Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
The bizarre number of these foreign gene sequences in early COVID samples and in this article I only glanced at earlier not having any grounding for it ...

Unexpected novel Merbecovirus discoveries in agricultural sequencing datasets from Wuhan, China

... helped make sense out of the data. It's an interesting read as it discusses at length the problem of 'index hopping' when analyzing genomes of organisms. I'm looking at the paper now but thought I'd share it for other people to look at as it appears to be key to whether a specimen is grossly contaminated or whether there is a technical issue with the analyses.

But that also begs the question, why were some of these specific viral pathogens there at all?


Abstract
In this study we document the unexpected discovery of multiple coronaviruses and a BSL-3 pathogen in agricultural cotton and rice sequencing datasets. In particular, we have identified a novel HKU5 related Merbecovirus in a cotton dataset sequenced by the Huazhong Agricultural University in 2017. We have also found an infectious clone sequence containing a novel HKU4-related Merbecovirus related to MERS coronavirus in a rice dataset sequenced by the Huazhong Agricultural University in early 2020. Another HKU5-related Merbecovirus, as well as Japanese encephalitis virus, were identified in a cotton dataset sequenced by the Huazhong Agricultural University in 2018. An HKU3-related Betacoronavirus was found in a Mus musculus sequencing dataset from the Wuhan Institute of Virology in 2017. Finally, a SARS-WIV1-like Betacoronavirus was found in a rice dataset sequenced by the Fujian Agriculture and Forestry University in 2017. Using the contaminating reads we have extracted from the above datasets, we were able to assemble complete genomes of two novel coronaviruses which we disclose herein. In light of our findings, we raise concerns about biosafety protocol breaches, as indicated by our discovery of multiple dangerous human pathogens in agricultural sequencing laboratories in Wuhan and Fouzou City, China.
 
Last edited:
The bizarre number of these foreign gene sequences in early COVID samples and in this article I only glanced at earlier not having any grounding for it ...

Unexpected novel Merbecovirus discoveries in agricultural sequencing datasets from Wuhan, China

... helped make sense out of the data. It's an interesting read as it discusses at length the problem of 'index hopping' when analyzing genomes of organisms. I'm looking at the paper now but thought I'd share it for other people to look at as it appears to be key to whether a specimen is grossly contaminated or whether there is a technical issue with the analyses.

But that also begs the question, why were some of these specific viral pathogens there at all?

From Drastic? I don’t know. Maybe I’ll wait for it to get peer-reviewed. The first name on the paper is known for his …. unorthodox theories.
 
Fauci vs Rand Paul

https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/fauci-blasts-rand-paul-covid-lab-theory-1247137/

Fauci is scarcely neutral but Rand Paul being a Republican moron will pay no heed to evidence.

Sums up some recent revelations.

First:
But Fauci is steadfast in his denial that the National Institutes of Health knowingly funded gain-of-function research on viruses that could have created Covid-19, telling George Stephanopoulos on Sunday, “It is molecularly impossible for those viruses that were worked on to turn into” Covid-19.
Fauci has no idea what all the WIV was doing as they have not been transparent.


“He’s probably never going to admit that he lied,” Paul said of Fauci. “He’s going to continue to dissemble and try to work around the truth and massage the truth.”
Just like Dump and a gazillion other GOP legislators do all the time.


The NIH sent a letter to Congress last week describing an “unexpected result” from research by EcoHealth Alliance that made a bat coronavirus more transmissible, but, according to Fauci, that was not the goal of the research, and it would have been “molecularly impossible” for that particular virus to turn into Covid-19.
This is BS but even taken on face value: It's not GoF because they didn't mean to? That's just stupid. What exactly was EcoH trying to do?

One need only look at the progress report Daszak submitted as required for the grant money he was spending to see that is exactly what they were doing. Of course again we have no way to know what data has been left out of that report.
 
First:Fauci has no idea what all the WIV was doing as they have not been transparent.

Fauci is not speaking for the WIV; he is speaking for the NIH, which is why he says that they have not knowingly funded gain-of-function at the WIV.

If the WIV did some by themselves, or with alternative funding, that would be a different issue.
 
Skeptic Ginger, would you mind acknowledging that one of the bat coronaviruses found in Laos, BANAL-52, is closer to SARS-CoV2 than RaTG13?

W.D Clinger and I have both pointed this out to you. If we are to get to the bottom of this, it would help to acknowledge the barest minimal facts, otherwise how can we trust each other's speculations?
 
Skeptic Ginger, would you mind acknowledging that one of the bat coronaviruses found in Laos, BANAL-52, is closer to SARS-CoV2 than RaTG13?

W.D Clinger and I have both pointed this out to you. If we are to get to the bottom of this, it would help to acknowledge the barest minimal facts, otherwise how can we trust each other's speculations?

I have no issue with that. It wasn't relevant and I'm not sure why you and Clinger think it is.

Would you mind acknowledging that the Laos discovery only adds the evidence that pieces of COVID 19 can be found in nature (though apparently we are still waiting to find the furin cleavage gene segment in a coronavirus in the wild) but there is no evidence of those pieces being together in one coronavirus, nor is there evidence of how any such assembled virus got from Laos to Wuhan?
 
I have no issue with that. It wasn't relevant and I'm not sure why you and Clinger think it is.

Would you mind acknowledging that the Laos discovery only adds the evidence that pieces of COVID 19 can be found in nature (though apparently we are still waiting to find the furin cleavage gene segment in a coronavirus in the wild) but there is no evidence of those pieces being together in one coronavirus, nor is there evidence of how any such assembled virus got from Laos to Wuhan?

Okay, good. Thanks for that.

I think the reason it is important is that as I have said some lab leakers assume that RaTG13 is the progenitor virus. With the discovery of BANAL-52 this theory is laid to rest in my opinion.

Similarly, it removes another objection that coronaviruses of its type don’t have this RBD. Even Yuri had to admit that he didn’t think one would show up.

To me it is looking more like the God of the gaps (or lab leak of the gaps) and the transitional fossils argument. The scientists are getting closer to discovering a virus which is similar to SARS-CoV2. Now, if one turns up in the wild with a furin-cleavage site what would be your response?

By the way, why is YOUR theory for how the closest known virus to SARS-CoV2 is in Laos?
 
Okay, good. Thanks for that.
And yet you ignored my request: "Would you mind acknowledging that the Laos discovery only adds the evidence that pieces of COVID 19 can be found in nature".


I think the reason it is important is that as I have said some lab leakers assume that RaTG13 is the progenitor virus. With the discovery of BANAL-52 this theory is laid to rest in my opinion.
Progenitor only in the sense it was a common ancestor, and I don't see how BANAL-52 is that much more closely related as a common ancestor than the Yunnan virus.

From the paper:
Last year, researchers described another close relative of SARS-CoV-2, called RaTG13, which was found in bats in Yunnan5. It is 96.1% identical to SARS-CoV-2 overall and the two viruses probably shared a common ancestor 40–70 years ago6. BANAL-52 is 96.8% identical to SARS-CoV-2, says Eloit — and all three newly discovered viruses have individual sections that are more similar to sections of SARS-CoV-2 than seen in any other viruses.
"Sections" as in not a single virus that looks like it is the ancestor of COVID. BANAL is 0.7% more similar. So how many years ago did any of these viruses share a common ancestor with COVID? Decades at a minimum?

This was discussed earlier on in the thread when there was a debate about the pangolin being the transitional species. The whole pangolin coronavirus was not a match, only one segment. And researchers found evidence recombinant events with bat coronaviruses were common. So a bat coronavirus in Yunnan could have acquired the pangolin segment without needing direct interaction with pangolins.

The only thing new here is evidence of more segments of COVID being found in the wild.


Similarly, it removes another objection that coronaviruses of its type don’t have this RBD. Even Yuri had to admit that he didn’t think one would show up.
You don't appear to remember we've had this discussion already. Early on in the thread when the furin cleavage and other COVID genetic irregularities were argued as the basis for it being a lab generated virus, it was pointed out all the 'irregularities' were found in nature. For me personally, I quit considering the furin cleavage and whatever else were direct evidence of a lab constructed virus. It wasn't something I had any special expertise in so I steered clear of the argument.

More recently I saw the argument in a citation that those gene segments were not found in SARS-CoVs or something like that. I put that in the back of my mind but I don't believe I posted that finding as evidence of the lab origin.

Now there are more segments of COVID being found in bat coronaviruses. So for me that is not 'evidence' of a smoking gun for a natural origin. IMO you've latched on to this finding the same way you latched on to the pangolin being the transitional species and they must have sold them at the seafood market in Wuhan.

They didn't even sell bats at the market and it has been noted, again in citations I've read, that consuming bats was not as common in China as it was being purported to be. I don't believe I posted consuming bats were uncommon, especially in Wuhan. I might have. I did did say there was a lack of bats in Wuhan wet markets and I might have mentioned the bat-soup fallacy then.

IMO consuming bats and the pangolin trade were only arguments against a natural spillover in that neither were found in the seafood market. Other people, other reports might have been using arguments that the gene segments in question were evidence of a lab origin. Feel free to argue with them. For me in this thread that is a straw man. Once I read that recombinant coronaviruses in bats were commonly found I didn't see finding these segments in COVID was evidence of a lab origin.


To me it is looking more like the God of the gaps (or lab leak of the gaps) and the transitional fossils argument. The scientists are getting closer to discovering a virus which is similar to SARS-CoV2. Now, if one turns up in the wild with a furin-cleavage site what would be your response?
To me it looks like you cherry pick an argument here and there and claim it is the argument for a lab leak. It's easy to battle straw men. How about battling the arguments you can't refute? Or better yet, how about arguing the bigger picture the evidence provides?


By the way, why is YOUR theory for how the closest known virus to SARS-CoV2 is in Laos?
Why it is in Laos? How about how the segments got from Laos to Wuhan all put together, ready to go to infect humans with such efficiency the recombinant virus became a worldwide pandemic in a couple of months?


You only see gap arguments because you cherry pick them and ignore the rest. For example there is now good evidence GoF research with SARS-CoVs was being done at the WIV. If I were to 'cherry pick' an argument of my own it would be that the 'no GoF at the WIV' research was no longer a valid argument against a lab origin. It appears that gap no longer exists for the spillover evidence. Care to address that?


Have you ever addressed Daszak's conflict of interest and his efforts to make everyone think the lab leak hypothesis was a CT? He's getting pilloried right now as he should be in some news and scientific circles. There are even calls for him to resign as head of EcoHealth Alliance. He's been kicked off any further WHO teams addressing the origin issue. And in the following citations on the matter, the Lancet which was developing an origin team, disbanded it because of Daszak's bias.

Business Insider: Chairman disbands panel investigating COVID-19's origins, saying its links to a nonprofit that worked with a Chinese lab raises bias concerns
A Lancet-affiliated scientist panel studying the origins of COVID-19 has been disbanded.
The chairman of the panel told WSJ he was concerned about its links to EcoHealth Alliance.
EcoHealth Alliance has been facing scrutiny over its connection to an institute in Wuhan.

BMJ: Covid-19: Lancet investigation into origin of pandemic shuts down over bias risk
The work of a task force commissioned by the Lancet into the origins of covid-19 has folded after concerns about the conflicts of interest of one its members and his ties through a non-profit organisation to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. ...

... shut down the scientist led investigation into how the covid-19 pandemic started because of concerns about its links to the EcoHealth Alliance, a non-profit organisation run by task force member Peter Daszak.1 ...

The decision came as evidence continued to accumulate that Daszak had not always been forthright about his research and his financial ties to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Daszak now faces increased scrutiny from scientists, the media, and members of US Congress.

EcoHealth Alliance has been given millions of dollars in grants by the US federal government to research viruses for pandemic preparedness. The alliance has subcontracted out its research, including around $600 000 (£434 000; €504 000) to the Wuhan Institute of Virology.2


So let's see, which pieces of evidence for the spillover argument have been refuted by the following findings?

There is evidence GoF research is being done at the WIV.
There is evidence they were experimenting with live viral cultures at the WIV.
That evidence includes adapting SARS CoVs to infecting human cells.
There is evidence of live bats at the WIV.
There is evidence Daszak has been lying.
There is evidence Shi has been lying.​


Then there is the evidence that has been there from the beginning arguing in favor of a lab-accident.

Two years of intensive search and no direct ancestor of COVID has been found.
No explanation for how the virus adapted so well to humans upon its first appearance.
No trail leading from anywhere horseshoe bats are found to Wuhan except what the researchers have collected in the field and brought back to the WIV.​
 
And yet you ignored my request: "Would you mind acknowledging that the Laos discovery only adds the evidence that pieces of COVID 19 can be found in nature".

Oh sorry. Yes, of course I acknowledge that. I consider the process of tracking down the progenitor virus to be a long-term project. I see no reason why if it is not found immediately it must be a lab leak.

The very point that these coronaviruses are widespread and that we are now finding whole sections identical to SARS-CoV2 in completely different areas to the Mojiang mine are evidence of a natural origin.


Progenitor only in the sense it was a common ancestor, and I don't see how BANAL-52 is that much more closely related as a common ancestor than the Yunnan virus.

No, RaTG13 is several decades removed from SARS-CoV2, whereas BANAL-52 and the other Laos viruses could well be much closer to SARS-CoV2 temporally:

Last year, researchers described another close relative of SARS-CoV-2, called RaTG13, which was found in bats in Yunnan5. It is 96.1% identical to SARS-CoV-2 overall and the two viruses probably shared a common ancestor 40–70 years ago6. BANAL-52 is 96.8% identical to SARS-CoV-2, says Eloit — and all three newly discovered viruses have individual sections that are more similar to sections of SARS-CoV-2 than seen in any other viruses.

Viruses swap chunks of RNA with one another through a process called recombination, and one section in BANAL-103 and BANAL-52 could have shared an ancestor with sections of SARS-CoV-2 less than a decade ago, says Spyros Lytras, an evolutionary virologist at the University of Glasgow. “These viruses recombine so much that different bits of the genome have different evolutionary histories,” he says.

From the paper:"Sections" as in not a single virus that looks like it is the ancestor of COVID. BANAL is 0.7% more similar. So how many years ago did any of these viruses share a common ancestor with COVID? Decades at a minimum?

Really, Skeptic Ginger! It was in the section that YOU quoted when you accused me of not reading beyond the headlines.

This was discussed earlier on in the thread when there was a debate about the pangolin being the transitional species. The whole pangolin coronavirus was not a match, only one segment. And researchers found evidence recombinant events with bat coronaviruses were common. So a bat coronavirus in Yunnan could have acquired the pangolin segment without needing direct interaction with pangolins.

The only thing new here is evidence of more segments of COVID being found in the wild.


You don't appear to remember we've had this discussion already. Early on in the thread when the furin cleavage and other COVID genetic irregularities were argued as the basis for it being a lab generated virus, it was pointed out all the 'irregularities' were found in nature. For me personally, I quit considering the furin cleavage and whatever else were direct evidence of a lab constructed virus. It wasn't something I had any special expertise in so I steered clear of the argument.

More recently I saw the argument in a citation that those gene segments were not found in SARS-CoVs or something like that. I put that in the back of my mind but I don't believe I posted that finding as evidence of the lab origin.

Now there are more segments of COVID being found in bat coronaviruses. So for me that is not 'evidence' of a smoking gun for a natural origin. IMO you've latched on to this finding the same way you latched on to the pangolin being the transitional species and they must have sold them at the seafood market in Wuhan.
They didn't even sell bats at the market and it has been noted, again in citations I've read, that consuming bats was not as common in China as it was being purported to be. I don't believe I posted consuming bats were uncommon, especially in Wuhan. I might have. I did did say there was a lack of bats in Wuhan wet markets and I might have mentioned the bat-soup fallacy then.

IMO consuming bats and the pangolin trade were only arguments against a natural spillover in that neither were found in the seafood market. Other people, other reports might have been using arguments that the gene segments in question were evidence of a lab origin. Feel free to argue with them. For me in this thread that is a straw man. Once I read that recombinant coronaviruses in bats were commonly found I didn't see finding these segments in COVID was evidence of a lab origin.

I never "latched onto the pangolin" thing. Why are you telling porkie pies?

I suppose you may have got me confused with someone else.

I also never claimed that people got the virus by eating bats.

What I have done is shown an interest in the idea that the wildlife trade is central to the story. I don't know what the immediate incubator host could be for the virus, but I think Garry and Worobey have made some persuasive arguments, and there was also that study which talked about how much wildlife there was (my understanding is that pangolins and bats were NOT traded in the markets - so please don't go telling me that that is my theory).

My own pet theory is that a small wildlife farm reared the virus somehow and then was shipped to Wuhan after the swine flu epidemic had led to a mass culling of pigs and an increased demand for wildlife. That is a pet theory, however, and not one that I think anyone should buy into without greater evidence.

Also, the natural spillover theory does not talk of smoking guns. All that this does is provide further evidence that the bats that carry similar viruses need not be confined to the Mojiang mine where many of the the lab leak theories are centred.

To me it looks like you cherry pick an argument here and there and claim it is the argument for a lab leak. It's easy to battle straw men. How about battling the arguments you can't refute? Or better yet, how about arguing the bigger picture the evidence provides?


Why it is in Laos? How about how the segments got from Laos to Wuhan all put together, ready to go to infect humans with such efficiency the recombinant virus became a worldwide pandemic in a couple of months?


You only see gap arguments because you cherry pick them and ignore the rest. For example there is now good evidence GoF research with SARS-CoVs was being done at the WIV. If I were to 'cherry pick' an argument of my own it would be that the 'no GoF at the WIV' research was no longer a valid argument against a lab origin. It appears that gap no longer exists for the spillover evidence. Care to address that?


Have you ever addressed Daszak's conflict of interest and his efforts to make everyone think the lab leak hypothesis was a CT? He's getting pilloried right now as he should be in some news and scientific circles. There are even calls for him to resign as head of EcoHealth Alliance. He's been kicked off any further WHO teams addressing the origin issue. And in the following citations on the matter, the Lancet which was developing an origin team, disbanded it because of Daszak's bias.

Business Insider: Chairman disbands panel investigating COVID-19's origins, saying its links to a nonprofit that worked with a Chinese lab raises bias concerns


BMJ: Covid-19: Lancet investigation into origin of pandemic shuts down over bias risk



So let's see, which pieces of evidence for the spillover argument have been refuted by the following findings?

There is evidence GoF research is being done at the WIV.
There is evidence they were experimenting with live viral cultures at the WIV.
That evidence includes adapting SARS CoVs to infecting human cells.
There is evidence of live bats at the WIV.
There is evidence Daszak has been lying.
There is evidence Shi has been lying.​


Then there is the evidence that has been there from the beginning arguing in favor of a lab-accident.

Two years of intensive search and no direct ancestor of COVID has been found.
No explanation for how the virus adapted so well to humans upon its first appearance.
No trail leading from anywhere horseshoe bats are found to Wuhan except what the researchers have collected in the field and brought back to the WIV.​

The rest of this is a kind of Gish Gallop of stuff we have hashed over multiple times.

If you want to talk about a specific thing, bring that up, but you have changed the subject from the Laos coronaviruses by asking me to address twenty five different things, much of which we have discussed endlessly ("Have you ever addressed Daszak's conflict of interest and his efforts to make everyone think the lab leak hypothesis was a CT?" - FFS, what?!?!? I think we went over this over and over again. Talk about flogging a dead horse!)
 
Gish gallop my ass. You have a problem with well documented POVs.

So what I went from your cherry picked evidence to some of the rest of the evidence? Is that some kind of faux pas? Is there a rule only one bit of evidence per post? Seriously? And for the record, I didn't change the subject, I finished commenting on it and moved on.

I'll address the rest in subsequent posts (plural). Apparently you need smaller bites or you ignore the content. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Let's look at this quote that you misread:

ne section in BANAL-103 and BANAL-52 could have shared an ancestor with sections of SARS-CoV-2 less than a decade ago, says Spyros Lytras, an evolutionary virologist at the University of Glasgow.
See that piece you ignored?
 
Gish gallop my ass. You have a problem with well documented POVs.
So what I went from your cherry picked evidence to some of the rest of the evidence? Is that some kind of faux pas? Is there a rule only one bit of evidence per post? Seriously? And for the record, I didn't change the subject, I finished commenting on it and moved on.

I'll address the rest in subsequent posts (plural). Apparently you need smaller bites or you ignore the content. :rolleyes:

I don't understand what you mean about "well-documented POVs".

And yes, what you did in that post is a classic Gish Gallop. Absolute textbook.

I'm talking about the Laos virus and you want to talk about Peter Daszak's conflict of interest. And Shi "lying".

We have been round those mulberry bushes a million times. It looks like the only reason you want to go round them again is to change the subject.
 
Re the pangolin, going through the first 15 pages you aren't the one pushing that hypothesis, but wow, you sure did suck up Daszak's and Shi's lies and distortions as fact.

You really need to take a look at what has come to light in the last 6 months about their dishonesty.

You also call the evidence I presented as "not evidence" and you simply hand-waved away anything you could if the source was too right-wing for you. In doing so you ignored the content in the citations.
 
I don't understand what you mean about "well-documented POVs".

And yes, what you did in that post is a classic Gish Gallop. Absolute textbook.

I'm talking about the Laos virus and you want to talk about Peter Daszak's conflict of interest. And Shi "lying".

We have been round those mulberry bushes a million times. It looks like the only reason you want to go round them again is to change the subject.
You are repeating your insistence that I should only have discussed your cherry-picked evidence in my post. I'll move the rest to new posts so you can actually address the issues instead of dismissing them as tl,dr.
 
Re the pangolin, going through the first 15 pages you aren't the one pushing that hypothesis,


*ding*

Thank you.

but wow, you sure did suck up Daszak's and Shi's lies and distortions as fact.

You really need to take a look at what has come to light in the last 6 months about their dishonesty.

Hey, you're the one who has suddenly decided that the first 15 pages of this thread are now the topic.

It's funny that you are always getting upset that people are making this thread about you, and arguing that this thread should be about the evidence, but now suddenly you don't want to talk about the evidence of the Laos virsu and instead want to talk about how much I agreed with Daszak and Shi on the first 15 pages of this thread.

You also call the evidence I presented as "not evidence" and you simply hand-waved away anything you could if the source was too right-wing for you. In doing so you ignored the content in the citations.

*sigh*

Let's face it, much of what you posted, when put through the right-wing spin machine was indeed nonsense or from very low quality sources.
 
You are repeating your insistence that I should only have discussed your cherry-picked evidence in my post. I'll move the rest to new posts so you can actually address the issues instead of dismissing them as tl,dr.

Gish Gallop, definition:

Gish Gallop is a technique, named after the creationist Duane Gish who employed it, whereby someone argues a cause by hurling as many different half-truths and no-truths into a very short space of time so that their opponent cannot hope to combat each point in real time.

Example:

So let's see, which pieces of evidence for the spillover argument have been refuted by the following findings?

There is evidence GoF research is being done at the WIV.
There is evidence they were experimenting with live viral cultures at the WIV.
That evidence includes adapting SARS CoVs to infecting human cells.
There is evidence of live bats at the WIV.
There is evidence Daszak has been lying.
There is evidence Shi has been lying.​


Then there is the evidence that has been there from the beginning arguing in favor of a lab-accident.

Two years of intensive search and no direct ancestor of COVID has been found.
No explanation for how the virus adapted so well to humans upon its first appearance.
No trail leading from anywhere horseshoe bats are found to Wuhan except what the researchers have collected in the field and brought back to the WIV.​
 
Oh sorry. Yes, of course I acknowledge that. I consider the process of tracking down the progenitor virus to be a long-term project. I see no reason why if it is not found immediately it must be a lab leak.

The very point that these coronaviruses are widespread and that we are now finding whole sections identical to SARS-CoV2 in completely different areas to the Mojiang mine are evidence of a natural origin.

No, RaTG13 is several decades removed from SARS-CoV2, whereas BANAL-52 and the other Laos viruses could well be much closer to SARS-CoV2 temporally:

Really, Skeptic Ginger! It was in the section that YOU quoted when you accused me of not reading beyond the headlines.
Addressed, waiting your response..

I never "latched onto the pangolin" thing. Why are you telling porkie pies?

I suppose you may have got me confused with someone else.

I also never claimed that people got the virus by eating bats.
Addressed. No reply needed.


What I have done is shown an interest in the idea that the wildlife trade is central to the story. I don't know what the immediate incubator host could be for the virus, but I think Garry and Worobey have made some persuasive arguments, and there was also that study which talked about how much wildlife there was (my understanding is that pangolins and bats were NOT traded in the markets - so please don't go telling me that that is my theory).

My own pet theory is that a small wildlife farm reared the virus somehow and then was shipped to Wuhan after the swine flu epidemic had led to a mass culling of pigs and an increased demand for wildlife. That is a pet theory, however, and not one that I think anyone should buy into without greater evidence.

Also, the natural spillover theory does not talk of smoking guns. All that this does is provide further evidence that the bats that carry similar viruses need not be confined to the Mojiang mine where many of the the lab leak theories are centred.
There's no evidence after an intense 2 year search that any wild animal, animal farm, frozen food, or patient zero coming from outside Wuhan were involved in the origin of the outbreak.

Multiple source corroborate that patient zero was infected in Wuhan sometime in or after Sept 2019 and it was out-of-the-box ready to go from the beginning.

You are speculating on hypotheses that have failed to be supported by any evidence. Researchers are moving on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom