Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
As in no one has confirmed the sequencing?I'd concur with that. Seems the sequences of the 2 lineages can not have occurred by transition and rather could be a sequencing error.
Several virologists have said lineage A precedes lineage B and given their reasons. At least one who did also allowed for questioning that conclusion.
As for multiple jumps, most dying out, the problem becomes where are these animals which the virus possibly jumped from?
It would have to be circulating somewhere if this were the case and evidence for such circulating hasn't been found in almost 2 years.
It could not have jumped multiple times eventually acquiring the ability to spread person to person without circulating in a species.
With SARS that was found within 4 months and multiple documented spillovers occurred in more than one wet market. Then the virus circulated in people in Guangdong for a couple months before it began to spread from there. More than likely the person to person spread improved during that time.
With influenza, cases are monitored very closely through sampling and analyzing their genomes. We have had a number of 'almost' pandemics that were identified. Typically the source animals are quickly found. Multiple spillovers have been documented and again are closely monitored.
Even with a small proportion of serious cases COVID would still have showed up; unless as I noted in another recent post, the virus acquired both the ability to spread and gained lethality at the same time. Not only that, but both A and B lineages would have had had to acquire the same variant mutations.
It makes no sense.
The article says:
OK, that means there weren't 2 lineages. And that doesn't support multiple spillover events.can more parsimoniously be explained by sequencing error.
So where is the evidence of 2 patient zeros that just happened to show up in Wuhan at nearly the same time?In other words, we looked at whether putative A/B intermediates shared with “pure” A or “pure” B virus genomes one or more mutations outside of those that define the two pure lineages. If so, then either those mutations arose independently in both the putative intermediate and its pure counterpart, or (more likely) the putative intermediate is not an intermediate at all, and is actually a pure A or B lineage very closely related to its pure-lineage counterpart.
Continuing the authors note this deus ex machina suggestion:
The lineages don't fit, throw them out,These findings cast substantial doubt on the veracity of C/C or T/T intermediate genomes in early 2020. We suggest that these early C/C and T/T genomes are erroneous and should be excluded from phylogenetic analyses.
Yes, when one has outliers it is common to ignore them. Is that what these samples actually show, that one or more of them is an outlier?
As for being evidence of multiple jumps:
That is correct, but once again, with SARS that animal species was quickly found. If it were only circulating in a couple of animals then how did 2 lineages evolve? It would take a bit of circulating just as the author claims didn't happen after the jump to humans.Capsid said:Worobey seems to think so, "If a human-transmissible SARS-CoV-2 progenitor was circulating among such animals, the SARS1 story teaches us that it would be likely to jump multiple times into humans."
!