Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't misunderstand the coincidence.

Sharkeu accepts that SARS-CoV1 emerged in Guangzhou despite being such a large distance from Yunnan, and thinks it is much less likely to have got to Wuhan. Yet, it did - or at least it got to Hubei Province which is the same province as Wuhan.

It may not counter all the points, but it is at least one point that is countered.
There was no lab in Guangdong let alone one studying coronaviruses. The source of the SARS spillover was found within a couple months. A SARS-like virus was circulating in the civet cat population and in a couple of other species sold in the wet markets in Guangdong. After the spillover the virus took another month or so of mutating in the Guangdong population before it became adapted to humans and the first outbreak was noted to be among healthcare workers taking care of people with a new pneumonia.

If you want to cherry pick distance from the bats alone, you probably don't understand what the important points are.

And let's not forget, SARS started where the civet cats, etc were, not where the bats were.
 
Stuart Neil points out that some researchers have found...

Link

Of course, I don't have or claim to have the competence to assess the paper:

Paper

Nothing new here that hasn't been posted about in the thread already.

A couple of the genetic features of COVID are rare but the incorrect initial claims they were never seen elsewhere was already posted.
 
Interesting, certainly very strong evidence for a bat origin. I had read a paper showing that a number of people in that area (Indochina) had neutralising antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 pre covid, and this perhaps represented a similar but less virulent circulating virus. They then hypothesised that the relative good control of Covid in Indo-China might be partly contributed to by a degree of pre-existing immunity in the population.
We just discussed this in the thread because Daszak put out a purely speculative paper about how common spillovers must be. But he failed to conduct any new seroprevalence studies to back it up. Instead he used the seroprevalence studies done after the 6 miners contracted a serious viral pneumonia (not a fungus, BTW) which showed a small positive result in people who lived near the mine in Yunnan.

I believe it was around 3%. I'll go look it up.
 
Interesting article for more than just the seroprevalence numbers. This is a letter with supplementary evidence, published in 2018, and the study was in 2015. It was cited upthread as well as here.

Serological Evidence of Bat SARS-Related Coronavirus Infection in Humans, China
In this study, we performed serological surveillance on people who live in close proximity to caves where bats that carry diverse SARSr-CoVs roost. In October 2015, we collected serum samples from 218 residents in four villages in Jinning County, Yunnan province, China (Fig. 1A), located 1.1–6.0 km from two caves (Yanzi and Shitou). ...

This region was not involved in the 2002–2003 SARS outbreaks and none of the subjects exhibited any evident respiratory illness during sampling. ...

Most (81.2%) kept or owned livestock or pets, and the majority (97.2%) had a history of exposure to or contact with livestock or wild animals. Importantly, 20 (9.1%) participants witnessed bats flying close to their houses, and one had handled a bat corpse. As a control, we also collected 240 serum samples from random blood donors in 2015 in Wuhan, Hubei Province more than 1000 km away from Jinning (Fig. 1A) and where inhabitants have a much lower likelihood of contact with bats due to its urban setting.
That they used Wuhan inhabitants for controls I find very interesting and tangentially relevant.

The 2.7% seropositivity for the high risk group of residents living in close proximity to bat colonies suggests that spillover is a relatively rare event, however this depends on how long antibodies persist in people, since other individuals may have been exposed and antibodies waned. During questioning, none of the 6 seropositive subjects could recall any clinical symptoms in the past 12 months, suggesting that their bat SARSr-CoV infection either occurred before the time of sampling, or that infections were subclinical or caused only mild symptoms.
So less than 3% positivity in a population with close contact with the bats in Yunnan. That hardly supports Daszak's paper. He needs to do more seroprevalence studies if he wants to confirm his highly speculative report on how common these bat spillover events occur in the world.


Oh yeah, then there is this I forgot to repeat in my above post:
Isolation of SARS-related coronavirus (SARSr-CoVs) from masked palm civets and the detection of SARS-CoV infection in humans working at wet markets where civets were sold suggested that masked palm civets could serve as a source of human infection (Guan et al. 2003).
As a control they looked at vegetable dealers in the wet markets and found a significantly lower rate of positive serum. China could have done a similar study to corroborate the spillover hypothesis but they didn't do so or if they did they did not disclose the testing or the results.


And I want to come back to this from the link:
In addition, the receptor binding domains (RBD) of the spike protein (S) from SARS-CoV, bat SARSr-CoVs Rp3, WIV1, and SHC014 were produced in mammalian cells (Ge et al. 2013; Yang et al. 2016).
 
Last edited:
Getting back to the comment in my last link:

Isolation and characterization of a bat SARS-like coronavirus that uses the ACE2 receptor
This was cited upthread so consider this a review.

Most importantly, we report the first recorded isolation of a live SL-CoV (bat SL-CoV-WIV1) from bat faecal samples in Vero E6 cells, which has typical coronavirus morphology, 99.9% sequence identity to Rs3367 and uses ACE2 from humans, civets and Chinese horseshoe bats for cell entry. Preliminary in vitro testing indicates that WIV1 also has a broad species tropism
This is from the WIV that Dr Shi claims no live cultures or bats were handled in the lab.


This one was also posted upthread:

2015: Isolation and Characterization of a Novel Bat Coronavirus Closely Related to the Direct Progenitor of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus
Continued surveillance of this group of viruses in bats will be necessary and important not only for a better understanding of the spillover mechanism but also for more effective risk assessment and prevention of future SARS-like disease outbreaks.
And yet there are no clear records of these surveilled samples from the WIV.
 
There was no lab in Guangdong let alone one studying coronaviruses. The source of the SARS spillover was found within a couple months. A SARS-like virus was circulating in the civet cat population and in a couple of other species sold in the wet markets in Guangdong. After the spillover the virus took another month or so of mutating in the Guangdong population before it became adapted to humans and the first outbreak was noted to be among healthcare workers taking care of people with a new pneumonia.

If you want to cherry pick distance from the bats alone, you probably don't understand what the important points are.

And let's not forget, SARS started where the civet cats, etc were, not where the bats were.

Irrelevant! It demonstrates a plausible wildlife trade route to Hubei and not just to Guangdong. This is what sharkeu had disagreed with me about. It’s another nail in the coffin of the argument that it is TOO coincidental.
 
There was no spillover documented there either.

Irrelevant! The point is that the supposed uniqueness of SARS-CoV2’s receptor-binding domain in its family of viruses turns out to not be true. This is one more nail in the coffin of the argument that it MUST have been engineered.
 
Irrelevant! It demonstrates a plausible wildlife trade route to Hubei and not just to Guangdong. This is what sharkeu had disagreed with me about. It’s another nail in the coffin of the argument that it is TOO coincidental.

Yep, a total lack of evidence and completely different circumstances are irrelevant all right. :rolleyes:
 
Irrelevant! The point is that the supposed uniqueness of SARS-CoV2’s receptor-binding domain in its family of viruses turns out to not be true. This is one more nail in the coffin of the argument that it MUST have been engineered.
That ship sailed 10 or 20 pages back. Why do you think this is a revelation now?

No one is using that argument. Rare, yes and that is relevant. But think about it, angrysoba, if it had been unique only to COVID 19 we'd have called it a smoking gun. No smoking gun argument for either origin hypothesis has been presented here.
 
That ship sailed 10 or 20 pages back. Why do you think this is a revelation now?

No one is using that argument. Rare, yes and that is relevant. But think about it, angrysoba, if it had been unique only to COVID 19 we'd have called it a smoking gun. No smoking gun argument for either origin hypothesis has been presented here.

No, it was absolutely argued that it was unique to SARS-CoV2, and it was argued that no such RBD would be found in a bat coronavirus.

There's no point pretending that nobody argued that. Look, here is an exchange between Yuri Deigin (one of the most prominent lab leak proponents, but one who is apparently open to being persuaded the opposite way) and Stuart Neil (one of the more prominent spillover proponents who is also open to being persuaded the other way).
 

Attachments

  • Stuart and Yuri.jpg
    Stuart and Yuri.jpg
    42.8 KB · Views: 6
By the way, I was going to write in response to your point about "smoking guns".

A "smoking gun" that would satisfy the lab leak proponents would either be a highly unlikely find such as swabbing a random bat and finding a 99.9% similarity with SARS-CoV2, or impossible, because even that probably wouldn't count, as the lab leakers would just pivot away from the GoF stuff to say that it was probably caught by WIV scientists and they then infected people in Wuhan.

There actually cannot be a single smoking gun. Demands for one are unscientific and unreasonable.
 
This is goal-post moving. I pointed out the argument I was addressing, and you said it doesn't address a different argument. No, it doesn't. That's why I said it is irrelevant.
I did not move any goalpost. I never set any. You did. I just responded to your cherry-picked detail with the rest of the missing facts.

Sorry you don't like the fact you didn't make the splash you wanted to.
 
No, it was absolutely argued that it was unique to SARS-CoV2, and it was argued that no such RBD would be found in a bat coronavirus.

There's no point pretending that nobody argued that. Look, here is an exchange between Yuri Deigin (one of the most prominent lab leak proponents, but one who is apparently open to being persuaded the opposite way) and Stuart Neil (one of the more prominent spillover proponents who is also open to being persuaded the other way).
That's not from the thread. And even though it was indeed put forward and even cited, subsequent posts recognized there were indeed rare exceptions.
So I don't know who you are arguing with, those guys are not in the forum. You are posting stuff already recognized in the thread.
 
By the way, I was going to write in response to your point about "smoking guns".

A "smoking gun" that would satisfy the lab leak proponents would either be a highly unlikely find such as swabbing a random bat and finding a 99.9% similarity with SARS-CoV2, or impossible, because even that probably wouldn't count, as the lab leakers would just pivot away from the GoF stuff to say that it was probably caught by WIV scientists and they then infected people in Wuhan.

There actually cannot be a single smoking gun. Demands for one are unscientific and unreasonable.

So a semantics argument now?

You need to keep up. You are posting revelations already posted and discussed.
 
I did not move any goalpost. I never set any. You did.

Wrong. Sherkeu did. It was her point I was responding to. Not yours. I was addressing her point, not yours. You were the one who said, "But whatabout...whatabout....?"

They are irrelevant to what we were talking about.
 

Attachments

  • as and sherkeu.jpg
    as and sherkeu.jpg
    34.2 KB · Views: 6
That's not from the thread. And even though it was indeed put forward and even cited, subsequent posts recognized there were indeed rare exceptions.
So I don't know who you are arguing with, those guys are not in the forum. You are posting stuff already recognized in the thread.

Not everything is about you, you know. In fact, I seem to remember you getting extremely annoyed when people made things about you.

I am posting about the "Origins of Covid", not about you. If you want us to post about you, start a thread about you.
 
So a semantics argument now?

You need to keep up. You are posting revelations already posted and discussed.

No, it is not a semantics argument. The lab leak side (your side) have been looking for smoking guns. You are demanding unreasonable evidence for something that may have to be put together painstakingly.
 
We can wait until Sherkeu sticks her head back in the thread but I'm pretty sure she was in on the same discussion as everyone else. I doesn't change the fact you are still refuting a claim that was already refuted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom