Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
When it comes to lab leak, again, is it a conspiracy theory?

Answer: It depends, OR not necessarily.

A virus could have leaked from a lab.

Some variations on the lab leak are conspiracy theories:

1.) It was a bioweapon! (this has been relegated to conspiracy theory territory; I am sure everyone will agree).
2.) It was engineered from RaTG-13 taken from sick miners and GoF'd into SARS-CoV2. This is popular with Matt Ridley, for example, and others toy with it. This has almost completely been debunked due to the existence of BANAL-52.

At this point, most of the scientific evidence suggests the virus emanated from Huanan Seafood Market in December, with possible emergence being November, and much less likely earlier.

The challenge: Could someone come up with a lab leak scenario that is consistent with the known scientific evidence and does not rely on large amounts of conspiracy theorising to paper over the cracks?
 
When it comes to lab leak, again, is it a conspiracy theory?

Answer: It depends, OR not necessarily.

A virus could have leaked from a lab.

Some variations on the lab leak are conspiracy theories:

1.) It was a bioweapon! (this has been relegated to conspiracy theory territory; I am sure everyone will agree).
2.) It was engineered from RaTG-13 taken from sick miners and GoF'd into SARS-CoV2. This is popular with Matt Ridley, for example, and others toy with it. This has almost completely been debunked due to the existence of BANAL-52.


At this point, most of the scientific evidence suggests the virus emanated from Huanan Seafood Market in December, with possible emergence being November, and much less likely earlier.

The challenge: Could someone come up with a lab leak scenario that is consistent with the known scientific evidence and does not rely on large amounts of conspiracy theorising to paper over the cracks?

3) Scientists are covering up evidence for a lab leak. While a coverup isn't impossible any large scale coverup is going to leave a lot of evidence, and in this evidence doesn't exist. Such claims of large scale coverups that leave no convincing evidence are pretty much the defining characteristic of a conspiracy theory.
 
3) Scientists are covering up evidence for a lab leak. While a coverup isn't impossible any large scale coverup is going to leave a lot of evidence, and in this evidence doesn't exist. Such claims of large scale coverups that leave no convincing evidence are pretty much the defining characteristic of a conspiracy theory.

Correct, but if there had been a lab leak, the few who actually had evidence on the virus being held or developed in the lab would be in the lab itself and they wouldn't be telling anyone. Simple fear that it might have been a lab leak would be enough to bias the scientific community involved in virus research towards a different scenario.
 
Correct, but if there had been a lab leak, the few who actually had evidence on the virus being held or developed in the lab would be in the lab itself and they wouldn't be telling anyone. Simple fear that it might have been a lab leak would be enough to bias the scientific community involved in virus research towards a different scenario.

Here’s where conspiracy theories always fall down. Any major conspiracy, like the covid lab leak one, would involve a large number of people who have networks surrounding them. To imagine so many people keeping quiet is fanciful.
 
Here’s where conspiracy theories always fall down. Any major conspiracy, like the covid lab leak one, would involve a large number of people who have networks surrounding them. To imagine so many people keeping quiet is fanciful.

So you already biased your comment with your assumption that the idea of a lab leak coverup is a conspiracy involving thousands. I'm pointing out that those who actually know what was being worked on in the labs would be a small number. Hence there would be no need to keep a large number quiet. Also remembering that this is China, where keeping quiet is a way of life.
 
Last edited:
So you already biased your comment with your assumption that the idea of a lab leak coverup is a conspiracy involving thousands. I'm pointing out that those who actually know what was being worked on in the labs would be a small number. Hence there would be no need to keep a large number quiet. Also remembering that this is China, where keeping quiet is a way of life.

I did not say thousands. I did say more than a few. You have no basis for your opinion of a few knowing. You are making the claim only a few would have known. The onus is on you.
 
I did not say thousands. I did say more than a few. You have no basis for your opinion of a few knowing. You are making the claim only a few would have known. The onus is on you.

Actually I said a small number. in the post you responded to. How many would be working in the lab? Less than a large number I suspect. Small enough to control? Probably.

Stop quibbling. I'm sure you can understand my point that the coverup need not involve thousands.
 
Actually I said a small number. in the post you responded to. How many would be working in the lab? Less than a large number I suspect. Small enough to control? Probably.

Stop quibbling. I'm sure you can understand my point that the coverup need not involve thousands.

Er, I quoted you saying “the few”. And to repeat I did not say thousands. Please stop lying.
 
Er, I quoted you saying “the few”. And to repeat I did not say thousands. Please stop lying.

Oh good grief, fine, I said the few and then said a small number, and you didn't say thousands. My point still stands and your quibbling over numbers does nothing for your argumant.
 
It should also be pointed out that in China it would mean severe punishment if you spilled the beans and admitted there was a lab leak.

I am not saying there was a lab leak, even though I don’t think it is impossible. I just think that if there were, it would be highly unlikely that one of the Chinese working in the lab would say so.
 
Here’s where conspiracy theories always fall down. Any major conspiracy, like the covid lab leak one, would involve a large number of people who have networks surrounding them. To imagine so many people keeping quiet is fanciful.
This.The "lab leak" theory is and was nonsense. But the cranks supporting it are threatening and abusive.
 
It should also be pointed out that in China it would mean severe punishment if you spilled the beans and admitted there was a lab leak.

I am not saying there was a lab leak, even though I don’t think it is impossible. I just think that if there were, it would be highly unlikely that one of the Chinese working in the lab would say so.

Theres that, and the fact that until a virulent killer was identified elsewhere no one in the lab would have any idea that one of the multitude of viruses they had been working on in the past was in any way responsible.

Consider the workings of such a lab. Viruses are sampled from all sorts of places and brought to the lab. I assume they are then analysed categorised and stored. Perhaps some are brought out, subjected to experiment and the results of that experimentation would also be analysed categorised and stored.

Assuming for a moment that one of the researchers gets contaminated and carries a virus outside the lab. Given the ability of covid to transmit without symptoms or with minor symptoms, unless the researcher got sick enough for hospital where their illness would be analysed they would have no idea they had carried a virus outside the lab.

So at that point, the lab itself would have finished with the virus and be continuing with its work in total ignorance.

Then a virus is found spreading near the lab. The lab researchers might wonder if their lab could somehow be the cause, but no more than that. Finally the virus is analysed well enough that a trawl through the lab databases might find a match to the new killer virus. Now, how many of the lab researchers have the access and the time to carry out that trawl off their own bat and would they dare? and if they do find a match? Are they really going to go to the press? or are they more likely to report to the lab director?

Personally I consider that the numbers of people who would actually know for sure that a match for the killer virus had been found in the lab databases would be very small indeed and eminently controllable. Lots of others might have suspicions, but a concerted programme of disinformation and intimidation would easily convince them to reign in their ideas.

Do I think it happened that way? Meh, who knows, I wouldn't put money on it myself, but then I'm not that enamoured of the alternatives either. Case unproven for the whole thing.

However, the above is why I object to the "But they must have had to silence thousands who knew the truth to hide it" claims frequently made on here. this wasn't a few thousand emails saying "Capitol Hill, next Sunday - bring pitchforks and AR15s" this was a few people looking over databases and in fear of their livelyhoods and even lives.
 
Theres that, and the fact that until a virulent killer was identified elsewhere no one in the lab would have any idea that one of the multitude of viruses they had been working on in the past was in any way responsible.

Consider the workings of such a lab. Viruses are sampled from all sorts of places and brought to the lab. I assume they are then analysed categorised and stored. Perhaps some are brought out, subjected to experiment and the results of that experimentation would also be analysed categorised and stored.

Assuming for a moment that one of the researchers gets contaminated and carries a virus outside the lab. Given the ability of covid to transmit without symptoms or with minor symptoms, unless the researcher got sick enough for hospital where their illness would be analysed they would have no idea they had carried a virus outside the lab.

So at that point, the lab itself would have finished with the virus and be continuing with its work in total ignorance.

Then a virus is found spreading near the lab. The lab researchers might wonder if their lab could somehow be the cause, but no more than that. Finally the virus is analysed well enough that a trawl through the lab databases might find a match to the new killer virus. Now, how many of the lab researchers have the access and the time to carry out that trawl off their own bat and would they dare? and if they do find a match? Are they really going to go to the press? or are they more likely to report to the lab director?

Personally I consider that the numbers of people who would actually know for sure that a match for the killer virus had been found in the lab databases would be very small indeed and eminently controllable. Lots of others might have suspicions, but a concerted programme of disinformation and intimidation would easily convince them to reign in their ideas.

Do I think it happened that way? Meh, who knows, I wouldn't put money on it myself, but then I'm not that enamoured of the alternatives either. Case unproven for the whole thing.

However, the above is why I object to the "But they must have had to silence thousands who knew the truth to hide it" claims frequently made on here. this wasn't a few thousand emails saying "Capitol Hill, next Sunday - bring pitchforks and AR15s" this was a few people looking over databases and in fear of their livelyhoods and even lives.

This is possible, of course. However, this scenario misses the point that nearly every posited lab leak theory has argued that the virus was itself manipulated in some way. If what you are saying is that a lab worker went off into the wild, got contaminated and then spread the virus, maybe with only one or two people knowing it was in the database OR maybe it never getting to the database stage, this is all possible. BUT in addition to the claim that it was engineered, the claim it may have accidentally got out now seems to be undermined by the evidence that it probably came from the Huanan seafood market. This is in addition to the, maybe slightly less solid, claim that there were multiple lineages (at least two apparently) that came from two spillover events. This kind of evidence makes the lab leak less obvious UNLESS you start trying to explain the scientific claims supporting lab leak as some kind of collusion among many scientists and their reviewers.
 
This is possible, of course. However, this scenario misses the point that nearly every posited lab leak theory has argued that the virus was itself manipulated in some way. If what you are saying is that a lab worker went off into the wild, got contaminated and then spread the virus, maybe with only one or two people knowing it was in the database OR maybe it never getting to the database stage, this is all possible. BUT in addition to the claim that it was engineered, the claim it may have accidentally got out now seems to be undermined by the evidence that it probably came from the Huanan seafood market. This is in addition to the, maybe slightly less solid, claim that there were multiple lineages (at least two apparently) that came from two spillover events. This kind of evidence makes the lab leak less obvious UNLESS you start trying to explain the scientific claims supporting lab leak as some kind of collusion among many scientists and their reviewers.

Hmm, I've included the possibility of manipulation but haven't assumed it. The researcher I mention could have picked it up in the lab either during first analysis or during any further work on the virus (GOF being only one possibility) and then gone outside (I'm assuming they were allowed to go home at the end of the day :) )

Understand I am not fixated on this scenario, nor am I fixated on the whole lab leak theory, I am just using it to explain my reluctance to accept the usual "it has to be a conspiracy theory because they would have to have silenced so many people" statements that abound both here and elsewhere.
 
Actually I said a small number. in the post you responded to. How many would be working in the lab? Less than a large number I suspect. Small enough to control? Probably.

Stop quibbling. I'm sure you can understand my point that the coverup need not involve thousands.

I believe the number of WiV staff working in the lab is ~300. All were tested for Covid early on and the test results came back negative, which further extends the conspiracy to people who performed the testing.

Of course since that lab is far removed from where all the early cases are the "lab leak" have since moved on to saying it wasn't the WiV at all but the Chinese NiH who have a lab that is much closer but still several Km from where all the early cases occurred. Of course this doesn't stop them from claiming it's still a conspiracy of scientists working with WiV covering everything up.
 
It should also be pointed out that in China it would mean severe punishment if you spilled the beans and admitted there was a lab leak.

I am not saying there was a lab leak, even though I don’t think it is impossible. I just think that if there were, it would be highly unlikely that one of the Chinese working in the lab would say so.

nah. Dr Shi has challenged the official government line in the past. She was the one who tracked down the Origin of SARS when the Chinese government was insisting it wasn't spillover due to wild animal trade.

Also worth noting is that zoonotic spillover is a direct challenge to Chinese culture, so the Chinese government is more apt to cover that up then a lab leak. In fact China is still pushing the idea that it was US lab leak at US military level 4 lab that was closed due to safety issues just before military personnel went to China for the military games.
 
Theres that, and the fact that until a virulent killer was identified elsewhere no one in the lab would have any idea that one of the multitude of viruses they had been working on in the past was in any way responsible.

Consider the workings of such a lab. Viruses are sampled from all sorts of places and brought to the lab. I assume they are then analysed categorised and stored. Perhaps some are brought out, subjected to experiment and the results of that experimentation would also be analysed categorised and stored.

Assuming for a moment that one of the researchers gets contaminated and carries a virus outside the lab. Given the ability of covid to transmit without symptoms or with minor symptoms, unless the researcher got sick enough for hospital where their illness would be analysed they would have no idea they had carried a virus outside the lab.

So at that point, the lab itself would have finished with the virus and be continuing with its work in total ignorance.

There is a catalog, Covid was not it.
There are preserved samples, no Covid was found in them
The staff were tested for Covid and Covid antibodies, no evidence of Covid infection was found
The lab is nowhere near where the early cases occurred. It would be roughly comparable to blaming a lab in Hoboken New Jersey for a disease outbreak in central park.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom