Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Isn't Henipavirus just a portmanteau of Hendra (discovered in Australia) and Nipah (discovered in ...er...Nipah in Malaysia)?

There was also supposedly a henipahvirus found in the Mojiang mine as well.
 
Isn't Henipavirus just a portmanteau of Hendra (discovered in Australia) and Nipah (discovered in ...er...Nipah in Malaysia)?

There was also supposedly a henipahvirus found in the Mojiang mine as well.

They are in the same genus of Henipahvirus but are distinct.
 
DetectedMotion is asking for information about this

This is not the thread for discussing coronavirus conspiracy theories, but it looks to me as though DetectedMotion entered this thread in search of information that would counter a talking point that appears to have originated, or at least to have become popular, in an interview conducted by Reiner Fuellmich. I viewed that interview at the urging of an anti-vaxxer acquaintance of mine, but I don't want to link to it here.

Instead, I will link to a fact check of an interview of Fuellmich conducted by Steve Bannon, in which Fuellmich restates many of the claims made in the interview that I suspect to have been the origin of the talking point that concerns DetectedMotion. I will also link to a FOIA request that may well be the one DetectedMotion heard about.

From Fact Check: Video Does NOT Reveal Proof COVID-19 Pandemic Is A Fake Planned By Global Elites Seeking World Dominion:

[size=+1]Claim: There is no coronavirus pandemic[/size]

At three minutes into the video, citing "all the really important people in the field" Fuellmich says "... what is happening right now, in our view is not a pandemic, at least it's not a corona pandemic, rather it's a PCR test pandemic."

...snip...

[size=+1]Claim: The PCR test is creating false positive tests for COVID-19[/size]

Fuellmich, at 13 minutes, 51 seconds, declares without evidence that PCR test results are invalid.

...snip...

[size=+1]Claim: The pandemic was staged by power- and profit-mad elites[/size]

Fuellmich, at three minutes 18 seconds, begins the first of his two recitations of the conspiracy theory on Bannon's show:

The plans for this were made, concrete plans for this pandemic were made by very rich and powerful people some 10 years ago, amongst them the Rockefeller Foundation.

...snip...

[size=+1]Claim: Video "reveals" how pandemic was planned[/size]

Fuellmich himself undermines the video's headline, which promises revelations.

"The evidence that I have collected wasn't really collected by myself, but it was collected by the Berlin Corona Investigative Committee," he says at one minute 45 seconds into the video.

...snip...

Even Bannon, who invited Fuellmich on his show and let him speak for almost 20 minutes straight, breaks in to express concern about this idea, saying, at 11 minutes into Fuellmich's monologue "... It sounds crazy on the face of it."

...snip...

Fuellmich's general summary is as follows, starting at 12 minutes 19 seconds:

The whole thing did in fact start with that accident at the Wuhan Virology Lab ... This was their springboard or triggering point because they've been planning for this, the other side, meaning very powerful and rich people who through companies, funds like Black Rock ... these people have been planning for this for at least 10 years.

On 14 October 2021, someone named Sara Cooke submitted an FOIA request to the office of Massachusetts state governor Charles Baker. Here is the relevant excerpt from that letter:

Under the Freedom of Information Act and pursuant to the Massachusetts Public Records Law (950 CMR 32.00), I hereby request the following information:

1) All records of scientific laboratory tests, under a microscope, analyzing and identifying the COVID-19 (SARS-CoV-2) virus from isolated samples extracted from a human being. This sample must be taken directly from a human being, where the patient sample was not first combined with any other source of genetic material or contamination.
2) All records of scientific laboratory tests, under a microscope, analyzing and identifying the COVID-19 delta variant (SARS-CoV-2) virus from isolated samples extracted from a human being. This sample must be taken directly from a human being, where the patient sample was not first combined with any other source of genetic material or contamination.

I am unable to find proof of the above. Please ensure your response includes the specific criteria requested above of laboratory tests, under a microscope, from isolated samples extracted from a human being.
Surely, the governor and/or his agents must have this information. I cannot see Governor Charles Baker signing EUAs (Emergency Use Authorizations) or implementing contact tracing, curfews, testing requirements, or mask mandates without having proof that a virus (or a variant of said virus) exists.


The state's response quoted the request I quoted above, down to but not including "I am unable to find proof of the above", followed by

We have received your correspondence and have concluded that this Office has no records responsive to your request. Thank you.


