Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
September infections of Covid?

That makes no sense.

This has clearly not reached the level of established fact otherwise it would be part of any working theory of the origins of Covid.

Besides, if the cases were in September it would torpedo your claim the Wuhan Games led to the outbreaks in Italy.
I'm not sure how other researchers were supposed to incorporate in their work research only recently published.

How would cases in Sept mean the military games in Oct couldn't have spread the virus worldwide? :boggled:
 
The ones China at first admitted to then later refused to share any of the demographic data about. Demographic as in the things an epidemiologist would look at to track down the source of an outbreak.

That sounds a lot like 9\11 CT that argues early, erroneous, statements prove that latter more accurate information are really part of a coverup. The earliest confirmed case was recorded on Dec 11, non-confirmed or speculative cases before this date should not be used in these studies.
 
On my reading of the paper by Caraballo-Ortiz et al., they are not suggesting any humans had been infected with SARS-CoV-2 in September 2019, or even in October. So far as I can tell, their methods are incapable of determining when the first human infections occurred. In the following quotation, they are talking about the evolution of the Most Recent Common Ancestor (MRCA) of SARS-CoV-2. With my highlighting:

Right! This would not be inconsistent, then, with Worobey's paper, as far as I can tell.

When I looked through the paper, and I am not competent to judge the science of the paper, I could not find any reason for thinking it would favour the lab leak over spillover.

Indeed. It would even answer the questions the lab leakers often ask which is why the virus was ready for human to human transmission immediately. The answer would be, it wasn't.
 
I'm not sure how other researchers were supposed to incorporate in their work research only recently published.

How would cases in Sept mean the military games in Oct couldn't have spread the virus worldwide? :boggled:

I was referring to your link that said it was in Italy in September 2019.

The article was from November 2020.

Is this still considered plausible? Genuine question as I have no idea. It refers to some people who were screened for lung cancer.

Were these contaminated samples?
 
No evidence of Covid infections in blood donors in Wuhan from Sept-Dec 2019.

we reviewed SARS-CoV-2 antibody results from these donors who donated several times from September 2019 to June 2020, partly tested in a previous published study, no one was found a significant increase in S/CO of antibodies against SARS-CoV-2. Our findings showed no SARS-CoV-2 specific antibodies existing among blood donors in Wuhan, China before 2020, indicating no evidence of transmission of COVID-19 before December 2019 in Wuhan, China.

Link
 
Just out in Science, seems like Covid-19 came from the seafood market.


Abstract

Understanding how severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) emerged in 2019 is critical to preventing zoonotic outbreaks before they become the next pandemic. The Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in Wuhan, China, was identified as a likely source of cases in early reports but later this conclusion became controversial. We show the earliest known COVID-19 cases from December 2019, including those without reported direct links, were geographically centered on this market. We report that live SARS-CoV-2 susceptible mammals were sold at the market in late 2019 and, within the market, SARS-CoV-2-positive environmental samples were spatially associated with vendors selling live mammals. While there is insufficient evidence to define upstream events, and exact circumstances remain obscure, our analyses indicate that the emergence of SARS-CoV-2 occurred via the live wildlife trade in China, and show that the Huanan market was the epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic.
 
By the way, the Pekar paper, also peer-reviewed and published at the same time, did look at the TopHap analysis (Caraballo-Ortiz et. al and Kumar et. al) as well as Jesse Bloom's paper (which I think I mentioned in this thread when Worobey strongly criticized it in a Twitter thread). However, I have no idea how to judge these types of analyses, so I will just quote the part that talks about it and leave it for others...

Even though sequence similarity to closely related sarbecoviruses alone is insufficient to determine the SARS-CoV-2 ancestral haplotype, this similarity can inform phylodynamic inference. Rather than rely on outgroup rooting [fig. S18B and (18)], we developed a rooting method that assigns the recCA as the progenitor of the inferred SARS-CoV-2 MRCA (fig. S18C). As opposed to the unconstrained rooting, the recCA root favored a lineage A haplotype over lineage B, although support for C/C was unchanged (Table 1). Our results were insensitive to the method of breakpoint identification in the recCA (supplementary text).

The A.1 and A+C29095T proposed ancestral haplotypes were strongly rejected by all the phylodynamic analyses, even when rooting with recCA or bat sarbecovirus outgroups, which include both C18060T and C29095T (Table 1 and data S3). Hence, WA1-like and 20SF012-like haplotypes cannot plausibly represent the MRCA of SARS-CoV-2 as previously suggested (19–21): the similarity of these genomes to the recCA is due to C-to-T reversions. Haplotypes not reported in Table 1 were similarly rejected (data S3).

We inferred the tMRCA for SARS-CoV-2 to be 11 December 2019 (95% HPD: 25 November–12 December) using unconstrained rooting. It has been suggested that a phylogenetic root in lineage A would produce an older time of most recent common ancestor (tMRCA) than a lineage B rooting (21). Therefore, we developed an approach to assign a haplotype as the SARS-CoV-2 MRCA and inferred the tMRCA (i.e., A, B, C/C, A.1 or A+C29095T) (fig. S18D). The tMRCA was consistent with the recCA-rooted and fixed ancestral haplotype analyses (table S2 and supplementary text).

We infer only three plausible ancestral haplotypes: lineage A, lineage B, and C/C. However, the inability to reconcile the molecular clock at the outset of the COVID-19 pandemic with a lineage A ancestor without information from related sarbecoviruses (e.g., the recCA) requires us to question the assumption that both lineages A and B resulted from a single introduction.
 
Andersen, Garry and Worobey are all listed as authors of that paper. And interestingly Garry is a "co-founder of Zalgen Labs, a biotechnology company developing countermeasures to emerging viruses." All of these people are interconnected to the whole research community that is funded by and involved in the research that might have resulted in the lab accident.

I'm not saying that means we should dismiss any rebuttal to the TopHap research. But it is important to keep that bias in mind that there were 2 spillovers at the seafood market.

With that in mind, these discrepancies are interesting:
The first zoonotic transmission likely involved lineage B viruses around 18 November 2019 (23 October–8 December)
That's a large range meaning the Nov 18th date isn't as precise as it sounds.

And:
These findings indicate that it is unlikely that SARS-CoV-2 circulated widely in humans prior to November 2019 and define the narrow window between when SARS-CoV-2 first jumped into humans and when the first cases of COVID-19 were reported.
Doesn't Worobey's paper rely on the virus being widespread before the first cases were reported? That's how he accounts for the earliest cases that were not connected to the market.

It's still hard to discount lineage B evolving from lineage A given other researchers suggest that happened. The two lineages are very closely related. If they came from 2 different spillover events how is that any more likely than the lineages split after they were in the human population?

Say lineage A spilled over into humans. CoV2 then continued to evolve in the hypothesized source animal. Then lineage B spilled over into humans.

How is that more likely than B evolved as a variant of A after it was in the human population?


What is one thing this paper supports? The virus jumped into the human population already well adapted to person to person spread.

The paper may be a follow up that questions the TopHap analysis. I await the author's reply. In the meantime the BBC reminds readers: There is no definitive piece of evidence - no Covid-positive bat or a confirmed first human case - to show conclusively how it started.
The authors of this new report point out that none of those were, or could have been, manipulated to become Sars-Cov-2. But some scientists do not entirely accept that conclusion, including Prof David Relman, of the US's Stanford University.

"I see this [new report] as a deliberate effort to marshal all the possible information in support of what is a perfectly good hypothesis - natural spillover - but [it's] not balanced and objective," he told BBC News. ...

"What we don't need right now is for scientists to insist on their favourite explanation in the absence of new, solid data," says Prof Relman.

"Sars-Cov-2 has not been found in any natural animal host. Let's just cool it and demand a proper investigation."
 
Last edited:
So what you are saying is... the Wuhan Institute of Virology infected some wildlife animals and sent them to the seafood market, and then it became a pandemic?

I knew this was suspicious!

Those Chinese are sneaky little *******.

Next they'll be using dolphins to sniff out subs.
 
Andersen, Garry and Worobey are all listed as authors of that paper. And interestingly Garry is a "co-founder of Zalgen Labs, a biotechnology company developing countermeasures to emerging viruses." All of these people are interconnected to the whole research community that is funded by and involved in the research that might have resulted in the lab accident.

]

I’ll get to the other stuff later, but for now, are you really doing this?

This is like something I would expect from anti-vaxxers. (“How much are they taking from Big Pharma, huh?”). Remember that earlier you were fairly confidently claiming that these papers would not pass peer review. But now they have, so I guess we are to assume that the peer reviewers are also being paid off too? Do you see how this the route to conspiracy theory?
 
I’ll get to the other stuff later, but for now, are you really doing this?

This is like something I would expect from anti-vaxxers. (“How much are they taking from Big Pharma, huh?”). Remember that earlier you were fairly confidently claiming that these papers would not pass peer review. But now they have, so I guess we are to assume that the peer reviewers are also being paid off too? Do you see how this the route to conspiracy theory?

No it isn't like anti-vaxxer stuff. Maybe to you with a serious bias from the start it was spillover it seems that way.

I did not say they wouldn't pass peer review, I said it will be interesting to see the rebuttal analyses. There are holes in the work.

But we don't need to see that now since those rebuttals have been in the media.

You seem to be operating on some assumption being published means one's conclusions were well supported. If that were the case half the research would never be published.

As I quoted above:
"It's not true that we don't know where it came from - we just don't know how it got into humans," says Glasgow University virologist Prof David Robertson.

It is widely accepted that an ancestor of the virus originally circulated harmlessly in wild bats. But it is vital to discover how, where and exactly when that first made its way into a person to prevent a similar future outbreak.

There is no definitive piece of evidence - no Covid-positive bat or a confirmed first human case - to show conclusively how it started. That may never be known, but the scientists who wrote this latest report want to clarify the available evidence and what it means.

Comparing me to an anti-vaxxer shows your preference to avoid the actual debate.

What about the discrepancy re circulating low levels of disease put forth as Worobey's explanation for early cases he ignored in his research?

What about the fact nothing yet has been definitive? Worobey claims the idea his work is wrong is as unlikely as being struck by lightening. Isn't that over the top demonstrating he's simply ignoring evidence that doesn't fit his conclusions?


Why don't you debate the issues instead of trying to make me look stupid? I am not stupid and you'll get nowhere with that approach except maybe some local cheerleading by other members in this thread.


BTW, hope you're staying safe. It looks like cases exploded in Japan. :eye-poppi
 
Last edited:
MedicalExpressNews: WHO says all theories still on table after studies point to natural COVID origin
The World Health Organization on Wednesday welcomed new studies concluding that COVID-19 first emerged at an animal market in China's Wuhan, but insisted it was too early to rule out other theories.

"All hypotheses remain on the table," WHO emergencies director Michael Ryan told reporters from the UN health agency's Geneva headquarters. ...

Two peer-reviewed studies published in Science Tuesday claimed to have tipped the balance in the debate about the virus's origins, concluding it must have been introduced naturally through the wildlife trade at the Wuhan market. ...

Maria Van Kerkhove, WHO's technical lead for COVID-19, welcomed the studies, as well as another one published this week looking at environmental samples.

WHO experts, she said, had already evaluated the studies, which were previously posted as "preprints" before being vetted by scientific peer review.

"These are good analyses," she told reporters, but stressed that more studies on the ground in China and beyond were needed before any final conclusions could be drawn.

So no, my pointing out Worobey is overstating his case is not like an anti-vaxxer. It's not a CT.
 
Last edited:
MedicalExpressNews: WHO says all theories still on table after studies point to natural COVID origin

So no, my pointing out Worobey is overstating his case is not like an anti-vaxxer. It's not a CT.

That is not what looks like a CT. This is...

Andersen, Garry and Worobey are all listed as authors of that paper. And interestingly Garry is a "co-founder of Zalgen Labs, a biotechnology company developing countermeasures to emerging viruses." All of these people are interconnected to the whole research community that is funded by and involved in the research that might have resulted in the lab accident.

What does the highlighted mean? Does it mean we cannot trust them? If so, then that is the purpose of peer review. An independent scrutinzing of the methods of the research. Not that peer review is perfect. Not by a long shot. A lot of crappy research sails through peer review when the data is not properly analyzed.

But you said that Worobey et al. "ignore" early cases.

As far as I can tell this is just not true at all, and throwing that around is pretty obnoxious and suggests that you think they are engaged in some kind of scientific malpractice.

Worobey et al are completely up front about the fact that they only have the first known cases to go on.

Are you asking them why they are not investigating the unknown cases? The clue should be in the question. If they don't have access to that data then they can only go on what they have. This is not unusual in science. Data is almost always going to be incomplete.

BTW, hope you're staying safe. It looks like cases exploded in Japan. :eye-poppi

Thanks, I appreciate it. Yes, numbers are extremely high here now. Fortunately deaths are relatively low.

Likewise, I hope you are well.
 
With that in mind, these discrepancies are interesting:
That's a large range meaning the Nov 18th date isn't as precise as it sounds.

No, maybe not. But I don't think it is much of an objection. Worobey et. al say:

In a related study, we infer separate introductions of SARS-CoV-2 lineages A and B into humans from likely infected animals at the Huanan market (38). We estimate the first COVID-19 case to have occurred in November 2019, with few human cases and hospitalizations occurring through mid-December (38).

In other words, "around 18 November 2019 (23 October–8 December)". It hardly seems to be a problem.

And: Doesn't Worobey's paper rely on the virus being widespread before the first cases were reported? That's how he accounts for the earliest cases that were not connected to the market.

Not "widespread" but circulating. And they say that:

One of the key findings of our study is that ‘unlinked’ early COVID-19 patients, those who neither worked at the market or knew someone who did, nor had recently visited the market, resided significantly closer to the market than patients with a direct link to the market. The observation that a substantial proportion of early cases had no known epidemiological link had previously been used as an argument against a Huanan market epicenter of the pandemic.

It's still hard to discount lineage B evolving from lineage A given other researchers suggest that happened. The two lineages are very closely related. If they came from 2 different spillover events how is that any more likely than the lineages split after they were in the human population?

Maybe it cannot be discounted. However, the presence of both within the stalls and in proximity does increase the chances that the Huanan Market was likely a locus. My understanding, from looking at other virologists commenting on this is that this did not begin with an animal being infected by a bat in a stall, but animals already infected brought into the market having been infected in the supply chain, either at a farm or en route, suggesting also that supply chain workers could also have been infected somewhere along the line.

A recent preprint (24) confirms the authenticity of the CCDC report (data S1) and records additional positive environmental samples in the southwestern area of the market selling live animals. This report also documents the early presence of the A lineage of SARS-CoV-2 in a Huanan market environmental sample. This, along with the lineage A cases we report in close geographical proximity to the market in December, challenges the suggestion that the market was simply a superspreading event, which would be lineage-specific. Rather, it adds to the evidence presented here that lineage A, like lineage B, may have originated at the Huanan market then spread from this epicenter into the neighborhoods surrounding the market and then beyond.

Say lineage A spilled over into humans. CoV2 then continued to evolve in the hypothesized source animal. Then lineage B spilled over into humans.

How is that more likely than B evolved as a variant of A after it was in the human population?

I don't know. Maybe more analysis can be done here and presumably it all depends on how much it holds up.



Personally, I doubt very much that this is the final word on the origins of Covid. I think it seems too premature for that and obviously more investigation will be needed to track down the wildlife route origin, if, in fact, that is how it got to Huanan in the first place.

I think the point for now is that it makes a pretty plausible case that Huanan is a very likely candidate for the origin of the virus's emergence.
 
So of course, the question is going to be, well where is the animal(s) that brought the virus?

Yes, it is true that none have yet been found despite "80,000 animals being tested", but as this person on Twitter points out, the markets had clearly been selling a lot of wild life which was never tested.

In addition, very soon after the outbreak it seems there was a rush to close wildlife farms and a mass extermination of animals there. This is not unusual in pandemics in fact, and certainly does point to the Chinese government finding a wildlife route to be a plausible explanation for the pandemic.

This article came out in February of 2020:

Nearly 20,000 wildlife farms raising species including peacocks, civet cats, porcupines, ostriches, wild geese and boar have been shut down across China in the wake of the coronavirus, in a move that has exposed the hitherto unknown size of the industry.

Until a few weeks ago wildlife farming was still being promoted by government agencies as an easy way for rural Chinese people to get rich.

But the Covid-19 outbreak, which has now led to 2,666 deaths and over 77,700 known infections, is thought to have originated in wildlife sold at a market in Wuhan in early December, prompting a massive rethink by authorities on how to manage the trade.

China issued a temporary ban on wildlife trade to curb the spread of the virus at the end of January and began a widespread crackdown on breeding facilities in early February.

Why would China have reacted like this unless they saw the likelihood of it being caused by the wildlife trade?
 
Why would China have reacted like this unless they saw the likelihood of it being caused by the wildlife trade?

My thought on this part only. I don't think there is any relation to what really happened to how China is reacting. This is public reaction. Something China thinks we want it to do. And probably what China wanted to do anyway. Even if covid haven't started in the market, prior infections certainly did, and future ones might.

Also Chinese government is criminal conspiracy from the beginning. Somebody supporting official position should prove his independence to greater than usual extent.
 
My thought on this part only. I don't think there is any relation to what really happened to how China is reacting.

You think that China shut down the wild life farms because "we" wanted them to do so? Wow! Good for China then, to finally start taking "us" into consideration. Usually they tell "us" to go **** ourselves and stop interfering in their domestic issues.

Do you really think that?

This is public reaction. Something China thinks we want it to do.

Public relations? This is something you know, or something you suspect but have decided to categorically state as if it is common knowledge?

Again, I am quite surprised you immediately think that China is thinking of "us" when doing this. My understanding is that China does not want to implicate the wildlife trade, and have made up all kinds of their own conspiracy theories such as how the virus leaked from a US lab or that it began in Italy or came to China on frozen food or lobsters from Maine, etc...

And probably what China wanted to do anyway. Even if covid haven't started in the market, prior infections certainly did, and future ones might.

Yes, they did. That in itself should influence your priors.

Also Chinese government is criminal conspiracy from the beginning. Somebody supporting official position should prove his independence to greater than usual extent.

I'm not supporting the official position at all. The idea it originated in the Huanan Market is NOT the official position of the Chinese goverment.

China’s top epidemiologist said Tuesday that testing of samples from a Wuhan food market, initially suspected as a path for the virus’s spread to humans, failed to show links between animals being sold there and the pathogen. Gao Fu, director of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, said in comments carried in Chinese state media, “It now turns out that the market is one of the victims.”

Link

Their actions implicate the market and the wildlife trade while their statements officially deny it.

They also deny the lab leak scenario as well, of course.

But you should remember, if you are going to make claims like those you have about China doing things for public relations, that their official position is NOT that the market is the centre of the outbreak.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom