Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, the US intelligence report has been released on origins of Covid.

I guess I will look through it later:

https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/Declassified-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins.pdf


Key Takeaways:
The IC assesses that SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, probably emerged and infected humans through an initial small-scale exposure that occurred no later than November 2019 with the first known cluster of COVID-19 cases arising in Wuhan, China in December 2019. In addition, the IC was able to reach broad agreement on several other key issues. We judge the virus was not developed as a biological weapon. Most agencies also assess with low confidence that SARS-CoV-2 probably was not genetically engineered; however, two agencies believe there was not sufficient evidence to make an assessment either way. Finally, the IC assesses China’s officials did not have foreknowledge of the virus before the initial outbreak of COVID-19 emerged.

After examining all available intelligence reporting and other information, though, the IC remains divided on the most likely origin of COVID-19. All agencies assess that two hypotheses are plausible: natural exposure to an infected animal and a laboratory-associated incident.

...(snipped four bullets summarizing unnamed agencies' opinions)...

The IC judges they will be unable to provide a more definitive explanation for the origin of COVID-19 unless new information allows them to determine the specific pathway for initial natural contact with an animal or to determine that a laboratory in Wuhan was handling SARS-CoV-2 or a close progenitor virus before COVID-19 emerged.
 
Well, the US intelligence report has been released on origins of Covid.

I guess I will look through it later:

https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/Declassified-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins.pdf

Supports everything I've been saying. It looks thorough and very fair in how it assesses the evidence.

I notice the genetic findings in the Laos coronavirus strains aren't in the report. Nonetheless they still don't match closely enough to be considered a precursor strain.
 
Supports everything I've been saying. It looks thorough and very fair in how it assesses the evidence.

I notice the genetic findings in the Laos coronavirus strains aren't in the report. Nonetheless they still don't match closely enough to be considered a precursor strain.

The Laos viruses were not known about then obviously otherwise they would have been in that table. Literally nobody is considering the virus to be a “precursor strain”, to say that misses the significance which is that of the RBD and other similarities to SARS-CoV2.
 
The Laos viruses were not known about then obviously otherwise they would have been in that table. Literally nobody is considering the virus to be a “precursor strain”, to say that misses the significance which is that of the RBD and other similarities to SARS-CoV2.
I didn't miss the significance, I pointed out it was being exaggerated.

You said:
No, RaTG13 is several decades removed from SARS-CoV2, whereas BANAL-52 and the other Laos viruses could well be much closer to SARS-CoV2 temporally

The actual % of the full genome of BANAL-52 is only 0.7% closer: 96.1% vs 96.8%.

LiveScience; Sept 2021: Viruses found in Laos bats are closest known relatives to SARS-CoV-2
One of the viruses, BANAL-52, was 96.8% identical to SARS-CoV-2, according to Nature News. That makes BANAL-52 more genetically similar to SARS-CoV-2 than any other known virus. Previously, the closest known relative to SARS-CoV-2 was RaTG13, which was found in horseshoe bats in 2013 and shares 96.1% of its genome with SARS-CoV-2, Nature News reported.


The point is it is an exaggeration to claim the Laos viruses are "much closer". The authors of the preprint implied a similar exaggeration of the findings with which science reporters followed suit.

But in peer review, here is the first comment:
Monali Rahalkar
commented on 18 September, 2021
The overall genome genome similarity between BANAL strains and SARS CoV2 should have been stated right in the abstract or at least in the results section. From the tree it looks like RaTG13 is still the closest genomic neighbor. There is only mention of the closeness of RBD, but to maintain clarity it should be stated how close are these overall to Sarscov2. Please make this change in the final format. Also, a table with similarities with all related strains would help.
 
Supports everything I've been saying. It looks thorough and very fair in how it assesses the evidence.

Supports everything I've been saying as well.

Surprising how easy it is to reach areas of agreement when we focus upon accepted facts, as reported by sources that have little or no emotional commitment to particular conclusions, and must defend their work to peers.
 
I didn't miss the significance, I pointed out it was being exaggerated.

You said:
No, RaTG13 is several decades removed from SARS-CoV2, whereas BANAL-52 and the other Laos viruses could well be much closer to SARS-CoV2 temporally
The actual % of the full genome of BANAL-52 is only 0.7% closer: 96.1% vs 96.8%.

Please re-read what I wrote before you leap all over it. "Much closer" temporally. The word "temporally" means "in time", so the percentage of the genome is irrelevant.

RaTG13 is decades removed.
BANAL-52 may be less than a decade.

Please acknowledge and fix your false criticism.

LiveScience; Sept 2021: Viruses found in Laos bats are closest known relatives to SARS-CoV-2



The point is it is an exaggeration to claim the Laos viruses are "much closer". The authors of the preprint implied a similar exaggeration of the findings with which science reporters followed suit.

But in peer review, here is the first comment:
Monali Rahalkar
The overall genome genome similarity between BANAL strains and SARS CoV2 should have been stated right in the abstract or at least in the results section. From the tree it looks like RaTG13 is still the closest genomic neighbor. There is only mention of the closeness of RBD, but to maintain clarity it should be stated how close are these overall to Sarscov2. Please make this change in the final format. Also, a table with similarities with all related strains would help.

Sorry, but what???

Monali Rahalkar is a member of DRASTIC. Are you saying she is one of the peer reviewers of the study?

Peer review is, as you surely know, anonymous. So why would she be attaching her name to the peer review? Could you tell me where you found this comment? If it was a comment under the pre-print then this is not peer-review.
 
Please re-read what I wrote before you leap all over it. "Much closer" temporally. The word "temporally" means "in time", so the percentage of the genome is irrelevant.

RaTG13 is decades removed.
BANAL-52 may be less than a decade.

Please acknowledge and fix your false criticism.

Sorry, but what???

Monali Rahalkar is a member of DRASTIC. Are you saying she is one of the peer reviewers of the study?

Peer review is, as you surely know, anonymous. So why would she be attaching her name to the peer review? Could you tell me where you found this comment? If it was a comment under the pre-print then this is not peer-review.
It wasn't a false statement. You haven't supported anything that suggests the genetic changes needed to go from decades to less than a decade. You'd need to show that recombinant events were going like gangbusters in those Laos caves and at least a semblance of a trail to Wuhan to support your temporal estimate.

The problem here is similar to your other one where you simply ignored the relevant background on spillovers and asserted your own version without supporting it.


You think no one from DRASTIC could be a peer reviewer? It doesn't have to be formal or official to be a peer review. Dr Rahalkar agrees with my assessment the text overstates the findings.

Biography - Dr. Monali C. Rahalkar
Her Education & Scientific Career: Postdoctoral research fellow in University of Bremen, Germany (2007-2009), Doctorate in Microbial Ecology, University of Konstanz, Germany (2003-2007), Junior Research Fellow (CSIR) in Division of Biochemical Sciences, NCL, Pune (2001-2003), Project Assistant in Division of Biochemical Sciences, NCL, Pune (1999-2000), MSc in Microbiology (1997-99) University of Pune, BSc in Microbiology (1994-97) University of Pune.
 
Last edited:
It wasn't a false statement. You haven't supported anything that suggests the genetic changes needed to go from decades to less than a decade. You'd need to show that recombinant events were going like gangbusters in those Laos caves and at least a semblance of a trail to Wuhan to support your temporal estimate.

The problem here is similar to your other one where you simply ignored the relevant background on spillovers and asserted your own version without supporting it.

It was absolutely false. Look again at what you wrote:

The actual % of the full genome of BANAL-52 is only 0.7% closer: 96.1% vs 96.8%.

When I said "much closer" I was not talking about the percentage of the genome but the amount of time from the most recent common ancestor. That was absolutely clear to anyone who read my post properly. You clearly did not otherwise you would have seen I wasn't talking about "much closer" in terms of proportion. So yes, you were making a false statement.

Last year, researchers described another close relative of SARS-CoV-2, called RaTG13, which was found in bats in Yunnan5. It is 96.1% identical to SARS-CoV-2 overall and the two viruses probably shared a common ancestor 40–70 years ago6. BANAL-52 is 96.8% identical to SARS-CoV-2, says Eloit — and all three newly discovered viruses have individual sections that are more similar to sections of SARS-CoV-2 than seen in any other viruses.

...

Viruses swap chunks of RNA with one another through a process called recombination, and one section in BANAL-103 and BANAL-52 could have shared an ancestor with sections of SARS-CoV-2 less than a decade ago, says Spyros Lytras, an evolutionary virologist at the University of Glasgow. “These viruses recombine so much that different bits of the genome have different evolutionary histories,” he says.

Link


You think no one from DRASTIC could be a peer reviewer? It doesn't have to be formal or official to be a peer review. Dr Rahalkar agrees with my assessment the text overstates the findings.

Biography - Dr. Monali C. Rahalkar

Again, this is only if you don't understand the significance of the findings. The RBD was one of the main areas that people argued was evidence of lab manipulation.

The finding of the virus showed what many of the natural origins proponents had already claimed, that the lab was not necessary to put the RBD there.
 
Anyway, as I stated before, the reason why the Laotian viruses were not there was because they were not known about when the assessment by US intelligence was being made so it didn't appear in the report.

Is that correct or not?
 
Anyway, as I stated before, the reason why the Laotian viruses were not there was because they were not known about when the assessment by US intelligence was being made so it didn't appear in the report.

Is that correct or not?
It appears so, so what? You seem to think the Laos cave specimens have more significance than they actually do.

Unless you can show how said viruses or gene segments got into a virus that appeared in Wuhan, it's not very meaningful.

Sometime back in this thread certain citations were professing the finding or this or that feature of COVID not being found in the wild was evidence COVID was engineered in a lab. That argument was dismissed shortly after. No one is making it here (in this thread anyway).

What you have in the Laos cave coronaviruses is another piece of evidence refuting what has already been refuted.
 
It appears so, so what? You seem to think the Laos cave specimens have more significance than they actually do.

Okay, I "seem to think" it is more significant. You seem to think it is less significant.

If a virus was found that was, say, 98% similar to SARS-CoV2 would you then think it was significant?

If a virus was found that had the same furin cleavage site would you then think it was significant?

I don't know what you think is significant.

Unless you can show how said viruses or gene segments got into a virus that appeared in Wuhan, it's not very meaningful.

You see, I think it is meaningul.

Why? Because knowing that they exist in nature and in a place that is unlikely to have been sampled by the WIV itself suggests that those viruses were not taken back to the WIV and then released.

Sometime back in this thread certain citations were professing the finding or this or that feature of COVID not being found in the wild was evidence COVID was engineered in a lab. That argument was dismissed shortly after. No one is making it here (in this thread anyway).

What you have in the Laos cave coronaviruses is another piece of evidence refuting what has already been refuted.

From what I can see, Dr Quay and various others in DRASTIC absolutely still do believe there is some kind of engineering or manipulation involved.

In fact, you MUST do too otherwise why are you talking about this "straight out of the box" point?
 
Sometime back in this thread certain citations were professing the finding or this or that feature of COVID not being found in the wild was evidence COVID was engineered in a lab. That argument was dismissed shortly after. No one is making it here (in this thread anyway).


According to the archives of this thread, someone cited a recent WSJ opinion piece by Richard Muller and Steven Quay in which they continued to argue that this or that feature of COVID not being found in the wild was evidence COVID was engineered in a lab.

Most of that article is behind a paywall, but there has been some open discussion of its errors, as in this opinion piece, which is more balanced than some will conclude from these cherry-picked paragraphs:
A number of virologists and other relevant experts denounced the article, including Purdue University professor David Sanders, who called me to detail what he described as pseudoscientific claims and nonsensical technical language.

...snip...

One problem with the Journal column by Muller and Quay is that it conflated the idea of a lab leak with the theory that the virus was altered in the lab. The crux of their argument was that the virus started out unusually adapted to replicating in humans, and therefore was unlikely to have jumped directly from another species.

According to Sanders, that assertion “is simply wrong and silly and unscientific.” He said that though he’s a virologist, he didn’t know what the authors meant by the claim that the virus was “99.5% optimized for human infection.” The problem wasn’t just that the number was questionable, but that virology doesn’t recognize optimization as a measurable, quantifiable property at all. “I don’t know what 99.5% optimized could possibly mean,” he told me.
 
Please re-read what I wrote before you leap all over it. "Much closer" temporally. The word "temporally" means "in time", so the percentage of the genome is irrelevant.

RaTG13 is decades removed.
BANAL-52 may be less than a decade.

IMO it's more accurate to say that one of BANAL-52's recombinant ancestors is less than a decade removed from SARS-CoV-2. It has other recombinant ancestors that are farther away that this. One of BANAL-52's recent ancestors underwent recombination with a virus that is VERY closely related to the one that causes Covid-19.

This means it BANAL-52 shared a common host with with either the proximal ancestor of SARS-CoV-2 or a very close relative of it sometime within the last decade. This could significantly narrow down where the proximal ancestor is\was located.
 
Supports everything I've been saying. It looks thorough and very fair in how it assesses the evidence.
Does it?

It seems to refute any suggestion of genetic manipulation, which runs counter to much of what you have posted. At most it leaves the door open for spillover of a natural virus that for some reason was in a lab without being catalogued. While this is a possibility, location and the inability to find a proximal ancestor in any know database or lab samples make this an unlikely possibility.

It also says China had no prior knowledge of the outbreak which runs counter to your suggestion that a database was taken offline and edited prior to the outbreak in order to cover-up the source.
 
Okay, I "seem to think" it is more significant. You seem to think it is less significant.

If a virus was found that was, say, 98% similar to SARS-CoV2 would you then think it was significant?

If a virus was found that had the same furin cleavage site would you then think it was significant?

I don't know what you think is significant.

You see, I think it is meaningul.

Why? Because knowing that they exist in nature and in a place that is unlikely to have been sampled by the WIV itself suggests that those viruses were not taken back to the WIV and then released.

From what I can see, Dr Quay and various others in DRASTIC absolutely still do believe there is some kind of engineering or manipulation involved.

In fact, you MUST do too otherwise why are you talking about this "straight out of the box" point?
I don't think Quay is in DRASTIC, not that it matters.

Here's where I'm at: Going by the formal security report they make a good case for there still being nothing conclusive one way or the other. I agree with that. It doesn't mean I don't lean one way. Obviously I do.

From my POV nothing has been found in 2 years that should have been found by now if this happened by spillover. Instead from that side of the argument all I see are people unwilling to let go of the idea it couldn't have been a lab leak because it's too awful to contemplate.

So instead they gather up everything that might be evidence of a natural event but they are missing the key piece of evidence, that of some evidence this virus actually existed in the wild. Bits and pieces of it, thousand of kilometers away, evidence it could have existed and could have been a natural event, but only if you make up scenarios there is no evidence supporting.

Now look at the other side.

I don't care what you believe, Daszak and Shi have told lies when there was no reason to. China is hiding information which may or may not be rational action on their part. From the Western POV it makes no sense but taking culture into account one could see other reasons for withholding information.

The report confirms the Chinese are withholding evidence. I'm not sure why you keep asking for more evidence on that front.

Then you have Daszak talking about how easy it is to manipulate coronaviruses. You have a proposal from him to do just that. You have mixed messages about GoF research they were doing. There is evidence they were working with live cultures and live bats: more things Daszak and Shi denied.

As for straight out of the box ready to go, that's one of the strongest pieces of evidence. The pandemic began abruptly, no evidence whatsoever of an adaptation period, another thing there should be evidence for but there isn't any.

There is an explanation for the virus being in Wuhan and for how it came into existence that doesn't require a scenario there is no evidence for.

There's more but that's enough on its own.
 
Last edited:
I don't think Quay is in DRASTIC, not that it matters.

Here's where I'm at: Going by the formal security report they make a good case for there still being nothing conclusive one way or the other. I agree with that. It doesn't mean I don't lean one way. Obviously I do.

From my POV nothing has been found in 2 years that should have been found by now if this happened by spillover. Instead from that side of the argument all I see are people unwilling to let go of the idea it couldn't have been a lab leak because it's too awful to contemplate.

So instead they gather up everything that might be evidence of a natural event but they are missing the key piece of evidence, that of some evidence this virus actually existed in the wild. Bits and pieces of it, thousand of kilometers away, evidence it could have existed and could have been a natural event, but only if you make up scenarios there is no evidence supporting.

Now look at the other side.

I don't care what you believe, Daszak and Shi have told lies when there was no reason to. China is hiding information which may or may not be rational action on their part. From the Western POV it makes no sense but taking culture into account one could see other reasons for withholding information.

The report confirms the Chinese are withholding evidence. I'm not sure why you keep asking for more evidence on that front.

Then you have Daszak talking about how easy it is to manipulate coronaviruses. You have a proposal from him to do just that. You have mixed messages about GoF research they were doing. There is evidence they were working with live cultures and live bats: more things Daszak and Shi denied.

As for straight out of the box ready to go, that's one of the strongest pieces of evidence. The pandemic began abruptly, no evidence whatsoever of an adaptation period, another thing there should be evidence for but there isn't any.

There is an explanation for the virus being in Wuhan and for how it came into existence that doesn't require a scenario there is no evidence for.

There's more but that's enough on its own.

What about the fact the Virus could be spread By Contaminated waste water?
Couldn't the Virus have been Carried into Wuhan by a Human Truck driver infected at home who drink from a Natural spring?
Lack of evidence is not proof of Conspiracy, this virus is highly contagious we don't know who actually was patient zero, we only know who was hospitalized first.
 
What about the fact the Virus could be spread By Contaminated waste water?
Couldn't the Virus have been Carried into Wuhan by a Human Truck driver infected at home who drink from a Natural spring?
The evidence suggests this might have happened in reverse. One of the reports a while back documented accidental spills in the wastewater FROM the lab. I'll see if I can find it. But as for it coming in on a truck driver or their truck gives you the same problem as any of the other natural spillover problems, there is no source where there should be a source.

How did said truck driver get infected? Why is there no evidence of the virus percolating within bats or other species, and why has no one gotten infected by the driver or their truck on the way there? The driver's household members, unusual pneumonia cases outside of Wuhan?


Lack of evidence is not proof of Conspiracy, this virus is highly contagious we don't know who actually was patient zero, we only know who was hospitalized first.
First off, no one is claiming any conspiracy was behind the virus itself. This is not the thread you want to discuss that nonsense.

There is evidence of a conspiracy to cover it up. That's backed up by solid evidence of Shi and Daszak lying multiple times and the Chinese government refusing to give the data they have on the first cases which are on the record, just not the details on their circumstances.

When I say: absence of evidence is sometimes evidence of of absence, it happens when one does not find evidence where one should find it. After 2 years no source of the virus has been found. No similar coronaviruses with all the pieces put together or at least in closer proximity to Wuhan has been found. The Chinese tested nearly 80,000 specimens and there was no COVID found.

All the other recent spillovers did not abruptly appear in the human population out of nowhere. COVID did.

And no, the search for an HIV source is not a relevant example for the reasons I pointed out upthread: the science wasn't there yet, it took > 5 years just to identify the HIVirus that was the cause and the very long incubation period of years are not the same as with COVID.
 
Last edited:
The evidence suggests this might have happened in reverse. One of the reports a while back documented accidental spills in the wastewater FROM the lab. I'll see if I can find it. But as for it coming in on a truck driver or their truck gives you the same problem as any of the other natural spillover problems, there is no source where there should be a source.

How did said truck driver get infected? Why is there no evidence of the virus percolating within bats or other species, and why has no one gotten infected by the driver or their truck on the way there? The driver's household members, unusual pneumonia cases outside of Wuhan?


First off, no one is claiming any conspiracy was behind the virus itself. This is not the thread you want to discuss that nonsense.

There is evidence of a conspiracy to cover it up. That's backed up by solid evidence of Shi and Daszak lying multiple times and the Chinese government refusing to give the data they have on the first cases which are on the record, just not the details on their circumstances.

When I say: absence of evidence is sometimes evidence of of absence, it happens when one does not find evidence where one should find it. After 2 years no source of the virus has been found. No similar coronaviruses with all the pieces put together or at least in closer proximity to Wuhan has been found. The Chinese tested nearly 80,000 specimens and there was no COVID found.

All the other recent spillovers did not abruptly appear in the human population out of nowhere. COVID did.

And no, the search for an HIV source is not a relevant example for the reasons I pointed out upthread: the science wasn't there yet, it took > 5 years just to identify the HIVirus that was the cause and the very long incubation period of years are not the same as with COVID.

Simply drinking Contaminated water would get someone infected.
It takes days before you show symptoms time to drive 1000 miles and return home.
This article expresses how hard it is to find a source Animal.
http://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02110-8#:~:text=The%20real%20mystery%2C%20says%20Banerjee,source%20can%20expose%20other%20animals.%E2%80%9D
 
Simply drinking Contaminated water would get someone infected.
It takes days before you show symptoms time to drive 1000 miles and return home.
This article expresses how hard it is to find a source Animal.
http://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02110-8#:~:text=The%20real%20mystery%2C%20says%20Banerjee,source%20can%20expose%20other%20animals.%E2%80%9D

The water still has to get contaminated in the first place, meaning one should be able to not only find the contaminated water in your hypothesis, one should also be able to find the source of the contamination.

And COVID is airborne, it doesn't look like food or water are sources of infection in people.

As for the Nature article, it's about deer getting infected from us, not the other way around. Remember China has tested almost 80,000 animals looking for the source and haven't found it.


This was the second reference in the Nature article:
Susceptibility of White-Tailed Deer (Odocoileus virginianus) to SARS-CoV-2
In that link they infected the deer via nasal inoculation. The contaminated wastewater noted in the Nature article is only a suggested hypothesis, it isn't something they found infecting the deer. COVID does show up in wastewater. I'm not sure anyone has tested wastewater for infectious virus, just for evidence it was present. But it's moot. You still need to find the source.


There is no shortage of hypotheses on how COVID might have been from a natural spillover. But there is no evidence any of those scenarios actually occurred.


Side note: This keeps being repeated from the first efforts of Daszak to steer people away from the lab leak hypothesis and it simply isn't true:
Current evidence suggests a likely spillover into humans from an animal reservoir.
And neither is this:
Given the presumed zoonotic origin of SARS-CoV-2

Repeating these unsupported assertions is unfortunate given the evidence Daszak put his thumb on the scale early on in the search for the origin. Had the first WHO team not injected that unsupported assertion into their report, a lab leak would appear no less likely than spillover.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom