Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
In a person in a car ? Easily.

If you had a person driving around in a car spreading a virus you'd expect an outbreak at every location they stop, not a single outbreak 20 miles away and no outbreaks anyplace else, not even the lab where they contracted it in the first place.
 
So, how's the work of finding the presumed natural zoonotic origin of Covid-19 coming along? Are large numbers of additional species/samples still being tested monthly? Given the importance of the question and the massive effort required to answer it, is this still a major priority of virology and health authorities in China and around the world?

Or has it morphed into more of an "OJ Simpson still searching hard for the real killer" kind of thing?
 
So, how's the work of finding the presumed natural zoonotic origin of Covid-19 coming along? Are large numbers of additional species/samples still being tested monthly? Given the importance of the question and the massive effort required to answer it, is this still a major priority of virology and health authorities in China and around the world?

Or has it morphed into more of an "OJ Simpson still searching hard for the real killer" kind of thing?

There clearly should be a lot more animal and serological testing along the wildlife route.

I don’t know if anyone really knows how much is being done. From what I gather, most western scientists cannot get into China to do the research.

Some has been done in countries bordering China where viruses similar to SARS-CoV2 have been found.

The main problem is that China’s semi-official position is that the virus came from abroad (Italy or America), and NOT from the wildlife trade, so they don’t want to look too hard into that.
 
The main problem is that China’s semi-official position is that the virus came from abroad (Italy or America), and NOT from the wildlife trade, so they don’t want to look too hard into that.

Of the possible explanations, that one is the most ◊◊◊◊◊◊*-crazy of them all.
 
There clearly should be a lot more animal and serological testing along the wildlife route.

I don’t know if anyone really knows how much is being done. From what I gather, most western scientists cannot get into China to do the research.

Some has been done in countries bordering China where viruses similar to SARS-CoV2 have been found.

The main problem is that China’s semi-official position is that the virus came from abroad (Italy or America), and NOT from the wildlife trade, so they don’t want to look too hard into that.

Wasn't there something about it escaping or being brought from a lab in the US via a military games or somesuch? I'm sure the US haters are still slavering over that one.
 
The problem has always been that pandemics go from animal to people not via a lab. The 1917 A1H1 Flu pandemic spread from birds to US pigs to people (and this virus still circulates). The 1957 AH2N2 flu pandemic which mutated into the 1968 AH3N2 pandemic strain originated from Geese in China. HIV 1 originated from chimpanzees and HIV 2 from monkeys, there may also have been transmission events from gorillas which have not spread worldwide. SARS came via bats and civets to humans, although failed to become pandemic. Monkeypox likewise originated by spread from rodents. Smallpox probably arose from camels about 2 -3 Kyr BP, measles probably originated from cattle about the same time.

So pandemic viral events routinely occur by contact between humans and animals; so to justify a case for a non-animal origin you really need to disprove an animal origin; exceptional claims require exceptional evidence.
 
The problem has always been that pandemics go from animal to people not via a lab. The 1917 A1H1 Flu pandemic spread from birds to US pigs to people (and this virus still circulates). The 1957 AH2N2 flu pandemic which mutated into the 1968 AH3N2 pandemic strain originated from Geese in China. HIV 1 originated from chimpanzees and HIV 2 from monkeys, there may also have been transmission events from gorillas which have not spread worldwide. SARS came via bats and civets to humans, although failed to become pandemic. Monkeypox likewise originated by spread from rodents. Smallpox probably arose from camels about 2 -3 Kyr BP, measles probably originated from cattle about the same time.

So pandemic viral events routinely occur by contact between humans and animals; so to justify a case for a non-animal origin you really need to disprove an animal origin; exceptional claims require exceptional evidence.

Most scenarios I heard about lab theory are animal origin, except the transfer happened in the lab, or in the lab workers outside the lab, like during sample collection. Even if you improve the virus in the lab using natural methods, like simple selection of the fittest .. you have to test the virus in an animal .. and if it leaks, it will still be animal origin.
I think the question is if the lab or lab workers assisted in the virus introduction in any way. In other words, if the lab intended to prevent new pandemics didn't actually helped to create one.
 
The problem has always been that pandemics go from animal to people not via a lab.
But this is not really an argument against a lab leak is it? Lab leaks have occurred, and people have been infected from them with fatal outcomes. They just have not resulted in a pandemic, because people are already vaccinated against the disease - a specific example is poliomyelitis.
 
While I understand the reasons for dismissal of the "lab leak" hypothesis, but what changes if conclusive evidence is found for intentional or unintentional leak from the Wuhan bio lab?
 
So, how's the work of finding the presumed natural zoonotic origin of Covid-19 coming along? Are large numbers of additional species/samples still being tested monthly? Given the importance of the question and the massive effort required to answer it, is this still a major priority of virology and health authorities in China and around the world?

Or has it morphed into more of an "OJ Simpson still searching hard for the real killer" kind of thing?

The problem is that Covid jumps species so readily, if you find it in a wildlife population it's difficult to know if this was a human variant that spread to that animal population.

That said, one close Covid relative has been identified that has a spike protein that diverged from Covid less than a decade ago. The trail of close Covid relatives seems to point to SE Asia somewhere near the Thailand China border. Not only have a number of close relatives been found there. but Covid reactive antibodies have been found in wild populations as well.

Most virologists seem to be assuming raccoon dogs were likely an intermediate host, but again Covid jumps species so readily that it could be any of the dozens of animals present in the Huanan Seafood market. Environmental samples suggest Covid was widespread in the animals kept there, so narrowing it down to a single species may not even make sense.
 
There clearly should be a lot more animal and serological testing along the wildlife route.

I don’t know if anyone really knows how much is being done. From what I gather, most western scientists cannot get into China to do the research.

Some has been done in countries bordering China where viruses similar to SARS-CoV2 have been found.

The main problem is that China’s semi-official position is that the virus came from abroad (Italy or America), and NOT from the wildlife trade, so they don’t want to look too hard into that.
Blaming the wildlife trade calls Chinese cultural practices into question, China really does not want Covid to be a result of this. They did the same thing with SARS, effectually trying to blame it on anything else until Dr Shi positively identified the exact cave SARS originated it.

Keep in mind that most of the lab leak CT's try to insinuate Dr Shi is one of the principles involved in the supposed cover-up when in fact history shows she is more than willing to engage in research the Chinese government would prefer not to come to light.

Wasn't there something about it escaping or being brought from a lab in the US via a military games or somesuch? I'm sure the US haters are still slavering over that one.

A level 4 US military lab in Virginia was closed due to safety violation just prior to the military games. That version of the lab leak hypothesis posits that the violation in question was the accidental release of Covid which was then carried to China by US military personnel.

This is yet another "early Covid" hypothesis that would require Covid to be circulating much earlier than the earliest identified cases and earlier than genetic clock studies typically say Covid jumped to humans. It also doesn't account for the fact there were 2 distinct Covid lineages right from the start, something best explained by multiple crossovers from a wild population rather than a single lab leak.
 
Most scenarios I heard about lab theory are animal origin, except the transfer happened in the lab, or in the lab workers outside the lab, like during sample collection. Even if you improve the virus in the lab using natural methods, like simple selection of the fittest .. you have to test the virus in an animal .. and if it leaks, it will still be animal origin.
I think the question is if the lab or lab workers assisted in the virus introduction in any way. In other words, if the lab intended to prevent new pandemics didn't actually helped to create one.

This would necessitate a very closely related virus not only being present in lab samples but actively being studies. No sufficiently closely related virus exists either in retroactive analysis of samples or in any database.

It would also require lab staff to have been infected, but tests show no sign of Covid antibodies in any lab workers.

And again, he early infections are all in the wrong place for a lab leak, but exactly where you'd expect to find them for zoonotic crossover due to the wildlife trade.

In terms of lab experimentation, the discovery of closely a whole range of related Corona viruses in various stages of evolution, strongly point to something that evolved naturally. Furthermore, the Covid RBD actually contains sequences that are out of frame, meaning you don't expect it to work at all. No lab experiment would do this.

There is also the fact that the furin cleavage site that allows Covid to infect so many creatures is only a partial cleave site. A full furin cleavage site would be much more efficient, and any lab would have used that instead, or would have if anyone had know what the effect of such a site was. Prior to actually studying Covid, however, no one knew the importance of this feature so there would have been no reason to play around with it.
 
Blaming the wildlife trade calls Chinese cultural practices into question, China really does not want Covid to be a result of this. They did the same thing with SARS, effectually trying to blame it on anything else until Dr Shi positively identified the exact cave SARS originated it.

Keep in mind that most of the lab leak CT's try to insinuate Dr Shi is one of the principles involved in the supposed cover-up when in fact history shows she is more than willing to engage in research the Chinese government would prefer not to come to light.

Indeed. The Chinese authorities even reprimanded Li Wenliang when he connected the virus to the seafood market right at the beginning of the pandemic:

Dr Li Wenliang, who lost his life to the novel coronavirus, SARS-CoV-2, became the face of the threat of SARS-CoV-2 to frontline workers, the clinicians taking care of patients. Li, 34, was an ophthalmologist at Wuhan Central Hospital. On 30th December, 2019, when the Wuhan municipal health service sent out an alert, he reportedly warned a closed group of ex-medical school classmates on the WeChat social media site of “Seven cases of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) like illness with links with the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market” at his hospital. He was among eight people reprimanded by security officers for “spreading rumours”. In a tragic turn of events, he subsequently contracted SARS-CoV-2 and, after a period in intensive care, died on the morning of Friday 7th February, 2020

Link

The idea that the "official Chinese government" story is that it spilled over from the market is completely wrong.
 
This would necessitate a very closely related virus not only being present in lab samples but actively being studies. No sufficiently closely related virus exists either in retroactive analysis of samples or in any database.

It would also require lab staff to have been infected, but tests show no sign of Covid antibodies in any lab workers.

And again, he early infections are all in the wrong place for a lab leak, but exactly where you'd expect to find them for zoonotic crossover due to the wildlife trade.

In terms of lab experimentation, the discovery of closely a whole range of related Corona viruses in various stages of evolution, strongly point to something that evolved naturally. Furthermore, the Covid RBD actually contains sequences that are out of frame, meaning you don't expect it to work at all. No lab experiment would do this.

There is also the fact that the furin cleavage site that allows Covid to infect so many creatures is only a partial cleave site. A full furin cleavage site would be much more efficient, and any lab would have used that instead, or would have if anyone had know what the effect of such a site was. Prior to actually studying Covid, however, no one knew the importance of this feature so there would have been no reason to play around with it.

Actually, I don't think that the highlighted is true. It does seem that this was a feature that virologists were looking for or had warned could increase a virus's pandemic potential.
 
While I understand the reasons for dismissal of the "lab leak" hypothesis, but what changes if conclusive evidence is found for intentional or unintentional leak from the Wuhan bio lab?

It would be an absolute PR disaster for China, as the entire pandemic could be completely and utterly blamed on them.

So, they would literally do anything to cover that up, if it were true. The idea that in modern China, such a conspiracy would be bound to come out is frankly laughable.

If it were true, anyone who tried to break such a story would be disappeared, their families threatened and disappeared. Any coverage in media or the web would be suppressed in minutes or even seconds.

China under Xi is not like any other country you know. It really isn't.
 
It would be an absolute PR disaster for China, as the entire pandemic could be completely and utterly blamed on them.

Why are you so interested in blaming China for the pandemic?

So, they would literally do anything to cover that up,

On the contrary, zoonotic crossover via wet markets are the wildlife trade are much bigger problem for China because it directly impinges on Chinese cultural practices.

China under Xi is not like any other country you know. It really isn't.

Not liking the Chinese government isn't evidence of a conspiracy, and remember there are (or at least were) western scientists working in these labs so the conspiracy wouldn't just be limited to Chinese scientists.

Also it's worth remembering that Chinese scientists are more or less just like western scientists and simply want to get to the truth. This includes looking into things like the wildlife trade that the Chinese government wants to protect.
 
I mentioned Jeffrey Sachs, earlier, claiming that Covid-19 came from a US lab.

Jeffrey Sachs of the Lancet Study Group is now suggesting it came from a US lab. But scientists say he is talking out of his arse as he is not a scientist and seems to be speculating. Link.

How credible is Sachs?

Looks like you can tune in and listen to him on a podcast hosted by... anti-vaxx campaigner, Robert Kennedy Jr...

https://anchor.fm/rfkjr/episodes/Origins-of-the-Virus-with-Jeffrey-Sachs-e1mob9s

Seriously...?!
 
It would be an absolute PR disaster for China, as the entire pandemic could be completely and utterly blamed on them.

So, they would literally do anything to cover that up, if it were true. The idea that in modern China, such a conspiracy would be bound to come out is frankly laughable.

If it were true, anyone who tried to break such a story would be disappeared, their families threatened and disappeared. Any coverage in media or the web would be suppressed in minutes or even seconds.

Li Wenliang is an example of someone who was silenced, but the news got out.

China under Xi is not like any other country you know. It really isn't.

I have been to China and I have also been to North Korea. I would say North Korea is easily more repressive than China is.

In fact, I have students from China who will sometimes tell me their views on Chinese policies and how social media is supressed (and a few of the ways people sort of get round those restrictions). Of course there are many ways China will shut down anything they don't like, but even then there are limits.

It was claimed on this thread that the Wuhan Military Games in October of 2019 was a superspreader event of Covid-19, and that the whole city was locked down while the athletes were there (and how they got Covid anyway). That level of locking down being completely scrubbed from all media and reporting is impossible. There are embassies and foreign students who would notice, as well as those with families abroad who would be able to pass on the messages.

Yes, China is repressive. Far more than any European country, but that fact doesn't mean we get to make up the origin carte-blanche in defiance of what scientific evidence we do have.
 
Actually, I don't think that the highlighted is true. It does seem that this was a feature that virologists were looking for or had warned could increase a virus's pandemic potential.

I don't remember the episode but I remember a discussion TWIV that said the importance of the furin cleavage site wasn't know until after scientists had seen Covid.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom