Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't remember the episode but I remember a discussion TWIV that said the importance of the furin cleavage site wasn't know until after scientists had seen Covid.

You could be right. I may have been thinking of the receptor-binding domain, which I suppose is Virology 101. :)
 
So the next step in the saga, is that some of the lab leakers such as Deigin and Quay and a few others, are arguing that Pekar et. al got it wrong when they claimed that lineage A and B are separate spillover events.

One of the authors of the paper has written a tweet thread explaining the process.

I honestly have no idea about this.

My thinking here, however, is that while the lab leakers seem to believe that spillover proponents (or what they call zoonati) are funded by this kind of research and are therefore desperate to protect it at all costs, it seems to me that these virologists presumably believe in what they are doing otherwise why would they be digging themselves in so deep.

Anyway, here is the thread:

Link

The lab leakers? Well, maybe they will destroy their own reputations in virology but they never had any so it is no loss for them. It is the BS asymmetry problem.
 
Blaming the wildlife trade calls Chinese cultural practices into question, China really does not want Covid to be a result of this. They did the same thing with SARS, effectually trying to blame it on anything else until Dr Shi positively identified the exact cave SARS originated it.

Keep in mind that most of the lab leak CT's try to insinuate Dr Shi is one of the principles involved in the supposed cover-up when in fact history shows she is more than willing to engage in research the Chinese government would prefer not to come to light.
I know you have said this before, but I don’t think you can be sure that you know what the Chinese government would accept or not. There is a difference in claiming wild animals in China have produced a dangerous virus that has spread to humans, and claiming that sloppy practice in a Chinese lab caused a dangerous virus to spread to humans - quite aside from the fact that if this had happened in Dr Shi’s lab, publishing it would have severe repercussions on her own research.

On the other hand, I know nothing about Dr Shi, and I can’t possibly know for sure if she would risk her career in this way, or if her status in China is essentially untouchable, so she can publish whatever she likes.

I am content with the fact that we’ll never get to the bottom of this. I think that lab leak or not, all labs working with such viruses will tighten up their practices after Covid, and wet markets will probably be monitored in some fashion in the future, or at least the reaction will be faster next time a novel virus appear in a city with a wet market.
 
Why are you so interested in blaming China for the pandemic?

Because China is to blame for the pandemic, obviously.

It is to blame because it had full information about the Wuhan spread and that it could be transmitted between humans, yet they sat on that information for weeks until it was too late, precisely because it knew that admission would make China look bad.

The Chinese authorities knowingly and deliberately tried to cover it up for around 6 weeks, knowing full well it was transmissible between humans by mid December. Xi himself by his own admission knew all about it by 5th Jan. The government only admitted human to human transmission in their announcement in late January. They lied about it to the world for over a month.

Just before that late Jan announcement Wuhan went ahead with a 40,000 strong communal dinner, trying to set a world record, and a day or so after held a Chinese New Year festival. God knows how many people were infected just from those events.

Only when it was obviously spiralling out of control and they couldn't keep a lid on it any longer did they act meaningfully, going for the lockdown, but even then it was badly handled, allowing 5 million to leave the area before the lockdown occurred, and spreading throughout China and onwards.

In summary, both local and national governments knowingly and deliberately covered it up once recognised, lied that it was not human transmissible, and denied the scale until the news reports that were getting out were too prevalent to ignore. And even then they applied the shutdown badly, allowing it to spread globally.

China is not to blame for other countries responses, of course, but that they are to blame for its global spread is not remotely in doubt.

This is entirely separate from the lab leak theory, which may or may not be true. If it has a zoonotic origin, China is still to blame for the pandemic.

I was merely pointing out that if it were a leak from a government lab, there would be nothing that they would not do to stop that getting out. That is not a conspiracy, that is fact. That the whistleblower was eventually able to get out information about the early cases once they were in the community has no bearing on the likelihood of a lab leak being suppressed, as he was not talking about the origin.

Xi's China is not the China from 3, 5 or 10 years ago. Its a completely different beast. China spends many time more on its internal security and censorship than it does on its military, and we know how big China's military is.

Does that mean a lab leak is more likely? Not in the slightest. But if China doesn't want something to get out, it wont get out.
 
Because China is to blame for the pandemic, obviously.

It is to blame because it had full information about the Wuhan spread and that it could be transmitted between humans, yet they sat on that information for weeks until it was too late, precisely because it knew that admission would make China look bad.

The Chinese authorities knowingly and deliberately tried to cover it up for around 6 weeks, knowing full well it was transmissible between humans by mid December. Xi himself by his own admission knew all about it by 5th Jan. The government only admitted human to human transmission in their announcement in late January. They lied about it to the world for over a month.

Just before that late Jan announcement Wuhan went ahead with a 40,000 strong communal dinner, trying to set a world record, and a day or so after held a Chinese New Year festival. God knows how many people were infected just from those events.

Only when it was obviously spiralling out of control and they couldn't keep a lid on it any longer did they act meaningfully, going for the lockdown, but even then it was badly handled, allowing 5 million to leave the area before the lockdown occurred, and spreading throughout China and onwards.

In summary, both local and national governments knowingly and deliberately covered it up once recognised, lied that it was not human transmissible, and denied the scale until the news reports that were getting out were too prevalent to ignore. And even then they applied the shutdown badly, allowing it to spread globally.

China is not to blame for other countries responses, of course, but that they are to blame for its global spread is not remotely in doubt.

This is entirely separate from the lab leak theory, which may or may not be true. If it has a zoonotic origin, China is still to blame for the pandemic.
I was merely pointing out that if it were a leak from a government lab, there would be nothing that they would not do to stop that getting out. That is not a conspiracy, that is fact. That the whistleblower was eventually able to get out information about the early cases once they were in the community has no bearing on the likelihood of a lab leak being suppressed, as he was not talking about the origin.

Xi's China is not the China from 3, 5 or 10 years ago. Its a completely different beast. China spends many time more on its internal security and censorship than it does on its military, and we know how big China's military is.

Does that mean a lab leak is more likely? Not in the slightest. But if China doesn't want something to get out, it wont get out.

I agree with all your points about China's ultimate responsibility one way or another.

I think, however, that the actions taken by both the national and local governments seem more in line with a zoonotic disease than a lab leak - particularly if we are talking about a virus that has been engineered for greater spread.

One of the problems seems to be their duplicitousness regarding the wild-life trade. It is clear that they were speaking out of both sides of their mouth by claiming they had clamped down on wild-life sales, while also turning a blind eye to it except to occasionally hand out slaps on the wrist fines.

The theory, not original to me, that sounds most plausible is that after botching the swine flu response, which resulted in such a massive culling of pigs, wild-life farms ended up making up the short-fall increasing the likelihood of spillover.
 
Because China is to blame for the pandemic, obviously.

The evidence doesn't support that.

I will say that the people responsible for the next Corona virus pandemic are the ones attacking science and scientists researching these viruses. Most of this necessarily involves Chinese scientists, so stop blaming China and maybe take a look at your own actions.


It is to blame because it had full information about the Wuhan spread and that it could be transmitted between humans, yet they sat on that information for weeks until it was too late, precisely because it knew that admission would make China look bad.

This isn't true. You can't just say "there are multiple cases so it must be spreading person to person" not only is this bad science it's completely irresponsible and 9 times out of 10 will create unnecessary panic.

The Chinese authorities knowingly and deliberately tried to cover it up for around 6 weeks, knowing full well it was transmissible between humans by mid December.

Again completely false. Chinese hospitals stared identifying clusters of an unknown respiratory disease around Dec 20. Nothing was known and nothing could be known about it at that time, not the cause not how it spread.


Chinese scientists tracked down the virus causing the illness and published it's genome 10 days later on Dec 30. This is an acceptable, perhaps even speedy response to tracking down and sequencing a completely new virus. From this point on research was global, so trying to blame China is nonsensical.

Obviously it would be impossible to know if it was human to human transmissible before this, but in practice you also need to be able to test for the presence of the virus before you make conclusions on how it spreads, and tests were not available until Jan 14.


Once you know who's infected you can start looking at how they got infected, and the WHO started looking at the data immediately, and a weak later concluded it was spreading person to person.


Just before that late Jan announcement Wuhan went ahead with a 40,000 strong communal dinner, trying to set a world record, and a day or so after held a Chinese New Year festival. God knows how many people were infected just from those events.

So? The rest of the world continued to hold sporting events even though they had full access to all the research on the virus. The fact that it was a true respiratory virus and initial estimates on fatality rates wouldn't be available until February so it's only natural scheduled events would continue.



Only when it was obviously spiralling out of control and they couldn't keep a lid on it any longer did they act meaningfully, going for the lockdown, but even then it was badly handled, allowing 5 million to leave the area before the lockdown occurred, and spreading throughout China and onwards.


Covid had spread beyond Wuhan before it was even possible to test for it's presence and long before any of it's key properties were know. China acted far more aggressively to contain Covid than any western nation would have but containing to to Wuhan was impossible from the outset.


In summary, both local and national governments knowingly and deliberately covered it up once recognised, lied that it was not human transmissible, and denied the scale until the news reports that were getting out were too prevalent to ignore. And even then they applied the shutdown badly, allowing it to spread globally.

The facts and timelines produced by the WHO not only do not support this, they definitively refute it.




There are more than enough real things to criticize China for, I suggested you stick to those instead of listening to "news" outlets with an axe to grind.
 
The evidence doesn't support that.

I will say that the people responsible for the next Corona virus pandemic are the ones attacking science and scientists researching these viruses. Most of this necessarily involves Chinese scientists, so stop blaming China and maybe take a look at your own actions.

This isn't true. You can't just say "there are multiple cases so it must be spreading person to person" not only is this bad science it's completely irresponsible and 9 times out of 10 will create unnecessary panic.

Again completely false. Chinese hospitals stared identifying clusters of an unknown respiratory disease around Dec 20. Nothing was known and nothing could be known about it at that time, not the cause not how it spread.

Chinese scientists tracked down the virus causing the illness and published it's genome 10 days later on Dec 30. This is an acceptable, perhaps even speedy response to tracking down and sequencing a completely new virus. From this point on research was global, so trying to blame China is nonsensical.

Obviously it would be impossible to know if it was human to human transmissible before this, but in practice you also need to be able to test for the presence of the virus before you make conclusions on how it spreads, and tests were not available until Jan 14.


Once you know who's infected you can start looking at how they got infected, and the WHO started looking at the data immediately, and a weak later concluded it was spreading person to person.

So? The rest of the world continued to hold sporting events even though they had full access to all the research on the virus. The fact that it was a true respiratory virus and initial estimates on fatality rates wouldn't be available until February so it's only natural scheduled events would continue.

Covid had spread beyond Wuhan before it was even possible to test for it's presence and long before any of it's key properties were know. China acted far more aggressively to contain Covid than any western nation would have but containing to to Wuhan was impossible from the outset.

The facts and timelines produced by the WHO not only do not support this, they definitively refute it.


There are more than enough real things to criticize China for, I suggested you stick to those instead of listening to "news" outlets with an axe to grind.

You are wrong.

Everything I have said is a fact, is not disputed by China, and was reported in the South China Morning Post, a Chinese owned newspaper, based on Chinese state press releases.

Nothing I have said is incorrect. I knew about what would become Covid by late December, because it was reported in said newspapers.

The fact that things like the existence of the 40,000 person dinner in January, and that they knew about human transmission by mid-December are not widely known outside China doesn't make it incorrect, it just means you didn't know about it because it wasn't reported in the western press. It was reported in China and in Hong Kong.

They didn't just make up the idea of human transmission based on the fact that there were many cases, their scientists had studied the patients in hospital and in the lab and had detected human to human transmission, published scientific papers to that end (which is how we know they knew), then the government sat on that knowledge, and lied and said there was no human to human transmission. This is a fact, again reported in South China Morning Post, amongst others.

That they were able to lockdown China and Wuhan so effectively once the horse had bolted shows they had the capability at the time to do so, but simply didn't want to and preferred to cover it up.

There are indeed plenty of things to criticise China for, some that are not justified, and many that are entirely justified. This is one of those in the latter category.

China is to blame for the pandemic.
 
I agree with all your points about China's ultimate responsibility one way or another.

I think, however, that the actions taken by both the national and local governments seem more in line with a zoonotic disease than a lab leak - particularly if we are talking about a virus that has been engineered for greater spread.

One of the problems seems to be their duplicitousness regarding the wild-life trade. It is clear that they were speaking out of both sides of their mouth by claiming they had clamped down on wild-life sales, while also turning a blind eye to it except to occasionally hand out slaps on the wrist fines.

The theory, not original to me, that sounds most plausible is that after botching the swine flu response, which resulted in such a massive culling of pigs, wild-life farms ended up making up the short-fall increasing the likelihood of spillover.

Yep, this seems likely.

I agree, in general their actions do point more toward a zoonotic spillover.

My point has always been that the lack of evidence of a lab leak in pretty much any other country in the world (ok, outside North Korea!) would indicate that a lab leak was unlikely. This is just not the case in China.

Does that help us in any way? Unfortunately not. We are still left guessing, and looking for evidence that is not yet forthcoming.
 
You are wrong.

Everything I have said is a fact, is not disputed by China, and was reported in the South China Morning Post, a Chinese owned newspaper, based on Chinese state press releases.


Everything I said is well documented fact generated by western scientists working either independently of for the WHO, not speculation or rumor that may or may not have been published in a Chinese newspaper of indeterminate journalistic quality.


When the first know cases were reported is not in doubt (Dec 11)
When hospitals first suspected they were seeing a cluster of related cases is not in doubt (Dec 19-21)
When the genetic sequence of the virus responsible was released to scientists worldwide isn't in doubt (Dec 31)
When German scientists developed the first PCR test for Covid is not in doubt (Jan 10)
the WHO was looking into whether it was human to human transmissible, On Jan 18 they said there was insufficient evidence and that they needed another week to study the question. On Jan 21 they announced that it was in fact human to human transmissible. Before this all you had was people speculating and guessing but little actual evidence.
 
Everything I said is well documented fact generated by western scientists working either independently of for the WHO, not speculation or rumor that may or may not have been published in a Chinese newspaper of indeterminate journalistic quality.


When the first know cases were reported is not in doubt (Dec 11)
When hospitals first suspected they were seeing a cluster of related cases is not in doubt (Dec 19-21)
When the genetic sequence of the virus responsible was released to scientists worldwide isn't in doubt (Dec 31)
When German scientists developed the first PCR test for Covid is not in doubt (Jan 10)
the WHO was looking into whether it was human to human transmissible, On Jan 18 they said there was insufficient evidence and that they needed another week to study the question. On Jan 21 they announced that it was in fact human to human transmissible. Before this all you had was people speculating and guessing but little actual evidence.

President Xi knew, as reported in Chinese state media, by January 5th, by his own admission.

Sure, it is correct the WHO did not know on January 18th whether it was human transmissible, because China, who already knew it was, refused to tell them.

That is a fact.

This is also not something I have just cooked up, it was reported in newspapers in March 2020, and I posted about it at that time in the main Covid science thread, e.g. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13018520&postcount=995

To show how apalling their attempts were to control it:

"Two days after they finally admitted it was human transmissible, they continued to hold a Lunar New Year dance performance attended by senior officials from all across Hubei. Amazingly, state media reported that the performers, some with runny noses and feeling unwell "overcame the fear of pneumonia, winning praise from the leaders.""

Xi knew, China knew, they failed to tell the WHO, and allowed it to spread because they were trying to cover it up first.
 
Everything I said is well documented fact generated by western scientists working either independently of for the WHO, not speculation or rumor that may or may not have been published in a Chinese newspaper of indeterminate journalistic quality.


When the first know cases were reported is not in doubt (Dec 11)
When hospitals first suspected they were seeing a cluster of related cases is not in doubt (Dec 19-21)
When the genetic sequence of the virus responsible was released to scientists worldwide isn't in doubt (Dec 31)
When German scientists developed the first PCR test for Covid is not in doubt (Jan 10)
the WHO was looking into whether it was human to human transmissible, On Jan 18 they said there was insufficient evidence and that they needed another week to study the question. On Jan 21 they announced that it was in fact human to human transmissible. Before this all you had was people speculating and guessing but little actual evidence.

The South China Morning Post is not some unknown newspaper of indeterminate quality, it is Hong Kong's newspaper of record, and still considered authoritative and independent.

And in this case, was simply reporting facts from Chinese state media, facts that reflected badly on China, so were extremely unlikely to be reported by said state media if they could get away with not reporting them, and impossible to be reported if they were false.
 
President Xi knew, as reported in Chinese state media, by January 5th, by his own admission.

Sure, it is correct the WHO did not know on January 18th whether it was human transmissible, because China, who already knew it was, refused to tell them.

That is a fact.

This is also not something I have just cooked up, it was reported in newspapers in March 2020, and I posted about it at that time in the main Covid science thread, e.g. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13018520&postcount=995

To show how apalling their attempts were to control it:

"Two days after they finally admitted it was human transmissible, they continued to hold a Lunar New Year dance performance attended by senior officials from all across Hubei. Amazingly, state media reported that the performers, some with runny noses and feeling unwell "overcame the fear of pneumonia, winning praise from the leaders.""

Xi knew, China knew, they failed to tell the WHO, and allowed it to spread because they were trying to cover it up first.

Indeed, but the fact we now know about this cover-up and the initial cover-up when Li Wenliang was warning about about spread from the Huanan seafood market CANNOT be seen as evidence that covering up a lab leak would be easy. If anything, both points again, undermine a lab leak and suggest the Chinese government instead tried (and failed) to cover up a wild-life born spillover, and have been muddying the waters ever since.

Many times in this very thread, I've been told by lab leaker(s) that the Huanan Seafood Market has been completely refuted to the point that it is no more likely than coming from space. Yet, the initial and most plausible hypothesis, that it DID come from the wildlife trade and emerged from the Huanan Seafood Market is becoming more plausible, rather than less, and the lab leak theory is looking less plausible without some very far-fetched and far-reaching theorizing necessary to paper over the cracks.
 
I think the chapter on HIV in Spillover is quite good. It goes pretty deeply into the OPV theory of AIDS (which was that oral polio vaccine used a form of the simian version of AIDS which then led to the HIV and then AIDS) and also Worobey's involvement in initially accompanying W. D. Hamilton (a prominent proponent of the theory) to Congo to find blood samples in order to see if it contained SIV. Apparently Hamilton contracted malaria on the trip and later died, and the blood samples showed no SIV.
Regarding Worobey's theory here, the TWIV team don't really ask many questions because, as they say at the end, Worobey basically answers all the ones that they planned to ask, and they apparently had a lot that they wanted to ask.

Regarding the wild animals, I don't think Worobey thinks they came from near Wuhan, as far as I remember. They could have been farmed many miles away.

I also don't think he is arguing it spilled over in multiple markets. Just one.

How did it get adapted to humans? Well, presumably there is a survivorship bias. Lineage A was not as adaptive as B, and maybe there were others that fizzled out. We know it was adapting all the time as he even mentions another variant that completely took over.

And we can hardly say he is "ignoring" the proximity of the labs. It was the very proximity of the labs that got him and Jesse Bloom to write a letter to Science saying that the lab leak theory needs to be taken seriously.

Anyway, it will be interesting to see what the peer reviewers make of it.

I think I may have forgotten to point out that Matt Ridley was one of the proponents of the theory that AIDS had come from the oral polio vaccine and not a spillover.

Well, here he is going back to that theory now. I think when we see these kinds of thought processes then it becomes pretty clear why lab leak is thought of a conspiracy theory....
 

Attachments

  • Ridley back to OPV.jpg
    Ridley back to OPV.jpg
    47.5 KB · Views: 10
I'm going to necro this thread, a little, as one of the contentious suggestions about the origins of Covid has been that all the top scientist guys - Fauci, Andersen, Farrar, Vallance, Holmes, etc... knew that the virus had come from a lab and then tried to hush it up.

Then some redacted emails came out in which it was thought that they had admitted the origins, or of making the virus, and had decided to redact those bits.

I think I may have had a bit of fun with those claiming that this is what lay under the redactions.

Anyway, now the unredacted emails have been released.

I have not read them all, but here is a thread by Angie Rasumussen in which she argues that what is going on here is a group of scientists initially wondering in horror if the virus had indeed been engineered, and then changing their mind the more they looked into it.

Link
 
Headline: Lab Leak Most Likely Origin of Covid-19 Pandemic, Energy Department Now Says

U.S. agency’s revised assessment is based on new intelligence

Reality:

The conclusion from the energy department – which oversees a network of 17 US laboratories, including areas of advanced biology – is considered significant despite the fact that, as the report said, the agency made its updated judgment with “low confidence”.

In meteorological terms, that is <20%.

Still leaves US agencies that report on the pandemic 4-2 in favour of natural origins.

Murdoch priming the pump?
 
Headline: Lab Leak Most Likely Origin of Covid-19 Pandemic, Energy Department Now Says

U.S. agency’s revised assessment is based on new intelligence
Paywalled, and I can find no reference to it on the DOE's website. Seems like they are trying to keep it quiet...

Meanwhile
White House national security adviser Jake Sullivan on Sunday responded to a new Wall Street Journal report that found the Department of Energy has concluded the COVID-19 pandemic most likely developed from a lab leak, saying there’s “no definitive answer” on the question.

“Here’s what I can tell you. President Biden has directed, repeatedly, every element of our intelligence community to put effort and resources behind getting to the bottom of this question,” Sullivan said on CNN’s “State of the Union.”

“If we gain any further insight or information, we will share it with Congress, and we will share it with the American people. But right now, there is not a definitive answer that has emerged from the intelligence community on this question,” the national security adviser said.
 
You can't say "low confidence" of a lab origin means 2-4 likelihood without saying what the confidence is for a natural spillover event. Both could be equally low confidence. I happen to think, as I have posted and supported my POV before that there is a bias begun when Peter Daszak manipulated the early conclusions. A lot of scientists don't want to believe it was a lableak.


Moving on:
Did you miss the whistleblower who reported it was the lab. He worked with EcoHealth Alliance.

Our past discussion was pretty much at a stalemate. Then I ended up in the hospital for 2 weeks with respiratory failure (autoimmune diagnosed though it was quite disturbing to read my lung CT had a "ground glass" appearance :eek: ). That was ~5 months ago. I'm not totally better but hopefully I'm getting there.

Anywho... The whistleblower articles showed up but I wasn't ready to start this debate again. I haven't read his book yet.

Here are a couple of the links I've bookmarked:

WA Times: Virus hunter for EcoHealth Alliance says COVID-19 leaked from Chinese lab
Andrew Huff, an infectious disease epidemiologist and former vice president at the New York-based EcoHealth Alliance, said in an interview that the group was engaged in “gain-of-function” research at the Wuhan Institute of Virology in the years before the COVID-19 virus first emerged from the Chinese city in late 2019. He said he is convinced that the virus that caused the COVID-19 pandemic was manufactured at the institute’s laboratory and leaked out.

“I suspected that this was a lab leak from Day One, and as time went on, the information gaps that I had were filled,” Mr. Huff said.


Scientist who worked at Wuhan lab says Covid was man-made virus
In his new book — The Truth About Wuhan — whistleblower Dr Huff claims the pandemic was the result of the US government’s funding of dangerous genetic engineering of coronaviruses in China.

The epidemiologist said China’s gain-of-function experiments, carried out with shoddy biosecurity, led to a lab leak at the US-funded Wuhan Institute of Virology.

“EcoHealth Alliance and foreign laboratories did not have the adequate control measures in place for ensuring proper biosafety, biosecurity, and risk management, ultimately resulting in the lab leak at the Wuhan Institute of Virology,” he said in his book, ...
That last paragraph has been thoroughly documented in this thread.


The NIH did not monitor how its money was spent regardless of Fauci's denials.
'Extremely disconcerting': NIH didn't track U.S. funds going to Chinese virus research, watchdog finds
The National Institutes of Health failed to provide adequate oversight of an American organization that funded controversial research at the Wuhan Institute of Virology in China, according to a new government report that is sure to raise new questions about the origins of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The report is evidence of “major failures in past NIH oversight of high-risk research on enhanced potential pandemic pathogens,” Rutgers molecular biologist Richard Ebright told Yahoo News in an email.

Issued by the inspector general of the federal Department of Health and Human Services, the new report says nothing about the origins of the coronavirus. ...

But it does note that the American organization in question, the EcoHealth Alliance, should have been more rigorously scrutinized by federal officials regarding assurances that its partner lab in Wuhan was not using U.S. funds to conduct gain-of-function research, which boosts viruses to study how they might evolve in nature.



For more genetic evidence:
Thus spoke peptides: SARS-CoV-2 spike gene evolved in humans and then shortly in rats while the rest of its genome in horseshoe bats and then in treeshrews
Abstract
SARS-CoV-2 is suspected to be the product of a natural or artificial recombination of two viruses – one adapted to the horseshoe bat and the other, donor of the spike protein gene, adapted to an unknown species. Here we used a new method to search for the original host of the ancestor of the SARS-CoV-2 virus and for the donor of its gene for the spike protein, the molecule responsible for binding to and entering human cells. We computed immunological T-distances (the number of different peptides that are present in the viral proteins but absent in proteins of the host) between 11 species of coronaviruses and 38 representatives of the main mammal clades. Analyses of pentapeptides, the presumed principal targets of T-cell non-self recognition, showed the smallest T-distance of the spike protein of SARS-CoV-2 to humans, while the rest of SARS-CoV-2 proteome to the horseshoe bat. This suggests that the ancestor of SARS-CoV-2 was adapted to bats, but the spike gene donor was adapted to humans. Further analyses suggest that the ancestral coronavirus adapted to bats was shortly passaged in treeshrews, while the donor of the spike gene was shortly passaged in rats before the recombination event.
Sure sounds like gain of function research, manipulating the genome. That is unless someone thinks the virus acquired human gene segment(s) that had been passed through treeshrews and rats, all in the wild. :rolleyes:
 
You can't say "low confidence" of a lab origin means 2-4 likelihood without saying what the confidence is for a natural spillover event. Both could be equally low confidence. I happen to think, as I have posted and supported my POV before that there is a bias begun when Peter Daszak manipulated the early conclusions. A lot of scientists don't want to believe it was a lableak.


Moving on:
Did you miss the whistleblower who reported it was the lab. He worked with EcoHealth Alliance.

Our past discussion was pretty much at a stalemate. Then I ended up in the hospital for 2 weeks with respiratory failure (autoimmune diagnosed though it was quite disturbing to read my lung CT had a "ground glass" appearance :eek: ). That was ~5 months ago. I'm not totally better but hopefully I'm getting there.

Anywho... The whistleblower articles showed up but I wasn't ready to start this debate again. I haven't read his book yet.

Here are a couple of the links I've bookmarked:

WA Times: Virus hunter for EcoHealth Alliance says COVID-19 leaked from Chinese lab


Scientist who worked at Wuhan lab says Covid was man-made virusThat last paragraph has been thoroughly documented in this thread.


The NIH did not monitor how its money was spent regardless of Fauci's denials.
'Extremely disconcerting': NIH didn't track U.S. funds going to Chinese virus research, watchdog finds



For more genetic evidence:
Thus spoke peptides: SARS-CoV-2 spike gene evolved in humans and then shortly in rats while the rest of its genome in horseshoe bats and then in treeshrewsSure sounds like gain of function research, manipulating the genome. That is unless someone thinks the virus acquired human gene segment(s) that had been passed through treeshrews and rats, all in the wild. :rolleyes:

No, no one thinks that happened in the wild.

Everyone thinks that happened in the wet markets, where all kinds of animals are packed next to each other in cages, and are handled by humans everyday.

:rolleyes:
 
Murdoch priming the pump? :rolleyes: Maybe trying to distract from the Dominion lawsuit and exposed stolen election lies but it's not like Fox is the only news agency report.

Not paywalled news on the DoE report:

MSN/CNN: US Energy Department assesses Covid-19 likely resulted from lab leak, furthering US intel divide over virus origin
Two sources said that the Department of Energy assessed in the intelligence report that it had “low confidence” the Covid-19 virus accidentally escaped from a lab in Wuhan.

Intelligence agencies can make assessments with either low, medium or high confidence. A low confidence assessment generally means that the information obtained is not reliable enough or is too fragmented to make a more definitive analytic judgment or that there is not enough information available to draw a more robust conclusion.

Like I said above:
In 2021, the intelligence community declassified a report that showed four agencies in the intelligence community had assessed with low confidence that the virus likely jumped from animals to humans naturally in the wild, while one assessed with moderate confidence that the pandemic was the result of a laboratory accident.

I believe this represents the stalemate that this thread became:
In May 2020, researchers at the government-backed Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory issued a classified report that found it was possible that the coronavirus escaped from a lab in Wuhan, which came at a time when that line of inquiry was considered taboo.

The US began exploring the possibility that Covid-19 spread in a laboratory as early as April 2020, though the intelligence community has noted repeatedly that a lack of cooperation from Beijing has made it difficult to get to the bottom of the question.

A total muck up because who could trust anything Trump's minions said and then you had Daszak and Fauci denying the uS funded any gain-of-function research.


As expected the GOP is having a field day with the DoE report.
 
No, no one thinks that happened in the wild.

Everyone thinks that happened in the wet markets, where all kinds of animals are packed next to each other in cages, and are handled by humans everyday.

:rolleyes:
Come on, move the discussion forward. If you think a spillover occurred in the wet market in Wuhan then post some new evidence of the intermediate species involved, cases circulating in an intermediate species before the spillover, data on the initial cases in WuHan that China is withholding etc. Those are some of the holes in the spillover hypothesis.

Otherwise you are just recycling stuff we debated ad nauseum. It's fine if you want to say what POV you have concluded, but don't go dismissing the whistleblower with unsupported generalities that "no one thinks". Because obviously many people have settled on the lab leak side.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom