Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Your favorite handwaving off excuse. This is the source and it isn't Quay: Nature: The COVID lab-leak hypothesis: what scientists do and don’t know
That's a good article. Reading it would be a good way to learn almost everything that could be learned by reading this entire thread, without having to wade through all the noise.

Here are some more excerpts from that article:
Most scientists say SARS-CoV-2 probably has a natural origin, and was transmitted from an animal to humans. However, a lab leak has not been ruled out....

Scientists don’t have enough evidence about the origins of SARS-CoV-2 to rule out the lab-leak hypothesis, or to prove the alternative — that the virus has a natural origin....

Researchers have some leads that support a natural origin....

Still, the possibility remains that SARS-CoV-2 escaped from a lab....

In theory, COVID-19 could have come from a lab in a few ways....There is currently no clear evidence to back these scenarios, but they aren’t impossible.

People have made a number of arguments for a lab origin for SARS-CoV-2 that are currently conjecture....

Outbreak-origin investigations often take years, and some culprits remain unknown. It took 14 years to nail down the origin of the SARS epidemic...To date, a complete Ebola virus has never been isolated from an animal in the region where the world’s largest outbreak occurred between 2013 and 2016.

Just because the virus spreads among humans doesn't mean it was designed to do so....“This was not some supremely adapted pathogen,” says Joel Wertheim, a molecular epidemiologist at the University of California San Diego.

So, for SARS-CoV-2 to have come from this mine in China, WIV researchers would have had to overcome some serious technical challenges — and they would have kept the information secret for a number of years and misled investigators on the WHO-led mission, scientists point out. There's no evidence of this, but it can't be ruled out.


The next-to-last paragraph of the article ends with this sentence:
A spokesperson for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People's Republic of China, Zhao Lijian, said that US labs should instead be investigated, and that some people in the United States “don't care about facts or truth and have zero interest in a serious science-based study of origins”.
While it is true that some people in the United States “don't care about facts or truth and have zero interest in a serious science-based study of origins”, that is also true of some people in China, notably the people at China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs for whom Zhao Lijian is speaking.
 
The Origin of Covid could be any place an animal urinated into a water supply such as a cave or underground spring, and where sanitary conditions were lax in China.

And if it were the source should have been found by now. These things don't arrive by immaculate conception. Zoonoses leave lots of footprints.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, but what? BANAL-52 is closer to SARS-CoV2 as you know, and anyway, I think you have already agreed that RaTG13 is not the progenitor virus, so all we are left with is not finding the virus. It doesn't mean we know it is in the lab. To conclude that is just another example of Lab-leak-of-the-gaps.
I answered that with your cited source. No it isn't. Only a piece of it matches, not the whole genome.

Let's look at that source, in context...

Exactly, but chopping off that context is what Dr Quay does, and you follow his lead.
If I post something from Quay by all means address it. But once again I ask you to stop trying to make my POV some CT. I have posted a wide array of sources that include a number of different avenues of investigation.

Trying to equate my arguments with a single person or thing is not a debate on the evidence.



As for imagining a scenario where they simply haven't tested enough animals, that's classic confirmation bias. You are again trying to make the evidence fit your preconceived conclusion. It is not how one tests an hypothesis.
 
I answered that with your cited source. No it isn't. Only a piece of it matches, not the whole genome.

Yes, it is...

Last year, researchers described another close relative of SARS-CoV-2, called RaTG13, which was found in bats in Yunnan5. It is 96.1% identical to SARS-CoV-2 overall and the two viruses probably shared a common ancestor 40–70 years ago6. BANAL-52 is 96.8% identical to SARS-CoV-2, says Eloit — and all three newly discovered viruses have individual sections that are more similar to sections of SARS-CoV-2 than seen in any other viruses.

Link

So the overall genome is closer in BANAL-52 than RaTG13.

What is probably confusing you is this...

Viruses swap chunks of RNA with one another through a process called recombination, and one section in BANAL-103 and BANAL-52 could have shared an ancestor with sections of SARS-CoV-2 less than a decade ago, says Spyros Lytras, an evolutionary virologist at the University of Glasgow. “These viruses recombine so much that different bits of the genome have different evolutionary histories,” he says.



If I post something from Quay by all means address it. But once again I ask you to stop trying to make my POV some CT. I have posted a wide array of sources that include a number of different avenues of investigation.

Trying to equate my arguments with a single person or thing is not a debate on the evidence.



As for imagining a scenario where they simply haven't tested enough animals, that's classic confirmation bias. You are again trying to make the evidence fit your preconceived conclusion. It is not how one tests an hypothesis.

I'm not "imagining a scenario". I'm pointing to the fact that the source you told me you got the 80,000 figure from also states that insufficient testing has been done, and that it hasn't been targeted in ways that are most likely to turn up the virus. You chopped off that part and made this statement:

Remember China has tested almost 80,000 animals looking for the source and haven't found it.

But what does your source say?

As for finding an intermediate host animal, researchers in China have tested more than 80,000 wild and domesticated animals; none have been positive for SARS-CoV-2. But this number is a tiny fraction of the animals in the country. To narrow the search down, researchers say, more strategic testing is needed to isolate animals that are most susceptible to infection and those that come in close contact with people.

By stripping the context from your own source, you end up doing what is known as "classic cherrypicking". Both you and Dr Quay cite the 80,000 figure without the qualifiers.

So this does not have to be about you, but at least present both sides of the coin to show that you are not giving more weight to one side without explaining the context.
 
Last edited:
I'm not confused. You keep ignoring:
individual sections that are more similar to sections of SARS-CoV-2

Even as the whole genome it gains very little
BANAL-52 is 96.8% identical to SARS-CoV-2,
It's not a close enough ancestor to be the direct source of COVID. And there is still the problem there is no connecting trail to Wuhan.

As for your claim I've cherry-picked some meaning of the 80,000 animals tested, that's just crap. I cited a link not connected to Quay. The fact doesn't change the Chinese have been on an intensive quest to find the source and they have not found it.

You can address your POV that this or that animal source wasn't tested without trying to taint my POV with your favorite whipping boy. Quay is not the source of the 80,000 number.
 
Last edited:
I'm not confused. You keep ignoring:

Even as the whole genome it gains very little It's not a close enough ancestor to be the direct source of COVID. And there is still the problem there is no connecting trail to Wuhan.

As for your claim I've cherry-picked some meaning of the 80,000 animals tested, that's just crap. I cited a link not connected to Quay. The fact doesn't change the Chinese have been on an intensive quest to find the source and they have not found it.

You can address your POV that this or that animal source wasn't tested without trying to taint my POV with your favorite whipping boy. Quay is not the source of the 80,000 number.

Cherry-picking again….

The genome of BANAL-52 is closer to that of SARS-CoV2 than RaTG13. That is overall!

And I did not say Dr Quay was your source for 80.000 animals. I said it was a favourite talking point of his and it is for yours. Ultimately the source is the WHO origins report which goes into many of those animals. I pointed that out and to the fact that many of those animals were in the zoo! Do you think that looking in the zoo is a likely place to find the spillover? I mean, it might be worth a try, but probably not likely… if you search places where the virus is not likely to have come from then you won’t find it any more than a drunk man will find his keys under the lamp post because that’s where the light is.

Unfortunately we don’t know what is going on in China and it is pretty frustrating that they are not open about what they are doing.

So we are forced to speculate or find other bits of evidence elsewhere. The BANAL-52 virus, despite its name is one of the most interesting bits of evidence we have found so far. Of course it is not anywhere near conclusive. But I think it is unreasonable to suddenly find the virus easily if there is the potential for the virus to be spread across a wide area.
 
I assume this report from US Intelligence has been discussed already. Forgive me for not reading the whole thread:

https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/Declassified-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins.pdf

There is no consensus in the US Intelligence Community regarding the origins, except on a few points:
In addition, the IC was able to reach broad agreement on several other key issues. We judge the virus was not developed as a biological weapon. Most agencies also assess with low confidence that SARS-CoV-2 probably was not genetically engineered; however, two agencies believe there was not sufficient evidence to make an assessment either way. Finally, the IC assesses China’s officials did not have foreknowledge of the virus before the initial outbreak of COVID-19 emerged.

Other than on those questions, they seem to be divided on whether an accidental lab leak or natural origin scenario is more plausible. I suppose you could say that they lean toward natural origin (4 agencies lean that way, 1 leans the other way, and 3 others are divided and think more information is needed).
 
We are not forced to speculate. We can just do nothing. Which is exactly what we should be doing without any new information.

Okay, maybe a bad choice of words.

It pretty much all is speculative aside from arguing about whether or not that speculation is based on factual premises.

When it comes to whether BANAL-52 or RaTG13 is closest to SARS-CoV2, the authors of the preprint say it is, according to their analysis of the genome.

This leads to the conclusion that there could be similar viruses across a wide area.
 
I assume this report from US Intelligence has been discussed already. Forgive me for not reading the whole thread:
It's been posted but seems to be ignored and not discussed. I think because it, in a nutshell, says the same thing that Dr Sid said most recently just a few posts up. I'll paraphrase my own version: "There simply isn't enough known to come to a conclusion right now".
 
I assume this report from US Intelligence has been discussed already. Forgive me for not reading the whole thread:

https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/Declassified-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins.pdf
It has been discussed, and the excerpt you quoted has been quoted, but substantive matters are often buried in an avalanche of noise. That's why reading this entire thread would be madness.

Over 33% of the posts in this thread were contributed by a single person, and a substantial fraction of the other posts are responding to something that person has posted.

The following examples come from a single post.

I have posted a wide array of sources that include a number of different avenues of investigation.
That is true. Skeptic Ginger's sources include such diverse personalities as poet Amber Marie Young and "serial entrepreneur" Dr Steven Quay, whose efforts to monetize the COVID pandemic include a "COVID-19 Survival Manual" you can buy for $14.99. According to Dr Quay, that book is "chock-full of lifesaving tips you can’t find anywhere else", such as his tip that you should wear a mask. ("Learn the #1 most effective way to prevent the spread of coronavirus as we reopen society (Hint: it’s the one thing the CDC said was “NOT effective” when coronavirus hit the U.S.)")

As for imagining a scenario where they simply haven't tested enough animals, that's classic confirmation bias. You are again trying to make the evidence fit your preconceived conclusion. It is not how one tests an hypothesis.
An even better example of classic confirmation bias is cherry-picking a single sentence in support of the uncontroversial fact that "researchers in China have tested more than 80,000 wild and domesticated animals" without quoting the following two sentences that say "more strategic testing is needed to isolate animals that are most susceptible to infection and those that come in close contact with people", and then accusing people who quote the full context of being guilty of "classic confirmation bias."

We are not forced to speculate. We can just do nothing. Which is exactly what we should be doing without any new information.
Yep.
 
It has been discussed, and the excerpt you quoted has been quoted, but substantive matters are often buried in an avalanche of noise. That's why reading this entire thread would be madness.

Yeah, I participated in the thread at one point earlier, but eventually bowed out because it reached an impasse and cannot be settled conclusively either way without substantial additional evidence.

I expect that evidence may come eventually, but in the meantime I will focus my limited attention elsewhere and wait for that evidence to arrive.
 
Yeah, I participated in the thread at one point earlier, but eventually bowed out because it reached an impasse and cannot be settled conclusively either way without substantial additional evidence.

I expect that evidence may come eventually, but in the meantime I will focus my limited attention elsewhere and wait for that evidence to arrive.

I believe the Evidence may come from a Bat Species native to Wuhan China, that is in a place that is not reachable by Human researchers.
That would explain, everything as bats pee in flight and Urine could have gotten into someone's face and caused the infection totally Zoologically.
 
I believe the Evidence may come from a Bat Species native to Wuhan China, that is in a place that is not reachable by Human researchers.
That would explain, everything as bats pee in flight and Urine could have gotten into someone's face and caused the infection totally Zoologically.

If that were the scenario, it could have happened just about anywhere in China or Southeast Asia, but by coincidence it just happened to occur right at a wet market in Wuhan or in the neighborhood of the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Pretty strange coincidence. Not saying it's impossible, but the circumstantial evidence seems to suggest either a connection with the wet market or with the WIV.
 
I assume this report from US Intelligence has been discussed already. Forgive me for not reading the whole thread:

https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/Declassified-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins.pdf

There is no consensus in the US Intelligence Community regarding the origins, except on a few points:

Other than on those questions, they seem to be divided on whether an accidental lab leak or natural origin scenario is more plausible. I suppose you could say that they lean toward natural origin (4 agencies lean that way, 1 leans the other way, and 3 others are divided and think more information is needed).
There is no reason to read this whole thread. :)

There has been nothing that could settle the origin debate between lab and spillover.

I do think that we should take the '4 lean toward natural spillover' with a grain of salt because of the successful effort of Daszak to portray the lab leak for more than a year as a far-fetched CT. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, the WHO director-general, noted Daszak made those assertions without any investigation at all, let alone finding evidence ruling the lab out.

It's quite awful to think this came from a lab and that alone makes some people want to see the spillover origin. It has taken a while for more and more scientists to move toward the middle.


It's been posted but seems to be ignored and not discussed. I think because it, in a nutshell, says the same thing that Dr Sid said most recently just a few posts up. I'll paraphrase my own version: "There simply isn't enough known to come to a conclusion right now".
Not ignored at all. I've said it repeatedly. I do think the evidence is stronger on the lab leak side but that doesn't mean I think it is proven.


Yeah, I participated in the thread at one point earlier, but eventually bowed out because it reached an impasse and cannot be settled conclusively either way without substantial additional evidence.

I expect that evidence may come eventually, but in the meantime I will focus my limited attention elsewhere and wait for that evidence to arrive.
The only new evidence of any significance is that after 2 years of intensive search, no natural source has been found.

And documents have come to light proving Daszak asked for NIH funding for GoF research with coronaviruses. There's a bit worth looking at there.

Angrysoba thinks the coronavirus finds in the Laos cave(s) are significant.


If that were the scenario, it could have happened just about anywhere in China or Southeast Asia, but by coincidence it just happened to occur right at a wet market in Wuhan or in the neighborhood of the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Pretty strange coincidence. Not saying it's impossible, but the circumstantial evidence seems to suggest either a connection with the wet market or with the WIV.
With a different wet market, yes, absolutely. But no wet markets have been clearly connected to the first cases. The seafood wet market was a super-spreader source but the earliest cases had not been there.

Nonetheless some natural source has not been ruled out by any evidence.
 
Last edited:
Okay, maybe a bad choice of words.

It pretty much all is speculative aside from arguing about whether or not that speculation is based on factual premises.

When it comes to whether BANAL-52 or RaTG13 is closest to SARS-CoV2, the authors of the preprint say it is, according to their analysis of the genome.

This leads to the conclusion that there could be similar viruses across a wide area.
I think that conclusion, "there could be similar viruses across a wide area" was already a given. The arguments that this or that genetic segment of COVID couldn't be found in nature was dismissed long ago as very weak argument or no argument at all.

But your insistence it's significant that a coronavirus 0.8% closer genetically than the Ra13TG strain, located in Laos further away than Yunnan, is not significant.
 
Last edited:
I think that conclusion, "there could be similar viruses across a wide area" was already a given. The arguments that this or that genetic segment of COVID couldn't be found in nature was dismissed long ago as very weak argument or no argument at all.

It's the argument that Dr Quay and others (such as those in DRASTIC) have been making for a long time and continue to make.

As has been pointed out, you keep linking to those sources and they build their arguments on the claim that SARS-CoV2 was a product of some kind of genetic engineering. They may have conceded that the RBD exists in nature, but they still claim the furin cleavage site was inserted. They point to the grant application for spraying bat caves as evidence that they were very interested in furin cleavage sites.

But your insistence it's significant that a coronavirus 0.8% closer genetically than the Ra13TG strain, located in Laos further away than Yunnan, is not significant.

Thank you. I have been trying to correct you on this since you initially claimed this...

There's nothing closer than Ra13TG in the bats if that is the reservoir species.

That's what makes this thread so needlessly long.
 
It's the argument that Dr Quay and others (such as those in DRASTIC) have been making for a long time and continue to make.

As has been pointed out, you keep linking to those sources and they build their arguments on the claim that SARS-CoV2 was a product of some kind of genetic engineering. They may have conceded that the RBD exists in nature, but they still claim the furin cleavage site was inserted. They point to the grant application for spraying bat caves as evidence that they were very interested in furin cleavage sites.
Oh for pity's sake. Are you conflating everything I've ever posted in this debate with your favorite hand-waving-away smears?

I've posted a ton of stuff, much of which you don't even read calling them gish gallops when in reality they are simply tl;dr for your taste.

I thought that spraying genetic segments or whatever into the Yunnan caves was too odd for me to make much sense of at this point. Daszak/Shi wanted to do something along that line but I don't see it was ever carried out or even developed fully, at least in the literature. There are no posts of mine here using that as any kind of significant evidence or argument.

You would do well to simply read the posts I've summarized my evidence points in. Stop trying to smear me when you can't actually address the arguments I've put forward. It's really poor debate form.


Thank you. I have been trying to correct you on this since you initially claimed this...
That's a lot of effort over a 0.8% difference in a genome that is only in the 96% similar range to begin with.

My posts on this have been in response to your assertions the Laos cave findings were a very close recent ancestor of COVID. I believe you made an unsupported claim the Laos coronavirus strain was only a decade or so removed in terms of genetic changes needed to get to the COVID genetics. And that's ********.

Cross talk is all this was:
You claiming the Laos coronavirus finds were close to the genetics of COVID
Me pointing out to you the gene segments matching COVID were in different coronaviruses
You continuing to claim a close genetic match to COVID was found
Me pointing out segments segments segments because 0.8% difference wasn't significant and it wasn't something that made much of an argument
You now ignoring all that and making it sound like I didn't recognize the whole genome of one of the strains was a 0.8% closer match than Ra13TG​


That's what makes this thread so needlessly long.
What's making it needlessly long is you attacking me instead of addressing the actual evidence.

If you clarified your claim to say you recognize the Laos strain was lass than 1% closer than the Ra13TG, it would have shortened the debate. Instead you kept insisting the Laos strain was some sort of close match when it wasn't.

Like I said, crosstalk.
 
That's a lot of effort over a 0.8% difference in a genome that is only in the 96% similar range to begin with.

You are correct that it takes a lot of effort for you to concede the point. But if you will make it difficult, what is the alternative? To allow you to state things that are untrue? No, sorry.

My posts on this have been in response to your assertions the Laos cave findings were a very close recent ancestor of COVID. I believe you made an unsupported claim the Laos coronavirus strain was only a decade or so removed in terms of genetic changes needed to get to the COVID genetics. And that's ********.

Cross talk is all this was:
You claiming the Laos coronavirus finds were close to the genetics of COVID
Me pointing out to you the gene segments matching COVID were in different coronaviruses
You continuing to claim a close genetic match to COVID was found
Me pointing out segments segments segments because 0.8% difference wasn't significant and it wasn't something that made much of an argument
You now ignoring all that and making it sound like I didn't recognize the whole genome of one of the strains was a 0.8% closer match than Ra13TG​

You didn't recognize it. That is the point.


What's making it needlessly long is you attacking me instead of addressing the actual evidence.

If you clarified your claim to say you recognize the Laos strain was lass than 1% closer than the Ra13TG, it would have shortened the debate. Instead you kept insisting the Laos strain was some sort of close match when it wasn't.

Like I said, crosstalk.

Why should I have clarified my claim? Your claim was that RaTG13 was closer. I pointed out this was incorrect. Then we had several goes round the mulberry bush where you tried to say it was only segments of the virus etc...

You then make it sound like I was mistaken for not "clarifying" that while you were wrong, you were less then 1% out. That's just silly. You know it is silly, but you double down and triple down and quadruple down and then take it personally when all you needed to have said was, "Oh yeah, you are right!"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom