Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.

Beat me to it. Published in "Science" by people who spent a lot of time in Wuhan.

If the COVID-19 virus originated in a lab, as some conspiracy theories suggest, you’d expect a single introduction into humans – rather than two distinct viral lineages. And both strains were found in samples taken from Huanan market. “That, I think, is pretty good evidence,” says Dwyer.

It looks like real experts have relegated the lab leak theory to CT status.
 
Steven Novella summarizes the two papers here.

He essentially considers them to be a body blow and a knock-out punch to the lab leak theory.

David Gorski is a little more restrained, which is more or less my position, but points out that the scientific evidence strongly supports zoonotic spillover, and argues that while there was nothing inherently unscientific or conspiratorial about the possibility of a lab leak, the arguments in favour of lab leak have become increasingly conspiratorial. I agree with this.

We have seen a lot of it in this thread....

Since the early days of the pandemic, there has been a question of whether SARS-CoV-2 arose naturally or had escaped from a lab. The latter hypothesis didn’t start out as a conspiracy theory, as lab leaks have happened before—although none had ever caused a pandemic that has thus far claimed millions of deaths worldwide, over a million in the US alone. However, it rapidly took on the characteristics of a conspiracy theory such that even those advocating the “lab leak” hypothesis often had difficulty not interspersing more serious scientific arguments with what can be only described as a dollop of conspiratorial thinking. As time went on, if anything, the lab leak hypothesis drifted further and further from legitimate science and deeper and deeper into conspiracyland, such that, try as I might, I now have a difficult time finding examples of lab leak advocates who don’t add conspiracy mongering narratives to their arguments.
Here’s what I mean. By by May 2021 it clearly had developed all the hallmarks of a conspiracy theory, complete with a coverup narrative in which China and powerful forces in the US were “suppressing” all mention of a lab leak as a “conspiracy theory,” attacks on funding sources of investigators doing research on coronaviruses, bad science in the form of anomaly hunting (Nicholas Wade and furin cleavage sites or Steven Quay and Richard Muller and CGGCGG, anyone?) in which any observed oddity in the nucleotide sequence of the virus was portrayed as clear-cut evidence of lab manipulation by scientists doing gain-of-function research (which, apparently, went very wrong), all coupled with an utter resistance to disconfirming evidence. It didn’t help, of course, that the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) was not far from the wet markets that were first identified as likely sources of the outbreak and that WIV was studying coronaviruses and thus had them on premises. Lab leak proponents are also fond of other kinds of conspiratorial thinking, such as attribution errors, weaponization of disagreements within a general consensus, shifting the burden of proof, moving the goalposts in response to disconfirming evidence, and others, all with an intense belief in a coverup at the highest levels of multiple governments.

Yes, we know that China is a repressive secretive country, but lab leak theories now apparently implicate a wide range of scientists from all over the world because of their reliance on funding. There is also a kind of lab leak of the gaps argument being made when specific data points ("the early cases") that are not known or may not even exist are apparently "ignored". Surely, if we only had that data, then the current picture of the cases emanating out of the Huanan Market, with those directly linked to the Huanan Market apparently living further away from it, than those who were not linked to it, would change and presumably favour the lab leak.

Gorski thinks that the lab leak cannot be completely ruled out (he says it is "not homeopathy level improbable"), but the papers certainly make spillover the best explanation so far.
 
"Mainstream science is suppressing the truth!!!" is the catercorner of virtually every pseudoscience and conspiracy theory out there.
meaningless comment




The lab leak side was asked to provide evidence, and so far it hasn't managed to come up with any.
... and exactly how would that evidence look?

As for why zoonotic crossover is the default, it's something that has been happening for billions of year and there are infection outbreaks and epidemics that start this way every single year.
Show me where it is stated for zoonotic being the default because "it's something that has been happening for billions of year..."

Every virus that infects humans likely crossed over from some other species at some point. Conversely there isn't a single recorder example of a novel virus coming from a lab leak.
Completely false comment! Small pox escaped from British lab(s) in the 1970's. The 1977 flu is "suspected" to be a lab leak. It is suspected because it is virtually impossible to detect a lab leak unless the lab announces it. Again, how do you disprove a lab leak?




It's been explicitly proven that Covid wasn't created in a lab.
Where do you come up with these comments. Point us in the direction where it is "explicitly proven that Covid wasn't created in a lab"?

I don't know where you got you mistaken impressions about GoF research, but it's a critical tool in identifying what viruses are a risk to jumping to humans. Not knowing what viruses could jump from other animals and kill you isn't going to save you from it happening.
What is my mistaken impression? Read up on GOF, it genetically alters an organism.
 
Steven Novella summarizes the two papers here.

He essentially considers them to be a body blow and a knock-out punch to the lab leak theory.

David Gorski is a little more restrained, which is more or less my position, but points out that the scientific evidence strongly supports zoonotic spillover, and argues that while there was nothing inherently unscientific or conspiratorial about the possibility of a lab leak, the arguments in favour of lab leak have become increasingly conspiratorial. I agree with this.

We have seen a lot of it in this thread....



Yes, we know that China is a repressive secretive country, but lab leak theories now apparently implicate a wide range of scientists from all over the world because of their reliance on funding. There is also a kind of lab leak of the gaps argument being made when specific data points ("the early cases") that are not known or may not even exist are apparently "ignored". Surely, if we only had that data, then the current picture of the cases emanating out of the Huanan Market, with those directly linked to the Huanan Market apparently living further away from it, than those who were not linked to it, would change and presumably favour the lab leak.

Gorski thinks that the lab leak cannot be completely ruled out (he says it is "not homeopathy level improbable"), but the papers certainly make spillover the best explanation so far.
This is nothing but an opinion. The papers are not a "body blow" to a lab leak... not even close. Below is the quote which was to deliver the "knock out punch"...

We report that live SARS-CoV-2 susceptible mammals were sold at the market in late 2019 and, within the market, SARS-CoV-2-positive environmental samples were spatially associated with vendors selling live mammals. While there is insufficient evidence to define upstream events, and exact circumstances remain obscure, our analyses indicate that the emergence of SARS-CoV-2 occurred via the live wildlife trade in China, and show that the Huanan market was the epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic.

All hilites show the amount of speculation that is taken. The final sentence is the most sophomoric comment regarding a "finding" without providing one lick of evidence. At best, he can show a correlation that SARS-CoV-2 susceptible mammals were sold at the market and the market is considered ground zero and that is all. Outside of that, he provides absolutely nothing which proves SARS-CoV-2 came from a mammal at the market.
 
Know what, I think I’ll go with the “Science” article linked a few posts ago.
I read that over and over... When the conclusions contain phrases like: "likely", "suggest", "however" are used ... it is only speculation. They did a scientific experiment but it was not conclusive and it failed to provide a causation. What is missing from the detailed maps (in the paper) is the location of the Wuhan Virology Lab and the Wuhan Center for Disease Control in relationship to the Huanan Seafood market along with the #2 Metro Line that service all 3 locations. But they don't even though the Line is the fastest and most highly used route to reach all 3 locations. Kristian Andersen has already shown his colors with his hastily put together presentation on Pangolins all he does with this one is continue his shot gun approach to guessing.
 
This is nothing but an opinion. The papers are not a "body blow" to a lab leak... not even close. Below is the quote which was to deliver the "knock out punch"...

We report that live SARS-CoV-2 susceptible mammals were sold at the market in late 2019 and, within the market, SARS-CoV-2-positive environmental samples were spatially associated with vendors selling live mammals. While there is insufficient evidence to define upstream events, and exact circumstances remain obscure, our analyses indicate that the emergence of SARS-CoV-2 occurred via the live wildlife trade in China, and show that the Huanan market was the epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic.

All hilites show the amount of speculation that is taken. The final sentence is the most sophomoric comment regarding a "finding" without providing one lick of evidence. At best, he can show a correlation that SARS-CoV-2 susceptible mammals were sold at the market and the market is considered ground zero and that is all. Outside of that, he provides absolutely nothing which proves SARS-CoV-2 came from a mammal at the market.

In fact, I agree with this to some extent, which is why I said my own position is similar to that of Gorski's rather than that of Novella.

Obviously the papers are written as scientific papers should be with plenty of cautious language.

However, if you look at the likelihood of spillover and compare it to the case of lab leak, then you will notice that the evidence for spillover is getting stronger:

a) The earliest known cases were connected with the market, and those that were not directly linked turned out to be closer to the market than those directly linked.

b) I am not competent to assess this, but the Pekar et. al paper suggests two spillovers - or two independent entries to humans. Again, I cannot verify this myself, but that would surely be strong evidence of a spillover.

c) The fact that there were animals in the market that were candidate animals for spillover is evidence for spillover. This is, after all, how SARS got started.

d) Although lab leak is not, in principle, impossible, nearly all suggested arguments in favour of it require an ever-expanding conspiracy. Many of the original planks of the theory have since been shown to be refuted: 1) The bioweapon theory is (for most) completely dead now, 2) RaTG13 being the progenitor virus that was GoFed in the lab after its pandemic potential was covered up, was refuted by the discovery of BANAL-52 (and other viruses which had RNA sequences closer to that of SARS-CoV2) 3) The RBD being special to SARS-CoV2 has also been conclusively refuted by the discovery of SARS-CoV2 4) The idea the FCS cannot evolve in nature has been apparently refuted (though I have no competence to assess this either). 5) The apparent emergence date of SARS-CoV2 debunks the idea that public access being made available to a database is a factor as that was taken down months before.

Of course, this does not mean it is impossible, but it seems less a scientific argument than it does a conspiratorial/political argument to assert the lab leak is more likely than a spillover.

There are certain things that I still find odd about it. I do think the DEFUSE proposal looks very dodgy in context given that it was proposed to find viruses and insert FCS to test their pandemic potential.

Jeffrey Sachs of the Lancet Study Group is now suggesting it came from a US lab. But scientists say he is talking out of his arse as he is not a scientist and seems to be speculating. Link

The two papers in Science, though, assuming other scientists agree with the findings, seem to make the most plausible case, as far as I can see.
 
I read that over and over... When the conclusions contain phrases like: "likely", "suggest", "however" are used ... it is only speculation. They did a scientific experiment but it was not conclusive and it failed to provide a causation. What is missing from the detailed maps (in the paper) is the location of the Wuhan Virology Lab and the Wuhan Center for Disease Control in relationship to the Huanan Seafood market along with the #2 Metro Line that service all 3 locations. But they don't even though the Line is the fastest and most highly used route to reach all 3 locations. Kristian Andersen has already shown his colors with his hastily put together presentation on Pangolins all he does with this one is continue his shot gun approach to guessing.

Did you also note that the researchers believe that those who think the virus was released from the lab are conspiracy theorists? Their words not mine.

And I'd rather their "likely" than the certainty of some who post here that the virus came from the lab.
 
Wow, thanks!

I always wondered where smallpox came from. All those thousands of years we've been wondering and it came from a lab with a time machine.

Beat me to it. Only the most deluded imagine Small Pox originated from a UK lab in the 1970s.
 
I read that over and over... When the conclusions contain phrases like: "likely", "suggest", "however" are used ... it is only speculation. They did a scientific experiment but it was not conclusive and it failed to provide a causation. What is missing from the detailed maps (in the paper) is the location of the Wuhan Virology Lab and the Wuhan Center for Disease Control in relationship to the Huanan Seafood market along with the #2 Metro Line that service all 3 locations. But they don't even though the Line is the fastest and most highly used route to reach all 3 locations. Kristian Andersen has already shown his colors with his hastily put together presentation on Pangolins all he does with this one is continue his shot gun approach to guessing.

Also, only conspiracy theorists, Fox News and woos (and some in this thread) make definitive statements about the origin of covid. Real scientists make considered statements. Is this speculation? **** no.
 
Also, only conspiracy theorists, Fox News and woos (and some in this thread) make definitive statements about the origin of covid. Real scientists make considered statements. Is this speculation? **** no.

Who on here has made definitive statements? Some have stated that they consider the lab leak scenario is more convincing but I don't recall anyone stating an absolute belief in the idea of a lab leak.
 
Who on here has made definitive statements? Some have stated that they consider the lab leak scenario is more convincing but I don't recall anyone stating an absolute belief in the idea of a lab leak.

Well Skeptic Ginger has in my view. Interesting she hasn’t posted for a while.
 
Well Skeptic Ginger has in my view. Interesting she hasn’t posted for a while.

I've never got that impression, more that SG considers the commitment of others to the spillover event to be excessive.
 
Did you also note that the researchers believe that those who think the virus was released from the lab are conspiracy theorists? Their words not mine.

And I'd rather their "likely" than the certainty of some who post here that the virus came from the lab.
Yes and when people are accused of being a CT, it is to back them down and to build up one's own theory.

Using "likely" requires a comparison without a conclusion. This virus was either man-made or natural... those are the only options, to say "likely" is to give a nod towards a direction without enough empirical evidence to draw a conclusion and that creates a bias.

What is entertaining is that neither side (lab leak vs nature) can shore up their positions. It is understandable the lab leak people can't because of restrictions on access and just the difficulty of "proving" a lab leak. On the other hand, the Nature people are rehashing information that has been out there since day one and/or they develop their case by showing the similarities of various components and then declaring that those similarities point us toward natural selection.

Instead of conducting an unbiased/unprejudiced research there is a desire to prove one over the other...
 
Also, only conspiracy theorists, Fox News and woos (and some in this thread) make definitive statements about the origin of covid. Real scientists make considered statements. Is this speculation? **** no.
There is merit in your statement. In this scenario, "likely" is not appropriate as there are no shades of gray, it can only be binary.
 
I read that over and over... When the conclusions contain phrases like: "likely", "suggest", "however" are used ...
That's how real scientific papers are worded...

In this scenario, "likely" is not appropriate as there are no shades of gray, it can only be binary.

Pseudoscience love binary choices, real science does not.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom