Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
We can wait until Sherkeu sticks her head back in the thread but I'm pretty sure she was in on the same discussion as everyone else. I doesn't change the fact you are still refuting a claim that was already refuted.

I am definitely not doing that.

I posted two things which were not widely known until two or three days ago.

1.) The Laotian CoV containing the RBD has only just been reported in the paper dated 17th September 2021. It is completely false to say that you knew about this 20 pages ago.

The implications are that it obviates the need for GoF or hybridization to have made the virus transmissable to humans. That is a big deal for GoF proponents such as yourself.

2.) The detection of an independent SARS-CoV1 lineage in Hubei province had been reported in 2007, but it seems to have been overlooked until very recently. This tweet on the finding is dated 16th September.

This whole "yawn! Old news" routine is not convincing.

I have noticed though, that you will sometimes argue for a theory and then when presented with counter-evidence pretend that this is old news.
 
Dr Shi never stated that there were no live cultures at WIV

Getting back to the comment in my last link:

Isolation and characterization of a bat SARS-like coronavirus that uses the ACE2 receptor
This was cited upthread so consider this a review.

This is from the WIV that Dr Shi claims no live cultures or bats were handled in the lab.
It is a lie that Dr Shi stated that there were no live cultures at WIV as anyone reading what was cited a bit further upthread on 15 September 2021 knows.
CALL OF THE WILD Why many scientists say it’s unlikely that SARS-CoV-2 originated from a “lab leak”
Linfa Wang, a molecular virologist at the Programme in Emerging Infectious Diseases at Duke-NUS Medical School in Singapore who has collaborated extensively with WIV on bat coronavirus studies, has a simpler reason for dismissing the lab-leak hypothesis. “Accidents can only happen when you already have a live virus in culture that can leak,” Wang says. Bat coronaviruses are notoriously hard to grow. Shi told Science last year that her lab had more than 2000 bat fecal samples and anal and oral swabs that tested positive for coronaviruses. But the lab had only isolated and grown three viruses over 15 years, Shi said, and none closely resembled SARS-CoV-2. Some have questioned Shi’s veracity—she may well be under pressure from the Chinese government—and noted inconsistencies in her statements, but several scientific collaborators outside China have high regard for her integrity.
The Isolation and characterization of a bat SARS-like coronavirus that uses the ACE2 receptor paper from 2013 is probably the analysis of the first of those 3 live cultures taken from bat samples. The corresponding authors are Peter Daszak & Zheng-Li Shi!

It is a fantasy that Dr Shi stated that there were no live bats "handled in the lab" when you have given no evidence of live bats at WIV or even cited Shi's statement.
20 September 2021: Cite Dr Shi's no "bats were handled in the lab" (or no live bats at WIV) statement, Skeptic Ginger.
1 September 2021: Cite your sources that give evidence of live bats at the WIV.
Shi and other scientists have stated there are no Rhinolophus bats at any labs because they cannot be kept in captivity in labs*. Not scientist has said that is wrong.
There may have been live bats at WIV a couple of years before late 2019 but they would not be ones carrying SARS-CoV-2 related viruses. The dubious video with bats in cages allegedly at WIV uses (abuses?) state TV footage from 2017 and has someone in full PPE feeding a worm to a bat of not stated species. Rhinolophus (horseshoe) bats feed on flying insects (but worms may be easier to get or cheaper than say crickets).

Search this thread for "Zheng-Li Shi live bats" and the 9 results are that unsupported assertion, "evidence (posted upthread) they were working with live bats" when the point is that WIV have to be working with live bats carrying SARS-CoV-2 related viruses. Also Daszak's corrected no live bats error.

* I suspect that Rhinolophus bats can be kept in large enclosures (not cages). I found Spontaneous, generalized lipidosis in captive greater horseshoe bats (Rhinolophus ferrumequinum) where 3 of 34 greater horseshoe bats captured for echolocation studies died. Google for the care and feeding of Rhinolophus bats in laboratory cages and the results are related to the references, not the bats.
 
Last edited:
Look, look, I'm posting a link to a virology paper that supports lineage A and B represent 2 separate events. I have been asking for evidence of this for a few pages now.

Evidence Against the Veracity of SARS-CoV-2 Genomes Intermediate between Lineages A and B
We refer to these genomes as C/C or T/T, because they have the same nucleotide at these two key sites. Here, we investigate the veracity of these sequences and conclude it is probable that neither C/C nor T/T genomes circulated at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic; they are likely the result of sequencing or bioinformatics issues. ...

In other words, we looked at whether putative A/B intermediates shared with “pure” A or “pure” B virus genomes one or more mutations outside of those that define the two pure lineages. If so, then either those mutations arose independently in both the putative intermediate and its pure counterpart, or (more likely) the putative intermediate is not an intermediate at all, and is actually a pure A or B lineage very closely related to its pure-lineage counterpart. This latter scenario implies that the C/C or T/T pattern in the putative intermediate was due to an error in inferring either site 8782 or site 28144....

The paper has its criticisms in that it has yet to be verified.

From ISID ProMed, the first article:
Several researchers contacted by Nature, who sequenced some of the samples included in the study, say it is unlikely that their sequences include errors in the 2 key nucleotides.

But the study authors counter that even if some of the genomes were sequenced correctly, other parts of the same genomes, or the locations from which the samples were collected, still clearly indicate that they belong to only one or the other lineage.

"It is very unlikely" that any of the so-called intermediate genomes are actually transitional genomes, says study co-author Joel Wertheim, a molecular epidemiologist at the University of California, San Diego.

Xiaowei Jiang, an evolutionary biologist at Xi'an Jiaotong-Liverpool University in Suzhou, China, says that the team behind the study must verify the findings by getting "the original raw sequencing data for as many genomes as possible".

And from the Mod:
[The hypothesis that there were 2 SARS-CoV-2 spillover events that set off the COVID-19 pandemic has many dramatic implications, including discrediting of the "lab spillover" hypothesis. However, recall Carl Sagan's dictum that "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence." We have thus included the above Nature article in its entirety to include certain questions and issues that have already been raised by other scientists. The original molecular phylogenetic analysis, which is highly technical, may be viewed at https://virological.org/t/evidence-...mes-intermediate-between-lineages-a-and-b/754. - Mod.LXL]
 
Look, look, I'm posting a link to a virology paper that supports lineage A and B represent 2 separate events. I have been asking for evidence of this for a few pages now.

Evidence Against the Veracity of SARS-CoV-2 Genomes Intermediate between Lineages A and B

I posted that same link, two weeks ago, on September 6th.


Okay, so I don't understand any of the science here, but it seems that one of the questions to do with the origins is at what stage lineage A and lineage B of SARS-CoV2 diverged.

Well, a group of scientists including Michael Worobey, suggest that maybe they did not and that they therefore represent different points of emergence.

Link

This might bolster the multiple spillover theory.

Your response...

I had to take those ******* quote marks out of your link to make it work. It would be nice if you would test links before hitting reply.

https://news.arizona.edu/story/nove...-undetected-months-first-covid-19-cases-wuhan

I posted about that already. I referred to it as sputtering. It's an hypothesis but I didn't see any evidence that supported it. I'll look again.

I do think the two lineages has to put the origin back before Oct explaining the removal of access to the WIV work on Sept 19, 2019.

Presumably you only looked at one of the links and not to the one you have just re-posted.

Anyway, yes, the upshot is that if the lineages are distinct, it reduces the chances that it was a singular event. This also reduces the chances of at least two lab leak possibilities. The idea that a WIV researcher in the field was bitten by a bat, or the chance that it was a single accidental infection in a lab.

What it might support as more likely is that a group of infected animals were sent along a supply chain, possibly to more than one market in Wuhan or that there may have been multiple spillovers. Presumably it could also mean multiple lab leaks in a particularly haphazard working environment at the WIV, I suppose.
 
Anyway, thanks for posting the two lineages work, SG.

In return, just to let you know that the new documentary from Sharri Markson is coming out soon. I think it is called "What Really Happened in Wuhan".

She tweeted this:

For all of those asking how you can watch our documentary at 8pm AEST if you don't have Sky News...

There is a 10-day free streaming trial to Foxtel Now. Sky News is part of this offer.
https://foxtel.com.au/watch/sky-news.html

If you're in the US, it will air on FOX Nation from 5am Sep 21.

Link

I guess they are going to expose the lab leak. Preferably to paying customers. ;)
 
I posted that same link, two weeks ago, on September 6th.

Your response...

Presumably you only looked at one of the links and not to the one you have just re-posted.

Anyway, yes, the upshot is that if the lineages are distinct, it reduces the chances that it was a singular event. This also reduces the chances of at least two lab leak possibilities. The idea that a WIV researcher in the field was bitten by a bat, or the chance that it was a single accidental infection in a lab.

What it might support as more likely is that a group of infected animals were sent along a supply chain, possibly to more than one market in Wuhan or that there may have been multiple spillovers. Presumably it could also mean multiple lab leaks in a particularly haphazard working environment at the WIV, I suppose.
There is no evidence of any infected animal sources, let alone two spillovers.

Did you also post the ISDS response? No, you couldn't have given it was only posted on the 17th. Capsid concurred with the paper. The ISID (International Society for Infectious Diseases) mod wasn't completely convinced.

As for the bad link, why are you rehashing that after I said I was wrong?

To which you replied No problem. Glad it got sorted out.
No doubt people do [act unpleasantly toward me], so how about we call a truce and try to go through things objectively. The first one to be unpleasant to the other one's a loser. How about it?
That didn't last long. I've been under constant attack in this thread because certain people can't address the issues objectively. I am no longer answering those posts.



Moving on: The genome evidence may suggest two initial events. Yet there is no evidence of any spillover, let alone 2. Previous discussions on the divergence of A & B lineages have been posted in this thread. Here is an additional discussion I don't believe has been cited. It followed Bloom's research that felt A was "ancestral to B". Bedford is another researcher at the Fred Hutch here in Seattle.


Trevor Bedford @trvrb Jun 24

Although alternatively, one could hypothesize multiple zoonotic events of closely related viruses to explain this pattern as suggested by Bob Garry in this Virological post (https://virological.org/t/early-app...-suggests-sars-cov-2-has-a-natural-origin/691), but this is in my eyes less parsimonious than a single spillover event. 8/15 ...

Two primary methods of root placement give conflicting results. Placement by molecular clock prefers lineage B and placement by outgroup (via RaTG13 or other bat SARS-like viruses) prefers lineage A. This is detailed in
@lpipes

@ras_nielsen
et al (https://academic.oup.com/mbe/article/38/4/1537/6028993). 9/15

Importantly, prior to Jesse's detective work, there were >77 genomes collected from Wuhan in Dec and Jan and shared publicly. These samples fall into both lineage A and lineage B (https://nextstrain.org/groups/blab/ncov/early-outbreak/root-A?f_location=Wuhan). 10/15 ...

As one might expect, the 13 sequences from BioProject SRR11313485 uncovered by @jbloom_lab also fall into both lineages A and B, with 8 out of 13 residing in lineage B (Table 1 of Bloom colored by identify at site 28144). 11/15
Bedford noted the genome data Bloom found in the cloud doesn't appear to have been purposefully hidden. I believe Bloom said as much.

Bedford remains neutral re the 2 origin hypotheses, lab and spillover, finding neither to be ruled out or ruled in.
 
There is no evidence of any infected animal sources, let alone two spillovers.

Did you also post the ISDS response? No, you couldn't have given it was only posted on the 17th. Capsid concurred with the paper. The ISID (International Society for Infectious Diseases) mod wasn't completely convinced.

As for the bad link, why are you rehashing that after I said I was wrong?

To which you replied No problem. Glad it got sorted out. That didn't last long. I've been under constant attack in this thread because certain people can't address the issues objectively. I am no longer answering those posts.

The point is that I posted what you asked for already. As for the response, thanks for posting that, but I never claimed I had seen it before.


Moving on: The genome evidence may suggest two initial events. Yet there is no evidence of any spillover, let alone 2. Previous discussions on the divergence of A & B lineages have been posted in this thread. Here is an additional discussion I don't believe has been cited. It followed Bloom's research that felt A was "ancestral to B". Bedford is another researcher at the Fred Hutch here in Seattle.

Trevor Bedford @trvrb Jun 24

Bedford noted the genome data Bloom found in the cloud doesn't appear to have been purposefully hidden. I believe Bloom said as much.

Bedford remains neutral re the 2 origin hypotheses, lab and spillover, finding neither to be ruled out or ruled in.

Interesting that you say Bloom feels A is ancestral to B, as this is what Trevor Bedford says in your link:

If the root is at the base of lineage B, it fits with Huanan market as emergence location

So this just goes back to our conundrum of whether A or B came first, and led to the other, or whether or not the two represent different emergences. Yes, I agree that the latter (multiple spillovers) is less parsimonius, but it seems to be genuinely in play according to Worobey, Garry and Bedford. Maybe Bloom also considers it possible, for all I know.
 
...Interesting that you say Bloom feels A is ancestral to B, as this is what Trevor Bedford says in your link:

So this just goes back to our conundrum of whether A or B came first, and led to the other, or whether or not the two represent different emergences. Yes, I agree that the latter (multiple spillovers) is less parsimonius, but it seems to be genuinely in play according to Worobey, Garry and Bedford. Maybe Bloom also considers it possible, for all I know.
Bedford hypothesized what A ancestral to B would look like, and what A & B would look like if they represented 2 separate events. He didn't draw a conclusion in those Twitter posts that I saw.

The "Bloom Lab" at the Hutch Tweeted this:
They were also all lineage B, which would be surprising if you think (as I do) that lineage A is ancestral. But even if A not ancestral to B, still surprised that early lineage B seqs would not have some mutations polarized to bat coronaviruses as that must be where it came from.
 
I don't know if this is something that was in the documentary, but Richard Ebright has tweeted a document that I think was put together by DRASTIC on a proposal (apparently rejected by DARPA), for constructing viruses:

EcoHealth: "We will analyze all SARSr-CoV..sequences for..proteolytic cleavage sites in S2 and for..potential Furin cleavage sites..[W]e will introduce appropriate human-specific cleavage sites and evaluate growth potential in Vero cells and HAE cultures."

Link

Ebright then also links to this DRASTIC document.
 
It's not very easy to read or understand the main points from. Is there a video of this around?

Unfortunately, I haven't been able to find one.

Her summary

Take home messages were:

1. No definitive evidence for natural or lab origin - jury still out

2. No actual investigation of lab origin yet

3. Extensive SARS-related virus work done at low biosafety levels

4. Large pathogen database MIA

5. But natural origins still possible



It's been interesting to see how the initial messages by some big names had a chilling effect- at least on what scientists were willing to say in public. & I don't think I've ever seen the public so interested in phylogenetics. If those missing sequences/database turns up, it could dramatically change the topology/inferences.
 
What do people make of this?

Wuhan scientists planned to release coronaviruses into cave bats 18 months before outbreak

I don't understand how such an action was supposed to work:
Wuhan scientists were planning to release enhanced airborne coronaviruses into Chinese bat populations to inoculate them against diseases that could jump to humans, leaked grant proposals dating from 2018 show.

I don't see anything on the DRASTIC website and links to The Telegraph site are behind a paywall for me. I have not yet looked at their Twitter feed. I'll do that next.

Papers, confirmed as genuine by a former member of the Trump administration, show they were hoping to introduce “human-specific cleavage sites” to bat coronaviruses which would make it easier for the virus to enter human cells. ...

The documents were released by Drastic, the web-based investigations team set up by scientists from across the world to look into the origins of Covid-19.
 
I found it: How EcoHealth Alliance and the Wuhan Institute of Virology Collaborated on a Dangerous Bat Coronavirus Project
“The DARPA DEFUSE Project”

Peter Daszak and the EcoHealth Alliance (EHA) proposed injecting deadly chimeric bat coronaviruses collected by the Wuhan Institute of Virology into humanised and “batified” mice.

The EHA / WIV proposal (named ‘DEFUSE’) was ultimately rejected for full funding (but leaving open the door for partial funding), in part because it mis-interpreted the GOF guidelines.

In other words, a branch of the federal government had already judged aspects of EHA’s research, and the corresponding shared research plan with the WIV, as falling under the definition of GOF, only for HHS to approve similar work without P3CO review in 2018 and 2019.
I read that already so it isn't new.


Leaked documents show EcoHealth Alliance requested $14 million from DARPA in 2018 for gain-of-function research with Wuhan Institute of Virology
 
OK, this makes more sense: 5. EHA PLANNED TO INOCULATE WILD BATS WITH AEROSOLIZED VACCINES
The proposal for wide scale inoculation of bats in the wild using aerosolized inoculum delivery has never been publicly released or opened to the wider scientific community for discussion as to potential risks associated with this plan.

Not the same as the Telegraph headline in Yahoo news:
planned to release coronaviruses

One of Daszak's pet projects though he is not an author of this paper: Self-disseminating vaccines to suppress zoonoses
One possibility is to eliminate the threat of spillover before it occurs using vaccines capable of autonomously spreading through wild animal reservoirs. We are now poised to begin developing self-disseminating vaccines targeting a wide range of human pathogens, but important decisions remain about how they can be most effectively designed and used to target pathogens with a high risk of spillover and/or emergence.
 
Last edited:
Looks like Yuri Deigin is particularly impressed by the Sharri Markson documentary. From the clip he posts here, it sounds to me more like Trump apologists making up stories to cover their mishandling of the pandemic ("If only we had known earlier..." - Really? And yet you would still have ****** it up!)

Mind you, you have to say that the scary music does some heavy lifting here. Mike Pompeo claims that it all started in October, but that is not convenient for some other lab leakers (Rossana Segreto, for example) who need the pandemic to start in September to account for the removal of access to the databases.

Link
 

Attachments

  • Deigin WHIW 1.jpg
    Deigin WHIW 1.jpg
    31.2 KB · Views: 6
  • Deigin WHIW 2.jpg
    Deigin WHIW 2.jpg
    29 KB · Views: 5
Looks like Yuri Deigin is particularly impressed by the Sharri Markson documentary. From the clip he posts here, it sounds to me more like Trump apologists making up stories to cover their mishandling of the pandemic ("If only we had known earlier..." - Really? And yet you would still have ****** it up!)

Mind you, you have to say that the scary music does some heavy lifting here. Mike Pompeo claims that it all started in October, but that is not convenient for some other lab leakers (Rossana Segreto, for example) who need the pandemic to start in September to account for the removal of access to the databases.

Link
Want to dismiss evidence instead of discussing it? Invoke Dump and politics and attribute specific motives to certain conclusions.

This is not the first time there has been evidence of earlier cases.

I'm trying to find the SkyNews piece for a better look at it. It doesn't look promising.

I can't find anything new about the WIV folks with an illness in 2019.
 
Last edited:
Want to dismiss evidence instead of discussing it? Invoke Dump and politics and attribute specific motives to certain conclusions.

This is not the first time there has been evidence of earlier cases. I'm trying to find the SkyNews piece for a better look at it. It doesn't look promising.

I can't find anything new about the WIV folks with an illness in 2019.

It's not the first time because it is exactly the same claim that's been made over and over again by the same person, Mike Pompeo.
 
It's not the first time because it is exactly the same claim that's been made over and over again by the same person, Mike Pompeo.

You seem to have missed a lot of the genetic timeframe research walking the mutations back in time and looking for the common ancestors. We just discussed this when the possible scenarios for A and B lineages were discussed. :boggled:


Do you think the A & B lineages (either or both) began/diverged in Oct? That makes no sense.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom