Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.


Rand Paul brings up the 80,000 animals thing and says outright that it was a lab leak and Fauci's NIH funded gain of function research that led to the outbreak of Covid-19.

Fauci responds to a few points of Paul's Gish Gallop, saying that most virologists believe it is likely of natural origin, not a lab leak and that they did not fund GOF in Wuhan.

Paul of course twists Fauci's words over and over again, as he has done throughout this.
 


Rand Paul brings up the 80,000 animals thing and says outright that it was a lab leak and Fauci's NIH funded gain of function research that led to the outbreak of Covid-19.

Fauci responds to a few points of Paul's Gish Gallop, saying that most virologists believe it is likely of natural origin, not a lab leak and that they did not fund GOF in Wuhan.

Paul of course twists Fauci's words over and over again, as he has done throughout this.

Isn't it just pedantism to say that it was not gain of function research?


It's stipulated by all involved that they did in fact fund research in Wuhan.

So now it's an argument over the definition of a term.
 
If that were the scenario, it could have happened just about anywhere in China or Southeast Asia, but by coincidence it just happened to occur right at a wet market in Wuhan or in the neighborhood of the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Pretty strange coincidence. Not saying it's impossible, but the circumstantial evidence seems to suggest either a connection with the wet market or with the WIV.

Insects fly above wet markets and Bats eat Insects, does that fulfill your coincidence clause?
 
Isn't it just pedantism to say that it was not gain of function research?


It's stipulated by all involved that they did in fact fund research in Wuhan.

So now it's an argument over the definition of a term.

Maybe, but maybe the definitions matter.

Clearly the point here is that Rand Paul wants to accuse Fauci, and the NIH in general, of doing something illegal.
 
If that were the scenario, it could have happened just about anywhere in China or Southeast Asia, but by coincidence it just happened to occur right at a wet market in Wuhan or in the neighborhood of the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Pretty strange coincidence. Not saying it's impossible, but the circumstantial evidence seems to suggest either a connection with the wet market or with the WIV.

True, but in more isolated regions it could have just petered out unnoticed without enough people getting sick enough to be noticeable and without the opportunity for forward transmission.

However, in a big city, with many more people and the possibility of superspreader events, the virus could have taken hold much better and had more opportunities for forward transmission.

This is at least a theory by Michael Worobey, and I think a lot of virologists agree that the logic makes sense.
 
True, but in more isolated regions it could have just petered out unnoticed without enough people getting sick enough to be noticeable and without the opportunity for forward transmission.

However, in a big city, with many more people and the possibility of superspreader events, the virus could have taken hold much better and had more opportunities for forward transmission.

This is at least a theory by Michael Worobey, and I think a lot of virologists agree that the logic makes sense.

Also it being a Coincidence has nothing to do with the Scientific validity of a theory, one bat Urinating in Flight could have been the start of this pandemic.
It just happened to do so in Wuhan also bats excrete Saliva when they feed, maybe Wet markets should be closed or covered when bats are feeding?
 
Also it being a Coincidence has nothing to do with the Scientific validity of a theory, one bat Urinating in Flight could have been the start of this pandemic.
It just happened to do so in Wuhan also bats excrete Saliva when they feed, maybe Wet markets should be closed or covered when bats are feeding?

There are many different possibilities for how the virus could have spilled over and right now we simply don't know.

I really do recommend David Quammen's book, Spillover, though. It goes into the difficulties of how to trace a virus and of how much luck can play a part. It also talks about how lab leaks can and have occurred.

https://www.amazon.com/Spillover-Animal-Infections-Human-Pandemic/dp/0393066800
 
There are many different possibilities for how the virus could have spilled over and right now we simply don't know.

I really do recommend David Quammen's book, Spillover, though. It goes into the difficulties of how to trace a virus and of how much luck can play a part. It also talks about how lab leaks can and have occurred.

https://www.amazon.com/Spillover-Animal-Infections-Human-Pandemic/dp/0393066800

I worry about the spread and Mutations of this virus in Kentucky we seem to have the perfect Environment for it's spread.
We can't even find the end to Mammoth Cave, which has it's own bat population.

http://images.app.goo.gl/sTCgBHokHu2Y65cy6
 
To be fair, much of it you didn't read either.
I read what I post and you don't know any different. You on the other hand admit to not reading what I cite.

The problem here is I try to fully back up what I assert or more commonly what corroborates the evidence I post. To call thorough support of evidence a gish-gallop is bizarre.

Another problem is back at the beginning of the thread a lot of things were coming out from different sources. I posted a lot of it. Eventually some was corroborated some wasn't. And some that wasn't hasn't been refuted while some has.

It's difficult to assess and discuss some of the evidence because it does indeed come from right-wing sources. Dump is responsible for interfering in the science debate with his ignorant attack on China. But some of the evidence on right-wing sources has been corroborated. To hand-wave all that away based on the source does not move this debate forward. It demonstrates an unwillingness to consider all the evidence.



How about a discussion of just the arguments for and against without any hand-waving away based on sources? If the evidence promoted by a right wing source is indeed specious, say how and why the evidence is faulty, rather than dismissing it without consideration. Can we start with your arguments for a spillover event and address mine later? It will keep the discussion cleaner.

Also I kindly ask that you try to avoid fitting some hypothesis to the evidence. State your hypothesis first then say what backs that up. For example if you hypothesize a virus spread from a Laos cave to a human who then flew to Wuhan without infecting anyone in Laos or anyone on the plane, what evidence supports that?

If you don't want a clean, evidence based debate, that's fine, it's up to you.


Here are the evidence supported arguments I believe you have made and the problems with some of them:

1) Natural spillovers are well known to occur and some researchers believe there are many of these which burn out before they get started. There is evidence from close monitoring of flu strains around the world that many do indeed burn themselves out. The virus strains infect people who are in close contact with a source but the virus is not well adapted to humans. The result is the infected person doesn't shed a lot of virus. The strain may spread to a family member in close contact but no human to human transmission goes beyond that.

It takes adaptive mutations, plural, in the new host (in this case the new human host) to move from spillover to active human to human transmission. The virus doesn't make some one-off mutation in the origin host species that just happens to infect a person that just happens to acquire another mutation which takes it from silent spreading to an epidemic.

When the spread is undetected at first it's not likely to become deadly with rapid spread seemingly coming out of nowhere. Rapid spreading and significant lethality take different mutations. Again, this doesn't occur with magical one-off mutations, plural, that come out of the blue. These mutations occur as the virus circulates in the new host. Some of the mutations may have occurred as the virus circulated in the original species.

As the virus becomes more lethal, that also doesn't happen all at once with a single mutation.

Then there are the viral strains that are adapted to both the origin species and the new host species it spills over to from the beginning. This has been suggested could have occurred with COVID.

That's true but if so then a very close common ancestor population should exist in at least a small colony of the host species. Again it isn't going to spillover ready to go without a source population where the virus is circulating.


2) The closest common ancestor genetically is not close enough and it was found 2300 kilometers away in Laos. It could have arrived by air, but you would still expect to see cases along the way. In this case besides a much closer common ancestor you'd be seeing cases locally in Laos.


3) You appear to trust what Daszak and Shi said. They are proven liars with serious conflicts of interest. Maybe you've changed that position.

So Daszak and Shi vs right-wing sources with their own conflict of interest as China bashers are a wash. Evidence from either source needs to be corroborated but not hand-waved away.


What other arguments of yours have I missed? Let's discuss the above and any other arguments of yours I've missed, please without muddying things up with attacks on me, my other arguments, or my sources. The idea is to get back to the actual evidence based debate and away from irrelevant side issues. I'll list my arguments and rebuttals in the next segment of this debate.
 
You are correct that it takes a lot of effort for you to concede the point. ...
Sidenote unrelated to my last post: You want me to concede an irrelevant point? Whatever. I was pointing out it wasn't relevant because it wasn't a serious common ancestor while you were insisting 0.8% more similar was significant.

That's crosstalk.
 


Rand Paul brings up the 80,000 animals thing and says outright that it was a lab leak and Fauci's NIH funded gain of function research that led to the outbreak of Covid-19....
Rand Paul repeating the 80,000 animals tested isn't the source of that evidence. That he's using it in a Congressional hearing isn't relevant.
 
I read what I post and you don't know any different. You on the other hand admit to not reading what I cite.

The problem here is I try to fully back up what I assert or more commonly what corroborates the evidence I post. To call thorough support of evidence a gish-gallop is bizarre.

Another problem is back at the beginning of the thread a lot of things were coming out from different sources. I posted a lot of it. Eventually some was corroborated some wasn't. And some that wasn't hasn't been refuted while some has.

It's difficult to assess and discuss some of the evidence because it does indeed come from right-wing sources. Dump is responsible for interfering in the science debate with his ignorant attack on China. But some of the evidence on right-wing sources has been corroborated. To hand-wave all that away based on the source does not move this debate forward. It demonstrates an unwillingness to consider all the evidence.



How about a discussion of just the arguments for and against without any hand-waving away based on sources? If the evidence promoted by a right wing source is indeed specious, say how and why the evidence is faulty, rather than dismissing it without consideration. Can we start with your arguments for a spillover event and address mine later? It will keep the discussion cleaner.

Also I kindly ask that you try to avoid fitting some hypothesis to the evidence. State your hypothesis first then say what backs that up. For example if you hypothesize a virus spread from a Laos cave to a human who then flew to Wuhan without infecting anyone in Laos or anyone on the plane, what evidence supports that?

If you don't want a clean, evidence based debate, that's fine, it's up to you.


Here are the evidence supported arguments I believe you have made and the problems with some of them:

1) Natural spillovers are well known to occur and some researchers believe there are many of these which burn out before they get started. There is evidence from close monitoring of flu strains around the world that many do indeed burn themselves out. The virus strains infect people who are in close contact with a source but the virus is not well adapted to humans. The result is the infected person doesn't shed a lot of virus. The strain may spread to a family member in close contact but no human to human transmission goes beyond that.

It takes adaptive mutations, plural, in the new host (in this case the new human host) to move from spillover to active human to human transmission. The virus doesn't make some one-off mutation in the origin host species that just happens to infect a person that just happens to acquire another mutation which takes it from silent spreading to an epidemic.

When the spread is undetected at first it's not likely to become deadly with rapid spread seemingly coming out of nowhere. Rapid spreading and significant lethality take different mutations. Again, this doesn't occur with magical one-off mutations, plural, that come out of the blue. These mutations occur as the virus circulates in the new host. Some of the mutations may have occurred as the virus circulated in the original species.

As the virus becomes more lethal, that also doesn't happen all at once with a single mutation.

Then there are the viral strains that are adapted to both the origin species and the new host species it spills over to from the beginning. This has been suggested could have occurred with COVID.

That's true but if so then a very close common ancestor population should exist in at least a small colony of the host species. Again it isn't going to spillover ready to go without a source population where the virus is circulating.


2) The closest common ancestor genetically is not close enough and it was found 2300 kilometers away in Laos. It could have arrived by air, but you would still expect to see cases along the way. In this case besides a much closer common ancestor you'd be seeing cases locally in Laos.


3) You appear to trust what Daszak and Shi said. They are proven liars with serious conflicts of interest. Maybe you've changed that position.

So Daszak and Shi vs right-wing sources with their own conflict of interest as China bashers are a wash. Evidence from either source needs to be corroborated but not hand-waved away.


What other arguments of yours have I missed? Let's discuss the above and any other arguments of yours I've missed, please without muddying things up with attacks on me, my other arguments, or my sources. The idea is to get back to the actual evidence based debate and away from irrelevant side issues. I'll list my arguments and rebuttals in the next segment of this debate.

There is too much here to address individually.

I will briefly explain why I think the evidence fits the spillover theory:

1.) This is the opinion of the majority of the experts in the virology community from what I can see. This is important because nobody can be an expert in everything, so just as I have not done any first-hand testing of whether or not climate change has been caused by human action, and just as I have not been able to personally do the tests on whether or not vaccines are safe and effective, and just as I cannot know from my personal observations, the nature of black holes, so I have to have some trust in people who are experts in their field.

2.) Conversely the vast majority of the people arguing the opposite are either not experts in their field, seem to have some seriously glaringly bad arguments (Dr Quay and his "Bayesian analysis" doesn't seem to have any clear sign of how he worked anything out and is written like he doesn't know what a paper should even look like - the Irish Journal of Medicine letter about Wuhan which you defended as a pilot study, an epidemiological study etc... which even lowly old me was able to debunk by following her method but using non-cherry-picked data), or are very obviously right-wing ideologues with seriously dubious motives, or some feuding academics like Richard Ebright who has hated GoF for decades and has been making actual conspiracy theory claims against everyone from Peter Daszak to Anthony Fauci to even David Quammen - author of that book that I "claimed" to have read, etc... or they are the usual "heterodox" bunch of - yes, conspiracy theorists - such as Bret Weinstein, and increasingly it has become clear that many of them are also anti-vaxxers.

You may question whether that is a good way to judge what is correct, to judge whether I should trust established scientists or a bunch of loons and to say, sorry, I think I'll go with the scientists, but that's pretty much how it is.

Could it be that the loons are right? Sure, it is possible. And bear in mind that sometimes the scientists can be mistaken. Also, it is important that many of the scientists do say that the chances of the lab leak are not zero, that maybe they are 10% or so.

I haven't completely made up my mind. I think it is possible that it was a lab leak. I certainly would like to see more co-operation and openness from China, but Communist China is what it is. But the arguments I have seen so far shift rationale so much only to conclude the same way. Some people just want a lab leak, I guess.
 
A "closest common ancestor" in Laos error

Persists with irrelevant fantasies about Shi and Daszak.
Repeating fantasies does not make Shi into a liar.
Has anyone seen any any quote "claiming there were no in vitro CoV cultures at the WIV" from Shi?

Influenza viruses have adapted well enough to humans to kill millions of people over the years. Spanish flu killed at least 17 million people and may have killed 100 million people. A typical flu season kills 290,000–650,000 people a year.
Influenza is only spread in the same way as SARS-Cov-2. Anyone can contact the flu from an infected person who breathes, talks, coughs or sneezes close to to them. That is why people are asked to distance themselves and wear masks.
A vague "one-off mutation" claim. Viruses nutate continuously. SARS-Cov-2 probably come from an animal reservoir that has infected people before and can infect them again.

A "The closest common ancestor genetically is not close enough and it was found 2300 kilometers away in Laos." error. No common ancestor was found. What was found was a virus in bats from Laos that was a bit closer generically to SARS-CoV-2 than other sources. This is evidence that SARS-CoV-2 came from those bats, not the WIV lab.
 
Persists with irrelevant fantasies about Shi and Daszak.
Repeating fantasies does not make Shi into a liar.
Has anyone seen any any quote "claiming there were no in vitro CoV cultures at the WIV" from Shi?

Influenza viruses have adapted well enough to humans to kill millions of people over the years. Spanish flu killed at least 17 million people and may have killed 100 million people. A typical flu season kills 290,000–650,000 people a year.
Influenza is only spread in the same way as SARS-Cov-2. Anyone can contact the flu from an infected person who breathes, talks, coughs or sneezes close to to them. That is why people are asked to distance themselves and wear masks.
A vague "one-off mutation" claim. Viruses nutate continuously. SARS-Cov-2 probably come from an animal reservoir that has infected people before and can infect them again.

A "The closest common ancestor genetically is not close enough and it was found 2300 kilometers away in Laos." error. No common ancestor was found. What was found was a virus in bats from Laos that was a bit closer generically to SARS-CoV-2 than other sources. This is evidence that SARS-CoV-2 came from those bats, not the WIV lab.

Actually direct human to animal spread of the virus, kinda proves it could have spread from Bats to Humans without an Intermediate species involved that Makes Bat to Human more Likely.
 
but by coincidence it just happened to occur right at a wet market in Wuhan or in the neighborhood of the Wuhan Institute of Virology.


But the Wuhan Institute of Virology isn't particularly close at all, and the level 4 lab is much farther that that from where the epicenter of the outbreak. It's clear that both cases and deaths started well away from the lab on the other side of the river and slowly spread towards it. Not what you'd expect from a lab leak.


In response to this the "it's a lab leak" crowd decided that it must be a different lab, but in that case there are BSL 2 and BSL 3 labs everywhere so it's no coincidence at all that there was one nearby.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom