Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually, what is stupid is claiming that there is evidence the virus was released from a lab without any evidence that the virus was ever in a lab prior to discovery of the first cases.

Round and round the mulberry bush, the debate fails to go anywhere.

So give me an example, if you would be so kind, of what circumstantial evidence for a lab accident would be if it existed.
 
And speaking of gain of function research, we already know about Baric's work. COVID does not show evidence of an engineered virus such as the one Shi and Baric were working on. And I thought Daszak forwarded NIH money to the WIV without the NIH approving of it. Turns out the NIH may very well have approved of the grant. That is very disappointing if it meant the US blocked funding for that particular dangerous research in the US but didn't mind another country doing similar work.

Internal Documents Further Contradict Fauci’s ‘Gain-of-Function’ Research Denials


That's then followed by a bunch of political crap in the article.



This article is mostly about the history of the WIV and the level 4 biosafety unit. It is a reminder coronaviruses weren't being handled in the level 4 lab. In addition it corroborates other citations that note the WIV did have live bats.

WA Po (not behind a paywall here): Inside the Wuhan lab: French engineering, deadly viruses and a big mystery

Stuart Neil is underwhelmed by this...

SCOOP: they’ve published 2 of Ecohealth’s grant proposals. (The second one is about viral surveillance in SE Asia and doesn’t appear to include China)

Will have to read in detail but on first inspection, it’s a proposal@to do exactly what they said they were doing and what they subsequently published using the money

Excuse me while lift my jaw from the floor.

What is interesting is that despite proposing to isolate viruses from bats, the publications are based on lenti pseudotypes or the chimeric viruses we all know about

Why interesting? Well isolating viruses is hard and I think that they favored the chimeras because of that

But absolutely nothing new here apart from disabusing everyone of the notion that animal experiments were carried out at BSL2 - they were not. They used a BSL3 animal facility as is entirely appropriate for this work and should provide more than adequate containment

What’s more interesting is how exercised both Ebright and Alina Chan are over these ‘revelations’

And what made me laugh was after all the accusations of unsafe working, Alina is actually now criticizing the scientists who write the proposal for doing a proper risk assessment for field work! You really couldn’t make it up

Link

I get the distinct impression that Richard Ebright has an axe to grind with many of the players in this. I believe he is a long-term opponent of gain-of-function and is possibly motivated by that opposition to see the WIV as the source of the pandemic. I also notice how he likes to make claims that anyone who disagrees with him is being "paid off".
 
This article is mostly about the history of the WIV and the level 4 biosafety unit. It is a reminder coronaviruses weren't being handled in the level 4 lab.

As Capsid has said, bat coronaviruses are BSL-3 pathogens. I have heard the same thing independently from a number of other virologists.

It is also true that they did some experiments at BSL-2, but my understanding is that these were pseudoviruses so it was believed that these did not need to be BSL-3. Apparently there is a fair amount of controversy about that, in terms of the biosecurity level, and I have definitely seem a few non-lab leak commentators express disquiet about that.

That said, there is literally no reason at all to be surprised that coronaviruses were not studied at BSL-4.
 
I have one good reason: SARS 1.

In fact, that is not true. SARS 1 is a BSL-3 pathogen.

From the Wikipedia page on this...

Biosafety level 3 is commonly used for research and diagnostic work involving various microbes which can be transmitted by aerosols and/or cause severe disease. These include Francisella tularensis, Mycobacterium tuberculosis, Chlamydia psittaci, Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus, Eastern equine encephalitis virus, SARS-CoV-1, MERS-CoV, Coxiella burnetii, Rift Valley fever virus, Rickettsia rickettsii, several species of Brucella, chikungunya, yellow fever virus, West Nile virus, Yersinia pestis,[15] and SARS-CoV-2

Link

SARS and Covid-19 are nasty, but BSL-4 is reserved for even more serious pathogens.

Biosafety level 4 laboratories are used for diagnostic work and research on easily transmitted pathogens which can cause fatal disease. These include a number of viruses known to cause viral hemorrhagic fever such as Marburg virus, Ebola virus, Lassa virus, and Crimean-Congo hemorrhagic fever. Other pathogens handled at BSL-4 include Hendra virus, Nipah virus, and some flaviviruses.

If you remember, Capsid said that Zhengli Shi spoke at the Nipah Conference in December 2019 to promote the BSL-4 lab. In fact, there is a Nipah outbreak going on right now.

So it is perfectly consistent with standard operating procedures to use BSL-3 for coronavirus research.
 
You missed the error in the quote. The NIH never funded their specific definition of gain in function research: work that would have deliberately enhanced SARS-like viruses, MERS, or flu by—for example—making them easier to spread through the air. The WIV was not working on making any virus more transmittable. WIV were not researching how to make any virus air borne. They were researching the risk of virus spillover into human cells.
 
Round and round the mulberry bush, the debate fails to go anywhere.

So give me an example, if you would be so kind, of what circumstantial evidence for a lab accident would be if it existed.

There is no debate worthy of the name. You are assuming the virus was in a lab and subsequently was released in some sort of accident. There is no evidence that the virus was present in a lab prior to the initial human infections. Once it is demonstrated that the virus was actually in a lab at the proposed time the circumstances around a possible accident can be discussed. Until that time any discussion of circumstances is pure speculation.
 
There is no debate worthy of the name. You are assuming the virus was in a lab and subsequently was released in some sort of accident. There is no evidence that the virus was present in a lab prior to the initial human infections. Once it is demonstrated that the virus was actually in a lab at the proposed time the circumstances around a possible accident can be discussed. Until that time any discussion of circumstances is pure speculation.
So live bats at the WIV, missing records of just what was in the Chinese labs in Wuhan, Shi contradicting the evidence of what the Yunnan miners had, the fact accidents have happened in these same labs ... all of that in your mind just isn't good enough to qualify as relevant circumstantial evidence.

Do you see what you have indicated would be circumstantial evidence here? Proof, or at least darn close to it.
 
Way to miss the point. I didn't mean it was standard practice, I meant how it should have been and still should be classified.

You’ll have to take that objection up with just about the entire world of Virology. It’s an internationally recognized standard so you cannot condemn the WIV for abiding by that standard. There is obviously a trade off between being able to do research and maintaining biosecurity. Presumably only the most lethal pathogens such as Ebola, smallpox, Hendra etc… are studied under BSL-4.
 
Rumor, rumor, a repeated error, and a bad error.

So live bats at the WIV, missing records of just what was in the Chinese labs in Wuhan, Shi contradicting the evidence of what the Yunnan miners had, the fact accidents have happened in these same labs ...
Actually: rumor, rumor, a repeated error, and a lie.
  • You give no evidence of live bats at the WIV.
    1 September 2021: Shi stated that there were no live bats at the WIV.
    NBC News toured the WIV tabs in August 2020 and did report see any cages, etc. We can have a conspiracy theory of a coverup removing all evidence of live animals and silencing the scientists and workers. But then we need to add a time machine to remove any mention of live bats from published papers :p.
    Commonsense says there would be no need of live bats at WIV when all they need are the samples collected at the caves.
    WIV say there were no live bats at the labs,
    People who visited the labs say there were no live bats there.
    There is a video showing some kind of bats in a lab somewhere in China. What we see is the outside of the WIV, then a lab, then an image of bats in a cage somewhere, then a wall of maybe empty containers, then someone feeding a bat a worm. The people are in full protective gear including air hoses. The original video looks like the state TV program back in 2017. What is obviously dubious is that no one reports that the video stated that there were live bats at the WIV. Researching does not even give the original video or a transcript of the original video!
    What researching does find is CALL OF THE WILD Why many scientists say it’s unlikely that SARS-CoV-2 originated from a “lab leak”
    Linfa Wang, a molecular virologist at the Programme in Emerging Infectious Diseases at Duke-NUS Medical School in Singapore who has collaborated extensively with WIV on bat coronavirus studies, has a simpler reason for dismissing the lab-leak hypothesis. “Accidents can only happen when you already have a live virus in culture that can leak,” Wang says. Bat coronaviruses are notoriously hard to grow. Shi told Science last year that her lab had more than 2000 bat fecal samples and anal and oral swabs that tested positive for coronaviruses. But the lab had only isolated and grown three viruses over 15 years, Shi said, and none closely resembled SARS-CoV-2. Some have questioned Shi’s veracity—she may well be under pressure from the Chinese government—and noted inconsistencies in her statements, but several scientific collaborators outside China have high regard for her integrity.

    Wang also discounts reports that WIV has live bats. “Many years back” the lab conducted immune studies on live bats, Wang says, but these were not of the genus Rhinolophus—the only one found to harbor SARS-related coronaviruses—which no lab has ever been able to keep alive in captivity.
  • You give no evidence of missing records about the contents of the WIV labs.
    When Shi first learned about COVID-19, she checked to see if there were any SARS-CoV-2 virus samples at the lab and found none.
  • 6 September 2021: Shi was correct that the miners [probably] had fungal infections (the bats did not have SARS-CoV or SARS-CoV 2 :eek:!)
    No one knows what the miners had. But we know that it was probably as Shi stated - fungal infection. It could have been a rat henipa-like virus (Mojiang paramyxovirus).
  • Writing "the fact accidents have happened in these same labs " is a bad error when you must know there have been no accidents reported at the WIV labs.
    The SARS lab accidents were not at Wuhan (Thailand, Taiwan and Beijing). The WHO team found no accidents at the WIV.
    You may mean that there have been accidents throughout the world at the same type of labs. That says nothing about the relatively new WIV labs.
    CALL OF THE WILD Why many scientists say it’s unlikely that SARS-CoV-2 originated from a “lab leak”
    Shi has reported that her lab tested blood from the miners and did not find evidence of coronaviruses or antibodies to them. Wang, who helped with these analyses, finds the assertion that the team suppressed evidence of SARS-CoV-2’s link to the Mojiang mine preposterous. “We wanted to prove that a coronavirus caused the deaths,” says Wang, who grew up in Shanghai but is now an Australian citizen. “If we proved that another SARS-like virus was in humans in China that would have been scientifically brilliant,” he says. “It’s a Science or Nature paper. No scientist is going to wait for this to leak.”
 
Last edited:
Well there IS evidence. The outbreak started nearby the lab. It's not much, but it's not nothing. That's why it's on the table. If the lab was 1000km from the Wuhan, nobody would even think about it.

Most epidemics have nearby labs that study the exact thing that causes the epidemic. It's almost like scientists understand the local risks and focus their research on these things...


A more detailed examination of location suggests the lab in question isn't in the right place to be the original source. The earliest cases occur some 20 km away on the other side of the Yangtze River and radiate outward from that epicenter. It's weeks before cases overtake the lab and months before expected deaths rise near the lab. If you want a US comparable it would be like having a major disease outbreak starting in Manhattan and radiating outward from there, then blaming it on a lab in Newark New Jersey.

It may not be impossible but it's not something that follows from the evidence we currently have.

picture.php


picture.php
 
Larry Moran of SandWalk has a good description of the Science Call of the Wild article earlier this month.
Most scientists dismiss the lab leak conspiracy theory makes a good point in a footnote. If we believe that the Chinese government is covering up a lab leak with measures such as forcing Chinese scientists (even outside of China) to lie, then what is the point in asking for lab notebooks, computers, and freezer contents? It is a coverup. The Chinese government would destroy or fake those.
 
Larry Moran of SandWalk has a good description of the Science Call of the Wild article earlier this month.
Most scientists dismiss the lab leak conspiracy theory makes a good point in a footnote. If we believe that the Chinese government is covering up a lab leak with measures such as forcing Chinese scientists (even outside of China) to lie, then what is the point in asking for lab notebooks, computers, and freezer contents? It is a coverup. The Chinese government would destroy or fake those.

Point of asking is to show there is coverup.
 
The BBC World Service has a programme on the Origins of SARS-CoV2 featuring interviews with Angela Rasmussen, Peter Daszak, Michael Worobey and others.

Link
 
Point of asking is to show there is coverup.
The point is that the results of asking are very unlikely to show there is a coverup. If we go for a conspiracy theory of a coverup by the Chinese government, we cannot know whether any supplied or missing evidence is part of that coverup or not.
 
But so far they plainly refused. So we can know.
We cannot know there is a coverup. Read Most scientists dismiss the lab leak conspiracy theory
Conspiracy theorists will conclude that this is evidence of guilt but what if the scientists at WIV are telling the truth that they were never working with SARS-CoV-2 before the pandemic? Given that there's no evidence that these respected Chinese scientists are lying, how do you expect the Chinese government to respond? How would the American government respond to similar false accusations about the scientists at NIH? Would the Americans turn over all their lab notebooks and computers to foreign investigators?
The Chinese government is reasonably refusing baseless demands tor an independent audit of key Wuhan labs. Shi Zhengli and dozens of co-workers would have to be lying about the existence of SARS-CoV-2 in the labs.
 
We cannot know there is a coverup. Read Most scientists dismiss the lab leak conspiracy theory

The Chinese government is reasonably refusing baseless demands tor an independent audit of key Wuhan labs. Shi Zhengli and dozens of co-workers would have to be lying about the existence of SARS-CoV-2 in the labs.

Day I will trust anything from Chinese government hasn't come yet. If they say the sky is blue, and it would seems blue to me, I will have my eyes checked.
On the other hand, I'd agree that them hiding something doesn't necessarily mean something happened. They are hiding everything by default.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom