Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
I had to take those ******* quote marks out of your link to make it work. It would be nice if you would test links before hitting reply.Okay, so I don't understand any of the science here, but it seems that one of the questions to do with the origins is at what stage lineage A and lineage B of SARS-CoV2 diverged.
Well, a group of scientists including Michael Worobey, suggest that maybe they did not and that they therefore represent different points of emergence.
Link
This might bolster the multiple spillover theory.
Michael Worobey, on this Twitter thread, discusses a dispute he is having with one of the DRASTIC members about whether he is doing the science right. As Worobey says, it is pretty technical, and I have no idea how to say who is right and who is wrong in this.
The bottom line seems to be that there has been more than one introduction of SARS-CoV2 into humans, which would support the idea of multiple spillovers rather than, say, a single lab accident.
Two possible counter-arguments are that:
1.) The two lineages diverge from each other, and we have evidence of that which Worobey is throwing out (I think that is Daoyu's position)
and
2.) The two lineages diverge from each other even if we currently don't have evidence of it, and the divergence is simply lost somewhere.
As I say, I have no idea.
Maybe Capsid or SG want to chime in here...![]()
https://news.arizona.edu/story/nove...-undetected-months-first-covid-19-cases-wuhan
I posted about that already. I referred to it as sputtering. It's an hypothesis but I didn't see any evidence that supported it. I'll look again.
I do think the two lineages has to put the origin back before Oct explaining the removal of access to the WIV work on Sept 19, 2019.
Last edited:

! That leaves the probable cause as fungal infection. Dr Shi stated what she believed.