Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
Sept cases if they occurred would not have been enough to establish a pattern of the virus simmering unless they included cases of a pneumonia outbreak of unknown origin.How do you square that with your claim that the virus was loose in early September? Surely the pattern of pneumonia that you said we would see would have been visible.
Another experience of what we see in new pathogen outbreaks:
Just like SARS 1 and the H5N1HPAI experiences, zoonoses leave a trail.Lucey notes that the discovery of the coronavirus that causes Middle East respiratory syndrome, a sometimes fatal disease that occurs sporadically, came from a patient in Saudi Arabia in June 2012, although later studies traced it back to an earlier hospital outbreak of unexplained pneumonia in Jordan in April 2012. Stored samples from two people who died in Jordan confirmed they had been infected with the virus.
Keep this in mind: The removal of the database from online could be a red-herring. The evidence isn't conclusive. But if it is connected, all that had to have happened to trigger the move was a breach of containment. Maybe it wasn't clear the virus actually infected anyone. Or maybe it infected one or two people and it was thought that was all that would happen.
Regardless of those possibilities from a red herring to a couple cases, it doesn't include evidence of a simmering pathogen. You only need to have had one case in Sept.
We have cases being recognized in Dec. There had to be an incubation period before the cases were in the hospital. We know patient zero wasn't among these cases because those first recognized cases were from the seafood market cluster.
More patients were found that came earlier than the Seafood market. These are recognized cases (from the A lineage I believe) but for which China will not release any information on them about their cases or exposure history.
Multiple sources have been posted. I can't believe you don't know that. But whatever, here are some again.Do you have a source for this?
Science; Jan 26, 2020: Wuhan seafood market may not be source of novel virus spreading globally
Description of earliest cases suggests outbreak began elsewhere
a description of the first clinical cases published in The Lancet on Friday challenges [first cases at the seafood market] hypothesis.
The paper, written by a large group of Chinese researchers from several institutions, offers details about the first 41 hospitalized patients who had confirmed infections with what has been dubbed 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV). In the earliest case, the patient became ill on 1 December 2019 and had no reported link to the seafood market, the authors report. "No epidemiological link was found between the first patient and later cases," they state. Their data also show that, in total, 13 of the 41 cases had no link to the marketplace. ...
Earlier reports from Chinese health authorities and the World Health Organization had said the first patient had onset of symptoms on 8 December 2019—and those reports simply said "most" cases had links to the seafood market, which was closed on 1 January.
Lucey says if the new data are accurate, the first human infections must have occurred in November 2019—if not earlier—because there is an incubation time between infection and symptoms surfacing.
Keep in mind, by end of Jan 2020 there were hundreds of cases showing up all over the world.
WSJ: China Refuses to Give WHO Raw Data on Early Covid-19 Cases - Officials withhold personalized information on patients that could help determine pandemic’s origins
The rest is paywalled but this same story has been repeated by other researchers asking China for information on the first cases.BEIJING—Chinese authorities refused to provide World Health Organization investigators with raw, personalized data on early Covid-19 cases that could help them determine how and when the coronavirus first began to spread in China, according to WHO investigators who described heated exchanges over the lack of detail.
BBC: Covid-19 pandemic: China 'refused to give data' to WHO team
Microbiologist Dominic Dwyer told Reuters, the Wall St Journal and the New York Times the team requested raw patient data from early cases, what he called "standard practice".
He said they only received a summary. ...
. There are the unnoticed mild cases from exposure to the animals before spillover. Then as in SARS, COVID-19 and many other brakouts, there is an explosion of cases.