Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re Worobey, the issue I've haven't gotten back to the thread on is his use of a faulty underlying premise that he was operating with very early virus cases.

In this Science article, Worobey makes the case that the earliest cases were in Dec 2019 and they clustered around the seafood market.

Viewpoint: Dissecting the early COVID-19 cases in Wuhan

No one is disputing the market cluster. But it's pretty telling that the head of the Chinese CDC believes the market was where a super-spreader event took place, not where the first cases occurred.

From the article Worobey is convinced A&B lineages are evidence of 2 separate spillover events.


Preprint; Worobey et al: The Huanan market was the epicenter of SARS-CoV-2 emergence

Abstract

Despite strong epidemiological links and the documented presence of SARS-CoV2 susceptible animals, the role of the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in the COVID 19 pandemic remains controversial. Using spatial analyses we show that the earliest known COVID-19 cases diagnosed in December 2019 were geographically distributed near to, and centered on, this market. This distribution cannot be explained by high densities of elderly people at greater risk of symptomatic COVID-19. This pattern was stronger in cases without, rather than with, identified epidemiological links to the Huanan market, consistent with SARS-CoV-2 community transmission starting in the surrounding area. By combining spatial and genomic data, we show that both the two early lineages of SARS-CoV-2 have a clear association with the Huanan market. We also report that live mammals, including raccoon dogs, were sold at the market in late 2019 and geospatial analyses within the market show that SARS-CoV-2-positive environmental samples were strongly associated with vendors selling live animals. Together, these analyses provide dispositive evidence for the emergence of SARS-CoV-2 via the live wildlife trade and identify the Huanan market as the unambiguous epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic.

One sentence summary:

Geographical clustering of the earliest known COVID-19 cases and the proximity of positive environmental samples to live-animal vendors suggest that the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in Wuhan was the site of origin of the COVID-19 pandemic

Nowhere in the paper does Worobey, et al recognize any cases earlier than Dec 2019.

Science: Do three new studies add up to proof of COVID-19’s origin in a Wuhan animal market?

Answer, no.
Preprints unlikely to end debate over how SARS-CoV-2 began the pandemic, but some scientists say lab-leak hypothesis has taken a “blow”
"Some scientists" have always favored the natural event. All those working to keep the lab-leak hypothesis in play and not have it snuffed out before the evidence really rules it out are not likely to have changed their minds based on these reports.


As for the raccoon dogs being sold at the seafood market, I have no issue with that fact. But let's see the follow up then hunting down where were these raccoon dogs from that were supplied to the market? Is there any evidence there could have been infected raccoon dogs anywhere?

And given how easily COVID seems to have been spread to other animal species, where are all the infected animals in China? Given the lack of cases found in any animal species in China it supports the conclusion humans were the first species infected.
 
Re Worobey, the issue I've haven't gotten back to the thread on is his use of a faulty underlying premise that he was operating with very early virus cases.

The Worobey et. al paper explicitly points out in a number of places that they cannot be sure exactly when the earliest cases were and that they explicitly deny the first known case was the first actual case. In fact, they suggest that for every known case there were probably at least 10 and maybe up to 70 cases of unknown infections.

They say that the Pekar et. al paper is the one that deals with the estimates of when the virus appeared in humans.

What I did not get from looking at the paper by Kumar, et, al was exactly what was being claimed, whether it was a "proto-SARS-CoV-2" or one that was already in humans.

I have no way of knowing whether Pekar et al or Kumar et al are more likely to be correct.
 

Attachments

  • Worobey et al 1.jpg
    Worobey et al 1.jpg
    42.4 KB · Views: 6
  • Worobey et al 2.jpg
    Worobey et al 2.jpg
    45.7 KB · Views: 6
  • Worobey et al 3.jpg
    Worobey et al 3.jpg
    59.6 KB · Views: 8
  • Worobey et al 4.jpg
    Worobey et al 4.jpg
    41.9 KB · Views: 5
No one is disputing the market cluster. But it's pretty telling that the head of the Chinese CDC believes the market was where a super-spreader event took place, not where the first cases occurred.

Nothing in your post provides evidence for this assertion.

Nowhere in the paper does Worobey, et al recognize any cases earlier than Dec 2019.

There are no known identifiable cases earlier than Dec 11 so he's using the available data, as he should. There were almost certainly un-diagnosed cases as far back as early Nov but unknown and un-diagnosed cases are of no value to a study like this one.
 
Nothing in your post provides evidence for this assertion.



There are no known identifiable cases earlier than Dec 11 so he's using the available data, as he should. There were almost certainly un-diagnosed cases as far back as early Nov but unknown and un-diagnosed cases are of no value to a study like this one.

Indeed. I read through the Gao et.al. paper (CDCC) and did not find anything in it in which they “ruled out” Huanan market as a spillover location. The only thing that the paper did was confirmed that it was the site of an amplifying event, which had already been suspected. In fact the paper seems to me to be exactly what you would want in a science paper making use of available data and drawing reasonable conclusions without attendant wild speculation.

It may be the case that the Chinese government are making wild claims about covid leaking from a US lab or arriving on frozen lobsters but that was not what was written in the Gao paper.

In fact, that is obviously one of the disadvantages of being a good scientist, when people demand certain answers, good scientists will often have to say they don’t know.

“Oh YOU done know? Well I know someone who does!”
 
The Worobey et. al paper explicitly points out in a number of places that they cannot be sure exactly when the earliest cases were and that they explicitly deny the first known case was the first actual case. In fact, they suggest that for every known case there were probably at least 10 and maybe up to 70 cases of unknown infections.

They say that the Pekar et. al paper is the one that deals with the estimates of when the virus appeared in humans.
This is the conclusion in the Worobey paper I have an issue with:
Collectively these results provide incontrovertible evidence that there was a clear conduit, via susceptible live mammals for the zoonotic emergence of SARS-CoV-2 at the Huanan market towards the end of 2019. ...

And this:
Together these analyses provide dispositive evidence for the emergence of SARS-CoV-2 via the live wildlife trade and identify the Huanan market as the unambiguous epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Another POV:
Science: Do three new studies add up to proof of COVID-19’s origin in a Wuhan animal market?
Skeptics of the natural origin theory maintain the market cluster could merely be a superspreader event touched off when a person infected with a lab-escaped coronavirus visited it. But Worobey thinks further data could make that contention even less tenable. A more transparent analysis of the market’s genetic sampling data, in particular, might identify exactly which species of animals sold there carried the virus.
So Worobey admits more data is needed.


Back to the commentary:
In the new preprint, Gao and colleagues analyzed 1380 samples from 188 animals in the market and the environment, including sewer wells, the ground, feather removing machines, and “containers.” They found SARS-CoV-2 in 73 samples. But because all were from the environment, not the animals themselves, they assert that humans introduced the virus to the market. The authors call the market an “amplifier,” not the source, of SARS-CoV-2.
Gao would like to move patient zero out of China altogether. He asserts the patients in Italy predate the patients in Wuhan.

Not sure where you think Gao doesn't rule out the market being more than a super-spreader event. He has asserted this from the beginning.


This was discussed in my recent link. China wants the source to be outside China. Half of the 'Western' scientists don't want the lab to be implicated for multiple reasons, especially that it hits too close to home and might implicate their own work is potentially dangerous.


I'm not seeing overwhelming evidence that the A&B lineages represent two separate introductions of the virus into humans.
Garry had identified two different forms of SARS-CoV-2, differing by just two mutations, which he argued surfaced at different Wuhan markets in December 2019.
So A&B lineages differ by only 2 mutations yet they dismiss the possibility B descended from A?


What I did not get from looking at the paper by Kumar, et, al was exactly what was being claimed, whether it was a "proto-SARS-CoV-2" or one that was already in humans.

I have no way of knowing whether Pekar et al or Kumar et al are more likely to be correct.
I'll get back to this.
 
Last edited:
Indeed. I read through the Gao et.al. paper (CDCC) and did not find anything in it in which they “ruled out” Huanan market as a spillover location. The only thing that the paper did was confirmed that it was the site of an amplifying event, which had already been suspected. In fact the paper seems to me to be exactly what you would want in a science paper making use of available data and drawing reasonable conclusions without attendant wild speculation....

From my previous citation:
2) Environmental samples collected at the market are of human origin and did not come from animals sold there.
The aim of the Chinese CDC paper was to analyse the environmental samples (swabs from surfaces etc.) that they took in and around the Huanan market after Jan 1st, 2020 (Gao et al., 2022). They concluded that the market was only an amplifying event, in part because SARS-CoV-2-positive samples were associated with stalls belonging to multiple types of vendors, including those not selling animals (the Worobey preprint argues there is a correlation). More compelling, the CDC authors found that the samples collected from the market, which Pekar and Worobey claim are from infected animals, are admixed only with human genetic material and not with genetic material from raccoon dogs or other species potentially sold at the market. The only reasonable inference is that these positive samples did not derive from the faeces or urine or exhalations of a live non-human animal. Few results would better indicate that virus-positive market samples derive from infected humans as opposed to other species.

Different people apply different levels of relevance to the same evidence. But this suggests that Gao did indeed conclude the market was a super-spreader event and not the spillover event. Gao has been consistent in this conclusion from early on in the investigation and in citations posted earlier in the thread.

Remember, Gao is pushing the theory it started elsewhere, probably Italy.
 
Last edited:
I will repeat what I said...

Indeed. I read through the Gao et.al. paper (CDCC) and did not find anything in it in which they “ruled out” Huanan market as a spillover location. The only thing that the paper did was confirmed that it was the site of an amplifying event, which had already been suspected. In fact the paper seems to me to be exactly what you would want in a science paper making use of available data and drawing reasonable conclusions without attendant wild speculation.

What you are relying on is second-hand sources interpreting what they said.


2) Environmental samples collected at the market are of human origin and did not come from animals sold there.
The aim of the Chinese CDC paper was to analyse the environmental samples (swabs from surfaces etc.) that they took in and around the Huanan market after Jan 1st, 2020 (Gao et al., 2022). They concluded that the market was only an amplifying event, in part because SARS-CoV-2-positive samples were associated with stalls belonging to multiple types of vendors, including those not selling animals (the Worobey preprint argues there is a correlation). More compelling, the CDC authors found that the samples collected from the market, which Pekar and Worobey claim are from infected animals, are admixed only with human genetic material and not with genetic material from raccoon dogs or other species potentially sold at the market. The only reasonable inference is that these positive samples did not derive from the faeces or urine or exhalations of a live non-human animal. Few results would better indicate that virus-positive market samples derive from infected humans as opposed to other species.

I believe this is not what they said. They:

only confirmed it was an amplifying event,
they did not confirm it was only an amplifying event.

The two claims are different.

They leave a number of scenarios open such as the possibility that it came from elsewhere or that it came to the Huanan market via an intermediary.

You should read the paper yourself and not rely on others to interpret it for you. The paper is really very short.

Link
 
Last edited:
And I said Gao has had the position the market was a super-spreader event from the beginning.
Whatever's in the paper you've linked to is not the only place Gao has voiced his opinion.
 
And I said Gao has had the position the market was a super-spreader event from the beginning.
Whatever's in the paper you've linked to is not the only place Gao has voiced his opinion.

So what? Whatever opinions he has expressed elsewhere is irrelevant. Clearly the paper contains that which the authors can be confident of saying. It is inaccurate to claim, as your source does, that they conclusively rule out the market.
 
So what? ....
So what indeed.

Any good scientist will not deal in absolutes. Even in this debate, there is no proof one way or the other which origin hypothesis is correct.

Gao has access to the data on the early cases that China is withholding from the rest of thee world. It's in his political interest to promote the hypothesis that the origin occurred outside of China. He could provide more evidence of that fact if he truly believed the source was Italy or some other country.

In the beginning and for more than a year Daszak tried to steer the scientific community into repeating the unsupported opinion that the lab origin was a CT. More than a few scientists have described their being afraid to address the lab hypothesis because it led to being ostracized by their peers. This has all been documented in this thread.

More than a few people latched on to the Worobey study as some kind of relief they might put the lab origin hypothesis to bed. The news media reported on the study as if it were as strong of evidence as Worobey described: "incontrovertible evidence" and "unambiguous evidence." But that is an exaggeration.

When you try to make it sound like Gao only 'sort of' believes the market was a super-spreader but not a spillover event, you are biasing his position to fit your beliefs. Did he say the market might be the spillover location? No, of course not. That you are putting some kind of magical weight to the idea not denying it is the same as saying it's equivocal demonstrates that confirmation bias.

I have tried to look at the spillover evidence honestly. Had the Worobey study not claimed the A&B lineages were two separate introductions into the human population, had the researchers admitted their spatial analysis of the cases left out a lot of cases China was not releasing data on, had the report not been so overly assured of their findings, I would give that report more credence.

But they did not. The report's conclusions are overstated. And the likelihood the findings could also represent a super-spreader event is understated.


Just like the "spillover" is the default position because look how often it happens is not a convincing argument. I find the 'OMG you mean this happened only 17 miles (from the Worobey paper) from the one place in China they've been collecting these coronavirus bat specimens' to be a much stronger argument than it is some bizarre coincidence that some infected animal no one can find the source of just happened to set off a pandemic only 17 miles from the WIV.
 
Last edited:
So what indeed.

Any good scientist will not deal in absolutes. Even in this debate, there is no proof one way or the other which origin hypothesis is correct.

Exactly. Then Latham and Wilson have no business drawing absolute conclusions that were not in the paper while claiming that those conclusions were in the paper. And you should read the paper instead of relying on them to give an accurate gloss on the paper.
 
From your link:
All the four sewerage wells in the market tested positive. This suggested that either contaminated sewage may have played a role in the cluster of cases in the market or that the infected people in the market contaminated the sewage
Does that say maybe animals from the market could have been a source of the contaminated sewage?

No, it says maybe the contaminated sewage played a role in the cluster of cases.

Further down:
These results suggested that SARS-CoV-2 might have been circulating in the market, especially the western zone, for a period of time in December 2019, leading to an extensive distribution of the virus within the market, which might have been facilitated by the crowded buyers and the contaminated environment.

Does that say a spillover event cannot be ruled out?

No.

All the 457 animal samples tested negative for SARS-CoV-2 nucleic acid, suggesting that the animal infections with SARS-CoV-2 might be rare in the market.
That includes a lot of samples taken that include some before the market was purged of all animals.

More testing:
Therefore, the SARS-CoV-2 sequences from environmental samples were highly similar to the clinical strains obtained during the early stage of the COVID-19 outbreak
Does that say the conclusion could be they represent a spillover event occurred at the market?

No.
We analyzed the correlation of SARS-CoV-2 and the abundance of other species. The abundance of Homo sapiens showed the correlation to SARS-CoV-2(Figure 4), which highly suggests the SARS-CoV-2 might have derived fromHomo sapiens in the HSM. No animals were concluded, implying that no animal host of SARS-CoV-2 can be deduced.

How much more clear do you expect Gao to be?

I'm not sure why you think your interpretation of the paper is superior to the 2 PhDs' interpretation of the paper.
Thus, the market might have acted as an amplifier due to the high number of visitors every day, causing many initially identified infection clusters in the early stage of the outbreak as indicated in the Report of WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2 (10). In addition, live SARS-CoV-2 viruses also existed in the environmental samples. However, no SARS-CoV-2 was detected in the animal samples from the market. Definitely, more work involving international coordination is needed to investigate the real origins of SARS-CoV-2(10), especially considering the SARS-CoV-2 positive results of samples collected in 2019 in retrospective studies of different countries (29, 30).
IOW Gao wants to see more investigating of older samples from different countries.

And you can't use your go-to excuse on these negative findings that all the testing of animals was done after all the animals were purged. Gao describes samples that reflected the actual animals in the market. And the paper documents the live virus they successfully cultured in their study all matched human virus, none matched animal viruses.

And that ties into the TopHap analysis which found the same thing: This was a human adapted virus from the very beginning of the pandemic.
 
Last edited:
From your link:Does that say maybe animals from the market could have been a source of the contaminated sewage?

No, it says maybe the contaminated sewage played a role in the cluster of cases.

Further down:

Does that say a spillover event cannot be ruled out?

No.

That includes a lot of samples taken that include some before the market was purged of all animals.

More testing:Does that say the conclusion could be they represent a spillover event occurred at the market?

No.

Absence of evidence =/= evidence of absence.

This is elementary logic and yet, your authors derived the latter from the former.

I'm not sure why you think your interpretation of the paper is superior to the 2 PhDs' interpretation of the paper.

TWO PhDs!!!!

I guess 2 PhDs can't be wrong.
 
Absence of evidence =/= evidence of absence.

This is elementary logic and yet, your authors derived the latter from the former.
What are you talking about?

Did you lose track of the discussion?

You claim Gao didn't rule out a spillover event at the market. By your measure he didn't rule out a panspermia virus either. :boggled:


BTW, the Gao paper was posted before the Worobey study wasn't it? Or do I have the dates wrong? Why would you expect Gao to comment one way or the other on a spillover event at the market?

Does the Worobey study address the findings in the Gao paper? Why not? It concludes the earliest viruses don't have remnants of animal viruses.
 
Last edited:
What are you talking about?

Did you lose track of the discussion?

You claim Gao didn't rule out a spillover event at the market. By your measure he didn't rule out a panspermia virus either. :boggled:


BTW, the Gao paper was posted before the Worobey study wasn't it? Or do I have the dates wrong? Why would you expect Gao to comment one way or the other on a spillover event at the market?
Does the Worobey study address the findings in the Gao paper? Why not? It concludes the earliest viruses don't have remnants of animal viruses.

I don't contend he does.

The claim by you and Latham and Wilson is that Gao rules out a market spillover.

My claim is that Gao's paper does not do that. It merely says that their is evidence of an amplifying event there. It also says that no animal samples were found there.

I don't think anyone really disputes those points.

The dispute is on the spin you are giving it.
 
Does the Worobey study address the findings in the Gao paper? Why not? It concludes the earliest viruses don't have remnants of animal viruses.

No, it does not! Why not? Because the Gao paper was posted something like one day before Worobey et al's paper came out.

How do you expect them to repond that quickly?
 
So Gao should have an opinion on the market being a spillover event but the Worobey group can't possibly address the Gao et al paper because they came out a day apart?

It's easy to focus on something pedantic and miss the bigger picture.

Worobey overstated the findings of their study. Nothing about being interpreted by anyone else.

More than a few Western researchers and experts have a confirmation bias toward finding a natural event, not a lab accident for the origin. I brought this up a couple posts upthread. The implications of a lab accident could have repercussions that affect the whole viral research field.

Gao has a clear motive to find an origin of the pandemic outside of Wuhan, outside of China. Why would he consider a possible spillover event at the market? That makes no sense.


None of these people except Gao are necessarily aware of their biases.


That's why the TopHap study is so important. It's also important to look at what these coronavirus researchers were doing before the pandemic. There is a lot of evidence to be found there.
 
From Jamie Metzl's Twitter:
I'd love to see a respectful public dialogue between
@MichaelWorobey & Sudhir @kumar_lab re pandemic origins. If Kumar's phylogenetic analysis of #SARSCov2 evolution is correct, Worobey et al's case for "dispositive evidence" of a #COVID19 market origin cannot be defended.
He links to both papers in the next 2 Tweets.

Someone has noticed. :popcorn1
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom