Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Day I will trust anything from Chinese government ...
This is little to do with the Chinese government. We should trust the scientists, both in China and outside of China. It is the scientists working in the labs who state there was no SARS-CoV-2 in the labs.
CALL OF THE WILD Why many scientists say it’s unlikely that SARS-CoV-2 originated from a “lab leak”
Linfa Wang, a molecular virologist at the Programme in Emerging Infectious Diseases at Duke-NUS Medical School in Singapore who has collaborated extensively with WIV on bat coronavirus studies, has a simpler reason for dismissing the lab-leak hypothesis. “Accidents can only happen when you already have a live virus in culture that can leak,” Wang says. Bat coronaviruses are notoriously hard to grow. Shi told Science last year that her lab had more than 2000 bat fecal samples and anal and oral swabs that tested positive for coronaviruses. But the lab had only isolated and grown three viruses over 15 years, Shi said, and none closely resembled SARS-CoV-2. Some have questioned Shi’s veracity—she may well be under pressure from the Chinese government—and noted inconsistencies in her statements, but several scientific collaborators outside China have high regard for her integrity.
Those "inconsistencies" in the Vanity Fair article do not really exist. There is the Mojiang miners from 2012 who probably had fungal infections. There is the funding from the NIH confusion in 2020 (a revoked termination of funding). Shi stated “there had been no reports of unusual diseases, none diagnosed, and all staff tested negative for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies.”. Shi is stating that any reported illnesses were normal and tested to be not SARS-CoV-2. The State Department got this wrong in a Jan 15, 2021 fact sheet with
The U.S. government has reason to believe that several researchers inside the WIV became sick in autumn 2019, before the first identified case of the outbreak, with symptoms consistent with both COVID-19 and common seasonal illnesses. This raises questions about the credibility of WIV senior researcher Shi Zhengli’s public claim that there was “zero infection” among the WIV’s staff and students of SARS-CoV-2 or SARS-related viruses.
There is the WIV’s database web site being hacked and taken offline on September 12, 2019. This is data that was made available in US databases! The WHO team knew this and did not bother asking for what was already available.
 
Last edited:
This is little to do with the Chinese government. We should trust the scientists, both in China and outside of China.
We can’t trust the Chinese scientists, whether they are respected or not. They live and work under a totalitarian regime that punishes anything that might be construed as being against the interests of the Chinese government, and if they want to be able to keep working in the lab instead of an re-education camp, they have to lie.

In my eyes, that does not make them less respected; we have appreciate the difficult conditions they work under.
 
We can’t trust the Chinese scientists, whether they are respected or not. They live and work under a totalitarian regime that punishes anything that might be construed as being against the interests of the Chinese government, and if they want to be able to keep working in the lab instead of an re-education camp, they have to lie.

In my eyes, that does not make them less respected; we have appreciate the difficult conditions they work under.
You are forgetting that what the Chinese scientists in China have stated has been confirmed in general by
  • Chinese scientists not in China as in the article and what I quoted.
    "Linfa Wang, a molecular virologist at the Programme in Emerging Infectious Diseases at Duke-NUS Medical School in Singapore". Linfa Wang was educated in Shanghai.
  • Foreign scientists who have visited the labs.
    None of these have stated that there were samples of viruses resembling SARS-CoV-2 in the labs.
  • Indirectly by virologists around the world not pointing out any lies.
Thus Shi's assertion of a total of 3 isolated and grown viruses in 15 years and none closely resembling SARS-CoV-2 is credible.

Also consider the history of COVID-19 and the lab leak theory. There was about a year when a lab leak was a remote possibility suggested by scientists. And a mostly ignored political fantasy from Trump. It was not until early 2021 that the theory became publicly widespread and people began to reassess it. Did the Chinese government then use a time machine to repress evidence of a lab leak before December 2019 :D? Conspiracy theorists would have something like a known lab leak in November 2019 of SARS-CoV-2 and nothing being done for months despite having the example of the 2002–2004 SARS outbreak (at least 774 deaths from over 8,000 infected people).
 
Last edited:

Sorry, but who is he?

Some red flags right here in this quote:

But according to shocking new claims by a Chinese whistleblower, that crucial early warning – which came six long weeks before China admitted an outbreak had occurred – fell on deaf ears even as the bodies began to pile up.

That's according to defector and democracy campaigner Wei Jingsheng, who makes the stunning revelation in Sky News' new documentary, What Really Happened in Wuhan.

The documentary, which premieres on Monday and is based on a new book of the same name by Sharri Markson, includes interviews with Jingsheng, who claims he attempted to tell US authorities just how serious the emerging crisis was back in October 2019 after being informed of the outbreak by contacts in Beijing.
 
This is Wei Jingsheng who was deported from China on 16 November 1997! He has a unsupported story of contacts saying there was an outbreak in October 2019. He claims he passed this to US authorities, including someone of "concerningly high rank", " high enough to be able to reach the President of the United States". If this is true, they ignored him possibly with good reasons, e.g. an unknown source perhaps reporting the start of the flu season. What makes this dubious to me is that we are almost 2 years after this alleged event.

Wie says he "first heard of a mysterious new virus at the time of the World Military Games in Wuhan in October 2019.". But the athletes and spectators were magically immune and did not spread this virus when they returned to other countries! Wei "alerted intelligence agencies, a US politician with links to the president and Chinese human rights activist Dimon Liu". But no one seems to have mentioned that in the past 2 years. Dimon Liu merely repeats what Wie said in her book.

ETA: Some athletes say they and other athletes were sick during the games. This is more evidence of an outbreak of flu in late October 2019. They were never diagnosed with COVID-19. No antibody tests showing COVID-19 infection. They were not hospitalized. None died. There were no cases of OVID-19 outside of China when they returned.
 
Last edited:
You are forgetting that what the Chinese scientists in China have stated has been confirmed in general by […]
My comment was about your statement that we should trust respected Chinese scientists in general. They may be saying the truth, and it is all well and good if it is corroborated, but as a general rule we cannot trust Chinese scientists on matters where they might face punishment by their government.
 
Back in February of this year, we discussed the whole question of how it is that a virus could have come from the same place that SARS-CoV1 came from (in Yunnan), and gone all the way to Wuhan.

Well, obviously it could not have been that difficult to get to Guangdong, the site of the emergence of SARS-CoV1, but it was argued that Wuhan is less likely because it is a little bit further away than Guangdong and may involve more than one change of trains, etc...

Here's an important point:

One of the supposedly compelling pieces of evidence is that the outbreak - or at least the emergence - of Covid-19 began in Wuhan when the idea is that it came from bats that dwell in caves in Yunnan Province. But that's like 100s of kilometres away! How is it possible that a coronavirus found in bats travelled 100s of kilometres!!!?!?!? How is it even possible?!?!

The theory then is that Wuhan Institute of Virology scientists to Yunnan, extracted the coronavirus from the bats, went back to Wuhan and let the virus escape because of shoddy protocols and then kept quiet about it because of "face" (*yawn*!)...

Except, why were they down in Yunnan in the first place? Well, because that is where SARS Cov1 was thought to have come from. So is that where SARS Cov1 emerged? No, it emerged in Guandong Province. But that's like 100s of kilometres away! How is it possible that a coronavirus found in bats travelled 100s of kilometres!!!?!?!? How is it even possible?!?!

Could it be that Guandong and Wuhan are both big cities and transport hubs, and that vast amounts of travellers and produce from all over China pass through there every day?

No! I want to ruminate instead on important questions of the concept of face. That's what scientists do after all...

Of course it could be. The original SARS obviously traveled --and given the distance to the source was not a likely place for it start its' spread.

There are currently 113 cities in China with over 1 million people in the urban areas. It could have emerged anywhere, even outside of China, though it would be more likely in a closer city or one with some close 'supply' chain relation to the area. The difference with Wuhan is that we KNOW these SARS-related viruses went there, purposely, multiple times over many years, from persons having direct contact with the people, animals, and caves at the source. And so a theory that those travels contributed to the emergence there becomes more likely- however it happened. I am perplexed that it sounds so conspiratorial.

Going by just the 'main hub' train stations (of the 5500 they have), Yunnan to Guangdong is one main hub away. Wuhan looks like three hubs away.
[qimg]https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/50977770886_6cc1078dc4_z.jpg[/qimg]https://flic.kr/p/2kEJpff https://www.flickr.com/photos/155114068@N02/

However, it now turns out that SARS-CoV1 actually turned up in civets in Hubei in 2005...

Link

Identification of three civet-CoVs in the central China province of Hubei.
Previous studies have identified 35 civet-CoVs in Guangdong where the SARS epidemic of 2002 through 2003 originated. In this study, we were able to recover S genes from three civets found in farms in the central China province of Hubei, which is geographically distant from the province of Guangdong. This is the first report of the identification of naturally infected civets outside the Guangdong province. The discovery of civet-CoVs in the Hubei province should not be a surprise as SARS-CoV-like viruses were recently found in a bat species in the same province (16). Based on the phylogenetic analysis of S genes, the three new viruses are relatively divergent from one another and also from the viruses previously identified (Fig. ​(Fig.1).1). This finding indicates that the spread of civet-CoVs in the Hubei province is unlikely to be recent. Based on the genetic distance, it is likely that there are three major clusters of civet-CoVs (named ciSZ, ciHB, and ciGD) in the phylogenetic tree (Fig. ​(Fig.1).1). Since three viruses found in the Hubei province are more closely related to ciGD, the dominant cluster of civet-CoVs, than to ciSZ or SARS-CoV, these civet viruses probably shared a common ancestor. However, whether viral variants within the dominant cluster of civet-CoVs harbor any distinct biological functions remains unclear.

Link to the 2007 paper
 
Also, there is a new preprint out estimating that zoonotic spillovers are happening at a higher rate than previously thought.

Only two new coronaviruses have spread globally the past 2 decades: SARS-CoV, which caused an outbreak of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) in 2003, and SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19. But that may just be the tip of the iceberg of undetected infections with related viruses emerging from bats, a new paper claims. In a preprint published yesterday researchers estimate that an average of 400,000 people are likely infected with SARS-related coronaviruses every year, in spillovers that never grow into detectable outbreaks.

Link

Sounds interesting. That said, it probably won't convince many of the lab-leak theorists given that it was co-authored by Peter Daszak and Linfa Wang.

Here's a link to the pre-print anyway...

Link
 
Back in February of this year, we discussed the whole question of how it is that a virus could have come from the same place that SARS-CoV1 came from (in Yunnan), and gone all the way to Wuhan.

Well, obviously it could not have been that difficult to get to Guangdong, the site of the emergence of SARS-CoV1, but it was argued that Wuhan is less likely because it is a little bit further away than Guangdong and may involve more than one change of trains, etc...

However, it now turns out that SARS-CoV1 actually turned up in civets in Hubei in 2005...

Link

Link to the 2007 paper
I think you misunderstand the unlikely coincidence just a tad.

Of course it could have happened. The problem is where is the evidence of a trail leading to such an abrupt beginning in Wuhan?

Where are the civet cats or other animal species the virus circulated in before the human cases?

And if it did arrive via an animal source, why wouldn't that same source have seeded human outbreaks elsewhere?

Where is the outbreak among humans anywhere except Wuhan?
 
Also, there is a new preprint out estimating that zoonotic spillovers are happening at a higher rate than previously thought.

Link

Sounds interesting. That said, it probably won't convince many of the lab-leak theorists given that it was co-authored by Peter Daszak and Linfa Wang.

Here's a link to the pre-print anyway...

Link
Yeah, I was waiting for someone to bring up that paper. This is what Daszak and his Eco company have been trying to sell since well before the COVID pandemic. It's not really anything new. It's all speculation and nothing in the way of new or even hard evidence.

There was a coronavirus survey in the humans that lived near the Yunnan cave way back when the 6 miners became ill. There was a small percentage of the population that had some evidence of past coronavirus infections. It's way back at the beginning of this thread. It wasn't any explosive revelation then and all Daszak has done here now is suggest the number of coronavirus spillovers might be huge.


Here's from your first link:
Study pinpoints Asian regions that could spark the next coronavirus pandemic...

Evidence suggests that some bat SARS-related coronaviruses (SARSr-CoVs) could infect people directly, and that their spillover is more frequent than previously recognized.
Could, not did. Could, not found.
They claim in the abstract they used seroprevalence in the risk assessment and describe using the data on seroprevalence from the literature. They did not do any further seroprevalence studies.
We then use probabilistic risk assessment and data on human-bat contact, human SARSr-CoV seroprevalence, and antibody duration to estimate that ∼400,000 people (median: ∼50,000) are infected with SARSr-CoVs annually in South and Southeast Asia....
Spillover of SARSr-CoVs may therefore be substantially skewed to people who have high exposure to these species, and this would likely have been missed in the relatively small serological surveys upon which our analyses are currently based.
They used the seroprevalence studies done in 2012.


Next they describe all the bat coronaviruses they have found in Yunnan and elsewhere in the world. We know that.

Their modeling:
Our approach provides proof of concept for systematic risk assessment of zoonotic spillover
We know that. Daszak has been working on that problem since the beginning of his company. And it is/was a worthwhile issue to investigate. Daszak, before COVID, was working on a noble cause: working to end the wild animal trade.



Back to the current pandemic.

One thing I found relevant to Daszak's paper was the seroprevalence testing done in the wet markets in Guangdong when the SARS epidemic began. They compared workers who handled animals to vendors that sold vegetables. The animal handlers including people who transported the animals had a significantly greater percentage of SARS antibodies than the workers with less contact with the suspect animals.

Epidemiologic Clues to SARS Origin in China
Several observations support the hypothesis of a wild animal origin for SARS. Cases apparently occurred independently in at least five different municipalities; early case-patients were more likely than later patients to report living near a produce market (odds ratio undefined; lower 95% confidence interval 2.39) but not near a farm; and 9 (39%) of 23 early patients, including 6 who lived or worked in Foshan, were food handlers with probable animal contact....

Seroprevalence of immunoglobulin (Ig) G antibody to SARS-CoV is substantially higher among traders of live animals (13.0%) in Guangzhou municipality than among healthy controls (1.2%), and the highest prevalence of antibody is among those who traded primarily masked palm civets (72.7%) (15). The pattern of the Guangdong epidemic is consistent with the classical process of emergence from an animal reservoir: the initial introduction of the virus into a nonimmune human population followed by the establishment and rapid dissemination of infection...

Many larger cities in Guangdong, as well as rural areas, were also apparently spared by the epidemic.

Although the possibility that SARS may pre-date the earliest known case cannot be excluded, the temporal and spatial clustering of index cases described in the case series suggests that the initial source of the Guangdong epidemic was either a single point source (with the links between cities not identified) or several point sources in the Pearl River basin. Outbreaks in cities affected later in the epidemic can all be traced to an imported case.


2003: Animals in Chinese markets carried SARS-like virus The studies were done by Chinese scientists which is more indication the Chinese don't want to find the 'spillover' evidence because they could have followed the steps taken with the SARS epidemic.
The scientists also tested people who worked in the market for SARS antibodies. Forty percent of animal traders and 33% of workers who slaughtered animals had antibodies to the SARS virus, according to the report. In contrast, only 5% of people who sold vegetables had antibodies to the virus. .
Many of those people with antibodies appear to have had asymptomatic cases. That is evidence SARS circulated in people before becoming as virulent as it became. Why didn't Daszak actually do seroprevalence studies?
 
Last edited:
My comment was about your statement that we should trust respected Chinese scientists in general. They may be saying the truth, and it is all well and good if it is corroborated, but as a general rule we cannot trust Chinese scientists on matters where they might face punishment by their government.
I agree up to the "face punishment" point. What we saw in the early days was scientists following procedures on reporting diseases internationally that the Chinese government had agreed on. There was temporary bureaucratic interference and delay until January 2020s. It was early 2021 when the lab leak theory became widespread and the Chinese government went over the top about it. So punishment for what?

There is a bit of corroboration from scientists outside of China for some statements. Linfa Wang working in Singapore stated “Accidents can only happen when you already have a live virus in culture that can leak”. He worked extensively with the WIV on bat coronavirus studies and should know what was happening. This corroborates Shi's statement that there were 3 isolated and grown three viruses over 15 years and none closely resembled SARS-CoV-2.
 
The point is that the results of asking are very unlikely to show there is a coverup. If we go for a conspiracy theory of a coverup by the Chinese government, we cannot know whether any supplied or missing evidence is part of that coverup or not.
A perfect coverup is indistinguishable from no coverup at all. Which indicates that this one is very good.

"But what about the supplied and missing evidence"? you say. "Doesn't that suggest a coverup that is not very good"? But when we examine this evidence we invariably find it wanting. That is deliberate. You see, if there wasn't any evidence of a coverup that would prove there is a coverup. So they leak fake evidence to discredit anyone who finds it. Then nobody will look for the real evidence - of which there isn't any, that would prove a perfect coverup!
 
A perfect coverup is indistinguishable from no coverup at all. Which indicates that this one is very good.

"But what about the supplied and missing evidence"? you say. "Doesn't that suggest a coverup that is not very good"? But when we examine this evidence we invariably find it wanting. That is deliberate. You see, if there wasn't any evidence of a coverup that would prove there is a coverup. So they leak fake evidence to discredit anyone who finds it. Then nobody will look for the real evidence - of which there isn't any, that would prove a perfect coverup!

I'm not quite sure what you mean here but...

The data that is missing was specifically withheld by China after numerous requests from multiple sources like the WHO and different researchers from different countries.

China has withheld data on the earliest cases claiming some privacy concerns which are easily refuted.

China took a large amount of genome data offline in Sept, 2019.

Shi claimed the miners in 2012 died from fungal infections when there are multiple sources of data proving that is a false claim.​

As for the more speculative stuff:
Despite a record of multiple trips to the Yunnan mine to collect bat samples since 2012, very few records of those samples have been released.

Shi denies they had any live SARSr Co V cultures or kept live bats at the WIV. That has been refuted by at least two different sources: One they applied for a patent for bat cages and two, there is at least one report of collecting live bats from the Yunnan mine. And as for the cultures, there are papers indicating live cultures in vitro were studied.​

Now if someone wants to speculate there may or may not be relevant data there, they need a good reason for why such data is not being released by the Chinese.
 
I think you misunderstand the unlikely coincidence just a tad. Of course it could have happened. The problem is where is the evidence of a trail leading to such an abrupt beginning in Wuhan?

Where are the civet cats or other animal species the virus circulated in before the human cases?

And if it did arrive via an animal source, why wouldn't that same source have seeded human outbreaks elsewhere?

Where is the outbreak among humans anywhere except Wuhan?

I don't misunderstand the coincidence.

Sharkeu accepts that SARS-CoV1 emerged in Guangzhou despite being such a large distance from Yunnan, and thinks it is much less likely to have got to Wuhan. Yet, it did - or at least it got to Hubei Province which is the same province as Wuhan.

It may not counter all the points, but it is at least one point that is countered.
 
Stuart Neil points out that some researchers have found...

Major new Bat sarbecovirus discovery in horseshoe bats in Laos. A virus with a spike protein containing an RBD only 2 amino acids different from Wuhan SARS CoV2 and uses hACE2 as efficiently

So now this is definitive. There is nothing unnatural or "uniquely adapted" about SARS2

Link

Of course, I don't have or claim to have the competence to assess the paper:

The animal reservoir of SARS-CoV-2 is unknown despite reports of various SARS-CoV-2-related viruses in
Asian Rhinolophus bats, including the closest virus from R. affinis, RaTG13. Several studies have
suggested the involvement of pangolin coronaviruses in SARS-CoV-2 emergence. SARS-CoV-2 presents a
mosaic genome, to which different progenitors contribute. The spike sequence determines the binding
affinity and accessibility of its receptor-binding domain (RBD) to the cellular angiotensin-converting
enzyme 2 (ACE2) receptor and is responsible for host range. SARS-CoV-2 progenitor bat viruses
genetically close to SARS-CoV-2 and able to enter human cells through a human ACE2 pathway have not
yet been identified, though they would be key in understanding the origin of the epidemics. Here we show
that such viruses indeed circulate in cave bats living in the limestone karstic terrain in North Laos, within
the Indochinese peninsula. We found that the RBDs of these viruses differ from that of SARS-CoV-2 by only one or two residues, bind as efficiently to the hACE2 protein as the SARS-CoV-2 Wuhan strain isolated in early human cases, and mediate hACE2-dependent entry into human cells, which is inhibited by antibodies neutralizing SARS-CoV-2. None of these bat viruses harbors a furin cleavage site in the
spike. Our findings therefore indicate that bat-borne SARS-CoV-2-like viruses potentially infectious for
humans circulate in Rhinolophus spp. in the Indochinese peninsula.

Paper
 
Stuart Neil points out that some researchers have found...



Link

Of course, I don't have or claim to have the competence to assess the paper:



Paper

Interesting, certainly very strong evidence for a bat origin. I had read a paper showing that a number of people in that area (Indochina) had neutralising antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 pre covid, and this perhaps represented a similar but less virulent circulating virus. They then hypothesised that the relative good control of Covid in Indo-China might be partly contributed to by a degree of pre-existing immunity in the population.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom