No, maybe not. But I don't think it is much of an objection. Worobey et. al say:
In other words, "around 18 November 2019 (23 October–8 December)". It hardly seems to be a problem.
Not "widespread" but circulating. And they say that:
All of this is speculation on Worobey's part. I will repeat what I said before: There are a number of holes in Worobey's study and he simply makes stuff up to fit his round data in a square hole.
One key giveaway to his significant bias is him claiming how his and the other study makes a lab-leak origin as unlikely as a lightning strike, (or however he worded it). Give me a break, that is a narcissistic overstatement. He is certain he knows.
But a lot of people involved, like Andersen and Tedros, have commented the lab-leak has not been ruled out.
It's not useful to debate where Worobey has filled in the blanks sans evidence. Best if we debate the new evidence rather than repeating what we've already discussed ad nauseum about Worobey's holes in his evidence..
Take the following for example:
Maybe it cannot be discounted. However, the presence of both within the stalls and in proximity does increase the chances that the Huanan Market was likely a locus. My understanding, from looking at other virologists commenting on this is that this did not begin with an animal being infected by a bat in a stall, but animals already infected brought into the market having been infected in the supply chain, either at a farm or en route, suggesting also that supply chain workers could also have been infected somewhere along the line.
What is it you are talking about here? Both lineages can be traced to the market, is that right? When you say "within the stalls" was that people who worked in those stalls?
There were no bats at that market. It wasn't on the menu in many Wuhan homes. We had a long discussion early in the thread when 'bat soup' was suggested as the problem.
Yes, there had to have been a supply chain. So where is evidence of infected animals outside of the market? Outside of Wuhan? How did an infected animal handler not infect anyone except at the market?
The odds are not in favor of this hypothesis for two reasons:
There is no trail, none zilch. Even given the Chinese scrubbing and closing the market would not erase the trail of COVID to Wuhan.
And Worobey can only speculate about those earliest cases. They may have a direct link to the WIV or to the CCDC lab near the market. We don't know and neither does Worobey.
I don't know. Maybe more analysis can be done here and presumably it all depends on how much it holds up.
Personally, I doubt very much that this is the final word on the origins of Covid. I think it seems too premature for that and obviously more investigation will be needed to track down the wildlife route origin, if, in fact, that is how it got to Huanan in the first place.
I think the point for now is that it makes a pretty plausible case that Huanan is a very likely candidate for the origin of the virus's emergence.
I agree, we don't have the final word. Plausible, maybe. But missing evidence is pretty damning, IMO. Where do you expect this missing animal trail is going to be found if it hasn't already?
China might not want that trail found but like early cases of COVID in Dec 2019 were leaked by health care providers, no cases of COVID-like pneumonia outside of Wuhan were leaked.
Now consider what evidence China might be hiding.
The raw data on the lab workers' COVID tests was not shown to the WHO inspectors.
They have yet to release all the coronavirus genome data they have quashed.
They won't release information on the earliest cases.
Those things could go a long way toward ruling out the lab ... or incriminating it.