Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
So of course, the question is going to be, well where is the animal(s) that brought the virus?

Yes, it is true that none have yet been found despite "80,000 animals being tested", but as this person on Twitter points out, the markets had clearly been selling a lot of wild life which was never tested.

In addition, very soon after the outbreak it seems there was a rush to close wildlife farms and a mass extermination of animals there. This is not unusual in pandemics in fact, and certainly does point to the Chinese government finding a wildlife route to be a plausible explanation for the pandemic.

This article came out in February of 2020:



Why would China have reacted like this unless they saw the likelihood of it being caused by the wildlife trade?
The obvious answer to that is because it would point the finger away from the real cause. ;)
 
The obvious answer to that is because it would point the finger away from the real cause. ;)

You laugh, but that is exactly what is being proposed, and that they probably wanted to do it anyway, because that is how pandemics start and they want to prevent future pandemics.
 
You laugh, but that is exactly what is being proposed, and that they probably wanted to do it anyway, because that is how pandemics start and they want to prevent future pandemics.

Pity they didn't do it after the SARS 1 outbreak then.
 
Pity they didn't do it after the SARS 1 outbreak then.

Indeed. My understanding is that there actually had been some moves to do this.

BUT... there was also a swine flu epidemic. This article is from Dec 17th 2019 (not long before we learned of Covid-19) and it was to do with an ongoing swine flu epidemic ranging from China that ended up going into other neighbouring countries.

WULONGQIAO, China — A devastating disease spreading from China has wiped out roughly one-quarter of the world’s pigs, reshaping farming and hitting the diets and pocketbooks of consumers around the globe.
China’s unsuccessful efforts to stop the disease may have hastened the spread — creating problems that could bedevil Beijing and global agriculture for years to come.

To halt African swine fever, as the disease is called, the authorities must persuade farmers to kill infected pigs and dispose of them properly. But in China, officials have been frugal to the point of stingy, requiring farmers to jump through hoops to seek compensation from often cash-poor local governments.

As a result, Chinese officials are not reaching farmers like Peng Weita. When one of his pigs suddenly died three months ago from swine fever, he said, he quickly slaughtered his other four dozen before they could fall sick as well. But he buried them and took a big loss rather than reporting the deaths to the government for compensation.

“Three years of costs were all for nothing,” Mr. Peng said.

His loss was the government’s as well. Because he did not report the episode, local officials could not make sure he followed all the steps necessary to halt the spread, like burying carcasses a considerable distance from the farm. Mr. Peng said he probably buried them too close to his farm but declined to discuss details of the disposal.

The epidemic shows the limits of China’s emphasis on government-driven, top-down solutions to major problems, sometimes at the expense of the practical. It has also laid bare the struggle of a country of 1.4 billion people to feed itself.

Link

I remember on This Week in Virology (TWiV) hearing someone explain that this massive swine flu epidemic that wiped out so many pigs, led to... guess what? The ramping up of the wildlife trade to make up the shortfall in food and income for farmers.
 
You think that China shut down the wild life farms because "we" wanted them to do so? Wow! Good for China then, to finally start taking "us" into consideration. Usually they tell "us" to go **** ourselves and stop interfering in their domestic issues.

Do you really think that?

Yes. Not that we want them to do it. But that they think we are expecting it. Like this:

Sir ! There is a new disease spreading in Wuhan apparently from a seafood market !
Ah, Wuhan ? Isn't that where our new virus lab is ? Don't tell me it's our fault !
We can't tell sir !
Yeah .. as expected .. we can't admit it is either way. But we should do something, right ? To save face.
Certainly, sir ! What about regulating those damn markets, those places are terrible !
Oh, why we didn't do it already anyway ? It's not like farmers will revolt, right ? Ha ha ha.
They know we would just shoot them, sir ! Ha ha ha.
Ah, and don't forget to purge the lab documents, just to be sure.
I've already ordered that, sir.
 
Yes. Not that we want them to do it. But that they think we are expecting it. Like this:

Sir ! There is a new disease spreading in Wuhan apparently from a seafood market !
Ah, Wuhan ? Isn't that where our new virus lab is ? Don't tell me it's our fault !
We can't tell sir !
Yeah .. as expected .. we can't admit it is either way. But we should do something, right ? To save face.
Certainly, sir ! What about regulating those damn markets, those places are terrible !
Oh, why we didn't do it already anyway ? It's not like farmers will revolt, right ? Ha ha ha.
They know we would just shoot them, sir ! Ha ha ha.
Ah, and don't forget to purge the lab documents, just to be sure.
I've already ordered that, sir.

Okay, so are you just going to go with something you made up as the origin of Covid?

Mmmkay.
 
Not at all. That's just why I think China's action against wet markets is irrelevant. IMHO they would do it even if they knew it came from lab.
Why so angry ? :rolleyes:

Not angry, but wondering why you are posting this speculative drivel and not acknowledging the corrections I have made to your claims or answered questions I have asked you. It makes me think you are not arguing in good faith, and maybe not very well versed in the topic so you are resorting to bluster and tone policing instead of the topic at hand.

I
 
No, maybe not. But I don't think it is much of an objection. Worobey et. al say:

In other words, "around 18 November 2019 (23 October–8 December)". It hardly seems to be a problem.

Not "widespread" but circulating. And they say that:
All of this is speculation on Worobey's part. I will repeat what I said before: There are a number of holes in Worobey's study and he simply makes stuff up to fit his round data in a square hole.

One key giveaway to his significant bias is him claiming how his and the other study makes a lab-leak origin as unlikely as a lightning strike, (or however he worded it). Give me a break, that is a narcissistic overstatement. He is certain he knows.

But a lot of people involved, like Andersen and Tedros, have commented the lab-leak has not been ruled out.

It's not useful to debate where Worobey has filled in the blanks sans evidence. Best if we debate the new evidence rather than repeating what we've already discussed ad nauseum about Worobey's holes in his evidence..


Take the following for example:
Maybe it cannot be discounted. However, the presence of both within the stalls and in proximity does increase the chances that the Huanan Market was likely a locus. My understanding, from looking at other virologists commenting on this is that this did not begin with an animal being infected by a bat in a stall, but animals already infected brought into the market having been infected in the supply chain, either at a farm or en route, suggesting also that supply chain workers could also have been infected somewhere along the line.
What is it you are talking about here? Both lineages can be traced to the market, is that right? When you say "within the stalls" was that people who worked in those stalls?

There were no bats at that market. It wasn't on the menu in many Wuhan homes. We had a long discussion early in the thread when 'bat soup' was suggested as the problem.

Yes, there had to have been a supply chain. So where is evidence of infected animals outside of the market? Outside of Wuhan? How did an infected animal handler not infect anyone except at the market?

The odds are not in favor of this hypothesis for two reasons:
There is no trail, none zilch. Even given the Chinese scrubbing and closing the market would not erase the trail of COVID to Wuhan.

And Worobey can only speculate about those earliest cases. They may have a direct link to the WIV or to the CCDC lab near the market. We don't know and neither does Worobey.​

I don't know. Maybe more analysis can be done here and presumably it all depends on how much it holds up.

Personally, I doubt very much that this is the final word on the origins of Covid. I think it seems too premature for that and obviously more investigation will be needed to track down the wildlife route origin, if, in fact, that is how it got to Huanan in the first place.

I think the point for now is that it makes a pretty plausible case that Huanan is a very likely candidate for the origin of the virus's emergence.
I agree, we don't have the final word. Plausible, maybe. But missing evidence is pretty damning, IMO. Where do you expect this missing animal trail is going to be found if it hasn't already?

China might not want that trail found but like early cases of COVID in Dec 2019 were leaked by health care providers, no cases of COVID-like pneumonia outside of Wuhan were leaked.

Now consider what evidence China might be hiding.
The raw data on the lab workers' COVID tests was not shown to the WHO inspectors.

They have yet to release all the coronavirus genome data they have quashed.

They won't release information on the earliest cases.​

Those things could go a long way toward ruling out the lab ... or incriminating it.
 
Last edited:
I'm wondering what other method of dealing with 'major problems' would be more appropriate. Pretend there's no problem and hope it goes away by itself?

Well indeed. These are not my words, of course, but of the article that I was quoting about the swine flu epidemic that prefigured Covid.
 
All of this is speculation on Worobey's part. I will repeat what I said before: There are a number of holes in Worobey's study and he simply makes stuff up to fit his round data in a square hole.

One key giveaway to his significant bias is him claiming how his and the other study makes a lab-leak origin as unlikely as a lightning strike, (or however he worded it). Give me a break, that is a narcissistic overstatement. He is certain he knows.

But a lot of people involved, like Andersen and Tedros, have commented the lab-leak has not been ruled out.

I don't think the phylogenetic analysis is "speculation". I don't know much about how this kind of thing is done, but would you accept dismissing the TopHap analysis as "speculation"?

Besides, Worobey did not do the analysis. It was Pekar. Presumably you could work your way through the supplementary materials or contact them to find out how they arrived at the emergence date. It would be meaningless to me because I do not have the competence to understand these things. Hopefully it will all be open to other scientists who want to do their own calculations.

Take the following for example:
What is it you are talking about here? Both lineages can be traced to the market, is that right? When you say "within the stalls" was that people who worked in those stalls?

I believe so, but I could be wrong.

There were no bats at that market. It wasn't on the menu in many Wuhan homes. We had a long discussion early in the thread when 'bat soup' was suggested as the problem.

I don't think any of the scientists of the spillover scenario have ever talked about bat soup. If there was any "long discussion" about bat soup it was probably a strawman or someone talking very ignorantly about the situation.

If my memory is mistaken, I would be happy for you to find the discussion again.

Nobody is suggesting bats were in the market.



Yes, there had to have been a supply chain. So where is evidence of infected animals outside of the market? Outside of Wuhan? How did an infected animal handler not infect anyone except at the market?

There isn't any.

The odds are not in favor of this hypothesis for two reasons:
There is no trail, none zilch. Even given the Chinese scrubbing and closing the market would not erase the trail of COVID to Wuhan.

And Worobey can only speculate about those earliest cases. They may have a direct link to the WIV or to the CCDC lab near the market. We don't know and neither does Worobey.​

Yes, maybe, but it seems odd that we are now moving the lab leak itself from the primary suspect based on X, Y and Z reasons to a completely different lab based only on proximity. Remember that the reasons for suspecting the WIV were that it was BSL-4, worked on coronaviruses and was in Wuhan. So the CCDC, well, it is in Wuhan and close to the market where all the cases were found. The rationale seems very weak in comparison.

I agree, we don't have the final word. Plausible, maybe. But missing evidence is pretty damning, IMO. Where do you expect this missing animal trail is going to be found if it hasn't already?

China might not want that trail found but like early cases of COVID in Dec 2019 were leaked by health care providers, no cases of COVID-like pneumonia outside of Wuhan were leaked.

Now consider what evidence China might be hiding.
The raw data on the lab workers' COVID tests was not shown to the WHO inspectors.

They have yet to release all the coronavirus genome data they have quashed.

They won't release information on the earliest cases.​

Those things could go a long way toward ruling out the lab ... or incriminating it.

Could you be more specific here. Which earliest cases do you know of that China has been refusing to release?
 
I don't think the phylogenetic analysis is "speculation". I don't know much about how this kind of thing is done, but would you accept dismissing the TopHap analysis as "speculation"?
What was speculated about in both studies was the missing data on the earliest cases, not the analysis in either study.

TopHap didn't fill in any missing data blanks. When you analyze thousands of genomes for the genetic trail your conclusions are based on very strong data. When you base your study on the earliest cases and you are missing the key gemomes/cases your data is weak.

Besides, Worobey did not do the analysis. It was Pekar. Presumably you could work your way through the supplementary materials or contact them to find out how they arrived at the emergence date. It would be meaningless to me because I do not have the competence to understand these things. Hopefully it will all be open to other scientists who want to do their own calculations.
Sigh ... From the Pekar/Worobey et al study:
The earliest lineage A viruses, Wuhan/IME-WH01/2019 and Wuhan/WH04/2020, were sampled on 30 December 2019 and 5 January 2020, respectively
Those are not the earliest lineage A virus genomes, they are the earliest genomes except for the true 'earliest' genomes the Chinese refuse to disclose. Look how late the viruses were sampled.

You continue to ignore the problem of this missing key data. Over and over you repeat the same things while ignoring this problem.

If your phylogenetic analysis used a small sample size then it can be greatly affected by missing data, especially if that missing data consists of a group of genomes all from the earliest cases.

Worobey, as good of a scientist as he clearly is, is displaying an incredible amount of confirmation bias here in how he discusses the strength of his conclusions. What he should be saying is the two studies do come at the problem from different angles and corroborate each other, but our research was limited by the missing earliest cases.

That is how you report research, at the end of your conclusions you add the study's limitations. That is standard protocol in a research report. You don't run around all excited overstating the significance of your findings.

I have to run to the store. I'll try to address the rest when I get back.
 
What was speculated about in both studies was the missing data on the earliest cases, not the analysis in either study.

This seems like an odd choice of wording to me. Can something be missing if it never existed in the first place?

The data on the earliest cases don't exist, nor is there any valid reason to think it should exist. Describing it as "missing" sounds like you are trying to imply someone is covering up something.
 
This is like something I would expect from anti-vaxxers. (“How much are they taking from Big Pharma, huh?”). Remember that earlier you were fairly confidently claiming that these papers would not pass peer review. But now they have, so I guess we are to assume that the peer reviewers are also being paid off too? Do you see how this the route to conspiracy theory?
Peer review is not robust. Peer Review exhibits the same weaknesses as Institutions that accept monies from various sources... money talks and money keeps various minds from exploring certain possibilities. The problem started when the lab leak hypothesis people were told to prove there was a leak without demanding the same from the zoonotic side (I say demanding because for some reason the default is that COVID-19 is zoonotic which is totally arbitrary). Given that labs have used GOF to "create" things we will never know, the default should be that new virus' be initially suspected as lab created. If nature is at work, it will be found.
 
Last edited:
Peer review is not robust. Peer Review exhibits the same weaknesses as Institutions that accept monies from various sources... money talks and money keeps various minds from exploring certain possibilities.

"Mainstream science is suppressing the truth!!!" is the catercorner of virtually every pseudoscience and conspiracy theory out there.


The problem started when the lab leak hypothesis people were told to prove there was a leak without demanding the same from the zoonotic side (I say demanding because for some reason the default is that COVID-19 is zoonotic which is totally arbitrary).

The lab leak side was asked to provide evidence, and so far it hasn't managed to come up with any.

As for why zoonotic crossover is the default, it's something that has been happening for billions of year and there are infection outbreaks and epidemics that start this way every single year. Every virus that infects humans likely crossed over from some other species at some point. Conversely there isn't a single recorder example of a novel virus coming from a lab leak.


Given that labs have used GOF to "create" things we will never know, the default should be that new virus' be initially suspected as lab created.

It's been explicitly proven that Covid wasn't created in a lab.

I don't know where you got you mistaken impressions about GoF research, but it's a critical tool in identifying what viruses are a risk to jumping to humans. Not knowing what viruses could jump from other animals and kill you isn't going to save you from it happening.
 
Peer review is not robust. Peer Review exhibits the same weaknesses as Institutions that accept monies from various sources... money talks and money keeps various minds from exploring certain possibilities. The problem started when the lab leak hypothesis people were told to prove there was a leak without demanding the same from the zoonotic side (I say demanding because for some reason the default is that COVID-19 is zoonotic which is totally arbitrary). Given that labs have used GOF to "create" things we will never know, the default should be that new virus' be initially suspected as lab created. If nature is at work, it will be found.

This is what I am saying about it sounding like an anti-vaxx argument.

If I say, "This peer-reviewed RCT shows the effectiveness of Vaccine A", then anti-vaxxers will say, "Nah, the writers and peer reviewers and journals are paid off by Big Pharma so none of the RCTs can be trusted."

I am fine with saying that there are all kinds of flaws with the peer-review system. Indeed, there are, and we have seen examples of that with people submitting to low-quality journals with fraudulent data on things like Ivermectin. There is a good book called Science Fictions which goes into the problems of peer review (and much else besides such as bias, negligence and hype). But please note that in the case of Ivermectin, researchers actually looked into and evaluated the methods and data of the research before determining that the science was bad (if not outright fraudulent.).

If you simply dismiss a paper on a priori grounds that any paper that argues for a zoonotic spillover must be the result of a conspiracy by Big Pharma, then there is almost no point in you being in the discussion, because you have determined your conclusion first and based it upon unknowable surmising that you have no evidence for (you do NOT know whether the peer-reviewers were paid off, nor do you know that this is the case with the authors of the papers).
 
Looks like case closed to me:

The virus almost-certainly jumped from wildlife into humans in the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in Wuhan, the papers argue. The authors have even found the most likely section of the market. They have old photos of caged raccoon dogs – known carriers of Covid-19 – being sold there.

If the Covid-19 virus originated in a lab, as some conspiracy theories suggest, you’d expect a single introduction into humans – rather than two distinct viral lineages. And both strains were found in samples taken from Huanan market.

https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/ex...s-sounded-scientists-pinpoint-covid19s-origin
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom