W.D.Clinger
Philosopher
That is a better abstract of the paper than the abstract Quay wrote.Are you talking about Quay's Bayseian analysis?
I have skimmed through the paper and I cannot make head or tail of his argument. It just looks like he arbitrarily attaches probabilities to cherry-picked datapoints.
No, not that paper. Give me a few minutes and I'll edit the link in here.
angrysoba asked whether that was the paper your meant, you said it wasn't, and now it appears to have been the paper you meant.No, not that paper. Give me a fewminuteshours (I got busy with other things) and I'll edit the link in here.
This is the paper you say you didn't understand:
A Bayesian analysis concludes beyond a reasonable doubt that SARS-CoV-2 is not a natural zoonosis but instead is laboratory derived
If you recall, you dismissed Quay not based on the paper but on the fact you weren't impressed by his background.
That paper is rubbish, for the substantive reason stated above by angrysoba. If I remember correctly, I have given a more substantive review of that paper earlier in this thread, and will try to find that review if SkepticGinger continues to refer to it.