Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
What is entertaining is that neither side (lab leak vs nature) can shore up their positions.

What "shoring up" is required? The first know cases come from in and around the market and radiate outwards from there. This by itself is compelling evidence that the pandemic originated in that market. Furthermore the virus has been confirmed as being in animals in that market, the Covid genome is consistent with an evolutionary spectrum of Corona viruses known to exist in the wild, there were multiple strains right from the start something you'd only expect if it were of zoonotic origin.

Conversely the initial outbreak is in the wrong place at the wrong time to be a lab leak, the virus has never been identified in existing lab samples, which it should if it was a lab leak, and as pointed out by others the idea that it's a human engineered virus has been completely debunked.
 
That's how real scientific papers are worded...



Pseudoscience love binary choices, real science does not.
I guess being partially pregnant is being considered "real science". Unless you are engaged with something that cannot be tested... then speculation is accepted. Areas like String Theory are required to have speculation but not virology. It can be tested, if the proper elements are found (that is why the virologist are looking for that creature). Until the accepted basis of zoonotic transmission is established... it cannot be called zoonotic. That is straight forward without equivocation and we are currently at that phase unless you can provide conclusive proof otherwise.
 
What "shoring up" is required? The first know cases come from in and around the market and radiate outwards from there.
You just stated that the total process of COVID-19 started in the market... how insane is that? There is a difference between when something is first notice and where, when and how what was noticed came to being.

This by itself is compelling evidence that the pandemic originated in that market.
I am not arguing that it was not found in the market, I do however take exception that COVID-19 originated in the Huanan Market. Please provide your proof that COVID-19 originated in the market.

Furthermore the virus has been confirmed as being in animals in that market
There were animals in the market place that had this virus susceptibility but I am not aware that an animal from the Huanan market was tested and found to contain the virus. Please provide your support for that claim.

the Covid genome is consistent with an evolutionary spectrum of Corona viruses known to exist in the wild, there were multiple strains right from the start something you'd only expect if it were of zoonotic origin.
Wrong but prove your point by providing conclusive evidence that COVID-19 is a natural occurrence.

Conversely the initial outbreak is in the wrong place at the wrong time to be a lab leak, the virus has never been identified in existing lab samples, which it should if it was a lab leak, and as pointed out by others the idea that it's a human engineered virus has been completely debunked.
You provided a nice summation as to why a lab leak is difficult, if not impossible, to determine. Having said that, if the virus is naturally found then that will support your claim; unfortunately that has not taken place hence why we have speculation and all of those scientific terms like... "likely", "however" and "suggest" are laced in those papers.
 
Also, only conspiracy theorists, Fox News and woos (and some in this thread) make definitive statements about the origin of covid. Real scientists make considered statements. Is this speculation? **** no.
Real scientists don't tell you what to think; real scientist provide their findings along with explanations regarding assumptions... not speculations. I see no mathematics applied to the claims that COVID-19 could be found in nature or should be found in nature. The most current papers are resource richer than the releases in early 2020 yet they fail to make appreciable advances in the zoonotic theory. These incremental forward movements are similar to a mini-Bayes' Theory where each new piece of information improves your chances but failing to make it home. This is the proverbial rabbit who is 5 miles away from his destination and if he jumps half the distance to his destination with each hop... how many hops will it take to reach the destination?
 
I guess being partially pregnant is being considered "real science".

Partly and probably are two different word with two different meanings. You should really spend some time figuring out what they mean before you try to use them in a sentence...


Unless you are engaged with something that cannot be tested... then speculation is accepted. Areas like String Theory are required to have speculation but not virology. It can be tested, if the proper elements are found (that is why the virologist are looking for that creature).

If you are doing something that can't be tested it's not science. What you don't seem to understand is that a positive test means the hypothesis you are testing is probably correct. At least if the test is any good.

It can be tested, if the proper elements are found (that is why the virologist are looking for that creature). Until the accepted basis of zoonotic transmission is established... it cannot be called zoonotic.

It can be tested, and in fact has been tested. We know what the fingerprint for zoonotic origin looks like in terms of who gets infected, where and when and what the virus should look like compared to it's wild relatives. These tests come up positive.

We also know the early infection profile for a lab leak, where and when cases occur and what a man made virus would look like and what research records would show if it was a natural virus released by accident. These come up negative.

Both sets of tests heavily favor zoonotic origin, which is why the scientists who activaly study virus outbreaks near unanimously say it's probably zoonotic in origin.
 
You just stated that the total process of COVID-19 started in the market... how insane is that? There is a difference between when something is first notice and where, when and how what was noticed came to being.

I am not arguing that it was not found in the market, I do however take exception that COVID-19 originated in the Huanan Market. Please provide your proof that COVID-19 originated in the market.

There were animals in the market place that had this virus susceptibility but I am not aware that an animal from the Huanan market was tested and found to contain the virus. Please provide your support for that claim.

Wrong but prove your point by providing conclusive evidence that COVID-19 is a natural occurrence.

You provided a nice summation as to why a lab leak is difficult, if not impossible, to determine. Having said that, if the virus is naturally found then that will support your claim; unfortunately that has not taken place hence why we have speculation and all of those scientific terms like... "likely", "however" and "suggest" are laced in those papers.

Nonsensical gibberish.

Viral outbreaks radiate outwards from their place of origin. The data shows the Covid outbreak radiating outward from the fish market. This tells us that the market was place the outbreak started.

Not only does the data not show the outbreak radiating outwards from the lab, the outbreak starts 25Km away from the lab and moves towards the lab, the exact opposite of what you'd expect from a lab leak.
 
Nonsensical gibberish.
Good way to not address comments...

Viral outbreaks radiate outwards from their place of origin. The data shows the Covid outbreak radiating outward from the fish market. This tells us that the market was place the outbreak started.
Origin of what? Origin of the virus itself or origin of people who contracted the virus?

Not only does the data not show the outbreak radiating outwards from the lab, the outbreak starts 25Km away from the lab and moves towards the lab, the exact opposite of what you'd expect from a lab leak.
You completely miss my points probably due to my inability to relate to your level (whatever level that is...)

I would rather have this COVID-19 be a natural creation. If it is a lab leak, then GOD help us for in the future we could have something much more dangerous than what we are currently experiencing.

If found naturally, we at least have an opportunity to address it and prepare like we have for decades. The problem if it was naturally created is that we (the World) must be lacking some skills needed to find the origin in a timely manner and I will say that close to 3 years is not timely when it comes to dealing with a pandemic.

In short, no matter if it is a lab leak or a natural occurrence we are screwed. We are screwed because we have people arguing about the wrong aspect of this pandemic. We should examining why the USA has the highest number of deaths per 1K due to COVID-19 than the entire west coast of Africa (worldometers has now stop keeping track of this for the USA). We should be examining why we made a knee jerk reaction to shutting down the economy without any supportive data outlining why quarantining will stop this virus. We should be examining our role as a country in funding experiments. We should be examining why our medical industry rolled over which allowed the government and insurance companies to dictate courses of actions along with employers.
 
We should examining why the USA has the highest number of deaths per 1K due to COVID-19 than the entire west coast of Africa
My guess would be that it was mostly due to the average life expectancy of Africans being sixty something, and the POTUS being a moron.

We should be examining why we made a knee jerk reaction to shutting down the economy without any supportive data outlining why quarantining will stop this virus
.
I think we had all the data we needed to support the contention that the spread of a highly infectious virus could be reduced by limiting person to person contact.
 
Did you also note that the researchers believe that those who think the virus was released from the lab are conspiracy theorists? Their words not mine.

And I'd rather their "likely" than the certainty of some who post here that the virus came from the lab.
If you had been following from the beginning you would have seen Daszak's big push to get everyone repeating the CT nonsense. To that Tedros from the WHO pushed back and noted this dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis was before any evidence had been collected about the possible origin of the virus in the lab. Other researchers pushed back noting there was no proof of either origin hypothesis.

That has not changed. Trying to dismiss the lab leak hypothesis as a CT is an attempt to cover up the fact the natural spillover hypothesis is unproven and still has many holes.

Why are you or anyone else here trying to assert one of the two origin hypotheses is a CT? What are you basing this CT accusation on? Who is doing this conspiring? How are you not just trying to insult people who are standing up for a view you don't hold?
There is one actual conspiracy. China is trying to prove the virus originated outside of China. And a number of researchers have a confirmation bias against finding a lab accident responsible for the pandemic. I've posted about these elements that are affecting the interpretation of the research.


The assertions in this thread and elsewhere that the natural spillover has been proven is false.

Where's the proof? There isn't any.

What are the holes in the natural spillover hypothesis?

No source animal.
No outbreaks outside of Wuhan and not just that, no outbreaks in Wuhan except near the WIV.
China has not shared key information about the earliest cases.
The virus appeared in humans ready to go right out of the box, that is highly unusual for a zoonosis source.
China took the coronavirus genome database offline.​

Have any of these problems been resolved? No, they haven't. Certain researchers filled in the blanks in their hypotheses where there was no supporting evidence.
 
... We should be examining why we made a knee jerk reaction to shutting down the economy without any supportive data outlining why quarantining will stop this virus. We should be examining our role as a country in funding experiments. We should be examining why our medical industry rolled over which allowed the government and insurance companies to dictate courses of actions along with employers.
That's off topic in this thread. Take it to one of the politics threads, thanks.
 
I've never got that impression, more that SG considers the commitment of others to the spillover event to be excessive.
You could put it that way when some people are willing to overlook the lack of established evidence because some researchers have hypothesized how this or that could have occurred.

You need evidence that it is how this or that occurred, not speculation how it might have occurred.
 
Who on here has made definitive statements? Some have stated that they consider the lab leak scenario is more convincing but I don't recall anyone stating an absolute belief in the idea of a lab leak.
Pretty much. The evidence supported position is that neither hypothesis has been proved.

Gleefully proclaiming one hypothesis is now favored is not an evidence based assertion. It's wishful thinking.
 
Beat me to it. Only the most deluded imagine Small Pox originated from a UK lab in the 1970s.

And this is relevant to this discussion, how? :boggled:

And who has ever made that claim in the first place? Never mind, don't answer, it's off topic.
 
The virus escaped... not one word was said about smallpox originating in GB.

Per the exchange below you gave Smallpox as an example of a novel virus originating from a lab leak from a British lab in the 1970's.

Conversely there isn't a single recorder example of a novel virus coming from a lab leak.


Completely false comment! Small pox escaped from British lab(s) in the 1970's.
 
Good way to not address comments...

Why would I address your nonsensical comments?

I would rather have this COVID-19 be a natural creation.

It is natural in origin. This has been demonstrated beyond any reasonable doubt. The virus has properties that no researcher would have known to even try prior to 2020 and other cases of unintelligent design" that no competent researcher would do.

To create such a virus would require a virologist who is simultaneous the most brilliant in the history of the field and utterly incompetent all at the same time.

We also traced much of Covids evolutionary history by studying it's close relatives, including 1 virus who's spike protein diverged from Covid less than 10 years ago.
 
Last edited:
This may well be interesting. It seems that a member of DRASTIC found another dissertation. However, in this case, the dissertation was about the first exported case of Covid-19 in Beijing.

Link


The man who had Covid, had worked in a small pharmacy in the entrance of the Huanan Seafood Market:

One of the new patients disclosed in this paper is 51M. He was previously not known to be an early patient and/or connected to the Huanan seafood market. However, he is among the earliest genome patients in December 2019 and connected to the market.

Link

First preprint with
@Engineer2The

@Drinkwater5Reed

@Franciscodeasis
on our dive into early Covid cases, focusing on sequences. https://zenodo.org/record/6672912

We found some raw reads unpublished as sequences (https://academic.oup.com/cid/article/71/15/713/5780800 ) and that Beijing's 1st case was earlier than thought

They wrote a pre-print which has some - perhaps unexpected conclusions...

We also present some information on the first Beijing patient, who had an onset date of December 17, 2019 and was related to the Huanan market outbreak.

Using the collated information, significant progress has been made towards solving the discrepancies in the early sequences. A phylogeny of 19 early patients is presented, based on onset dates, as well as several tMRCA estimates – falling in late November.

Link

I have not read the pre-print, but interesting to me that some DRASTIC members, doing their own research, have come to conclusions very consistent with the theory of a spillover in November from the Huanan Seafood Market.

Overall we get 19 sequenced patients with onset in 2019, 16 of which are linked to the Huanan market.
We could then obtain a reasonable consensus genome for each of these early patients, likely representing the haplotype at the time of onset.

Link
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom