Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay, this is interesting.

This is from an older TWiV, back in the fairly early days of the pandemic. Ian Lipkin is the guest and he is calling in from China and suffering from Covid-19.

Ian Lipkin is talking with the host about how he heard about the virus in December 15th, so he has been pretty consistent in saying this.

This comes up at about the 17-minute mark. He says it was from a Chinese professor who is part of an underfunded international program called GIDEON (Global Infectious Disease Epidemiology Network).

Lipkin was one of the signatories of the Proximal Origins paper, but I think he may be somewhat on the fence about the possibility of a leak.

Interestingly, this is, I think, the first TWiV I ever listened to.
 
I'm addressing a specific argument that you have made. I think it is worth examining each one if you think it is worth making the argument.

You argue that the virus could not have been so adapted to humans in a short space of time because:

a) SARS-1 took longer
b) H5N1 has taken even longer

But by that argument, SARS-1 could not have adapted so quickly because it did so quicker than H5N1.
This is a straw man. You have and continue to distort my argument. But no worries, carry on. I'll move on.

There is an easy answer to this point: some viruses achieve pandemic potential quicker than others by mutational chance.
Obviously.

Where did the furin cleavage site come from?


Sure. And one day, maybe we or someone will. But the "needs to explain why..." also applies to every other theory.
The evidence leans toward the lab-leak hypothesis. IIRC your main argument is that natural spillovers are more common therefore the odds are higher this was a natural spillover. Is that your main argument?

Do you agree or disagree that Worobey's hypothesis has serious problems? In particular he has used a faulty underlying premise that he's working with the earliest genomes.


I read a whole book about it and have been following a lot of scientists talking about this. Frankly, it requires far more knowledge, and ultimately it requires the type of knowledge that I will never attain. In fact, even for the top experts, there are a LOT of areas of incomplete knowledge.
I've been working with infectious diseases including species jumps for 30 years. The knowledge is not that incomplete. Care to cite an example so I have a better idea what you are talking about?


Then there is no point in you comparing SARS-1 and H5N1 and drawing conclusions about how possible it was to adapt to humans so quickly.
They are relevant examples in this case. You don't have to agree.


Okay, I will have to look at that.
You still haven't??????


So there is a bit of a contradiction here, I think.

You are expecting a viral outbreak elsewhere in the country to be easily picked up by the surveillance system.

Yet, if that is true, why did it not pick up the early (Sept-Oct) outbreak.
How do you know it didn't? What we can say is there was no evidence of an outbreak outside of Wuhan, and no evidence of initial spread from any location outside of Wuhan.


Worobey has an answer to that, which is that the system as set up is not sensitive enough to small numbers of cases. He also, in fact, points out that even SARS-CoV2 was not identified through this system.

If the actual pandemic itself was not detected by it, we cannot assume that the virus's precursor must be.
Unless you look at the MOA/TopHap there is no point in discussing Worobey's work.
 
It's a pain going back to the beginning of the thread because it's saturated with the false belief the lab-leak hypothesis is a CT and with all the Trumpian and alt-right contamination of the data. So I'll just be pulling from some of the themes.

Like this one about the military games in Oct 2019 in China spreading COVID cases. We are still stuck with the paucity of data on whether ill participants were ever diagnosed with COVID. But there was this study:

The impact of the World Military Games on the COVID-19 pandemic
There is a correlation between the number of individuals who travelled to the event and the number of COVID-19 cases in the country to which they returned. Whether this explains the rapid spread of the pandemic or not is not known definitively. However, this study shows a mathematical model to predict the number of COVID-19 cases in a country as a result of each infected individual travelling to that country.

It's also worth noting China claims the athletes brought COVID to Wuhan. That's a bit of a contradiction if they also say the first cases were in early Dec.


BBC June 2020: Coronavirus: Satellite traffic images may suggest virus hit Wuhan earlier
Harvard researchers say satellite images show an increase in traffic outside five hospitals in the Chinese city from late August to December.

The traffic spike coincided with a rise in online searches for information on symptoms like "cough" and "diarrhoea". ...

In one case, researchers counted 171 cars parked at one of Wuhan's largest hospitals, Tianyou Hospital in October 2018.

Satellite data from the same time in 2019 showed 285 vehicles in the same place, an increase of 67%.


BBC: The author Catherine Mayer believes it's possible her late husband Andy Gill - guitarist and co-founder of Gang of Four - may have been one of the earliest to be struck down by Covid-19. He was 64.
Andy returned from a tour in China on 23 November 2019 and fell ill in December with many symptoms of Covid-19. He died in St Thomas's hospital on 1 February. Doctors did consider whether it might be this new virus they were hearing about, but the timelines didn't seem plausible. ...

... She began doing her own detective work and discovered that his tour manager had fallen seriously ill with a respiratory infection too. And, sadly, Catherine's stepfather also died, on 22 December. "It raises all sorts of questions for me on a personal level," she says.

And further down the page:
Debra Scott from Blackpool thinks she caught the virus in late November at her husband's school reunion, where there was "lots of hugging and handshaking".

Her symptoms included a "cough that could kill a horse" and lasted for weeks. "I kept thinking I was getting better then - boom - it floored me again and again," she says.

She was so convinced it was Covid that she sent a blood sample off to a lab for an antibody test, which came back positive.

Some of these are anecdotes, there are caveats and alternative explanations. But the evidence does corroborate the TopHap study.
 
Question from SG:

“Do you agree or disagree that Worobey's hypothesis has serious problems? In particular he has used a faulty underlying premise that he's working with the earliest genomes.”

Huh? The “earliest genomes”? No, the earliest available ones, maybe, but he does not claim that these were the first cases. He explicitly says the virus had infected others before it was detected.

As for that “study” in the Irish Journal of Medicine, I have already shown why that “study” is a pile of crap. It is a letter, not a study, by someone who put numbers of athletes in European countries into an Excel spreadsheet with numbers of people who had been infected about a YEAR later worldwide. I showed that if you input all the other countries’ numbers into the Excel spreadsheet then the correlation goes away. I even manually put the numbers in and posted it here, from what I remember. So for you to bring up that crap again is pretty insulting.
 
IIt's also worth noting China claims the athletes brought COVID to Wuhan. That's a bit of a contradiction if they also say the first cases were in early Dec.

I don't think the claims of the Chinese government need to be taken very seriously, partly because some of these claims probably come as retaliation for the claims that the virus leaked from their labs.

In addition, it is not a contradiction if you simply acknowledge that different people in China have asserted different things, just like different people in the US and other countries have asserted different things.

As far as I can see, George Gao (et al) of the CCDC makes no mention of the Wuhan Military Games in their paper.

From what I can see, all it does is affirm that there was a high amount of virus in the Huanan Market in December 2019. suggesting it was an amplifying event. It does not claim it originated then and there. It also does not refute the idea that it originated in the market.

Latham and Wilson in the article you linked to makes some suggestion that the papers by Worobey et al and Pekar et al somehow contradict Gao et. al. I don't see the contradiction there either. By the way, do they still stand by their Mojiang Mine serial passage theory? It seems to me that this theory is now obsolete.
 
Here is a link to my debunking of that Irish Medical Journal letter that SG claimed was a study by the NIH….

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13587617&postcount=2263

Of course which is why I noted there were caveats, some of the info came from anecdotes (of which there are many more) and there were contradictions and other explanations. And for similar reasons I didn't post about the COVID antibodies in stored blood taken for other reasons.

Before you waste your time, there were criticisms of the traffic and searches for certain COVID symptoms on Weibo as well.

Coronavirus: Fact-checking claims it might have started in August 2019

All of the things posted early (and later for that matter) in the thread were criticized. Some were dismissed simply because the researchers were dismissed like Quay. Some was dismissed on the basis it appeared on a right wing site like the National Review.

The point of taking a second look is to do so with the new study information.

Again you are not moving forward. I'm looking for stuff that corroborates an earlier outbreak in Wuhan in Oct or even Sept.

It's fairly well documented there were cases in Nov. It's not just the embassy cable, and the 3 WIV workers who were never confirmed to have been hospitalized. Shi denied there were any WIV workers with pneumonia but refused to let the WHO team see any of the raw data where these workers were tested.

You might also recall that some evidence was ignored (outside of the thread) until people stopped referring to it. The fact the seafood market cases were a super-spreader event later became the claim they were the first cases. That got repeated over and over in the media until the first cases China acknowledged but later wouldn't release data on became forgotten in some circles.

I'll have to get back to this an address Worobey's claims in a bit.
 
Of course which is why I noted there were caveats, some of the info came from anecdotes (of which there are many more) and there were contradictions and other explanations. And for similar reasons I didn't post about the COVID antibodies in stored blood taken for other reasons.

Not "caveats"! The "study" is meaningless. MEANINGLESS.

Again you are not moving forward. I'm looking for stuff that corroborates an earlier outbreak in Wuhan in Oct or even Sept.

We move on when you throw that letter in the bin!

Never bring that letter up again.

Also, "I'm looking for stuff that corroborates" sounds like confirmation bias. It is a bad idea to latch onto any old crap that supports your pre-existing belief. And that letter is really really crap!
 
Last edited:
Not "caveats"! The "study" is meaningless. MEANINGLESS.



We move on when you throw that letter in the bin!

Never bring that letter up again.

Also, "I'm looking for stuff that corroborates" sounds like confirmation bias. It is a bad idea to latch onto any old crap that supports your pre-existing belief. And that letter is really really crap!

The Parent virus of Covid 19 came from Laos, one Laotian worker in China's great build Urinating on the ground could have gotten the Virus into the Karst and Caves under Wuhan.
Once into the Karst Geology it could have spread rapidly among wildlife in the caves.
 
Not "caveats"! The "study" is meaningless. MEANINGLESS.



We move on when you throw that letter in the bin!

Never bring that letter up again.

Also, "I'm looking for stuff that corroborates" sounds like confirmation bias. It is a bad idea to latch onto any old crap that supports your pre-existing belief. And that letter is really really crap!

So you haven't looked at the MOA/TopHap material or my post looking at it in detail yet then?:boggled:
 
So you haven't looked at the MOA/TopHap material or my post looking at it in detail yet then?:boggled:

It's almost as if people around the world have jobs and families and cannot spend their whole time reading endless studies and answering a blizzard of questions that even when answered come back again as zombie theories.

When I have time I will do it. I have no obligation to do so until then.
 
Of course which is why I noted there were caveats, some of the info came from anecdotes (of which there are many more) and there were contradictions and other explanations. And for similar reasons I didn't post about the COVID antibodies in stored blood taken for other reasons.

Before you waste your time, there were criticisms of the traffic and searches for certain COVID symptoms on Weibo as well.

Coronavirus: Fact-checking claims it might have started in August 2019

All of the things posted early (and later for that matter) in the thread were criticized. Some were dismissed simply because the researchers were dismissed like Quay. Some was dismissed on the basis it appeared on a right wing site like the National Review.

The point of taking a second look is to do so with the new study information.

Again you are not moving forward. I'm looking for stuff that corroborates an earlier outbreak in Wuhan in Oct or even Sept.

It's fairly well documented there were cases in Nov. It's not just the embassy cable, and the 3 WIV workers who were never confirmed to have been hospitalized. Shi denied there were any WIV workers with pneumonia but refused to let the WHO team see any of the raw data where these workers were tested.

You might also recall that some evidence was ignored (outside of the thread) until people stopped referring to it. The fact the seafood market cases were a super-spreader event later became the claim they were the first cases. That got repeated over and over in the media until the first cases China acknowledged but later wouldn't release data on became forgotten in some circles.

I'll have to get back to this an address Worobey's claims in a bit.

Presumably a stuttering outbreak with poor person to person transmission from e.g. September would fit with how you imagine an outbreak would occur if a virus had spread from an animal into humans? The isolates from December would by then have passed through many persons and have adapted to humans.
 
It's almost as if people around the world have jobs and families and cannot spend their whole time reading endless studies and answering a blizzard of questions that even when answered come back again as zombie theories.

When I have time I will do it. I have no obligation to do so until then.

And yet here you are repeating old arguments. :confused:

Of course you are not obligated. The evidence is what it is whether you read it or not. It disproves Worobey's position there was a spillover beginning in the seafood market. I'm waiting for him and/or Bloom to comment on the new phylogenetics work.

I'll post about it here if I find anything.
 
Very interesting reading Worobey's Twitter. He's quite annoyed his* findings are being questioned, complaining the people critiquing him are not experienced virologists with research under their belts.

*I should be including K Anderson is a co-author.

Worobey repeats "earliest known" cases when that is demonstrably false because there are earlier cases China continues to withhold data on. And he continues to insist A & B lineages represent 2 separate spillover events even though at least two researchers cited in this thread now said A was the initial strain and B evolved from A.

I repeat, he ignores contradictory evidence.

Worobey mentioned Ian Lipkin claiming he heard about cases in Wuhan on Dec 15. Worobey does cite some convincing evidence Lipkin had not heard about said cases on Dec 15 because he said nothing about it on Dec 16 in a relevant meeting. It's not a piece of evidence that matters much if we toss it out.

But it seems to be odd Worobey cares to rebut Lipkin when there is other evidence the Worobey/Anderson paper does not use the earliest cases. Since I'm supposedly wrong about the paper's claims, I'll take another look at it.


The Seeker's Twitter on Mar 10th makes a detailed case for the lab-leak origin and against the natural spillover origin without mentioning the MOA/TopHap analysis.

@TheSeeker268
·
Mar 10
There is no evidence of a single spillover, let alone two spillovers.

Besides, as one virologist tells me:
Way too much is being made of the two lineages thing. They only differ by two mutations. The virus gets that many mutations in ~10% of human transmission events. ...

The Seeker
@TheSeeker268
·
Mar 10
If it’s true that first IH-to-human cases occurred in the market, it means that the IH already had the key mutations to cross species, and perhaps the FCS region incorporated. So, the virus was already a generalist on the IH. Then, why it did not transmit widely to other animals?
The Seeker
@TheSeeker268
·
Mar 10
Why didn’t in end up in other markets besides Wuhan? Where is the trail leading to such an abrupt explosion of cases in Wuhan? Where are the intermediate strains? If it were only circulating in a few animals then how did two lineages with ultra rare mutations evolve? ...

The Seeker
@TheSeeker268
·
Mar 10
All of this makes the coincidence a lot more than just “proximity”.

In short: I think it would have to be a very unusual set of circumstances where the virus failed to emerge in other places, but Wuhan...

There's a video of Ralph Baric saying a virus could be engineered that was not detectable.

The Seeker also noted:
One more thing to keep in mind: WIV was awarded a state-funded megaproject – with funding from the CAS and NSFC – just after the DARPA proposal was rejected.
Important if one thinks Shi and Daszak only had access to US funds.
 
Worobey is not “rebutting” Lipkin, he is merely questioning whether the date is accurate.

I already posted the podcast episode in which Lipkin explains how he came to know of the outbreak and also how he came to leave for China.

I think it would be very useful for Lipkin to be involved in the search for the origins of the virus by the sounds of things as he clearly has a good rapport with the Chinese scientists. Of course, if he doesn’t find a lab leak everyone who suspects it will accuse him of a conflict of interest.
 
Very interesting reading Worobey's Twitter. He's quite annoyed his* findings are being questioned, complaining the people critiquing him are not experienced virologists with research under their belts.

*I should be including K Anderson is a co-author.

There are 18 authors on the paper that you definitely read.

Worobey repeats "earliest known" cases when that is demonstrably false because there are earlier cases China continues to withhold data on. And he continues to insist A & B lineages represent 2 separate spillover events even though at least two researchers cited in this thread now said A was the initial strain and B evolved from A.

I repeat, he ignores contradictory evidence.

Worobey mentioned Ian Lipkin claiming he heard about cases in Wuhan on Dec 15. Worobey does cite some convincing evidence Lipkin had not heard about said cases on Dec 15 because he said nothing about it on Dec 16 in a relevant meeting.

It was Angela Rassmussen who was surprised that Lipkin didn't mention it. She is one of the co-authors of the paper that you definitely read.


It's not a piece of evidence that matters much if we toss it out.

You can hardly use it as evidence of a lab leak then.

But it seems to be odd Worobey cares to rebut Lipkin when there is other evidence the Worobey/Anderson paper does not use the earliest cases. Since I'm supposedly wrong about the paper's claims, I'll take another look at it.

Have you read it once, yet?


Expecting: Oh so here is new evidence that I missed on my first reading.
 
Worobey is not “rebutting” Lipkin, he is merely questioning whether the date is accurate.

I already posted the podcast episode in which Lipkin explains how he came to know of the outbreak and also how he came to leave for China.

I think it would be very useful for Lipkin to be involved in the search for the origins of the virus by the sounds of things as he clearly has a good rapport with the Chinese scientists. Of course, if he doesn’t find a lab leak everyone who suspects it will accuse him of a conflict of interest.

He rebutted Lipkin's claim of being told on Dec 15th 2019 there was an outbreak of pneumonia (or a corona virus—whatever) in Wuhan. So we have Lipkin saying he was told and Worobey saying it doesn't add up and you questioning the claim and me saying, meh, file it away until further information comes of it.

I did not see your link to said podcast. It's not worth more time than that at the moment.
 
There are 18 authors on the paper that you definitely read.

It was Angela Rassmussen who was surprised that Lipkin didn't mention it. She is one of the co-authors of the paper that you definitely read.

You can hardly use it as evidence of a lab leak then.

Have you read it once, yet?

Expecting: Oh so here is new evidence that I missed on my first reading.
Your tu quoque is a fail. Yes I did read Worobey's still-not-peer-reviewed preprint. Has it been published now? Reading something and not recalling every detail is not the same as arguing old points in the thread when a new pretty significant study is posted that you have yet to even look at. It's the whole point of opening the thread again.

Though I do need to go back to see what I thought about the 2021 paper.


So I should be saying Worobey, et al. :rolleyes: The reason I said I should add in Anderson is because Anderson and Garry are prominent natural spillover proponents. It's not a big deal any more than it is a big deal how many authors signed on to Worobey's study.


As for using XYZ as evidence of a lab leak, this is exactly what I said about your repeated posts throughout the thread that single out something while ignoring the bigger picture.

It's not critical what Lipkin said or didn't say. Just like it was never critical what Quay published or didn't, or what was printed in the National Review.

The biggest pieces of evidence are the papers Shi published before Dec 2019, the thesis and doctorate dissertation on the miners in Yunnan, the emails and contracts involving Daszak revealed under the FOIA, the fact live bats were kept at the WIV which was denied, the removal of a database of SARS CoV genomes from net access in Sept 2019, the fact the Chinese government refuses to release data on the first infections, the attempt by Daszak to steer the WHO team away from the lab-leak hypothesis before it was investigated and his attempt to label the lab-leak investigations as CTs, the lack of any source animals found that one would expect to see by now, the fact there have been no other outbreaks across China that didn't originate in Wuhan, the fact the WIV was studying the PPVs with only level 2 biosafety precautions ... and so on.

Those are big pieces of evidence but even those need to be considered as a lot of pieces adding up, not as this piece or that piece being the key to the whole tower of evidence.

Look at the sum of the whole, which origin hypothesis has stronger evidence?
 
I think this should be of interest...

Since the identification of theSARS-CoV-2 in Wuhan, China, in January 2020 (1), the origin of the virus has been a topic of intense scientific debate and public speculation. The two main hypotheses are that the virus emerged from human exposure to an infected animal [“zoonosis” (2)] or that it emerged in a research-related incident (3). The investigation into the origin of the virus has been made difficult by the lack of key evidence from the earliest days of the outbreak—there’s no doubt that greater transparency on the part of Chinese authorities would be enormously helpful. Nevertheless, we argue here that there is much important information that can be gleaned from US-based research institutions, information not yet made available for independent, transparent, and scientific scrutiny.

The data available within the United States would explicitly include, but are not limited to, viral sequences gathered and held as part of the PREDICT project and other funded programs, as well as sequencing data and laboratory notebooks from US laboratories. We call on US government scientific agencies, most notably the NIH, to support a full, independent, and transparent investigation of the origins of SARS-CoV-2. This should take place, for example, within a tightly focused science-based bipartisan Congressional inquiry with full investigative powers, which would be able to ask important questions—but avoid misguided witch-hunts governed more by politics than by science.

In particular, the call for an independent investigation is into US researchers, particularly those in the University of North Carolnia (Baric's lab) and UCD. They also want to investigate EHA, particularly those who worked in Wuhan.

They also have an interest in the FCS:

In fact, the assertion that the FCS in SARS-CoV-2 has an unusual, nonstandard amino acid sequence is false. The amino acid sequence of the FCS in SARS-CoV-2 also exists in the human ENaC α subunit (16), where it is known to be functional and has been extensively studied (17, 18).

Link
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom