Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
Delete, Deny, and Destroy: Chinese and Western Strategies To Erase COVID’s Origin Are Being Exposed By Independent Research; by Jonathan Latham, PhD and Allison Wilson, PhD
This is an excellent and very thorough article that tears down both the Worobey hypothesis and the Chinese CDC attempt to focus the blame outside of China.
This piece of evidence is important and I'm not sure it was mentioned before:
Not only is the evidence lacking for 2 spillover events, it's lacking for even one such event.
There's a very interesting discussion of bad science by good scientists that everyone in this forum should find interesting whether they care about the origin debate or not.
Moving on: But if we aren't going to get evidence from the earliest cases in Wuhan that the Chinese have, is there another way to get at the truth? Turns out there is.
This is where I'm going to stop and finish the discussion in a second post since my long posts tend to get ignored and dismissed as data dumps. But by all means feel free to read ahead in the paper. You won't be disappointed.
This is an excellent and very thorough article that tears down both the Worobey hypothesis and the Chinese CDC attempt to focus the blame outside of China.
A Huanan market origin has officially been dismissed by the authorities in China. Nevertheless, on February 25th a preprint authored by George Gao, head of China’s CDC, and 38 other Chinese virologists appeared that seems intended to settle the issue (Gao et al., 2022). ...
Just sixteen hours later, on February 26th, two preprints appeared simultaneously that directly contradict the Gao conclusions. The senior authors of these companion articles are an overlapping set of very high-profile virologists. None are from China.
One of these preprints asserts, based on surface swabs and other environmental samples found there, that the Huanan market was the “unambiguous epicenter” of the pandemic (Worobey et al., 2022). The second argues that SARS-CoV-2 emerged at least twice at the market (Pekar et al., 2022). According to these latter authors, one zoonotic spillover created what are known as the lineage A SARS-CoV-2 viruses and a second spillover was the root of all lineage B SARS-CoV-2 viruses. These two spillovers, they say, decisively contradict a lab leak.
I won't rehash the reasons to doubt the Worobey work but do read the specifics outlined very carefully in this paper.Especially if one includes the new Gao et al. evidence, there are already powerful reasons to doubt both the market-zoonotic origin and a dual-spillover. These reasons are largely glossed over by the Pekar and Worobey preprints so they are worth outlining briefly:
This piece of evidence is important and I'm not sure it was mentioned before:
And this is essentially what I said about conveniently filling in the holes in the evidence:2) Environmental samples collected at the market are of human origin and did not come from animals sold there.
3) Pekar and Worobey rely on circular reasoning to identify root viruses.
Not only is the evidence lacking for 2 spillover events, it's lacking for even one such event.
There's a very interesting discussion of bad science by good scientists that everyone in this forum should find interesting whether they care about the origin debate or not.
If you doubt the Western scientists are motivated to support a natural spillover event do read the section of this paper that discusses it in detail. And then remember what I've been saying since the beginning of this thread that there has been a concerted effort to portray the lab leak origin as a CT. It is not a CT.It is a reasonable inference from the above that the leading virologists on each side, and who are directing these efforts, strongly suspect (or know because they are sitting on the evidence) that early data would not exonerate virus research in Wuhan, otherwise the same people would be hunting for early samples with great alacrity, which is clearly not happening. And we can surmise it is a lab leak that is being covered up since it is the only concern that both Chinese and Western virologists could plausibly share.
Moving on: But if we aren't going to get evidence from the earliest cases in Wuhan that the Chinese have, is there another way to get at the truth? Turns out there is.
Until recently, the COVID-19 origin question was therefore set to devolve into a simple two-way tug-of-war between the Gao club in the East and the Fauci club in the West. What none of them expected, however, was that a novel phylogenetic method would emerge capable of discrediting their careful calculus.
Mutational Order Analysis
This is where I'm going to stop and finish the discussion in a second post since my long posts tend to get ignored and dismissed as data dumps. But by all means feel free to read ahead in the paper. You won't be disappointed.
Last edited: