Crazy Chainsaw
Philosopher
- Joined
- Aug 12, 2006
- Messages
- 8,339
The water still has to get contaminated in the first place, meaning one should be able to not only find the contaminated water in your hypothesis, one should also be able to find the source of the contamination.
And COVID is airborne, it doesn't look like food or water are sources of infection in people.
As for the Nature article, it's about deer getting infected from us, not the other way around. Remember China has tested almost 80,000 animals looking for the source and haven't found it.
This was the second reference in the Nature article:
Susceptibility of White-Tailed Deer (Odocoileus virginianus) to SARS-CoV-2
In that link they infected the deer via nasal inoculation. The contaminated wastewater noted in the Nature article is only a suggested hypothesis, it isn't something they found infecting the deer. COVID does show up in wastewater. I'm not sure anyone has tested wastewater for infectious virus, just for evidence it was present. But it's moot. You still need to find the source.
There is no shortage of hypotheses on how COVID might have been from a natural spillover. But there is no evidence any of those scenarios actually occurred.
Side note: This keeps being repeated from the first efforts of Daszak to steer people away from the lab leak hypothesis and it simply isn't true:
And neither is this:
Repeating these unsupported assertions is unfortunate given the evidence Daszak put his thumb on the scale early on in the search for the origin. Had the first WHO team not injected that unsupported assertion into their report, a lab leak would appear no less likely than spillover.
OK then tell North American white Tailed deer to wear mask and Social distance.
The infection of the deer could only have come from humans, because deer don't fly on Jet planes. Most likely from Sewage contaminated water.
. No credible evidence of live bats at the WIV. Not even evidence of horseshoe bats being kept in any lab anywhere in the world. Shi sys that they cannot be kept in labs so where are the hundreds of researchers saying she is wrong? Where are the papers on keeping horseshoe bats in labs?