ETA: Upon re-reading DetectedMotion's most recent post, I see there was a similar FOIA request made in the state of Illinois. Anti-vaxxers might well be submitting similar FOIA requests in every state. According to DetectedMotion, the talking point that is the subject of these FOIA requests is also becoming a basis for lawsuits. Inasmuch as none of this has anything to do with the actual origins of COVID-19, it might be better to continue this conversation in the thread(s) devoted to coronavirus conspiracy theories.
 
Last edited:
This is not the thread for discussing coronavirus conspiracy theories, but it looks to me as though DetectedMotion entered this thread in search of information that would counter a talking point that appears to have originated, or at least to have become popular, in an interview conducted by Reiner Fuellmich. I viewed that interview at the urging of an anti-vaxxer acquaintance of mine, but I don't want to link to it here.

Instead, I will link to a fact check of an interview of Fuellmich conducted by Steve Bannon, in which Fuellmich restates many of the claims made in the interview that I suspect to have been the origin of the talking point that concerns DetectedMotion. I will also link to a FOIA request that may well be the one DetectedMotion heard about.

From Fact Check: Video Does NOT Reveal Proof COVID-19 Pandemic Is A Fake Planned By Global Elites Seeking World Dominion:

​

On 14 October 2021, someone named Sara Cooke submitted an FOIA request to the office of Massachusetts state governor Charles Baker. Here is the relevant excerpt from that letter:




The state's response quoted the request I quoted above, down to but not including "I am unable to find proof of the above", followed by

It's the old Kary Mullis misquote about the PCR test again. And "Under a microscope" wtf?
 
Isn't Henipavirus just a portmanteau of Hendra (discovered in Australia) and Nipah (discovered in ...er...Nipah in Malaysia)?

There was also supposedly a henipahvirus found in the Mojiang mine as well.
You could just read the Wiki entries on both, and maybe once in a while actually read or at least skim the citations instead of handwaving them without a glance. :rolleyes:


There are several papers prior to 2019 which mention the rat paramyxovirus as a potential cause of the miners' illness.

In 2017 it was suggested the novel paramyxovirus could have been missed by the tests used on the 2012 miners.

Idiosyncratic Mòjiāng virus attachment glycoprotein directs a host-cell entry pathway distinct from genetically related henipaviruses
Furthermore, we find that MojV-G is antigenically distinct, indicating that MojV would less likely be detected in existing large-scale serological screening studies focused on well-established HNVs.



But it doesn't seem like the idea went very far.

Science, 2014: A New Killer Virus in China? - Novel pathogen found in cave may solve medical mystery
The three victims in Yunnan succumbed long before scientists arrived on the scene, so "we have not established a direct relationship between human infection and MojV," says Qi Jin, director of the State Key Laboratory for Molecular Virology and Genetic Engineering in Beijing, and leader of the new work, reported in the June issue of Emerging Infectious Diseases. The new virus and any relatives, if they exist, are keeping a low profile. Jin's team sampled bats from the cave in Mojiang a second time and again came up empty. More recently, he says, a "systemic viral survey" in 38 bat species across China conducted by his team failed to turn up any henipaviruses. He believes rodents should be further investigated as potential wildlife reservoirs of henipavirus. But for the time being, Jin says, MojV is "more likely a curiosity."


This is another cite that I have in a downloaded PDF and can't link to.
Short note - Understanding the origin of ‘BatCoVRaTG13’, a virus closest to SARS-CoV-2; Monali C. Rahalkar1 and Rahul A. Bahulikar2

... Later on, a paramyxovirus was isolated from the rats in these mines, however, the correlationship between the MojV and pneumonia cases was not made 7. The news about the deaths of mineworkers was also covered in the Science journal 7
May 2020: Understanding the Origin of ‘BatCoVRaTG13’, a Virus Closest to SARS-CoV-2; Monali C. Rahalkar * and Rahul A. Bahulikar
The "short note" is related but the quote is not in this paper.



Frontiers in Public Health, Oct 2020: Lethal Pneumonia Cases in Mojiang Miners (2012) and the Mineshaft Could Provide Important Clues to the Origin of SARS-CoV-2
The Science article describes that a paramyxovirus, MojV was isolated from a rat sample in the same mine (4). Two further papers reported that no direct relationship between human infection and MojV could be established (4–6). In the Scientific American interview, Dr. Zhengli Shi outlines that fungus was responsible for pneumonia in the miners (2). However, no detailed information was elucidated in literature and the cause of the miners' illness remained a mystery.
One wonders why Shi didn't mention the paramyxovirus.


That's as far down the rabbit hole as I'm going at the moment. Whether it explains the miners' illness or not, I can't find any evidence the paramyxovirus is related to the Nipah virus found in the initial COVID specimens from the seafood market sequenced at the WIV which is the bottom line.
 
It was requested evidence of GoF research at WIV be provided. In addition there was the Rand Paul-Fauci exchange about what constitutes GoF, did the US fund said research at the WIV, and did Fauci lie to Congress.

I don't care about the definition Fauci was using to claim it wasn't GoF research and I don't care if he lied or didn't lie to Congress. And Rand Paul's little hearing drama was stupid.

But now someone from the NIH sent a letter to GOP rep James Comer.
But a letter from the NIH to Ranking Member Rep. James Comer of the House Committee on Oversight and Reform Wednesday admitted to a "limited experiment" conducted in order to test if "spike proteins from naturally occurring bat coronaviruses circulating in China were capable of binding to the human ACE2 receptor in a mouse model" – contradicting Fauci’s previous claims.

It was a wee bit more than a limited experiment. And tough tiddlywinks this is being reported in Fox. Their news department is not as far gone as the idiot talking heads that have a platform on Fox. It matters not because the evidence is not a news report, it is the RPPR (Research Performance Progress Report) annual report for 2018-2019 submitted 08/03/2021

Not sure why this is only coming to light now but it may have been a request by Comer for more information. The letter to Comer is signed by Lawrence Tabak, Principle Deputy Director. It was embedded in this Tweet:
July 28th NIH says “no NIAID funding was approved for Gain of Function research at the WIV.”
Obviously, they were lied to.
NIH confirmed today EcoHealth and the WIV conducted GOF research on bat coronaviruses.
@PeterDaszak with EcoHealth hid it from the USG.

Back to the RPPR:
.... To understand the risk of zoonotic CoV emergence, we propose to examine 1) the transmission dynamics of bat-CoVs across the human-wildlife interface, and 2) how this process is affected by CoV evolutionary potential, and how it might force CoV evolution. ..In this study, we propose three specific aims and will screen free ranging and captive bats in China for known and novel coronaviruses; screen people who have high occupational exposure to bats and other wildlife; and examine the genetics and receptor binding properties of novel bat-CoVs we have already identified and those we will discover...

As was posted in a cite upthread, they found only a minuscule evidence of spillover.
During Year 5, we finalized the analysis of both quantitative and qualitative data from human surveillance in three provinces in Southern China: Yunnan, Guangxi, and Guangdong provinces. ... Serological testing of serum samples from 1,497 local residents revealed 9 individuals (0.6%) were positive for bat coronavirus, indicating exposure at any point in their life to bat-born SARS related Coronavirus (n=7, Yunnan) and HKU10 Coronavirus (n=2, Guangxi), or other coronaviruses that are phylogenetically closely related to these two coronaviruses...
Clearly not the risk Daszak was hoping to find. Didn't stop him from extrapolating how that represented thousands of potentially infected people. Maybe there was some random sampling in there. :rolleyes:

But I digress.
From May to October 2018, we collected 1,697 rectal swabs, oral swabs, and feces specimens from 26 bat species in Hubei, Shandong, Yunnan and Guangdong Provinces across southern, central and northern China in Year 5, ...
Anyone interested can read more about the data these busy little beavers collected in the paper.


It's this part of the report that is most important:
In Year 5, we continued with in vivo infection experiments of diverse bat SARSr-CoVs on transgenic mice expressing human ACE2. Mice were infected with 4 strains of SARSr-CoVs with different S protein, including the full-length recombinant virus of SARSr-CoV WIV1 and three chimeric viruses with the backbone of WIV1 and S proteins of SHC014, WIV16 and Rs4231, respectively. Pathogenicity of the 4 SARSr-CoVs was evaluated by recording the survival rate of challenged mice in a 2-week course. All of the 4 SARSr-CoVs caused lethal infection in hACE2 transgenic mice,...


Taking a reverse genetic strategy that we used in SARSSr-CoV studies we constructed the full-length infectious clone of MERS-CoV and replaced the RBD of MERS-CoV with the RBDs of various strains of HKU4-related coronaviruses previously identified in bats from different provinces in southern China. ... these chimeric MERS-HKU4r-RBD coronaviruses were able to infect human cells from different tissues including lung, liver, intestine and kidney. ... The results suggest potential risk of the bat HKU4r-CoVs for cross-species infection in humans.

Keep in mind this is from work they were doing up until May of 2019. If these mix and match chimeras and other fashioned CoVs don't match up with COVID 19, they weren't done. I should also point out all this work was done at the WIV. EcoHealth doesn't have any labs of their own.
 
Last edited:
To address a few loose ends:

Sept 12 China took a large conronavirus genome database offline and has refused to share the information. I knew I'd read one source putting the first COVID case back as far as Sept but couldn't find it again earlier.

Here it is:

Science Daily: COVID-19: Genetic network analysis provides 'snapshot' of pandemic origins
Since today's PNAS study was conducted, the research team has extended its analysis to 1,001 viral genomes. While yet to be peer-reviewed, Forster says the latest work suggests that the first infection and spread among humans of COVID-19 occurred between mid-September and early December.



Then there was the question I kept asking: if the A & B lineages in the first COVID patients were evidence the virus was circulating before it reached Wuhan, where was this and what was the evidence? I have seen it referenced before that A simply preceded B but both began in Wuhan. This article is more specific:

The PNAS study linked to in the Science Daily article:
Phylogenetic network analysis of SARS-CoV-2 genomes
In a phylogenetic network analysis of 160 complete human severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-Cov-2) genomes, we find three central variants distinguished by amino acid changes, which we have named A, B, and C, with A being the ancestral type according to the bat outgroup coronavirus. The A and C types are found in significant proportions outside East Asia, that is, in Europeans and Americans. In contrast, the B type is the most common type in East Asia, and its ancestral genome appears not to have spread outside East Asia without first mutating into derived B types, pointing to founder effects or immunological or environmental resistance against this type outside Asia. ...

Node B is derived from A by two mutations
That hardly suggests the lineages began in distant geographical locations or at different times. The article describes where each lineage spread to, adding lineage C which evolved from B. They make suggestions as to why each spread where it eventually did.
 
And something new supporting the conclusion COVID started in Wuhan ready to go in humans sometime in or after Sept 2019:

We already know there has been no evidence of COVID circulating in humans, bats or an intermediate species developing an adaptation to spread in humans before it emerged. Most if not all zoonosis take a few generations or more to adapt well in the new species it jumps to. The evidence overwhelmingly supports the conclusion COVID arose ready to go right out of the gate. Not only that, it appears it arose well adapted not just to cells lining human airways, but to lung tissue itself.

Evolutionary Bioinformatics Online; Oct 8, 2021: Compelling Evidence Suggesting the Codon Usage of SARS-CoV-2 Adapts to Human After the Split From RaTG13
From the abstract:
SARS-CoV-2 needs to efficiently make use of the resources from hosts in order to survive and propagate. Among the multiple layers of regulatory network, mRNA translation is the rate-limiting step in gene expression. Synonymous codon usage usually conforms with tRNA concentration to allow fast decoding during translation. It is acknowledged that SARS-CoV-2 has adapted to the codon usage of human lungs so that the virus could rapidly proliferate in the lung environment. While this notion seems to nicely explain the adaptation of SARS-CoV-2 to lungs, it is unable to tell why other viruses do not have this advantage. ...

We calculate the RSCU (relative synonymous codon usage) weighted by gene expression in each human sample, and investigate the correlation of RSCU between the human tissues and SARS-CoV-2 or RaTG13 (the closest coronavirus to SARS-CoV-2). Lung has the highest correlation of RSCU to SARS-CoV-2 among all tissues, suggesting that the lung environment is generally suitable for SARS-CoV-2. Interestingly, for most tissues, SARS-CoV-2 has higher correlations with the human samples compared with the RaTG13-human correlation. This difference is most significant for lungs. In conclusion, the codon usage of SARS-CoV-2 has adapted to human lungs to allow fast decoding and translation. ...

This finding depicts the trajectory of adaptive evolution from ancestral sequence to SARS-CoV-2, and also well explains why SARS-CoV-2 rather than other viruses could perfectly adapt to human lung environment. ...

They only note COVID differs in this trait from the closest known coronavirus, RaTG13. They don't suggest how this adaptation was acquired.
 
And something new supporting the conclusion COVID started in Wuhan ready to go in humans sometime in or after Sept 2019:

We already know there has been no evidence of COVID circulating in humans, bats or an intermediate species developing an adaptation to spread in humans before it emerged. Most if not all zoonosis take a few generations or more to adapt well in the new species it jumps to. The evidence overwhelmingly supports the conclusion COVID arose ready to go right out of the gate. Not only that, it appears it arose well adapted not just to cells lining human airways, but to lung tissue itself.

Evolutionary Bioinformatics Online; Oct 8, 2021: Compelling Evidence Suggesting the Codon Usage of SARS-CoV-2 Adapts to Human After the Split From RaTG13
From the abstract:

They only note COVID differs in this trait from the closest known coronavirus, RaTG13. They don't suggest how this adaptation was acquired.

To me that only confirms that RaTG13 was not the basis of SARS-CoV2. Literally no zoonotic spillover proponents would expect anything else.
 
RaTG13 is only of peripheral interest to the origins story except for lab leakers who often consider it to be central. What is being said here is RaTG13 is not central.
 
RaTG13 is only of peripheral interest to the origins story except for lab leakers who often consider it to be central. What is being said here is RaTG13 is not central.
The difference between RaTG13 and COVID was not the central issue. It's all the researchers had to compare as "the closest to COVID" given after 2 years no other COVID related viruses have been found in any animal species be it humans, bats or some other transitional species.

You missed the key point of the article: The initial outbreak in humans in Wuhan remains the only place they've found anything close to COVID 19.

The report corroborates that this virus appeared in humans not just ready to go, but ready to infect lungs and ready to rapidly spread from person to person. Where did COVID acquire this adaptation? Are you ready to apply Occam's Razor to the current circumstances yet? A spillover is not the hypothesis best supported by the evidence unless you can explain how COVID 19 appeared on the spot ready to go.

It had to have acquired the exquisite adaptation to humans somewhere.

The WHO report found no evidence it started outside of Wuhan or that it started much earlier than it was first seen. And it spread incredibly fast from patient zero. Yet there's no evidence it was passed about from person to person getting better adapted to humans like SARS 1 was in the first few months.

H5N1 HPAI has yet to make that leap and it's been years since it first infected humans. It has infected a few people in direct contact with the source animal. But humans shed little virus, enough to infect family members but it has yet to adapt to shed a large enough viral load to spread efficiently let alone rapidly person to person.

A period of time for a virus to adapt to the new human host is key to a zoonosis. At this point the only explanation that fits the evidence is that adaptation occurred in a lab rather than in the wild.
 
The difference between RaTG13 and COVID was not the central issue. It's all the researchers had to compare as "the closest to COVID" given after 2 years no other COVID related viruses have been found in any animal species be it humans, bats or some other transitional species.

You missed the key point of the article: The initial outbreak in humans in Wuhan remains the only place they've found anything close to COVID 19.

The report corroborates that this virus appeared in humans not just ready to go, but ready to infect lungs and ready to rapidly spread from person to person. Where did COVID acquire this adaptation? Are you ready to apply Occam's Razor to the current circumstances yet? A spillover is not the hypothesis best supported by the evidence unless you can explain how COVID 19 appeared on the spot ready to go.

It had to have acquired the exquisite adaptation to humans somewhere.

The WHO report found no evidence it started outside of Wuhan or that it started much earlier than it was first seen. And it spread incredibly fast from patient zero. Yet there's no evidence it was passed about from person to person getting better adapted to humans like SARS 1 was in the first few months.

H5N1 HPAI has yet to make that leap and it's been years since it first infected humans. It has infected a few people in direct contact with the source animal. But humans shed little virus, enough to infect family members but it has yet to adapt to shed a large enough viral load to spread efficiently let alone rapidly person to person.

A period of time for a virus to adapt to the new human host is key to a zoonosis. At this point the only explanation that fits the evidence is that adaptation occurred in a lab rather than in the wild.

No, the finding of the bat viruses in Laos demonstrates that evidence for a natural origin is cumulatively emerging:

Scientists have found three viruses in bats in Laos that are more similar to SARS-CoV-2 than any known viruses. Researchers say that parts of their genetic code bolster claims that the virus behind COVID-19 has a natural origin — but their discovery also raises fears that there are numerous coronaviruses with the potential to infect people.

Link

Ockham's razor states: "entities should not be multiplied beyond necessity".

We know that viruses can spillover from animals to humans, and we have ample evidence that this is happening on a fairly regular basis.

You are arguing that, no, natural origin is not sufficient to explain the pandemic, we must also have a lab, and secret gain of function, and a progenitor virus that is still unknown, etc...

I am not convinced that Ockham's razor favours a lab leak.
 
You are arguing that, no, natural origin is not sufficient to explain the pandemic, we must also have a lab, and secret gain of function, and a progenitor virus that is still unknown, etc...

I am not convinced that Ockham's razor favours a lab leak.
I don’t think you can wield Ockham’s razor that easily.

Natural origin is indeed a viable option, but your list of dependencies is flawed. You could also say that instead of an “unknown progenitor virus” and “secret gain of function” the lab leak is dependent on a repressive political system, and an a lab accident (that we know happens every so often).
 
I don’t think you can wield Ockham’s razor that easily.

Natural origin is indeed a viable option, but your list of dependencies is flawed. You could also say that instead of an “unknown progenitor virus” and “secret gain of function” the lab leak is dependent on a repressive political system, and an a lab accident (that we know happens every so often).

I wasn't the one to bring up Ockham's razor. SG was. I was pointing out that it can go both ways.
 
No, the finding of the bat viruses in Laos demonstrates that evidence for a natural origin is cumulatively emerging:

Link

Ockham's razor states: "entities should not be multiplied beyond necessity".

We know that viruses can spillover from animals to humans, and we have ample evidence that this is happening on a fairly regular basis.

You are arguing that, no, natural origin is not sufficient to explain the pandemic, we must also have a lab, and secret gain of function, and a progenitor virus that is still unknown, etc...

I am not convinced that Ockham's razor favours a lab leak.
You've been reading headlines without reading the actual research papers.
The finding of those 3 viruses in Laos are akin to the piece of COVID that might have come from a recombinant event like it's been suggested the piece from a pangolin coronavirus. IOW, if you read the actual report on the finding, all they found were some virus strains with certain pieces of COVID 19 the same way there is a piece in pangolin coronaviruses.

The argument was some pieces of COVID 19 didn't look like they appeared in nature. Now you have more pieces that could have come together in a recombinant event.

From your link:
... they found viruses that are each more than 95% identical to SARS-CoV-2, which they named BANAL-52, BANAL-103 and BANAL-236. ...

Last year, researchers described another close relative of SARS-CoV-2, called RaTG13, which was found in bats in Yunnan5. It is 96.1% identical to SARS-CoV-2 overall and the two viruses probably shared a common ancestor 40–70 years ago6. BANAL-52 is 96.8% identical to SARS-CoV-2, says Eloit — and all three newly discovered viruses have individual sections that are more similar to sections of SARS-CoV-2 than seen in any other viruses. ...

Viruses swap chunks of RNA with one another through a process called recombination, and one section in BANAL-103 and BANAL-52 could have shared an ancestor with sections of SARS-CoV-2 less than a decade ago, says Spyros Lytras, an evolutionary virologist at the University of Glasgow. “These viruses recombine so much that different bits of the genome have different evolutionary histories,” he says.
Note none of the viruses found in Laos are any closer in their total genomes than COVID is to RaTG13.

So you don't have all the pieces and more importantly there's no evidence of such a recombinant virus precursor to COVID 19.

The Laos study offers insight into the origins of the pandemic, but there are still missing links, say researchers. For example, the Laos viruses don’t contain the so-called furin cleavage site on the spike protein that further aids the entry of SARS-CoV-2 and other coronaviruses into human cells.

The study also doesn’t clarify how a progenitor of the virus could have travelled to Wuhan, in central China, where the first known cases of COVID-19 were identified — or whether the virus hitched a ride on an intermediate animal.

Other than it made for a nice headline, the Laos finding doesn't move the ball down the field at all.

Another preprint, also posted on Research Square and not yet peer reviewed, sheds light on the work under way in China7. For that study, researchers sampled some 13,000 bats between 2016 and 2021 across China. But they did not find any close relatives of SARS-CoV-2, and conclude that these are “extremely rare in bats in China”.
 
I don’t think you can wield Ockham’s razor that easily.

Natural origin is indeed a viable option, but your list of dependencies is flawed. You could also say that instead of an “unknown progenitor virus” and “secret gain of function” the lab leak is dependent on a repressive political system, and an a lab accident (that we know happens every so often).

The simplest explanation given all the pieces is a lab leak.

No precursor virus or species found after an intense 2 year search.

No evidence of COVID 19 origin anywhere except Wuhan.

Evidence of the virus being well matched to infect humans and no explanation of how it got that way naturally.

The virus spread from person to person with lightning speed around the world. That is how well it was adapted to being a human pathogen.

And the location of the beginning just happens to be in Wuhan where there was research going on with coronaviruses and no reservoir of the bats which carry similar viruses nearby.​

And to that you can add:
Dr Shi lying about what the Yunnan miners died from in 2012.

Dr Shi lying about not having live bats at the WIV.

A progress report on a grant to the US Congress that described GoF work being done at the WIV.

A proposal that was turned down earlier describing what risky ideas Daszak had. While they didn't get the US funds for that project, they could have easily gotten the money elsewhere.

And as of yet not clarified: the finding of Nipah virus sequences in the first COVID genomes examined.​

And that's not all of the evidence but alone it is enough to say the simplest explanation for all of those pesky little details is a lab leak, not a natural spillover event.
 
You've been reading headlines without reading the actual research papers.
The finding of those 3 viruses in Laos are akin to the piece of COVID that might have come from a recombinant event like it's been suggested the piece from a pangolin coronavirus. IOW, if you read the actual report on the finding, all they found were some virus strains with certain pieces of COVID 19 the same way there is a piece in pangolin coronaviruses.

The argument was some pieces of COVID 19 didn't look like they appeared in nature. Now you have more pieces that could have come together in a recombinant event.

From your link:
Note none of the viruses found in Laos are any closer in their total genomes than COVID is to RaTG13.

So you don't have all the pieces and more importantly there's no evidence of such a recombinant virus precursor to COVID 19.



Other than it made for a nice headline, the Laos finding doesn't move the ball down the field at all.

Well, the paper itself has a discussion on this...

We then focused our study on the five sarbecoviruses for which we obtained full-length sequences. Among these, three (BANAL-52, -103, and -236) were considered to be close to SARS-CoV-2 because of the similarity in amino acids of one of the S domains (S1-NTD, S1-RBD, or S2) with the homologous domain of SARS-CoV-2. The similarity plot analysis revealed that the evolution history of SARS-CoV-2 is more complex than expected and that R. affinis RaTG13, isolated in Yunnan in 2013, is no longer considered the proximal ancestor of SARS-CoV-2: strains close to R. pusillus RpYN06, R. malayanus RmYN02, and Rhinolophus sp. PrC31 isolated in China in 2018-2019, along with R. malayanus BANAL-52, R. pusillus BANAL-103, and R. marshalli BANAL-236 isolated in Laos in 2020, contributed to the appearance of SARS-CoV-2 in different regions of the genome. No closer viral genome has yet been identified as a possible contributor, and pangolin coronaviruses appear as more distantly related than bat coronaviruses.

Because genomic regions subject to recombination are likely contributing to host-virus interactions and adaptation following spillover events, we compared SARS-CoV-2 strains from the two lineages identified at the very onset of the COVID-19 outbreak19 to these novel bat sarbecoviruses and to pangolin strains within the SARS-CoV-2 clade. We thus identified potential recombination sites, allowing for the reconstruction of the phylogenetic history of early isolated SARS-CoV-2 strains between homologous regions defined by recombination points. The interaction of the SARS-CoV-2 spike with hACE2 is a key event in cell infection. The spike is divided into two subunits, S1 and S2: S1 contains an RBD that specifically binds to hACE2, whereas the S2 subunit contains the fusion peptide. Regarding the spike, we identified a breakpoint at the beginning of the SARS-CoV-2 RBD, resulting in a downstream fragment composed of the RBD, the furin cleavage site, and ending in the N-terminal region of S2. Despite the absence of the furin site in these novel bat sarbecoviruses, phylogenetic reconstruction of this fragment, key for the virus tropism and host spectrum, revealed that Laotian R. malayanus BANAL-52, R. pusillus BANAL-103, and R. marshalli BANAL-236 coronaviruses are the closest ancestors of SARS-CoV-2 known to date. Identification of strains of animal origin with a furin cleavage site may require additional sampling. As seen by others, ORF8 was highly divergent between SARS-CoV-2 related genomes. ORF8 from strains BANAL-52, -103, -236, like that of RaTG13, were closer to SARS-CoV-2 than to pangolin strains. ORF8 encodes a protein that has been proposed to participate in immune evasion28. It is noteworthy that ORF8 was deleted in many human SARS-CoV-2 strains that appeared after March 202029, which is reminiscent of the deletions identified during the 2003 SARS epidemic30. Therefore, ORF8 can be a marker of SARS-CoV-2 adaptation to humans and its presence in bat strains is consistent with bats acting as a natural reservoir of early strains of SARS-CoV-2.

Link

Our results contribute to understanding the origin of SARS-CoV-2: they show that sequences very close to those of the early strains of SARS-CoV-2 responsible for the pandemic exist in nature and are found in several Rhinolophus bat species. The RBDs of the viruses found in our study are closer to that of SARS-CoV-2 than to the RaTG13 RBD, the virus identified in R. affinis from the Mojiang mineshaft where pneumonia cases with clinical characteristics strikingly similar to COVID-196 were recorded in 201233,34. We found here sarbecoviruses with RBDs closest to that of SARS-CoV-2 in three different bat species, R. marshalli, R. malayanus, and R. pusillus. Our results therefore support the hypothesis that SARS-CoV-2 could originally result from a recombination of sequences pre-existing in Rhinolophus bats living in the extensive limestone cave systems of South-East Asia and South China35, which provides ideal conditions for interspecies interactions among Rhinolophus bats.
 
Last edited:
Quoted for the irony (highlighting as in the original):
You've been reading headlines without reading the actual research papers.


Skeptic Ginger went on to write the following. (Note that BANAL-52, BANAL-103, and BANAL-236 were found in Laos, while RaTG13 was found in Yunnan, China.)
From your link:
... they found viruses that are each more than 95% identical to SARS-CoV-2, which they named BANAL-52, BANAL-103 and BANAL-236. ...

Last year, researchers described another close relative of SARS-CoV-2, called RaTG13, which was found in bats in Yunnan5. It is 96.1% identical to SARS-CoV-2 overall and the two viruses probably shared a common ancestor 40–70 years ago6. BANAL-52 is 96.8% identical to SARS-CoV-2, says Eloit — and all three newly discovered viruses have individual sections that are more similar to sections of SARS-CoV-2 than seen in any other viruses. ...

Viruses swap chunks of RNA with one another through a process called recombination, and one section in BANAL-103 and BANAL-52 could have shared an ancestor with sections of SARS-CoV-2 less than a decade ago, says Spyros Lytras, an evolutionary virologist at the University of Glasgow. “These viruses recombine so much that different bits of the genome have different evolutionary histories,” he says.
Note none of the viruses found in Laos are any closer in their total genomes than COVID is to RaTG13.
Note that the sentence I highlighted in yellow is false. Apparently Skeptic Ginger glanced at the quoted text long enough to see the phrase "each more than 95% identical" but did not read it carefully enough to see the "more than" part of that phrase.

I have highlighted the relevant percentages in red.
  • RaTG13 is 96.1% identical to to SARS-CoV-2.
  • BANAL-52 is is 96.8% identical to SARS-CoV-2.
96.8% is greater than 96.1%.

Based on Skeptic Ginger's misreading of those percentages, she immediately went on to write her next sentence:
So you don't have all the pieces and more importantly there's no evidence of such a recombinant virus precursor to COVID 19.
If the percentages were really all that decisive (which they aren't), their evidence would count in favor of a precursor in Laos rather than China, which seems to be the opposite of the conclusion Skeptic Ginger is asking us to draw here.
 
Last edited:
Well, the paper itself has a discussion on this...

Link

That doesn't say anything I didn't say.

Our results therefore support the hypothesis that SARS-CoV-2 could originally result from a recombination of sequences pre-existing in Rhinolophus bats living in the extensive limestone cave systems of South-East Asia and South China35, which provides ideal conditions for interspecies interactions among Rhinolophus bats.
It's not even all that new. Shi and whoever at the WIV found the pangolin segment could have been acquired through a recombination event rather than the pangolin being an intermediate species in the sequence of events leading up to COVID. Citation has been posted in this thread.
 
That doesn't say anything I didn't say.

It's not even all that new. Shi and whoever at the WIV found the pangolin segment could have been acquired through a recombination event rather than the pangolin being an intermediate species in the sequence of events leading up to COVID. Citation has been posted in this thread.

Honestly, nobody cares about that. Look at W.D Clinger’s post…. heck, reread your own post and you will see that BANAL-52 is closer in both genetic percentage to SARS-CoV2 than RaTG-13 and it likely has a more recent common ancestor than RaTG13. In addition, it has the RBD. All of that debunks the theory that RaTG13 the virus that was gain-of-functioned into Covid-19 and points strongly towards a natural origin.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom