Let’s see if I can make it clearer….
You say that the first cases almost certainly preceded the first official cases in December. So how do you know that the virus was perfectly adapted to humans in the initial spillover stage. Maybe in September it was NOT well adapted to humans but became so in the subsequent months.
Re Shi lying about the miners: everyone else knows they didn't die of a primary fungal infection. Shi has presented no evidence they did. Yet you choose to ignore all the evidence so you can claim Shi isn't lying. That's not a very honest way to evaluate the evidence.
Plus there are pictures of the bat cages at WIV and Daszak discussed on the record how they were experimenting with live coronavirus cultures, 2 things Shi denied. Again you choose to ignore the evidence.
Moving on to how do we know the virus had no precursor circulation where it adapted to humans. Had this happened there would be evidence of it. And no, it's not akin to tracking down the source of HIV for a dozen reasons.
What you are saying is you believe in something that there is no evidence supporting because said evidence could show up in the future.
There are times when the absence of evidence is evidence of absence: when you expect that evidence to be there and it isn't.
In this case one would expect the kind of circulating we saw with SARS 1 which did become adapted over a couple of months. And the H5N1 HPAI (flu) which has spilled over but not yet become adapted to humans. In neither case was the pre-adapted circulation silent without coming to the attention of the medical community.
You don't go from some kind of silent circulating (silent as in unnoticed mild cases) to a sudden explosion of highly infectious cases. At a minimum you would see that circulation included cases of pneumonia. Pneumonia cases would not have only begun all at once. Even if the Dec cases were the first time some single or relatively few mutations appeared, you wouldn't additionally have rapid person to person spread.
First you see cases that occur with more extensive direct contact with the source. In the case of H5N1HPAI it was in people in close contact with the infected chickens. Those cases occurred sporadically. The patients were quite ill but didn't yet shed a lot of virus. Some household members became infected but it went no further.
In the case of SARS 1 the virus came to the attention of the medical community because healthcare workers were catching it from patients who had a pneumonia of unknown cause. It didn't begin with cases of unnoticed spread that gradually became adapted enough to humans to seemingly spring up out of nowhere. The earliest cases had connections to wet markets. It took a couple months for the virus to adapt well to humans.
In neither case was early circulation without at least some cases of pneumonia. China has a similar monitoring system for flu and pneumonia as we do here in the US. The WHO team looked at the records of that monitoring for all of 2019. This was one of the records the team actually got to look at as opposed to being told what was in the records. There was no increase or even an unusual pattern of pneumonia in China in 2019 until shortly before the Dec COVID cases. The Chinese government acknowledges there were cases prior to Dec for which records exist. They refuse to share the records of the first patients despite multiple requests.
In addition, you can take the genetic record of the Dec and later cases and see there was little adaptation going on. The virus was, for all intents and purposes, ready right out of the box. There are multiple citations supporting this.
You are choosing to ignore all that and instead hold on to some unsupported hypothesis that fits what you want to believe.