Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
The water still has to get contaminated in the first place, meaning one should be able to not only find the contaminated water in your hypothesis, one should also be able to find the source of the contamination.

And COVID is airborne, it doesn't look like food or water are sources of infection in people.

As for the Nature article, it's about deer getting infected from us, not the other way around. Remember China has tested almost 80,000 animals looking for the source and haven't found it.


This was the second reference in the Nature article:
Susceptibility of White-Tailed Deer (Odocoileus virginianus) to SARS-CoV-2
In that link they infected the deer via nasal inoculation. The contaminated wastewater noted in the Nature article is only a suggested hypothesis, it isn't something they found infecting the deer. COVID does show up in wastewater. I'm not sure anyone has tested wastewater for infectious virus, just for evidence it was present. But it's moot. You still need to find the source.


There is no shortage of hypotheses on how COVID might have been from a natural spillover. But there is no evidence any of those scenarios actually occurred.


Side note: This keeps being repeated from the first efforts of Daszak to steer people away from the lab leak hypothesis and it simply isn't true:
And neither is this:

Repeating these unsupported assertions is unfortunate given the evidence Daszak put his thumb on the scale early on in the search for the origin. Had the first WHO team not injected that unsupported assertion into their report, a lab leak would appear no less likely than spillover.

OK then tell North American white Tailed deer to wear mask and Social distance.
The infection of the deer could only have come from humans, because deer don't fly on Jet planes. Most likely from Sewage contaminated water.
 
The water still has to get contaminated in the first place, meaning one should be able to not only find the contaminated water in your hypothesis, one should also be able to find the source of the contamination.

And COVID is airborne, it doesn't look like food or water are sources of infection in people.

As for the Nature article, it's about deer getting infected from us, not the other way around. Remember China has tested almost 80,000 animals looking for the source and haven't found it.


This was the second reference in the Nature article:
Susceptibility of White-Tailed Deer (Odocoileus virginianus) to SARS-CoV-2
In that link they infected the deer via nasal inoculation. The contaminated wastewater noted in the Nature article is only a suggested hypothesis, it isn't something they found infecting the deer. COVID does show up in wastewater. I'm not sure anyone has tested wastewater for infectious virus, just for evidence it was present. But it's moot. You still need to find the source.


There is no shortage of hypotheses on how COVID might have been from a natural spillover. But there is no evidence any of those scenarios actually occurred.


Side note: This keeps being repeated from the first efforts of Daszak to steer people away from the lab leak hypothesis and it simply isn't true:
And neither is this:

Repeating these unsupported assertions is unfortunate given the evidence Daszak put his thumb on the scale early on in the search for the origin. Had the first WHO team not injected that unsupported assertion into their report, a lab leak would appear no less likely than spillover.

It5 a new virus it might take a decade or to to find the source.
 
The infection of the deer could only have come from humans, because deer don't fly on Jet planes. Most likely from Sewage contaminated water.
Why should deer get infected from food and drink when humans don’t? OK, maybe deer sniff before they drink, whereas humans only do it with alcohol …
 
Why should deer get infected from food and drink when humans don’t? OK, maybe deer sniff before they drink, whereas humans only do it with alcohol …

Wild deer are infected in many states, that is a fact, and I don't believe they got it from Jet Traveling Chinese deer.
 
OK then tell North American white Tailed deer to wear mask and Social distance.
The infection of the deer could only have come from humans, because deer don't fly on Jet planes. Most likely from Sewage contaminated water.
I'm not sure how that is relevant here but it is a good discussion to have on the science of COVID thread.
 
Skeptic Ginger continues to repeat misinformation

...
Now look at the other side.
Followed by repeated misinformation from Skeptic Ginger.
Repeating fantasies does not make Shi into a liar.
Has anyone seen any any quote "claiming there were no in vitro CoV cultures at the WIV" from Shi?

Daszak and Shi did not lie. Even if they had stated errors or lied, that says nothing about the origin of COVID-19.
China is refusing to provide raw patient data that the WHO team already have as anonymous patient data. No one is asking for more evidence about this well known fact.
Daszak talking about how easy it is to manipulate coronaviruses is irrelevant.
The WIV GoF research is irrelevant to the lab leak theory.
The Daszak and Shi denied live cultures and live bats idiocy. No actual evidence that Daszak or Shi denied live cultures at WIV. Isolating and growing bat coronaviruses, e.g. as live cultures, is the part of the WIV research :eye-poppi. No credible evidence of live bats at the WIV. Not even evidence of horseshoe bats being kept in any lab anywhere in the world. Shi sys that they cannot be kept in labs so where are the hundreds of researchers saying she is wrong? Where are the papers on keeping horseshoe bats in labs?
All pandemics begin "abruptly"!
The persistent misinformation that there is no evidence for a spillover event.
  • The fact that spillover events happen is evidence.
    COVID-19 is basically a repeat of the much, much smaller SARS outbreak.
  • The fact that the virus is ~96% similar to other viruses is evidence.
  • The lack of evidence for a lab leak is indirect evidence for a spillover event.
 
Here's where I'm at: Going by the formal security report they make a good case for there still being nothing conclusive one way or the other.
As W.D.Clinger quoted[/URL
[URL="https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/Declassified-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins.pdf"]Updated Assessment on COVID-19 Origins (PDF)
The case they make with the existing information is that it was probably a spillover event. They judge that a more definite explanation needs new information.
 
It5 a new virus it might take a decade or to to find the source.
Based on what evidence?


Based on other zoonoses, after a 2 year intensive search something closer than Ra13TG besides bits and pieces thousands of miles from Wuhan should have been found.
Other examples of how long it took to find at least some evidence of the source of new zoonosis:
SARS: ~4 months
Nipah (NiV) - as soon as the organism was identified it was connected to pigs; intensive surveillance of cases in Bangladesh identified the connection to fruit bats.
Marburg - as soon as it was discovered the source was traced.
Ebola is the closest recent zoonosis example of a hard to find source. The origin is still not certain but there are huge differences: The first cases were in the 70s, there are 5 and maybe 6 different strains, and the source of outbreaks was traced even if the reservoir species have not been. At least one ebola strain has been found in bats and several strains have been found in non-human primates.
Zika - not a new zoonosis.
​
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19108397/
It is probable that initial transmission of NiV from bats to pigs occurred in late 1997/early 1998 through contamination of pig swill by bat excretions, as a result of migration of these forest fruitbats to cultivated orchards and pig-farms, driven by fruiting failure of forest trees during the El Nino-related drought and anthropogenic fires in Indonesia in 1997-1998.


https://www.cdc.gov/vhf/marburg/index.html
Marburg virus was first recognized in 1967, when outbreaks of hemorrhagic fever occurred simultaneously in laboratories in Marburg and Frankfurt, Germany and in Belgrade, Yugoslavia (now Serbia). Thirty-one people became ill, initially laboratory workers followed by several medical personnel and family members who had cared for them. Seven deaths were reported. The first people infected had been exposed to Ugandan imported African green monkeys or their tissues while conducting research. One additional case was diagnosed retrospectively.
So the origin of Marburg was found almost as soon as it was discovered.


Despite not finding the origin of ebola, it has been found in bats. It's not like there is no evidence of a zoonosis origin.

https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn12567-fruit-bats-carry-deadly-marburg-virus/ (Discusses both Marburg and Ebola.)
Hundreds of wild animals were tested before Eric Leroy and colleagues at the International Centre for Medical Research in Franceville, Gabon, found traces of Ebola in three species of fruit bat in 2005 (New Scientist, 3 December 2005, p 20). Their breakthrough came when sensitive PCR analysis revealed genes of the Ebola virus in bat tissues. Leroy and his team used the same technique to look for the Marburg virus, which they have now found in Rousettus aegyptiacus bats.
Hundreds of specimens were tested for ebola, not 80,000.

And more recently:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4309665/
The severe Ebola virus disease epidemic occurring in West Africa stems from a single zoonotic transmission event to a 2-year-old boy in Meliandou, Guinea. We investigated the zoonotic origins of the epidemic using wildlife surveys, interviews, and molecular analyses of bat and environmental samples. We found no evidence for a concurrent outbreak in larger wildlife. Exposure to fruit bats is common in the region, but the index case may have been infected by playing in a hollow tree housing a colony of insectivorous free-tailed bats (Mops condylurus).

More ebola origin progress, a new hypothesis:
https://gh.bmj.com/content/6/4/e005783
By recalibrating the balance between ‘spillover’ and ‘flare-up’, we suggest that EVD manifests less as a series of discrete epidemics and more as an endemic disease in humans over long timescales and wide areas, helping to account for the increasing frequency of episodes. ...

The first human case in an Ebola outbreak is acquired through contact with blood, secretions organs or other bodily fluids of an infected animal. EVD has been documented in people who handled infected chimpanzees, gorillas, and forest antelopes, both dead and alive, in Cote d’Ivoire, the Republic of Congo and Gabon. The first case in the West Africa outbreak was likely acquired via exposure to bats.


Another zoonosis, Zika was discovered in monkeys first decades ago before humans were infected.
https://www.who.int/news-room/feature-stories/detail/the-history-of-zika-virus
1947: Scientists conducting routine surveillance for yellow fever in the Zika forest of Uganda isolate the Zika virus in samples taken from a captive, sentinel rhesus monkey.
1948: The virus is recovered from the mosquito Aedes africanus, caught on a tree platform in the Zika forest.
And that was half a century ago.


In all of these zoonoses at least some trace of virus was found in at least one animal source. In none of them did they go 2 years without a trace of the viruses being found. And by trace I mean of the actual viruses, not bits and pieces within different virus genomes.
 
Why should deer get infected from food and drink when humans don’t? OK, maybe deer sniff before they drink, whereas humans only do it with alcohol …

It's not unheard of for viruses to have different routes of transmission in different species. Influenza for example, is a GI disease in poultry and it is spread in feces, while in humans it is droplet spread for the most part.

The example still wasn't relevant since the deer got it from us, not the other way around, and the water source was just tossing ideas out there, there wasn't evidence that's how the deer became infected.
 
It's not unheard of for viruses to have different routes of transmission in different species. Influenza for example, is a GI disease in poultry and it is spread in feces, while in humans it is droplet spread for the most part.

The example still wasn't relevant since the deer got it from us, not the other way around, and the water source was just tossing ideas out there, there wasn't evidence that's how the deer became infected.

It's just the only likely way so many Deer got infected.
 
Based on what evidence?


Based on other zoonoses, after a 2 year intensive search something closer than Ra13TG besides bits and pieces thousands of miles from Wuhan should have been found.
Other examples of how long it took to find at least some evidence of the source of new zoonosis:
SARS: ~4 months​


4 months??!?!?

Not true. Look at Wikipedia:

The SARS epidemic began in the Guangdong province of China in November 2002. The earliest case developed symptoms on 16 November 2002.[37] The index patient, a farmer from Shunde, Foshan, Guangdong, was treated in the First People's Hospital of Foshan. The patient died soon after, and no definite diagnosis was made on his cause of death. Despite taking some action to control it, Chinese government officials did not inform the World Health Organization of the outbreak until February 2003.

It was four months before China even alerted the WHO!

But then....

In late May 2003, studies were conducted using samples of wild animals sold as food in the local market in Guangdong, China. The results found that the SARS coronavirus could be isolated from masked palm civets (Paguma sp.),

Does this mean that the animals were still in the markets?

Probably yes.

However, this is not the case with SARS-CoV2 where the markets were relatively quickly shut and decontaminated. Animals were, I think disposed of.

As for the 80,000 animals tested, this seems to be a popular talking point of Dr Quay.

The answer is, so what? You have to test the right animals. If the markets and the wildlife farms are worried about being culpable for the next SARS, then you have to expect that they have taken actions to clean up their mess.

Besides, if you look at the report you can see that some of the animals tested are African elephants etc... why? Because they tested animals in the zoo, and poultry, horses, farm animals, stray dogs etc...

You can test a million animals. If you aren't testing the right ones, then it doesn't make a difference.​
 
It's just the only likely way so many Deer got infected.

Again, what it suggests is that SARS-CoV2 is a generalist virus that can attach to ACE2 receptors of many animals and spread quickly. This obviates the need for a long process of adaptation. That's why you can't look at other viruses and simply say, "look at Ebola and others, they still haven't adapted well to humans, so we should expect SARS-CoV2 to take many years in which time we would detect it." If that were the case, we wouldn't have pandemics like this one or the Spanish flu etc...
 
It's just the only likely way so many Deer got infected.
Not necessarily, unless you are suggesting it was in rainwater.

From the Nature article:
Department of Agriculture (USDA) in Fort Collins, Colorado, and her colleagues tested 385 blood samples collected as part of regular wildlife-surveillance activities between January and March 2021 in four US states — Michigan, Pennsylvania, Illinois and New York. They found that a striking 40% of the samples contained SARS-CoV-2 antibodies, which are produced in response to infection. None of the surveyed deer showed signs of illness.

The researchers’ testing of archived samples also turned up antibodies in 3 samples from early 2020, when SARS-CoV-2 was beginning to circulate in the United States. All told, one-third of the 2020 and 2021 samples had antibodies for the virus.
There is no connected wastewater those deer drink. They do however, sometimes eat food people leave out for them, especially in cold weather. And they live in a lot of urban areas. We have a lot of deer here but we don't have any open wastewater sources that deer would be drinking from.
 
Not necessarily, unless you are suggesting it was in rainwater.

From the Nature article: There is no connected wastewater those deer drink. They do however, sometimes eat food people leave out for them, especially in cold weather. And they live in a lot of urban areas. We have a lot of deer here but we don't have any open wastewater sources that deer would be drinking from.

You can say there is no Urine from deer hunters Urinating in the woods during Deer season?
 
Skeptic Ginger has been stating that there is no evidence for zoonosis of SARS-CoV-2. Now she is citing the same evidence for SARS that we have for SARS-CoV-2!
We did find SARS coronavirus in masked palm civets about 6 months after the first case and later in raccoon dogs, ferret badgers and domestic cats. They are not the source of SARS.
SARS Origin and animal vectors
Phylogenetic analysis of these viruses indicated a high probability that SARS coronavirus originated in bats and spread to humans either directly or through animals held in Chinese markets. The bats did not show any visible signs of disease but are the likely natural reservoirs of SARS-like coronaviruses. In late 2006, scientists from the Chinese Centre for Disease Control and Prevention of Hong Kong University and the Guangzhou Centre for Disease Control and Prevention established a genetic link between the SARS coronavirus appearing in civets and humans, bearing out claims that the disease had jumped across species.[62]

It took 14 years to find the original bat population likely responsible for the SARS pandemic.[63] In December 2017, "after years of searching across China, where the disease first emerged, researchers reported ... that they had found a remote cave in Xiyang Yi Ethnic Township, Yunnan province, which is home to horseshoe bats that carry a strain of a particular virus known as a coronavirus. This strain has all the genetic building blocks of the type that triggered the global outbreak of SARS in 2002."[3] The research was performed by Shi Zhengli, Cui Jie, and co-workers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, China, and published in PLOS Pathogens. The authors are quoted as stating that "another deadly outbreak of SARS could emerge at any time. The cave where they discovered their strain is only a kilometre from the nearest village."[3][64] The virus was ephemeral and seasonal in bats.[65] In 2019, a similar virus to SARS caused a cluster of infections in Wuhan, eventually leading to a global pandemic.
Phylogenetic analysis gives evidence that SARS-CoV-2 originated from bats.
There are diseases that must have come from zoonosis but we have never found the originating species. Not finding an originating species after 2 years is not evidence against zoonosis or for a lab leak.
 
Last edited:
4 months??!?!?

Not true. Look at Wikipedia:

It was four months before China even alerted the WHO!

But then....
Cases were found by epidemiological evidence. Notifying the WHO is not where the search for the source begins. Kind of hard to find the source until you identify the virus.

SARS: Timeline of an Outbreak
March 24, 2003 -- CDC officials present the first evidence that a new strain of a virus most frequently associated with upper respiratory infections and the common cold in humans called the coronavirus might be likely cause of SARS. ...

April 12, 2003 -- Canadian researchers announce they have completed the first successful sequencing of the genome of the coronavirus believed to cause SARS.
May 1, 2003; The Genome sequence of the SARS-associated coronavirus was published.
In March 2003, a novel coronavirus (SARS-CoV) was discovered in association with cases of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS). The sequence of the complete genome of SARS-CoV was determined, and the initial characterization of the viral genome is presented in this report. The genome of SARS-CoV is 29,727 nucleotides in length and has 11 open reading frames, and its genome organization is similar to that of other coronaviruses. Phylogenetic analyses and sequence comparisons showed that SARS-CoV is not closely related to any of the previously characterized coronaviruses.
May 1st is when the full genome was published. That's the soonest other researchers had the genome data to begin searching for the specific source.

Published ion Sept 4, 2003: Isolation and characterization of viruses related to the SARS coronavirus from animals in southern China
A novel coronavirus (SCoV) is the etiological agent of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS). SCoV-like viruses were isolated from Himalayan palm civets found in a live-animal market in Guangdong, China. Evidence of virus infection was also detected in other animals (including a raccoon dog, Nyctereutes procyonoides) and in humans working at the same market. All the animal isolates retain a 29-nucleotide sequence that is not found in most human isolates. The detection of SCoV-like viruses in small, live wild mammals in a retail market indicates a route of interspecies transmission, although the natural reservoir is not known.

So in April 2003 the discovery of SARS was announced. By May 1 researchers
published the genome. They already had epidemiological evidence of the connection of the first cases to the wet markets. But they didn't have a specific organism to test the markets for.

Then on Sept 4, 2003 results were published that the source of the virus had been found in the civet cats at the suspected wet markets.

May June July Aug: that's 4 months from the time the genome was published to the discovery of the virus in civet cats.
I'll address the rest in another post so it's not tl;dr.
 
Last edited:
... Does this mean that the animals were still in the markets?

Probably yes.

However, this is not the case with SARS-CoV2 where the markets were relatively quickly shut and decontaminated. Animals were, I think disposed of.
Using this argument one would have had some cluster of cases in an intermediate species that was remarkably all destroyed so no one could look at them. Where did those mysteriously untested animals get infected from? Why are they only in one market in Wuhan and not in wet markets in other cities? There's nothing closer than Ra13TG in the bats if that is the reservoir species.


...As for the 80,000 animals tested, this seems to be a popular talking point of Dr Quay.
Your favorite handwaving off excuse. This is the source and it isn't Quay: Nature: The COVID lab-leak hypothesis: what scientists do and don’t know
As for finding an intermediate host animal, researchers in China have tested more than 80,000 wild and domesticated animals; none have been positive for SARS-CoV-2.



..The answer is, so what? You have to test the right animals. If the markets and the wildlife farms are worried about being culpable for the next SARS, then you have to expect that they have taken actions to clean up their mess.

Besides, if you look at the report you can see that some of the animals tested are African elephants etc... why? Because they tested animals in the zoo, and poultry, horses, farm animals, stray dogs etc...

You can test a million animals. If you aren't testing the right ones, then it doesn't make a difference.
And here you are again making up a scenario to fit the evidence instead of starting with an hypotheses then seeing if the evidence supports it or not.
 
Again, what it suggests is that SARS-CoV2 is a generalist virus that can attach to ACE2 receptors of many animals and spread quickly. This obviates the need for a long process of adaptation. That's why you can't look at other viruses and simply say, "look at Ebola and others, they still haven't adapted well to humans, so we should expect SARS-CoV2 to take many years in which time we would detect it." If that were the case, we wouldn't have pandemics like this one or the Spanish flu etc...
You can say there is no Urine from deer hunters Urinating in the woods during Deer season?
To infect deer in 4 states you would need an awful lot of COVID infected hunters shedding virus in their piss. We don't have evidence urine even has COVID in it.

Found in sewage, yes but even that hasn't been confirmed to be viable virus. It could just be killed virus or even incomplete fragments.

Again, an interesting discussion for the COVID science thread, but it isn't relevant to the origin thread unless you go by angrysoba's noting it shows the virus is a generalist. That's fine but it doesn't support the origin argument unless you find the source.
 
To infect deer in 4 states you would need an awful lot of COVID infected hunters shedding virus in their piss. We don't have evidence urine even has COVID in it.

Found in sewage, yes but even that hasn't been confirmed to be viable virus. It could just be killed virus or even incomplete fragments.

Again, an interesting discussion for the COVID science thread, but it isn't relevant to the origin thread unless you go by angrysoba's noting it shows the virus is a generalist. That's fine but it doesn't support the origin argument unless you find the source.

The Origin of Covid could be any place an animal urinated into a water supply such as a cave or underground spring, and where sanitary conditions were lax in China.
 
Using this argument one would have had some cluster of cases in an intermediate species that was remarkably all destroyed so no one could look at them. Where did those mysteriously untested animals get infected from? Why are they only in one market in Wuhan and not in wet markets in other cities? There's nothing closer than Ra13TG in the bats if that is the reservoir species.

Sorry, but what? BANAL-52 is closer to SARS-CoV2 as you know, and anyway, I think you have already agreed that RaTG13 is not the progenitor virus, so all we are left with is not finding the virus. It doesn't mean we know it is in the lab. To conclude that is just another example of Lab-leak-of-the-gaps.

Your favorite handwaving off excuse. This is the source and it isn't Quay: Nature: The COVID lab-leak hypothesis: what scientists do and don’t know


Let's look at that source, in context...

As for finding an intermediate host animal, researchers in China have tested more than 80,000 wild and domesticated animals; none have been positive for SARS-CoV-2. But this number is a tiny fraction of the animals in the country. To narrow the search down, researchers say, more strategic testing is needed to isolate animals that are most susceptible to infection and those that come in close contact with people.


Exactly, but chopping off that context is what Dr Quay does, and you follow his lead.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom