Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, I participated in the thread at one point earlier, but eventually bowed out because it reached an impasse and cannot be settled conclusively either way without substantial additional evidence.

Same here, and the only thing conclusively proven so far is that the subject required its own thread, because I'd be royally pissed off if all this was in the Covid thread.

I check once a month or so to see if anything new happened, and it keeps not happening, like an infinite carousel.

Wake me up in another month...
 
I've not watched it yet, but lab leak proponent, Yuri Deigin from DRASTIC, and natural spillover-proponent, Stuart Neil - a virologist from King's College, had a debate on the origins.

They usually have a pretty spirited but civil back on forth on Twitter, and both seem to have a good sense of humour so it might be worth watching.

My only reservation is the moderator who in my experience is a tedious waffler.

 
Yeah, it would. It's not a scientific/technical book according to the reviews. It's a mass marketing opinion book.
But no worries one way or the other.

I think what you mean is that it is a popular science book, not a "mass marketing opinion book".

The weird part of your post is your use of the word "claim", which means, "state or assert that something is the case, typically without providing evidence or proof."

It implies skepticism from you that I read a popular science book. Surely it would be a bigger claim for me to have said I had read some technical works on spillovers.
 
Alina Chan and Matt Ridley have finally published their book.

Unfortunately, the "zoonati" must have got onto it, as the book is not being very well received.

Here, for example, is the Guardian/Observer review:

Alina Chan and Matt Ridley are similarly puzzled why, if the virus had a natural origin, it was first detected in Wuhan and not closer to Yunnan, 900 miles to the south. “Of all the gin joints in all the towns in the world…” they write.
...

... The result is a viral whodunnit that is sure to appeal to armchair detectives and sceptics of scientific orthodoxies.

There is just one problem: nowhere do they present proof that Sars-CoV-2 was manufactured. Take Chan’s claim that it appeared pre-adapted to human transmission “to an extent similar to late epidemic Sars”. This claim rests on a single mutation in the spike protein that appears to “slightly enhance” (Chan and Ridley’s words) its ability to bind to human receptor cells and suggests that by the time it was first detected in Wuhan it had “apparently stabilised genetically”.

But this is highly misleading. As the subsequent alphabet soup of variants demonstrates, the coronavirus has undergone repeated mutations that have steadily increased its fitness. Furthermore, studies of viruses isolated from pangolins, one of the animals suspected of being an intermediary host, bind to human receptor cells even more efficiently than Sars-CoV-2, suggesting capacity for further adaptation. As two leading virologists put it, the virus was not perfectly adapted to humans but was “just good enough”.

Link

They also then talk about the furin cleavage site, the Mojiang mine, and RatG13 pointing out that none of these really get us any closer to a lab leak, and indeed the reviewer argues that the most parsimonious explanation is a natural spillover.
 
Alina Chan and Matt Ridley have finally published their book.

I'll play.

University of Arizona evolutionary virologist Michael Worobey - a specialist in the origins of viral epidemics, says the first infection known was a vendor at the food market, and that the geographic pattern of early cases strongly supports the hypothesis that the virus came from an infected animal at the Huanan Seafood Market.

Of course, some people have a problem with that...
 
I'll play.

University of Arizona evolutionary virologist Michael Worobey - a specialist in the origins of viral epidemics, says the first infection known was a vendor at the food market, and that the geographic pattern of early cases strongly supports the hypothesis that the virus came from an infected animal at the Huanan Seafood Market.

Of course, some people have a problem with that...

Yes. I came here to post the article Worobey wrote. Definitely worth reading for those who have been following the details of the origins:


Crucially, however, the now famous “earliest” COVID-19 case (1), a 41-year-old male accountant, who lived 30 km south of Huanan Market and had no connection to it—illness onset reported as 8 December—appears to have become ill with COVID-19 considerably later (12). When interviewed, he reported that his COVID-19 symptoms started with a fever on 16 December; the 8 December illness was a dental problem related to baby teeth retained into adulthood (12). This is corroborated by hospital records and a scientific paper that reports his COVID-19 onset date as 16 December and date of hospitalization as 22 December (13). This indicates that he was infected through community transmission after the virus had begun spreading from Huanan Market. He believed that he may have been infected in a hospital (presumably during his dental emergency) or on the subway during his commute; he had also traveled north of Huanan Market shortly before his symptoms began (12). His symptom onset came after multiple cases in workers at Huanan Market, making a female seafood vendor there the earliest known case, with illness onset 11 December (12). Notably, she reported knowledge of several possible COVID-19 cases in clinics and hospitals that were near Huanan Market from 11 December, and Huanan Market patients were hospitalized at Union Hospital as early as 10 December (see fig. S1).

He also answers questions raised before in this thread such as “why was the Pneumonia of Unknown Etiology not triggered for early spillover cases? Well, apparently most doctors don’t even know if it’s existence. That was a question asked to me when I suggested that it may have emerged on the wildlife trade or from some small-holding farm. It would suggest that such incidents may have gone unreported (and in fact we have direct evidence it could have as Worobey points out that it was a hospital, not through the PUE that made us aware of Covid-19).

Also an interesting point that distinguishes this from the first SARS and which I have banged on about myself on this very thread is an explanation of why we have not found the intermediate host animal:

With SARS, live-animal markets continued to sell infected animals for many months, allowing zoonotic spillover to be established as the origin and revealing multiple independent jumps from animals into humans (3). Unfortunately, no live mammal collected at Huanan Market or any other live-animal market in Wuhan has been screened for SARS-CoV-2–related viruses (1), and Huanan Market was closed and disinfected on 1 January 2020. Nevertheless, that most early symptomatic cases were linked to Huanan Market—specifically to the western section (1) where raccoon dogs were caged (2)—provides strong evidence of a live-animal market origin of the pandemic.

In addition, on his Twitter feed, Worobey has pointed out that a superspreader event at a seafood market is less likely than, say, in a nursing home or a theatre, etc… the market, on the other hand would be a good environment for a spillover and possibly multiple spillovers as Worobey also argues there are likely multiple lineages of the virus.

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abm4454
 
He also answers questions raised before in this thread such as “why was the Pneumonia of Unknown Etiology not triggered for early spillover cases?

I don't buy that as a question worth asking, let alone answering. It just highlights the straw-clutching of the conspiracists.

"Why weren't earlier cases found?"

I'd just wonder why China is supposed to have noticed a few very likely older people with pneumonia and a dodgy health system when the self-laballed greatest country in the world, and sole superpower, didn't find a single case in Washington State for five whole weeks after the first positive, and only noticed then when old people kept turning up dead and someone wondered why.

And that was when they knew the thing was on the loose.

The question is nonsense.
 
I don't buy that as a question worth asking, let alone answering. It just highlights the straw-clutching of the conspiracists.

"Why weren't earlier cases found?"
I'd just wonder why China is supposed to have noticed a few very likely older people with pneumonia and a dodgy health system when the self-laballed greatest country in the world, and sole superpower, didn't find a single case in Washington State for five whole weeks after the first positive, and only noticed then when old people kept turning up dead and someone wondered why.

And that was when they knew the thing was on the loose.

The question is nonsense.

Well, neither do I because I have pointed out that if that is supposed to be evidence that a viral infection could not have occurred earlier in the countryside, then it can hardly help the lab leakers' case if they also claim that Wuhan had infections as far back as September (and hence the rationale for removing the database) or the so-called Wuhan Military Games superspreader event given that the WMG was in October.
 
Unfortunately Scientist who said lab-leak theory of Covid-19 origin should be probed, now says evidence points to Wuhan market does not link to the Sceince article by Michael Worobey.
Dissecting the early COVID-19 cases in Wuhan by Michael Worobey.
The case for the "the now famous “earliest” COVID-19 case" being later is really only a video. The corroborating hospital records are not cited. The corroborating scientific paper (reference 13) looked at samples from 9 patients. One had no exposure to the Huanan seafood market but their date of symptom onset is Dec 27, 2019.
The video is on the Chinese The Paper web site and dated 2020-03-25. The first case at the South China seafood market was a Ms. Wei who developed a fever on 11 December. According to a caption, a list at a clinic says that a Mr. Chen was the first patient with no exposure to the market and developed a fever on 16 December. He is an accountant. This is the Mr. Chen who is in the WHO study as having an onset of 8 December. There are papers shown n the background that may be the clinic or other records about him.
 
Last edited:
I'd just wonder why China is supposed to have noticed a few very likely older people with pneumonia and a dodgy health system when the self-laballed greatest country in the world, and sole superpower, didn't find a single case in Washington State for five whole weeks after the first positive, and only noticed then when old people kept turning up dead and someone wondered why.
The question is nonsense.

Precisely. And after weeks of warning.
 
Yes. I came here to post the article Worobey wrote. Definitely worth reading for those who have been following the details of the origins:

He also answers questions raised before in this thread such as “why was the Pneumonia of Unknown Etiology not triggered for early spillover cases? Well, apparently most doctors don’t even know if it’s existence. That was a question asked to me when I suggested that it may have emerged on the wildlife trade or from some small-holding farm. It would suggest that such incidents may have gone unreported (and in fact we have direct evidence it could have as Worobey points out that it was a hospital, not through the PUE that made us aware of Covid-19).

Also an interesting point that distinguishes this from the first SARS and which I have banged on about myself on this very thread is an explanation of why we have not found the intermediate host animal:

In addition, on his Twitter feed, Worobey has pointed out that a superspreader event at a seafood market is less likely than, say, in a nursing home or a theatre, etc… the market, on the other hand would be a good environment for a spillover and possibly multiple spillovers as Worobey also argues there are likely multiple lineages of the virus.

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abm4454

This is no different from other people who have mapped out their genetic trails. It's been received by people like Bloom with the assessment the hypothesis is not strongly supported.

Trying to find a link that isn't paywalled: New Review Claims First COVID Patient was Wuhan Market Vendor
"I don't disagree with the analysis," Jesse Bloom, a virologist at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in Seattle, told the Times. "But I don't agree that any of the data are strong enough or complete enough to say anything very confidently, other than that the Huanan Seafood Market was clearly a super-spreading event."

Studies of the virus' genome -- including one conducted by Worobey himself -- suggest that the first infection occurred in about mid-November 2019, weeks before the market vendor got sick, the Times reported.
IOW Worobey had a conflicting earlier analysis.

This is just another hypothesis.

Still no source, no means the virus got to the seafood market, and no acknowledgement of the earliest cases we know existed but which did not have a wet market connection. Seems like Worobey fits the evidence to his hypothesis ignoring some of the evidence altogether.
 
This is no different from other people who have mapped out their genetic trails. It's been received by people like Bloom with the assessment the hypothesis is not strongly supported.

Trying to find a link that isn't paywalled: New Review Claims First COVID Patient was Wuhan Market VendorIOW Worobey had a conflicting earlier analysis.

This is just another hypothesis.

Still no source, no means the virus got to the seafood market, and no acknowledgement of the earliest cases we know existed but which did not have a wet market connection. Seems like Worobey fits the evidence to his hypothesis ignoring some of the evidence altogether.

One thing it does do is undermine the claim that “the earliest cases had no connection to the market”. This can no longer be asserted with any confidence because the earliest known cases were associated with the market now.

Besides, it does not mean that Worobey’s earlier analyses are incorrect. We just don’t know where patient zero got infected and surely this puts the market back in play and cannot be ruled out as the locus. So it is not contradicting anything Worobey said before as far as I can see.
 
Well, neither do I because I have pointed out that if that is supposed to be evidence that a viral infection could not have occurred earlier in the countryside, then it can hardly help the lab leakers' case if they also claim that Wuhan had infections as far back as September (and hence the rationale for removing the database) or the so-called Wuhan Military Games superspreader event given that the WMG was in October.

The WA State example is not analogous. Dump was actively interfering in public health measures, he announced there were no cases in the US and he banned Chinese visitors. But the biggest problem was the lack of testing ability and CDC interim guidelines which said not to test anyone who didn't have a direct exposure to a known case made contact tracing impossible for most of 2020. It also meant known cases of pneumonia were not tested. That doesn't mean we had no record of those cases if one was to do an analysis.

As for sentinel monitoring, China has followed the US example. Unusual cases of pneumonia means cases over and above the expected number for the season. It's not about looking for a new virus in an undiagnosed case.

The Influenza Division at CDC collects, compiles, and analyzes information on influenza activity year-round in the United States.

While we monitor for influenza, pneumonia deaths are also monitored.

Information on outpatient visits to health care providers for influenza-like illness (ILI) is collected through the U.S. Outpatient Influenza-like Illness Surveillance Network (ILINet). ILINet consists of outpatient healthcare providers in all 50 states, Puerto Rico, the District of Columbia and the U.S. Virgin Islands. ...

Prior to the 2020-2021 influenza season [because COVID 19 data was then accounted for], the NCHS surveillance data were used to calculate the percent of all deaths occurring each week that had pneumonia and/or influenza (P&I) listed as a cause of death.

As for China, their reporting in Dec 2019 to the WHO demonstrated there was an active surveillance system in place. It did not detect unusual pneumonia activity anywhere else in the country.

Pneumonia of unknown cause – China

CHP closely monitors cluster of pneumonia cases on Mainland

While the surveillance system isn't perfect, it did pick up the Wuhan outbreak and no other outbreaks were detected. I linked to and quoted the WHO investigation team's final report where they looked at the surveillance and other data from China for the whole year 2019 and no unusual pneumonia cases were seen in that time period.
 
As for sentinel monitoring, China has followed the US example. Unusual cases of pneumonia means cases over and above the expected number for the season. It's not about looking for a new virus in an undiagnosed case.

The Influenza Division at CDC collects, compiles, and analyzes information on influenza activity year-round in the United States.

While we monitor for influenza, pneumonia deaths are also monitored.



As for China, their reporting in Dec 2019 to the WHO demonstrated there was an active surveillance system in place. It did not detect unusual pneumonia activity anywhere else in the country.

Pneumonia of unknown cause – China

CHP closely monitors cluster of pneumonia cases on Mainland

While the surveillance system isn't perfect, it did pick up the Wuhan outbreak and no other outbreaks were detected. I linked to and quoted the WHO investigation team's final report where they looked at the surveillance and other data from China for the whole year 2019 and no unusual pneumonia cases were seen in that time period.

You should read Worobey's paper:

Although a widely cited report (7) credits the VPUE mechanism with uncovering the pandemic, it was HPHICWM (Hubei Provincial Hospital of Integrated Chinese and Western Medicine) that identified both the outbreak and the Huanan Market connection and passed on these fully formed discoveries to district, municipal, and provincial public health officials by 29 December (9). National officials reportedly did not learn about the outbreak until CCDC Director George Gao encountered online group chats about the WHC emergency notices on the evening of 30 December. Concerned that so many cases had not been reported to the VPUE system, he quickly notified the National Health Commission (14) (see fig. S1).
Therefore, the preponderance of early cases connected to Huanan Market could not have been an artifact of ascertainment bias introduced by case definitions in the VPUE system. Although mechanisms like China’s VPUE system are potentially invaluable, they will fail without both widespread buy-in from health care providers and rapid data sharing from local to central authorities. Key problems with the VPUE system were known before the pandemic, including that most clinicians in China had little awareness of the VPUE system and were not reporting cases to it—for example, 0 of 335 PUE cases in one study from 2019 (5). China should be commended, however, for having such a system, which is lacking in most countries. The focus now should be on fixing the problems that COVID-19 has exposed and blanketing the globe with a highly functional PUE early warning system.
 
One thing it does do is undermine the claim that “the earliest cases had no connection to the market”. This can no longer be asserted with any confidence because the earliest known cases were associated with the market now.

Besides, it does not mean that Worobey’s earlier analyses are incorrect. We just don’t know where patient zero got infected and surely this puts the market back in play and cannot be ruled out as the locus. So it is not contradicting anything Worobey said before as far as I can see.

Come on your kidding right an open air wet market couldn't possibly have Insects night flying bats would feed upon, and bats don't travel long distance because everyone knows they don't have wings and have to walk.
Wouldn't be like they could be hiding in a cave with a baseball size opening as the only way in or out, high up on a ridge.
I mean surely every bat in China has been tested by now.
 
This is basically a tabloid rumor that the White Coat Waste Project (a animal protection group) has emails between the EcoHealth Alliance and US government funding agencies. A document says the EcoHealth Alliance was sampling bats in Laos, it was too complicated to spend some of the grant in a Laotian lab, so they would like to send these samples to Wuhan.
What makes this a rumor that the emails are not produced. The journalism missing is
  • Were the samples from the same caves where BANAL-52 was found? Or even from northern Laos?
  • Were the samples actually sent to WIV?
  • What did the WIV do with these hypothetical samples?
 
Another piece of lab-leak evidence is revealed with a FOIA request. EcoHealth Alliance sent emails to a US 'funding' source revealing they were collecting viruses from the Laos caves. You like the Banal-52 strain, angrysoba, and I've been saying 'where is the trail to Wuhan?' Well here it is:

New documents back theory that Covid outbreak started in Wuhan lab
Wuhan scientists were studying viral samples of high-risk bat species living in Laos - the country where the closest relative to Covid-19 has been found, leaked documents show. ...

In September, researchers discovered a viral strain called Banal-52 in Laos, which shares 96.8 per cent of its genome with Sars-CoV-2 - boosting claims that the pandemic was caused by a natural spillover event, rather than a laboratory leak.

However, it remained unclear how a bat-borne virus from Laos could have ended up sparking an outbreak in Wuhan, more than 1,000 miles away.
Until now that is.

Now, leaked emails between EcoHealth Alliance and US government funders show viral samples were being collected from bats in Laos and sent back to the Wuhan Institute of Virology for study.

The emails, uncovered in a Freedom of Information Request by the US-based White Coat Waste Project, suggest that viral DNA from “bats and other high-risk species” were sent to Wuhan between June 2017 to May 2019.

So let's put a couple pieces together.

The WIV collected and was studying SARS-like CoVs from Yunnan. And now we see they were also collecting and studying similar coronaviruses from caves in Laos.

Maybe that's how they ended up looking in the Laos caves ... but I digress.

And we have the Daszak proposal to DARPA for research money:
Mr Demaneuf points out that such manipulation of viruses had already been discussed in a grant application by EcoHealth Alliance, which was collaborating with the Wuhan institute

Proposals to the US Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, which were leaked to Drastic earlier this year, show the scientists were hoping to introduce “human-specific cleavage sites” to bat coronaviruses which would make it easier for the virus to enter human cells.

And we have the genetic sequences being taken off-line in Sept, 2019 which was suspicious timing but still not clearly tied into the events a month or more later:
The genetic sequences collected from both Yunnan and Laos were kept in an online database at the Wuhan institute. However, that was removed in September 2019, leaving experts unsure of exactly what strains were studied at the lab.

Backtracking in the article a bit more:
Viscount Ridley, co-author of Viral: The Search for the Origin of Covid-19, said the emails added more weight to the theory that the virus leaked from a lab in Wuhan.

Speaking at the Institute of Economic Affairs in London, the peer said: “Banal-52 is not close enough to be the progenitor, it's still not the smoking gun,
No, not a smoking gun, just some more smoldering pieces.

And all this explains why no spillover source has yet to be found.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom