Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Multiple source corroborate that patient zero was infected in Wuhan sometime in or after Sept 2019 and it was out-of-the-box ready to go from the beginning.

The "or after" is doing a lot of heavy lifting.

After September 2019, obviously there is evidence of this. The first known patients were in Wuhan in December.

But you have a problem with your theory.

Who are these people in September? No evidence for them. If this thing was out of the box and ready to go, why didn't the cases emerge in September, October, November...?

We don't know.

However, there is one possibility which is that the virus was still becoming adapted to humans during this time and there may have been some fizzling out of the virus at this time.

The problem is that you have two theories that undermine each other. If the virus was sputtering at the beginning, say in September 2019, it undermines the claim it was already well-adapted so bang goes your need for gain-of-function.

If you argue another point that you have made, that there was no seroprevalance evidence of the virus circulating then you have undermined your claim that the virus was around in September 2019.

Do you not see this?
 
angrysoba said:
The rest of this is a kind of Gish Gallop of stuff we have hashed over multiple times.

If you want to talk about a specific thing, bring that up, but you have changed the subject from the Laos coronaviruses by asking me to address twenty five different things, much of which we have discussed endlessly ("Have you ever addressed Daszak's conflict of interest and his efforts to make everyone think the lab leak hypothesis was a CT?" - FFS, what?!?!? I think we went over this over and over again. Talk about flogging a dead horse!)

I'll have to split this up for you apparently.

Let's start with Daszak's conflict of interest and new evidence.

What is new is he's been ejected from the new WHO investigation team because he was biased and not forthcoming.

The Lancet disbanded their team looking into the origin hypothesis because Daszak was on the team and it gave the appearance of bias.

A number of researchers wrote their own letter to the Lancet objecting to the one Daszak had written and gotten scientists to sign on because he deceived them about who wrote the opinion piece. The Lancet published the new letter and admitted the first 2 op eds published on the subject were premature and the lab leak should still be considered.

And you already know about the documented lies both Shi and Daszak wrote/said and that the head of the WHO walked back the first formal WHO report. He said the lab leak hypothesis was dismissed too soon and before any investigation of it was made.

Given all the 'new' evidence that Daszak's and Shi's conflicts of interest resulted in their evidence being unreliable, why are you still relying on it and posting as if the two were honest and reliable?
 
I'll have to split this up for you apparently.

Let's start with Daszak's conflict of interest and new evidence.

What is new is he's been ejected from the new WHO investigation team because he was biased and not forthcoming.

The Lancet disbanded their team looking into the origin hypothesis because Daszak was on the team and it gave the appearance of bias.

A number of researchers wrote their own letter to the Lancet objecting to the one Daszak had written and gotten scientists to sign on because he deceived them about who wrote the opinion piece. The Lancet published the new letter and admitted the first 2 op eds published on the subject were premature and the lab leak should still be considered.

Yep, okay. That's good. So the Lancet wants to be scrupulous about being seen to be objective. That's good. What are the problems with that?

And you already know about the documented lies both Shi and Daszak wrote/said and that the head of the WHO walked back the first formal WHO report. He said the lab leak hypothesis was dismissed too soon and before any investigation of it was made.

I don't agree with you about "documented lies". This is something you keep repeating as though it were a fact. I know you will again bring up fungus and Mojiang, but you already know what I think of that.


Given all the 'new' evidence that Daszak's and Shi's conflicts of interest resulted in their evidence being unreliable, why are you still relying on it and posting as if the two were honest and reliable?

Excuse me? What am I relying on and posting?

Give me an example of something I am "still relying on and posting"?
 
With my highlighting:
Skeptic Ginger, would you mind acknowledging that one of the bat coronaviruses found in Laos, BANAL-52, is closer to SARS-CoV2 than RaTG13?

W.D Clinger and I have both pointed this out to you. If we are to get to the bottom of this, it would help to acknowledge the barest minimal facts, otherwise how can we trust each other's speculations?

I have no issue with that. It wasn't relevant and I'm not sure why you and Clinger think it is.
Speaking only for myself, the only reason I thought it might be relevant to this thread is that someone asked me to take note of it, and I presumed he/she/it was asking me to take note of it because he/she/it thought it was relevant.

If you'll give me a moment, I might be able to find it by scrolling back through the thread....ah, here it is:
Note none of the viruses found in Laos are any closer in their total genomes than COVID is to RaTG13.

So you don't have all the pieces and more importantly there's no evidence of such a recombinant virus precursor to COVID 19.
When I tried to take note of that as instructed, I noted the assertion is not true.

Having noted that, I went on to speculate that the conclusory sentence following the false assertion had lost whatever support the false assertion might have offered had it been true.

Had I realized the admonition to note a falsehood was not intended to be relevant to this thread, I'd have assumed the falsehood and the conclusory sentence that followed were just part of a Gish Gallop or something.
 
With my highlighting:

Speaking only for myself, the only reason I thought it might be relevant to this thread is that someone asked me to take note of it, and I presumed he/she/it was asking me to take note of it because he/she/it thought it was relevant.

If you'll give me a moment, I might be able to find it by scrolling back through the thread....ah, here it is:

When I tried to take note of that as instructed, I noted the assertion is not true.

Having noted that, I went on to speculate that the conclusory sentence following the false assertion had lost whatever support the false assertion might have offered had it been true.

Had I realized the admonition to note a falsehood was not intended to be relevant to this thread, I'd have assumed the falsehood and the conclusory sentence that followed were just part of a Gish Gallop or something.

Indeed!

My guess is that if BANAL-52 had suddenly been discovered to be part of the WIV database, it would have been highly relevant to Skeptic Ginger.

The point here is that, as natural spillover proponents have said, the coronaviruses are spread out over a wide area, and they have not been adequately sampled.

Therefore the fact that the progenitor virus has not yet been found is not really that surprising. Certainly not as surprising as the lab leakers assume it would be. They argue that it should be easy to find. Why? Because SARS 1 was found by chance in a market in Shenzhen even though it did not spillover in Shenzhen. A couple of years later it was also found in Hubei which is the same province that Wuhan is in. Therefore it is at least suggestive that such wildlife trails could be the passage for another similar coronavirus.
 
... I don't agree with you about "documented lies". This is something you keep repeating as though it were a fact. I know you will again bring up fungus and Mojiang, but you already know what I think of that.
If you are aware of the issue: Shi claims the miners died of a fungus, multiple sources support the conclusion they had an unknown virus including one miner who recovered without having had any anti-fungals, then I don't need to repeat it.

But you, nor anyone else, nor Shi have provided anything supporting her claim. And you claim the SciAm interview was not what it was presented as but you've not provided any evidence that was the case.

... Excuse me? What am I relying on and posting?

Give me an example of something I am "still relying on and posting"?
You continue to cite Daszak and Shi without addressing their conflict of interest and dishonesty.
 
If you are aware of the issue: Shi claims the miners died of a fungus, multiple sources support the conclusion they had an unknown virus including one miner who recovered without having had any anti-fungals, then I don't need to repeat it.

But you, nor anyone else, nor Shi have provided anything supporting her claim. And you claim the SciAm interview was not what it was presented as but you've not provided any evidence that was the case.

You continue to cite Daszak and Shi without addressing their conflict of interest and dishonesty.

I pointed out that we don't really know the details of the miners' deaths.

She is not a pathologist, so all we can go on is that she detected none of the viruses that she tested for.

Do you simply think she is lying about that and covered up a spillover? If you do, it is a really bizarre thing to do. A really bizarre thing to do. Your explanation for this, based on a highly conjectural article from Counterpunch, is convoluted in the extreme (yet you claim to be applying Ockham's razor!) and essentially assumes not just lies but outright evil.

But it also makes no sense from a gain of function POV. For a start, the virus would have to be way more virulent than Covid-19 as why would it have a CFR of 50%? Then apparently through gain of function they made it, what...less virulent? More transmissable? But why? If funding was what they were after then ringing the alarm bell that they had found a spillover would get the money rolling in! It would vindicate their work! But, you say, no, they didn't do that. They did something way darker and more cynical because....well... I guess they are evil. So, you say you are applying Ockham's Razor but when we look at the details of what you are saying it presupposes all kinds of really highly illogical and dubious notions. The simplest argument is that they tested for viruses and when they found none, they said they had none, because they are good scientists.

As for a miner getting better without anti-fungals, we probably went over this two or three times and I doubt it will make a difference to mention again, but some people do get better from fungal infections without anti-fungals. This is not exactly news to anyone.

Again, my Ockham's razor suggests that she may have said to the reporter that they didn't find evidence of a virus and then ventured that maybe they died of a fungus, then the reporter, for the sake of brevity removed the qualifiers and paraphrased her as saying it was a fungus.

So we have a choice. My reasonable and simple explanation or your Byzantine one that requires turning the whole pandemic prevention mission of the WIV, the NIH and EHA on its head.

What would William of Ockham say?
 
The "or after" is doing a lot of heavy lifting.

After September 2019, obviously there is evidence of this. The first known patients were in Wuhan in December.

But you have a problem with your theory.

Who are these people in September? No evidence for them. If this thing was out of the box and ready to go, why didn't the cases emerge in September, October, November...?

We don't know.

However, there is one possibility which is that the virus was still becoming adapted to humans during this time and there may have been some fizzling out of the virus at this time.

The problem is that you have two theories that undermine each other. If the virus was sputtering at the beginning, say in September 2019, it undermines the claim it was already well-adapted so bang goes your need for gain-of-function.

If you argue another point that you have made, that there was no seroprevalance evidence of the virus circulating then you have undermined your claim that the virus was around in September 2019.

Do you not see this?
More cherry picking as if all my arguments rely on the Sept data removal. They don't.

One source said Sept; 2 said Oct. Neither relied on seroprevalence so I'm unclear what you mean. All 3 relied on walking the genetic time clock back. No source I've seen thinks the Dec cases were the first. We know they weren't because the Chinese have declined to release information on the first cases.

I don't have 2 theories and they don't undermine each other. You seem to be claiming the sputtering is one of my theories? It isn't.

I believe there is one source that hypothesized with no supporting evidence the sputtering you speak of. ALL the other sources note the virus began abruptly without this adaptation you imagine occurred, and that includes the genetic records we do have.

Your post attributes things to me I didn't claim.
 
Still spreading misinformation

As was posted in a cite upthread, they found only a minuscule evidence of spillover. ...Clearly not the risk Daszak was hoping to find.
23 September 2021: The preprint and paper with Daszak as an author give comparable numbers of people expected and detected to have coronavirus antibodies.

Sept 12 China took a large conronavirus genome database offline and has refused to share the information.
27 October 2021: Repeats a "has refused to share the information" fantasy when she does not cite anyone being refused.
The web site was taken down on 12 September 2019 because of a hacking attack. The sequences in the database are mostly available in other databases.

"I knew I'd read one source putting the first COVID case back as far as Sept but couldn't find it again earlier" was her cherry picking 1 study from the WHO report which lists many studies whose overall result is the first COVID case is probably December.
Science Daily: COVID-19: Genetic network analysis provides 'snapshot' of pandemic origins is an analysis of the spread, not the origins of COVID-19. The actual quote from Science Daily on April 9, 2020:
Since today's PNAS study was conducted, the research team has extended its analysis to 1,001 viral genomes. While yet to be peer-reviewed, Forster says the latest work suggests that the first infection and spread among humans of COVID-19 occurred between mid-September and early December.

If you are aware of the issue: Shi claims the miners died of a fungus, multiple sources support the conclusion they had an unknown virus including one miner who recovered without having had any anti-fungals, then I don't need to repeat it...
Repeating fantasies does not make Shi into a liar.
21 October 2021: "Although the fungus turned out to be the pathogen" is not Shi's words.
22 October 2021: Cites a non-peer reviewed, not submitted preprint with what looks like "COVID-19 was genetically engineered" nonsense.

Some people get better from diseases without the treatment for those diseases. A miner most probably with a fungal infection can recover without anti-fungals. All that says is that their immune system coped with the infection. Even people who get COVID-19 can recover with no treatment.
 
More cherry picking as if all my arguments rely on the Sept data removal. They don't.

One source said Sept; 2 said Oct. Neither relied on seroprevalence so I'm unclear what you mean. All 3 relied on walking the genetic time clock back. No source I've seen thinks the Dec cases were the first. We know they weren't because the Chinese have declined to release information on the first cases.

I don't have 2 theories and they don't undermine each other. You seem to be claiming the sputtering is one of my theories? It isn't.

I believe there is one source that hypothesized with no supporting evidence the sputtering you speak of. ALL the other sources note the virus began abruptly without this adaptation you imagine occurred, and that includes the genetic records we do have.

Your post attributes things to me I didn't claim.

Let’s see if I can make it clearer….

You say that the first cases almost certainly preceded the first official cases in December. So how do you know that the virus was perfectly adapted to humans in the initial spillover stage. Maybe in September it was NOT well adapted to humans but became so in the subsequent months.
 
Larry Moran gives a clear explanation on why a natural origin of SARS-CoV-2 is the most probable origin: The case for a natural origin of SARS-CoV-2
Lots of people seem to be confused about the origin of SARS-CoV-2, the virus responsible for the COVID-19 pandemic. The investigating committee ot the World Health Organization (WHO) concluded last winter that a natural origin is the most likely scenario but there still seems to be a substantial percentage of the population who think that the virus was being studied at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) and leaked from there to start the pandemic. This belief in a lab leak scenario persists in spite ot the fact that 21 expert scientists have discounted it and concluded that a natural origin is the best hypothesis. The lab leak speculation persists even when the United States intelligence agencies reached the same conclusion as the scientific experts and said that a natural origin was more likely.

I've published several posts on this topic over the past year trying to emphasize four points: (1) the evidence strongly favors a natural origin, (2) there is no scientific evidence to support the claim that the WIV scientists were working on SARS-CoV-2 before the pandemic started, (3) the most knowledgeable science experts agree that a natural origin is the most likely scenario, and (4) the media is misrepreseting the science and treating the two competing explanations as equivalent.

In this post I want to describe the case for a natural origin in as simple a manner as possible so that people can refer to the main lines of evidence and so that opponents of a natural origin can explain why they dismiss that evidence. I also want to briefly explain why we need to listen to the experts instead of arbitrarily dismissing their views as a argument from authority and assuming that our own research trumps the experts.
He debunks the "highly adapted" claim.
If the scientists are repeating statments that have aready been refuted then you are right to question their credibility. It suggests that they either have an unscientific agenda or they aren't on top of their subject. For example, if a scientist says that SARS-CoV-2 was highly adapted to humans when it first appeared then you should be skeptical because, in fact, SARS-CoV-2 is a generalist virus that can propagate in a wide variety of mammalian species. The repetition of previously refuted claims is a key indicator of low credibility.
 
Last edited:
.... No source I've seen thinks the Dec cases were the first..
Wrong. Skeptic Ginger knows about The WHO report and the time to most recent common ancestor studies that average around December :eye-poppi.
13 August 2021: The molecular clock papers are consistent with the first cases in December 2019.
There are 5 studies that infer the time to most recent common ancestor to be the first week in December 2019. The 95% confidence limit for the studies gives a range of 13 November 2019 and 23 December 2019. There is one and only one study that gives "late September".

A bit of "We know they weren't because the Chinese have declined to release information on the first cases." illogic and misinformation. If we do not have the data, we have no idea when the first cases were :jaw-dropp! All we can say is that the earliest known case was in early December 2019. The Chinese have released information in the first cases. Skeptic Ginger has cited paper(s) using those cases. What was refused was a follow-up to the WHO study with access to raw patient data. Of course anyone who believes in a lab leak and a coverup will believe that the raw patent data will exclude the "real" first cases such as WIV personnel infected by the leak. The Chinese are in a catch-22 situation. If they gave access, they would be accused of hiding data. They refused and are accused of hiding data!
 
Last edited:
Would you mind acknowledging that the Laos discovery only adds the evidence that pieces of COVID 19 can be found in nature

The exact origin of SARS-CoV-1 was identified using such pieces. Your attempt to diminish this comes off a little like ID proponents trying to get biologists to admit that Evolution is "just a theory".

nor is there evidence of how any such assembled virus got from Laos to Wuhan?

The trade in wildlife destined for live animal markets like the Wuhan Fish Market has been proved to be able to transport viruses distances like this.
 
Progenitor only in the sense it was a common ancestor, and I don't see how BANAL-52 is that much more closely related as a common ancestor than the Yunnan virus.

From the paper:"Sections" as in not a single virus that looks like it is the ancestor of COVID. BANAL is 0.7% more similar. So how many years ago did any of these viruses share a common ancestor with COVID? Decades at a minimum?

Parts of BANAL-52 share a recombinant ancestor that lived as little as a decade ago. This is much closer than the 5-7 decades that separate RaTG13 and SARS-CoV-2

There is evidence GoF research is being done at the WIV.
There is evidence they were experimenting with live viral cultures at the WIV.
That evidence includes adapting SARS CoVs to infecting human cells.
There is evidence of live bats at the WIV.
There is evidence Daszak has been lying.
There is evidence Shi has been lying.​


You are confusing accusations with evidence.

And, even if the accusations turn out to be true these are non-sequitur. It doesn't follow from any of these things that the pandemic was a lab leak.
 
Last edited:
Seriously? You don't understand the difference between saying BANAL-52 is a close ancestor of COVID and in saying one genetic segment of BANAL-52 is close to a segment in COVID?

Are you sure you understand? These segments came from recombinant ancestor that existed a mere 10 years ago. That's much closer that the 50-70 years that separate SARS-CoV-2 and RaTG13
 
If you are aware of the issue: Shi claims the miners died of a fungus, multiple sources support the conclusion they had an unknown virus

We settled this months ago. The symptoms support Shi's rather then the student who suggested she was wrong.

Also it doesn't matter if Shi was wrong, if the bar for accepting scientific conclusions is that the scientists involved have never been wrong about anything ever, well that's just an outright rejection of ALL science.

You continue to cite Daszak and Shi without addressing their conflict of interest and dishonesty.

You continue to slander them without questioning the honesty of your sources. Sorry but I've seen this type of slander to many times now. It's part of the anti-science playbook to cherry pick supposed "inconsistencies" and claim to have proved dishonesty.

If you are going to claim "the scientists are lying" it's an extraordinary claim that requires extraordinary evidence to support, and the evidence you have provided so far not only doesn't do that it's downright lacking.
 
No source I've seen thinks the Dec cases were the first. We know they weren't because the Chinese have declined to release information on the first cases.
The patient information China refused to make public IS from the Dec cases
 
Let’s see if I can make it clearer….

You say that the first cases almost certainly preceded the first official cases in December. So how do you know that the virus was perfectly adapted to humans in the initial spillover stage. Maybe in September it was NOT well adapted to humans but became so in the subsequent months.

Re Shi lying about the miners: everyone else knows they didn't die of a primary fungal infection. Shi has presented no evidence they did. Yet you choose to ignore all the evidence so you can claim Shi isn't lying. That's not a very honest way to evaluate the evidence.

Plus there are pictures of the bat cages at WIV and Daszak discussed on the record how they were experimenting with live coronavirus cultures, 2 things Shi denied. Again you choose to ignore the evidence.


Moving on to how do we know the virus had no precursor circulation where it adapted to humans. Had this happened there would be evidence of it. And no, it's not akin to tracking down the source of HIV for a dozen reasons.

What you are saying is you believe in something that there is no evidence supporting because said evidence could show up in the future. There are times when the absence of evidence is evidence of absence: when you expect that evidence to be there and it isn't.
In this case one would expect the kind of circulating we saw with SARS 1 which did become adapted over a couple of months. And the H5N1 HPAI (flu) which has spilled over but not yet become adapted to humans. In neither case was the pre-adapted circulation silent without coming to the attention of the medical community.

You don't go from some kind of silent circulating (silent as in unnoticed mild cases) to a sudden explosion of highly infectious cases. At a minimum you would see that circulation included cases of pneumonia. Pneumonia cases would not have only begun all at once. Even if the Dec cases were the first time some single or relatively few mutations appeared, you wouldn't additionally have rapid person to person spread.

First you see cases that occur with more extensive direct contact with the source. In the case of H5N1HPAI it was in people in close contact with the infected chickens. Those cases occurred sporadically. The patients were quite ill but didn't yet shed a lot of virus. Some household members became infected but it went no further.

In the case of SARS 1 the virus came to the attention of the medical community because healthcare workers were catching it from patients who had a pneumonia of unknown cause. It didn't begin with cases of unnoticed spread that gradually became adapted enough to humans to seemingly spring up out of nowhere. The earliest cases had connections to wet markets. It took a couple months for the virus to adapt well to humans.

In neither case was early circulation without at least some cases of pneumonia. China has a similar monitoring system for flu and pneumonia as we do here in the US. The WHO team looked at the records of that monitoring for all of 2019. This was one of the records the team actually got to look at as opposed to being told what was in the records. There was no increase or even an unusual pattern of pneumonia in China in 2019 until shortly before the Dec COVID cases. The Chinese government acknowledges there were cases prior to Dec for which records exist. They refuse to share the records of the first patients despite multiple requests.


In addition, you can take the genetic record of the Dec and later cases and see there was little adaptation going on. The virus was, for all intents and purposes, ready right out of the box. There are multiple citations supporting this.


You are choosing to ignore all that and instead hold on to some unsupported hypothesis that fits what you want to believe.
 
In the case of SARS 1 the virus came to the attention of the medical community because healthcare workers were catching it from patients who had a pneumonia of unknown cause. It didn't begin with cases of unnoticed spread that gradually became adapted enough to humans to seemingly spring up out of nowhere. The earliest cases had connections to wet markets. It took a couple months for the virus to adapt well to humans.
....

China has a similar monitoring system for flu and pneumonia as we do here in the US. The WHO team looked at the records of that monitoring for all of 2019. This was one of the records the team actually got to look at as opposed to being told what was in the records. There was no increase or even an unusual pattern of pneumonia in China in 2019 until shortly before the Dec COVID cases.

How do you square that with your claim that the virus was loose in early September? Surely the pattern of pneumonia that you said we would see would have been visible.

The Chinese government acknowledges there were cases prior to Dec for which records exist. They refuse to share the records of the first patients despite multiple requests.

Do you have a source for this?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom