in Wuhan (and funded in part by the US). Wuhan WIV is THE top bats sars corona virus lab in the world. Wuhan is where the outbreak happened. The closest viruses are a thousand miles away, but are documented to have been collected and transported to the lab in Wuhan - for many years. The research was being done, not in the level 4 facilities with the most safety controls, but level 2 and 3.

So, while not definitive, what more do you need to say "likely"?
It's been the likely source this whole time.
 
Natural origin means what? What animal? None have been found. No evidence for it.

There is, however, evidence that a Sars corona virus adapted to humans was being sequenced as part of research at the lab in Wuhan (and funded in part by the US). Wuhan WIV is THE top bats sars corona virus lab in the world. Wuhan is where the outbreak happened. The closest viruses are a thousand miles away, but are documented to have been collected and transported to the lab in Wuhan - for many years. The research was being done, not in the level 4 facilities with the most safety controls, but level 2 and 3.

So, while not definitive, what more do you need to say "likely"?
It's been the likely source this whole time.

BATS!

Since there is no identified precursor bat virus mentioning bats is scary but irrelevant. The failure to identify the immediate precursor virus in animals is used as an argument against a natural origin, but equally must be an argument against a laboratory escape origin.

MICE!

This paper suggests that Omicron may have evolved in mice. So perhaps we need to look for a virology laboratory that does work with mice.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8718870/

Think how long it took to identify the animal origins of HIV, so it is not surprising we don't know the animal origin of SARS-CoV-2.
 
To poke a little at that -

So, in short, not much way to verify much of anything. In a way, that's rather convenient for anyone more interested in backing their bias, whatever it is. Given the timing, I also sorta have to wonder if politics is in play at all, too.

Either way, CT's are likely to jump on it.

That's pretty much where I am - nothing new, a purely political statement.

Citation please.

What are you talking about? The article I linked says exactly what I typed.

I posted this, maybe you haven't read that post yet:

I don't intend to - I'm just stating what was said.

"Most likely" means >50%. "Low confidence" puts some upper limit on that probability.

Utter nonsense. Low confidence means exactly that.

Low - 20%
Moderate - 40-60%
High - 80%

They have low confidence of a likelihood.

It's a big fat nothingburger.
 
Utter nonsense. Low confidence means exactly that.

Low - 20%
Moderate - 40-60%
High - 80%

They have low confidence of a likelihood.

It's a big fat nothingburger.


Sorry, but what you are saying is logically, mathematically, and semantically wrong. The DOE said that a lab leak most likely was the cause. "Most likely" means "more likely than not," which in turn means >50% probability. When they say they have low confidence in their conclusion, they don't mean that they have "low confidence in the likelihood" (which would be incoherent). They mean that they have low confidence in their conclusion that the cause was a lab leak. Taken together, that means that they think it "most likely"; ie, more likely than not,; ie, >50% chance, that a lab leak was the cause; but they still think that there is a substantial probability (but, necessarily, less than 50%) that the cause was other than a lab leak.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, but what you are saying is logically, mathematically, and semantically wrong. The DOE said that a lab leak most likely was the cause. "Most likely" means more likely than not, which in turn means >50% probability.

Normally, "most likely" used as it was in the headline could also refer to a particular option being assessed as more likely than the alternatives, which is not necessarily the same thing as greater than 50% probability - there can be more than 2 options, after all. There is something to be questioned about whether "meteorological terms" are at all applicable here, of course, and more broadly what the actual assessed probabilities are.
 
Last edited:
Normally, "most likely" used as it was refers to a particular option being assessed as more likely than the alternatives, which is not necessarily the same thing as greater than 50% probability - there can be more than 2 options, after all.


There is a difference between "most likely (did something)" and "the most likely (something)." When we say "X is the most likely (something)," we mean that there are more than 2 somethings and that X is the most likely of them, which could mean that P(X) < 50%. (Here, "likely" is an adjective.)

But the DOE didn't say the lab leak hypothesis was the most likely something (ie, hypothesis). It said (at least according to the Times) that "a lab leak most likely caused the pandemic." In that sentence, "most likely" means "more likely than not." (Here, "likely" is an adverb.)

To put it another way, according to the Times, the DOE did not say, "The most likely cause of the pandemic was a lab leak." They said, "The pandemic was most likely caused by a lab leak." In the former, the probability that a lab leak caused the pandemic could, in principle, be <50%; whereas, in the latter, a lab leak is asserted to be, more likely than not, the cause of the pandemic.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, but what you are saying is logically, mathematically, and semantically wrong. The DOE said that a lab leak most likely was the cause. "Most likely" means "more likely than not," which in turn means >50% probability. When they say they have low confidence in their conclusion, they don't mean that they have "low confidence in the likelihood" (which would be incoherent). They mean that they have low confidence in their conclusion that the cause was a lab leak. Taken together, that means that they think it "most likely"; ie, more likely than not,; ie, >50% chance, that a lab leak was the cause; but they still think that there is a substantial probability (but, necessarily, less than 50%) that the cause was other than a lab leak.

There are 8 options.
Options A to G each have a probability of 12% option H has a probability of 16%.

Which of the options is the most likely?
 
The virus we have is very close to the bat virus. Not any particular virus, but all the parts look like known virus parts.

Tracking down various variants, the bat virus remains were collected and sequenced in China. No live virus from the bat feces could be grown in lab. It's all in the Quammen book. He called and zoomed a number of scientists around the world during the pandemic year.

https://www.amazon.com/Breathless-S...77503346&sprefix=david+quammen,aps,159&sr=8-2
 
BATS!

Since there is no identified precursor bat virus mentioning bats is scary but irrelevant. The failure to identify the immediate precursor virus in animals is used as an argument against a natural origin, but equally must be an argument against a laboratory escape origin.

MICE!

This paper suggests that Omicron may have evolved in mice. So perhaps we need to look for a virology laboratory that does work with mice.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8718870/

Think how long it took to identify the animal origins of HIV, so it is not surprising we don't know the animal origin of SARS-CoV-2.

Those are the Omicron variants. The only virus we should be tracking is the original virus sequenced in the first wave of the disease in China. That is the one you would relate to any animal viruses prior to that.
 
There are 8 options.
Options A to G each have a probability of 12% option H has a probability of 16%.

Which of the options is the most likely?

It depends if there is any political fallout for choosing H...
 
Another source of speculation is the mere presence of the furin cleavage site.[18][118] It is absent in the closest known relatives of SARS-CoV-2 (but present in other betacoronaviruses e.g. BtHpCoV-ZJ13).[122] Scientists consider that this diversity of cleavage sites is likely the result of recombination,[118][123] and is further unsurprising since the genetic lineage of these viruses has not been adequately explored, sampled, or sequenced.[124][125] A common occurrence amongst other coronaviruses, including MERS-CoV, HCoV-OC43, HCoV-HKU1, and appearing in near-identical fashion in HKU9-1, the site is preceded by short palindromic sequences suggestive of natural recombination caused by simple evolutionary mechanisms. Additionally, the suboptimal configuration and poor targeting of the cleavage site when compared with known examples (such as HCoV-OC43 or HCoV-HKU1), along with the complex and onerous molecular biology work this would have required, is inconsistent with what would be expected from an engineered virus.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_lab_leak_theory
 
The virus we have is very close to the bat virus. Not any particular virus, but all the parts look like known virus parts.

Tracking down various variants, the bat virus remains were collected and sequenced in China. No live virus from the bat feces could be grown in lab. It's all in the Quammen book. He called and zoomed a number of scientists around the world during the pandemic year.

https://www.amazon.com/Breathless-S...77503346&sprefix=david+quammen,aps,159&sr=8-2

There is no 'bat virus' there are many bat viruses, only a few of which have been sequenced. SARS-CoV-2 is not 'very close' to any known bat virus the closest known virus is a bat virus with about 95% sequence homology. On a similar basis humans and chimps have about 98% homology, but humans did not arise from a laboratory experiment with chimps there was a common ancestor.

With SARS it was about 5 years for the origin to be traced from a horseshoe bat virus that infected pangolins that then infected humans. The natural zoonotic spread is actually more embarassing for the Chines than a laboratory incident as it proposes virtually the same pattern of events as caused the SARS near pandemic. If the Chinese do not mend their ways, a third coronavirus outbreak seems likely.
 
That's pretty much where I am - nothing new, a purely political statement.

What are you talking about? The article I linked says exactly what I typed.

I don't intend to - I'm just stating what was said.

Utter nonsense. Low confidence means exactly that.

Low - 20%
Moderate - 40-60%
High - 80%

They have low confidence of a likelihood.

It's a big fat nothingburger.
It wasn't the low confidence I was referring to, it was this unsupported conclusion you drew:
Still leaves US agencies that report on the pandemic 4-2 in favour of natural origins.
No it did not and neither did anything else you posted.

I supported what I said, both hypotheses have a low favor.

Support your claim that "US agencies report on the pandemic" in favor of a natural origin. They don't. They favor both with equally low confidence.

As for not intending to read what I posted supporting my position, I quoted myself to make it easy for you. Did you not even read the post you replied to?
 
Last edited:
When they say they have low confidence in their conclusion, they don't mean that they have "low confidence in the likelihood" (which would be incoherent).

:dl:

This thread gets funnier by the post. You don't even realise how idiotic your post is, because that's exactly what they're saying.

Please do continue.

Support your claim that "US agencies report on the pandemic" in favor of a natural origin.

Read. The. Link.

4 agencies say natural, 2 say lab.

It really is that simple.

You're right that none of them have better than low confidence, so we're exactly where we were 12 and 24 months ago.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom