Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
There was no lab in Guangdong let alone one studying coronaviruses. The source of the SARS spillover was found within a couple months. A SARS-like virus was circulating in the civet cat population and in a couple of other species sold in the wet markets in Guangdong. After the spillover the virus took another month or so of mutating in the Guangdong population before it became adapted to humans and the first outbreak was noted to be among healthcare workers taking care of people with a new pneumonia.I don't misunderstand the coincidence.
Sharkeu accepts that SARS-CoV1 emerged in Guangzhou despite being such a large distance from Yunnan, and thinks it is much less likely to have got to Wuhan. Yet, it did - or at least it got to Hubei Province which is the same province as Wuhan.
It may not counter all the points, but it is at least one point that is countered.
If you want to cherry pick distance from the bats alone, you probably don't understand what the important points are.
And let's not forget, SARS started where the civet cats, etc were, not where the bats were.